I'll Show You Mine, If You Show Me Yours

by Brony_Headbanger

Rating: mature
Tags: Original Character, Sex, Human, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Second Person, Romance
Length: 5120

Twilight is now eager to study you, and your species.

You've been staying with Twilight for sometime now after her and one of her friends found you, hopeless, hurt. But, after resting in her bed with her. She's eager to study you.

{Second Person} {You x Twilight}

Thanks to my awesome friend Harms Way for proofreading this story!

crunkymonkeystudios after dark's Reading Here!

Published 2015-10-01 01:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2015-10-01 01:10:01 UTC

I'll Show You Mine, If You Show Me Yours.

You’ve been sitting on Twilight’s bed since she told you that she had to go and do something with Spike. You’re just sitting there with your acoustic guitar, just trembling a few cords as you wait on her.

You decorated your acoustic with some few minor details. Like some favorite bands you know from home, and some other bands that Rainbow Dash has shown you. Since that you and her are into the same type of music.

As you’re still playing the guitar, you start to remember back when you first met Twilight. At first, when you first seen the princess of Equestria, and her alicorn sister. You were freaked out by all the talking horses in this magical land of colorful talking ponies everywhere.

You stayed in the royal palace for two weeks, just to make sure that you’re no harm to anypony in Equestria. And it seemed like a good idea to you too. But not because of that, you would think that you may be dreaming.

First, you pinched yourself. Yup, that hurt.

You also tried to fly. Nothing. Because hey, you can do whatever you want in a dream, can you? You try to think of something else to do to make sure that you’re not dreaming.

After thinking of whatever you could do, it turns out, you’re not dreaming. This is all real now. But the question is… Will you ever visit your home world again?

After those couple weeks had passed, and that you’re now use to the talking ponies. You’ve been escorted to Ponyville.

You remember on the way there, you looked at the amazing view of the land. How nice it must be.

As you got there, you had gotten a bunch of stares and weird looks from the other ponies in town.

You still remember how you first met Twilight. Celestia introduced you to her, and Twilight has been studying you ever since you first saw her face to face.

You’re now probably tired of being studied, since that you haven’t been in Equestria for a month. It’s only been three weeks since you walked into this strange magical world.

Your train of thought was interrupted by a sound of clopping hooves on the floor, coming from the hallway from outside Twilight’s bedroom.

As you looked at the door that’s been left cracked ever since Twilight left, you can see a shadow that’s coming towards the door.

A violet aura covers the door handle, and it opens on its own. Twilight walks into the room, taking a deep sigh.

“Well, that wasn't what I expected.” She said as she trotted to the bed towards you. You went back to gently strumming a few chords on the guitar.

Twilight hops onto the bed and she tucks her hooves underneath her.

“What was it that Spike wanted, Twilight?” You asked as you tuned your guitar.

“*Sigh* Well, I thought it was gonna be something important. But, it turns out to be the same thing.” She said as she laid her head down, resting her head on her hooves.

“Is it the whole trying to get with Rarity thing, again?” You asked. Twilight nods her head. “*Weak moan* Yeah, I've been down that road too when I was young. And God was it horrible.”

You can’t help but feel bad for that poor baby dragon assistant. You always keep thinking that Rarity doesn't really like him because he’s too young for her anyway.

You still remember your first crush back when your early teenage years. And it was terrible for you. You still cringe from it.

“What was it like with you?” Twilight asked as she lifted her head up.

“Well… I probably don’t wanna talk about it.” You said to her as you got done tuning your guitar, and you’re now strumming some chords on it. You went to a “C” tuning as you strum it.

“To tell you the truth, Twi. It’s actually this thing right here.” You said as you pointed your guitar.

“Really?”

“Yup.”

“How did that go?” Twilight asked curious.

“Wanna hear my story?” You asked. Well, that was a stupid question.

“Please.” Twilight said as she smiled at you.

“Alright...” You said as you begin your story. You remember your friend told you that he can get all the girls because of the guitar that he plays. You remember the girl that you had a huge crush on back in Middle School, and you couldn't let go of it.

You remember you first asked her out, and she would tell you no. You would think of different ways to try to make her say yes.

