Reality is Better Than a Dream

Why oh why did she say that?! This was him! The man from her dreams who captured her! As far as she knew, she just gave him the opening he needed to lock her up. It was a crowded party, and a masquerade at that. No one would even notice she was gone. Sapphire Shores would ask about her, but she might just suspect that Rarity had left early or something.

Yet she had just asked him to take her. Maybe she did want this. Perhaps she did want to be captured.

“Are you sure?” the masked man, apparently named Noble Heart said (she didn't think that was his real name though).

“Yes!” Rarity said all too quickly, “You're right. I do need this. I'm just a little...”

“Nervous?” Noble Heart asked, taking Rarity's hand and caressing it, “You know, I do know a little about BDSM.”

“Do you now?” Rarity asked, her breathing picking up from both his words and his touch.

“As the sub, it's on you to control the scene,” he continued, “You decide what we do, how it begins, and how far we go.”

“Oooooh...” Rarity moaned. Noble Heart moved so he was right behind her and still with her hand in his, he used his other hand to rub her shoulder. He leaned in close and whispered into her ear.

“So, how would you like this scene to start? Do you want me to just lead you to my room, or do you want to really have fun with this? Make it a bit of a game of pretend?”

Pretend, huh? She used to play pretend a lot with her friends when she was a kid. She liked to fantasize about her perfect capture, so maybe she could make it happen here. But what if Noble Heart took advantage of this, tied her up somewhere and just left her there.

Ooh… I must be sick…

The idea of being bound and left there is just too appealing to me…

“D-don't just… take me to your room...” Rarity stuttered, “I want this to feel like an actual kidnapping.”

“Very well,” Noble Heart said, “How about this then. I'll leave the party, so start mingling for a few minutes. At around...” he looked up at the clock, “nine fifteen, step away from the party, going to that hall over there.”

He pointed to a hall on the left side of the main room. Rarity noticed that not a lot of people were going in that direction.

“What's over there?” Rarity asked. Noble Heart squeezed her arm, and she gasped from the sudden pressure.

“That, Rarity, leads to the stairs going to my room,” he explained, “No one is there for the party, so you can say that you're going to explore.”

“Are you sure that's okay?” Rarity asked.

“Technically you're not, but we'll pretend that your curiosity got the better of you.”

“From there,” Rarity said, feeling creative, “You'll scold me, and claim that you'll punish me for trespassing.”

“Do you want me to do anything before we go to my room?” Noble Heart asked.

How could she make this better? How could she make this feel real to her? Well, there was something she had always envisioned happening to her, just like in a story she read.

“Well… this is a little risque… but…” Rarity said, deciding to just take a chance and go all out, “There's something special that I'd like you to do to me once you catch me…”

“Auntie!” Blueblood called out, tracking down his aunt, who was still sitting with that blue haired woman in the fancy mask, “I need an inhibitor ring!”

Luna looked up at Blueblood and blinked, her friend putting a hand on her hip.

“That's... not odd at all,” she said sarcastically.

“Hush Sapphire,” Luna said sweetly, “I think I know why he needs it,” she pulled out a small ring out of her pocket and cast a spell on it, “This should suffice. It'll last as long as you want it to.”

“Thank you Auntie,” Blueblood said taking the ring and hugging her, “I freaking love you.”

“I set up a few things in your room,” Luna said with a knowing smirk, “Make use of them, and just have fun.”

“I don't know what you mean, but I won't ask questions,” Blueblood smiled at Luna, “This is the best birthday ever!”

He ran to his room to prepare. She didn't know who it was, but that didn't matter to him at the moment. Just one night with Rarity to give her the night she wanted was all he wanted. Mind you, he didn't fully understand why she wanted this, but she had assured him that it would be okay, and he had also discussed with her a safe word.

As long as she didn't say “red” it would be fine.

In his room, he was shocked to say the least. It wasn't much, but it was enough to make Blueblood wonder exactly what his aunt did in her spare time. Well, none of that mattered. Right now all he needed to do was prepare for Rarity. He was determined to give her a night she'd never forget.

“Rarity, is that you?” Sassy Saddles said walking over to Rarity, who stood by the refreshment table nursing a drink.

“Oh, yes,” Rarity said greeting her friend with a hug, “How are you enjoying the party?”

