A rare moon

by Lon35hadow

Rating: mature
Tags: Dark, Alternate Universe, Anthro, Romance
Length: 8449

Nightmare returns. But not alone.

Alternate universe taking place during the series premiere.

There are a great many secrets in the world. Many remain that way, but a few, often the ones that could change a world, always come to light, sometimes willingly. This is the tale of one of those secrets coming to light, and the changes it brings.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2016-02-18 02:58:06 UTC

Prologue- A reuniting dream

It was a beautiful night over in the small town of Ponyville. Everything was silent, and not a single pony was in the streets. But, in the world of dreams, a place everypony must visit, eventually, it was an entirely different story.

No dream was linked, but, all felt the long rippling affects of another's. That is, unless that dream was shielded, something only a few could do.

Our current setting is one such dream. The scenery looked like a regal castle made out of pure, black onyx with a polished sheen to it, fashioned in the ancient castle of the royal pony sisters, only it didn't have the wear and tear as the real thing, which was to be expected in the dream realm. In the equivalent of the throne room, which contained two thrones, the one on the left being a crescent moon, the other having six, twinkling stars, both emblems being just above where the heads of those who sat in them would be, the one with the six stars having been occupied.

Said occupant had a majestic, sleeveless gown that went to the floor, colored a majestic black with silver accents. The one who wore it, a mare, had dark, almost black skin. Around her neck was a silver choker with a white gem at the place where her collar bone met her chest. Her hair went down just past her shoulders, and was colored purple with accents of white, her tail being of the same color scheme, both looking like they were cared for by the best mane and tail stylists, and her horn was of a majestic length. Her pupils spoke the most to her heritage, said parts being snake like, with the rest of the eyes having a teal like color. But, out of all of that, what stood out most were the furled wings on her back.

Tonight was a special night, as the mare rarely ever controlled her dreams, and the few times she did, she never dreamed of her true form.

The doors, two, large pieces of oak wood with the design of a crescent moon surrounded by six stars on each door, though, were the real center piece of the castle, or, at least, until the real dream version of this castle was finished.

The doors opened, and the mare on her respective throne, the one with the six stars, smiled as she saw the one who walked in. "Hello, Mother," she said, as the one who walked in, she knew, was not a dream.

The mare who walked in wore old combat armor, the armor being colored teal blue, with the robes underneath being purple. Her helmet, swept back across her neck, and was gilded to provide full range of motion, her horn protruding from just above where it stopped at the upper base of her muzzle, between her eyes, which were teal colored, the pupils being teal. Her wings were folded across her back.

"Hello, my dear Selena," Nightmare Moon said to her daughter. With that, she unfurled her wings, and flew to her daughter, giving her a hug as she landed. "How I missed you."

"I missed you, too, mother," Selena said as she returned her mother's hug. "But we are together here in the dream world now, at least."

Nightmare let her daughter go, but kept her hands on Selena's shoulders. "Yes," she said, "and soon, we will be together in the physical realm as well."

"Yes, and I am glad that our banishment is nearly over, Mother," Selena said. "We simply need to ensure my aunt can't stop us."

Nightmare chuckled. "That is why I am glad I can, at least, look somewhat into the future in the dream realm. I know she will send her student, a mare known as Twilight Sparkle, to try and stop us."

"I will deal with it, Mother," Selena said. "After all, I wouldn't mind having a second pet."

"Ah, I can only imagine my sisters face when she sees her personal and prized student obeying our command," Nightmare said. "That is, before I break her, and make Celestia the slut she is."

Selena smiled. "But first, we'll need her to say she's passing her power over to us, and make it known that the moon's composition would increase the power of the sun's light during an eclipse, and that's how we are going to bring about eternal night: an eclipse."

"That will be easier said then done, my daughter," Nightmare said. "But with the two of us reunited, we can take care of it."

"I'll just be happy for you to return," Selena said. "Everything else is simply a bonus."

"As it is for me, Selena," Nightmare said, caressing her daughter's cheek. "As it is for me." She planted a kiss on Selena's cheek as she began to fade away from the dream. "I'll see you soon."

"See you soon, Mother," Selena said as Nightmare vanished from her dream.

Back in the physical realm, a single mare awoke. She had white skin and a purple mane and tail. She wore a two piece nightie, with an eye mask over her face.

She removed the mask, and went to the kitchen. She got a glass and filled it with water, putting some ice into it. Just as she was about to go back up, she heard, "Rarity, what are you doing up?"

Rarity looked at where the vice had originated, just at the base of the stairs, and her sister, Sweetie Belle, stood there, her mane and tail a mess, with pajamas with pictures of various actors Sweetie liked.

"I'm just getting a drink, Sweetie," Rarity said with a weak smile. "Go back to bed."

"Okay," Sweetie said, and she went back upstairs to her room.

Once she was upstairs, Rarity walked over to the window, and looked up at the moon. More accurately, the "Mare in the Moon."

"Don't worry, Mother," Selena, dropping her disguise of Rarity, said. "We'll succeed this time. I promise you."

