The Game

Having sex with Rainbow Dash was about as awesome as it came. Not only did she literally do a “sonic rain-cum,” but her serious sex was intense as well. I hated to say that my “welcome-back fuck” with Luna was merely “alright.”

As long as I made her happy, I guess.

In fact the whole of my day was spent beating off to “saved images” of Rainbow Dash that I had on my computer, just so I’d get bored enough of her for a while to have passionate enough sex with the rest of the ponies I was supposed to bone.
I cuddled back into bed that “night” with Luna, where we spooned as we fell asleep.
_________________________________________________________________________________________

I woke feeling refreshed, but my hand felt warm and moist. Upon moving it, I felt it slide out of a wet, fleshy slit. My motions in Luna’s vagina woke her up.

I’m not even surprised at this point.

“Good morning,” she greeted. “Who’s up next today?”

“I don’t know."

“Who do you have left?”

“Let’s see. I may have Bon-Bon, The Doctor, the Wonderbolts…” I began to realize how many ponies I had left and decided to go straight to the dice.

“Are you really starting so early?” asked Luna.

“Yes. I’m sorry that we can’t fuck right now, but I really want to get moving. I promise that we’ll make passionate love when I get back.”

“Alright.” Her voice sounded forlorn, but I ignored it. I rolled the dice. Six.

M’kay.

The piece moved and the text appeared.

Of the two newlyweds, with whom do you want to share their bed?

Two more texts appeared.

Shining Armor. Cadance.

I began feeling pangs of pre-emptive guilt. I didn’t feel comfortable enough providing love to one and not the other. Plus, I haven’t gotten with a stallion since Big Mac.

“Uh…” I began. “Both?”

It seemed to have worked, for I was whisked into the board with no complications.
_________________________________________________________________________________________

The next thing I knew, I was flung from the closet in what looked like Rarity's room from the Sweet and Elite episode. Upon looking around, I saw both Shining Armor and Cadance on the bed. Cadance was on her back with her wings spead out and her legs wide open, revealing her moist vagina. Shining Armor laid on his side, his erect cock lying on the bed between them.

I hope I didn’t interrupt anything.

“Oh,” exclaimed Cadance. “I guess its that time. Who’s turn is it?”

“I said both. Does that count?”

Giving his wife a sly smile, he levitated my naked body to the bed.

“Alright,” said Shining Armor, “who gets to go first?”

I leaned into his ear and whispered something. Something that apparently made Shining Armor very happy.

“What is it dear?” Cadance asked.

“Let me finish,” he said climbing back on top of her.

Shining Armor began to penetrate his wife again, resuming what I assumed to be what they were doing before my arrival. I crawled over the bed and behind Shining Armor. I began by licking the bare skin in his asscrack, tasting the sweat that rolled down his flesh. Sometimes I would feel his hot thighs squeeze my tongue as he contracted the muscles to thrust inside of Cadance.

I then inserted my tongue as deep as I could into the stallion’s anus. He had no “undesireable” solids inside of him, just like Big Macintosh. And like Big Macintosh, it didn’t taste like anything in there. I again felt his asshole tighten with each time he inserted himself into his wife.

The next time, I applied a lot of spit to my tongue, and upon inserting it, I felt as the flesh of Shining Armor’s innards contracted around my tongue and “sucked” the saliva off. Now, he was nice and lubricated.

Crouching over the stallion, I stuck my erect penis into the bottom part of his asscrack, letting his thighs take hold. The sweat mixed with my spit helped it slide in easily. After thusting into him more in the same place, I moved up a little, into the place in his ass where my dick rubbed up against Shining Armor’s waist and lower stomach. After more thrusts, I knew it was time. Using my strength, I plowed into his anus just before he could thrust.

The feeling of my cock in his ass must have surprised him, as I felt the same pressure around my sex as I did with my tongue earlier, but my with my vigor and saliva coating the inside of him, I continued to push my way in. Shining Armor bit his lip, obviously feeling a massive amount of ecstacy. Realizing this was a losing battle for him, he let me slip my dick fully into his asshole.

He then pulled out a little for another thrust, and I did the same. He thrust in again, and so did I. With his contracting anus holding my dick, I thrust into him until I felt a tight tug on my foreskin.

