Starlight Glimmer's Punishment

Pinkie Pie

Starlight Glimmer hummed a happy tune as she trotted through Ponyville. After many weeks of living in the small town, many of the townsponies had greatly accepted her as one of their own. She'd even made a new friend in the form of a local magician by the name of Trixie! She couldn't wait to tell Twilight all about it, but her goal today was one place and one pony.

Sugarcube Corner, and the legendary earth pony mare, Pinkie Pie.

Pinkie had invited Starlight to come and bake cakes with her for a day. It turned out that the energetic pony lived just above the confectionery shop, and the store's owners the Cakes were out on their delivery rounds. Starlight could expect to have the whole store, and Pinkie, to herself.

Starlight licked her lips. Her thoughts drifted to the others, and the experiences she'd shared with each of them. Each one of Twilight's friends had taught her something a little different, and in turn she'd been able to help each one of them. She quietly giggled as she passed by Fluttershy and Bulk Biceps walking in the park together. The two were pretty adorable together, and she was glad that she had given the shy mare a little push in the right direction.

Starlight made her way up the next street, stopping in front of her destination. She knocked on the door carefully and waited.

The door opened and a pink blur grabbed her and yanked her inside. Starlight flumped to the floor and groaned.

“Ohmygosh are you alright?!” she heard a high pitched voice squeal.

“I'm fine,” Starlight said as she pushed herself to her hooves. She turned and was met with a pair of the brightest blue eyes she'd ever seen.

“That's great! I'm sorry, I just wanted to, you know, help you in,” Pinkie said, bouncing in place. “Let me go just lock the door and we can get started.”

“Don't you have like, customers to serve?” Starlight said, cocking her head.

“Nope! Store is always closed when the Cakes are out on delivery. Usually I have to watch the two foals, but they decided it was such a nice day and only to Canterlot that they'd take them with! So it's just you and me, and the kitchen. Well, and Gummy of course. Watch yourself there, he's right underneath you,” Pinkie said in a mouthful as she rushed to the door and clicked the lock closed.

Starlight blinked and looked down between her forelegs. A tiny green alligator sat on the floor, his vacant eyes staring in two different directions. It opened its mouth, revealing a row of nothing but gums. It had no teeth whatsoever!

“I... I see,” Starlight said as she walked around the toothless gator. “Well, then I'm ready to learn how to bake.”

“Great!” Pinkie chirped. “Have you ever baked anything before?”

“No... Sugar Belle was always the baker in the town,” Starlight said.

Pinkie frowned. “I think we can agree not to talk about that baking.”

“Heh, agreed,” Starlight said with a nervous chuckle.

“Well, with that out of the way, let's get started. Follow me to the kitchen,” Pinkie said.

Starlight nodded, walking behind the bouncing pink mare in front of her. As they walked (and bounced), Starlight couldn't help but be amazed at Pinkie's energy. She was bouncing so much that Starlight could barely get a glimpse of Pinkie’s baked goods, the mare was moving so fast.

Still, she could tell that despite all her energy, Pinkie was definitely much different in body type than the others. She was plump, likely owing to the amount of baked goods she ate, but she wasn't fat. She had a very natural appeal to her, a certain bubbly quality that Starlight found rather attractive.

The two mares made their way to the kitchen, where Pinkie slid across the floor on her hooves, coming to rest near the counter. Starlight trotted over and sat on the stool next to her.

“Alright!” Pinkie said. “Baking is just as much of a science as it is an art form. It's about expression, but it's also about measurement!”

Pinkie reached beneath the counter and quickly pulled out several mixing bowls. Starlight watched in awe as Pinkie grabbed ingredient after ingredient and began to throw them haphazardly into the mix. It was a veritable whirlwind of flour and eggs. When she was finished, one of the bowls had a pale yellow gloop in it that appeared to be the consistency of sludge. Pinkie picked it up and carefully poured it into a cake pan where it settled.

“Um, measurements?” Starlight said cautiously. She was feeling slightly concerned over the mare's mathematical skills. “Pinkie, how much of each ingredient did you use?”

“Oh, you know. A smidge here, a dash there, a cantelope and forty pounds of sugar,” Pinkie replied nonchalantly.

“What.”

“I'm kidding silly. I make this stuff look easy I know. I've been doing it a lot longer than even I can remember, and that's a really long time! Probably longer than since I was an itty bitty twinkie Pinkie! Oh boy, I can't wait to tell you about how I got my cutie mark, but wait you don't like cutie marks so you might not like that story. Oh I know! I'll tell you about how Equestria came to be! That's a great story, and eerily similar to how I got my cutie mark!”

