!

Loud sobbing came from Pinkie Pie dressed as a chicken as she is crawling away from, Moon having a complete mental breakdown. Her face is completely an utterly terrified of Moon, who had unleashed her nightmare powers on her. Causing her to fall asleep where Moon dragged her into a dark dream world that felt so real that, Pinkie couldn’t tell it wasn’t real. Forcing her to live out one nightmare after another, of her being eaten alive, living cakes and candy ripping her to pieces, and other horrors. All having her being killed and waking up again just for it to happen again.

“Moon, isn’t that a bit too much?” Twilight as Star Swirl asked as she and the other ponies at the Nightmare Night stared in horror of what just happen to Pinkie Pie.

Pinkie Pie is huddled into a ball rocking herself, crying for her moms as she doesn't know if this is just another nightmare. She has woken up to find her back in the real world, only for it to turn into a nightmare. The ponies around her opening their jaws revealing sharp teeth and piling on top of her biting off chunks of her flesh. Other times they toss her into a big pot of boiling water and cook her alive. Or they grab her limbs and rip her apart.

“Let’s see, all night she’s been pretending to be scared and freak out just because she thought it be fun to do that. While never making it clear it’s just an act, thinking that I will just agree with it without making things clear first. The only way she can learn is by me doing this to her, mind raping her where she’s trap in a nightmare where, I cut off her fingers one by one with a dull knife, asking her if she thinks it’s fun to be trolling me and Luna,” Moon said.

“Yup, real dumb,” Sunset said who is dressed as Oscar the grouch. Which is her wearing a large metal trash can and wearing the lid on her head. Which she turtles herself into now and then, to keep herself from being pulled into any orgy that she didn’t want to get caught up in.

“Sunset,” Twilight said.

“Don’t give me that. Pinkie Pie is the dumb one, who does things that are only fun for her. Which is why I keep responding with hurting her, as that’s the only way she can learn. Like this Nightmare Night, I asked her to help me out in the planning, but she ended up taking over the planning and making it her own thing while never telling me anything, till I force her to tell me. All I wanted from her was some help with what, I had already but she wanted it her way and start all over, which is why I kicked her off the planning. As she’s horrible at explaining things and working with others if it's not her way,” Sunset said.

“She isn’t that bad,” the Cakes said who are dressed up as rag dolls.

“The reason why she listens to you is that you pay her and she lives with you,” Sunset points out. “Besides, I told her to not ruin the night for my aunts, after the first time she made a big scene. But she kept on doing it even after, I made it clear it’s upsetting my aunts. Like saying no to something but she just does it anyways.”

“And her punishment is what allows the human holiday of Halloween replace Nightmare Night,” Luna said who had canceled Nightmare Night as a holiday, because of Pinkie Pie.

“It’s basically the same thing but without my aunts as the big monsters,” Sunset said as she looks down at the sobbing form of Pinkie Pie. “So want to be scared?”

“Nononono,” Pinkie Pie wailed as she stumbles onto her feet, her face covered in tears as she ran away sobbing. She run into the Cake's bakery and ran into her room where she barricaded her door. (1)

“I think you completely ruined anything scary for Pinkie Pie,” Rainbow said who is dressed as a Shadowbolt and been using lightning to scare ponies all night. And is in stocks having been put there by Sunset who didn’t like Rainbow doing that when Luna was talking with Pinkie, making her cause a big scene that scared the young ponies.

“Good,” Sunset said. “I don’t need her. She's completely useless to me. All she does is play around when it's not time to have fun. She talks alot about what she wants but plays around instead of laying down what needs to be done first. Or in my case makes sure, I'm ok with her plan first and when I say no to something, it doesn't mean just do it and think, I'll be ok in doing it.”

“She is the element of Laughter. She likes making people happy and have them have a good laugh,” Applejack said who is dressed as a scarecrow.

“Well, I find it funny when she’s on the ground crying and in pain. So, she’s doing her job, by making me feel happy as she’s completely humiliated and has been broken to the point where she’s sobbing as she breaks down,” Sunset said causing all the towns ponies to stare at her. “Besides she did ruin my aunts first and only Nightmare Night. She caused my aunts to cancel that holiday forever, for all of Equestria, after this night Nightmare Night will never be celebrated again. You are all just lucky that a human holiday of Halloween is just like it.”

“She has a point there,” Zecora said who is dressed as a witch doctor.

Causing the ponies in the crowd to nod as Pinkie Pie caused a beloved holiday to be canceled forever.

“So how do you celebrate Halloween?” Rarity asked dressed as a princess.

“You go door to door dressed up in a costume and say Trick or Treat and the people inside give you candy,” Sunset said.

“Wait that’s what we already do,” Trixie said who is dressed as a bear.

“Yup but with no Nightmare anything as an evil spirit that eats fillies,” Sunset said.

“Good, keep it that way,” Luna said.

“Well there is Skeleton Jack the Pumpkin King. He and the other monsters of Halloween Town, make the holiday nice and scary but always make sure it’s all in good fun and unlike Pinkie Pie never do things without making sure others know it’s all in good fun,” Sunset said thinking of the film Nightmare Before Christmas.

“I like it already. Tell us more,” Moon said.

The ponies of Ponyvile gathered around Sunset as she told them all about Halloween and the monsters of Halloween Town. And how to setup a haunted house where you can be scared but know it’s just fake. As not telling someone of things before hand, can ruin things. (2)

!

Author's Note

1 - Yeah with how Pinkie was never punished or called out for all the things she did. Which wasn’t funny at all and caused Luna to cancel the holiday. Is why I wrote her being more scared of things that are scary then Fluttershy after being mind raped by Moon, using nightmares where she’s tortured and killed in her dreams.

And no there is no Nightmare on Elm Street thing, where if you die in your dreams you die for real.

2 - Pulling off pranks where you scare people is only fun till you scare someone who thinks it’s real or get hurt. Have a safe Halloween and think out what you’re going to do before hand. You wouldn’t want to be sued or have the cops called on you.