A Tempting Offer

by Karackas

Rating: mature
Tags: Princess Celestia, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Comedy, Nightmare Moon, Sex
Length: 2900

Nightmare Moon rules Equestria. The night is everlasting and more ponies adhere to her point of view every day. There is no pony left willing to stand against her, so why does her sister still resist the pleasures the night could provide her?

The Night has finally taken her rightful place at the head of Equestria. As a result of her return from exile, a blanket of lust has covered the nation, and the streets of Equestria are packed with the writhing orgies of its citizens. After all, there is no judgment in the dark, and the night has always brought out the hottest flames of passion. Not a hole goes unfilled, and the ponies rejoice at the return of their true princess.

Above the joyous cities, Nightmare Moon tries her hoof at converting her sister. It shouldn't be too difficult. Who can resist the allure of endless pleasure?

Contains: light bondage, forced voyeurism, yelling, guilt, shifting perspective.

((Cover image not owned by me.))

Published 2015-09-06 13:50:02 UTC
Last updated 2015-09-06 13:50:02 UTC

A New Future

Author's Note

This was a piece for a competition, and I'm fairly proud of it. Not sure if I'll make a second chapter, I'll probably base that on public opinion. I wrote this on my mobile, so it'll look better on a mobile device!

A New Future

Chapter 1: A New Future

"I don't understand why you won't just accept it, Celestia!" The dark figure ranted, feeling quite annoyed. "You could have so much joy and happiness in your life if you would just let somepony inside! Even once!"

Celestia turned her face away, not deigning to speak to that creature. Not that she could if she wanted; she was currently bound and gagged, her wings tied together and her flank sitting chained to the floor in her own bedroom. Why she had had the slots for the chains installed in her own room she couldn't remember for the life of her.

"It's not like it's a bad thing! It's done exactly the same ways as before, just more often. And with more partners. Often in public. No limitations." The dark alicorn smiled, looking very pleased with herself. "You deserve it more than anypony, Tia! How long has it been since you've felt release? A millennium? Two? You need this, sister."

Celestia's eyes glared at her captor, the contempt in her gaze a thin veil for the heartbreak she felt on the inside. It had been a thousand years since she had lost her sweet little Lulu to that devil that paced before her. Now that thing that ate her was here. In front of her. Opening her scars and bringing all her pain to the surface. Nightmare Moon insisted that she was really still Luna; just a version of her that wouldn't cow down to the neglect and mistreatment she had experienced at the hooves of her sister.

The shackled white alicorn had to hold back tears whenever she thought of those words. Angry as she was, she simply couldn't deny the truth in the Nightmare's words. She had been horrible to her baby sister in the last few years. Stealing Luna's responsibilities, disregarding her counsel, ignoring her cries for help, assuming her pleas for attention were just that. This was entirely on her, and she would never forgive herself if she lost her sister forever because of her own stupidity.

Nightmare Moon stared at her sister, hoping her words would provoke some sort of reaction. Seeing that her plan had failed, she decided on a new tactic.

"I assume you've needed it just as much as I had," Celestia's ears perked up. That's what Nightmare wanted to see. "I was so pent up for so long, you know. But of course you know, it was your fault!" She used her hoof to turn Celestia's face, forcing the gagged mare to look at her. "How many suitors came to the castle for me, Celestia? How many ponies did you keep away from me just because you were afraid to lose the spotlight?!"

A defeated look appeared on Celestia's face. She was right again. She HAD been keeping ponies away from Luna. She DID love being in the spotlight, and that had been all that had mattered. Regardless of what Nightmare Moon felt, nopony hated Celestia more than she did herself.

"But those problems are all over, for me," Nightmare gloated. "Ooooohhh, yes. The first time I had sex as Nightmare Moon, I saw colors! It had been so long, and he got sooooo deep inside me…"

She didn't want to hear this. Luna was still her baby sister, and the thought of her having mind-blowing sex with some hunky, well-hung stallion is… is…

…Kinda hot.

Wait, what?!

"When he finally filled me up, I thought I would go blind! He just kept cumming and cumming and I screamed for a full minute! But he didn't stop there, no. The sounds his hips made against my luscious plot were music to my ears. As much fun as it is to be in charge, there are few pleasures in life that can match when a stallion uses you like a toy for his own pleasure."

At this point, Nightmare was breathing heavily. She loved thinking back to that night. Not to mention the subsequent nights that followed it. A lot of sexual tension can build up when being alone for a thousand years, and masturbation stops helping after a while. She was still making up for a millennium of arousal, as evidenced by the moisture that began dripping down her leg during her monologue.

Celestia, loathe to admit it, was in a similar state of arousal. Of course, she was much too proud to even acknowledge that what the dark creature said was truth. Her little Luna would never. Come to think of it, that rant of her’s didn't even sound real. It sounded like something out of those lame clopfics of which she totally had not read hundreds, and most certainly had not written any of her own.