We continued the same motions, me thrusting into him as he thrust into Cadance. Shining Armor was in a sweat, indicating that he was getting close. With my dick massaging his prostate, his cum was extraordinary. He made a loud yell as he shot a load of semen into her. His final massive insertions brought Cadance over the edge, leaving her screaming as she came. The sounds of intense pleasure overcame me too, as I ejaculated into Shining Amor.

Shining Armor and I laid on the bed together in exhaustion, my face being inches from his dick. Without a second thought, I gave his cum-coated dick an experimental lick.

Tastes just like his sister.

I continued to caress Shining Armor’s sex with my mouth when I was interrupted by his wife.

“Okay,” she said. “Your turn.”

I climbed back onto my knees and knelt in front of Cadance. As I began to climb over her so I could penetrate her, my mind flashed and saw Cadance as Rainbow Dash for a second. Ignoring it, I began to fuck Cadance. The more I boned her, the more I imagined Rainbow Dash. I knew that I wasn’t seducing a mare that I was feeling like fucking, so I felt my penis begin to soften.

I quickly took myself out of her and sat down on the bed.

“What’s wrong?” she asked me, sitting up and rubbing my back.

“There’s… somepony else,” I muttered.

“You mean…”

“I had sex with Rainbow Dash last. I really liked my time with her and now I can’t feel the same about any other mare.”

“Here,” said Cadance. “I can help with that. Lie on your back and let me see your penis.”

I did as I was told. Cadance stood above me, her head directly above my dick.

“Can you imagine Rainbow Dash for me?” she asked.

I imagined Rainbow Dash on top of me as she sucked me off like last time. I felt my penis begin to rise until my dick was fully erect. I looked at Cadance, whose horn began glowing. She then pointed it towards my penis and began lowering it towards it. Once her horn touched my tip, I felt a comfortable heat on it. That’s when she inserted her horn into my urethra.

I was instantly reminded of the painful curse that Discord began to do on me, but instead of sheer pain, I felt comfortable and warm. With my new penis length, she had to insert a little more than half of her horn into my dick. Then, her horn grew a bright white, and multiple red hearts swirled around my penis. I then began to feel love for everypony all at once. Those that I’ve already had sex with in the course of this game, those that I had left to screw, and of course, Cadance.

Oh, Cadance. You beautiful creature. You’re so unbelievably sexy that I could just… I could…

Cadance then quickly took her horn out from my cock before I came at least a cup of sperm into the air all over the bed.

“Oops,” I say.

“Don’t worry about it,” said Cadance, lying on her back again. “Now, where were we.”

I took no second thoughts about rutting her. I quickly, but gently slid my entire penis into her. As I began to rut her, I felt something insert itself into my anus. I looked over my shoulder to see Shining Armor boning me from behind. Surprisingly, his dick felt snug in my asshole and also felt amazing as it massaged my prostate. I continued on Cadance as Shining Armor continued on me.

As I rutted Cadance, I laid my body on top of her and wrapped my arms around her upper back. Her fur was so smooth and she looked drop-dead gorgeous. Cadance hugged me in tighter with both her forelegs and her wings, putting me in a full-bodied hug.

Shining Armor even spruced things up, licking my body all over during, including my anus a couple of times (having to pull out to do so of course). However, Shining Armor’s reinsertion felt wonderful afterwards.

With the combination of Cadance’s warm juices on my sex, the softness and warmth of her fur and down all over my body, and Shining Armor’s hard, fleshy penis probing my prostate, I finally came inside of her. Strangely, Cadance came immediately after me and Shining Armor after Cadance, which was the order of our last threesome. Shining Armor took himself out of me and began sucking my ass like a large straw. Once he was done, I looked back. He gave me smile with his teeth covered in milky white goo.

Cadance was asleep by the time Shining Armor went to the bathroom to spit. After cumming two times and performing a spell like that, I’d be sleepy too. Shining Armor crawled back into bed, where I napped for a while, hugging him like a teddy bear… that I just fucked.

After waking up, I found Shining Armor’s crouching down with his ass above my face.

“Well,” said Shining Armor, “it’s been fun. Good luck on completing the game.”

I gently slapped Shining Armor’s asshole, signaling my readiness to return. He sat on my face, sucking me into him and brining me back to my room.

“There you are,” said Luna. “I’ve been waiting forever for you.”

I looked at Luna, and all of the sudden, I just realized that I never saw her this beautiful.

What could have caused me to- ha! The spell!

“Hello?” she asked, trying to get an answer from my mesmerized self.

I then leaped onto the bed and proceeded to rut her brains out.