So you started off with the guitar, and when you gotten a bit better. You played a little song, but you never sung the song. And she would still tell you no.

And as you kept playing that guitar of yours, you think to yourself that it isn't just to get with girls. It’s just for fun.

As your story comes to a close, Twilight’s ears folded back, and she looked at you with those eyes of hers.

“I’m sorry that happened to you.” She said as she rubbed her hoof on the bed sheets.

“Yeah, but I’m not really worried about that anymore. I mean, hey, it’s awesome to play this thing. What was even cooler is teaching someone a little bit about it.” You said with a smile.

“Really?” Twilight asked.

“Uh-huh. I've taught one or two of my friends on how to play it. They enjoyed it, and I was happy that they did.”

“Huh. I never knew how interesting it must be to… Play the guitar.” Twilight looked at it as your fingers moved along the lower part of the fret board. As you looked at her for a short few heartbeats, an idea popped in your head.

“Wanna give it a try?” You asked.

“Huh?”

You took the guitar over you, taking it off of your shoulder and you handed it to Twilight.

“You wanna try it out, Twilight?” You repeat yourself.

“A-Are you… You can’t be serious. Right?” She said as she feels a little nervous.

“Hey come on, Twi!” You said with a smile. “Just try it out.” You slide the guitar towards her.

“Well…” Twilight said as she’s thinking about it with that smile on her face. “I… Guess I can give it a shot.”

Twilight sits up, and you sit on the edge of the bed. Twilight sits on your lap the way you sit down. You can feel her rump rub up against your pants a little. But you ignored it, as soon as you feel her up against your…

You try to ignore it as you can feel her rub up against your crotch a little. You can feel it starting to heat up a little.

‘No!’ You screamed in your head. ‘Not now! God dammit, not now! Go away boner!’

You’re hoping that she didn't noticed. Until your the heat from your crotch went away.

‘Thank you!’ You screamed in your head. You grabbed the guitar, and you placed it on Twilight’s lap.

“So… How do you do this?” She asked as she looked up at you.

“I’ll show you.” You said. You grabbed her right hoof with your right hand, and you placed it on the bridge of the guitar. You now grabbed her left hoof with your left hand, and you placed it on the first fret on the fretboard of the guitar.

You was about to ask if she needed a pick. But since that ponies don’t have fingers to hold the pick, you’ll have to take that question out.

“Ready?” You ask. Twilight nods her head in excitement. You begin to slowly and gently strum the chords as you move her hoof along the upper strings. Just how you was playing it earlier.

As you’re helping her strum the strings gently, you take her left hoof, and you move it to the second, and third fret of the guitar. You also told her the basics, what you can do, and how you move your fingers to the higher strings.

Twilight would try her best to do what you tell her to do, and your response was some weird sounds from the guitar.

“It’s hard.” She said as you’re helping her picking the strings with her hoof.

“Yeah. Once you put some effort into it, you’ll get use to it.” You said as you’re still helping her strumming the strings with her hoof. “Wanna stop, or…?”

“Yeah, I think I can stop for right now.”

“Alright.” You chuckled and you put the guitar down for now, and you both just sat on the bed, doing nothing.

“I’m bored.” You said out loud.

“Yeah, I can’t think of anything either.” Said Twilight as she lays her head down on her hooves. Her eyes staring directly at you, and you just stare right back at her.

“How ‘bout a staring contest?” You said.

“Oh please, I know you’ll win. You’ve beat me at that game like three times.” Twilight chuckled.

“Heh, yeah, I still can’t believe that you try to make me blink before you did.” You reminded her as you smirked at her.

“What? What’re you talking about?” Twilight asked as she tried to play it cool.

“Oh please,” You teased her. “Don’t tell me that you tried to cheat once at the last game.”

“I still don’t know what you’re talking about.” Twilight giggled. As you try to make her admit it, an idea popped into your head. You know what to do.

“Oh really.” You said as you began to crawl to her.

“Oh yes, and there’s no way that you can prove it.” She said as you’re now right in front of her, on your knees.

“Alright.” You said as you shrugged your shoulders. “Since that you won’t confess it. I might just have to make you.” You smirked.

