Dark Gift

by Questionable Brony

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Sunset Shimmer, Main 6, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Alternate Universe, Human, Nightmare Moon, Romance, Rarity
Length: 2762

Human Rarity gets turned into Nightmare Rarity. From there on she decides to "share" the gift she was given with her friends.

Human Rarity gets turned into Nightmare Rarity. From there on she decides to "share" the gift she was given with her friends.

It's sex. Not much of a story really in there.

Picture source.

Published 2015-08-16 02:50:01 UTC
Last updated 2015-11-02 23:55:35 UTC

Chapter 1

Author's Note

I didn't actually plan to write another story until I was done with The other kind of Generosity. Guess I have to hurry up. Also, next chapters are gonna be longer, don't worry. Finally constructive criticism would be very welcome.

Chapter 1

Rarity was reading one of her romance novels, lying in her almost queen sized bed. The story in general was about a dark queen, who just wanted to be loved, but had no experience in proper socializing, because of the dark history of her kingdom.

As the high school girl was absorbed in her book, she didn't noticed the black smoke entering her room through the open window. It didn't had any kind of form, yet the "head" seemed to be looking around, before quickly hiding under the bed. Rarity looked up from her book, thinking to have heard something. Her gaze fell onto the window and she concluded it just had been the wind.

Shrugging to herself she returned to her book, while the black cloud looked up from under the bed.

About thirty minutes later Rarity closed her book and laid it aside. Before shutting off the light on her nightstand, Rarity put on her sleep mask and laid back, snuggling into her blankets.

In the meantime under her bed, the black cloud waited for another hour or so until it made its move. Flying upwards it watched the sleeping human for a few seconds. Then the cloud lowered itself and gently picked up the girl. Careful not to wake her up, it titled the head of the girl a little, so it could enter Rarity's body. Once completely inside, Rarity's body unceremoniously hit the mattress.

Inside her dream, Rarity was wearing a beautiful blue dress complete with blue diamonds adorning it just at the right places. She was watching herself in the mirror, posing like a supermodel would do, when suddenly a woman walked up from behind. Startled a little, Rarity turned in order to greet the woman, but somehow couldn't bring herself to speak a word. Instead she stared at the woman, who quite easily was the most beautiful woman she had ever seen, even rivaling supermodels like Fleur De Lis. She wore a blue dress, which revealed quite a bit of her naked body, black stockings with high heels and black gloves. Around her neck was a black collar with a blue diamond in the middle. She wore blue lipstick, her hair was violet with white streaks in it and when one looked carefully, you could see that the eyes of the woman were draconian like and glowing in a faint blue.

"You're quite beautiful." The woman spoke, putting a hand on Rarity's cheek. "But something is missing." she continued moving her hand under the chin of the girl and forcing her to look into the eyes of the woman. "A certain touch..." the woman brought her face closer to Rarity, their lips only inches away from each other. Rarity didn't care. She was too enthralled in the beautiful eyes of the woman. "A certain touch of...darkness." The woman gave Rarity a gentle kiss on the lips.

Rarity wasn't sure if this was real or a dream, but she didn't really care. As soon as her lips and the lips of the woman had met, she had felt something inside her. And she liked the feeling. The woman gently kissed Rarity's lips again. And again. And each time the feeling would become stronger. A dark, exciting feeling.

The high school student dared to move closer to the woman, who seized the opportunity to wrap her arms around the girl and this time passionately kissed the girl on the lips. At first Rarity was taken aback, but after a moment she started to kiss back just as passionately, her lips fighting with those of the woman.

Rarity let out a moan, when she felt something inside her pussy! In fact the woman had put two of her fingers inside the pussy of the girl, who was now standing naked in front of the just as naked older woman. Hadn't they both been wearing clothes only a few minutes ago? Rarity didn't care. She didn't know why, but she felt so alive, so sexy and Faust damn it, she was horny. She moved her arms around the woman and forcefully grabbed both ass cheeks with her hands. Unfazed the woman continued with her two finger assault, while at the same time starting to kiss down Rarity's neck.

The girl moaned in pleasure and cried out loud, when the woman added two more fingers. It didn't take long for Rarity to reach her climax with those skillful fingers of her sex partner. Throwing back her head, she let out a scream, as the juices floated out of her pussy. The girl leaned against the woman's breast, who was stroking Rarity's head and chuckling darkly. The woman snapped with her fingers and suddenly she and Rarity were lying on a bed, with Rarity being at the bottom of the woman. Said beauty spread her legs, inviting Rarity to lick her pussy.

The high school girl didn't need anything else as a command. She quickly crawled over and started licking. The woman in return squished her own breast, while at the same time pressing the school girl's head between her legs.

"Oh yes, that's a good girl. Hmm, I wonder...oooh...are you a natural or do you perhaps...yesssss, that's it.....do you perhaps have experience in this kind of activity? Ahh...I beg to the latter."

