My Little Pony: Sisterly Convergence

Chapter 11

Several days later, after the two sisters were nearly caught making love to one another, the two were currently lying in bed together like they usually did ever since they first became a couple. During the gap between then and now the two were almost caught a few more times, one was where Twilight came for a visit and nearly saw them kissing and another time was when Cadance and Shining Armor arrived. Luckily their niece managed to get him away before he could see the using their horns to penetrate each other.

But despite many close calls they’ve gotten, the two were still very much in love and currently snuggled up together in a cute manner. They both remembered to lock the door this time, so that nopony could enter without their say so.

At the moment, Celestia was currently staring up at the ceiling with a love sick look on her face. She began to think of what else the future had in store for them both, she even considered actually getting married like Cadance suggested, having a baby, creating a family and coming out to their subjects.

However, deep down she knew that they couldn’t and that those thoughts would never come to be, as their subjects would probably never accept them if they knew the truth…

She then heard a yawn and was surprised to see it coming from her sister.

“Oh! Luna! I did not know you had awoken,” she said. “I’m sorry if I disturbed your slumber in some way.”

“No, it’s alright sister, I just woke up on my own…” Princess Luna assured her as she turned to her sister and smiled at her fondly.

Celestia returned the smile, feeling relieved. “Good…”

“So… I see you were deep in thought.” Her younger sister observed.

“Uh… oh… yes…” Celestia confessed with a sigh.

“What about?” Luna inquired, curiously.

Celestia paused before speaking. “Our future…”

Luna was a bit surprised by this, but also understanding. “Oh… interesting… as was I.”

“Oh?”

“Yes… specifically… about the times… we were almost caught…”

“Ah, yes, they were indeed very close… but we managed to not draw any suspicion.”

“Maybe… but I fear that we may have just been lucky.”

“Luna…” Celestia breathed, as she stared at her sister, who had a somber look, sympathetically.

“And it’s been happening more and more often lately… pretty soon somepony other than Cadance is going to find out and it will be the end for us both.” The Princess of the Night stated.

“That will never happen, Luna.” Celestia told her sister, seriously as she cupped her face with her hoof. “I won’t let them.”

Luna looked into her eyes seriously and unconvinced. She entangled herself from her sister and got out of the bed hastily.

“Luna?” Celestia said, surprised and confused. “Where are you going, sweetie?”

“I am returning to my room, before any guards show up to wake you.” Princess Luna stated, firmly as she got her crown and other accessories back on.

“You don’t have to. Surely you can stay just a little longer.” Princess Celestia tried to urge her.

“No. I’m going back to my room, end of discussion.” Her younger sister said very firmly as she magically opened up the doors and began to step out.

“Luna…” The elder sister began to say before Luna closed the doors behind her, leaving Celestia baffled and concerned by her sister’s behavior. “Oh dear…”

While her big sister continued to try and figure out why she was behaving in such a manner, the Princess of the Night continued to trot down the hallway quickly and with purpose. As she went down another hallway, she passed a few guards that were still standing at their stations and managed to overhear them whispering about something behind her back. She made she not to let them know she was listening as she walked and listened carefully.

“So, did you also hear about the time when Sky Flier saw Princess Luna’s rump bright red?” One of them said, making Luna freeze and let out a small gasp.

She knew that day. That was the day of the parade where she had the stupid idea to tease her sister out in the open and in retaliation Celestia playfully spanked her before they began to make love again. They were almost caught in the again that day, and this time by the castle guards and not some senile old pony they could trick. Luna then decided to keep listening.

“Yeah… what do you think did that?”

“I hear Princess Celestia spanked her.”

“Really?”

“Yeah!”

“Huh, I heard that she had gotten a rash or a sunburn that day…”

“Heh, oh I’ll bet got a ‘sunburn’ alright.” The guard joked. The two of them laughed until they caught the sight of Luna giving them both a death glare and resumed looking stoic as they usually were. Luna then resumed walking down the hallway and thinking while the sun’s rays shined through the open windows, indicating that Celestia had begun raising the sun as usual.

“Oh sister… I do love you, but what if somepony does find out about us? I know she thinks that she can prevent such a thing from occurring but…” Luna thought with a sad expression. Her thoughts stopped for a while as soon as a certain memory of a dream she had flashed in her mind. A dream involving she and her sister being caught in the act and spanked in front of their subjects. “This dream I keep having… what if it comes true? What would we do then? Celestia would probably try to take all the blame for it in order to save me… I can’t let that happen!”

As she thought this a determined look then appeared on her face while her eyes narrowed. She knew what she had to do next and what she had to say to her sister, and it would not be pleasant for either of them…

It soon came time for breakfast and like always, things were already set up for the two of them and Luna was already at the table, waiting for her sister. However, she had not touched any of her food and instead stared at it with a sad look on her face. She was so lost in thought in fact that she barely even registered her own sister/lover entering the kitchen as well.

