“W…what?”

Fluttershy couldn’t believe what she had just heard.

“You… want me to… take off m…my…”She stuttered in panic.

The Siren’s sniggered at her surprise.

“Like I said.” Adagio explained impatiently, “you humiliated me, so now I’m going to humiliate you. You are going to take all of your clothes off right now, in front of us. If you don’t, we will strip you naked ourselves, tie you to the flagpole outside, and leave you there until morning. It’s your choice.”

Fluttershy gasped again,

“N….no not…. You wouldn’t…”

“Yes, we would.” Adagio assured her, “and it would give me great pleasure.” Sonata and Aria nodded and readied themselves to pounce upon Fluttershy.

“Now, I’m going to ask you one more time. Strip, or be stripped.”

Fluttershy’s face turned a bright shade of pink. Her eyes were filled with fear when she realised that Adagio was serious. There was no way out; she had to do what they said, if she wanted this whole ordeal to be kept between the four of them. She tried not to cry as she lowered her head and looked at her body.

“Start with your boots.” Aria commanded.

Fluttershy took a breath and bent down to remove her boots, she could do that much fairly easily. She just had to not think about the situation, to concentrate on other things and forget that she was moments away from being stark naked and at the mercy of the three bullies.
She pulled one boot off, and tried to place it near her, but Aria snatched it out of her hands.

“Now the other one.” Sonata joined in.

Fluttershy removed her other boot, which was also taken by Aria. She then gazed upwards as though she wasn’t sure what to do next. Adagio rolled her eyes,

“Socks.” She folded her arms in an authoritive manner.

Fluttershy slowly pulled her socks off, one by one, and this time handed them to Aria, in hopes that the Siren’s would go a little easier on her if she cooperated. When she stood back up, she wasn’t overly surprised when Adagio didn’t give her the next step. The mean girl simply glared at her top, then into her eyes, and Fluttershy knew what she had to do.

She still hesitated however; the thought of having her bra on display was overwhelmingly embarrassing. Fluttershy was extremely self-conscious of showing off her body; she never even wore bikinis during summer.

“P…please.” She said timidly, “please don’t make me….”

Adagio only needed to frown to get the message across, and Fluttershy reluctantly lifted her white vest top higher and higher. She took another deep breathe before the fabric reached her breasts, then pulled it over her head in one swift movement.

She instantly heard giggling coming from the three sirens, and the shy girl clasped her arms to cover her chest while her cheeks turned far more vivid pink. Her top was snatched this time by Sonata.

“You’re almost done.” Adagio said tauntingly,

If anything those words made Fluttershy feel much worse, ‘almost done’ meant ‘almost completely naked in front of three evil girls who want to do unspeakable things to you’.

Tears appeared in Fluttershy’s eyes and she bowed her head,

“Please… if you let me go…. I won’t tell… I’ll do anythi….”

“Skirt.” Aria ordered coldly, and held out her hand.

Fluttershy sighed, feeling defeated and miserable. She reached for the hem of her skirt, and after pausing for a few seconds to try and relax her mind, she pulled it from her body, handed it to Sonata, then clenched her legs together and covered herself as best she could.

~*~

Sonata burst out laughing, closely followed by Aria and Adagio. Fluttershy whimpered and tried to hold back her tears as she stood there in her white underwear, being mocked and humiliated.

Then…. Flash.

Fluttershy gave a horrified squeak as she looked up and saw Sonata taking pictures of her on her phone.

“N…no… please!” She panicked and waved her arms around.

Adagio grabbed her.

“Don’t worry.” She said mockingly, “these pictures are for our personal use only. We won’t send them out to any other students…. so long as you keep your word and do whatever we say... slave.”

She let go of the whimpering girl, whilst Sonata took a few more photos.

Fluttershy had never felt so ashamed. She crouched and hid her face in her hair, trying to forget where she was and what was happening to her. It almost worked, for a second, but things were about to get much, much worse when Adagio gave the dreaded order.

“Remove your bra.”

Those words sent Fluttershy into a state of panic.

“P…please no… please! I… I’ll do anythi… please… don’t make me…” She cried,

Adagio was having none of it.

“Remove. Your. Bra.” She ordered. “or we will take it from you and post those pictures all over the school website. Sonata can log into our fake account and put them up for every student in the school to see. It would only take a few clicks.”