Mind breaking

The day after Selena had seen her mother for the first time in a thousand years, she sat at her table, Sweetie and her parents there as well.

One thing to note that was of interest about Selena and the Belle family was this: A thousand years ago, with Celestia not knowing of Selena, after her mother had been banished, Selena had gone to the one family she could trust, and that was the Belle family. They had been more night ponies back then, as their job required moon light to be done. They had taken her in, with Selena pretending to be the sister of the youngest until they reached a certain age and moved to another town. Usually, the one she was pretending to be a sister, genetically, didn't know at first, but was eventually told. Sweetie had no knowledge of "Rarity's" true identity, but, if all went as Selena hoped, that would change in a few days.

"So, Rarity," her "mother" asked, "has anything interesting happened since last time?" The two of them rarely visited, and, as a precaution since the agreement had first been made, the children spent most of their young years with "Rarity", so as to ensure they, at least, had the common family ideal, which is that Celestia should be taken off the throne.

"Not really, no," she replied. "The only thing of note is I had an interesting dream tonight." One thing Selena had done with each generation was to have some kind of code phrase to let them know she had spoken with her mother, and, for those two, what she had just said was that phrase.

Both of her, for lack of  better word, adoptive parents froze up slightly, not enough for Sweetie to notice, but it was enough for Selena to notice.

"Oh," her "father" said. "What was it about?"

"Oh, I don't remember much," Serena lied. "What I do remember was a castle, and two thrones, though."

"Really?" Sweetie asked.

"Yes, Sweetie, really," Selena said. Out of all of her fake siblings over the years, Selena liked Sweetie the most. Not to the point of romance, but close to it. "Now, hurry up with your food. Don't you have something to do for school over the weekend?"

"But Sis," Sweetie whined, "it isn't due until next Tuesday."

"That's good," Selena said. "The sooner you get to work on it, the better. Now, get to work on it."

"Fine," Sweetie sighed, rolling her eyes and getting out of her seat and put her plate in the sink.

Once she was gone and the three were certain she wouldn't over hear them, Sweetie's mother said, "Did you mother say anything, Highness?"

"Yes, but I will keep what she said between myself, her, and my pets. I trust you two, but I don't want to risk any of Celestia's loyal subjects overhearing us."

"Of course, highness," Sweetie's father said as he and his wife bowed their heads.

"Now, if you two will excuse me," Selena said, "I'm going out for some fun." With that, Selena left the table, as well as her house.

If there was one thing aside from making dresses, that part of her Rarity persona was true, though only exaggerated, Selena liked, it was walking. She didn't know why, but just that simple act, no matter how long the walk was, but walking helped her calm down and let her think.

Right now, she was thinking of being with her mother again, and being, for the first time in a thousand years, in her physical embrace, really feel her mother instead of just imagining and applying it, as she had done last night. A small smile came to her face from that thought. Nothing could ruin her mood.

"Well, howdy, Rarity." Except for that.

She turned and saw a booth that sold apples, and, standing behind the booth, the one mare she couldn't stand. Applejack. She really, honestly, had no idea why she didn't like her, she simply had a deep feeling of hatred towards the mare. It probably didn't help that she also reminded Selena of a mare she met about five hundred years ago that had gotten the same feeling from Selena, but had given a reason to do so. Basically, she nearly killed Selena, accidentally, yes, with a prank. She didn't even bother to apologize. That, and both that mare and Applejack were part of the Apple family.

"Hello, Applejack," she said, faking a smile. Given the fact she had to lie over the past thousand years, her acting had gotten quite good. Whether or not it could fool Applejack, she wasn't certain though. "How are you doing this fine morning?"

"Just fine, Rarity," Applejack said as she grabbed an apple from her cart and offered it to Selena. "Want an apple. Looks like ya could use one."

Selena waved a hand, saying, "No, thank you, though. I just ate."

Applejack chuckled. "Come on, Rarity," she said. "We both know y'all are gonna want one later. Migh' as well get it now."

Selena rolled her eyes. "Fine," she said, taking the apple in her hand before putting it in the purse by her side. "Thanks."

"No problem," Applejack said. "Hope you have a good day, Rarity."

"You too, Applejack," Selena said as she walked away. Once Applejack was out of earshot, she mumbled, "Honestly, can't she take a bucking hint that I don't want anything to do with her family." And, walking away from the one pony she couldn't stand, Selena made her way to the school house, where a particular teacher she thought attractive was about to become her newest, and second, toy in Ponyville.

As Selena made her way to the school house, which, given it was a Sunday, meant Cheerilee was there, as the mare was always there at the beginning of a calendar week to get the lesson plan ready.

Once she was at the door, Selena did two things. The first, obviously, was knock, in which she got a, "Coming," from Cheerilee. The second was lighting her horn and casting a spell she had first made just after the Belle family took her in, and had spent years perfecting. What this spell did, really, depended on the circumstances. Right now, it allowed Selena to look into another pony's mind and see what they desired the most, even if they themselves didn't know. In this case, Selena was specifically using it to see what unconscious sexual desires lived in Cheerilee, her not knowing of them. And boy, did she find something.