“Hello, my love.” Celestia said, sweetly. She did not seem to notice her sister’s certain state of mood.

“Hello.” Luna responded, apathetically. That was when Celestia saw how sad her sister looked.

“Luna? What is wrong? You’re not eating.” Celestia observed, concerned.

“I’m fine…” The younger sister said, glancing away.

Celestia looked at her little sister sternly. “Luna. You’re not fooling me, I know something is on your mind and troubling you so why don’t you tell me?”

“I said I’m fine.” Princess Luna insisted, only more firmly as she gave her sister a look. A look that just screamed ‘Don’t ask me again’.

“Please Luna, talk to me… don’t make me have to enter your mind.” Princess Celestia warned her.

“You promised me that you would never do that.” Princess Luna said, with quiet anger.

“But I should have 1000 years ago, then I might have been able to help you better. And ever since you came back I’ve never had another reason to read your mind to know what you were thinking… until now.” Celestia told her. “Now… tell me what’s wrong.”

Luna sighed in defeat, not wanting to be angry with or argue with her sister any further. “Alright… it’s about… us,” she revealed.

“Us?” Celestia echoed, both surprised and confused.

“Yes… I keep getting these… thoughts in my head…”

“What kind of thoughts?”

“Bad ones…”

Celestia raised a brow. “Oh?”

“Yes… where you and I are discovered and… humiliated and disgraced before our subjects…” Luna revealed, shivering at the thought.

“Luna… I told you; I won’t let that happen.” Celestia told her, firmly.

“Yes, but what if it did!?” Luna exclaimed. “What if one day we get too reckless and end up exposed? And what if it’s my fault!? I can’t let that happen!”

“It won’t!” Celestia insisted.

“You don’t know that!” Luna shot back.

“Luna… we can’t keep fearing what might happen.” The Princess of the Sun said. “Ask yourself; is what you said a thought… or a fact?”

Luna lowered her head, unable to come up with an answer for a while until finally… “You may be right… maybe I am confusing a thought with a fact… but still… the danger of us staying together, especially with all the things the guards have said, is too great.”

“What are you saying, sister?” Princess Celestia asked, fear beginning to fill her voice.

Luna pushed away her plate, got out of her seat and began to turn away. “I am saying that we are done. Goodbye, sister.”

As her sister began to trot away and out of the kitchen, Celestia continued to sit where she was with a slack jaw and wide eyes, obviously shocked by what she had just heard and it seemed to be taking a while for it to sink it. When it finally did sink it, Celestia was soon full of sadness and confusion.

“Luna! Luna, wait!” she cried out as she got out of her seat and began to gallop after her younger sister. Eventually she used a teleportation spell and appeared in front of her sister in the middle of the hallway. “Luna, what do mean by ‘we’re done’!?”

“I am saying that I am ending our incestuous relationship sister, that is all, end of discussion,” Luna stated, firmly.

“But… but why Luna…!?” Celestia questioned, distraught.

“I have already told you the reason why.” Princess Luna told her sister. “Continuing this relationship now is growing far too dangerous and we must stop before somepony sees and exposes us.”

“And I already told you that I wouldn’t let that happen!” Princess Celestia exclaimed, upset.

“I cannot take that risk, this is not just for my safety but for yours as well.” The Princess of the Night said. “Now, please let us stop before this gets any more difficult.”

Luna turned and attempted to walk away once again but she stopped as soon as her sister raised her voice at her.

“As if this isn’t difficult enough already!? Don’t forget; your the one breaking up with me, not the other way around.” Celestia stated, frowning.

Luna turned to her again. “Yes, I know, you the one being… as the more modern ponies of this age call… dumped,” she acknowledged. “And I realize that the one on the receiving end of the break up is usually the one in the most amount of pain but let me assure you that this is as much painful for me as it is for you.”

Celestia continued to glare at her sister’s still seemingly calm and cold face. “Somehow I find that very hard to believe.”

“Trust me when I say it is the truth.” Luna assured her.

“Then why are you…” The Day Princess began, her voice beginning to crack up.

“Because…” Luna started to say as she turned her head, refusing to meet her sister’s heartbroken gaze. “I love you too much to risk something happening to you and I’m sure you feel the same way about me but if you won’t end this relationship then I will.”

Tears began to form in Celestia’s eyes. “Luna…”

“From now on we are nothing more then co-rulers of Equestria and sisters, they way we’re supposed to be and not in love, not anymore.” Princess Luna said once more in a firm tone before she used a teleportation spell and vanished leaving her sister alone to cry in the middle of the hallway.

When Luna finally arrived back in her bed chambers, at first she seemed calm, cool and collected like she was not to long ago but in just a few short seconds tears began to flow down her face. She sobbed softly at first but it soon became louder as she threw herself on her bed and continued to cry, devastated by what she had to do.