The sun had been set quite a while ago by the time I finally managed to return home, to where now I stood right outside... for the last five minutes.

There is a very good reason for this. I'm afraid of what Vinyl is going to do to me for being late. We had been planning what to do for when Octavia return from the day she had left for her retreat, and I'm the one who fucked that plan up. Because of how well I understand Vinyl, and the likely punishments that will happen for being late, my hesitance is quite understandable.

And quite easily explained, you're a cowered.

I don't need this right now Korvin. Go back to being locked in a cage.

I never left.

... Just shut up, I'm too tired for banter right now.

With that I felt his presence vanish, though it didn't help me think of a way out of my situation. Though I had stopped by an magic flower shop that I remember the girls mentioning offhand just as a possible solution, not that I expected it to get me out of trouble. I had gotten two very special flowers, one for each of them. The first the attendant at the shop called a glow rose, a flower that had been imbued with a small amount of electric magic to give a soft blue glow to a typical white rose. The other was called a wind lily, a simple white and purple lily with one special property, the colors continuously moved and twisted as if blown by the wind.

Now just as I worked up enough will to actually go in I heard Vinyl and Octavia through the door.

"Ok! I'm done waiting! I'm going out to find him, he is super late." I heard Vinyl.

"Vinyl just calm down, he probably has a good reason why he's late." Octavia spoke coolly.

"That doesn't excuse him. We had plans for when you got home and they're basically ruined because he decided to lose track of time."

I heard them get closer to the door as they continued talking. "What are you talking about? If you were planning to go to dinner or something that isn't something important enough to get angry about. We can always go another time." Octavia tried harder to calm Vinyl down

"It's not something as simple as dinner Tavi! It's way more important than that." I could hear Vinyl's voice dip at the end of that sentence.

"Vinyl you're not making any sense. What, were you going to ask me to make a herd with you guys or something?" Octavia partly joked.

I heard Vinyl go silent at Octavia guessing exactly what we wanted to talk to her about.

"Vinyl you're not serious are-"

I grabbed the door handle and opened the door before Octavia could finish asking her question, "Hello girls I'm sorry I'm so late, had to make a stop before coming home."

"Andrew! Where have you been?" Vinyl jumped a little in surprise because of my unexpected entrance.

I walked over to her and carefully took out the glow rose from my jacket pocket, "I wanted to get something for the mare I love. Can't I do that?" I asked rhetorically before handing the rose to the stunned mare and giving her a kiss.

Octavia looked on at our exchange with a smile, but it also contained a little sadness. Not wanting to let that sadness remain, I walked over to her after kissing Vinyl before retrieving the lily from the other side of my jacket, "And this one is for the mare that we've agreed that we want to share in that love." I say while present the flower to Octavia.

Now it was Octavia’s turn to be shocked. Octavia looked between the flower and me before looking to Vinyl as if to ask if she was dreaming. Vinyl just looked at her kindly with a smile and nodded to confirm. The next few seconds felt like an eternity as I waited for Octavia to take the flower, a fear flickered across my mind of what if she turned down the flower, one that grew as Octavia hesitated in taking the lily.

Then I felt my heart shatter when she quickly turned away and spoke a broken ‘N-no’. I couldn’t understand, I thought I had seen the signs, Vinyl said that she had too, but that one word shocked me more than anything I’ve dealt with in years.

However before I got a chance to respond Vinyl beat me to it, “What do you mean, ‘No’!?” Vinyl snapped at her best friend. “Octavia I’ve known you longer than anyone else besides my own parents, I can read and understand you usually better than you can do so for yourself. So explain to me why you just said the opposite of what I know you wanted to say.” Vinyl spoke feverishly.

Octavia turned back to us with tears streaking down her face, her voice stuttering as she fought through the tears, “B-because I’m damaged! I know you’re just trying to make me f-feel better and I appreciate it, but I know you can’t be serious. You already have each other and Andrew’s a human, I-I know enough about humanity to know that herds or polygamous relationships are taboo and almost no human would willingly consent to being in one.”

“You’re being ridiculous, Andrew doesn’t feel that way. We’ve talked about it before, you’ve been around when we have!” Vinyl argued.

“Stop trying to get my hopes up! There’s no way you’d want to make love to a known addict. What if it happened again? You’d both suffer for my mistake and I already feel bad enough that Andrew nearly got killed because of me, I couldn’t dare put you through that again.” Octavia broke down and fell to her knees. “I-I can’t let you l-love me knowing that you’ll just e-end up getting hurt, I c-care too m-much for both of you.” She sobbed out.