Rarity blushed, not that her partner could see her. The juices she was licking up tasted like the divine nectar of the gods. Unbeknownst to her, the woman was mumbling an enchantment, which caused Rarity's entire body color to slowly turn from white to a deep black. Not only that, but she also grew in size a little, her hair was getting longer and changing color and her breast were now as big as the ones of the woman receiving pleasure. As said woman began reached her climax, she got up and pressed Rarity's face against her pussy.

"Now drink Rarity. Drink and be reborn as the one and only Queen of the Night. Accept the darkness! Accept MEEEEEEEEEEE!" Nightmare screamed as the juices flooded into Rarity's mouth, who drank all of it, while pleasuring herself with two of her own fingers. She moaned uncontrollably as she felt herself all of the sudden becoming stronger, her soul being corrupted by the very essence of the Nightmare. She couldn't get enough, she needed more darkness, more pleasure, more power. Both Nightmare and Rarity let out a final scream, before it turned into one and Nightmare Rarity woke up.

Chapter 2

Rarity or Nightmare Rarity, inspected herself in front of her mirror, admiring the various changes her body had gone through. She looked just like a goddess. Indeed she was a goddess, a goddess of darkness that is. The power of the Nightmare flowed through her veins and she finally understood how Sunset Shimmer and the Dazzlings felt, when they were at the peak of their power.

Rarity frowned, at the thought of her friend. How she could live without this power was beyond her, but that wouldn't matter. She would give Sunset back what the poor girl lost. In fact she decided to share the power with all of her friends. It would be pretty selfish to keep everything for herself and her friends just had as much right as she had of owning this power.

Now the problem was, Rarity couldn't just straight out offer this gift to her friends. No doubt they would call princess Twilight over and she would find away to take everything away from Rarity and thus taking everything away from her friends, which, ironically, included Twilight herself. It would be best to convince them one by one and do it so in a more "subtle" approach. And Nightmare Rarity knew exactly how.

Smiling to herself, Rarity used her new found magic in order to turn her back to the high school girl she used to be. It was just an illusion of course and her old body was not quite as beautiful as her new one. But she would have to endure it for the time being. After all she was getting a visitor today. Luckily Sweetie Belle was staying with their parents for the time being.

I need to think of something else for Sweetie. What I'm about to do to Fluttershy really is nothing for children. She may be a dark goddess, but she still had her dignity.

The next hour Rarity waited impatiently for Fluttershy to arrive. In order to pass the time, she decided to start designing some new dresses, dresses worth for seven new Empresses. Easier said than done, especially for Applejack and Rainbow Dash, who weren't really the dress type. Armor perhaps? She sketched down some ideas, before the doorbell rang.

Excitingly Rarity walked to her door and opened it.

"Fluttershy. Do come in."

"Hello Rarity and thank you." her friend replied, stepping inside.

"Do you want some tea perhaps?"

Fluttershy smiled. "Tea sounds nice, thank you."

So adorable and so beautiful.

For the next thirty minutes the two had engaged small talk, regular stuff the two would always talk about. Fluttershy was like a very delicate flower and needed to be treated like one. Only after getting her second cup of tea, Rarity placed herself next to her friend on the couch.

"Speaking of Flash Sentry, did anyone perhaps caught your attention?" Rarity asked innocently.

Fluttershy blushed and looked to the side. "N-no." she squeaked.

Stifling a laugh, the goddess placed herself closer to her shy friend and placed a hand on the other one's. "You know Fluttershy, you can always ask me for help, if you ever feel this way towards someone. I know a lot of the boys have their eyes on you."

Fluttershy meeped again and hid further behind her hair. Rarity took the girl into a hug, rubbing the back of the pink haired animal caretaker. The girl quickly relaxed in her friend's grasp, partially because Rarity started using her magic, calming down the mind of the girl.

"Fluttershy, look up."

The shy girl did as she was told and found herself staring into a pair of beautiful blue glowing eyes. How come she never noticed that her friend had such pretty eyes?

"Fluttershy" the voice seemed to come from everywhere "look deep into my eyes. Feel yourself falling deeper and deeper under my spell."

"Y-yes...must fall deeper..." Fluttershy replied automatically. The world around her started to fade and only the eyes of her friend, no her mistress mattered.

"You're safe, Fluttershy." The voice continued. "I will not let anyone harm you ever again. As long as you are with you're safe. You are taking care off. You are loved. Your mistress loves you."

"Safe...taking care off...mistress loves me...."

"You love your mistress too, don't you?"

"Love mistress..."

"That's right Fluttershy. You love me: your mistress Nightmare Rarity. You love Nightmare Rarity, you trust her, you obey her. Repeat Fluttershy: trust, love, obey."

"Trust, love, obey..."

