Blowing Him Straight

by anonpony1

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Princess Cadance, Romance, Shining Armor, Sex, Alternate Universe
Length: 2344

Cadance walks in on Shining Armor making out with his boyfriend. She decides to turn her crush straight with a good blowjob.

Young Cadance had had a crush on Shining Armor for a while now, but sadly he is out of reach for her. He is not interested in mares at all and even has a boyfriend.

This night Cadance is at Shinings house again as so often to babysit his little sister Twilight. She was told no one else would be home – Shining Armor staying with his boyfriend for the night – but not everything turns out as planned.

Triggers: M/M-Kissing, F/M-Blowjob

(This story was written as a present for two friends. Don’t expect me to write something similar.)

Published 2015-11-07 23:00:02 UTC
Last updated 2015-11-07 23:00:02 UTC

Story

Cadance had just brought Twilight to bed. It always was really hard to get this filly to sleep, this time she had checked on her five times and every time Twilight had had a book hidden under her covers and secretly was reading, but now Cadance finally had time to relax.

She never took money to look after Twilight, because as a young princess she wanted to give something back to the ponies around her and she didn’t really have much else to do. Cadance still didn’t know what her job as a princess was after all.

Sure she was the princess of love, but what did a princess of love do? Equestria seemed to have been fine without a princess of love for several thousand years now. Princess Celestia managed everything pretty well on her own, so Cadance felt a bit useless as the second princess.

Being in her own mind thinking about what her purpose was she was sitting down on the family’s couch. She had brought a book, but was enjoying the silence of the moment way too much to read. Then there was a quiet thud upstairs.

With a groaned “Twilight” Cadance slowly got up again and went towards the stairs. Of course the filly still was reading instead of sleeping, but as she walked by Twilight's door there was another thud and it actually didn’t come from Twilight’s room. Instead it came from the next door, the room of Shining Armor – Twilight’s big brother.

Shining Armor was roughly the same age as Cadance, and Cadance had a huge crush on him, but to her dismay Shining wasn’t interested in her at all. He wasn’t interested in mares at all. That made things only worse for Cadance – gay stallions turned her really on. She always fantasized about seducing a gay stallion to make him straight, even though she knew that isn’t the way things work.

In this moment she didn’t spend much time daydreaming about that handsome gay stallion, though, instead she got a little bit scared. Shining Armor wasn’t supposed to be home. That’s why Cadance had to babysit Twilight.

As she slowly walked towards his door, she could hear more and more noise. It sounded like two ponies were in there. Maybe thieves? Cadance was a princess, and technically she could have defended herself, but she wasn’t very brave. She always got scared in situations like those.

Cadance slowly moved closer and closer to the door until she had her ear pressed firmly against it. That way the sounds from inside changed completely. Instead of a thief searching through cupboards she heard the squeaking of Shining’s bed and the moaning of two young stallions.

Was her unreachable crush home after all? His parent’s had told her he was with his boyfriend today, but maybe the two had sneaked into Shining’s room instead. Thinking about that, and hearing the moans from inside, Cadance got turned on.

She could feel a warmth rushing through her loins as her mind drew the picture of two young and very gay stallions making out with each other. Only moments later one of her front hooves was rubbing her then soaked marehood slowly. Hearing those moans from the other side of the door excited her so much she had to get more.

In a daring move Cadance slowly opened the door just enough for her to peek through. Beyond it was indeed Shining Armor. He was lying on his bed cuddling a unicorn stallion roughly the same age as he was. The two boys were in a deep kiss and moaned into each other's mouths while their tongues wrestled.

Cadance never could have imagined to watch her crush making out with another stallion. What she was seeing that moment – only a few feet away from her – was her biggest fantasy. She had spent so many lonely nights dreaming exactly of that.

As she could feel her thighs getting soaked from her arousal, she sped up her slow rubbing. Cadance imagined the stallions discovering her. In her mind they would keep making out and let her watch. Then Shining would fuck her while his boyfriend mounted him.

When she saw Shining slowly stroking his partner’s member the picture in front of Cadance became a blur. It got replaced with her fantasy of being involved – mounted by her crush.

Then she tripped.

Cadance couldn’t hold her balance and fell straight through the door – she landed right in front of Shining’s bed.

Nothing turned out the way she had fantasized though. Instead of inviting her to join, Shining Armor’s boyfriend gave out a startled high pitched scream and ran out through the door immediately – still with a glistening erection between his legs. He was so embarrassed his head looked like a giant tomato.

All Shining could do was to give a dumbfounded look and squeak a questioning off-tone “Cadance?”. He was looking at her with big eyes and his mouth agape, but nothing else came out of him.

Suddenly Cadance had a fit of inspiration. She was still soaking wet and in front of her was her big crush, still with a giant hard on from his gay make-out. Her decision was made and she stood up slowly and walked towards him.

Then with the best seductive voice she could manage and a deep look into his eyes she asked him, “Has your boyfriend ever sucked your cock, big boy?”

Shining Armor was still completely overwhelmed by this strange situation and just replied with a short almost whispered, “No.”

Without saying anything else Cadance sat down in front of Shining’s bed. She moved one hoof towards his hip and the other one landed on his thigh. Then it slowly moved up towards his still erect cock.

Cadance used her hoof to aim his prick at her face and kissed Shining’s tip sensually. Her lips continued to caress his gay meat and she could taste his precum entering her muzzle.

Shining Armor finally found his words again, but didn’t really know what to say, “Cadance, you-you’re really a nice mare, but-” His words were replaced with a surprised moan as Cadance licked along his whole length with her tongue once.