“And what are you gonna do about it, huh?” Twilight said playfully as she punched you playfully.

“I’ll show you how.”

You start to raise both of your hands, and you wiggled your fingers. Twilight just looked at your digits for just a second as you grabbed her, rolled her over, and you start to tickle her.

“Hey!” Twilight giggles. “Qu-Qu-Quit it!”

“Not until you admit that you cheated at that last staring contest game!” You said as you keep tickling her. You knew that Twilight was ticklish by how you accidentally came up on her once the other day, and she told you how ticklish she is, and you tested out for yourself. Turns out, she is ticklish.

“You gonna admit it now, Twi?!?” You said as you keep tickling her. Twilight just continues to laugh even harder as you go for the wings.

“No! Not the wings!” Twilight squealed as she continues to laugh.

“How about now?” You said as you begin to stand up as you’re about to be off of the edge of the bed. Your bare feet now on the floor as you continue to tickle Twilight. Which she continues to laugh harder and louder.

“S-S-Stop it! It really tickles!” She screams as she can’t stop laughing.

“Not until you confess!” You said as you now went for her hooves, which made her squeal in surprise.

“Alright! Alright! I admit it!” Twilight yells in laughter.

You start to climb onto the bed a little with your feet, and tried to get on your knees so you can continue to torture her with your tickleness.

“I-I-I did cheat! Just, stop with the tickling!” She said as she can’t stop laughing.

As you was about to climb on the bed with your bare feet, and still tickling Twilight.

“I knew you were gonna say tha-mmph”

Your foot slipped, and…

Twilight now stopped laughing, and you stopped tickling her. You both open your eyes at the same time. Your lips are now locked with her. .”

You slowly pull away from the kiss with a soft smack as you both blush at what just happened.

“Uh… Sorry” You apologized.

“Um… It’s okay. Uh… Let’s never speak of this.”

“Deal.” You both walked out of the room, not saying a word to one another, and just walked downstairs.

***

Later that night, a storm has rolled over in Ponyville. The pegasi must of scheduled a storm for the night.

You just sit in the bed with your arms hugging your knees, and watching the storm. Trying your best not to think of what happened earlier today.

You really can’t believe it actually happened. And you don’t even want to think about it. but, you just can’t stop thinking about it. Trying to stare at this storm that’s outside doesn’t even help either.

Your train of thought was interrupted as you hear the clopping sound of hooves, and what sounds like Spike walking down the hallway with Twilight. They’re talking.

“Well, I’m going to bed. Rainbow Dash said she’ll help me out with Applejack tomorrow to work on the barn.” You hear Spike.

“Why did you join on that, Spike? “ You hear Twilight’s voice which startled you a bit. A massive chill goes up your spine as you hear her voice.

“Eh, you said you were gonna be busy with books tomorrow. So, I need something to do besides just sitting on the couch doing absolutely nothing. Or talking to that guy that’s staying with us. He’s cool ‘N all, but still.”

“Yeah, I get what you mean, Spike.” Twilight sighed. As soon as Twilight and Spike reached the doors to Twilight’s room, Twilight jumped a little and she blushed as soon as she saw you sitting on the bed facing the window as you stare at her right back.

“Well. Goodnight, Twilight.” Spike said as he went off to his room.

“Goodnight Spike.” Twilight said as she couldn't take her eyes off of you. As soon as she walks in, she shuts the door with her magic and trots to the bed to sit by you.

“So…” Twilight said as she scoffs a hoof on the bed. “What’cha doin’?”

“Watching this storm.” You said as you looked out the window again.

“I see.” Twilight said as you start to feel her side press up against you. You start to get a little nervous as she did that.

Her head leans on your shoulder and she hums as she did that, and tries to get cozy and comfortable.

“The rain’s beautiful.” Twilight whispers.

“Yeah. It kinda is.” You said as you look out the window as lightning flashed, then comes in thunder.

You start to put your arm around her. As soon as your soft skin makes contact with Twilight’s soft fur, you heard her gasp, you look down on her.

“You alright?” You ask.

