Starlight Glimmer's Punishment

Bonus Chapter: Sunset Shimmer

Starlight Glimmer glanced up at the swirling portal. She returned a glance back over to Twilight, who was standing at the controls to the device that powered it.

“You're... you're sure this thing is safe?” she asked.

“Absolutely. I've used it many times to travel to the world that Canterlot High exists in,” Twilight chirped.

“Why am I doing this again?” Starlight said, grimacing. “Another friendship lesson?”

“Well, sort of. You see, you had such a successful friendship with Trixie, that I got to thinking that maybe you might find a new friend in another former villainous pony,” Twilight said. “There's a girl in this world by the name of Sunset Shimmer. She's originally from Equestria.”

“I've read about her. She tried to steal your crown, right?” Starlight said.

“She was also one of Celestia's pupils. She's actually very studied in magic, and has spent much time working on understanding how Equestrian magic has impacted her new world,” Twilight said.

“If she's so good at magic, why did she stay in this other world? Why not come back to Equestria?” Starlight said with another grimace.

“Well... it's a little complicated. Sunset has obligations there, and she has friends of her own. In fact... her friends look an awful lot like our friends,” Twilight said.

“So you mean this world... it's like a parallel dimension of ours? That these... humans you called them live in?”

Twilight nodded excitedly. “That's right. Now I've gone ahead and written to Sunset so that she can meet you outside the portal. The students at Canterlot High are well used to magic by now, but they won't know who you are.”

Twilight trotted from around the console and stepped up next to Starlight's side. She leaned in and gave her a soft kiss on the cheek.

“Will it hurt?” Starlight asked, her eyes focused on the portal.

“Not really. It might be a bit disorienting on the other side though,” Twilight said with a grin.

“What do you --” Starlight started to say before Twilight shoved her forward into the portal.

Starlight's eyes widened as the portal enveloped her completely. Lights swirled all around her vision and she felt her body beginning to change shape. The lights began swirling faster and faster until finally everything in sight was a hot burning white.

Then she fell forward. Her eyes were clenched shut and she felt herself stretched out and strange, propped up on a set of scrawny appendages.

Starlight opened her eyes. Her hooves were gone! In their place were slender hands like a gryphon’s talon or minotaur’s, but tiny. Starlight blinked. Was this... what a human looked like?

She slowly pushed herself up until she was on her knees and then finally she wobbled up onto two legs. As she stood, she became acutely aware that she was indeed very different looking. She turned around, seeing her reflection in the portal.

A strange but beautiful looking girl stared back at her, her hair up in a ponytail. Its coloration matched her pony mane. Her skin was a light pink, and she was wearing clothes. A tight-fitting blouse hugged the upper part of her body, while a skirt draped down from her waist over her legs. The skirt had her cutie mark emblazoned on it. Starlight blinked. The girl in the reflection blinked back. She reached up with her... her hands? Yes, that was right, her hands. She reached up with her hands and touched the tiny little button of nose where her muzzle should be.

“So weird,” she said to herself. Starlight looked about, realizing that she was by herself in the middle of a courtyard in front of a school. The sign above it read “Canterlot High.” There was no sign of this Sunset Shimmer that she'd be sent to find.

Starlight felt a tightening in her chest and nether regions as she shifted. She looked down and realized that stuffed inside her blouse was two round objects attached directly to her chest, covered first by some sort of silky strap thing and then her blouse. She lifted her hand and placed it on one of them, feeling her protruding nipple through the fabric. She gasped at the action. It felt good!

She analyzed the situation for a moment. Ponies had teats, so it stood to reason that these humans had them too... so theirs were just on their chest? Is that why they were covered? There were so many questions going through her mind. She felt a stiffness down below. She blinked. It stands to reason that if humans have mammary glands, then they would have...

She reached down, lifting the skirt slightly, just enough to run her hand up her legs. There she met a silky pair of what she could only assume were panties. She spread her legs and pulled them aside, feeling the wetness there. Yes, that was definitely what she thought it was. Her eyes closed as she reached in again, feeling her pleasure heighten as she ran her fingers across her pussy.

“You know... we usually don't do that stuff in public,” a voice said.

Starlight yelped in surprise and pulled her hand away, turning towards the source of the voice. She glanced across the courtyard to see another girl standing there. She wore a trim fitting blue blouse and a leather jacket, and her hair was like fire.

