Squeaky Pie

by AmtrakBrony

Rating: mature
Tags: Second Person, Romance, Random, Human
Length: 3446

There's one thing you really like about Pinkie Pie, and it only gets better when the two of you get a little kinky.

There are many things you like about Ponyville's pink party planner, but there's one thing you always like doing to her, and that's squeezing her. Whether it's a simple hug or multiple frisky acts under the covers, you can't get enough of it.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2015-11-06 01:40:01 UTC

A Sound You'll Never Get Tired Of

You wipe the back of your wrist over your forehead a few times, cleaning the sweat from your brow. You've just finished mopping the kitchen at Sugar Cube Corner, which means you're done with your duties at the shop for the night. However, you won't be leaving to go home anytime soon, as this building is already your place of residence.

A while back, after somehow winding up in Equestria, you met a cute, bouncy ball of energy, known by everyone in town as Pinkie Pie. She wasn't at all scared of the fact that you were a different species than she was. She was quick to offer you a place to stay, which ended up being her room at the café. It took a while for Mr. and Mrs. Cake to become comfortable around you, but after a while, they realized that you posed no threat to them or anypony else that was either in or out of the building.

After realizing just how much fun she was to have around, you and Pinkie quickly became more than just friends. She invited you to sleep in her bed, and from that moment on, there wasn't anywhere else you would rather sleep at night. The pink pony always snuggled against you cutely, and you had quite a hard time keeping your manliness in check as you watched her sleep against you. The way she smiled during her slumber, the way she nuzzled your chest unconsciously, it all seemed so wonderful after the first night.

The second night, however, got even better. You realized that Pinkie Pie was so cute that she was sexy. You had no idea how your brain could comprehend such a thought, but it didn't matter, as you had never been intimate with a girl back on Earth. From then on, every night you spent with Pinkie was one you would remember forever. However, there was one thing about the mare that you loved the best whenever you did this. It wasn't the pleasure you felt, nor was it the warmth the two of you shared as you fell asleep. No. It was something else.

Standing next to the pass-through to the shop area, you hear the bell at the front door ring, and that can only mean one thing. She's back.

"Anoooooooooonnn????" she exclaims in her playful tone. She can't see you, and she assumes you're playing hide-and-seek with her. "Where aaarrreee yooooouuuu?????"

You hide behind the wall, remaining out of her line of sight. Normally, she's the one who surprises you, but this time, you want to turn the tables on her, something you rarely get to do.

You hear hoofsteps getting louder and louder as Pinkie makes her way to the entrance to the kitchen. You squat down, waiting for her to come in. It takes a while, and you remain as silent as a sleeping foal as you sense Pinkie only mere feet away.

Finally, your patience pays off. You see a pink foreleg pass through the entrance, and immediately, you pounce.

"Whoa!" Pinkie yelps as you tackle her to the ground. As the two of you roll over a few times, you cheer internally as you realize that you've successfully surprised her before she did the same thing to you.

Eventually, Pinkie ends up on top of you, happily looking you in the eyes. "There you are!" she chirps, her tone remaining cute and playful. You immediately grab her cheeks and pull her into a kiss, which she gladly accepts. As your lips and tongues dance with each other, you wrap your arms back around her form and...

There it is. There's the one thing you love about Pinkie the best. Every time you hug or squeeze her, you hear the cutest squeaking sound coming from her, as if she's a big, soft squeaky toy that dogs play with. You would normally hear this sound if somepony smiled at you excitedly or guiltily, but with Pinkie Pie, that's something you don't have to worry about. All you have to do is embrace her and her body will do the rest.

"H-Hey! Stop!" Pinkie giggles, realizing what you're doing. Truthfully, she loves it when you squeeze her, but at times, it can get rather intense, as she's very ticklish throughout her body, and you doing this makes her laugh almost uncontrollably.

With a devilish smile, you squeeze her barrel again, her body making another squee noise as you release your pressure on her. She laughs again, and continues to do so as you repeat your actions a few times.