“Y-Yeah.” Twilight said nervously. “Just a. Uh… Can you warn me next time?” She puts a smile on her face as her cheeks flushed.

“Um…” You feel like you’re making this even more awkward than you thought. “Sure.” Was all you can say. So you held Twilight close to you, and you held her as you lean your head against hers.

You begin to brush her fur as you both watch the rain from inside the castle. Twilight hums at your touch.

“Your hand’s so soft.” She whispers.

“And your coat is so soft.” You said right back at her. “Really soft.”

Twilight begins to scoot as close as she can to you. That you didn’t actually noticed for a small second.

“Uh… Twilight?”

“Hmm?”

“Are you comfortable?” Wow, what a stupid question.

“Yes, I am.” She whispered, and she continues to watch the rain with you. You just sat there with her, watching the rain as silence surrounds the entire room for only a minute. Until Twilight then kisses you on the cheek, making you jump a bit and your face flushed.

“I think I’m ready to call it a night. This rain’s making me sleepy. What do you think?” She whispered in your ear. Your eyes shrank as her hot breath hit your ear like a massive freight train roaring down the tracks.

You turn to her, and you noticed her eyes twinkled in the dim light in the room. You couldn’t help but stare into those eyes of hers.

“Um… Yeah, I think I’m getting tired too.” You said as you rubbed the back of your neck. You scooted back to your side of the bed where you’ve been sleeping ever since you came into Twilight’s castle.

As you was getting comfortable, Twilight climbs on top of you, and gives you a hug as if you’re her teddy bear.

“Uh… Twilight?”

“Hmm?”

“What are you-”

“Shh.” She hushed you as you think she’s probably lost in her own world. “This is too good.”

Twilight leans her head where your heart is located. She sighs as she can feel your heartbeat over your chest, and begins to hug you a bit tighter.

You decide to just let it be for a minute until she soon looks up at you with that beautiful smile of hers.

“You mind if we can cuddle like this?” Twilight asked before she covered her mouth with her hoof. “Oh, I’m sorry. That slipped out of me.”

“Uh, if that’s what you want, I’m cool with it.” You said as you played it cool.

“Really?” She said excitedly.

“Yeah. If you want too.” You chuckled. Are you making this even more awkward?

Twilight goes back to rest her head on your chest, and she gets comfortable as she hums. You put your hand to her mane, and you stroke it. Twilight sighs in your touch as you pet her.

“Your heart beat’s so beautiful.” She whispered.

Hold up. What did she say?

You train of thought was interrupted as Twilight’s now scooting herself up to you. Her face just mere inches away from yours. She closes her eyes as her head is resting on yours.

You just lay there, not moving a single muscle and just thinking ‘What the hell’s going on with her? Why is she being like this? Was it because I accidentally kissed her, or..? I don’t know. I just don’t know. I mean, do I just-’

Your train of thought was interrupted as Twilight is now locking lips with you. You could’ve swarn she did that on purpose.

Twilight lets out a weak groan as she kisses you. You grabbed hold of the bed sheets as you lay there, witnessing what’s happening right in front of you.

Your face flushes as she doesn't disconnect her lips from you. You feel her mouth open yours as she dives her tongue right inside your mouth.

You yelped at how her tongue is now connected with yours, and you grab hold of the bedsheets even tighter while Twilight slashes her tail between your thighs as she continues to kiss you.

After a few seconds of just taking it, you start to think that… it feels good. You feel your eyes shut on their own, and you wrap your arms around her, and pull her in deeper.

Twilight does the same thing with you as your tongues battle in an epic dance you never knew they were capable of.

As you begin to kiss her, you feel something from down below poke Twilight. She yelps and breaks the kiss and looks down on you.

She notices that a friend of ours is sticking out from your pants. Twilight blushes and she covers her mouth with her hoof.

“Um… Is that… Is that what I think it is?” Twilight asked nervously.

“Uh, sorry Twilight. I got, uh, kinda, um.” You try your best to explain as you come up with something to say. But your brain was dead from that kiss. That amazing kiss that she gave you.

You hear Twilight whisper. “C-Can I see it?”

“What?” You said which what she said caught your attention. You felt really nervous as to what she just asked you.

