Hearts and Hooves Day

by Lonkey_M_Duffy

Rating: everyone
Tags: Fluttershy, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Other, Romance, Second Person
Length: 1369

Anon finds himself alone on Hearts and Hooves Day until he is visited by a shy, yellow mare.

During a harsh Winter storm on Hearts and Hooves Day, Anon finds himself alone until a knock on the door from his admirer, Fluttershy, changes his night for the better. The two are able to really get to know each other which may help blossom something in the future.

Published 2016-01-03 01:20:02 UTC
Last updated 2016-01-03 01:20:02 UTC

Hearts and Hooves Day

The howling of cold wind against your house sounds throughout your living room. You look out your window at the white blanket that covers the atmosphere and the ponies that are out walking about with their significant others.

"Jesus, its crazy out there, what are those ponies thinking?"

Taking a sip of the sweet, chocolaty liquid that fills your cup, you go to sit by the fire that crackles and gives the room a more, warm and welcoming feeling. Staring deep into the fire you remember that today is Valentine’s Day, well Hearts and Hooves day as everyone else here called it. And just like on Earth, you're alone for this romantic holiday. A feeling of loneliness washes over your mind. You begin to listen for something, anything, as if you were waiting for someone, or something to speak. But the only noises are the icy wind howling and the hot fire crackling. You look out your window again.

"Man, it's really picked up out there." You say with slight concern

Anypony that was outside, is now gone, in their homes to stay warm from the cold elements. As you go to take another sip, you realize you've finished your drink. With a disgruntled groan you get up to refill your cup. A knock on the door pauses your journey to the kitchen midway.

"Who could possibly outside in this weather?" You ask while opening your door.

There stands a shivering Fluttershy wearing only a hat and scarf. She's got a satchel that seems to be full of something, what it is you're not sure.

"H-h-hey An-non c-can I come in?" She says through chattering teeth.

"Of course of course, please come in." You step aside to let the nearly frozen mare in.You go to fetch her a blanket.

"Jesus Shy what were you thinking of coming out in the weather?" You ask wrapping the towel around her shivering body.

"I-I came to s-see you." She says hiding behind her mane.

You give her a surprised look. "Why's that?"

"W-well, I know you don't have a special somepony to spend Hearts and Hooves Day with, so I thought we could spend it together." She pulls out chocolate in a heart shaped box and a bottle of wine.

"Fluttershy.... I don't know what to say." You quietly say while looking at the chocolates and wine.

"I-It's fine if you don't want to." She says lowering her head, bracing herself for rejection.

"Don't be ridiculous, this is great!" You say hugging her and giving her a warm smile.

"R-Really?" She shoots her head up with a blush forming on her face.

"Yes! I was hating the thought of being alone today, and it's great to have company."

Fluttershy wraps her arms around your neck and nuzzles her face into your chest.

"Here, I'll go fix us something to eat while you pop open some of that wine."

"That sounds lovely Anon, thank you."

You get up to go to the kitchen. You pull out the ingredients to make your world famous, pasta. There's nothing famous about it, but you make some pretty damn good pasta. The familiar pop of a cork leaving the bottle breaks the silent room.

"Anon where you you keep your wine glasses?" Fluttershy asks from the other room.

"In here." You say opening a cabinet and getting out two wine glasses.

Fluttershy flutters in and gently pours two glasses.

"Thank you very much Flutters."

You stop your cooking to look at her.

"Here's to being single on Hearts and Hooves Day." You say raising your glass.

The mare giggles and raises her glass. The two of you tap the rims of your glasses together to make a clink noise. As you prepare the meal, you and Fluttershy talk. Fond memories are brought up of your time on Earth and of your time on Equestria. She tells you of her younger years as a school filly and all the shenanigans her and Dash got into. She sits on your couch while you sit on your floor right beside her.

"Hahaha, you actually thought it'd be a good idea to say the class pet ate the pie instead of Rainbow?" You ask while laughing at her story form her younger years.

"The best part was Rainbow Dash had pie filling and whipped cream all over her face." She finishes while you both laugh.

The timer goes off in the kitchen.

"Oh dinner's ready, you hungry?"

"Oh yes, that pie story kind of got my tummy rumbling." Fluttershy says while holding her stomach.

"Haha okay it'll be ready in a minute, go sit down at the table."

She complies and sits at the table waiting for the meal. You come out with two plates of spaghetti ad garlic bread.

"Oh Anon, it looks so good."

“Well don't just look at it, dig in!" You say plunging your fork into the pasta.

With that the two of you chow down on the meal. You drink some more, and more stories are shared. By the time the meal is finished, the two of you are a little tipsy. You clean up the dishes and sit by the fire with Fluttershy cuddled next to you. The warmth of the mare snuggled into you fills you with a feeling of happiness.

'Without her here, today would have sucked.' The thought circles your brain.

"H-hey Anon, thanks."

Look down to see a pair of teal eyes looking into yours.

"For what?"

"Showing me such a great time."

"I have to be the one saying thanks, if you didn't show up I'd just be sitting here grumpy."

"However, it is getting late, let me walk you home."

Fluttershy gives a disappointing sigh that the good time had to end, but rises from the couch with you. Grab your coat on and open the door. A powerful blast of cold wind flings the door open letting snow in. Struggle to shut the door before your home becomes the Arctic.

"...How do you feel about sleep overs?" You ask as a loud wind howls, blowing more snow all over.

The Pegasus shows excitement in her voice.

"OH I'D LOVE TO!" She exclaims loudly.

A hue of red crosses her cheeks.

"Haha I've never seen you like that before Flutters, but I like the enthusiasm."

"I don't have a guest room with a bed, so I can sleep on the couch while you take my bed."

"O-oh I w-was wondering i-if I could..." The shy mare begins to mumble.

"I'm sorry what? I can't hear you." You say teasing the mare.

"I-I was wondering i-if I-I could sleep with y-you?" She says hiding under her hooves.

"Wow that wine really makes you more forward, huh?"

A smirk comes across your face.

"Yeah alright, besides it gets cold in here when the fire dies out." You tell Fluttershy.

You pickup Fluttershy who is still covering her face and head up to your bed. She uncovers her face and looks to you with a smile of pure happiness. You reach your room and gently place her on your bed while you go into the bathroom to change into your pajamas. You come out only wearing pajama bottoms.

"I don't really like sleeping with a shirt on, is this going to bother you?"

A deep red covers her face. "O-Oh no, I don't mind r-really."

Hop into bed with her and cuddle up. She faces you. Her brilliant teal eyes make your heart melt.The only thing you can hear is each other’s breathing with the smell of wine lingering in your breaths.

"Hey Fluttershy?"

"Y-yes Anon?"

Your lips connect with hers. You can see that she's shocked, but calms down and kisses you back. Once the lock your lips have placed is broken she looks to you once more.

"Happy Hearts and Hooves Day Anon."

You smile at her and give her one more kiss before the two of you drift off in each other’s sweet embrace.

END

Author's Note

This was a story I wrote a while ago I figure you can enjoy it while I work on the second part of Dream Girl.