“Um... hi?” Starlight said.

“You must be Starlight Glimmer. Twilight told me that you'd be here soon,” the girl said. “I'm Sunset. Sunset Shimmer.”

“H-h-hi,” Starlight said. “How... how long were you watching me?”

“Long enough,” Sunset said with a chuckle. “That's not really an activity meant for the public eye, but I can understand. You have no idea how long I spent with myself when I first got here. It's definitely different than being a pony, especially with these things hanging off of you.” She pointed to her chest.

“What... what are they called?” Starlight asked.

“Oh, right. Twilight probably didn't brief you on that part. Probably wanted it to be a surprise. They're called breasts, or if you wanna go with slang terms you can call them boobs, tits, funbags, there’s a million of ‘em,” Sunset said.

“I see. So I guess you probably know who I am then, right?” Starlight said.

“Twilight may have told me that she found herself a student. She didn't really explain why she was sending you here for a little bit, though,” Sunset said, putting her hand to her chin.

“Well... she thought that maybe we might have some common ground,” Starlight said with a blush. “You see... I kinda tried to completely rewrite the timeline in Equestria to ensure that she and her friends never received their cutie marks at the same time, thus completely dooming the world.”

Sunset blinked. “Wow... I...”

“I know. It's bad, right?”

“Not nearly as bad as you think. I stole a magic crown from a different universe and tried to use it to convert the entire school into mindless zombies to take over Equestria,” Sunset said nonchalantly. “I guess Twilight thought it would be good for us to bond.”

“Wait. You mind controlled the whole school?” Starlight said.

“Yeah... it wasn't one of my best moments,” Sunset said. “But as I'm sure is the case with you, I'm in a much better place now. If it weren't for my friends giving me a chance when I needed it, I don't know where I'd be.”

Starlight nodded. “I feel the same way,” she said.

“Listen, since you're gonna be here a while, how about we go back to my place? I have an apartment not far from here,” Sunset said. “We could you know... have a slumber party or something.”

“Alright, lead the way.”

* * *

Sunset turned the key and pushed open the door. The apartment wasn't terribly far away, and the walk allowed Starlight to get a better grip on her new set of legs and feet. After some stumbling and some pointers from Sunset, she'd been able to quickly figure it out.

“It's not much, but it's home,” Sunset said as she flicked on the light.

Starlight stepped inside. Sunset's apartment was fairly clean, all things considering. A tiny desk sat in the far corner of the living room, a strange device composed mainly of boxes connected by tubes atop it. In the other corner was a strangely shaped blue device with a long neck.

“What's that?” Starlight asked.

“Oh, right. You've probably never seen a guitar before, have you?” Sunset said, picking it up. She pulled out a tiny triangle shaped piece of plastic and ran it across the strings a few times. The device made a twangy sound. “It's a musical instrument. You strum it, and the sound comes from the vibration in the strings.”

“Huh. You have such strange things here, how did you ever get used to it all?” Starlight said as she took a seat on Sunset's couch.

“Kind of had to. When I left Equestria, there was no going back for me. Even... even with all that Twilight has done for me here, I still can't return,” Sunset said.

“But it's not Equestria. Don't you miss it?” Starlight asked, feeling confused.

“Sure I do. But this place isn't so bad. It's just my new life now. I've got great friends, and people at the school are trusting me. Plus, once we graduate, I plan to go to college and study science. Someday, I hope that I can attain enough knowledge to truly understand how Equestrian magic works in this world,” Sunset explained. “But here you are listening to me ramble on. Would you like something to drink?”

“Uh... sure. Water? That sounds good actually,” Starlight said.

“Sure, one second,” Sunset replied. She stood and made her way to the kitchen. Starlight couldn't help but notice how the other girl's hips swayed as she walked. Sunset returned shortly with a cup of water which she set on the table across from Starlight.

Starlight smiled and reached out with her new hands. She enclosed the cup with one of them, intending on picking it up like she'd just seen Sunset do. Instead, she lost control of it and spilled water all over her blouse. Starlight yelped as the cup fell to the floor and rolled around.

“Oh I'm so sorry!” she said.