Twilight lays down on your right side, and she smiles at you. Her face just inches away from yours. Twilight repeats her question.

“Can I see it? I never got to see your… Thing.” The heat in your crotch rises even faster than you thought.

“Um, uh, well, I dunno Twi, I, uh… W-Well.” You try to explain. Twilight leans in closer to you. She puts her hoof to your mouth and she looks into your eyes. Giving you that face that a pretty girl would give you.

“Please?” She whispered as you felt her hoof rub on your member where it’s sticking out from your pants. “Just one time?”

You’re still not sure if you feel comfortable showing a pony your private area. To be for real, you never showed anypony your private parts before. But Twilight’s just begging you to show her your man part.

“*Sigh* Alright Twilight. Fine.” You said as you scooted back a little bit to give yourself some room. “Just one time. Okay?”

Twilight nods her head in agreement as she watches you unbuckle your belt and toss it on the floor behind Twilight.

You now get up and lay your back on the bed frame. You unbutton your jeans, and unzipped your pants. Whatever you’re doing is making your already hard as steal like when Twilight was asking you to take it out.

“Um… I don’t know, Twilight. Are you sure?” You ask to make sure.

“I’m sure. Please? I-I’ll tell you what. I’ll show you mine… I-If you show me… Yours.” Now your face went as red as a rose, and you feel like you're about to explode from how nervous you really are right now.

“I promise. I’ll show you mine, if you show me yours.” Twilight whispered as you can hear a shake in her voice with that pretty smile on her face. Is she nervous too?

“Well…” You began to think. Even though it may be weird to see a pony’s… parts. But, this is Twilight. The most beautiful mare in Equestria. She just gives you those beautiful eyes and she circles around her hoof on the bed sheets.

Finally. You make up your mind.

“Okay.”

You put your fingers around the waistband of your jeans, and put both of your thumbs on the waistbands of your underwear while you’re at it.

You slowly begin to pull down your front. You shifted a little bit so you can pull your own pants down to show Twilight what you have hiding underneath those things.

Finally, your manhood springs up. Standing up, proud. Twilight puts a hoof to her mouth as she soon sees it standing up.

She sits up, and takes a closer look at it. She just stares at it like it’s an insect that must be quickly squashed. She stares at the pulsing pole as she finally says something.

“So… This is what it looks like to a humans?”

“Yeah.” You whispered. “This is what it really looks like to a humans.”

Twilight stares at it for several heartbeats, and she now remembers the deal that you two made not too long ago.

“Right. Um, now I can show you mine.” She whispers.

Twilight sands up and she turns around. She bends her front body and she calls out your name to get your attention.

“You want to… Move my tail for me?” She asked as she blushes with that smile on her face.

“Y-Yeah, sure.” You said as you slowly bring your hands from your jeans that’s about pulled down. You take one of your hands around her tail and moved it to the side.

There it is. Her glistening slit, and her tight anus right in front of your face. Your member pulses as you see her private parts.

“Oh my god.” You whispered. Twilight just looks back at you as she blushes deep. As you’re staring at her sweet slit, dirty thoughts began to circle in your head.

Just thrusting into her as hard as you can. You can feel your shaft aching for the pleasure that it wants. You let out a weak moan as you moved your hips a little bit.

You let go of Twilight’s tail, and as it falls free, she now comes face to face with you. Ears folded back, that nervous smile on her face, and her blushing cheeks.

You couldn't help but move your hips a bit when you imagined fucking Twilight circled your head. God, just thrusting into that sweet rump of hers.

“Are you okay?” She asked as she sees you trying not to do what you think you want to do in front of her. You nod your head to try and get away with it and you put on a fake smile.

“It’s okay if you’re wanting to study with me.” Your thoughts stop right there, and you look at her dead in the eye. Did she say what you think she said?

“Um… I just-”

“Shh.” Twilight places a hoof to your mouth. “Forget sleeping tonight. This question was bugging me. I really wanna ask you…” Twilight said as she scoots her face closer to yours. Her lips are not even an inch away from your mouth. You can feel her hot breath hitting your lips. Twilight now whispers…

“Would you like to study with me?”