Whenever you squeeze the party pony, she doesn't feel as if she has any bones or internal organs. You can squeeze her as hard as you can and she won't feel any pain. You sometimes wonder how a pony's body is capable of such a thing, but Pinkie has always been a mystery to you, and - at this point - you couldn't care less about the things about her that confuse you to no end.

You soon cease squeezing the party pony, sadly sighing internally as you immediately begin to miss that adorable sound her body makes. Pinkie lets out a few more giggles as she pants for oxygen, still laying on your chest. You bring a hand back up to her cheek and say, "Hey there, Pinkie. Were you and the Cakes able to get everything there on time?"

"Absolutely!" she replies, "I've had this outing planned for days, and everything went according to plan! Everypony in Dodge Junction was ecstatic when they saw all the goods we had brought!" Pinkie Pie had just returned from said location, where a big birthday celebration for Cherry Jubilee had taken place. The Cakes were still over there, twins in tow, as they helped clean everything up. They had told you that Pinkie would be coming home first to help you run the shop until they got back, and you were looking forward to spending some alone time with the pony who, at this point, you considered to be your marefriend. As for you not going, you offered to stay behind and run the shop on your own, which brought big smiles to the faces of Cupcake and Carrot Cake.

"I'm glad," you reply, "I've been missing you."

"I've been missing you, too," Pinkie responds, nuzzling your cheek affectionately. In response, you cup your right hand and place it on the underside of Pinkie's chin, resting your thumb on her left cheek and leaving your remaining fingers on her right. You press inward, feeling part of her face squeeze in your grasp, which results in another squee noise and a few happy giggles from the mare on top of you.

You immediately wrap your right arm back around the party pony, and then you stand up, holding her in your grasp as she wraps her forelegs around your neck. You then give her a devilish smile and ask, "But you know what I've really been missing?"

Pinkie mirrors your gaze. "I think I know, but I wanna hear it from you," she replies in a seductive voice, bopping a forehoof against your nose as she finishes her sentence.

"Oh, I don't think I need to say anything..." you respond, moving one of your hands down to her shapely, pink rump. You grasp her left butt cheek in your hand and squeeze it, making the party pony moan slightly as you hear that all-too-familiar sound once again. You have no intention of moving that hand anywhere else at the moment, but for good measure, Pinkie Pie wraps her poofy tail around your wrist, letting you know that you're both on the same page.

Both your eyes and hers are half-lidded, and they stare at each other seductively before you both close them and lean in for another kiss. At that moment, you turn to your right and head up the stairs, keeping one eye open slightly as you feel Pinkie's tongue begin to enter your mouth. Eventually, you reach the top floor, which is her bedroom, and you walk the two of you over to her bed. You lay the pink mare back, still holding her close, as you continue your make-out session.

After what seems like forever, you break the kiss, slowly opening your eyes as Pinkie does the same, and you mirror her loving gaze. However, the gaze on the pink face in front of you changes back to a sultry one, and you feel Pinkie's forehooves tugging at the hem of your t-shirt. You finally release your grip on her and do the work yourself, easily pulling your shirt off of you and throwing it off to the side of the bed.

You then look back down at Pinkie Pie, but your eyes immediately take a trip further south, and you notice that her pink marehood is already glistening with her natural juices. Your instincts tell you to dive right in, but you have other plans.

You lean forward and begin planting butterfly kisses on the side of Pinkie's neck, making the mare chuckle cutely. At the same time, you place one hand on each side of her barrel and give her another squeeze, hearing even more chuckles as they mix with that adorable squeaking noise. Your lips soon leave her neck and begin their trek downward, leaving kiss after loving kiss down the center of her form. Your trail continues over her round belly until you feel your chin bump up against her plump, pink teats. You then lift your head and reposition it over her right breast, and then you descend, eventually encasing her pink nipple between your lips.

Pinkie moans loudly at the sensation, but that switches to more giggles as you begin suckling her teat. Why? Doing this causes her body to make a higher-pitched squeaking noise, as if a mouse was squeeing at you. Even if it doesn't sound the same, that doesn't mean it stimulates Pinkie's ticklish spots any less. You continue your ministrations for half a minute before lifting your head and giving her other nipple its share of your actions. Pinkie lets out a mixture of giggles and light moans as you continue to make her body squeak.

Finally, you lift your head again, giving your marefriend some reprieve as she catches her breath. But, just as she's able to return to steady breathing, you dive at her body, rolling onto your left side as you make the party pony do the same. She grunts slightly, but chuckles at you afterwards, knowing that you're about to kick things up more than just a mere notch.

Now in a spooning position, you wrap your left arm around her form and hold her tightly, all while moving your right hand down until it reaches her moist nether lips. You squeeze her one more time before tracing up the center line of her slit with your index and middle fingers. This elicits a loud, pleasure-laden moan from your marefriend, and your fingers repeat their journey over and over again, causing more and more liquid to flow out of Pinkie's love cave.

You continue your current actions for several more minutes, squeezing her affectionately and rubbing your fingers up and down her snatch, eventually sticking your fingers inside, seeking out the area that would give her the most pleasure. This results in more giggles, moans, cries of pleasure, and squeaking sounds coming from the mare you're pleasuring. All of these sounds combined drives your head crazy, testosterone pulsing through your body as your little friend down below gets bigger and bigger. You can feel it pressing against the tight confines of your boxers and blue jeans, and you're desperate to allow it room to breathe, but you put aside your desires and focus all of your attention on the pony in your arms.

Soon, Pinkie starts blissfully moaning and crying louder, which tells you that she's getting close. Putting your thumb to work, you search for the little nub of flesh at the top of her cunt, but when you find it and apply pressure, you hear something that you can't believe you're hearing, even though you've heard it many times already during previous sessions with Pinkie. As your thumb presses against her clit, an even higher-pitched squeaking sound can be heard, reminiscent of the tiny tweets and chirps given off by a newborn baby bird.

As soon as you hear this sound, all logical, physics-related items in your brain head out the door as you prepare to bring Pinkie to her climax. Still squeezing her barrel every few seconds, which, at this point, has already begun increasing her sexual lust as well as giving her a tickling sensation, you take your fingers out from inside her love tunnel and press the palm-side of your thumb and index finger together. You bring them both to her clit and, ever so gently, pinch her little love button. This not only gives off that really high-pitched squeak, but it's the last sensation Pinkie can take. With a loud moan, you feel her body tensing up, and your hand becomes coated in multiple layers of her marecum. You continue to rub her clit and slit as she orgasms, trying to prolong the event as much as you can before you hear the pink party pony give off a long, pleasurable sigh.

You continue holding your lover in your embrace as she relaxes, all while you bring your right hand up to your mouth. Pinkie's marecum is some of the sweetest liquid you've ever tasted. You can only describe it as a combination of bubble gum, strawberries, and cotton candy. You moan in delight as you lick the fluid off your hand and fingers, savoring the taste and wishing you had more.

Eventually, Pinkie Pie turns her head around and looks you in the eyes, smiling. "Wow...hhhh...Why can't ponies have fingers like you?" she asks, sounding sarcastically sad as she pants lightly for breath, "They feel soooooooo good!"

You grin at her and reply, "You mean like this?" At that moment, you bring your right hand, completely free of her fluids, to the underside of her chin. You begin tickling the party pony, making her laugh out loud as she tenses up slightly. You give her barrel another squeeze, prolonging her laughing fit as you hear that wonderfully cute noise once again.

You soon cease your actions, letting Pinkie catch her breath once again before letting go of her and climbing on top of her. You grin at her seductively, which she does to you in return. "You ready?" you ask.

"Yeah," she replies, "But...aren't you forgetting something?" she finishes while poking your crotch with one of her hind hooves. Your member is already fully erect, and you can feel it begging to be freed from the tight confines of your clothing. You reach a hand down and undo your belt, followed by both the button and zipper on your jeans. You then reach around the waistband to begin pulling your jeans and boxers down, but you stop as you feel two soft hooves against your hips. Pinkie starts pushing your remaining clothing down your legs with her hind hooves, her seductive gaze continuing to face you directly in your eyes.

Once you're completely naked, you lay down on top of your lover, lining your member up with her opening. As your chests meet, you push forward, sinking the head of your erection into her moist love cave. Both of you cry out in bliss as your bodies meet in the most intimate way possible. Soon, you push on further, sinking several more inches into her pussy before you feel your hips meet. However, when you do, you hear that sound again. You expected that, as previous love-making sessions with Pinkie have shown that every single part of her body will squeak when pressure is applied to those areas, and that includes her vaginal lips.

Pinkie giggles and moans as multiple sensations flood her body all at once. You moan as well, feeling your member become trapped within tight confines once again; however, these confines are the ones you want to be trapped inside.

Reaching under Pinkie's soft body, you wrap your arms around her again as you begin to pull back, only to thrust all the way back in soon after. Once again, you hear another moan and squee, followed by a light chuckle. One may think that either partner laughing during sex would be a turnoff, but with you and Pinkie, it makes the moment that much better.

You eventually find a comfortable rhythm, pumping in and out of the pink party pony as you hear more of the same sound you're used to hearing. All the giggles, moans, and squeaks drive you crazy as your crotch continues slapping right up against her soaking pussy lips. The squee noises that Pinkie's body makes when you do so muffle the sound of your wet flesh meeting hers, but that doesn't phase you one bit. Pinkie Pie is the cutest creature you've ever come into contact with, and since you admire her cute and bubbly nature so much, there isn't a single moment where you want it to stop.

Suddenly, you feel an immense pressure building up in your lower half, signaling your oncoming release. You unwrap your right arm out from under Pinkie's form and grab her left forehoof, squeezing it tightly. As much as the act makes Pinkie laugh, she herself is close, too, and now she's doing more moaning than giggling, and it's getting louder and louder.

Then, all at once, you grunt loudly as your member stiffens fully, blasting your hot cum deep into your lover's womb. You continue clutching Pinkie's hoof tightly, but since you never released pressure on it, you don't hear another adorable sound coming from it. It doesn't matter, as your orgasm is the only thing you want to experience right now.

Feeling your hot, hefty load filling her up makes Pinkie cry out one last time, her vaginal walls squeezing down on your cock as she releases more of her marecum, drenching your entire manhood and ballsack in the sweet, three-flavor delicacy. As you feel your member being squeezed, you have to wonder if Pinkie wishes that your cock would make that same noise her body does when being squeezed. That thought, however, is quickly brushed aside as the rest of your climax hits you hard, making you collapse on top of your lover as the two of you gasp for oxygen.

In the end, you and Pinkie lay together in a mix of arms, legs, and mane as the heat from both your bodies mix, creating a warm, intimate environment for you to bask in as your afterglow flows on. After a while, Pinkie turns the two of you over, and now she's lying on top of you. You each look at each other fondly, and you quickly move in for a passionate, open-mouthed kiss as your member finally exits her on its own. As you break the kiss, you squeeze Pinkie's barrel one more time, eliciting another squee noise and a giggle from your marefriend. Pinkie exhales audibly and says, "Hhhaaaaaa...That was amazing."

"I know..." you reply weakly while smiling, exhausted from your activities, "It only gets better every time."

"Awww...You're just saying that!" Pinkie responds, booping your nose with a forehoof.

You immediately grab that forehoof and squeeze it three times, hearing what is now your favorite sound, along with more giggles, once again. "Nope," you reply, "I mean it." You then lean forward and kiss her lovingly on the lips, and she pushes back against you as your head lays back on the pillow.

Pinkie soon breaks the kiss, smiling at you like she always does. "I love you," she says in her sweetest voice, giving you a nuzzle on your nose.

"I love you, too...Squeaky Pie." You then hear that sound again, but this time, you didn't have to do anything, as you see Pinkie Pie giving you a cute, wide, closed-eyed smile. Not more than a few seconds later, Pinkie drops her head onto you, snuggling into your chest as she nuzzles your neck affectionately. It isn't long before the normally overly energetic party pony is fast asleep on top of you, tuckered out from everything you two have done tonight. You keep your arms wrapped tightly around your lover as you lay your head back, joining her in dreamland no too long afterwards.

THE END