Vinyl was about to step forward and continue, but I caught her shoulder before she could. She looked back at me before realizing that I had a plan to deal with this, so she stepped back and let me try. I walked up to Octavia before kneeling in front of her and with a gentle hand brought up her chin so we could see each other’s eyes. Her beautiful mulberry orbs were red with tears, the fur on her face matted from them as well, but she still looked beautiful to me. So to prove what we were saying was true I did the first think that made sense in my mind, I quickly brought her lips to mine and kissed the gorgeous mare in front of me.

Octavia’s eyes grew wide at the contact and she tried to push me away, but when I saw her hands moving I grabbed her by the lower back and pulled her closer, deepening the kiss. Her hands slipped off my shoulders in her first attempt but she wasn’t done resisting. She firmly gripped my arms and tried to pull me away, and if I had still been normal she might have ended up hurting me. I felt a small tingle of energy flow through me to compensate for Octavia’s terran strength, which sparked an idea in me. I tried to prod her lips with my tongue but she was still resisting, though less than she had been, so I sent a small charge through my tongue to shock her. The reactionary pain was just what I needed to get her to open her lips just enough to let me deepen the kiss once further. I could see fresh tears start to fall as her grip on my arms started to loosen before falling to her sides. I softly cradled the back of her head as I continued kissing her, her eyes closed as she finally submitted to me while gently weeping while we kissed.

After a few more seconds I finally broke the kiss and pulled Octavia close as she gripped onto my shirt and wept into my shoulder. I felt Vinyl kneel down next to me and join in the embrace. The three of us knelt there until Octavia’s crying became more controlled. When she did she asked a question.

“Why won’t you two give up? I-I don’t deserve this much kindness. I don’t d-deserve to be loved by two people so wonderful.” Octavia’s voice could barely croak out from all her crying.

Vinyl responded for the both of us with, “Because you would never give up on us. You do deserve to be loved, and we do love you Octy, more than you realize. So no matter what you try to do, you aren’t going to get rid of us. We’re stubborn like that.”

Octavia chuckled at Vinyl’s joke, the tears finally appearing to have stopped when she looked up at us. “W-would you do something for me then?” She asked Vinyl.

“Anything, just name it.”

“Kiss me.” Octavia spoke shyly, looking away as she said it but then looking back at Vinyl for her answer.

Vinyl eagerly obliged her best friend, so eagerly in fact that she pushed Octavia to the floor were she made out her so intensely that it almost made me jealous. Though the small moans and eeps she got out of Octavia only truly served to turn me on. Vinyl apparently noticed this reaction because she I first saw her horn glow before feeling a tingle on my jeans. She was quick to undo my button and zipper before sliding the pants as far down as the could go from the kneeling position I was still in. I stood up so they could finish coming off just as Vinyl broke her kiss.

Octavia could see me now pantless and a blush showed through her dark coat as she glanced away. Vinyl got up before looking down at Octavia and saying, “We’re so not done yet, but lets continue in the bedroom.” She smiled down at Octavia before giving her a hand.

*Clop starts here*
If uncomfortable just skip to the end. Won’t majorly affect story.

Octavia took it and stood up, the blush on her face deepening as she knew what was about to happen. Vinyl took my hand with her free one and started towards the bedroom, a small flash of magic and I noticed the flowers I bought teleported into a small glass of water on the table as we passed by. Once we enter the bedroom I felt Vinyl pull me forward before pushing me onto the bed. I landed with an oof but didn’t have much time as I heard a short squeal as Vinyl repeated that action for Octavia pushing her on top of me. I had just enough time to bring up my hands and soften the impact so that neither one of us was hurt.

Vinyl crawled up onto the edge of the bed tracing a finger up Octavia’s dress until she found the zipper at the top. Octavia eeped as Vinyl undid the zipper in one fluid motion, the top of her dress fell down to reveal her surprisingly lacy violet bra, which barely covered her nipples leaving almost nothing to the imagination. Before Octavia was given a chance to think Vinyl had grabbed the sides of her loose dress and pulled it down and off her completely, causing Octavia to fall on top of me. We both opened our eyes to find our faces but mere inches from each other, each could feel the other’s breath on their skin or fur.

This time Octavia was the one to lean forward, our lips touched again, this time much softer and more controlled. I felt her tongue ask for entrance which I freely allowed as we deepened the kiss. My hands roamed over her soft fur as her hands tried to do the same, but I still had my shirt on. Just as we were going to break the kiss so that I could remove the troubling piece of clothing I heard a pop and felt the cool air hit my skin at the same time, Vinyl had decided to help so we didn’t have to stop. So we didn’t, our make out session continued for another minute or so before we finally broke for air. Our labored breathing only turning me on more as I felt Octavia’s breath hit my skin. Octavia then sat up to remove her bra, I saw her unclasp it from the front before letting the straps fall off her shoulders and letting it fall off her to the floor. Her breast were perky for their size with two bright pink erect nipples contrasting her dark fur. I felt hypnotized as she leaned back in and kissed me again, her breast pressing into me as I felt my hands return to massaging her back.