Sunset smiled. “No worries. I know it's hard getting used to using your hands. You should have seen Twilight when she first came here.” She walked over and picked up the cup and set it back on the table. “Let me get some paper towels and clean this up.”

“What about my... my shirt?” Starlight asked.

Sunset grimaced. “Yeah, you can't really wear a wet shirt can you? I'm going to have to hang it up and let it dry. Take it of and I'll take it to the laundry room.”

“T-t-t-take it off?” Starlight stuttered. She blushed.

“Yeah. It's alright. We're both girls here, not like I haven't ever seen a bra,” Sunset said with a grin.

Starlight gulped and nodded. She lifted her hands and fumbled with the buttons, but couldn't get them to come apart with her fingers.

“Oh, right. Sorry,” Sunset said. “Here, let me help you.”

Sunset walked over and put her hands on Starlight's shirt. She quickly undid the buttons all the way down the blouse with practiced ease.

Starlight glanced up into the other girl's eyes. A faint blush rested on Sunset's cheeks as she slipped off the blouse, revealing her bra. Starlight glanced down, noting that the piece of underclothing was lacy and nearly see-through. Her excitement showed through the fabric, the nipples on her breasts protruding outward.

“Wow, uh... you know... you're very pretty as a human, Starlight,” Sunset stammered.

“Really? You think so?” Starlight asked.

Sunset nodded mutely. Her eyes drifted to Starlight's breasts. She could see the outline of her nipples. Just seeing it made her start to feel very wet down below. She looked back up at Starlight's face.

“Yeah... you're cute. Very curvy. I like it,” Sunset said, trying to smile.

“I... I see,” Starlight said. “Would... would you maybe like to see more?”

Sunset's mind exploded. A million thoughts raced through her head. Most of them were telling her to say no, but the growing wetness in her crotch was telling her a different story. HELL YES! she thought as she nodded again without saying anything.

“Could you... could you help me? I don't know that I can get this thing off by myself,” Starlight said.

Sunset moved forward a few steps and stopped. She frowned. “Wait. I... I don't know. This isn't why Twilight sent you here.”

“Maybe not, but I can see it in your eyes, Sunset. You want this,” Starlight said. She ran her hand over one of her breasts, the unfamiliar sensation eliciting a shudder.

Sunset licked her lips and grimaced. “Starlight, you're very pretty I just... I invited you over so that we could learn more about each other, become friends.”

Starlight grinned and walked up towards Starlight, turning and leaning against her. She pulled one of Sunset's hands up to her left breast.

“Don't you want to learn more about this?” she said softly.

Sunset held her hand there for a brief second, feeling Starlight's nipple through her bra. She nodded mutely and leaned in, bringing the other girl into a deep kiss. She slowly massaged Starlight's breast as they kissed, their tongues dancing amongst each other. She pulled away, a trail of saliva dripping between the two.

“Bed... bedroom?” Sunset managed to say.

Starlight grinned once more and nodded. She walked forward, pulling away for a second before extending her hand.

Sunset breathed deeply and extended her own hand, taking Starlight's in hers. Together they walked towards Sunset's bedroom. Sunset pushed the door open. “It's not much, but here it is.”

Starlight took in Sunset's bedroom. It looked pretty spartan, with a simple four-post bed in the middle with a vanity in the corner. Hanging all around the vanity were pictures of Sunset and five other girls who looked just like Starlight's Ponyville friends.

“Twilight said that they looked different here. Have you ever...?” she said, flashing Sunset a wink.

Sunset blushed. “No. Never. Well... okay there was that one time we played Spin the Bottle and I had to kiss Pinkie Pie. But I've never... you know...”

“Ever?”

Sunset grimaced. She nodded.

“But you know that you... you like girls?” Starlight asked.

“For a while now, yes. I... I accidentally saw one of the girls naked. In the locker room. They didn't see me. They were changing, and I saw her breasts,” Sunset said, sitting on the bed. “I... I masturbated to it. I couldn't help myself. Thankfully they didn't see me.”

Starlight grinned as she sat on the bed next to Sunset. “Well... I won't lie. This isn't the first time I've been with a girl... but it is my first time as a human. So... I guess we'll have to help each other out, alright?”

Sunset nodded. She reached forward and draped her arms over Starlight's shoulders. “That sounds like a plan.”

