Chomping at the Bit

The sun disappeared below the mountains west of Ponyville as Rarity and Fluttershy left the spa. Luna’s moon already shone prominently even though the sky was still on fire as the sun’s last light gleamed from the clouds, casting an orange hue to the valley. The streets of Ponyville were quiet; further down the street, the silhouette of a shop owner could be seen closing up shop after a long day. The shops typically extended their hours in the summer as the days grew longer.

The duo paused for a moment as they gave their eyes a chance to adjust to the waning light. Rarity leaned forward and bowed towards the ground, reaching out with her front hoofs as she stretched her muscles. She gently pawed at the ground as she closed her eyes and let out a quiet whinny as she indulged herself in the stretch. Fluttershy watched Rarity and slowly flapped her wings a couple times to limber up.

The remainder of the spa date had been quiet. Neither of them had said much since they confessed their love for one other in the mud bath. But, there had been a lot of cuddling and some more kissing. Fluttershy blushed as she remembered what had just happened. As Rarity finished her stretch, Fluttershy broke the silence, “So, Rarity, would you… maybe like to come over for some tea or something?”. She was still somewhat apprehensive to express herself fully even though everything went perfectly at the spa.

“That sounds lovely, dear. But, do I really have to choose between tea and whatever that ‘something’ is?”, she said coyly.

Fluttershy took the hint. “Well that depends. Let’s see how well you behave on the way back.” Fluttershy started walking back home and beckoned for Rarity to follow her. Rarity eagerly trotted up to her, slowing down to match Fluttershy’s gait. Fluttershy could not believe how the evening was unfolding as Rarity caught up to her. Everything was going according to plan; it seemed that Rainbow Dash was right after all and there was actually nothing for her to worry about. Fluttershy decided to push the envelope a little as the two made their way to Fluttershy’s cottage. As they were walking, Fluttershy said, “Now did I say to walk right along side me? Be a good girl and stay a pace or two back until I tell you otherwise.”

“Yes, darling!” Rarity said with a smile on her face. She slowed down and dropped back a couple feet.

“Darling? Oh no, that won’t do at all.” Fluttershy’s confidence was growing, “From now on, I want you to refer to me as… Mistress.” Fluttershy angled her head a little to side as she reflected on the last word. It had never occurred to her that she would ever actually be called that outside of her fantasies. She liked it.

“Yes, dar-”, Rarity corrected herself, “I mean, Mistress.”. Rarity was delighted; she was living out her deepest fantasies with a pony whom she fully trusted. She adored the power exchange that was occurring and felt herself craving more and more to be controlled. The faculties of her imagination did not prepare her for how intense the emotions would be now that her were fantasies becoming reality.

“Good girl.”, Fluttershy looked back to make sure Rarity was still okay. Fluttershy’s gaze lingered for a moment on Rarity.

“Yes… Mistress?” Rarity’s voice had become noticeably quieter and less assertive.

“Oh, nothing. I was just thinking that… Well, since you have a new name for me, it’s only fair that I should have one for you, too, right?”

Rarity blushed at the thought of Fluttershy giving her some kind of humiliating pet name, but she did not object. Fluttershy seemed to pick up on this.

“Well, I’ll take it you want one then.”, Fluttershy quietly laughed to herself as she considered the possibilities. “Let me see here.”, Fluttershy paused for a moment, “Yes, I think this one will do just fine. Jewel. I shall call you Jewel.”

Rarity pouted, “Like some kind of Las Pegasus stripper!?”

“Exactly!”, responded Fluttershy. “Do you object?”

Rarity drew in a breath and replied, “No, Mistress.” Rarity had always considered herself to be the pinnacle of sophistication, but she just could not resist Fluttershy’s charm. Everything she said just made her want to melt, to submit to her, to become her pet with a name like a Las Pegasus stripper. Rarity released her ego for the night and decided to surrender herself to the emotions she had denied  herself for so long. She let silence consume her after acknowledging her Mistress.

“I didn’t think you would.” Fluttershy said as her and Rarity approached the cottage. Although Fluttershy was playing it cool on the outside, it took all her focus to keep her from screaming, “Oh my gosh! Oh my gosh! Oh my gosh! I can’t believe that this is actually happening!”

When they reached the door, Fluttershy turned to face Rarity. She balanced herself on her hind legs and wrapped her hoofs around Rarity. One hoof rested at the base of Rarity’s neck supporting Fluttershy while the other drew Rarity’s head in towards her own. Without hesitating, Fluttershy landed a big kiss on Rarity.

“Thanks, Jewel.” And as quickly as Fluttershy had propped herself on Rarity, she was already back on all fours opening the door to her home.

Rarity was in awe, trembling as she tried to process what was happening. She loved seeing this side of Fluttershy. It was the side of her that had always been there, the side of her that was never afraid to take what it wanted. She felt used and she enjoyed it. Rarity quickly realised that her thirst to be dominated only grew as Fluttershy continued treat Rarity as her toy, her pet.