“Pinkie. The cake?” Starlight said.

“Oh, right! How could I forget! We have to bake this puppy! Except it's not a real puppy, because that would be really mean,” Pinkie said.

“Err... right,” Starlight said nervously. “How about you put the cake in the oven and then you can show me how to do it, alright?”

“Sure thing!” Pinkie chirped. She kicked the cake pan into the air and bounced across the kitchen, catching it just in front of the oven.

To Starlight's surprise, the cake batter stayed perfectly in the cake pan. Starlight blinked. Twilight had warned her that Pinkie was... well... eccentric and strange, and that she shouldn't spend much time over-analyzing the peculiar mare's habits. Something about an anvil and a hydra. It hadn't ended well.

“Alright, so... where do we start?” Starlight asked. “So I can do this on my own?”

“First, you need your ingredients. The most important of which are flour, sugar, eggs, butter, and baking soda,” Pinkie said happily.

“And you're supposed to put them together in specific amounts, right? I didn’t have much time, but I did read up a little on this before I came over,” Starlight said.

“Silly filly, I've never read any books on baking. You don't need to, really. It's really super easy!” Pinkie replied.

“But... you just said that baking is a science? How are you so good at baking if you don't know the exact measurements?!” Starlight balked.

“Natural talent, I guess,” Pinkie said, putting a hoof to her mouth. “I tell you what, how about you give it a try and I'll be the food critic. A contest, if you will. Whichever one of us has the better cake, wins.”

Starlight's gaze narrowed at the other mare. “You're on. What does the winner get?”

“Oh, I've got a good prize in mind,” Pinkie said, flashing a grin. “Trust me.”

“Alright,” Starlight said. “Let's get started then. Your natural talent versus my exact measurements.”

Pinkie grinned widely and sped off towards the other counter while Starlight ignited her horn. A book popped out of nowhere and rested on the counter. She happily flipped it open to the recipes on cakes.

“Let's see here... a tablespoon of this… two eggs...” she said as she reached out with her magic and began to portion out and mix together the appropriate ingredients in the mixing bowl.

Soon she had a very consistent looking batter. She dipped her spoon in and licked a tiny bit and smiled. It was just right. She was going to win this contest for sure! She glanced over at Pinkie, who had already managed to get her cake into the oven. She grimaced and trotted over to the second oven. Pulling up her book, she found the section on actually baking the cake, and flipped the oven to the appropriate temperature. She set her cake inside and grinned.

“You are going to love my cake, Pinkie. I've got this in the bag,” Starlight said proudly.

“I don't see a bag, silly. Besides, my cake is the bestest cake to ever cake, and it will gobble your cake up for lunch!” Pinkie said. She put a hoof to her mouth again. “I wonder if cakes eat cake.”

Starlight facehooved. “Right. Well, we'll just see who the winner is. Besides, you're supposed to tell me what we need to prepare while the cake is baking.”

“Oh right! We need to get out the icing and the decorations!” Pinkie chirped. She bounced over to the cupboard and pulled it open, revealing a row of icing packets. She pulled them out and set them on the counter, along with various tips to use for decorating.

“Wow...” Starlight said as she eyed the various colors of icing. There was every color that could possibly be put on a cake, and there was even a bag of rainbow colored icing! “This is pretty amazing, Pinkie.”

“I know, right? Icing is the best part of any cake. It just tastes so yummy!” Pinkie said excitedly. “Here, try some!”

Starlight's eyes widened as Pinkie picked up one of the packets of red icing, apparently not noticing which way the hole was pointed. Icing squirted from the packet, landing squarely on Starlight's face. Pinkie stopped and Starlight blinked.

“Pffft.... “ Pinkie started before she began uncontrollably giggling and then full on laughing.

“Pinkie!” Starlight exclaimed. “I... Oh... you... I'm gonna get you!”

She picked up another packet of blue icing with her magic and threw it at Pinkie. The icing splattered all over the laughing mare's face, stopping her cold. She grinned, her teeth bright and clean against the blue frosted background.

“Food fight?” she asked.

Starlight blinked.

“FOOD FIGHT!” Pinkie shouted as she grabbed two more packets of icing and launched them at Starlight.

Starlight yelped and reached out with her magic, managing to stop one of them but not the other before it struck her dead in the chest. She retaliated, sending the one she'd caught back at Pinkie, but the bubbly mare moved out of the way and it landed on the floor in a splatter.

Pinkie grinned. “Gotta catch me first!”