"This sexual freedom that I have introduced to my nation is grand, and you could be a part of it! All you have do is accept my rule and swear fealty to me. And all those hot, sweaty, "sex-on-a-stick" stallions will be yours." Nightmare crooned in a soothing, almost sultry voice.

No. The beast had to be lying. It was all just a ploy to provoke some sort of reaction from her. She turned her head and closed her eyes, defiant. She would not be tempted by lust, no matter how hot and bothered some of those sexy, succulent stallion guards made her.

Nightmare noticed the lack of reaction and stalled for a second. What was the problem? Wait, did she play for the other team? "Uuhmm… not stallions, but sweet, tender, voluptuous mares instead?"

Still no response. Celestia refused also to think about the way sweat poured down a guardsmare's body after a workout.

The Nightmare's eye twitched. Nothing was working, this wasn't the plan! Celestia should have at least been a weeping or quivering mess by now.

"Say something."

She ripped off the gag that had been keeping Celestia muted.

"Say. Something."

Celestia flexed her jaw, but closed it and said nothing. She would not give it the satisfaction.

Enraged, Nightmare grabbed her sister's head with her forehooves and turned it to look in her eyes. "FUCKING SAY SOMETHING! Tell me I'm wrong, call me a bitch, spit in my face!"

It almost looked like tears were forming in Nightmare's eyes, but that must be a trick of the light. Celestia averted her eyes. No matter what, that crea-

"DAMMIT! NOTICE ME, SENPAI!"

Wait…

That voice was…

Nightmare Moon's hooves shot to her mouth in shock. A blush covered her cheeks, so bright red that it could be seen through her jet black fur. She turned her back to Celestia, not wanting to show any more weakness than had already been revealed.

Celestia's mouth hung in awe. She didn't know how it could be possible; but just then in that final shout, her voice had sounded much more like…

"L-Luna? Is that you?"

Nightmare Moon spun back around, wings flared and eyes blazing. "What did you call me?! I'M NIGHTMARE FUCKING MOON, BITCH! I'm the night itself! I'm every bad dream, scary shadow, and monster under the bed! I am the greatest princess Equestria has ever known, and you will address me as such!"

But the smiling white alicorn would not be deterred. "I know you're still in there, Lulu. And I promise that I will never stop fighting to free you!"

Moony snorted and turned away, heading for the door. "Fine. If you won't believe who I am, and you won't accept what I'm offering, then how about some… visual stimulation?"

Something in Nightmare's tone unsettled Celestia.

The door to her chambers opened and a unicorn guard walked in. The grin on his face was one of a pony whom had just won the lottery, and reminded Celestia of the look on Twilight's face when told that there would be a quiz today. The guard walked confidently toward the bed, standing tall on all five legs. He bowed low to Nightmare and mov-

Wait. Five legs?

That's when she saw it. Her face turned beet red and she rubbed her thighs together instinctively. That wasn't a leg. HOLY SHIT, was that stallion hung! The tip was almost dragging across the floor! Celestia's jaw dropped to the floor and a small puddle of fluid began to creep out from where she was sitting. She had never seen a unicorn that was hung like a zebra. It was usually pegasi that had it made in the inches department!

There was a reason most of her personal guard were pegasi, after all. It totally was NOT for THAT reason, of course. But she would be lying if she said that it wasn't a consideration. Now she was wondering how many other unicorns were hiding boa constrictors in their armor, and if she would have to rethink her "mainly-pegasi" policy.

At Nightmare Moon's behest, he jumped onto the bed and sat down, spreading his hind legs to give the two alicorn mares an unbridled view of his glory. Both Celestia and Nightmare held their breath; he wasn't quite erect yet, but his heartbeat was already visible in his junk. It was clear that he was a bit lacking in thickness, but he certainly made up for it in length. It was possible that he had a rough time in bed, considering how a smaller mare might barely get him halfway in.

Nightmare locked her lips with his and engaged in a battle of the tongues the likes of which most would associate with horny teenagers. They were all over the place; moaning into each other's mouths, hooves wrapped around the other, eyes closed and movements jerky enough to be almost violent. They visibly swallowed when they broke apart, having filled their mouths with their partner's saliva. They both wiped away the extraneous spit covering their lips and turned to Celestia, whom had noticed a detail that demanded all her attention.

The unicorn's cock had become rock hard at some point during the kiss. The damn thing reached all the way up to his chest, and throbbed in time with the horny colt's heartbeat. Nightmare noticed her sister's stare and took the meat rod in her hoof, holding it gently.

"You like? I discovered him by accident, but it was one of the happiest accidents ever," the guard kissed her cheek and Nightmare nuzzled him in return. "Celestia, meet my newest lover. I call him ‘Tower.’ Because, well, you know." She stroked the rod up and down with her hoof, her stallion resting his head on her shoulder as she did so.

