Rainbow began stroking herself immediately, as Fluttershy looked off into space, thinking back. "So… after we were finished last week at Pinkie's, Twilight was talking about how Pinkie did so much to make that party special, and I… I wasn't sure she received enough thanks. Especially because she started that party off so nervous...

"Once you and Twilight left, I turned the light off… it startled Pinkie a little, since she was busy cleaning up and thought everyone had left, but there was a full moon, so there was still light coming in through the windows. I just... thought it might be easier for me to do what I was about to do if the mood was a little calmer." She blushed.

"Pinkie was blinking, trying to get her eyes used to the darkness… I walked up to her, and I… well," she laughed lightly, "First I gave her a big hug… just a long, tight hug. She was pretty confused… but she giggled and hugged back.

"After a bit, I pulled back, and I told her… that I thought she needed to have more faith in herself, and that she was very special, and that none of us would ever care how much she overshadowed us, and that she should make cupcakes for herself next time, and…" She breathed in, and then out. "...and that I wanted her to get on the bed." Rainbow muffled her voice as her leg spasmed.

"So I started kissing her… I've always loved Pinkie's kissing. She goes at whatever speed she knows you like… um, so I started kissing her, and then we both started moving towards the bed, and… oh!" She looked at Pinkie. "I forgot you had just changed the sheets! And then we— I'm sorry!"

"Hey, spoilers!" Pinkie laughed. "Keep going!" She motioned for Fluttershy to continue.

Fluttershy regained her composure. "So… she gets on the bed first, and then sort of pulls me up… and we lay there, next to each other, just… kissing. I'm not sure for how long…

"Eventually, I moved on top of her, so she was on her back… and after one last, long kiss… I started to move back. I trailed my hooves down her as I went, and then… the moon was behind her, but I could still see…" She blushed again. "...enough.

"I lay on my side, curled up a bit so there was room for both of us on the bed, and then I… started licking. Just sliding up the entrance, pulling back, and sliding up again… just as I had been doing earlier that night, but I wanted to keep it that way this time. I know she likes it fast, but I thought after what we did do to her, maybe she'd like something slower…" Pinkie nodded silently to the other members of the audience, not wanting to interrupt.

"I kept softly licking, and felt her shifting softly, moaning very quietly, and giggling… She felt… happy. She breathed a little harder… her breathing was louder than her moans.

"I pressed forward a little bit, and put my tongue inside her. I've always enjoyed Pinkie's taste… I touched every surface I could find, just wanting to make sure she was feeling good. She made this… this soft 'oooohh…' I'm not sure I'd heard that before.

"She said some other things… um… 'Fluttershy, that's really good,' I think… 'This feels awesome'...? Which was nice… I tried to get a look at her face to see her smile, but I really only saw her mane, um, in the moonlight… I did see her breathing, though, from the light on her chest. And I know she was smiling. She's always smiling.

"I pressed in a little deeper, but I… didn't have much of a plan for after that point… all I had at that point was to keep licking like that until she was finished. I'm sure she would have. Um, finished, I mean — but, in the moment, I guess I started to grow anxious… I think she could tell, because that's when she said, um… 'Can I return the favor?'"

She smiled. "Of course, I had wanted this to be about her, but… well, as we saw earlier that evening, she really does just want to make the moment more special by helping out other ponies when she can. So… without saying anything, I started moving around, trying not to step on her. I tried to keep my tongue in Pinkie as best I could.

"I got to about the right position, and then Pinkie's hooves guided me the rest of the way. She put my flank in just the right spot, and then pulled me down, and then…" She beamed.

"I've never felt Pinkie go so slowly. I think she'd been watching the speed Rainbow's been using with me, the one that really…" She trailed off. "I could really feel that Pinkie was doing everything she could to try and make sure it was the way I liked it. I had to take a moment to gasp, then kept going.

"Every time I grazed her walls, she grazed mine. Every time I pushed in deep, she did as well. She just… wanted me to feel what she was feeling. And it was wonderful. I tried all sorts of new things, just to see how they felt. At one point, my tongue touched her ceiling just barely, and I heard this excited moan from her — and a moment later, she showed me what that was like, and I… I made just about the same noise.

