Vying for Her Love

The evening after Colgate and her new marefriends, Lemon Hearts and Twinkleshine, watched the Amending Fences episode had arrived. Like she always does, Colgate was fixing supper. Lemon Hearts headed into the kitchen and asked, "Colgate, so what are you fixing for supper tonight?"

Colgate replied, "Breaded fish portions and macaroni and cheese."

Lemon Hearts asked, "Colgate, why must you almost always include meat of some sort in our meals? You know Twinkleshine and I don't like it."

Colgate sighed, "Well there are some canned green beans in the cupboard. You can open them and you two can eat them." She licked her chops and continued, "Well I guess that will be more fish for me!"

Lemon Hearts asked, "Colgate, have you always liked meat?"

Colgate replied, "Of course I have! It is something that is in my family's DNA. We have eaten meat dating back to as far as our family records go."

Lemon Hearts rolled her eyes and took the green beans into the dining room where her and Twinkleshine began to eat. When they first started living together, them starting a meal without Colgate would have been a mistake but with them being an item now and given the fact that they were eating vegetables, she didn't mind.

Finally the mac and cheese and fish were done. Colgate yelled, "Dinner's ready!"

The two headed into the kitchen and got their serving of mac and cheese while leaving enough for Colgate. While they were eating their supper they began to discuss their future now that they are marefriends. Twinkleshine asked, "So are we all going to share the same bed now?"

Colgate replied, "Well first we would need to get a bed that can comfortably accommodate the three of us and secondly I think we should just sleep together on Friday and Saturday nights."

Lemon Hearts asked, "Why? Why can't we sleep together every night?"

Colgate replied, "Because I think it would be best if I slept solo on nights before I go to work. I want to be well rested and fully alert while I am at work."

While the two sighed in disappointment they could understand where she was coming from. Colgate was the primary breadwinner of the household and if she wasn't at her best, all three of them would suffer.

After supper they headed into the living room to watch TV like they always do on Saturday nights but this time it would be different. For the first time the three snuggled together on the couch while Colgate was flipping through the channels trying to find something good. Colgate stopped at ENC, Equestria News Channel. Twinkleshine protested, "News, seriously Colgate?"

Lemon Hearts added, "Yeah, why would we want to watch news? We should watch something romantic to celebrate our first night as being an item."

Colgate sighed, "Oh, ok. I wanted to see what is going on with that volcano erupting up by Vanhoover but I can read that in the paper tomorrow morning."

Lemon Hearts grabbed the remote from Colgate and began to flip through the channels. She was quickly getting frustrated as she could not find anything romantic on. All she could find was either news, documentaries, horror shows, sports and reality TV. She grunted, "Twinkleshine, you have romantic movies in your DVD collection, could you go get one?"

Twinkleshine replied, "Sure."

Colgate sighed because she did not have much use for romantic movies but realized that she, just like they will, will have to compromise and give in when it comes to certain things. A couple minutes later Twinkleshine returned with "The Bridges of Maredison County." Lemon Hearts was ecstatic when she saw that was the one she brought but Colgate, despite never seeing the film, could only feel a sense of dread. She thought to herself, "Ugh, I've heard that movie is horrible. Luna help me."

Twinkleshine got the movie started and while it wasn't what she was used to, Colgate didn't find it horribly bad, well until the more sensual parts arrived. Lemon Hearts said, "Awww....they make such a sweet couple." All Colgate could think was, "Ugh, gag me with a fork."

Colgate felt this way until her marefriends began to nuzzle her and wrap themselves around her. This brought about a warm feeling in her that she never felt before. She suddenly thought, "Well if sappy movies like this will lead to them doing this, watching them might be worth it, once in a while anyway."

As the movie progressed Twinkleshine and Lemon Hearts pulled themselves closer and closer to Colgate until they were basically draped over her, holding her in place to where she could barely move. At first this made Colgate a bit panicky wondering what would happen if she had to get up but soon Lemon Hearts was in her face, giving her a dreamy, loving look.

Colgate had never been in this situation before so she really wasn't sure how to react but quickly she pulled forward and gave Lemon Hearts a passionate kiss. Lemon Hearts began to moan gently as Colgate began to explore the inside of her mouth with her tongue, causing her to shoot sparks of energy out of her horn. This of course brought out envy from Twinkleshine and she pulled Colgate to herself and began to kiss her. At this point all three of them were no longer paying attention to the movie, which was perfectly fine in Colgate's mind, she was experiencing sensual pleasure for the first time in her life and was able to ignore a sappy movie.

After the movie was over Lemon Hearts asked, "Well Colgate, did you like the movie?"

Colgate blushed and replied, "Well I really didn't pay attention to the movie much, my whole focus was on you two."

Twinkleshine ran her hoof up Colgate's leg and said, "That's why we wanted to watch something like that!"

Lemon Hearts added, "We couldn't have got you in the mood like this had we watched the coverage of that volcano erupting."

Colgate blushed, "That's true." She got up and headed towards her bedroom. She yawned, "I don't know about you two but I am tired."

After turning off the TV and the lights, the three headed to Colgate's room to turn in for the night. Lemon Hearts looked at Colgate's bed and asked, "Uh, are we all going to be able to fit in there?"

Colgate replied, "I told you that I would likely have to get a new bed if we are going to sleep together."

The three piled onto the bed and discovered that there was no way all three of them would fit. Twinkleshine sighed, "Well I guess we'll have to wait until you get a bigger bed."

Colgate replied, "We'll get one this week so come next Friday night, we'll be able to have our first night in bed together."

The two cheered, "Yay! We can't wait."

Colgate yawned, "Well let's get some rest. It is getting pretty late."

While Colgate plopped on her stomach and got to sleep rather quickly, Twinkleshine and Lemon Hearts didn't get to sleep that easily. They laid in their beds in disappointment wishing so much that they were with their beloved Colgate. Eventually though fatigue won over and they fell asleep.