A short moment later Shining continued, “but I don’t like mares. I’m gaaaaay! Oh Celestia!” That moment Cadance had decided to take his tip into her muzzle and was now massaging it with her tongue.

Cadance was so nervous this moment. She never had given a blowjob to anypony before. She hadn’t even touched a real cock until now, but the hardest thing for her was to hide her excitement and look as sexy as possible and that really wasn’t easy with his intoxicating taste already filling her whole head and turning her on to the brim.

To do that she turned her head upwards and looked straight into Shining Armor’s eyes. Then the hoof she had used to hold his shaft slowly moved towards his balls. All the while she was flicking her tongue around his tip.

While slowly massaging Shining’s sensitive balls Cadance began to take more of his length into her muzzle. She let a bit of her saliva escape her lips to make it easier, and to make it look sexier for her gay crush.

Shining Armor was moaning and no longer protesting as Cadance slowly moved her head up again until only his tip was in her muzzle. After staying like that for a moment – deeply looking into his eyes all the time – she took his cook out of her mouth and licked along his shaft with her tongue.

The moment his whole length was glistening with her saliva she moved both of her hooves to his cock and took his tip into her mouth again. Then while stroking his shaft with her hooves she slowly bobbed her head up and down.

Even though Cadance intended to look like a slut to turn Shining Armor on, she was extremely turned on herself. This was the first time she ever had touched a real dick and the taste was intoxicating to her.

Without much attention she slowly moved one of her hooves stroking Shining’s glistening cock down to her own marehood. By now she was so worked up, the fur on both of her thighs was completely soaked by her juices.

Cadance continued bobbing her head on Shining’s cock for a while, but even though he was moaning all the time it didn’t seem to be enough to push him over. Cadance herself was only stroking her marehood enough to not cum herself – she didn’t want to interrupt the show she gave Shining for a sloppy orgasm.

Her goal was to make him cum – maybe he would leave his boyfriend for her then, but every time she tried to take his cock deeper it bumped against the back of her mouth. Her muzzle just wasn’t big enough to take his whole length!

Then she knew what she had to do.

Moving her head as far down as she could, Cadance tried to swallow when his tip again bumped against the back of her throat. At first she couldn’t manage to push his thick meat into her gullet, but then she pressed her head down even harder and forced it in. She was gagging really hard and making loud slurping noises, but she could feel his cock moving into her throat.

Her eyes began to tear up and she was gagging all the time, but Shining’s cock slowly moved down her tight throat until she could feel the fur of his belly against her nose. The rubbing between her haunches was frantic by now. Deep throating a cock was really painful for Cadance, but she never had experienced anything as hot as this ever before.

Looking up through her teary eyes, she could see that Shining’s mouth was agape. Apparently this finally evened out the way for his orgasm. Only a few more seconds of taking him down her throat and he would shoot his load, Cadance was sure of that.

To breath Cadance had to take his rod out of her throat every so often, but she never let it leave her muzzle. Everytime she swallowed it, she could feel it throbbing and slightly flaring, before it got back to it’s normal big size. She was sure he would cum any moment now.

Only seconds later Cadance could feel Shining Armor’s dick fully flare out in her throat. His massive meat completely cut off her air supply and she tried to get it out, but she didn’t manage to do it in time. The first shot of his hot seed was blown right into her belly.

Then she managed to pull his cock out with a forceful backwards jerk of her head – giving only more pleasure to her gay crush. While gasping for air another shot hit her muzzle. A moment later another one hit her mane. That moment Cadance came herself – Shining Armor still painting her entire head white.

After Shining's balls were finally emptied, Cadance’s face was completely covered in his spunk. There even were strands of white on and in her mane and dropping down from her horn. She only barely had managed to close her eyes in time – both of her lids were covered in his spunk.

Cadance was still playing her role – she just had to win Shining Armor over – so she licked across her face and tried to get as much sperm into her mouth as possible. The taste of it and how dirty she acted turned her on again. A moment later she used her hoof to get the goo off of her cheek and then licked it clean. Her other hoof was already rubbing her labia again.

Shining Armor was really indulged in this show, but then she began to lick his cock again. Her face wasn’t really clean yet, there was still cum in her mane and dripping from her horn and her whole coat was stained, but cleaning hadn’t been the point of licking it off.

Wanting to act like a good slut, she cleaned her gay boy’s tool with her mouth. When she was finished she almost came for the second time this night. Then Shining Armor finally found his words again, “Cadance. What have you done? You know I don’t like mares like that and I have a boyfriend!”

This was her final chance, she had to make it now or never, so she set up the most seductive tone she could handle and replied with half lidded eyes, “You seemed to enjoy yourself quite a lot, big boy. Maybe you should think about that boyfriend thing again? I’ll see you next friday for dinner in the castle.”

Then she turned around and walked towards the door without looking back once. Cadance made sure though to give Shining a good view of her flank with her hips swinging from side to side with every step she made and her tail covering less than it normally should.

Shining Armor was so baffled – and secretly turned on – by her response he again couldn’t find any words until the princess left his room and closed the door behind her.

Cadance on the other hoof was then standing right in front of his closed door – her heart had never been beating as hard as in this moment. What she had done was the most exciting thing in her whole live. It even felt more exciting than her own coronation.

Had she really won Shining Armor over? Would he show up for the date she forced on him?

From downstairs she could hear someone opening the front door, so she quickly trotted over to the family’s bathroom to wash her face before Mrs. Velvet or Mr. Light could see her stained face and mane.

Author's Note

And then they married. The End.