Hate that I Love You

by Autistic Writer

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Sunset Shimmer, Twilight Sparkle, Anthro, Main 6, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Romance
Length: 3552

Sunset Glare is recovering from a freezing lake when Twilight goes to check on him. However, Twilight is angry at Glare due to a misunderstanding. Will the two realize the misunderstanding is breaking their friendship.

Sunset Glare is recovering after he dives into the frozen lake for Twilight's toy, Smarty Pants. When she steps into the room to check on him, the two have a moment to clear the air of a misunderstanding Sunset Glare had with Twilight's sister in law, Cadence.

Will Twilight Sparkle and Sunset Glare be able to break the ice and become friends again, or will something new will change their relationship entirely.

Rated Mature for sexual themes and implications of sex.

Published 2015-10-30 22:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2015-10-30 22:30:01 UTC

Hate that I Love You

Sunset Glare stirred up as he woke up from a dream. He found himself in a strange room. The last thing he remembered was diving into a frozen lake trying to retreat Twilight’s favorite stuffed doll, Smarty Pants. He remembered he had grabbed it and pulled himself out of the water. He threw it somewhere in the snow before fading into unconsciousness. He tried to stand up, but noticed that his body was in an enormous pain.

“It would see that you are awake,” Twilight said sliding open the door as she walked inside the room with a large bowl.

Sunset Glare smiled. “How’s it going, Twilight?”

Twilight ignored Sunset Glare. She took the small rag from his forehead and put it inside the bowl of warm water. She took out a replacement rag and wrangle it out. After she got most of the water out, she push him back on the bed and put the rag on his forehead once more.

Twilight was about to leave, but Sunset Glare stopped her. He wouldn't allow her to leave after he heard her screaming his name.

“Get back on the bed,” Twilight ordered.

“Not until we talk. I am tired of you shutting me out.” Sunset Glare got up from his bed, but quickly fell back into it. He realized he was naked. He sighed as he looked at Twilight turning back and facing him.

“You’re clothes are in the dryer. They were wet when you had recklessly dived into that lake to retreat Smarty Pants,” Twilight told him. She added the extra hiss when she glared at him.

The reason why Twilight was being so cold with Sunset Glare was because of a misunderstanding she had with him. She thought that Sunset Glare had slept with her baby sitter, Cadence. He was without a shirt and she was naked under the covers. Twilight felt so broken by Sunset’s betrayal that she shut him out completely. She wouldn’t invite him to anything nor would she associate herself with him. She didn’t even understand why he would risk his life just to save something that she cared about.

“Twilight, I have told you a million times that nothing happened between me and Cadence. What do i have to do to make you forgive me?” Sunset Glare felt he needed this moment to clear up his misunderstanding with Twilight.

“How was I supposed to react when I saw you shirtless with Cadence right next to you?” Twilight yelled at him.

“Twilight, Cadence was only helping me because I spilled my drink on my shirt.” Sunset Glare said.

“Why was she naked?” Twilight growled.

"She was wearing a towel and it slipped off," Sunset Glare answered her.

“You shut me out of your life. How was I supposed to tell you?” Sunset Glare yelled back. “Though, Cadence is kind of cute.”

Twilight knew Sunset Glare was joking, but she grabbed one of his shoes and dropped it in the general direction of where one of his testicles resided. Sunset Glare's eye bolted open when he felt the boot dropping over to the other side of the bed.

“AHHHH GOSH TWILIGHT,” Sunset Glare groaned in pain as he looked at Twilight glaring at him.

“Serves you right,” Twilight said as she show him no emotion. “You could have been hurt. Do you realize how worried I was?”

“I know that you care a lot for Smarty Pants.” Sunset Glare knew that Twilight wouldn't refer to him at.

“I wasn’t talking about Smarty Pants” Twilight crossed her arms and avoided looking at him. The fiery haired teen looked over at Twilight. He saw a stream of tears running down her face.

“You were worried about me?” Sunset Glare realized. Twilight was about to get up again, but Sunset stopped her.

“Yeah, I don’t know what would have happened if I had lost my dear friend.” Twilight softly spoke trying to prevent herself from crying.

Suddenly, her words felt like a very large and heavy brick being placed on his body. He sighed as he was glad that Twilight still thought of him as a friend.

“You know, Sunset. It’s kind of funny,” Twilight giggled. “Cadence was telling me something that seemed out of place. She told me that you had some kind of crush on me.”

Sunset’s eyes widened as he bit his lip and nodded his head. “Yeah, pretty funny.”

Twilight looked down at Sunset Glare. She used the context clues from his words that he did, in fact, have a crush on her. Twilight’s eyes widened as Sunset Glare smirked and started to laugh a little bit.

