Button Mash has hidden feelings for the beautiful mare known as Sweetie Belle. He continuously tries to confess his feelings to her, but he always gets nervous and runs away from his feelings. One night, he comes across a realization: He always plays the hero in video games, and the hero always gets the girl, but will he, as a gamer, ever get the girl?

As Button starts playing his favorite video game, Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, he somehow gets sucked into the game and is forced to play through it.