“It's not my cup of tea usually, but I've never been one to turn down an open invitation,” she leaned in with a smirk, “I'm using this as an opportunity to advertise.”

“Wonderful idea,” Rarity said, taking a brief look at the clock. It was almost time. God she was nervous.

“Are you okay Rarity?” Sassy Saddles asked, “You seem a little tense.”

“Yes, I'm fine,” Rarity lied, trying her best to not tremble. Sassy Saddles seemed to accept it though as she went to pour herself a drink.

“I'm surprised though,” Sassy Saddles said.

“Surprised? By what?” Rarity asked.

“Seeing you here. I had thought you'd want to stay as far away from this party as possible.”

That was an odd thing to say. Why would she want to stay away from this party in particular?

“Um, I don't follow,” Rarity said.

“It's just that, after what you told me about the Gala, seeing you here of all places is a little odd,” Sassy Saddles continued.

Rarity was getting so confused right now. Just who was the birthday boy? She wanted to ask Sassy Saddles about it, but one look at the clock told her that she didn't have the time.

“Oh, would you look at the time,” Rarity said, “I wanted to take a look around the mansion before I left, and its getting awfully late.”

“Would you like some company?” Sassy Saddles asked.

“That's alright,” Rarity said, “Actually, I'm feeling a little claustrophobic here, so some time alone might do me some good. Um, give me a call later this week, okay?”

Sassy Saddles nodded, “I'll see you later Rarity.”

Rarity nodded and began making her way to the hall. A few other people tried to approach her, but she just waved them off continuing her journey. There was still this small part of her that was screaming for her to stop, but at this point she was determined to ignore it. She needed this, and she wasn't about to let her fears stop her.

But she was still afraid that this man was going to keep her.

The hallway was really nice. There were a lot of fancy vases and sculptures around. Whoever the birthday boy was they had a true love for art. Rarity was impressed. Now she really wondered who it was.

Especially with what Sassy Saddles had said to her. Sure, she didn't want to go to the party, but that was because the last two parties she attended were disasters. From Blueblood treating her like a servant to ending up stark naked in the middle of everyone thanks to Discord, she never left these parties with good memories. That was the reason why she didn't want to come here.

Just who was the man of her dreams?

“Can I help you?”

Rarity actually jumped when Noble Heart's voice was heard behind her. That was the intention of the scene, but he seriously startled her. Not wanting to break character, Rarity turned around to face him as he walked down the steps toward her.

“Oh, I'm sorry!” Rarity said nervously, “I was just looking around is all.”

“You do know that this section of the mansion is off limits, right?” Noble Heart said with a slight frown. Holy hell, he looked serious.

It's a scene. Remember that. He's just pretending.

“I didn't mean to trespass,” Rarity said baking up against the wall as he closed in, “I was just curious. T-that's all.”

“How do I know you didn't steal anything?” Noble Heart asked, now standing right in front of Rarity, “You say that you just wanted to look around, but it's awfully convenient that you're alone here. A masquerade party is the perfect time to steal something.”

“S-sir… I'm so sorry,” Rarity said, now trembling, “If you'd just let me go back to the party, I swear I won't go into places I'm not supposed to again.”

This is it… he's about to do it…

There's no going back now…

“Sorry, but I can't just let you off the hook,” Noble Heart said touching the side of her dress, “I need to know for certain that you're not hiding anything.”

He gripped the side of her dress tightly, and in one swift motion ripped it off her. She tensed up as she now stood there in front of Noble Heart, not only completely naked, but the only piece of clothing she had with her now useless.

She froze under his gaze, feeling flush as admired her curvy figure, his eyes lingering on her supple breasts, and again on her vulva. She quickly caught herself and held an arm over her breasts and another one over her womanhood, trembling as the realization hit her that she was helplessly naked in front of this man now. This man that she didn't know, but had seen in her dreams a number of times.

This is really it, isn't it...?

This is how he captures me...

“Well, it certainly doesn't look like you're hiding anything,” Noble Heart said smirking, “In fact, you were hiding even less than I thought.”

“T-this is an outrage!” Rarity fussed, “This, sir, is sexual harassment, and I will not stand for that!”