The door opened just as Selena stopped the spell, and there stood Cheerilee. She wore knee length beige skirt and a black, button-up shirt with a white undershirt. "Oh, hello, Rarity," she said. "Did you need anything?"

"Just talk," Selena partially lied. "May I come in?"

"Sure," Cheerilee said, smiling.

Selena walked in and took a seat at the desk closest to Cheerilee's desk, the student desks being the only available seating for her. "So," Cheerilee said, "what is it you wanted to talk about?"

"Oh, nothing important," Selena said. "I just thought you'd like to have somepony to talk to while you were here."

"That, I do need," Cheerilee said as she sat down at her desk. "You have no idea how boring this can get, Rarity."

"Oh, that, I know," Selena said. "So, how can it get during the actual school week?"

Cheerilee sighed. "It can get hectic," she said. "I know it's what I'm best at, but still, it's like most of them don't even know how to behave. Sweetie, at least, is one of the exceptions."

"Well, I guess that's some kind of positive, that not all of them behave like ruffians," Selena said.

Cheerilee chuckled. "Yeah, I guess so."

"So, what exactly are you planning for this week," Selena said as she lit her horn and cast a particular spell that would help her with her current goal.

"Basic science, like last week," Cheerilee replied as she suddenly began to fell hot.

"Like what, specifically?"

Before her brain could respond, Cheerilee's mouth said, "How to rut like there's no tomorrow." Once her brain had processed this, she gasped and covered her mouth, while Selena just chuckled.

"You're in heat, aren't you?" she asked, already knowing the answer.

"Apparently," Cheerilee said. "This is going to be an interesting week."

Selena smiled. This is what she wanted. "Maybe I can help?"

"Rarity, you don't-" Cheerilee said before Selena lit her horn and a similarly colored aura surrounded Cheerilee's muzzle, silencing her.

"Ah, ah," Selena said as she sat up. "I know you want this, Cheerilee," she said. "I've seen what your subconscious makes, and it wants you to get rutted like a slut, to be owned, to not have any amount of responsibility." Selena did the one thing she rarely ever did when out of her home. She removed her disguise, revealing her true form in all its regal glory. "And I always did want you as a pet." Selena released her spell on Cheerilee's muzzle, and redirected it to her arms and legs, as well as pinned her to the wall, her legs spread and arms out.

With a mix of fear and something else in her eyes, as well as her voice, Cheerilee asked,"What did you do with Rarity?"

Selena chuckled as she walked up to Cheerilee and stroked her face. "That's just it: Rarity was just a fake identity, a role, if you will. She never really existed. You should really be asking who I am."

Cheerilee gulped in fear. "W-who are you?"

"Why, I am Selena, daughter of the forgotten princess, Nightmare Moon," Selena said as she leaned in closer to Cheerilee's ear. Whe she was there, she added in a whisper, "and soon, your Mistress."

Before Cheerilee could say something else, she added, "And I know you want this, Cheerilee." Selena moved the hand on Cheerilee's cheek lower and began to fondle the school teacher's breast. "I wasn't lying when you want to be somepony's pet. I saw your mind, as well as all your fantasies.

"And I can easily help them come true."

"G-get away," Cheerilee said weakly.

"We both know you want it, Cheerilee," Selena said. "I won't hurt you," she said as she leaned in. "I do care for my pets, after all.

"Just let your fears go," Selena said as she lit her horn. "Let somepony else be in control for once." She leaned in further, noting Cheerilee's glazed over eyes and rapid breathing.

"Love the night. Let true, unfettered passion take you over, Cheerilee, and let me be your Mistress." Selena moved her hand up to the area the teacher's buttoned up shirt met her collarbone, just under the hem of the undershirt and gripped one half with that hand, and gripped the other in her other hand, then yanked, the buttons popping off. "Now, what is it you want?" she asked as she pulled the hem of Cheerilee's shirt up until her bra, and the sizable bust it contained, were revealed.

"To- to pleasure and obey you, Mistress," Cheerilee said.

Selena smiled. "I had hoped you'd say that, darling." She leaned in and gave her newest pet a small kiss on her nose.

"Thank you, Mistress," Cheerilee said. "What do you require of me?"

"Just for you to relax," Selena said as she grabbed Cheerilee's left breast and pulled it out of her bra. "Relax, and let me have some fun."

"Yes, Mistress," Cheerilee said, moaning as she felt her new Mistress's hand on her.

Feelings

Selena, disguised as Rarity, stepped out of the school house, leaving a panting, and smiling like an idiot, Cheerilee on the floor. She made sure she would be alright, repairing her clothes and putting them back on Cheerilee when they were done with their, ahem, activities.

One thing she had added, though, was a mark only she could see on the upper part of the hand. The symbol was designed, actually, to reveal itself to all once Nightmare returned. It was designed to look like the symbol ponies used on nightmare night, and was colored a bright silver to represent moon light, or black on ponies with white skin, or something similar.

Selena sighed. I really need somepony just to talk to, she thought to herself. Fortunately, she knew two ponies who would listen.

