Fluttershy has a secret that she's kept from her friends for a very long time. The only other pony who knows is Rainbow Dash, her best friend since they met when they were small. As this secret starts to make Fluttershy's dating life harder, it also begins affecting her emotionally. She know's she can't keep it a secret forever, but how will her friends take it? Or worse, how will the stallions of Ponyville take it?