Starlight grimaced and flung another packet. And another. And another. She couldn't hit Pinkie worth squat! For every one packet that she actually managed to land on the pink mare, Pinkie landed three back. The feeling of squishy icing on her coat covered her entirely, not to mention the floor of the kitchen. It was a multicolored mess of epic proportions.

Starlight moved forward to try and intercept Pinkie, stepping accidentally on a small puddle of icing. Her hoof slipped and she went sailing forward as she collided with the pink mare. They went down in a heap on the floor. They ended up face to face.

“Uh.. sorry about that,” Starlight said as she panted.

“It's okay, I wasn't watching where I was --” Pinkie started to say before Starlight leaned in and kissed her.

It wasn't a strong kiss, but it was enough to get the point across. Pinkie tasted delicious, her natural taste mixing with the icing on her face. It was perfect. Starlight pulled back.

“--going. Wow. You're a really good kisser, you know that? Fluttershy was right.”

“Thanks? You.. you're not so bad yourself,” Starlight replied. She giggled. “I feel really silly right about now. We're both covered in icing.”

“That's not a bad thing,” Pinkie said. She reached in and extended her tongue, licking some of the icing off Starlight's neck.

Starlight moaned softly as she felt the tingling touch of Pinkie's tongue. “I... I...”

“See? Icing tastes good on just about everything,” Pinkie replied.

Starlight nodded. She yearned for more. She could feel her loins getting tight and the heat increasing between her legs. She reached in again and kissed Pinkie again, more forcefully this time. They held the kiss for several long moments before coming back up for air.

“I wonder what else tastes good with icing... Oh, I know,” Pinkie said as she narrowed her gaze as Starlight. She slowly shuffled herself downwards, taking every opportunity to lick as much of the icing off Starlight as she possibly could on the way down.

Starlight groaned. Pinkie was hitting every button she could hit. She felt dirty. Her coat felt unclean and she sighed loudly as Pinkie worked down her body. She didn't care. She wanted it. She wanted more. She wanted to be dirty.

Pinkie slid down further, her eyes narrowed as she licked down to Starlight's rump. She paused for a moment before sliding Starlight's legs apart. Starlight felt another packet of icing explode over her clean belly, the liquid trickling down over her teats. Pinkie grinned and took one of them in her mouth, sucking the icing clean from it.

Starlight gasped loudly as Pinkie pulled in and sucked hard on her teat. She banged her hoof hard on the ground, trying to keep from shouting too loudly.

Pinkie grinned and worked her way down, stopping just before Starlight's pulsing marehood. She licked her lips.

“You sure look tasty. You wanna know what would make it even tastier?” she said with a hungry grin.

Starlight glanced down as the earth mare produced a bottle of what appeared to be chocolate sauce. Her eyes widened. Pinkie turned the bottle over and dumped as much of it as possible all over Starlight's already hot and steaming pussy.

“Mmm... not quite,” Pinkie said. She reached somewhere and pulled out a can of whipped cream. She turned it over and squirted it all over, the fluffy compound mixing with the hot sticky chocolate. “There we go. You look good enough to eat, if I do say so myself. I think I'll have the first taste, if you don't mind.”

Pinkie dove in with manic ferocity, licking and sucking the chocolate cream mix off of Starlight's pussylips. Starlight yelped and shuddered. She grunted as Pinkie's tongue worked up and down the her folds, occasionally slipping in between them.

“Oh.... oh wow...” she said breathily.

“Mmmm...” Pinkie moaned, her muzzle buried deep into Starlight's mound. She extended her tongue, pushing aside the folds of her partner's pussy. For several long strokes she continued pulling out and inserting her tongue.

Starlight's eyes rolled into the back of her head over the extreme pleasure she was feeling. Her tongue lolled out of the side of her mouth and she started bucking her hips into Pinkie's muzzle. Pinkie responded forcefully, licking and sucking so hard that Starlight wasn't sure if she was going to be able to hold out any longer.

“P-P-Pinkie... I'm gonna... gonna... oh Goddess I'm c-c-cummmiiiiiiiiing!” Starlight called out.

Starlight grunted loudly as she thrust her hips up through her orgasm's peak. She felt a hot rush of liquid erupt from her pussy. She shuddered, flopping onto the ground. She peeked an eye open and glanced at Pinkie. Not only was the party mare covered in icing, but now she had a healthy layer of glistening marecum too. Had she done that? Starlight's eyes widened.

“Oh, gosh... Pinkie... I...” she started to say.

“Wheee!! That was awesome! You squirted like a fountain!” Pinkie squealed. She licked her lips, pulling in some of the sticky liquid. “And you taste incredible, Starlight. You really gushed a lot though.”

“I... I've never done that before...” Starlight panted. “You really liked that?”

“Are you kidding me?! I kind of wondered if you were a squirter or not,” Pinkie said. “First time then, eh? Well, aren't you lucky. With the first one out of the way you'll probably be able to do it more often.”

“How do you...?”

“Oh, I do it too,” Pinkie explained. “Freaked me out the first time, but it's completely natural. Not everypony can do it though. Some just can't. Twilight for example. She's just incapable of it.”

“Huh,” Starlight said. “I... I can't move.”

“Yeah, that's probably pretty accurate too,” Pinkie said. “Here, let me help you up.”

Pinkie lowered a hoof and helped move the shaky mare onto her hooves. Starlight grunted as she managed to stand on wobbly legs.

“Thanks,” she said.

“You're welcome. We've made a bit of a mess it looks like,” Pinkie replied.

“Yeah...” Starlight said shakily. “We also look like we fell in a cake mixer.”

“I have an idea! How's about a shower and then we come down and clean all of this up?” Pinkie said, raising a hoof.

Starlight nodded. “That might be for the best before this icing decides it's going to be a part of my coat.”

“Good. Because it's going to be just you, me, and some suds,” Pinkie said with a grin.

* * *

Starlight climbed into the bathtub behind Pinkie. Her mind was still processing what had happened downstairs. She'd never done anything quite like that before even with their other friends. Pinkie was certainly something special. Perhaps she'd underestimated her. She smiled at the thought.

Pinkie reached up and turned the water on as she closed the curtain. The water trickled down on both of them, wetting their manes until they lay flat against their bodies and slowly working the icing from each of their coats.

Starlight resisted the urge to chuckle. She'd never seen Pinkie with her mane that way before. She sighed and lifted her head, letting the water drench her completely. She felt something rough on her coat begin to move back and forth. Her eyes peeked out, watching as Pinkie was scrubbing her with a bath brush that she held in her mouth.

“Mmm...” Starlight said. “That feels really good Pinkie.”

“Mmphmmmph,” Pinkie replied around the brush handle in her mouth.

“What's that?”

Pinkie spit out the brush. “I said you're welcome. You know... Starlight... I'm really glad you're here in Ponyville... for Twilight.”

“What do you mean?” Starlight said. She reached out with her magic and took up the brush. She started scrubbing on Pinkie's back and sides.

“Well I uh... ooh that's the spot... I just meant that you and Twilight have a lot in common that's all...” Pinkie replied. “She really cares for you, you know that right?”

Starlight blinked. Was Pinkie trying to say what she thought she was saying? “I... I know.”

“I'm just saying that maybe you should talk to her about it,” Pinkie said. She shuddered. “Oh yeah, right there. I mean... if you don't it might just lead to frowny faces, and I just can't stand seeing any of my friends not smiling.”

“You... you think of me as your friend?” Starlight said.

“Of course silly! Why wouldn't you be my friend?” Pinkie said. “Besides... if we weren't friends, would I be doing this?”

Pinkie hungrily reached in and kissed Starlight. Starlight's eyes widened, not expecting the sudden embrace. She returned the kiss happily though, and pulled away.

“I suppose you're right. Mmm... I have an idea. We're not exactly finished, you know,” she said.

Pinkie grinned widely. “Sure. What are you thinking?”

“Turn around and show me that sweet candy.”

Pinkie nodded and turned so that her rump was facing Starlight. She pushed aside her tail and revealed her pussy. Starlight took it in for a second. It was pert and pulsing amidst the water running down it from her asshole. She lifted the brush and lowered the handle towards Pinkie's rump.

*THWACK*

Starlight brought the bath brush down on Pinkie's rump, lightly but with enough force to send ripples through the plush pink posterior, eliciting a coo from the mare. Pinkie's pussy winked in response. Starlight grinned and brought the brush back up and down, this time on the other side of Pinkie's ass.

*THWACK*

“Oh...” Pinkie moaned out. “I see what you wanted to do. That's fine. Keep going though and don't stop.”

Starlight nodded. She lifted the brush and brought it back down in rapid succession. Pinkie shuddered and groaned. Starlight continued this several times further, each time eliciting tiny shakes and squeals from the party mare.

“Starlight... could you maybe... I heard that you had...” Pinkie said, panting hard. Her voice sounded... hungry. “I want you inside me. Fuck me as hard as you want. Use my pussy as your personal cocksleeve. I want it.”