She began to walk to Ponyville, walking by ponies in her Rarity guise who gave her waves in greeting, which she returned. If there was one thing good she could say about ponies in general, it's that they trusted their own easily. After a short walk, she made it to her destination. She knocked on the door.

"Coming," a male voice said from the other side before the door opened a few seconds later. Standing at the door was a green pegasus stallion with brown hair that had red accents. he had on a sleeveless, white shirt with knee length, brown cargo pants.

"Hello, Red," Selena said. Red, as well as his room mate, the other pony she wanted to talk to, were unique among other ponies she had met. Upon meeting the two of them shortly after they moved here from Canterlot, she had tried to make them her servants, but, as it turns out, both of them were in a part of the guard they refused to tell about, but had given them impressive mental capabilities, including being able to resist an alicorn grade spell. A first after that, she had avoided them at all costs, but when she had run during the last winter wrap up, as the three of them had been stuck on the same group, she had been forced to tell them why she did that. Needless to say, they were both pissed, understandably so, but, to Selena's surprise, told her they'd help her with bringing Nightmare back. When she asked them why, Lone, Red's room mate had responded.

"That group of the guard we were in?" he asked. "Can't tell you much, really, but I can say we were a secret division that Celestia doesn't know about, and we knew of that part of history. So, our ancestors went underground, and have been recruiting to give Nightmare, and her daughter, as some of our ancestors, mine included, were a part of your personal guard, an army before her return, and we'd consider it our duty to help you."

He had quickly added that he, on his part, at least, did not mean giving her dick when she wanted it. If she was in heat and he was the only one nearby, sure, but not at a whim.

"Oh, hey, Rarity," Red said. "What do you need?"

"I just want to talk. May I come in?" Over the last three months, the three of them had become close enough friends that Selena had insisted they not call her any special title.

"Yeah," Red said. "Lone's getting supper ready."

Selena smiled. She always did like Lone's cooking. "Then it looks like I'm staying for a while." With that, she walked into the house, a simple two story house with two bedrooms, a guest room, and one bathroom per floor. As she did so, she dropped her disguise.

She made her way to the kitchen, where she saw Lone, a unicorn stallion with black skin, as well as hair and tail with red and orange accents that gave his hair and tail the appearance of being on fire who wore a green, short sleeved shirt with a pair of jeans, at the stove, with a large pot of boiling water on it. "Hello, Lone."

"Hey, Selena," he said, not taking his attention off the food he was preparing. "How are you doing?"

"Oh, I'm fine Lone. What about you?" she asked as she sat down on the couch in the living room, which was right next to the kitchen.

"Just fine," he replied. "Hope you like spaghetti, as that's what I'm fixing. Assuming you're staying for supper, that is?" One of the few things she liked about Lone was that he fixed supper early. Something about letting the food stew in it's own juices, which, she had to admit, did increase the flavor slightly.

"I am," Selena said just as Red sat down on the seat opposite her. "So, what have you two been up to?"

Red shrugged. "Not that much, really."

"Yeah, we've really just been waiting for the preparations for you know what," Lone said. "You know, so we can be backstage and set a trap for you know who."

"Well, let's hope the two of you are with me on decorating the town hall," Selena said.

"Yeah, us too," Red said. "Oh, I just remembered," he said, jumping up off the seat. "I got to see Rainbow, guys. I'll be back tomorrow."

"See ya," Lone said. Once he had left, he added, "Probably going to buck her brains out like every week since you brought her in to the fold."

Selena chuckled. "Probably," she said. "I'm a little surprised you aren't curious where I was before I came over."

Lone shrugged from his location in the kitchen. "In all honesty, Selena, it's not really my business. Whatever it is, if you wanted to say, you probably would have said so."

"I guess," Selena said.

A few minutes of silence passed between the two of them, the only noise being that of the boiling water, before Lone said, "Selena, I've been wondering something."

"What's that, Lone?"

"Why is it you tried to, for lack of a better term, enslave Red and I when we met a few months ago?"

Selena blushed, both in embarrassment, and from a feeling she hadn't had in a while. "Do you really want to know?"

"It's something I've been curious about for a while," he said. "So, why?"

"Well," she said, as she got up and began walking to the kitchen, "Red was actually collateral. I actually wanted you."

Lone turned around, letting Selena see his face. He had normal looks, for the most part. The only actual thing of note was a small scar over his right eye, which was colored teal. "Why," he asked.

She blushed a little more as she said, "Because, well, those I try to bring into my service. . . gah, this is harder then I thought."

"Why's that," Lone asked.

"Because you and Red are the only ones to be able to resist my control. Those I do control, well, are ones I find," she said before her voice lowered to a barely audible, "attractive, and I'm afraid of them rejecting me."

Though what she said was a whisper, his proximity to her allowed Lone to hear. He smiled, and took Selena's hand in his own, getting a look of surprise from her. "Selena, you didn't need to do that with me," he said. "Even when I saw you as Rarity, I thought you were the most beautiful mare I had ever seen, and seeing the real you didn't hurt at all."

"Really?" she asked.