“What is so funny?” Twilight scorned

“That you are now realizing that I like you more than a friend?” Sunset Glare covered his face and tried not to laugh too long.

“How long?” Twilight gripped her hands and stared intensely at her legs, which she was sitting on.

“How long, what?” Sunset Glare raised a brow in confusion.

“How long have you had a crush on me?” Twilight blushed.

“Well, since you came back for the third time. Every one of your friends and even I made a bet to see how long it would take for you to realize that I liked liked you. I put a bet it would take a year knowing how oblivious you are.” Sunset Glare continued to laugh.

This only made Twilight grab his other shoe and dropped it down to the same area where she dropped his first shoe. He groaned in pain feeling the same pain he did last time. This made Twilight smirk and proud inside.

Twilight and Sunset Glare both stood there looking at one another. Sunset sighed feeling the awkward tension that quickly filled the room. He understood Twilight’s facial expressions. They were telling him that she wasn’t interested in him.

“It’s okay, I can take a hint.” Sunset Glare sighed.

“What?” Twilight said while feeling bewildered by Sunset Glare’s attitude.

“I know you don’t feel the same way about me, Twilight. I completely comprehend the fact that you don’t like me in that way.” Sunset turned his whole body away from Twilight.

“Glare, I didn’t know you felt so strongly about me like that.” Twilight blushed as she twirled a bit of her hair around. She went to touch his shoulder only to find that he was still cold. Twilight was extremely worried about him. She knew the proper way of warming him up, but she quickly felt embarrassed. She just needed him to keep facing the one side of the room.

Twilight quickly discarded pieces of her attire. She felt extremely embarrassed, but she ignored her embarrassment for the sake of Sunset Glare. She needed to warm him up and that was what she was going to do.

Sunset felt the bed sheet being lifted up and turned his head. However, the lavender skinned girl quickly slapped the side of his head. “Face the wall,”

“Twilight, what are you doing?” Sunset Glare felt Twilight’s small body holding him.

“I am warming you up. Don’t look over here, okay?” Twilight told him. Her legs were brushing his, her arms was wrapped around his chest.

Sunset Glare didn’t mind all this, except for the fact that he felt both of Twilight’s breasts on his backside. He bit his lip feeling aroused at thinking about a nude Twilight cuddling him. Sunset Glare has had thoughts of a naked Twilight, though most of which was in a bedroom by himself with a box of tissues.

He felt Twilight’s warm hands touching him as he looked down to see her hands and he then put his hands over Twilight’s. He soon found that Twilight’s hands were on his abs.
“Have you been working out?” Twilight thought she might make small talk. It was only to distract them from the embarrassing situation they found themselves in.

“Twilight, pleases.” Sunset Glare blushed. He didn’t want her in bed with him for two reasons. One, he was naked. Two, was an embarrassing reason. Sunset Glare was lying on top of his right side for a specific reason. If he had put his back on the floor, Twilight would have seen his “pitched” tent.

“Glare, stop fighting,” Twilight felt Glare’s resistance to her, and started to fight back.

The two of them fight over control in the covers as Twilight wanted to help Sunset Glare, yet he was probably embarrassed about her being naked. Sunset Glare, however, didn’t want Twilight finding out about a certain area in his body.

Twilight pulled his shoulder making his back hit the ground. The woman then climbed on top of his body. She was hoping her pounce would make him stop struggling.

“AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH,” Twilight jolted up as she suddenly shrieked. It felt like she had been slapped on her rear.

Twilight’s action lifted the sheet exposing Glare’s and her own upper body to the air. Twilight throat began to dry as she slowly looks down seeing Sunset Glare’s muscles while he was staring at her breasts.

“Take a picture, it will last longer,” Twilight crossed her arms.

“You’re one to talk,” Glare knew Twilight was in the same situation he was, “I see you looking at my chest as well.”

Twilight was about to say something, but she knew that Glare was right. Twilight was as guilty as Sunset was. She could have touched his chest, but it was the same as Glare touching her breasts. Twilight didn’t know what to do. She wanted to leave the room with her clothes, but the couple found themselves with a new problem.

Both eyes of the teens were lowering down to their legs. What had made Twilight jump was now clear. In the middle of their struggle, Twilight thought she could pin Sunset Glare down on the bed. She had pinned him down, but it wasn’t her hands that pinned him down. It was the fact that Sunset Glare’s manhood was inside Twilight. It was inside Twilight's vagina.

Sunset Glare knew he was dead. Twilight was his best friend. He had not only told Twilight he loved her, but his manhood was now inside her, going far from what he wanted to do. He needed to fix it.

“Twilight,” Sunset Glare hesitated.

