Vying for Her Love

After getting home from supper the three began to grab each other playfully before heading up to Colgate's bedroom. While Colgate was ready and raring to go, Twinkleshine thought that they should watch a movie first. "Girls, I was thinking that maybe we should watch a romantic movie before we turn in."

Lemon Hearts asked, "Seriously? You really want to wait to have fun until after we watch a movie?"

Colgate added, "I thought you would want us to get hot and heavy the second we got home."

Before Colgate even finished her sentence Twinkleshine had already ran up to her room. Quickly she returned with her limited edition DVD of "Sleepless in Vanhoover." Lemon Hearts saw this and began jumping up and down in excitement. She said, "Oh, I love that movie! I know it will make things even more romantic for tonight!"

Colgate had heard about this movie and knew how sappy it was. She began to gag, "Ugh....are you serious?" She looked towards the stairs and continued, "Can't we just go upstairs and start having our fun? I'm really in the mood and this movie might turn me off to anything for tonight."

Twinkleshine began to nibble on Colgate's ear and giggled, "Oh Colgate, my sweet Colgate. I'm sure this movie will only make you more in the mood. It will make us bond even more and we may even feel as though we are one at the end."

Colgate sighed, "Oh alright. If it will make you happy we can watch it."

Both her marefriends jumped on her and began to kiss her they were so happy. They began to tickle her causing her to giggle, "Alright girls, let's watch this so we can have a whole lot of fun!"

The two got off of her and put the DVD in to play. While Lemon Hearts and Twinkleshine enjoyed the film, the only thing Colgate liked was the kissing and sucking on her ears that her marefriends did. Finally when the film was finished Colgate breathed a sigh of relief. They shut the downstairs lights off and headed right to Colgate's bedroom. Lemon Hearts and Twinkleshine looked at Colgate's large bed in a daze realizing that the moment they had been waiting for for so long, even since before the three became an item, was about to become reality.

Colgate jumped on her bed, gave her marefriends a seductive look and said, "Come on girls! There's more than enough room!" Twinkleshine was getting to turn the light off but Colgate did not want the lights off. She saw this and continued, "Twinkleshine honey, leave the lights on. I want us to be able to see each other."

When Twinkleshine and Lemon Hearts would have their intimate moments they do it with the lights off but neither one of them objected to Colgate's request. They feared that if they did, that it might turn Colgate off. Lemon Hearts and Twinkleshine quickly jumped on the bed and the three began to roll around groping one another and kissing one another. During the days and the way the household ran, Colgate tended to take on the stallion role while her marefriends took on a more wifely duty, especially Twinkleshine since she was the pony who stayed at home all day but would it be the same way that night given Colgate has never been in this situation before?

It wasn't long until the two had Colgate pinned down. Normally such a situation would either cause Colgate to become angry or panicky, there was something about them holding her down that really turned her on. Twinkleshine saw her smile and asked, "Colgate honey, I take it you're enjoying this?"

Colgate replied, "Yes sweetie, I am."

Lemon Hearts said, "Well, let's play a little game. It is something that Twinkleshine and I do all the time."

Twinkleshine added, "You must correctly answer a question we ask you. If you answer it correctly, you will experience great pleasure. If you answer it incorrectly, you will experience some pain."

While the thoughts of pain kind of bothered her, she was ready to play the game. Lemon Hearts asked, "So Colgate, how many special events does Celestia have me plan per year?"

Colgate had no clue what the answer was but guessed, "Uh, nine?"

Lemon Hearts sternly replied, "No, it is twelve." She leaned down and bit Colgate's ear hard, causing her to scream.

"Owwww! That hurt!" screamed the blue unicorn. She asked, "Is all the pain going to be this bad?"

Twinkleshine giggled, "No, some of it will be worse!"

Colgate had a very nervous look on her face but decided to accept her fate. She realized that if the pain was going to be bad, that the pleasure would likely be incredibly wonderful. Twinkleshine asked, "Well, moving on. How many times a week do I mop the floor?"

This too was something Colgate knew nothing about as she was always at work when Twinkleshine did the housework. She nervously replied, "Two?"

Twinkleshine smacked her flank and bit down and bit her inner thigh, causing Colgate to scream out in agony. Twinkleshine growled, "No dear, it is three!"

It was Lemon Hearts' turn again. She asked, "Alright honey, I want to know how well you truly know me. What is my favorite color?"

Given that they had only been more than just friends or less than a week, she had no clue so she would have to guess. She guessed, "Blue?"

Lemon Hearts gave her a stern look and replied, "That is the......" Her stern look changed into a smile as she continued, "right answer! I love the color blue!"

She began to lick Colgate's horn, sending shivers up and down her spine. Soon that licking became sucking, causing much more pleasurable sensations through Colgate's body.

As Lemon Hearts continued to suck harder and harder, Colgate moaned, "Oh baby, harder, harder, harder! Oh Lemon Hearts baby! Oh it feels so good!"

A minute later she stopped and said, "That's what you get for one right answer. Answer another one right and you'll like what I'll do even more!"

Again it was Twinkleshine's turn. She decided that she would ask Colgate an incredibly difficult question, something that she possibly could not know. She asked, "So sexy girl, what was my favorite food when I was little?"

Colgate was nervous because she worried about what her punishment would be for another incorrect answer but knew that if she didn't answer at all, her punishment would be far worse. She replied, "Um, tomato soup?"

