The Real Reason Luna Became Nightmare Moon

by Bendy

Rating: mature
Tags: Princess Celestia, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Nightmare Moon, Princess Luna, Comedy, Random
Length: 1679

The true story why Princess Luna became Nightmare Moon.

The true story why Princess Luna became Nightmare Moon.

Published 2016-01-18 18:00:07 UTC
Last updated 2016-01-18 18:00:07 UTC

How Luna Became Nightmare Moon

A beautiful, dark blue alicorn happily flew through a light blue magical mist high in the lavender night sky. The stars above twinkled as hundreds upon thousands of beds floated in mid air above the clouds. Upon each bed was a pony, whom were fast asleep. The wind somehow had not shifted their thick and warm blankets in any way.

A smile came upon Luna’s face when she heard a nearby stallion utter sensual moans in his sleep. He was a most handsome earth pony stallion. Luna knew him to be Big Apple Mac, who had one of the largest penises in all of Equestria.

"Oh Luna, you’re so beautiful" the huge red stallion muttered in his sleep.

A bright red blush came upon her face upon hearing his words. "We find thy words most pleasant," she said softly, looking at him with bedroom eyes. "Perhaps, we should visit thee outside of the dreamscape for a romantic--

"Oh Luna, your sister is even hotter."

"WHAT???!!!!!!!" she roared in the traditional royal canterlot voice.

"I mean yeah, you got a lovely sweet big fat butt. But it is nothing when compared to Princess Celestia’s vastly superior, bigger and fatter butt."

Hot steam began to emit off Luna’s forehead. "How dare thee insult our royal posterior! she boomed. "Why our butt isn’t as big as Celestia’s butt, it still has it own unique beauty and--

"Bah! Luna get out of my dream. Your butt is so bony thin when compared to Celestia’s massive fat rump," bellowed a floating alabaster stallion from behind her. The sleeping stallion had a dark blue mane with a few light blue stripes running through it.

Luna’s eyes narrowed angrily upon noticing who it was. To add insult to injury this particular stallion was the most handsome one around, not to mention he had the biggest penis in all the world, not even Big Apple Mac’s penis could compare to it.

"Shining Armorer Sparkle, oh how we hate thee! Thou in the waking world always cruelly rejects us from joining in a threesome with our sister!" she roared, glaring daggers at the sleeping stallion.

She shook her head. "We must calm down, surely more of our handsome subjects love our royal big fat backside."

The alicorn’s eyes flashed with blinding light as her horn lit up with an azure glow. Her magic allowed her to hear everypony in all of Equestria at once. Mere mortal minds would break upon hearing so much noise. Luna being a mighty alicorn goddess was able to listen in carefully to each dream’s voice at once.

The dreamers called out both Luna’s and Celestia’s name, uttering praise to their royal backsides. However, tears soon began to flow down Luna’s cheeks when she noticed that her butt was only being praised by a small minority, the vast majority of which were praising Celestia’s butt.

Each harsh word through Luna’s mind stabbed her like a knife. The voices were unrelenting and cruel as they mocked Luna’s butt.

‘Luna’s butt is so ugly and thin, Celestia’s butt is so much bigger and fatter,’ came a voice.

‘Hah! Luna’s butt is so small when compared to Celestia’s vastly superior big fat butt,’ was another.

‘Luna’s butt is so skinny and flat like a pancake when compared to Celestia’s much bigger and fatter butt,’ came another one.

Luna uttered a sad whine, before rearing her front hooves up, placing them upon her ears to try stop herself from hearing the voices.

'I never masturbated even once to Luna’s butt at night before I went to sleep,’ came yet another one.

Luna choked from hearing the final one, before dropping her hooves to tightly grip her chest. "Nu-no. We are not listening!" she bellowed, her eyes becoming moist and her lower lip was quivering.

'I only fucked Luna’s ugly thin butt once so I could get a better chance to fuck Celestia’s much bigger and fatter butt.'

That did it, Luna then proceeded to cry like a baby. Wailing in grief over the harsh words uttered by the cruel ponies, like a river tears fell down her cheeks.

"But-but… I thought my subjects loved me?" came her voice, low and broken.

In the corner of her eye she saw a dark shadow slowly make its way towards her.

"It’s Celestia’s fault! spoke a deep demonic voice. "Her butt is unfairly big and fat. Thou must overthrow her. With Celestia out of the way, your subjects shall love thy butt more. Not Celestia’s butt."