“Shush,” Twilight told him.
“I didn’t mean for this to…” Sunset Glare asked again.

Twilight held a low growl before putting a finger on his lips to silence him. “SHUSH,”

Sunset Glare wasn’t sure why Twilight was telling him to be quiet. He figured that she would want to pull herself off of him and run out of the room, yet Twilight stood where she was. Why didn’t she let him speak or try to explain the situation?

A light bulb smacked Glare over his head. It was right there he realized that Twilight wasn’t moving because she was thinking the situation over. Did she want to do this with him?

Twilight took in a breath before she exhaled. “Well, it seems that we have reached a very bewildering situation.”

Twilight removed herself from Sunset Glare, who felt very panicky. “Twilight, I am sorry. I didn’t mean for that to happen. I…I…I…”

Twilight only turned to step towards his bag and open it. Glare wanted to get up, but he felt very cold.

“Twilight, what are you doing in my bag?”

Twilight ignored him and scattered all his clothes out of her way. She knew she had seen the item in his bag somewhere. Sunset Glare shivered to see what Twilight might discover in his bag. It felt like Twilight was going through his room in search of obscene materials. What exactly was she looking for?

Suddenly, Twilight lifted what she had wanted from Sunset Glare’s bag. The male gulped seeing Twilight holding up the condom in the bag. This made him sweat with fear. He didn't mean for Twilight to find them. He needed to explain himself.

“I can explain, ummm I was holding that for a friend and I told them that I was…” Sunset Glare saw Twilight with a blank expression. She was too smart for his lies. “Okay, it was might on the off chance we would make it this far, but I only had it as a last resort.”

Glare saw Twilight approaching him and feared what might happen tonight. Glare closed his eyes fearing that Twilight would berate him for thinking it could happen between them.

Suddenly, he felt the warm lips of Twilight on him. Sunset Glare opened one of his eyes seeing Twilight’s gaze on him. It was like that of a lover. He wasn’t sure if he was excited or scared of Twilight. Did she really want to do this with him?

“Twilight, do you possibly want to do this?” Sunset Glare raised a brow.

She carefully opened the condom to give to him and nods. Sunset Glare sighed before pulling her towards him.

“This night is about to become interesting for the both of us.” He told Twilight as he started to make out with her.

“Gees, how long does it take for his clothes to dry,” Rainbow Dash sighed. She was checking on Sunset Glare’s clothes. They were as wet as when he came out of the water. It took the combine strength of Rainbow Blitz, both Applejacks and herself to lift Sunset Glare and bring him into the house.

“At least, he is alright.” Fluttershy felt relieved.

“Yeah,” Butterscotch added as he sat down next to Fluttershy.

“I do hope that Twilight is taking the whole thing well,” Rarity felt more worried towards Twilight, who wasn’t acting like herself ever since Glare into the water.

The three girls knew that Twilight hated Glare for the Cadence situation, but they knew Twilight’s crush on him as well. When Twilight saw Sunset in the room with Cadence, Twilight’s heart was crush. She hated Glare from that point on, but some of her love for him remained.

Rarity saw her boyfriend, Elusive, looking upstairs for some reason.

“Is something wrong, my love?” Rarity asked.

“Yes, Twilight has been up there for a few hours and has not come down at all.” Elusive gazed over at the stairs.

“Well Elusive,” Rarity spoke, “Twilight saw Glare risking his life for Twilight’s doll. She hasn’t left his side at all.”

“That’s not what I mean,” Elusive answered before breathing in and out, “I mean, she hasn’t left that room. I also have been hearing strange noises. I want to check up on Sunset Glare.”

Rarity was about to stop him when the others passed by her announcing all of them want to check on Glare.

As much as she wanted to give Twilight and Sunset Glare their privacy, she also, wanted to check up on them.

“Let’s go and see them.”

Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy, Elusive, Butterscotch, and Rarity were the only ones checking up on Twilight. The others were checking on Sunset Shimmer and Dusk Shine, who had been in the Hot Springs for too long. Rarity’s party was checking up on Twilight and Sunset Glare.

“Remember, we are only checking up on them.” Rarity warned them.

As the five friends approached the room, they heard strange voices in the room. Rarity looked at Elusive. The voices did belong to Twilight and Sunset Glare, but their words were confusing. Rainbow Dash put her ear to the door.

“What are they talking about?” Rainbow Dash whispered.

“Rainbow Dash, it’s rude to eavesdrop.” Rarity said.

“Relax, Rarity.” Rainbow said before adding, “It’s just I don’t hear talking. I hear them saying something, but I can’t make it out.”

“Maybe we should come back another time,” Fluttershy spoke.

“I wouldn’t want to ruin their moment together,” Butterscotch added.