"Yeah," Lone said. "You're smart, beautiful, and you're a great mare. If I had seen you in the market, or someplace else, and I knew you were single, I would try to get your attention. I was just a littler nervous. You are a princess, after all."

Selena smiled, and lifted one of her hands to Lone's cheek. "Thank you, Lone. I assume that''s why you only, well, did me when I was in heat?"

"Yeah," he said. "Unless it was needed, I didn't want to have sex with a mare I'm not in a relationship with. I just didn't think it'd be right."

"Well, thank you for that, Lone," Selena said. She then did something Lone didn't expect. She leaned forward and kissed him, sliding her tongue in his mouth and putting her remaining arm on his back, the one on his face remaining there.

His eyes widened at first, but, eventually, they closed as he embraced Selena and the two began to wrestle with their tongues.

Eventually, the two pulled back and opened their eyes, and looked at each other, smiles of happiness son their faces as they looked at the other. "So, I guess this counts as our first date," Lone said.

"Yes, I imagine it does," Selena said with a small chuckle. "And I wouldn't want it any other way, Lone."

Matters of the heart

It's been a few hours since Lone and Selena revealed their feelings for one another, and they were sitting in the living room. The spaghetti was nearly ready. Red was still at Rainbow's house, and it didn't take a genius to guess what was happening there. Right now, though, the new couple were simply enjoying their time together.

"So, Selena," Lone said, "once your mother's back, what do you want to do?"

"So long as we do it together," Selena said, leaning into Lone's shoulder, "I don't care what we do."

"Same here, Selena," Lone said as he planted a small kiss on Selena's muzzle. "And I can not wait to meet your mother in person."

"I'm sure she'll want to meet you too, Lone." Just as Selena said this, there was a knock on the door.

"Huh. Wonder who it is," Lone said. "Best to disguise yourself, Selena. Just to be safe."

Selena nodded as she turned into Rarity. "Right," she said as another round of knocking came.

"Coming," Lone said as he got up and made his way to the door. Just as a third round came, he made it to the door and said, "I'm coming, damn it. Just hold on for-" he stopped as he opened the door and, to his surprise, Princess Celestia stood there. "Princess Celestia," he said, bowing. "I didn't expect you to come here. And I'm sorry for what I just said."

Celestia, in a flowing, sleeveless white dress, stood at the head of the doorway with a small smile as she said, "No need to apologize, Lone. You are one of my former body guards, after all. But I did come for a reason. May I come in?"

"Yeah," Lone said, standing aside. This, he could tell, was going to get interesting. Shame he had no precautions should this turn into a magical world war. "Rarity, we have a guest!" he yelled. With that, he followed Celestia into the living room. Once he entered, he saw Selena, still disguised, tense up, but Lone brought his hand up, then slowly lowered it. Stay cool. "Princess, this is my marefriend, Rarity," he said, sitting down next to her. Well, not close, as in hip to hip, but on the same couch.

"Hello, Princess," Selena said, having to force it out in a respectful tone. "What brings you here?"

"Personal matters," Celestia said as she sat down in a chair close to the couch. "More specifically, matters of the heart."

"What do you mean, Princess?" Lone asked, genuinely curious as to this.

"Well, I was hoping for your advice on this Lone. If Rarity wouldn't mind, I'd also like her help."

"Well, I'm willing to help," Lone said. "What about you, sweetie?"

"One, that's my sisters name, Lone," Selena said, getting a small chuckle out the others. "Two, I'd be happy to help," she said, though it was obvious she didn't.

"So, what do you need help with," Lone asked.

Celestia sighed. "Well, I have feelings for a stallion, but I haven't seen him for sometime. I am planning on seeing him soon, but it will only be for a small time. What I want to know is: how do I tell him I have feelings for him, and have him give me a chance?"

"Well, what's he like?" Lone asked.

Celestia smiled a little. "He's charming, smart, charismatic, and loyal. A little blind to others sometimes, but I think that makes him a little more, I don't know, perfect."

Selena thought for a few seconds before saying, "Well, I would simply ask him out."

"And if he is already in a relationship?"

"A:, he'll at least give you a chance, or B: he will say no, which means he isn't for you," Lone said.

"Then, in that case," Celestia said before lokking at the two, or, more specifically, Lone, "Would you like to go on a date with me, Lone?" she asked, nervousness in her voice.

Multiple things happened here. One was Lone face palming, wondering why he didn't see this coming, as how Celestia had described her crush was exactly how others, both in the Lunar Knights and not, described him. The second thing was Selena getting up, grabbing Celestia by the throat, and pinning her to the wall, snarling.

"Shit," Lone said, getting up and trying to make hos way to Selena, but she put a a magical shield that stopped him from getting to the two of them. He pounded on the shield, yelling, against his better judgement, but, hey, they were probably screwed over right now anyway, "Selena, stop it!"

Celestia's eyes widened. "S-Selena?" she asked, getting a small grin from her blood niece as she dropped the disguise.

"Hello, auntie," she said. "Surprised?"

"Selena, let her go!" Lone yelled. "You know as well as I do that we have precautions for this, and killing her isn't one of them!"