As they entered the cottage, Fluttershy instructed Rarity to sit down in the living room. Fluttershy quickly set the carrots she bought earlier on the kitchen counter and then went upstairs with her saddlebag. Once upstairs, she went to her closet and set her saddlebag down. She opened the top drawer of the chest of drawers in the closet that was reserved exclusively for her toys. She had been acquiring these toys for years, but never had the chance to use them. Fluttershy slowly ran her hoof along her collection of gags, blindfolds, bits, and blinders until she came across a single black leather collar. The collar had a purple velvet lining and featured a single dangling loop ring in the front. The back of the collar had a half loop fixed to one of the ends that could fit into the pre-cut holes on the other side thus allowing the user to lock the collar to its wearer. She grinned as she grabbed it and its lock. She hid it under her wing and headed back downstairs.

Rarity waited patiently for Fluttershy to return. She loved not knowing what was going to happen next. She loved being left in the dark and feeling helpless as she surrendered herself to Fluttershy. She heard the sound of drawers being opened and closed but was unable to make out what was going on upstairs. But, for all Rarity knew, Fluttershy was just putting her things away after a long day out of the house. Either way, the suspense was thrilling and Rarity continued to patiently wait for Fluttershy.

Fluttershy reached the bottom of the steps and looked towards Rarity who was right where she had left her. Fluttershy demurely approached Rarity. When she reached her, she positioned her head behind Rarity’s ears and said, “Well, I am very proud of you. You really have been good this evening, which is why I am going to tell you what that ‘something’ is that I was talking about earlier.” Fluttershy paused for a breath, “Would you like that?”

“Yes, Mistress.” Rarity finished her affirmation on a squeal as Fluttershy nibbled her ear.

“Okay, then.” Fluttershy circled Rarity and stopped when they could both face each other. Rarity quietly gasped as Fluttershy revealed the collar from under her wing. “I take it you know what this is then.”

Rarity nodded her head in agreement and felt her heartbeat quicken. She suddenly remembered all the fantasies she had of Fluttershy that had started in this same exact way.

“Well, even though I am pretty sure of what it is that you want, I need to hear it from you to be sure.” Fluttershy gently caressed Rarity’s cheek. “This is just a play collar, but if this works out and you like it, we can discuss something a little more permanent.” Fluttershy lost her train of thought as she looked into Rarity’s eyes. “When I put this on you tonight, it means that for the length of the time we are playing, you are mine. It is a symbol of my love for you, but it is also a symbol of your obedience as a gift to me. It means that you trust me. It means that are my pet, my plaything, until the collar comes off.” She caught herself looking down at the floor, but she raised her head back up to look at Rarity. Her voice softened a bit, “Is this what you want?”

“Yes, Mistress, oh so very much.”

“Okay. I guess that we had better get started then.” Fluttershy approached Rarity, “Kneel.”

Rarity did as she was told and bowed her head towards the floor. She extended a hoof forward so she was able to lower the front part of her body while keeping one hoof close to her chest in order to keep herself from falling. Fluttershy gently brushed aside Rarity’s mane and reached her hoofs around her neck, positioning the collar. The collar was secured as the small padlock clicked into place. Fluttershy took half a step back to admire her handiwork.

Fluttershy gently tugged on the dangling buckle of the collar twice to make sure that it was snug and secure. “Does it feel okay? Is my toy comfortable?”

Rarity was becoming flustered with arousal and struggled to find the words to respond. She was becoming lightheaded and the butterflies in her stomach had afflicted her with a shortness of breath. A pleasant tingling sensation made its way through her body, growing in intensity as it reached her extremities. Rarity felt herself becoming wet.

Just then, Fluttershy grabbed the collar and pulled her forward. “I said… is my toy comfortable?” Rarity closed her eyes and moaned as the carpet pulled on her slit, aggravating her arousal problem.

Rarity finally found the words and managed to say, “Yes, Mistress.” Her voice trembled.

“Good. Now follow me.” Fluttershy lead Rarity upstairs to the bedroom.

Fluttershy pointed to the foot of the bed, “Wait there and don’t move until I give you permission.” Rarity obeyed. Fluttershy went back to her closet. Rarity heard the same drawers from earlier opening and closing and she turned her head and tried to see what Fluttershy was doing, but she could not see anything from where she was positioned. “You better not be trying to see what’s inside this closet!” Rarity immediately corrected her position and turned her head away from the closet. Somehow Fluttershy knew what Rarity was trying to do. Fluttershy returned to Rarity toys in hoof and said, “Hold still.” Rarity felt a rubber bit force its way into her mouth. Rarity cried out as Fluttershy adjusted the straps on the harness; Fluttershy had accidentally snagged her mane. “Oh, did that hurt?” Rarity nodded. “Good.”

Next, Fluttershy donned a head harness with blinders onto Rarity. The harness was made out of a black latex/rubber material and pulled at Rarity’s coat and skin as it was positioned. It had several rings dangling from it that could serve as mounting points for other toys, ropes, or leashes.“This will help keep you from looking places you’re not supposed to.” Rarity blushed as Fluttershy finished securing it, she enjoyed being humiliated like this. Fluttershy used her hoof to move Rarity’s head up to kiss her. And as the were kissing, Fluttershy attached a leash to the collar.