“Ok, main mare being left out here.” Vinyl interrupted us.

We both looked over to Vinyl to see her already completely nude and rubbing her thighs together wantingly. “That may be extremely hot, and I might feel a little bad for interrupting but this mare needs some attention too.” Vinyl semi-whines to us.

Octavia moves to the side to make room for Vinyl who quickly joins us and eagerly kisses me. As we make out I slip a hand between her legs and begin to rub her dripping snatch. Vinyl squirms under my touch as she continues to invade my mouth with her tongue. I glance over to see Octavia biting her lip as her hand slowly rubs her own clit through her panties. Vinyl breaks the kiss before looking over to Octavia herself and saying.

“Oh no, enough of that I’m done being the only one nude.” She says while lighting her horn.

With a short flash I see Octavia panties disappear and I feel my underwear vanish as well. Octavia obviously noticed as this fact as she averted her eyes with her blush returning with full force. Vinyl grinned at this before she grabbed my cock and nuzzled it with her soft cheek.

“What’s the matter Tavi? Don’t you want to see the thing that is going to take your cherry.” She teased, but her words caused me to pause.

I sat up, making Vinyl move away with a huff of annoyance. “Tavi is that true? Are you a virgin?”

Octavia never looked more embarrassed as she answered, “W-what of it. There are lot’s of mares my age that are virgins.”

“No that’s not what I’m saying.” I reassured her as I used a hand to make her look at me. “Are you ok with giving something that special to me?”

Octavia looked shocked that I would be concerned with such a thing, her eyes started to water again but this time she was smiling. “Of course I am, Andrew. I can’t think of anyone else that I’d willing to give this to. I love you, and I want this honor to be yours, I’ve wanted it for a while actually.” She spoke the last part in barely above a whisper.

“Then who am I to deny a beautiful mare’s wish.” I said as I leaned in and kissed her again.

While I was kissing Octavia, Vinyl got impatient and decided to get my attention by swallowing my cock in one go. I moaned as Vinyl continued to suck and bob her head, Octavia chose this point to push into me which caused me to fall backwards. Once I was on my back Octavia broke the kiss and moved down to join Vinyl. They shared a non verbal agreement and switched places, with Vinyl being quite eager to catch my lips with hers. I felt Octavia be much more tentative, though Vinyl appeared to get annoyed with the shyness as she used her magic to lightly force Octavia’s head down onto my cock. Her mouth seemed smaller than Vinyl’s by the fact there was much stronger suction as she tried to pull her head back up, which Vinyl allowed until she was about to let my cock out of her mouth before forcing it back down. This became a steady rhythm and once Octavia had taken over the action with Vinyl’s help disappearing I began to compare the differences between the two.

Vinyl was more of a fan of using her broad tongue to bring me to complete euphoria, while Octavia seemed to like using her strong lungs to create strong suction almost as she was trying to suck my cum right out of my balls. Both felt great in their unique ways and I honestly couldn’t say one was better than the other. It was so great in fact that I could feel my climax nearing its peak. I tried to tell Octavia but all I could make out was a loud moan as Vinyl’s tongue ravished my mouth. There was no way she couldn’t tell what was about to happen from the amount of twitching I felt from my dick, but she kept going.

I couldn’t hold it back any more and I felt the wave of pleasure hit me stronger than when I had been with Vinyl alone. Vinyl’s vanilla scented musk was filling the room along with a berry-like scene which I could only assume was coming from Octavia, I’d never get tired of the pleasant smelling musk these ponies gave off, it only served to turn me on more. Octavia swallowed my entire load like it was her favorite drink and released my cock from her mouth with a pop. A shudder ran through me as Vinyl pulled back and I got a look at the twin predatory gazes that were locked on me.

Octavia and Vinyl again seemed to share some none verbal agreement as Octavia swung her leg over and straddled herself over my cock as Vinyl did the same over my head so that her pussy was dripping its juices onto my lips and into my mouth. I was able to see glimpses as Vinyl used her magic to line up my cock with Octavia’s own dripping pussy, I could feel the intense heat coming from her as my tip touched her entrance. Octavia hesitated here which got Vinyl’s attention. Vinyl noticed her hesitance and moved her hands so that one was on Octavia’s hip and the other on her cheek. “You ready, cause there is no going back now.” Vinyl asked calmly.

Octavia gave a small nod, too worried her voice would fail her. She grabbed one of my hands and placed it on the other side of her hip from where Vinyl’s hand was, as a means of telling me she was ready. So with both of our encouragement Vinyl and I pushed down and I broke Octavia’s hymen. She winced at the pain it caused but Vinyl distracted her by planting her lips on Octavia’s. My view was obscured as Vinyl pressed her pussy down on my face and ground herself on me in longing for some attention, so I obliged.