"No… I-I…. Celestia is good and kind. She loves us and she almost always invite us to a threesome with a handsome sta--

"She only does that because she pities thou. Celestia keeps the biggest phalluses of Equestria all to herself. Overthrow her and thee shall get all the big phallus going up thy butt."

Luna growled angrily. "You’re right! Celestia only cares about her bigger and fatter butt! Not my bony thin butt!" she boomed, her eyes flashing with blinding light.

"YES! Let the hate flow through you!" boomed the dark shadow as it flew toward her.

Luna’s mouth opened wide in shock as the darkness smothered her. Her horn sparked uselessly as she thrashed wildly to try push away the dark magic latching onto her. Her coat changed from dark blue to jet black, starting from her rump and slowly making its way across her body.

Tears fell down upon her dark blue cheeks, just before they were completely transformed black. Once the darkness took control, her tears stopped flowing.

The look of horror upon her face was replaced with a look of pure rage, her teeth baring and eyes narrowed to pin pricks There came a flash, followed by a helmet materializing upon her head.

"We shall have the greatest butt in all of Equestria. Celestia’s butt shall fall! All shall love me and despair!” she boomed in a sinister, deep voice. Lost was the sweet angelic voice that once was Luna’s.

Luna opened her eyes, said eyes narrowed angrily upon seeing a poster of the flag of Equestria, showcasing a small dark blue sphere upon the left side, next to a much bigger white sphere to the right.

"AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRGGGHHHH!!!!!!!" she roared in pure rage, destroying the poster by blasting a massive hole in the wall with a bright blue particle beam from her horn.

With that Luna stormed out of bed, trotting through the hole in the wall over the melted stone beneath her. The guards along the hall did do nothing but stay quiet and piss themselves in fear as the enraged alicorn walked past them.

Elsewhere Princess Celestia herself was fast asleep upon her red love heart shaped bed.

"Mmm! Butt fattening cake," she moaned in her sleep."

Suddenly, there came a loud banging sound upon her door. With a groan, Celestia slowly open her eyes.

"Oh, what is it Luna?" Celestia groaned, stumbling out of bed, before she slowly made her way to the door. "This better be important."

When Celestia opened the door with a flick of her magic, she gasped in shock upon seeing how different Luna looked.

"Luna? Is that you?" she said, dumbfounded.

"I am not Luna! I am Nightmare Moon!" she boomed, her voice blasting into Celestia’s face like a galeforce wind, causing her flowing mane to fly wildly about.

"Ow! My ears!" she shouted, before she shouted even louder in her mighty alicorn voice. "There’s no need to be so loud!" she boomed back, causing the dark alicorn’s mane to flow wildly about in return.

"There can only be one princess in Equestria! And that princess will be me!, she roared, stomping her hooves. Her super alicorn strength caused the floor to crack beneath her.

"Luna, what has made you so upset?" she said in a low, soft voice.

"Your butt! Our small, bony thin butt can’t ever hope to compete against thy much bigger and fatter butt!" her horn pulsed with power as she grinded her teeth together. "And that is why I must destroy you!"

With that Luna blasted a powerful beam of magic at her. Fortunately, Celestia quickly managed to summon a golden, sphere shaped shield around her body.

"What has happened to you?! Who said your butt was bony thin? Your beautiful butt is so big and fat!" she shouted in panic.

"LIES!" she boomed. "Did you really expect me to sit idly by while they all basked in your glorious big fat butt?"

"Butt Luna, many ponies love your butt too and--

"Only very few! Most of which worship thy royal fat pony butt! Not mine!" she angrily retorted with a harsh glare.

"Whatever darkness has consumed you, please fight it! I don’t want to fight you! Is there anything I can do to help cheer you up?! Like force Shining Armorer Sparkle to agree to a threesome or something?!" she shouted, looking at her with pleading doggy eyes.

"It is too late for that!" she boomed, blasting another beam of magic at her magic shield, small cracks forming upon it.

"I..I… I didn’t want to do this. But, you have left me with no choice," she said in a low voice, tears falling down her cheeks.

With that Celestia’s horn lit up with golden light. There came a flash and magical jewels floated around her body.

"I would cure you of your insanity! But the Elements of Harmony only allow me to banish you to the moon as a single user!" she shouted, her body flashing with rainbow light.

"Noooooooooooooo!" Nightmare Moon screamed, kicking her legs in the air as she was blasted by rainbows.

"See you in a thousand years," she said in a low voice, tears flowing down her cheeks.

‘Note to self. Write in the history books that the event was about her going crazy about the night not being long enough or something. The truth would be too embarrassing for Luna,’ came her thoughts.

And that was the true reason Luna became Nightmare Moon.

The End