"I make the rules, Lone," Selena said just as she heard sobbing, and looked at Celestia, who had tears running down her face. "What, upset you hadn't banished me with my mother? Your sister?" she asked, leaning closer, only, to her shock, for Celestia to put her arms around her.

"No," Celestia said, sobbing. "I was looking for you all those years ago, wanting to apologize for what I did to your mother, and hope you'd, at least, forgive me. You and her were the only family I had left, and i didn't want to lose one of you, let alone both of you. I thought I'd never find you, Selena." The sobbing died down a little, but not by much. "I know you don't believe me, but I swear I simply wanted to see you all those years, and would do anything to show you that I'm telling the truth."

"I. . . think I have an idea as to that." Both mares, Selena with a lowered snarl on her face, but hatred still there, turned to face Lone.

"And what might that be, Lone?" Selena said.

"Simple," Lone said, shrugging. "Make her a Lunar Knight."

New adherent

"Are you certain you wish to do this, Lone" Selena asked Lone. It had been a few minutes since Lone had proposed the idea of them initiating Celestia into the Knights. At Lone's insistance, Celestia had gone into his room while he and Selena discussed it.

"Yes, I am," Lone said. "It's a win for everypony. She gets to see her sister, hopefully without blood being spilled, you actually to have a conversation with her like before your mom was banished, which you've said you wanted for some time, she gets a chance with a relationship, and the Knights don't need to worry about imprisoning her."

"I hate it when you're right," Selena said, crossing her arms.

"You're cute when you're mad, you know that, right," Lone said before planing a small kiss on Selena's lips, making her giggle.

"At least be careful. The spell that'll put the mark on her hand is a tad unpredictable." Ah, yes, the spell that marks a pony as a member of, or at least affiliated with, the Knights had a few unpredictable side effects on those it is used on. The only reason why that didn't happen with Selena is because she used her own version of the spell. In fact, the main branch of the Knights, stationed in Canterlot, right under Celestia's nose, even had a book detailing what side effects have been seen, like side effect number sixty-three, which temporarily caused the affected to swap gender, and number ten, which, fortunately, was a rare one, as it made ponies want to go on a killing spree.

"Don't worry," Lone said. "I do know shielding spells, after all. I'll call you when the spell's done." With that, Lone made his way to his room, where Celestia sat waiting on the bed. "She's okay with it," Lone said as he closed the door behind him. "Sure about this?"

"Yes," Celestia said. "I'd do anything to be on my family's good side again."

"Then let me warn you, there a total of seventy possible side effects of the spell," Lone said.

"Just, please, do it, Lone," Celestia said, looking at Lone with pleading eyes.

"Just letting you know so you don't blame yourself for anything that might happen," Lone said before his horn lit up with a lime green color. "But it will definitely sting," he said as tendrils of magic began to swirl at Celestia's hooves before making their way up her legs and down her right arm, before settling on her hand, which she stared at with some slight apprehension, mixed with sadness and maybe longing.

She mouthed to Lone, "Thank you," as the mark appeared on her hand, and she winced a bit.

"It's done, Selena," Lone called out. "You okay," Lone asked Celestia, kneeling down beside her.

"Just a little light headed," she said as the mark, a vibrant black, began to fade, as they all did until the bearer wishes otherwise.

"Okay, so that narrows it down to side effects thirteen, twenty four, and sixty," Lone said. "None of which involve anything violent, by the way.," he said as Selena came in.

"Which ones?" she asked.

"Thirteen, twenty four, or sixty are the ones she going to have, assuming it isn't a new one," Lone said as he began to smell something. "Make that thirteen or sixty," he said, turning to face the solar alicorn. "Anything else?"

"I don't know, maybe," she said, putting a hand to her head.

"Right," he said. "Let us know if anything else happens. We'll be in the living room." With that, he got up, and both he and Selena made their way to the door. They closed it once they left the room, and made their way to the living room, where they sat on the couch.

"Lone, refresh my memory," Selena said. "What side effects are those?"

"Well, thirteen is mostly mare based, and makes them have orgasms for an hour straight, while sixty is basically heat brought on early, or a second time," Lone said, which made Selena grin.

"Oh, well, I do hope it's sixty," she said. "I always did wish to see Celestia taking a dick."

"And somehow I think you got side effect two," Lone said, "which would be the effected becoming extremely perverted in the non-child harming way." He chuckled. "Or that may just be you."

"You must keep in mind, Lone, there are so few alicorns, and because of that, incest is partly expected," Selena said, putting a hand on Lone's concealed package. "And have you not seen her rack? I'm a little jealous of her."

"Touche," Lone said, kissing Selena as he put a hand on her left boob, making her moan in pleasure. He pulled out of the kiss, saying, "But these are my first, so call me biased when I say these are better." He moved a hand to the shoulder strap of Selena's dress. "In fact, I think they need to breathe a little," he said as he put both hands on the respective straps and pulled them down, then the line of the dress, revealing Selena's mounds, which were as full as Lone could imagine.

"And I think," Selena said, sliding off the couch and getting on her knees in front of Lone, "that your friend needs some air, too." She unbuttoned Lone's jeans and slid them down, along with his underwear, revealing his sizable dick. "Oh, I missed this," she said as she put a hand around Lone's tool and put a small kiss on the head. She began to stroke it as she looked in Lone's eyes, a mischievous glint in her eyes. "Want me to suck it, honey?" she asked. "Or rather play with these," she asked, fondling Lone's nuts, making him moan.

"Whatever you want to do, Selena," he said.

"Oh, fun," she said before she put her mouth on the base of the cock and began licking up the length, as well as kissing it, stroking it the entire time as she played with her tits.

"Ohh," Lone moaned "Selena, yes, faster."

Selena said nothing, not that she could, but increased the speed of her head bobbing and stroking. She took her head off the head with a wet pop after a few minutes, smiling as she looked at Lone. "Shouldn't Celestia's side effect be kicking in right now," she asked as she continued to stroke.

"Different for everypony," Lone said. He smiled. "Love you, Selena."

"Love you too, Lone," she said as she stood up and removed the rest of her dress, revealing her wet, swollen lower lips. She walked over to Lone and straddled his cock with her lips, putting her hands on Lone's shoulders. "Now, fuck me."

"Only because you asked," Lone said before he started thrusting into Selena.

"Ah, yeeeeessss," Selena nearly yelled in pleasure. "Faster Lone, faster!"

"You got it," Lone said as he picked up the pace, making Selena's tits bounce back and forth, nearly hitting Lone in the face each time.

"Ah, Lone, I had forgotten how good it is to have you in me," Selena said.

"And I forgot how tight you are," Lone said as he squeezed Selena's ass. He leaned his neck forward and kissed Selena. "I can't wait to meet your mom," he said.

"I'm sure she'll like you, Lone," Selena said. "She always did want me to be in a relationship, and as long as it's with you, I can agree. Now, keep fucking me!"

"Of course, Highness," Lone said, which made both chuckle before Selena gasped, Lone having increased his speed, making his cock ram into Selena.

"Oh YES, YES, YES! HARDER! FUCK ME LIKE A WHORE, LONE!!"

"Fast as I can go," Lone said, Selena's boobs sow just barely stopping in front of his face. Every time they came close, he would lick the nipple on one of them, making Selena moan in pleasure.

"Ahhhh, yeeeeessss," Selena said as she bounced on Lone's warm, hard cock. "Lone, I'm about to- AHHH, FUCK, YES!" she yelled as she squirted mare cum over Lone's length. Lone and Selena stopped so that Selena could catch her breath. Her cheeks red, Selena, with a smile on her face, said, "It looks like you're the first one who can make me cum, Lone. That's new."

"Thanks, babe," Lone said before his face took on a look like something had just occurred to him. "Yeah, I hate to bring this up right now, Selena, but whatever side effect is going to happen for Celestia should have kicked in, and we'd be hearing her if she was in constant orgasm."

"Might just be because I was enjoying the show," a new, familiar voice said as white hands grabbed hold of Selena's mounds. "Now, how about you get off him, and let me show you how to take head, Selena," Celestia said, her head appearing, most likely from an invisibility spell just now losing power, behind Selena's right, which was Lone's left, shoulder. "It's been too long since I had. . . release."

"Oh, Auntie," Selena cooed. "I didn't know you were this horny," she said as she dismounted Lone, her mare cum still on his rod. "Lone?"

"If you're okay with it, Selena."

"Yay," Celestia, who wore nothing but a pair of yellow panties, said in a lustful tone as she knelt in front of Lone. She licked the tool in front of her. "Ohh, Selena, you taste good with a cock holding your flavor on it," she said with a lust filled smile before she began to lick the head, causing moans to come from the stallion it was connected to. "And the cock, too," she said as she looked Lone in the face and began to rub herself through her panties. "Now, let's see how the cock tastes." With that, Celestia put the head into her mouth, and began to bob up and down, taking in more of Lone's length with each thrust of her head.

"Oh, you're a larger slut than I had thought, Auntie," Selena said as she sat down next to Lone, her legs positioned as if she were sitting on a picnic with a skirt. "I must say it's. . . not what I had expected."

"What do you mean, Selena," Lone asked before a moan escaped his mouth from Celestia's blowjob.

"It just doesn't seem as satisfying as I had thought," Selena said. "I mean, I am glad she's a part of the Knights, but," she shook her head, "I just don't know."

"Might just be because you didn't expect to be in a threesome with her," Lone said as he planted small kiss on Selena's cheek. "Or maybe it's because your afraid I'll go with her," he said with a smirk.

"Never!" Selena said. "Okay, maybe a little," she said.

"You don't need to worry, Selena," Lone said.

Celestia pulled her head up, Lone's member exiting with a wet pop. "No need to worry, Selena," she said. "I always did want to be a part of a herd." She smiled as she brought her mouth level with the base of Lone's cock. "And I did have a few fantasies about being in a threesome with you and a stallionfriend of yours, Selena." She then licked the base of the cock she held in her hand, moving up to the head slowly. "And I do have the two of you to thank for helping me get rid of my inhibitions," she said once she reached the head. "So, how is it so far?"

