Colgate's Personal Pet

by Duelist96

Rating: mature
Tags: Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Colgate, Romance, Sex, Lightning Dust, Slice of Life, Berry Punch, Alternate Universe, Human
Length: 11616

Mistress Colgate loves trying out new things with her lovely pet Sarah. What decadent surprises will Sarah’s lovely Mistress devise next?

Sarah has been happily dating Colgate for four years. They have learned much about each other, both intimately and emotionally. Colgate is the greatest friend Sarah could ever ask for, even more so as their relationship developed. Tonight, Colgate has a surprise for her, and Sarah is eager to see what it is. When Colgate returns, Sarah gets more than what she could’ve hoped for. Will she able to handle the two new guests? And what else does Colgate have in store for her?

Editors: Word Worthy, Jay The Stormtrooper, Rumble, and Vic Viper

Cover Art: goldenmercurydragon

Published 2016-02-01 07:20:02 UTC
Last updated 2016-02-01 07:20:02 UTC

Bringing Home Another Pet

Colgate’s Personal Pet
By: Duelist96
Chapter 1: Bringing Home Another Pet

Sarah sat alone in her house, her body bare to the world, but only to those fortunate enough to stumble into the building and see her natural beauty. Her raven black hair with twin stripes of blue and purple reached the small of her back. Her gorgeous hazel eyes would occasionally glance from the book she was reading to the front door. Sadly, there was still no sight of her Mistress, so she laid the book down on her lap as she stretched. Her sizeable breasts bounced slightly as she leaned back several times, a moan of contentment escaping her lips as a few bones popped in her back.

Even as the sun shone brightly, the blinds were still closed to give her some privacy. Sarah didn’t mind being naked in the house, knowing Colgate, she would not mind either, but she did not see it proper to flaunt herself to the rest of the small town. It was true that the ponies of Ponyville did not wear clothing, and it wouldn’t be that different if Sarah did the same. She chose this more so because she wanted to maintain some of her own culture.

It has been eight years since Sarah arrived in Equestria, and she has adapted well to her new life. Fortunately, the ponies took her in with open hooves; a certain hyperactive pink party pony made it known to the whole town how ecstatic she was to make a brand new friend. Even with the headaches that Pinkie sometimes brought upon Sarah’s head, she knew how to be a good friend. During her first year in Equestria, Sarah actually stayed with Princess Twilight Sparkle until she was able to get her own place. After helping Twilight and her friends with some work, along with some assistance from Princess Luna, Sarah was finally able to purchase her humble abode.

Immediately after moving out of Twilight’s crystal castle, she decided to get a steadier job. This didn’t mean that Sarah was no longer helping her friends, for she was still always eager to offer her assistance if they needed it. She just wanted something that was a little more enjoyable. She got a job working with Colgate, her real name being Minuette, but she preferred her nickname. Colgate is the town’s local dentist, and surprisingly enough, a close friend of Twilight Sparkle.

Sarah couldn’t help but laugh at a particular memory, mainly her initial meeting with her future lover. During her first visit, what would soon be her regular yearly appointment, she actually guessed her name by accident. It didn’t help that Colgate had a mane and tail that was blue with a grey stripe that reminded Sarah of toothpaste. Colgate inquired as to where Sarah had heard her name, and after she admitted to how it came about, they started a slowly budding friendship. Sarah visited Colgate’s office often since she would always have her work finished earlier than most ponies, and would simply talk with about one thing or another.

After several months, Sarah asked if she could be her assistant since she had some basic knowledge of dentistry. Colgate happily accepted the offer, quickly getting Sarah up to speed on everything that she needed to know. It was certainly surprising seeing how much Colgate needed assistance around her office. There were four other dentists that worked in the office, but it didn’t seem to be adequate. Things went significantly more swimmingly as Sarah was able to handle most of the instruments while Colgate focused on her main job.

Two years had passed, and Sarah finally received news on her ability to return home. Sadly, it wasn’t the news she had hoped for. Neither of the princesses, or Twilight, were able to figure out a way to get her back to her planet safely without possibly sending her to a completely different world or dimension. Sarah became morose upon hearing the horrible revelation, resorting to visiting a local bar to numb the pain her heart felt.

Thankfully, Colgate caught on to her friend’s plight and helped her in any way she could. Whenever Sarah went to the bar, Colgate would take the time to accompany her as a drinking buddy, and to also make sure that she didn’t end up utterly shit-faced at the end of the night. No matter where Sarah went, Colgate was always right there beside her, finding any reason to talk with her.

It was a slow process, but after several months, Sarah was able to come to terms with her situation. With no other option, Sarah would have to build a new life, in a crazy little town where random shenanigans can occur at any time. Including evil demon gods trying to take over the world, or a giant bugbear trying to destroy the town. Although, Sarah does try to have a normal life.

Four years into her new life, Sarah received a pleasant surprise. Colgate had made her stay after work, saying that she had something she wished to speak to her about. Sarah was more than willing to stay longer to see what her friend wanted. After all the other ponies left, leaving just the two of them, Colgate locked up the doors and quickly turned towards Sarah.

To this day, Sarah could still feel her heart flutter after what happened next. Colgate had finally gained the courage to reveal her true feelings for her best friend. It was jarring to say the least, and the silence that Sarah let hang in the air worried Colgate that she had possibly gone too far. Upon remembering what Twilight said about interspecies dating and how trivial it was, and her desperate need for companionship in a world with no human males, Sarah came to a rather quick decision.

She heartily accepted Colgate’s offer, and now they are together and still going strong for the past four years. Over the years, they learned a lot about each other, both intimately and emotionally as their relationship went along. Eventually, they built a strong mutual trust, to the point where Sarah was able to convince Colgate to try out one of her deepest fantasies: to be dominated in the bedroom. To say that it went easy the first few rounds would be an utter lie. It took quite a bit of time for Colgate to get a handle on being Sarah’s Mistress. There were even nights where Colgate would be gone for a long period of time, and Sarah was never aware of where she went exactly. It seemed, though, that every time her Mistress returned, she came with more confidence and conviction. That is to say if the few thrown beds were any proof.

There was one subject that strained their relationship, but after some time talking it out, they were able to move past it. All her life, Sarah was used to having one lover at a time, whereas Equestria, mares and stallions would get together into herds. After living in a monogamous society, polygamy was something she would have to adjust to. This wasn’t for a lack of trying, having attempted to bring other ponies, Sarah just wasn’t able to go through with it. Forming a herd was a normality amongst the ponies, but her human instincts disallowed her to join one herself.

Even with the differences in their cultures, they have had wonderful times together.

Sarah gave another look towards the door and barely spotted the knob being sheathed in a light azure magical aura. Recognizing the color instantly, Sarah put her book on the coffee table and rose up from her seat. She stood in a sensual pose, her left arm covering her erect nipples while her right hand covered her vagina. It was something she felt would please her Mistress, and it was always met with a great reward.

The door opened to a familiar face that Sarah woke up to every morning. As the door opened further, Sarah took the time to admire Colgate’s beautiful sapphire eyes. Her eyes would always give a little glint whenever she was happy, and it was always infectious to Sarah. Letting her eyes wander further, she took in the brushed blue coat. As her eyes traveled further down, she reached one of her favorite places. On Colgate’s flank was her cutie mark, a hourglass that Sarah was happy to learn was very sensitive to touch.

“Sarah, are you home?” Colgate’s cheerful and angelic voice called out.

“Yes, Mistress. I’m in the living room,” Sarah replied in a slightly salacious tone, her heart racing in anticipation for the things to come.

Sarah heard the door close, already feeling her arousal on the horizon. It took much of her willpower not to run for the front door and present herself to her beautiful Mistress. It had been such a long time since they’ve been able to have a lot of free time together, and when they did, they made sure to make the most of it. As Sarah bounced on her toes, she heard the familiar clopping of hooves. Although, there was something different about them. She had come to learn that all ponies had a distinct sound when walking on their hooves, but Colgate’s seemed to be mixed in with two others.

Shaking her head, Sarah put it up to her just hearing things as she continued to wait. It wasn’t long before Colgate appeared in the living room, her bright smile instantly getting her to grin happily as well. Unfortunately, the smile faded quickly when she spotted the source of the other two sounds of hooves. Looking at the two ponies, she took quick note about their appearances. The one to Colgate’s left was a pegasus while the one on the right was a familiar earth pony.

The earth pony was the town’s resident bar owner and occasional drunkard, Berry Punch. Her mane and tail were a poofy cerise while her eyes were a slightly darker cerise, allowing for a little contrast between her colors. Her coat was a light mulberry with her strawberry and grapes cutie mark that was proudly presented on her flank. Berry Punch had a slight tinge of red going across her face, but those that know her well understood she has a high alcohol tolerance. Even with the small sign of inebriation, she was still very quick with her wits.