You can’t help but nod your head slowly. Twilight lets out a moan, and a grin grows on her face. She pecks you on the lips.

“Good boy.” She whispers as she lowers her head to your crotch where your shaft’s standing up. “Good boy.”

Twilight sticks her tongue out, and she starts licking your shaft from the base to the tip of your aching pole. You let out a moan, and a thick line of pre-cum is formed on the head.

She does this over, and over, and over again. Until you feel a warm wet lips around your shaft. You gasp in surprise as Twilight’s now sucking on the head. You moan out from the teasing that she’s giving you, until she lowers her head, taking it in as much as she can.

Your scream fills the entire room as Twilight soon bobs her head up and down in a slow pace. She locks eyes with you as she slowly moves her head up and down.

You put your hand on her head, and give her a scratch behind the ears. Twilight moans around your member. Sending shivers up your spine as her throat vibrated your shaft.

“T-T-Twilight…” You pant. She looks up at you with those half lidded eyes of hers. “C-Can you go faster?” You ask her. She nods her head, and she picks up the pace a little bit.

You tilted your head back and you can’t help but let out moans of pleasure. This is so amazing, how her mouth feels. This is a trillion degrees hotter than fire.

“Twilight!” You screamed her name as she continues her bobbing. “P-Put your tongue around it! Please! Put your tongue arou- AAHH!” You screamed as you feel her tongue wrap around your shaft as best as it can.

Twilight continues her blowjob for twenty more seconds until she finally spits you out. Your saliva coated dick still standing up proud. She looks at you as you’re giving her that questioned look.

Twilight nods her head, and she quickly gets in position. She turns around she bends her front for you, and she moves her tail to the side. You take off your pants and underwear, and tossed them on the floor.

“Please…” Twilight begs. “I need it. I need it bad.”

‘Oh, I need it too.’ You think to yourself as you positioned yourself. You grabbed her rump and your rub your shaft on her slit to tease her. Twilight gasps and she looks back at you.

“Please…” She begs again. “Please don’t tease me! Put it in already!”

Well, no need to argue with that. You now slide in her warm pussy. The tightness around your shaft as she clamps down on you makes you moan out from how amazing she feels.

You look into her eyes as she looks back at you, and she gives you a smile, and she nods her head.

You begin to thrust into her as hard and deep as you can. With each push you give her, Twilight lets out a scream that’s music to your ears.

“Oh god! Twilight!” You scream as you thrust her even harder. “You’re so hot!”

Twilight tries her best to speak. But she’s lost in her own world as you’re pounding her like a piston in a steam engine.

“Keep going!” Twilight pants. “D-Don’t stop!”

You weren't planning to anyways. You begin to thrust into her with all of your might, you start to feel that pressure build up inside you. You know what’s coming next.

“Oh fuck! Twilight! I can’t hold it much longer! C-Can I?” You ask her. “I wanna do it so badly!”

“Nngh… Yeah! Go ahead! Fill me up with that hot cum of yours, baby!” She screams. You begin to thrust into her so hard as you’re staring at her ass that’s jiggling in front of your face.

You and Twilight both let out a cry as you release inside her. Filling up her womb as your seed fills her up. A warm wet sensation floods around your shaft.

You both breathe heavily as you pull out of her, and you collapse on your back. Twilight crawls on top of you and wraps her hooves around you. You do the same by wrapping your arms around her, and the two of you shared a passionate kiss.

“I love you, Twilight…” You said in between pants.

“I love you too.” Twilight whispers.

You start to feel tiredness take over you as your eyes begin to shut on their own. Holding your mare in your arms as you sleep in a sweet slumber.

Author's Note

Sweet! A story that has one of my most favorite ponies that I haven't featured in a while! Yay!

"But Headbanger, what happened to Rarity?"

Rarity's still good in my book. But, Twilight was my most favorite pony about a month or so after I became a brony back in June of 2014 (Not August. June!). If you ask me who was my very first favorite, it was Rainbow Dash. So yeah.

Hope you guys enjoyed this story. Until next time, bye. Shred on that mother fuckin' guitar! :twilightsmile: