Poison Sweets

by MoonDiary

Rating: mature
Tags: Tragedy, Cake Twins, Mrs. Cake, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Alternate Universe, Thriller, Original Character, Rarity, Pinkie Pie
Length: 3200

Born a red and pick unicorn. Her Father (Remains Unknown) walked out and left Ponyville only when she was baby. And her mother "Pinkamena Diane Pie" raised her on her own. The rest is History to Read.

Written By me: MoonDiary A VampAlicorn

Born a red and pick unicorn. Sugar Sweetie Pie's Father (Remains Unknown) walked out and left Ponyville only when she was baby. And her mother "Pinkamena Diane Pie" raised her on her own. Everything was fun For Sugar, Till Her mother Passed away of an Illness. Leaving Sugar as just a young filly Not sent to mother mother's family on the rock farm, but forced into a Orphanage. The Rest is to come.

Published 2015-11-22 03:00:02 UTC
Last updated 2016-08-22 01:35:48 UTC

New home, New List

A week past and Sugar was getting abit lonely in the orphanage. she went around the house searching for something that maybe will help. She then came across a chest that happen to have a map of Equestria.
So she cleaned herself up, took the map, burned down the Orphanage and 400 bits and got on a train to ponyville.
Sugar got to ponyville in the evening from the train, and asked around for the building “Sugar cube Corner” she manage to get there and met Mrs.Cakes and her two pony twins Pound and Pumpkin Cake who looked older than Sugar.

Sugar told them about her and who she was and her mother. They let Sugar in with open arms and told Sugar about how they tried to take her in when they found out about her mother's death.

Sugar had a home to stay.

Each day she help Pound and Pumpkin cake make Cakes, pies, cookies, cupcakes, etc.

Sugar slowly was coming back to the fun her and her mother once had growing up.
Till one day, A Rich Stallion came into Sugar cube corner with his family is wife and his two spoiled fillies and teen colt.
Sugar welcomed them in with a smile but they gave Sugar an ugly mean glare.
Right then and there, Sugar had a feeling that this family of ponies seemed off... They didn't look nice. They looked..... rotten.

The Father Stallion walked over the Mrs.Cakes talking to her while Mrs. Cakes had her head down. The Bratty Phillies were making a mess and fussing and the Mother started talking down about Sugar Cube Corner, Sugar was about to tell them off, but Pound cake stopped her from saying anything. then the family left.

Sugar Rushed over to the crying Mrs.Cakes.

Turns out Sugar cube Corner was going to be run down due to not enough sells. Other ponies tried to help. not even Princess Twilight Sparkle couldn’t do anything. In her sad and depression, Sugar Sweet Pie cuddled in the room her mother had slept in. Sugar was upset to see others sad and being hurt by rotten ponies.
She then looked up and saw something in the corner of the room.
It was a piece of paper and a map.
A letter from Pinkie pie. Sugar’s Mother Pinkamena Diane Pie.

The note spoke of Pinkie slowly becoming depressed and soon making her work become a dark turn into killing other ponies… and making them into cupcakes. Also pinkie noted this to her child, Sugar. To know before Sugar was born, that Pinkamena began to kill other ponies and make them into sweets.

After reading, Sugar took the map and walked around till she reached a shed looking building, she walks in and see’s everything was dusty and abit rusty.

“no smell of blood fresh or old” Sugar thought.

Looking at everything in this shed, Sugar knew this place was meant for killing and torturing other ponies. Sugar thought long and hard about the situation with Sugar cub corner, helping Mrs.Cakes, and that Rotten Family.
At that moment, Sugar Sweet Pie knew what she had to do.
Follow in her mother’s foot steps.

Problem was, Sugar didn’t know how to get the ball rolling. She left the shed which happen to be deep within the Everfree Forest.
And made it back to see Pumpkin cake and Mrs.Cake walking to a building of Dresses.

Prepare

Sugar walked in and saw them trying on dresses. she walked up and asked whats with the dresses.

Then a very elegant voice said “Why it’s for the galloping gala my dear” It was none other than miss Rarity bringing in dresses for Pumpkin and Mrs.Cakes to try on, even had afew dresses for Sugar to try on. They paid for their dresses and left Rarity’s home and headed back to sugar cube corner.

In her room, Sugar Sweetie pie was pasting back and forth thinking very hard. “maybe things will turn around” she said “maybe that family had a bad day and is really caring family” talking to herself, she heard a noise outside. It seems that maybe Sugar was wrong about that family, the mother pony and her fillies came back before Sugar Cube Corner was closing.

By the time sugar got down stairs, the shop turned into a disaster. cakes were smashed and afew glasses were broken. Mrs. cakes then had a heart attack while the rotten pony mother was laughing about it. Pound and Pumpkin cakes ran to their mother Mrs.cakes and helped her. The rotten Pony and her Rotten phillies left Sugar cube Corner to its bad state. Pumpkin began to cry as they saw their mother passed out on the ground. That set Sugar Sweetie pie off and made her decision.

Follows in mommies hoof steps

A month has pass and the Galloping gala was a day away, Ms.Cakes was ok and everyone was getting reading for the gala while making lots and lots of cakes. Then, while everyone left and Sugar was left to watch the shop. She Decided to make afew cupcakes she’s been practicing baking for just a month. She called them “sweet dreams” a cupcake that will knock you out, and their apple flavored.

“Aren’t you just the Sweetest thing?” Sugar said with a wicked voice.

During the days after Mrs.Cakes was in the Hospital, Sugar went to the shed often to have everything ready for the night of the gala. and Surprisingly, the shad had a Kitchen to cook and bake. Sugar had found extra clean bowls and cooking utensils to be ready to use… and a bottle of poison. Sugar Sweetie Pie Began to smile and laugh very wickedly, for she was going to make a Sweet deal for the rotten family.

The next day turned to night and So Began The Galloping Gala. Mrs.Cakes, Pound and Pumpkin Cakes, and Sugar Sweetie Pie got to the gala along with the sweets. The night seems like a delightful party Sugar had thought, that is until the Rotten rich Ponies walked in. Sugar had to wait for her chance to strike. She knew it had to wait…. for now. As Sugar walked around serving cupcakes to Everypony, she overheard other ponies talking about the rotten family. Apparently, The Rotten wife was secretly having an affair. well dosent seem like a secret anymore. As soon as the fillies and teen colt were out of the rotten pony’s sight, she walked off and a minute later another pony followed. Sugar saw her opening Debut. She found a camera and started sneaking around spying on the rotten wife.
Comes to turn out another stallion were in the garden alone and well…. ““you know where this is going.”“

Sugar began to do her work, she wasn’t too grossed out, after all she killed the phillies in the Orphanage.
After the recording, sugar left back to the gala party.
She then bumped into the Rotten Stallion,
Sir Rum Fruit. Sugar gave him a smile.
He Grin at her.
Sugar then pulled out a cupcake, her cupcake “sweet dreams” Rum Fruit took a bite.
“Is this… apple flavor..?” He asked,
Sugar nodded “I love apples” said the Rotten stallion, He smiled and thanked her….. but as soon and he could go… he felt dizzy and then black out….. Sugar smile turned to a wicked grin. For her work had just begun.

Sugar took Rum fruit into a moving box.
Went to Mrs.Cakes and told her she was tired, so Sugar went home…..So she had them believe.
Sugar took the moving box and made it invisible with abit of magic she learn on her way to ponyville. then rolled the invisible moving box to the shed in the everfree forest.
The town was asleep so sugar had no problem being known. She locked the she and took off her gala dress and placed it somewhere safe from blood.
She put on a different outfit for this type of slaughter. She strapped up the sleeping stallion took out all her mother’s tools, All that was left was to wait for the Stallion to wake up.

The New Life of the Party

Within Minutes, Rum Fruit awaken from his slumber only to find himself tied down on a table with a ball gag in his mouth. Squirming and moving and trying to yell to get his way out, but it was no use.

“such a sweet sight you are”

A voice spoke softly in the dark.
Rum Fruit was trying to wonder where that voice came from. then out of the shadows came the young Sugar Sweetie Pie. Rum Fruit was shock to see her begging and pleading to get out.

“Sorry to bring you here but i need your help. you see, a rotten family came to my mother’s friend shop and ask for some cupcakes. I was raise to always make others smile with cupcakes….. problem is…. i don’t have the most super duper important Ingredient for my mother famous cupcakes…. well I didn’t have it at first, but now it do”

Sugar gave a very wicked giggle.

“So before we begin, there something you need to know before i make you into nice sweet rum cupcakes. Your wife that rotten pony who bare those soon to be bastard phillies of yours who destroyed Sugar cube corner and left Mrs.Cakes in a heart attack, She Sleeping with another Stallion, rumor travel fast. and there true. See?”

Sugar Showed Rum Fruit the Video of his wife messing around with another stallion.

“How tragic for you, much really feel unloved, or was that gone a long time ago? no matter. I dont care. your wife wants her cup cakes. lets make them together for the whole family”

With all that said, Sugar played some Opera and Began To Ripping, Stabbing, Peeling skin, Torturing every bit by bit on Rum Fruit as he screams through the ball gag, Sadly for him no one care hear him. Blood splattered everywhere as Sugar cuts open Rum Fruit by his sides and his stomach. Sugar’s eyes was pink and blank, the same look as her mother.

Sugar than took Rum’s skin and his body meat and place them in a metal bowl. she Worked her way up to his eyes and pulled one out. oh the Curdling blood Scream he shouted out for pain.
Sugar took all the small organs and began to making her mother cupcakes. But somehow,
Rum fruit got lose and hit Sugar in the back of her head five times. Leaving her on the floor and in shock, Rum Fruit then found a way to escape the shed.

He then became lost in the Everfree forest. Holding his body, he tried to find a lead to ponyville. He felt like he has been wandering in circles aimlessly.
Then he heard singing. His heart began to beat fast, for he knew it was sugar, Singing a song that sends chills up anyone’s spine

~“Come on every pony, Smile Smile Smile. Fill my heart up with Sunshine sunshine. All I really needs a Smile Smile Smile, From these Happy Friends of Mine"~

Rum Fruit Started running while coughing up blood. Through trees, and bushes, Rum fruit caught a glimpse of Ponyville. He takes another step and his hoove lands on a bear trap. He lets out a yell in pain. He struggles to get out of the trap….. but then he looks up…. Sugar was standing right in front of him.

“I.Found.You” She said with a Soft and wicked voice.

Before Rum Fruit Could scream, Sugar knocked him out. That was the last of Rum Fruit.

Meanwhile, The Rotten Wife and her kids, the two Fillies and teen colt were looking for Rum fruit.

Mrs.Cakes, Pound and Pumpkins Cakes got home and found Sugar in her mother bed asleep and the gala dress in the closet.

The Sweetest Thing

Three months have past, the search for Rum Fruit was called off after the search that was a no go. Sugar had got away with murder, and was ready for the final step. She took Rum’s frozen meat and organ’s and baked cupcakes.

The rotten family lived in Canterlot. so she had the box of cupcakes ship to their home. Along with a copy of the recorded tape.

News went around that the Wife Passion Fruit was recorded with another Stallion, Sugar went with some cupcakes to show “sympathy” to the family.

She got there and was let in the house to speak with Passion Fruit. her Phillies and colt “Strawberry & Blueberry Fruit” and “Tender Fruit” Sugar was talking with Passion Fruit and mention the disappearance of her husband Rum Fruit as the family but Tender Fruit was eating the cupcakes. Tender fruit left the house right As Sugar arrived.

As Sugar was talking to passion Fruit,

”I seen him at the gala that night, he seem to have a sweet tooth for young Phillies”

Passion fruit looked away in disgust as Sugar mention of Rum fruit.

“He loved apples, so i made apple cupcakes for you all… but that’s not why i am here. I’m here to ask that you sign this so Sugar cub corner stays up and running” Sugar pulls out a contract paper.

“And if i don’t?” Passion Fruit said.

“Well then you and your Phillies will die, the cupcakes your eating are my special. Poison Sweets. Sign this and I will give you the antidote for the poison so you and you bratty fillies can live. or die slowly.”

After what sugar said, Passion chuckled abit… but then saw her Phillies coughing.

“Clocks ticking Mrs. Fruit, what will it be?” Sugar said with a calm voice.

Passion Fruit began to feel weird as well. Her eyes Widen and she began coughing. She saw the paper and sign the contract using her horn magic and gave it back to Sugar Sweetie Pie.

Sugar took the contract and and gave Passion fruit the Antidote that looked like red liquid. She then Drunk the antidote and gave some to her Phillies.

“Are you insane?!?” Passion fruit yelled.

Sugar slowly began to smile

“Why are you smiling you little tramp?!?!” Sugar looked up

“why?” Sugar asked “oh…. thats why, Four reasons why”

“1: Do you remember eating some rum cupcakes a few weeks ago….? I hope he was as good as he looks. he seemed to have a sweet tooth” Sugar gave a wicked grin as Passion fruit slowly realize that sugar killed her husband, and worst she made him into cupcakes and she remembers her Phillies and her teen colt eating the cupcakes.

“2: There is no antidote, what I gave you was a mix of some funny medicine and your husbands blood. With you moving around alot, the poison is working its way into you, and so is your phillies” Passion fruit then began to feel weak and sick.
She stared coughing up blood and saw her fillies coughing blood and crying.

“3: Don’t worry about your son Tender fruit, he will make a sweet treat for everypony to enjoy.” As passion Fruit is on the group gasping for air she noticed her phillies are already dead.

“As for number 4″ Sugar said as she makes her way to the back door

“You fucked with Mrs.cakes, You fucked with me. Never..Fuck..With Miss Poison Sweets”

Sugar turned around and placed a sleeping stallion on the floor next to Passion fruit. It was her lover she was having an affair with. To make it seem he was the one who killed the rotten fruit family and murdered the husband. Sugar Sweetie Pie walked out with a grin while using invisible magic on her way home.

Word went around that the a stallion who was Passion Fruits lover came in and poisoned the Fruit family and the son “Tender fruit” came back home and saw The stallion holding passion fruit in his arms. the guards took him in and went to Sugar cube corner and talk with Sugar. Sugar told the guards she left when the stallion showed up with the obsessed look on his face.

The guards couldn’t find any the thing so the left Sugar alone.

Sugar got away with another sweet and deadly murder

Sugar grew to have this demon within her. Her Mother Pinkamena Diane Pie. Sugar didnt mind it, as long as she was with her mother through spirit.

years have pasted and it seems certain ponies were disappearing and they all have done wrong. Families complain of an unknown baker sending sweets. some sweets were filled with blood and guts, others were blood and poison.

And So begun the Scare of All Equestria, The Sweet mad Serial Killer

Poison Sweet

“Aren’t you Just the Sweetest Thing”

Little Pitch of Sugar

Sugar always loved her mothers sweet cupckakes. So she wanted to learn to make the sweet cupcakes her mother made.
She was doing well her age, but a last she was missing one ingredient……she couldn’t find the same recipe her mother have made. and she couldn’t ask her mother for "Pinkamena Diane Pie" have past away. She died when sugar was a philly. With no one to take her in, Sugar was sent to an Orphanage.
Sugar was bullied, but kept her head high and Smiled like her mother have told her when in dangerous times…….
One day sugar was wanting to bake cupcakes and more sweets for maybe the other fillies and colts will enjoy and maybe become friends.. but the other fillies began to push her around.
They took poor sugar and dropped 2 hot irons on her flank.The adult ponies wouldn’t even help, they just laughed and to make things worst, they destroyed her cupcakes…. all the laughter…. and memories….. Shattered….. And so came a Wicked loud Scream… and black out…….

Two hours later Sugar awoke from her black out. 4 fillies and 2 colts were alive and had terrified looks on their faces. Sugar looked down and saw blood on the floor, on her hooves, all over the walls, and a knife in front of her…. before she could let out a screams, she smelled a familiar scent. She slowly turned around and saw a cupcake covered in blood.

She couldn’t help but put up the bloody cupcake and slowly took a bite… something…clicked… Sugar realized what she was missing. what her mother Pinkamena Diane Pie have use to make her cupcakes.

Blood of another Pony. Sugar didn’t even know how to feel, She did know she needed to get started and making more of her mothers cupcakes. But she needed fresh blood… no more then that. Sugar Sweetie Pie needed to make cupcakes out of Ponies Flesh and blood. and maybe organs as well. Then She noticed the 4 phillies and 2 colts in the corner. She knew what she had to do…….
She killed all of them, cut them up and made their organs into cupcakes, cookies, cake, and many other sweets. the sweets were just as her mother made… abit too sweet but she loved it.