She reached in and gave Starlight another kiss, sloppily mashing her tongue against hers. Her arms reached down during the embrace and found the clasp to Starlight's bra. She quickly undid it, letting the silky undergarment fall free from Starlight's chest.

Starlight pulled away from the kiss and slipped off the bra from her arm. She glanced at Sunset and smiled. “Do you like them?”

Sunset gaped. Starlight's breasts were the most perfect set she'd ever seen in her life. They were ample and round, and her nipples were hard as a rock.

“They're very pretty,” Sunset said.

“Can I... see yours?”

Sunset nodded. She pulled up her blouse, lifting it over her head, revealing a satin red bra that hugged her breasts tightly. She reached behind her back and undid the clasp, pulling it away. Starlight's eyes brightened.

“Can... can I?” Starlight asked.

Sunset nodded again. Starlight reached forward and grabbed a hold of her breasts, eliciting a low moan from Sunset's mouth. The feel of her hands on them made Sunset wet with anticipation. She was starting to soak her panties just waiting for it.

Starlight lifted Sunset's right breast. She reached in and lifted it to her mouth, pulling Sunset's hard nipple inside. She sucked briefly before letting it go with a *pop*.

“Oh...” Sunset moaned. “That felt good.”

Starlight grinned and pushed forward. The two fell back onto the silky pillows of the bed, splaying Sunset's tits about. Hungrily, Starlight grabbed a hold of one while she sucked on the nipple of another.

Sunset moaned loudly. She had never before realized the pleasure that could be had from having her tits sucked like this. She lowered a hand and caressed Starlight's hair, holding onto her while the other girl carried out her ministrations.

Starlight released her left nipple with a sigh. “I gotta say I'm going to miss these things when I go back to being a pony. These are a lot more fun than our normal teats.”

“Heh... yeah,” Sunset breathed. “I'm not gonna lie... I'm incredibly wet right now.”

“I guess I'm going to have to do something about that, aren't I?” Starlight said with a hungry grin.

Sunset nodded. She lowered her hands down towards her pants, slipping them down. She gave Starlight another nod.

Starlight reached forward and tugged as well, pulling them over her knees and away. She threw the pants off the bed where they crumpled onto the floor. She looked down and saw that Sunset was also wearing a pair of solid red panties with an emblem of a sun embroidered on them. Starlight could only assume that the sun symbol was Sunset's cutie mark back in Equestria. It was... adorable in a sense. She also noticed that Sunset's panties were indeed absolutely soaking wet. She sniffed the air, smelling Sunset's arousal. It only served the heighten the growing wetness in her own crotch.

“Mmm... yes, I can see that,” she said. “Let's see if I can help you out with that.”

Sunset spread her legs, waiting nervously for Starlight to attend to her needs. Her mind raced with doubts. Why was she doing this? She was supposed to be showing Starlight how to be a good friend, not have sex with her. Still, her body couldn't resist every urge, every desire that she'd had built up ever since she'd seen Rainbow in the locker room. She had neglected to tell Starlight that part, for good reason. She didn't ever want Rainbow to know that she'd touched herself to the mere sight of her breasts.

Starlight grinned, licking her lips as she lowered herself towards Sunset's crotch. She reached out and grabbed onto her panties, forcefully pulling them aside and revealing the other girl's gaping and pulsing pussy. She extended her tongue and ran it alongside Sunset's outer folds, eliciting a shudder from her partner.

“Oh...” Sunset croaked.

Starlight's tongue lapped up and down, teasing poor Sunset with every stroke. She sped up her licks, burying her mouth deep into Sunset's wetness. She licked and sucked hard, feeling every shift and shake from Sunset.

“Oh... wow... yeah, right there yeah...” Sunset squealed. “Don't stop don't stop please oh Goddess it feels so good.”

Starlight hungrily devoured Sunset's pussy, forcing her tongue in between the folds, inserting it and withdrawing it quickly. She used her fingers on one of her hands to spread apart the orifice while using her other hand to caress and rub Sunset's labia. Her attention turned to Sunset's clitoris, taking the tiny nub into her mouth and holding it in her pursed lips. She sucked hard on it, causing Sunset to yelp and shout.

“Ohh... ohh.. fuck fuck fuck....” Sunset shouted. “Oh that feels so good please don't stop... I'm so close so close please fuck fuck fuck...”