Nightmare Rarity smiled, back in her true form. This was almost too easy. Fluttershy had fallen numb into her arms, looking up at Rarity's eyes with a smile.´But then again, Nightmare Rarity didn't really expect much resistant from Fluttershy of all people. The girl was just way too dependent on her friends.

"Fluttershy, fall deeper into the trance. With each time I kiss you, not only do you fall deeper, but you also feel a wave of pleasure going through your body."

Fluttershy shivered in delight as Rarity delivered the first kiss on her lips. It had been a light one and only lasted a moment or two. Rarity continued this procedure, each time sending shivers through Fluttershy.

"Trust, love, obey." Every so often Rarity would say those words, deepening the hypnosis.

Out of nowhere, Rarity started assaulting Fluttershy with kisses, starting on the lips and trailing down her neck. Fluttershy gasped and panted heavily. The pleasure going through her body was almost non-stop and she had the urge to touch herself, but couldn't do it, because her mistress didn't allow it.

Rarity continued her assault, knowing her friend was close, very close. She grabbed Fluttershy's head with her hands and pressed their lips onto each other, their tongues wrestling for dominance and Nightmare Rarity obviously winning. It was then that Fluttershy let out a moan, her juices flowing out of her nether.

"Look at what you have done, you naughty girl. I think it is time for a shower. Follow me."

"Yes, mistress."

In the shower Fluttershy moaned, while Nightmare Rarity stuck her fingers into Fluttershy's clit. With her left hand, Rarity moved her hand up and began rubbing one of her friend's tits, also kissing her on the back of her head. With each kiss, Fluttershy felt something like an electric shock going through her body. She moved her own hand up and started rubbing her other tit.

She heard Nightmare Rarity chuckling darkly. "You're enjoying it aren't you? But, don't you feel something else?"

"Something else?" Fluttershy asked her between pants. "Ah!" Rarity kissed her on the back of the head again.

"You feel it don't you? The darkness slowly spreading through your body. It feels good, doesn't it?"

"Ye-es, mistress. It's amazing!" Fluttershy's heart hammered against her chest.

Rarity turned the girl around in a swift motion and held the girl on her shoulders, while letting her gaze into Nightmare's eyes.

"Feel the darkness, Fluttershy. Embrace the darkness. Let it take over your mind and body and I promise you there will be no more pain, no more struggle, only pleasure. Aren't you sick of it? Everyone only using you? Being weak and helpless? You hate it."

"I hate it."

"You don't want to be pushed around anymore."

"I don't want to be pushed around anymore."

"That's right Fluttershy." Nightmare Rarity kissed her friend on the lips, the other kissing back eagerly. Rarity's hands trailed down, touching Fluttershy's ass cheeks."You want to be the mistress. Imagine, everyone else being your pet. You love pets, don't you?"

"I love pets." Fluttershy smiled evilly, images of her fellow students, either tied up or on a leash.

"Accept my gift Fluttershy and everything will be better. Say it."

"I..."

"Say it..."

"I...I accept."

Nightmare Rarity smiled, not an evil one, mind you. It was a genuine smile.

"Then kneel down." Fluttershy obeyed, going on her knees. Rarity walked up until she stood above the girl. "Drink." she pressed the girl's face against her pussy.

Fluttershy eagerly started licking, her tongue eagerly exploring her mistress' womanhood. Said mistress grabbed one of her own breasts, while continuing to press her friend's head against her own pussy. What Fluttershy lagged in skill, she easily compensated it with her eagerness.

"Yes, I'm almost there. Yes, yes, YES!" Rarity came on Fluttershy's face, who started glowing in a blue light as soon as it happened. As the light disappeared, Fluttershy was still there, but she looked a little different. Her hair was considerably longer and a little darker, her already large breasts increased in size and overall her skin was smoother and slightly shiny, like Rarity's.

Fluttershy, Rarity wasn't sure of the girl- no woman- still went by that name, stood slowly up until she was her full height and opened her eyes. Nightmare smiled, upon seeing the draconian eyes.

"You tricked me." Fluttershy stated as a matter of fact, her face completely passive. Rarity waited patiently for her friend to speak again.

"Thank you." she said after a minute, smiling at Rarity, revealing sharp canine teeth. Rarity smiled back and embraced her friend, both eagerly starting to kiss each other, their tongues once again wrestling for dominance. They only parted ways, because they needed to catch their breath.

"Still, you have been a naughty girl, Rarity." Fluttershy gave her friend a tooth grin. "Naughty girls need to be punished."

Rarity laughed at her words. "Oh? I think someone needs to learn just who the mistress is!" Without further warning, Rarity threw Fluttershy at the bottom of the bathtub and pressed their clits against each other. Fluttershy growled more like an animal, than a human managed to reverse their positions, by launching herself up and throwing Rarity onto the other end of the tub. Their struggle continued for hours to come.

Chapter 3

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.