"Second best," Lone said. "Just under Selena here."

"But has she done this with you," Celestia asked before she straightened her back, and squeezed her tits against Lone's shaft. "Has she fucked you with her tits?"

"Yes I did, Auntie,"Selena said with a sultry grin before leaning down and, to Lone's surprise, gave Celestia full blown kiss. It surprised Celestia, given her widened eyes, before she closed her eyes and returned it. "Now," Selena said as she pulled out of the kiss, "show us how good you can titfuck."

Celestia smiled before she began to bounce her breasts up and down along Lone's shaft, making the stallion moan. "Ohh, that feels good, Celestia," he said.

"I'm glad you think so, Lone, 'cause the best is yet to come," the solar alicorn said as she increased her speed and set her mouth to take what came out towards her mouth from her cleavage as Selena kissed Lone and played with her own mounds.

Selena pulled out of the kiss, a smile on her face, and said, "I think we should move this to a more. . .comfortable room. What do you two think?"

"As long as I get to feel Lone in me," Celestia said, slowing her pace but still tit fucking Lone. "I still want a good fucking."

"If that's what you two want," Lone said. "Where to?"

"Allow me," Celestia said with a grin before she lit her horn, causing a bright flash of light for the three. When it faded, they were in Lone's bedroom.

"Now, I think it's time for more fun," Celestia said as she stood up and turned around, showing off her ass, before she bent over, removing her panties and spreading her legs, revealing her wet, glistening pussy. "Put that large cock in me, Lone. I've gone too long without one, and I need it."

"If that's what you want, Celestia," Lone, smirking, said as he got off the bed, grabbed Celestia by her cutie marks, spun her around, placed her on the bed, and thrust himself in her.

"Ahh," Celestia gasped. "Yessssss. Fuck me. Fuck meeeeee!" she nearly yelled as Lone began to grind her pussy from the inside with his rod.

"Nearly as tight as you, Selena," Lone said as he continued his thrusts.

"Oh, why thank you, Lone," Selena said. "But I think Celestia should have something to eat," she said with a sultry grin as she positioned her wet lips in front of Celestia's muzzle.

Celestia smiled before she grabbed Selena and pulled her lips closer, and began to eat her niece out. "Ahhh, yeeeessss," Selena moaned out. "Don't stop, Auntie!" she yelled, Celestia expertly licking inside Selena's folds. Celestia being thrust forward and backward by Lone's thrusts simply heightened the experience for Selena.

Lone increased his speed, causing Celestia to moan from pleasure into Selena's folds, causing her to moan in turn. He had already been close to climax when Celestia had teleported the three of them into the room, and now, he was at the edge. "Girls, I'm about to cum!"

Selena grinned, as did Celestia as she pulled away from the former, and both got off the bed and on their knees in front of Lone. "Then cum on our tits, Lone," Selena said as she grabbed Lone's cock and began to stroke, and Celestia began to play with Lone's sack. "Cum on us like the dirty mares we are."

Lone brushed aside a strand of hair that had gotten in Selena's eye as she continued to jerk him off. "Just wait until you taste the cum, Auntie," Selena said. "It will put what ever else to shame."

"I sure hope so," Celestia said with a smile.

"Ahhh. Oh my-" Lone said just as the first rope of hot, sticky cum left his cock to splash all over Selena's face. "Yes," Lone said just as the second rope left and hit Celestia in the face. Another rope left with each pant, the next two hitting Selena and Celestia in the face, and then their chest. Eventually, only a little bit was left in Lone, which Celestia fixed with a quick suck.

"Mmm, delicious," she said, licking her lips as she finished.

"I'm glad you think so," Lone said through his panting as he walked to the bed and lay down, the two mares following suite and laying their heads on one of Lone's shoulders, their hands overlapped on his chest. "Dom=n't you need to get back to Canterlot, Celestia," Lone asked.

"No, I cast a spell that would take care of that duty for a day or two automatically just before the fun began," Celestia said with a smile. "Besides, I'd probably leave it at night, right now. Nightmare would like that."

"Yes, she would," Selena said with a small smile. "Welcome to the Lunar Knights, Auntie."

"And it is an honor to be with the Knights," Celestia said, her mark appearing, as well as Lone and Selena's. Though the marks were invisible until Nightmare's return, Knights would be able to see them when a new member had been added to the ranks.

With that, the two mares and one stallion began to drift into sleep, the food forgotten, and, eventually, dreams.

Notice

I want to point out that this story is not dead. I've simply been thinking as to what I'm going to do, and decided on this: a rewrite under a new story. The story idea will stay the same, I'm just going to change some stuff so it flows better. It may be a while, but when I get to it, I'll put a link to it in an update for this story. In the mean time, my thanks to those who followed and liked this iteration of the story. The rewrite will have the same major plot point, just written and rearranged a little better, as this is not the best example of just writing a story with just the outline, which is how I write my stories. I swear, the rewrite will be out sometime in the coming months, but with school and my other stories, I can not say a definite date. Let me know what you guys think down below, and any possible ways to improve this in rewrite mode.