Starlight's eyes widened. She nodded and her horn glowed brightly, bringing forth the cock spell that she'd used with Fluttershy. By now that particular spell was an old friend, and the magical member almost leapt into being between her legs.

She lifted up onto Pinkie's rump and positioned herself. “You alright?”

“Yeah... please... do it. Don’t play, don’t tease, just do it. Do meeeeEEEEEE!”

Starlight thrust as hard as she could, burying her dick balls deep into Pinkie's plump pussy. Pinkie shouted in joy. Starlight groaned, pulling out and back in. Her partner's pussy provided no resistance whatsoever, just a delicious sticky slickness. Over and over she pulled out and thrusted, sawing her way closer and closer to her inevitable conclusion.

Pinkie shuddered. “Oh... wow... woweee... pop my party cannon! Harder!”

Starlight grunted and redoubled her efforts, savoring the feel of the water on her hips almost as much as the clinging love channel of her partner. Pinkie squealed and shook below her. She felt the climbing tension in her cock. She was getting close, and so was Pinkie.

“Pinkie... I'm close...”

“Me too.... cum... cum inside me... I want to feel it...”

Starlight blew out a gusty pant of breath, almost a howl, and slammed herself into Pinkie as hard as she could, feeling her orgasm reaching its peak. She moaned and grunted and shook as the cock began to erupt inside Pinkie Pie, spewing sticky hot cum in her.

“OH OH OH OHHHH!”

And then Pinkie Pie came.

Starlight felt hot wetness flood along the bottom of her shaft and the tops of her legs. Starlight's eyes widened. She'd thought she'd squirted a lot earlier, but this was nothing compared to Pinkie. She pulled her cock out, trailing cum that leaked out of Pinkie's pussy, mixing itself with the abundant marecum.

Pinkie slumped and groaned, her body shaking as she expelled more of her juices into the bathtub. The mere sight of it was enough to send Starlight over the edge again. Her cock flared, spewing forth another strand of cum that landed along Pinkie's cutie mark.

Pinkie stood, shakily. She turned and smiled. “That sure was something. Fluttershy was right, that thing feels good.”

“Heh. You heard about that from her, I take it?” Starlight said.

“Yeah. We talk about stuff, you know...” Pinkie said.

“I see,” Starlight said with a grimace. Her horn glowed and she dismissed the cock spell, causing it to dissipate.

“We're gonna need to spend longer in this shower,” Pinkie said. “We're dirty again.”

“Well, I guess we could just brush each other off and resist the urge to go at it again,” Starlight replied coyly.

“Or you know... we could move to the bedroom and I could give you the blowjob of your life,” Pinkie said with a grin. “No reason to cut the party off now is there?”

Starlight chuckled. “That sounds like fun, but I probably need to get back to the castle. I think you're right about talking to Twilight. Besides, we still need to clean up that mess downstairs before the Cakes get home.”

“Alright, but the offer still stands. Anytime you want to cash it in,” Pinkie said.

Starlight nodded. She sniffed, taking in a whiff of something not belonging to either one of them. It smelled a lot like smoke.

“Um... Pinkie?”

“Yeah?”

“Something's burning.”

Pinkie's eyes widened.

“The cakes!”

* * *

Starlight made her way out the door of Sugarcube Corner and back out into the streets. Although a little wobbly and very thoroughly brushed, she felt very good. The cakes were a lost cause, having sat in the ovens long enough to resemble bricks more than confections, and it had taken a good amount of time to clean the remains of the Great Icing War off the floors of the kitchen.

She trotted back towards the Castle of Friendship, feeling somewhat apprehensive. Pinkie had clearly been trying to tell her something amidst their lovemaking that made her feel off.

Twilight. She had said something about Twilight.

Starlight grimaced as she found herself at the foot of the castle. The closer she got, the more worried she was. Was something wrong with Twilight that Pinkie was trying to warn her about? Or was it what she had wondered all along.

Did Twilight.... did she love her?

Starlight pushed open the door and walked up the first sets of stairs towards Twilight's bedroom. The way was second nature to her now. As she neared her door, she swore she could hear crying inside.

She carefully pushed open the door.

“Twilight?” she called out softly.

In the center of the bedroom was Twilight. She was slumped over her bed, her eyes wet with tears. She stopped and stared at Starlight.

“S-S-Starlight?”

“Twilight... we need to talk.”

Author's Note

If you like what you've read here, consider supporting me on Patreon!