“Hm… now we have a problem,” Noble Heart said getting even closer to Rarity putting his hands on the wall next to her trapping her, “I can't afford to have you telling anyone like the princess about what happened back here.”

“W-well… apart from tying me up somewhere I don't see how you're going to stop me...” Rarity said, her breathing picking up as Noble Heart took her hands and pinned them against the wall.

“That… is exactly what I had in mind,” Noble Heart said. Immediately he claimed her mouth with his own in a passionate kiss, forcing her mouth open and forcing his tongue in to wrap it around hers. Even though she was supposed to be fighting the kiss in the scene, she couldn't help herself. Noble Heart was an excellent kisser.

Get a hold of yourself, Rarity! You can't give yourself to him so easily!

Before she could turn away, Noble Heart broke the kiss and looked into her eyes. All of a sudden, everything stopped between them. She didn't care that he was naked in a mansion while a party was going on just a bit away. She didn't care that this was the man from her dreams that captured her. She didn't care that she had no idea who he even was behind the mask.

She wanted him, and somehow she had a feeling that he wanted her just as much.

He caught himself before she did and smirked, “Well now, seems you liked that quite a bit.”

Rarity felt her face turn red as she averted her eyes. Immediately Noble Heart turned her around to face the wall, and held her wrists behind her back. Rarity felt Noble Heart bind her wrist behind her with a rope.

No turning back now…

I belong to him…

“A beautiful woman all my own,” Noble Heart whispered into her ear as she trembled, fighting back the tears, “This makes this a happy birthday.”

He placed something cold on her horn, locking it in place. She instantly felt her connection to her magic be lost. All she could do now was trust him. This would either be the best night of her life, or the beginning of her life as a sex slave.

Taking the remains of her dress, Noble Heart grabbed Rarity's arm and dragged her up the stairs. As per the scene, she struggled and screamed, but just as Noble Heart had told her, no one even noticed that she was being taken.

She just hoped that these screams for help didn't eventually turn into serious cries for help.

Rarity was thrown onto the bed of her captor. His room wasn't the same as the room in her dreams, but that didn't mean anything. As far as she knew, Noble Heart (or whatever his name really was) would just move her to another location after this. It wouldn't make sense for him to keep her naked and tied up in his own home.

“First, let's remove this,” Noble Heart said, moving his hands to her mask. This was the last thing she had protecting her. The idea of him seeing her face along with her naked body, her unable to cover her modesty, it was far too much for her.

He didn't rip off her mask. Instead, he carefully and slowly removed it. Once it was off, Noble Heart just took her in. He almost seemed mesmerized, like he was looking at an angel. Despite herself, Rarity hadn't felt this beautiful in all her life.

“You're even more beautiful than I thought,” he said softly to himself, “Rarity, Element of Generosity, and one Princess Twilight's knights of the Council of Friendship.”

“T-that's right,” Rarity stuttered, trembling either from fear or anticipation. Noble Heart got up, but quickly pulled out more rope setting it on the bed. Holding Rarity's arms, he quickly undid the ropes on her wrists. Rarity fought her captor, trying to resist, but he was much to strong for her. He held her wrists to the bed, and claimed her mouth with his own. The kiss was forceful, meant as a symbol of ownership rather than a symbol of love.

Yet she loved it.

Still, she couldn't just let this happen. Both because of the scene and the possibility that this was in fact real. She did everything in her power to resist, but Noble Heart was too strong for her. Thus he had no problem holding her wrists to the top of the bed. His lips and tongue never ceased their action of dominance as he retied her wrists, now to the top of the bed. It was only once they were tightly bound that he broke the kiss and looked into her eyes.

“You belong to me now, Rarity,” he said, softly yet with so much strength and assurance. It was so much that she found her eyes watering. She moved her wrists a bit, feeling no slack in her bindings. She couldn't move. If this was real, it was too late. She was his prisoner now.

As Noble Heart moved to her ankles, Rarity's fear hit a head. She thought about using the safe word. That was all she needed to do, right? Just say the word “red” and this would end. She could stop this at anytime.

But she wouldn't say red, now would she? No, she wouldn't, because she wanted this. She had asked for this very moment, to be stripped of her freedom and reduced to a helpless damsel. She wanted to feel utterly out of control, and put to this man's mercy.

“SOMEBODY HELP!” Rarity screamed, “PLEASE, HELP ME!”

Noble Heart laughed grabbing her ankle, “No one can hear you,” Noble Heart said, “I charmed this room when we entered it. It's now completely sound proof. You can scream all you want.”

Was that true? Had this room been charmed? She didn't know, but with her magic inhibited she couldn't check. If that was true though, then she was truly at his mercy.

Say it! Say “red”! Do that and it will be over!

But this was what she had asked for. Even now as Noble Heart finished tying her left ankle to the bed she could feel her heart race in anticipation, and her pussy get warmer in response. This was the most arousing experience Rarity had ever had.

Noble Heart finished tying her right ankle to the bed, and stood up taking in her fully exposed and helpless frame.

“You are absolutely stunning,” Noble Heart said, “The kind of woman most men dream of having in their beds.”

She pulled honestly at her bindings. Once she was reminded of how helpless she was, she turned away from Noble Heart and let her tears flow freely. Noble Heart turned her face back to his and looked her deep in the eyes.

“Never look away from me,” Noble Heart said, “I want you to look at me at all times, is that understood?”

“Y-y-yes...” Rarity said, still crying yet not taking her eyes off of him. She didn't know why she was crying. Was it because she was afraid she'd never see her friends again? That she'd never see her little sister, or her parents again? That her freedom was forever stripped away by this man who's desire for her was so powerful she could feel it?

Or was she crying because she was overjoyed to be desired so badly.

For the longest few seconds he just took her in, his eyes lingering on her triple D breasts first.

“Magi women are some of my favorite,” Noble Heart said waling closer to Rarity, “They have the most voluptuous bodies besides angels,” he cupped one of her breasts harshly, “Your figure truly exemplifies what makes magi truly stunning.”

He began kneading her breast. Against her better judgment she found her breathing pick up, and soon a soft moan escaped her. She knew she messed up when he stopped and smirked at her.

“Oh hoh, are you enjoying this?” Noble Heart asked, “Rarity, known as the mightiest Element of them all, getting aroused?”

He then leaned in taking her nipple into his mouth, sucking it. Rarity tried her damn best to keep from vocalizing her arousal any further, but his mouth on her breast, his tongue licking her now erect nipple, she couldn't stop it. Another moan escaped her, this one louder than the last. When Noble Heart bit her nipple, she almost went over the edge. The sudden pain caused her to cry out both in pain and pleasure.

But it was the pleasure that Noble Heart took notice of.

“You're enjoying this just as much as I am, aren't you?” Noble Heart asked, his voice sounding strained, “You put on the front of a pure, noble woman, but deep down you're nothing but a filthy slut, aren't you?”

He got on top of her, and undid his pants setting his fully erect penis free. It was large, just like in her dreams. She had seen it enough times to recognize it from sight. The fact that his pants were merely open while she was completely naked further emphasized who was in control right now.

Oh… it's just like the dream…

This is real… oh God it's real…

He is the man from my dreams… and I was so foolish to not heed their warnings…

She couldn't stop the flood of tears as she looked at his large member. He moved it close to her face, its scent causing Rarity's mind to fade even as the tears flowed. On instinct she licked her lips, and action also not missed by Noble Heart.

“Would you like a taste, Element of Generosity?” Noble Heart asked. Instead of waiting for a response, he pushed his cock toward her mouth. She had no choice but to open her mouth, upon which Noble Heart shoved his penis in. Rarity was surprised by the sudden action, but neither of them moved immediately. Instead, Noble Heart grabbed Rarity by the horn.

“Bite it, and I snap this off,” he said seriously. He then began thrusting in and out, slowly fucking her mouth. Rarity, for her part, sucked and ran her tongue all along his penis. The taste was salty, yet sweet and appealing. As he used her mouth, Noble Heart moaned in pleasure, and Rarity noticed that he was getting harder. At the same time, his thrusts became faster and more erratic. Rarity had to breathe out of her nose, but that didn't stop her from feeling like she was going to suffocate. As the thrusts got deeper, she gagged slightly, which seemed to only spur her captor on even more.

He doesn't even care... He's just content using me as a fuck toy...

I shouldn't be enjoying this so much, but I'm so aroused right now I could come just from this alone...

She had given oral before, but never like this. Noble Heart was so big, he filled her mouth completely. Even with how fast he was thrusting, she still managed to lick his cock, which was so close to hitting the back of her throat. He was unforgiving, and she felt so used right now. Used, yet so aroused. She was getting closer to climax by the second.

“I'm… going to cum...” Noble Heart groaned, “Make sure you swallow every bit.”

He came only a few seconds later. Rarity had to swallow a constant stream of his cum, which to her surprise and shame wasn't unappealing at all. In fact, his cum tasted pretty good.

God… I really am a slut…

Noble Heart removed his penis from her mouth, and caressed her face as she swallowed the last bit, “You were getting into it, weren't you, my little slut?”

She couldn't answer him. She did enjoy it, but telling him that would be-

Noble Heart stuck his finger right into her pussy, causing her to cry out. He rubbed her inner wall, which made her even wetter than she already was. Shit, his hand was right there.

“You can't lie to me,” Noble Heart said into her ear, “You're enjoying this way too much. I can smell you arousal, Rarity. I can feel it dripping on my hand. Your body craves more, doesn't it?” he dug his hand deeper, making her cry out, “Doesn't it? Answer me, Rarity.”

“Y-yes...” Rarity sobbed. She couldn't deny it, this was the most aroused she had been her entire life. His cock hardened again almost immediately from her response.

“You want me inside you, don't you?” Noble Heart asked, now taking his hand out and rubbing his once again erect penis against her pussy, “Beg me. Tell me that you want my cock inside your pussy.”

“P-please...” Rarity pleaded, “I want you're cock… inside me…”

“Tell me that you want me to break you, to fuck you,” Noble Heart continued. Rarity took a deep breath, working up the courage to say these things.

“Fuck me… break… me...” Rarity continued, “Please…”

Noble Heart pushed into her pussy. She hadn't felt so full, so complete, in her entire life. She began to wonder if she could even take it all in.

Noble Heart began thrusting hard. This wasn't tender, nor was it loving. He was fucking her, and there was nothing she could do to stop it. Even if she used the safe word, she knew he wouldn't stop. She belonged to him now.

“You're nothing but a filthy slut, aren't you?” Noble Heart asked as he pounded into her, “Admit it! Say it!”

“Yes!” Rarity cried, “I'm a slut! A filthy slut!”

“This was the whole reason you came to my birthday party, isn't it? To get pounded, fucked, used by the birthday boy, right?”

“Yes…! Yes! YES!”

He continued pounding into her pussy, now even more forceful than before. Rarity came immediately, yet he didn't stop. He just kept going, driving her to the edge once again.

“Master…! MASTER!” Rarity screamed on instinct. Hearing her call him that must have brought him to the edge, because moments later he came hard inside of her. Rarity came a second time along with him, and she looked into his eyes. Something powerful formed between them at that moment. Rarity could see it in his eyes. He truly, honestly wanted her. Rarity forgot that she was his prisoner, and that he was her captor, as her desire for him matched his.

She was falling for him. Falling for the man that took away her freedom.

After they finished riding out their orgasms, Noble Heart fell down on top of her exhausted. Rarity closed her eyes and bit her lip, not moving or saying anything. He'd probably rest for a bit, and then start licking her neck getting her ready for-

“Give me a second… and I'll have you untied...”

What? He was going to untie her? He was setting her free? Right, this was supposed to be a scene. This means, she was actually safe the entire time?

Noble Heart slowly removed the bindings on her wrists, and then took off the inhibitor ring on her horn. He then smiled warmly, “How was that?” he asked, “Feeling better?”

“Quite,” Rarity said, still in a state of shock. This was clearly the man her dreams were warning her about, but he was releasing her. He wasn't trying to take away her freedom, at least not indefinitely.

Noble Heart kissed her cheek and got to work untying her ankles. Rarity looked at him the entire time, trying to understand him. He seemed completely different than before. Once again he was the sweet young man she met back in the party. After undoing her bindings he lay on the bed next to her and wrapped his arms around her comfortingly.

“What are you-”

“After care,” Noble Heart said, “After an intense scene like that, it's the dom's job to make sure their sub is okay. I was worried because I saw you were crying through the scene.”

“Oh…” Rarity blushed, “I'm sorry… It was so intense, that I sort of got… lost in the scene.”

“The only reason I didn't stop was because you didn't say the safe word,” Noble Heart said, “I hope I didn't go to far.”

“Not at all,” Rarity said snuggling into his embrace, “It was exactly what I was hoping for.”

Noble Heart breathed out in relief, “Good. The last thing I wanted to do was hurt you.”

“Noble Heart…” Rarity said softly, “Thank you for taking care of me. I only wish I could have done something for you, as it's your birthday.”

“Rarity, this is everything I wanted,” Noble Heart looked into Rarity eyes and caressed her face lovingly, “Just a chance to be with you like this made this day worth while.”

Rarity didn't know why she did it, but she closed the distance between them and kissed him tenderly on the lips. Noble Heart wrapped his arms around her pulling her in closer, deepening the kiss. It was as if he had wanted to do this for a long time. They stayed like that for a few seconds to a minute, savoring the closeness that both of them seemed to crave.

After breaking the kiss, Noble Heart looked away concerned.

“What's wrong, sweetie?” Rarity asked.

“It's just… your lovely dress,” Noble Heart said, “I destroyed it. Not only was it beautiful, but now you have nothing to put on.”

Rarity giggled, “Oh is that all? I told you earlier that I'd be able to fix it. That's why I was okay with you ripping it off.” Rarity got up and took the remains of her dress. Using her now freed magic, she engulfed her dress in her aura, and in a flash it not only returned to its previous state, but it also appeared over her body, “There. All better. May I have my mask, sweetie?”

“Y-yes. Certainly,” Noble Heart said handing Rarity her mask. Rarity put it back on and looked in Noble Heart's mirror.

“Perfect. Once again completely presentable,” Rarity said, running her hand in her hair a bit.

“How did you do that?” Noble Heart asked.

“What? Fix my dress? It's a spell Twilight helped me weave together. There was an incident in the last Gala that resulted in me completely naked. To ensure that never happens again, I had Twilight help me make a spell to recover my lost clothing should the need ever arise.”

“You made a spell… just in case you end up naked in public?” Noble Heart asked, incredulous.

“You never know what could happen,” Rarity said, “I didn't expect to end up streaking in the Gala, but last month it happened. I'm not taking that chance again.”

Noble Heart shook his head smiling, and escorted Rarity back to the party. It was probably winding down now, but that was okay, she got what she wanted.

Maybe now she could stop having such intense dreams.

After the party ended, Blueblood said goodbye to his guests, taking extra time with Rarity. There was a small part of him that wanted to tell her who he really was, but that would seriously put a damper on her night. She left the party with a smile. That was enough for him.

“So, did you have a happy birthday?” Luna asked once they were alone.

“Yes I did,” Blueblood said, “Auntie, it was amazing. She was everything I was hoping she'd be and more.”

“Do you think you'll be seeing her again?” Luna asked.

“Probably not. I never took off my mask,” Blueblood admitted, “That's fine though. As long as she left my party happy, and I got to treat her like the queen she truly is, then I'll sleep well tonight.”

As Blueblood walked to his room, Luna folded her arms frowning.

“If only life were that simple,” she said cryptically.

“Look at you,” Sapphire Shores said to Rarity as they drove back to Ponyville, “Someone's all smiles.”

“Well, let's just say coming to this party wasn't a complete waste of time,” Rarity said, not ready to admit that her friend was right the whole time.

“So when you disappeared on me, you were getting laid?” Sapphire Shores asked.

Rarity sighed, “Sometimes I can't stand you.”

Sapphire Shores laughed, “Most people hate how right I am, but I can't help being so fabulous.”

Rarity shook her head and leaned into her friend, “Thanks, Sapphire.”

“Anytime Rarity,” Sapphire Shores said wrapping her arms around Rarity, who closed her eyes and relaxed. Now that she got it out of her system, hopefully she'd be done with those terrifying dreams.

Maybe tonight she could just get a good night's sleep.

Author's Note

I was surprised by how much fun I had writing this scene. Please tell me what you thought of the sex scene, as I consider THIS to be my first true sex scene.

Please, if you liked this and want to help support my writing AND my campaign for world domination, then please come here to donate to my patreon.