Pinkie Pie was over at Fluttershy's House, they were both enjoying a lovely night, Fluttershy was reading a newspaper, while Pinkie Pie was playing with one of Fluttershy's ferrets. Fluttershy read an eerie article about a mysterious serial killer going around in Equestria, and about how ponies should stay inside.
As Fluttershy stopped reading her newspaper, she went to her kitchen to get some grass and a carrot.
"Hey Pinkie Pie, It's time to feed Mr. Nibble." Fluttershy said, as she and Pinkie Pie trotted to Mr. Nibble's cage, he wasn't there. The shy pegasus was afraid to know where he had gone off to.
"Huh, Where is she, Fluttershy?" Asked Pinkie Pie.
"I Don't know," Replied Fluttershy, "I-I really Don't know, Pinkie!"
"Flutters, calm down!" Said Pinkie, trying to comfort her pony friend, "I'm sure he's around here somewhere."
Fluttershy began to hyperventilate, after noticing that there was a hole in the cage, and the door was a bit opened.
"We have to find him." Exclaimed Fluttershy, with a worried look on her face.
Fluttershy took her lamp, and exited the door, Pinkie Pie right behind her, Fluttershy stopped before taking a step into the Everfree Forest, It was a dark night, who knows what dangers are ahead. Pinkie Pie smiled at Fluttershy, trying to pull her in.
"C'mon Fluttershy!" Exclaimed Pinkie. "Do you want to find you're Bunny?"
Fluttershy gulped and nodded her head. She slowly walked into the Everfree Forest. Fluttershy took brave steps ahead, no Matter how Scared she was on the inside. She would do everything for her pet's, she would even go into the most dangerous place in Ponyvile, Just to find one of her bunnies.
As both Ponies walked, Fluttershy heard a noise, It was some sort of noise you can make when you step on a branch, Fluttershy looked around while holding a Her light in her mouth. She turned around her to see Pinkie Pie only.
"Did you h-hear that?" Asked Fluttershy.
"Hear, what?" Pinkie asked.
"A strange sound!" Said Fluttershy. "Did you step on something?"
Pinkie Pie looked at her hooves and the ground. "Nope."
With a sigh, Fluttershy continued to walk forward. She shouted out Mr. Nibble's name.
"Mr. Nibbles" Shouted Fluttershy. "Where are you?"
Pinkie Pie started to yawn, she was tired of going nowhere, searching for a small, cute, little bunny. She sighed and kept looking around, to find Mr. Nibble. Then, Fluttershy heard another sound.
"I heard it again!" shouted Fluttershy. "This time, it sounded like somepony was running, or like a bush."
"Fluttershy," said Pinkie. "I think you're hearing weird things."
Fluttershy though to herself, Maybe Pinkie was right, maybe She was just hearing weird things, Fluttershy continued to walk, until a Bush eventually moved.
"Mr. Nibble?" Asked Fluttershy, while getting closer to the bush.
Fluttershy looked behind the bush, and noticed Mr. Nibble, she was about to smile with joy, finally finding her little bunny, until noticing, that he had blood on his paws, she looked down, and noticed Mr. Nibble's was bleeding, and eventually, bled to death. Fluttershy began to tear up, as she stepped out of the bush, she started to cry loudly.
"Mr. Nibble!" Fluttershy shouted. "W-what happened?" She cried.
Pinkie Pie looked in the bush, seeing Little Nibble's blood on the ground, she stepped out and looked at Fluttershy with a worried expression.
"Who did this?" Asked Pinkie. "Some wolves?"
"I don't k-know." Cried Flutershy, wiping her tears off with her bloody hooves, after realizing she had blood on her hooves, she wiped them in the grass.
"Should we go, home?" Asked Pinkie. "It's getting really cold."
"A-alright." Said Fluttershy, with tears still on her face and cheeks. Her eyes were pure red from the crying, After all that search, she found her own little bunny, dead in the forest.
Pinkie Pie noticed something moving in the bush, while Fluttershy was wiping her cheeks and eyes. As Pinkie Pie got close and looked in the bush, not seeing anything, since It was really dark, Something wrapped hooves around her neck and pulled her in, Pinkie Pie let out a big scream, when she was pulled in, Fluttershy heard this scream and quickly turned to Pinkie.
"What's wrong Pinki-" Before Fluttershy continued, she noticed Pinkie was gone, there was no sight of her. This got Fluttershy very worried, she looked around but Didn't see Pinkie at all.
"Pinkie Pie, stop j-joking." Fluttershy gulped, she started to walk forward, going back home. "Pinkie, where are you?" Fluttershy whispered.
Fluttershy continued to walk, wondering where Pinkie was. "PINKIE!" Fluttershy shouted.
There was no response, no giggle, no chuckle, only quietness. Fluttershy continued to walk in the Everfree Forest, she went so deeply into the forest, she forgot how to get back home. Flutteshy trembled, it was dark and cold, she was all alone. In the everfree forest, how would she get home?
As Fluttershy countinued to walk, she heard a sudden footstep, She looked around and saw nopony.
"P-Pinkie Pie?" said Fluttershy. "Is that you?"
Fluttershy suddenly heard a lot of footsteps, going to her way, as she turned around she saw a tall pony with a grey hoodie.
"Hello, Fluttershy." The mysterious pony said, and grabbed her, Fluttershy screamed, But the mysterious pony closed her mouth, he went with Fluttershy into the deep woods, where the Last thing Fluttershy saw, was Pinkie Pie laying dead on the ground and then, it was all black.
The next morning, reports about a yellow pegasus and pink earth pony were on the news. The two ponies have been found dead in the everfree forest. Idenities of the ponies were not able to be announced yet, as the bodies were to mangled to tell.