Elusive looked at Rarity before suggesting that they should at least lightly open the door. Not letting the couple know their presence while giving them privacy. Rarity loved her boyfriend’s suggestion. Rainbow had lightly opened the door, the five could see what was going on.

At first, nothing seemed out of the ordinary, however once they opened the door, the big picture revealed itself along with some sound.

“GOSH, GLARE. OH GOSH THIS FEELS GOOD.”

The five friends looked all around the room to find clothes on the floor, the room pitch black and two figures on the bed. Fluttershy and Butterscotch soon found Twilight’s clothes to be on the ground. Rainbow, Rarity and Elusive soon uncovered where the audio was coming from.

The five friends soon looked upon Twilight, who was probably naked, bouncing on top of Sunset Glare. The five knew why Twilight had a face like she was lifting a heavy box. Fluttershy and Butterscotch covered their eyes, Rainbow Dash remained speechless, Rarity blushed a lot and Elusive stood there. All five was watching Twilight and Sunset Glare profess their love for one another in a physical way.

“SUNSET, I AM SO CLOSE AHHHHHH GOSH!”

Elusive quickly closed the door as he didn’t want to be rude to the couple. Once he did, all five friend stood there in shock. They looked to one another before each of them spoke.

“I need to…ummmm…take a shower…” Rainbow Dash ran over to bathroom and locked the door.

Rarity tugged on Elusive’s arm. The male fashion design looked over seeing Rarity was quite aroused by Twilight and Sunset Glare’s display of affection.

“Let’s go,” Elusive said before rushing with Rarity to find a room for them.

Fluttershy and Butterscotch gulped while looking at the door. They both left the area taking with them their phones containing a photo of their chaotic lovers in a seductive matter.

Twilight and Sunset Glare threw themselves on the bed after the two of them went through such an intense and passionate love making session. Twilight cuddled up next to Glare as the two of them began to look at the ceiling. The two of them pretended that there was no roof and simply stared at the stars.

“That was…” Twilight spoke.

“…Amazingly incredible,” Sunset Glare finished her sentence.

Twilight wasn’t sure what else to say. She never expected to do such a thing to Glare, yet she was glad they did it anyways. The problem now was how was this going to affect their friendship.

“How are you feeling?” She asked him.

“I feel very warm, actually.” He told her as he pulled her close to him. Sunset Glare looked down at Twilight, “Look, this mess is all my fault. I was just trying to be nice to your sister in law and she knew I loved you. She just told me some things about you.”

Twilight gulped when Sunset Glare mentioned Cadence.

“Don’t worry, she didn’t tell me any moments from your childhood.” Sunset Glare relieved Twilight’s worries. “I am just glad we are friends again.”

“Are we?” Twilight turned her body to where her head was near his. The two of them just had sex, she was sure that friends don’t exactly do that in such a way.

“Well, I am not sure what you want to be after this?” Sunset Glare sighed. “I mean, I would ask you out, but I am not sure if you want…”

“Yes,” Twilight pounded his chest. “Yes, I want to go out with you.”

Sunset Glare looked at her, surprised at her answer. He wasn’t sure if he was dreaming or if this was real.

“Are you being serious?” Sunset needed to make sure that this was what Twilight wanted.

“As serious as you are with falling in love with me.” Twilight pulled him for another kiss before sitting on top of him.

“Yes, then I will go out with you and become your boyfriend.” Sunset Glare hugged Twilight. He held her in his arms. Twilight was blanketing his body with hers. Despite the fact he was warm, Twilight didn’t want to move away from him.

“Sunset?” Twilight gulped.

“Yes, my love.” Sunset Glare lowered his eyes to meet Twilight’s.

“Mind if I stay like this with you. Just for a little bit until the morning or when your clothes dry.” Twilight asked. She wanted to let him sleep, but soon she was tired as well. She would have lied next to him, yet his body felt like a large pillow.

"Also," Twilight took in a nervous yelp, "Do you think we can do 'it' again?"

“If that is what you wish, Twilight, I see no reason to say no to that request.” Sunset Glare nods as he felt Twilight snuggling up to him.

As Twilight fell asleep, Sunset Glare was glad to have Twilight liking him once more. He didn’t expect Twilight to love him as well.

Now that Twilight was his girlfriend, Sunset Glare was satisfied and content with his life. His eyes soon closed and he drifted off to join Twilight in dream land.

“I love you, Twilight Sparkle.” Sunset Glare were his last words for the night.

Author's Note

I don't own the rights to My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic. MLP:FIM is owned by Hasbro. I don't own the rights to Sunset Glare. He belongs to someone else.

Wow, does this seem interesting. Tell me what you guys think of this tale?

Until then, see you later.