Starlight bit and sucked hard on Sunset's clit, continuing to insert and withdraw two sets of fingers into her slippery pussy. She could feel her own arousal completely soaking her own panties. She craved release as well, but Sunset was more important. Sunset apparently needed this.

“Fuck fuck fuck fuck... FUCK FUCK FUCK!” Sunset cried out. “I'm close oh oh oh I'm cumiiiiiiiiiiing!”

Sunset bucked her hips as her orgasm took over, shaking and shifting as she rode it out, Starlight's head, tongue and fingers still buried into her crotch. Starlight continued her ministrations gently as Sunset’s orgasm rolled to an end. Sunset groaned.

“I... I've never came like that before...” she panted. “You... you really know what you're doing.”

Starlight grinned and climbed up towards Sunset. She reached in and kissed her, lingering just long enough that Sunset could taste her own wetness on Starlight's lips. She pulled away with a pant.

“We're not done yet, lover,” she said.

Sunset smiled. “Of course not. Turn around?”

“Oh? What do you have in mind?” Starlight said as she turned around, her ass facing Sunset.

“Bend over.”

“As you wish,” Starlight said. She bent over, her tits flushing against the bed. She felt Sunset slowly pull off her skirt and panties. She lifted her feet slightly so that Sunset could pull them off completely.

“Holy shit Starlight,” Sunset breathed. “Your ass and pussy are so incredibly hot.”

“Less talking, more fucking,” Starlight said with a grin.

“Yes, ma'am,” Sunset said. “Stay there. I think you'll like this next part.”

Sunset shuffled to the side of the bed and opened the drawer on the end table. Starlight couldn't see what she pulled out of it. She felt something cold and slick slide down her asshole towards her pussy. She gasped.

“It's alright, it's just lube,” Sunset said. “We'll need it, trust me.”

Sunset grinned as she lifted the butt plug into the air. It was emblazoned with her cutie mark on the gem. She lowered her other hand, squirting more of the lube onto Starlight's ass. She rubbed it in, inserting a finger into Starlight's asshole. Starlight grunted underneath her.

Sunset brought the butt plug down, teasing the perimeter of Starlight's hole with it before pushing it in. Starlight gasped as her asshole stretched to accommodate the girth of the plug.

“Wow... that's... wow...” Starlight panted. “How did you...?”

“Just because I've never had sex with anyone before doesn't mean I don't know how to pleasure myself,” Sunset said with a tiny grin. “I've had many a great nights inserting that into my ass and then fucking myself silly with my dildo.”

“Dildo?”

“Ah, right, you probably don't know what those are. Having access to magic means you can probably just create fake stallion cocks out of thin air, right?” Sunset said.

“...maybe.”

“I'm kind of envious of that, honestly. But this world has the next best thing,” Sunset said. She lifted something out from the drawer and set it where Starlight could see it. “We have this company here in this world, they call themselves 'Bad Dragon.' I bought this from them. I call him Chance.”

Starlight's eyes widened as she took in the sheer size of the stallionhood before her. It was certainly fake, but it's size was absolutely impressive, much more impressive than her own spells. She wasn't totally sure if she was going to be able to take the girth of the cock or not.

“I thought you liked...”

Sunset rolled her eyes. “Of course I like girls, but eating pussy isn't the only good thing about them. Having fun with toys is also a lot of fun. It's cleaner, and you don't need a guy for it.”

Starlight nodded. She shifted and spread her legs, waiting for Sunset to begin. She could feel the butt plug seated firmly in her asshole. It stretched her and pressed on her insides.

Sunset lifted the dildo, settling the head of it at the opening to Starlight's gaping pussy. She squirted some more lube on the latex and pushed the head inside.

Starlight gasped. She had never felt so full in her entire life. It was just the head but she felt as if she had taken the entire thing. She felt a mixture of fear and excitement, waiting for Sunset to insert more.

Sunset slowly pushed forward, burying the dildo a little deeper, and then a little deeper. She gave one final push, inserting it to the end where two massive stallion sized fake balls rested.

“You alright there?”

“Mmmph...” Starlight moaned, her face buried in the satin sheets.