I thrust my tongue as far as I could into Vinyl and did whatever I could think of as I also focused on the pressure of Octavia’s pussy on my dick. Her velvet insides were so tight that I almost though she would hurt herself if she tried to force it too far to fast. The moaning caused by the three of us was no doubt loud but I don’t think any of us cared one bit. The pleasure we were giving and receiving from each other was pure euphoria for our brains, and I know I could barely think straight as Octavia’s vise grip of a vagina was heavenly as she bounced her hips as a rapid pace for someone who had been a virgin only moments earlier. Vinyl was squirming more on my face as she was getting close to her own orgasm as I felt my climax rising once more. Octavia wasn’t able to hold on however and her pussy began to convulse and squeeze with almost painful pressure. This seemed to be just what was needed to reach my own as I use one arm to force Octavia down onto my hips as far as they could go as I used my other to force Vinyl harder onto my face as I thrust my tongue as far as I could possibly go, which made her reach her own orgasm.

The three of us road our collective orgasm before Vinyl fell to my side and Octavia collapsed on top of me. My sperm leaked out of Octavia as she cuddled into me. Though I wasn’t quite done yet. Vinyl was the first to recover as she pushed herself up and took Octavia’s spot over my hips. She wasted no time in inserting my cock into her waiting pussy and bouncing at a rapid pace.

Octavia seemed to like what she was watching so she got up to her knees and surprised the both of us by attacking Vinyl’s nipples with her mouth. Not wanting her to be left out I took my middle and ring fingers and shoved them into her pussy, she squealed a little at the unexpected penetration but did not stop her sucking on Vinyl’s nipples.

Vinyl after got a mischievous glint in her eye before winking at me. I didn’t realize what she was about to do, and I doubt Octavia did either, until I saw her sweep Octavia’s tail to the side just before shoving to fingers into her ass. Octavia squealed loudly at the mixture of pain and pleasure of having her anus unexpectedly penetrated, which caused her pussy clamped down so hard I could barely move my fingers and I saw her bite down on Vinyl’s nipple, hard. If she wasn’t a herbivore by race she probably would have drawn blood, though Vinyl’s nipple would be bruised for sure, Vinyl let out a squeal of her own at Octavia’s reaction which in turn brought pleasure to me as her pussy clamped down on me.

Moaning soon returned as the three of us settled into a rhythm, Vinyl shaking her hips on my cock, Octavia being double teamed as she tended to Vinyl, and myself trying my best to pleasure two mare at the same time. After several more minutes I could tell that all of us were just about to give out from the pleasure and fatigue it was bringing, though all of us were on the brink of what would likely be our last orgasm as well.

I tried my best to hold back until I felt one of the other mares climax but Vinyl’s pussy broke that hope. I attempted to warn Vinyl but all I could do was grunt as pleasurable euphoria shocked my body as I ejaculated into my beautiful marefriend. This apparently was just what Vinyl needed to go over the edge as well as I felt her clamp down as her pussy did its best to milk me of every last drop I could make. Our two orgasms caused us to curl our fingers which since some of which were in Octavia the pressure and timing of the action caused for each of us to get each other to climax.

*Clop ends. No explicit action past this point.

Once we came down from our high the two mare collapsed, one on each side of me. I put my arms around my mares lovingly as they cuddled into my sides. Vinyl magicked our pillows down so they were under our heads and we were comfortable. As Octavia squeezed into my side a bit more and sighed contently I decided to ask her a question.

“So Tavi, do you want to join our herd?” I smiled down at her, knowing I was being cheesy.

She chuckled at me before looking back at me and giving me a brief but passionate kiss before replying with, “Only if this can happen again.”

Vinyl beat me to the response with her own quip, “You’d better just kill me now if it doesn’t.” She joked before yawning.

We all chuckled at that before we started to feel the pull of sleep on our minds. I squeezed the mares a bit tighter before I closed my eyes and focused on the pleasant tiredness that made me proud and happy as I though to myself.

If I could just stay in this moment for eternity I would be ok with it. I now have two beautiful mares that love me as much as I adore them. Whatever comes next I am sure of one thing, I’m not going to let these two go for anything, just try and prove me wrong life. For I think in the first time in my life I have something that I would do anything to keep.

Author's Note

Ok this took a bit longer than I figured to complete, but I'm pleased with how it turned out.

I'm still a bit self conscious about writing sex scenes, mainly because I never though I would. I hope you guys enjoyed the chapter and keep reading as I continue to write.

That's really all I have, don't worry the next chapter will be longer and containing more story, until then.

Stay awesome everyone, Lyruil out.