Rarity saw herself in the mirror on the other side of the room. She had no clue that Fluttershy had all these toys and that there interests were so similar. But before Rarity could finish admiring herself—and her Mistress’s handiwork, she became distracted as Fluttershy dragged something from the closet. Rarity turned her head to see what Fluttershy had, but before she could get a look, Fluttershy said, “Tsk, tsk, tsk, Jewel. You’re not supposed to be looking over here remember? Actually, I think I’m owed an apology. I didn’t think that you would want to ruin the surprise!”

Rarity tried to her best ability to say, “Yes, Mistress. I beg your pardon, Mistress.” with the bit still in her mouth, but what came out was ultimately incomprehensible. After Fluttershy dismissed Rarity and thanked her for her apology Rarity returned to facing forward with a moan of disappointment.

“There.”, Fluttershy said to herself as she finally had everything positioned. She had placed what looked like the base of a rocking chair behind Rarity, except that this one was larger. There were four receptacles for hoofs along each arm of the rocker. The holes for the hoofs were fashioned out of a thick rubber material that was designed to form fit its occupant’s contours. Straps with buckles and locks hung loosely from the mounting points awaiting their next occupant. The straps were placed such that they could wrap around the rubber cuff and tighten onto themselves thus securing the occupant’s position.

Fluttershy grabbed Rarity’s leash with her mouth and slowly walked her back onto the rocker. The blinders kept Rarity from seeing what exactly was going on and walking backwards did not help. Rarity offered no resistance as she felt Fluttershy gently place one of her rear hoofs into the rubber cuff. As Rarity appreciated the snugness of it, she felt it compress around her paw as Fluttershy tightened the straps. Fluttershy then moved to the front hoof and did the same; Rarity had to be careful not to fall over as her hoof was pulled forwards into the slot. After spreading her legs into position, Fluttershy secured the remaining hoofs to the rocker. Rarity casually pulled at her restraints and found herself unable to move, the rubber bound tightly to her skin pulling at it every time she shifted her weight. Next, Fluttershy attached a rope on each side of the head harness and anchored the other sides down at the forward tips of the rocker. Rarity could no longer turn her head.

Fluttershy pushed Rarity on the apparatus to the other side of the room so that Rarity could see herself. “See? I told you I was going to turn you into my toy. You are going to be my little rocking pony tonight.” Fluttershy rested a hoof around Rarity as they both admired her work in the mirror. “Having fun?”, Fluttershy asked and gently pushed on Rarity’s plot and let go causing Rarity to rock back and forth. Rarity was helpless; at this point, she could not get out, even if she wanted to. She was completely at Fluttershy’s mercy.

“Stay here, Jewel.” Fluttershy gave Rarity another push, “not that I have to worry about that, right?” Fluttershy went back to the closet and retrieved another toy. She made sure to lay the towel down on the bed this time and then she plugged in the vibrator. She laid down on top of her bed and clicked the vibrator on to make sure it worked. The rocking toy and mirror were positioned so that Rarity was able to completely see herself and Fluttershy on the bed in the same image. Rarity moaned as she saw Fluttershy clopping herself off. Rarity struggled to move to please herself in any way she could, but she was too well bound. Every time she shifted her weight at all, she would just cause the rig she was on the rock back and forth. She would have to wait to see if Fluttershy would let her have an orgasm at that point. She resigned herself to watch patiently as her Mistress pleasure herself.

Rarity saw Fluttershy’s body gently convulse as she reached her climax. After a moment, Fluttershy got up and brought the vibrator over towards Rarity.

“Well, Jewel, I must say, you have been a really good pet and I think it’s time you had your reward.” Fluttershy grabbed the vibrator with her mouth and ran is over Rarity’s slit; the head of the vibrator was still wet from Fluttershy’s excretions. Rarity moaned in pleasure as her gyrations caused the rocker to resume its motion. Fluttershy made sure to compensate for the movement and kept the vibrator in contact at all times. Rarity made eye contact with Fluttershy in the mirror as Fluttershy said, “Cum for me, Jewel. You are my filthy little toy.” Rarity screamed in pleasure as she released herself. The series of climaxes were unlike anything she had ever experienced.

As the rocker came to a halt, Fluttershy removed Rarity’s hoofs from the restraints. She then removed the blinders and bit from her head before she led Rarity on the leash to bed.

“Thank you, Mistress.” Rarity was just starting to catch her breath.

“You are more than welcome. Now come here a moment.” Rarity leaned her head in as Fluttershy removed the play collar and leash. She gave Rarity a kiss on the mouth and forehead before telling her, “Go ahead and get some sleep. You’ll be staying here tonight. I’ll be right there.”

Fluttershy left the bed side to go clean up the mess they made as Rarity closed her eyes and rolled over, pulling the covers with her. Fluttershy smiled to herself and whispered, “Good night, Rarity. I love you.”