Sunset grinned. She slowly withdrew the fake cock, pulling it completely out of Starlight's wet pussy. The head exited with a *plop*. She quickly reinserted it and pushed again, this time meeting no resistance from Starlight's inner walls.

“Mmmphh....!” Starlight shouted into the sheets. She turned her head to the side. “OH.... FUCK!”

She groaned. She could feel every inch of the fake cock inside of her. She could also feel when the cock rubbed against the bulge created by the butt plug. The sheer intensity of the sensation drove her wild. She was close to cumming, she had been when she'd tongue-fucked Sunset, but now she was even closer. Her eyes rolled into the back of her head and she started bucking her hips into the rhythm of the dildo.

Sunset obliged, withdrawing and inserting the cock at such a pace that even she was starting to feel the pressure in her loins again just by merely watching. She pushed in and out, harder and faster with every buck and thrust.

“Oh... shit shit shit,” Starlight groaned. “I can feel it. Every Celestia-damned inch of it! Keep going, it's so fucking good... oh Goddess...”

Sunset grinned and started slamming Starlight's pussy harder and harder with Chance, the massive stallion cock burying deep into her partner's love hole. She could feel that Starlight was unbearably close. She needed to push her over the edge, tip her over so that she could achieve the orgasm of her life.

Sunset gave a hungry growl and lowered her mouth to Starlight's asshole. As she continued to slam Chance harder into Starlight's pussy, she extended her tongue and began to lick the rim around the butt plug. She felt Starlight quiver.

“Oh oh oh oh oh! F-Ff-f-f-f-fuck! I'm... Oh fuck I'm coming, I'm coming I'm coming!!!!!”

Starlight groaned loudly as her orgasm reached its peak, spilling over and out of her body in the form of a thick viscous clear fluid. The fake cock slid out of her pussy as she gushed all over the bed and consequently all over Sunset. She squirted hard, feeling the butt plug pressing against her insides like it was forcing it all out. When she was finished, she slumped and fell onto the wet and sticky bed.

“Holy... wow... that was... what did you just do?” Sunset said, her eyes wide.

“I... I should have mentioned to you... I'm... I'm a squirter,” Starlight said weakly. She rolled over, feeling her tits getting wet from the fluid. “I'm sorry, I should have said something. Now I've gone and ruined your bed.”

Sunset rolled her eyes as she lay down next to Starlight. She too could feel the wetness that had come from Starlight, but she didn't care.

“It's fine. I can't say it's the first time I've ever had to do my sheets because I got them wet, but I can say it's the first time I've ever had a girl squirt on me. To be fair, it's my first time,” she said. She reached out and caressed Starlight's hair, rubbing down her neck. “You are something, Starlight Glimmer.”

“You too... Sunset Shimmer,” Starlight said. “Do you... mind if I take a shower? I feel kind of icky.”

“I'll do you one better,” Sunset said. “I'll join you. We can, oh... I dunno... have a little fun while we're in there?”

Starlight chuckled. “Sure. Sunset?”

“Yeah?”

“Thank you. Not just for... well you know... the sex, but thank you for accepting me, and wanting to be my friend. I've had a really hard time since that happened, and the only true friend I've had to show for it back in my world is Trixie,” Starlight said.

“Wait... you have Trixie in your world too?” Sunset asked.

“Yeah, is she nice here too?” Starlight said.

“She's... she's something,” Sunset said. “Anyways... I kind of wanted to thank you too. Doing this... showing me that I can be confident with another girl... it kind of makes me want to tell her how I feel. You know... the girl I saw in the locker room.”

“It was one of your friends, wasn't it?”

“How did you know?” Sunset asked.

“I kind of figured it out. I think if you just approach her and tell her what you think... she'll listen. She wouldn't be your friend if she didn't. Besides... even if she doesn't want to be your girlfriend, she's not going to stop being that,” Starlight said. “Wow... I kind of sounded like Twilight for a second.”

“Heh,” Sunset chuckled. “Yeah, you kind of did. You know what? I'm glad you came to visit, Starlight. You're welcome here anytime you want. Maybe the next time you visit, we can... do this again?”

“Won't the mystery girl not like that?” Starlight asked with a grin.

“Maybe she can join us?”

“...sounds hot.”

Author's Note

If you like what you've read here, consider supporting me on Patreon!