“Would you rather keep this between us, or would you rather we broadcast it?” Threatened Aria, as she held her hand out for Fluttershy’s bra.

Now sobbing, Fluttershy slowly reached behind her back to undo the fastening. Then she grasped her left strap, and lowered it whilst still looking at the floor. Fluttershy was sure Sonata was still holding the phone, and knew she had to cover her chest the second her breasts were revealed to prevent them from being caught on camera.

One strap down, the shy girl reached for the other. She slowly tugged it, and lifted her arm out, but still held the bra firmly to her chest.

“Pass it here.” Aria was starting to giggle again, which really wasn’t helping Fluttershy’s nerves.

She clenched her eyes shut and quickly placed the bra in Aria’s hands, then covered her chest with her arms. Sure enough, there was another photo, and more laughter.

“Your down to your last piece of clothing.” Adagio stated as though Fluttershy needed reminding. She gazed at Fluttershy’s underpants. “Remove them.”

Fluttershy knew she had to do it, but the fear was far too great. She didn’t want to move her arms from her chest and reveal her breasts, and she didn’t want to take off her pants and reveal her most private area to these the sirens. It was too much, it was too hard.

Whilst the three sniggered at her shame, Fluttershy began to sweat and her entire body flushed pink. She looked into the eyes of Adagio, who seemed to be getting impatient once more.

Then, whilst maintaining eye contact with Adagio as best she could, Fluttershy dropped to her knees.

This came as a surprise to the sirens, they looked down at the trembling girl with a mixture of confusion and irritation.
Then, Fluttershy spoke.

“Please… I’m sorry for what happened today. Please forgive me. Please don’t make me do this. I…I’ll do your homework… I’ll do your homework for the whole year…. I’ll make it up to you I…. I promise.”

There was a minute’s silence, and the three girls glared down at their victim.

Then…. laughter. Laughter and flashes.

Adagio then turned to Sonata, and whispered something which caused them both to cackle evilly. Sonata held the phone steady and directly at Fluttershy, who knew exactly what she was doing.

Adagio turned to the cowering girl, “You want my forgiveness?” she smirked, “Then get down all fours and beg me for mercy.”

Fluttershy’s eyes widened as she realised the humiliating situation she had just bought upon herself. The Sirens were going to film her begging them to let her go. She began to hyperventilate as she wondered if this was better or worse than being stripped completely nude. Her captures still showed her no mercy.

“I’m waiting.” Adagio tapped her foot.

Realising there was no way out, Fluttershy began to imagine what the Sirens would do to her completely naked body. She concluded that she had to do whatever she could to prevent her final piece of clothing from being taken from her. She had to please them.

In one quick movement, Fluttershy removed her hands and placed them on the floor so that she was on all fours, but kept her arms close enough to her body to cover as much of her chest as possible.

As commanded, she started to beg.

“Please.” She cried, “I... I’m begging you. Please have mercy. I won’t tell anybody about this, I won’t ever anger you again, please just let me go and delete those pictures. Please, I beg you, please.”

The siren’s continued to laugh, and Fluttershy let a few tears fall to the ground in hopes they would take pity upon her.

She pleaded over and over, whilst Adagio and Aria grinned in delight at her shame. After what seemed like an eternity, Adagio spoke.

"Okay, okay, that's enough." she turned to Sonata, who tapped her phone to stop the recording.

“That was great!” Sonata chuckled, “I’m keeping this video forever!”

She then played it for Adagio and Aria, who watched the entire thing in continuous laughter. Fluttershy’s face went beetroot red when she heard her desperate begging being repeated. She didn’t get up.

“Now.” Adagio grinned, “you certainly wouldn’t want this video getting out, now would you?”

“N…. no…” Fluttershy shook her head rapidly and looked up at Adagio with huge crystal blue eyes filled with tears.

To her horror, the leader of the sirens wasn’t at all moved by her state of despair. She crossed her arms, raised an eyebrow and spoke the words Fluttershy was dreading the most;

“Then I suggest you stop messing around. Get up and give me your pants, now.”

Author's Note

I'm English, 'pants' for us are what you refer to as 'panties' in the US. Sometimes I change things in my stories to fit with the American English as you tend to be the majority of people on sites like this, but I just don't like that word, no offence. :P