The Wedding's true casuality

by KrspaceT

Rating: everyone
Tags: Alternate Universe, Princess Luna, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Princess Celestia
Length: 1163

Some consider Celestia a manipulative mastermind. Others wonder why she doesn't fix everything in Equestria. A few even assume she is disheartened by death. What happens when these ideas are put together as one?

This idea has been dabbling in my mind as of late: after reading the Great Alicorn Hunt, and reflecting on some tendencies in this fandom to treat Celestia the same way other fandoms treat characters like Dumbledore and the Sandiame/Third Hokage. My mind often thinks of ways to look at fandom cliches in new ways, and this is my take on the subject. Can't say if I would explore it further, but I am not against anyone else taking a dab at it.

Anyway, the idea here is that Celestia is musing in the aftermath of the Canterlot Royal Wedding, about how this may mean Shining Armor may now be doomed to die like a mortal, leaving a brokenhearted Cadence behind. Luna, who unlike Celestia has not had the years (about as long as Cadence has been a royal) to plan these things, is a bit more realistic, believing there is still plenty of time.

This also takes place before Season 3, where one could simply suggest this conversation leads to the plans to cause Twilicorn.

It also implies that Cadence and Shining Armor haven't come to realize the implications of Mayfly-December romance. As far as I know that pretty canon.

Hopefully this meets my goal: of trying to present a Celestia who could work as an antagonist, but one who isn't evil, diabolical, and could be an interesting take on the character for others to use.

Published 2015-10-19 06:20:01 UTC
Last updated 2015-10-19 06:20:01 UTC

1

As ruler of Equestria, a being who many revered not only in the vein of a ruler, but as a deity herself, people viewed her in many, radically different ways.

To some, she was bringer of daylight, the ensure of fertility and safety. Her sun warmed the earth, grew the plants, and repelled the monsters of the night.

Many even worshiped her as a deity, and while she drew a line at temples devoted to her or her sister they still tended to swear by her name. It was....an interesting quirk. Of course every so often someone decided to create an underground cult that she had to have dismantled before things went mad.

To others, she was the ultimate weapon: a fearsome entity whom could single handily protect Equestria from threats internal and external. While she was not infallible, as had recently been proven by the near disaster that was the royal wedding (and in truth it was a disaster, though in a way only she knew), the fact that she was alive kept foreign nations from thinking about waging war.

To a certain purple unicorn, she was a teacher, an idol, a second mother. The fact that said unicorn wasn’t looking at her with disappointment for her own mistakes over said wedding truly boggled her. Perhaps she should keep an eye on her, in case she was just bottling it in.

Celestia had no idea: Twilight Sparkle was a wonderful student with a brilliant mind and even more brilliant heart, but her mind tended to go to some strange places and make some odd connections. It wasn’t as random as her pink earth pony friend, by no means was she that…..unique, but it was something that even after so many years still caught Celestia off guard at times.

Perhaps she should read up on some of the latest childhood syndrome studies from the psychologists in Manehatten one of these days, just to get a grasp on it.

But, it wasn’t that unicorn that she was worried about at the moment.

….

“I take it transforming love sucking monsters were not how you anticipated the wedding going?”

Celestia, alicorn princess of the sun, turned from her balcony to her sister, princess of the moon Luna, with a unamused look.

“Hardly. I was expecting an attack, true, but not from a race I had thought vanquished. Normally a volcano makes a good prison for ones defeated adversaries” Celestia noted the night sky “I was expecting anything else really: Griffins, Yaks, anything but Changelings. Sort of makes a giant shield around the entire city pointless if they are using the one making it as a snack, doesn’t it?”

Sure, it did keep the majority of the swarm at bay first, but it didn't really do much when the shield could be broken by a few hundred bouncing emotion eating creatures as the shield's caster hadn't the ability to focus on keeping it up. Having your fiance replaced by a emotion eating, mind numbing mastermind of a villain was not conductive to efficient magic casting after all.

The black alicorn yawned, as if recalling how she managed to sleep through the entire invasion “Yes, yes it does. It does certainly derail that plan of yours, to have Shining Armor pushed to his limits defending the town, his sister, and his fiancé from an unknown threat now doesn’t it?”

The silence in the room was palpable. Had it been anyone else, such an accusation would have been treasonous, blasphemous, moon banishmentamous.

Between the two in the know of course, it was just basic motive dialogue. Perhaps if someone overheard them it would be considered alarming, but they were alone.

The guards knew how far to stand, and when not to listen in on the private discussions of royalty. While usually this meant sibling squabbles, this case it meant grand master plans that could be considered diabolical out of context.

“Yes, yes it has. And now, everything is ruined”.

The simple statement hit like one of Tirek’s energy blasts.

“We have time, sister. Given the fact that it has been not even a year since I was freed from the moon, and in that time we’ve seen the return of Discord and the Changelings, I’m certain something equally horrendous will occur that will put Shining Armor in the proper place”.

“It doesn’t matter if Discord teams up with Tirek and Sombra, this was the perfect opportunity to try and get him to push himself past the limits of himself, to do a legendary deed. To save himself and Cadence from realizing…..”

“Like I said sister, there is certainly plenty of time left before they come to realize that….implication” Luna assured her sister.

“As I’m sure you are quite aware, there are plenty of dangers in Equestria that could make anypony commit such a magnificent deed, as to surpass their mortal limits”

With that last line, the room fell silent once more.

For while some would suggest that a magical kingdom where creatures roamed capable of turning victims to stone, devouring them in a swamp of flames, eating them alive, conning them of life and bit, and myriads of other horrible fates was completely irresponsible of such a powerful and benevolent ruler. Why did she not simply destroy all such horrors, either by her own hoof or by her command?

It was quite simple: several years ago she had seen one such incident in a time when such oversights were truly just pure oversights, a wicked horse whose actions were stopped by a young Pegasus who pushed herself beyond what she should have been capable of.

Shortly after that, she found herself with a third immortal companion. And a new emotion now gripped the heart of this immortal and benevolent princess.

She wished, to have more. After centuries of being alone, she had tasted the flavor of truly lifelong companions even among the longest lived, after only having a sister she was forced to banish alongside her.

And she would taste it again.

Author's Note

So basically, if you don't get the gist of what I am suggesting, this is it.

Basically I am suggesting that the Celestia in this short thought that Shining Armor, in holding back the X invasion during the wedding with his shieldspell, would push himself so far he'd ascend to Alicornhood, thus ensuring he and Cadence would be together forever.

And that she doesn't, say, eradicate Cockatrices because she hopes that ponies may end up doing the same fighting against such things.

If I wanted to, I probably could make this into a larger idea and show characters in the MLP world in fact being pushed so far they ascend. Perhaps multiple sonic rainbooms would do it, one after the other? However, I have a lot on my plate right now so I 'd probably won't do that.

Adoption of this idea is allowed though, in case anyone is interested.