It was such an open display of affection that Celestia wondered just how close the two of them really were. She hadn't thought a creature of darkness could form attachments like that… but she also hadn't thought her sister could become a creature of darkness, so what did she know.

During this train of thought, Nightmare had switched positions. She was currently kneeling on the floor below Tower, his dick resting on her grinning face.

"Tower has been so good to me, Celestia," Nightmare crooned. "Tower and ‘his tower’ have helped me work through so much pent up stress. He could do the same for you, you know. Is that right, baby?"

He looked up at Celestia, giving her flank a good long stare. "Yeah, I'd tap that." His young, deep voice sent shivers down the spines of both mares in the room. "Of course I'd fuck her. That's the only reason anypony has ever joined the Guard; we all just want a chance at getting in her bed." He turned and smiled at Nightmare. "But you're a much better princess, my love. I'd follow you anywhere. Especially if I get to look at that sweet plot while I do!"

While the two lovers began another kiss, Celestia pondered his words. She had always known that ponies had found her attractive, and had long suspected that some became guards and such just to spend time in the castle around her. But ALL of them? She wasn't sure if she believed that.

His words didn't make his offer any less tempting, though. While she thought about all the benefits of having an army of huge cocks at her command, yet another strange notion entered her mind. If she had the power to turn the entire country into a harem with her at the center, why had she not done so before? What was holding her back? She felt like there was a piece of the puzzle that she was missing, but had to cut this thought short when Nightmare started talking again.

"I've brought Tower here tonight for his reward. After all he's done for me, he deserves it." Before another word could be spoken, Nightmare stuck out her tongue and ran it base to head along the underside of his cock, making Tower groan in delight. She repeated this action twice more before making an "O" shape with her mouth and enveloping the head in her maw. Her tongue circled the tip before she bobbed her head up and down to take the first two inches.

Tower was biting his lip and using every ounce of his willpower not to cum on the spot. Her mouth was like a little slice of paradise, and had an almost electric feel to it. There was no way to describe it beyond "the best fucking feeling in the universe." No mare had ever pleased him the way that Princess Moon could, and there was not a doubt in his mind that her highness had ruined him for other mares.

On her next downward plunge, Nightmare allowed more of him to enter her muzzle. Massaging his meat with her tongue as she went, she made it to the medial ring before his tip threatened to hit the back of her throat. Not moving any further down, she bobbed her head from the ring to his tip, giving him a proper blowjob.

Celestia was trying her best to not pay attention and not think about the conflicting emotions raging inside her. Her little sister was giving head to a hot stallion not five hooves away from her! What was worse; she was starting to feel attracted to them both! Nightmare's sweet, toned plot; and Tower's towering tower. But she mustn't think these thoughts. She'll just close her eyes and look away fro-

A magical aura turned her face toward the scene and pinned her eyelids open. She saw Nightmare's horn glowing, and Tower took the time from his moaning to wink at her.

The moaning of a happy stallion was an aphrodisiac to Nightmare, and she took her job one step farther. Taking a deep breath and relaxing her throat, she went past the medial ring to gobble up more of his sexy meat. Swallowing every inch that entered her throat, she finally came to a rest when her nose hit the hair on his crotch and her chin hit his balls. She looked up at him with wide, innocent eyes that were almost too adorable to be have ever been evil. Adorable even regardless of being those scary-looking turquoise dragon eyes.

Tower had meanwhile lost all semblance of coherent thought. No mare had EVER taken him to the hilt before. This was definitely a mare whom he would stand by for the rest of his life.

He was already on the edge from the blowjob, but those eyes sealed the deal. His body quaked and he tried his best to warn her. "Princess! I'm gonna-" but it was too late. Bursts of cum shot directly into Nightmare's stomach, his cock being so far down that she needn't even swallow. He was almost yelling his pleasure now, giving his mate an indication of the white hot bliss that he was experiencing.

Nightmare held his position and let him have his moment. She was loving this almost as much as he was, as evidenced by how swollen and wet her pussy had become. She loved pleasure, both giving and receiving. THIS was what her kingdom would be about!

When Tower finished and collapsed onto the bed, Nightmare pulled off his cock with a loud pop and took a few deep breaths. She sighed in contentment, appreciating a (blow)job well done. Remembering why she had been there in the first place, she turned around and almost doubled over in laughter at her sister's predicament.

Celestia's face was a bright shade of cherry red. Her wings her straining against their restraints, but the wingboner wasn't even the funniest part. Celestia was sitting in a veritable lake of her vaginal secretions. The pool extended at least two hooves away from the former princess, and the poor thing was almost tearing up in need.

When Nightmare Moon regained control over herself, she took a step toward her sister. Celestia did not flinch away this time. "There are hundreds of ponies whom would be ecstatic to clean up this mess and help you make a new one, sister. All you have to do is accept it."

What a tempting offer.