"Her hips started to press into me just a bit — it felt like her whole body was just moving on its own, trying to get more from me. It felt so… rewarding. Appreciative. I tried to give her the same feeling, but… I, um… sort of twitched. Just as I tried to press my hips into her, the light swirl I gave her a moment ago came back, and I… thrusted my self into her. From the giggling she made, though, I think she figured out that it was just… appreciation. And I liked the feeling of forcing her tongue deeper into me…

"So I continued to thrust myself into her… not — not violently, but… strongly. Every few seconds. I was breathing harder, and so was she… both of us moaning, so happily. I was holding on to Pinkie's legs very tightly, trying to hold back and keep my own licking slow...

"I heard Pinkie's moans getting louder and more frequent, and her hind legs were flexing and unflexing. I could feel her getting close… so I pressed in as far as I could, trying to see how deep I could get my tongue in this last moment. I felt her clench, and cry out happily… and in the same moment, of course, she sent her tongue as deep as she could, into me. And her tongue is a lot longer… it made me shiver right along with her.

"So, once she'd finished… I put my front hooves on the bed and pushed myself up a bit so I wasn't lying on Pinkie as she kept going. She was… wonderful. It truly felt like she wanted to thank me for staying behind… and I just kept crying out. I couldn't hold it in. I was arching my back, and moaning, and thrusting into her…

"I was barely able to tell her that I was getting close before I — I climaxed, shaking all over. And Pinkie stayed with me, holding me tight until I stopped trembling.

"I turned myself around, and laid down next to Pinkie, holding her, as I felt our heartbeats both slowly drop. And then…" She paused. "I guess I was more tired than I thought, because the next thing I remembered was sunlight coming through the windows, and a blanket over me… she must have gotten a new one from the closet. And there was a crumpled up blanket on the couch, where I guess… she spent the night…"

"Well… where was Pinkie?" Applejack asked, enraptured.

Fluttershy sniffled, her eyes misting. "That was when I heard her coming up the stairs, with a plate of fresh pancakes... and the syrup… it ran a bit, but I could tell it had been in a little… smiley face..."

She sniffled again, and walked over to Pinkie, hugging her tightly. "You're such a good friend, Pinkie."

Several hearts swelled as Pinkie hugged back. "You deserve it, silly! And you were plenty sweet that night yourself!"

Rainbow squinted at Pinkie, long and hard. Finally, she spoke. "Not sure if that was a sex joke..."

A chorus of boos and laughter rang out as the other ponies threw pillows at Rainbow. Fluttershy looked over at her for the first time in several minutes, only now noting that she was lying on her stomach, seemingly long having stopped touching herself. "O-oh… was… was my story not very good?" she said nervously.

Rainbow shook her head. "No! No, I just… I kind of, uh, finished back when you told Pinkie to get on the bed." She laughed, sheepishly. "I just… I dunno. I'm proud to see you having come that far."

Fluttershy blinked. She walked over to Rainbow, and she kissed her. "Only because of you, Rainbow…" She lay down next to Rainbow and nuzzled in.

Rarity looked out the window at the setting sun. "Well, if we're all good and done, I do believe it's time for us to take our leave. Don't get too settled in..." She stood up and headed for the shower.

Rainbow waved a hoof lazily. "Nope. Too late. We're sleepin' over." She closed her eyes and leaned on Fluttershy.

Applejack smirked. "Stayin' behind after a Friendship Orgy? You know what that leads to…"

Rainbow waved her hoof again. "Yeah, we'll tell you the story later." Applejack laughed.

Twilight watched as Applejack and Pinkie walked out of the room. "Yeah… storytime was a pretty good idea. Rarity and Applejack certainly seemed hardly able to sit still as they listened... " She thought for a moment. "...I'm pretty sure they're gonna go do it in the shower. Pinkie'll surely follow if she manages to notice."

Rainbow snorted. "And what about you?"

"...Those were some pretty good stories…"

"Well, get over here. They'll do their thing, we'll do ours, we'll regale each other next week."

Twilight laughed, and closed her bedroom doors. "Done."

Author's Note

Fluttershy's story takes place immediately following What Makes a Good Party!