Twinkleshine gave her a smile and replied, "That is right sweetie!" She bent down and began to suck on Colgate's stomach, causing her to giggle as she is very ticklish there. Soon Twinkleshine began to move down her abdomen towards her clit. When she reached her target she began to lick it quickly, causing Colgate to laugh but soon she began to suck on it sending Colgate into ecstasy. She moaned, "Oh Twinkleshine, that feels so good!"

Twinkleshine lifted her head up and replied, "Oh honey, I only got a tiny taste of you, I'm not done yet!"

She began to suck on her much harder and ran her tongue up in her marefriend causing her to shake and wrap her legs around Twinkleshine's head, pushing her face further in. Colgate squealed, "Oh baby, oh baby, deeper, deeper, deeper!"

Twinkleshine forced her tongue as deep as she could in Colgate and sucked harder and harder. Colgate screamed, "I'm gonna cum, I'm gonna cum!"

Twinkleshine quickly pulled out and smacked Colgate on the flank. She gave her a glare and ordered, "Not yet Colgate. You must wait to cum until I give you permission to."

Despite being the one who prefers being in control, Colgate was loving every moment of her first sexual experience. Lemon Hearts smiled at her and continued, "My turn again! Ok sweetie, what is my favorite number?"

Colgate was feeling more full of bliss at this moment so the fears of a wrong answer were not even present in her mind. She replied, "Twenty-two?"

Lemon Hearts gave her a warm smile and replied, "That is the......" Her smile turned into a frown and continued, "WRONG ANSWER!" She bit Colgate's other ear so hard that she drew blood. Colgate screamed out in agonizing pain begging for Lemon Hearts to stop biting her. Lemon Hearts finally loosened her clamp on her ear and said, "That will teach you to not answer my questions wrong!"

Colgate asked, "How was I supposed to know what it is? You never shared that with me."

Lemon Hearts replied, "Well as time goes by you'll get to know more of the small things about me and you won't have to worry about me biting you so much."

Twinkleshine interrupted, "It's my turn again!" She was eyeballing Colgate's prize as she asked, "So baby, who gave me my first kiss?"

Colgate knew some about Twinkleshine's history so she could give at least a semi-informed guess. She replied, "Lyra Heartstrings."

Twinkleshine gave her a scowl and replied, "That was the........" Her scowl turned into a smile as she crawled on top of her. She continued, "right answer! But enough about my past, my focus is on you!"

She began to kiss Colgate passionately and began to rub her marehood up against that of Colgate. Soon both mares were moaning in ecstasy which brought out a bit of jealousy from Lemon Hearts so as soon as Twinkleshine began to move down Colgate's torso, Lemon Hearts crawled on top of her and sat on her face. "Eat me sexy girl!" Lemon Hearts ordered Colgate.

Colgate began to suck on Lemon Hearts causing her to moan, "Oh baby, oh baby! Give me tongue, give me tongue!"

Colgate began to run her tongue up in the yellow unicorn while Twinkleshine was eating her. Both Lemon Hearts and Colgate were moaning in ecstasy and it wasn't long until Lemon Hearts was yelling, "I'm gonna cum, I'm gonna cum, I'M GONNA CUMMMMMM!"

Immediately a flood of tasty juices filled Colgate's mouth but given that she was laying down, she choked on them and began to cough. Lemon Hearts jumped off of her and asked, "Colgate sweetie, are you ok?"

Colgate continued to cough and replied, "I'll be fine. I guess we'll know not to cum in one another's mouths when we are laying down." She looked down at Twinkleshine who had stopped sucking when she was coughing and asked, "Well Twinkleshine sweetie, shall we continue?"

Twinkleshine nodded enthusiastically and quickly got back to work on Colgate. It was not long until she brought Colgate to a climax and was able to have a tasty treat of her own. Twinkleshine looked up at her marefriend and asked, "So sweetie, did you like it? Did you like what we did tonight?"

Colgate gave the two a smile and replied, "I loved it! You two made me feel like I have never felt before." She blushed a bit and continued, "For the first time in my life, I feel sexy!"

Lemon Hearts pulled her close and replied, "I'm so happy to hear that. I know how you have been your whole life and I'm sure I speak for both of us when I say that we are happy you have finally allowed yourself to relax and let your mane down."

Colgate said, "Well tomorrow night things will be a bit different. Tomorrow night I'll be the one in charge."

Lemon Hearts laughed, "Or so you think. Whoever gets pinned down first winds up being the sub. You'll have to be fast unless you want to be dominated again."

Colgate gave them both a seductive smile and said, "You know, the only reason I was the sub tonight is because I was completely new to this. Now that I know what to do, I'll be fast and be tough!"

Twinkleshine yawned, "I don't know about you two, but I'm really tired. I think we should hit the hay."

Colgate added, "I'm getting tired myself. What about you Lemon Hearts?"

Lemon Hearts replied, "Same here. Let's get some sleep. After all, we have ALL DAY tomorrow to continue to have fun!"

Colgate turned off the light and the three crawled into bed. While she normally sleeps closer to the edge on her side, Colgate slept in the middle so that her marefriends could both cuddle with her at once. While at first this would take some getting used to by Colgate, she would eventually be able to get to sleep being embraced.

Despite Colgate liking to have control of all situations she is involved in, she found being dominated that night as a huge turn on. Naturally she would never let her marefriends know because it would shatter the "tough mare" image that they have of her and it is that "tough mare" image that they love so much.