The pegasus had her eyes turned to the floor, but she gave a quick glance up that allowed Sarah to see her beautiful gamboge eyes. Her coat was a light turquoise with her mane and tail being amber with gold stripes running through them. On her flank was a lightning bolt with three stars near the point. Sarah wasn’t familiar with the new pony, but she did spot something peculiar. Around the pegasus’ neck was a collar with a tag. She couldn’t make out if the tag said anything on it, but it was clear that it was designed after Berry Punch’s cutie mark.

“Mmm, your pet looks quite ravishing, Colgate,” Berry Punch said, a modest slur in her voice, gaining Sarah’s attention.

Sarah saw Berry’s eyes looking her up and down, and she gasped, reaching instinctively for a blanket that was folded up on the couch; she quickly covered the entire front of her body. Berry’s buzzed grin wrinkled into a frown. Sarah thought it was pointed at her, but realized her attention was elsewhere. Sarah saw Colgate sheepishly rub the back of her neck as she avoided eye contact. Throwing aside her previous mindset, she addressed Colgate.

“You… didn’t say you would be bringing any guests.” Sarah frowned, giving a quick glance to the two ponies in the back before settling her gaze on Colgate.

Colgate gave a nervous laugh as she scraped her hoof against the floor, only giving brief glances up to Sarah before returning her attention towards the ground.

“Remember that surprise I told you about? Well this is it!” Colgate said, her horn glowing faintly. “You already know Berry here, but the mare next to her is her marefriend/pet, Lightning Dust.”

This sparked a past memory in Sarah’s mind as she recalled Rainbow Dash talking about a particular pony by that name.

“Do you mean the same Lightning Dust that endangered many of the new recruits that were trying out for the Wonderbolts with a giant tornado that got out of control?” Sarah asked, her attention switching to the aforementioned pony as she shrank back from the question.

“Yes, but I wouldn’t say her attitude is the same from before,” Berry answered as she stepped forward, Lightning following right behind her.

Sarah felt her body relax a little, the feelings of lust and excitement returning to her. Sarah’s eyes quickly moved over to Colgate, realizing what her devilish mistress was up to. “Mint!” Sarah said sternly.

Colgate’s horn went dim, and Sarah felt all the residual magic leave her body. As she was about to chastise Colgate for trying to manipulate her like that, Berry spoke up before her.

“Very good, Colgate. She uses the safety word when she needs to and you respond appropriately,” Berry said, giving an approving smile to both Sarah and Colgate.

“W-What are you talking about?” Sarah asked, glancing nervously between Colgate and Berry.

“Sarah,” Colgate started, getting Sarah’s attention immediately, “Berry is one of my closest friends, and she also taught me how to be a proper Mistress for you,” she explained, giving a nervous smile.

Sarah looked at Berry, a confused look on her face. “Since when does she have knowledge about this?” Sarah asked, trying to comprehend this situation.

“I’ve been a trainer for new dominatrices for a while, but only my close friends know of my… little hobby,” Berry answered happily.

Sarah sat down on the couch, rubbing her head as she tried to process this information. She had no idea how to properly react to learning that a pony that she considered a friend was a Mistress, but knew about her wildest fantasy as well. Giving a deep sigh, she looked back over at Berry and Lightning, one question lingering in her mind.

“How long have you been with Lightning Dust? Last time we talked, you were still single so you could look after your daughter,” Sarah asked, looking at the both of them.

Berry gave a warm laugh as she put a foreleg around Lightning’s neck and pulled her close. “This little pony made a bet that she lost,” she answered, giving a grin to Lightning.

“Did she challenge you to a drinking contest?” Sarah asked, somewhat aware of what the answer would be.

“She did, and she had quite the mouth on her, constantly boasting that she could beat me, but somepony bit off more than she could chew when we reached the sixth round,” Berry cooed, giving a quick nuzzle to her pet.

“So is this going to be a quick thing… or something more?” Sarah asked as she adjusted her blanket a little.

“She was actually supposed to be my helper for a month, but she poked her nose where it didn’t belong,” Berry explained, booping Lightning on the nose. “She found my collection of toys underneath the bar, and she seemed very eager for me to teach her a few things,” she said, kissing Lightning’s cheek affectionately.

“Then one thing led to another, and I find myself enjoying her company. I actually didn’t notice how lonely it’s been until I got my lovely little pet. Now we’ve been together for two years, and I’m actually excited to present her as my marefriend,” Berry said, a smile gracing her lips before she turned back towards Sarah.

“I see. Well, I’m happy for the two of you,” Sarah said, smiling at them before returning to Colgate who was giving a small smile to her. “So what exactly was your surprise?” she asked with a raised brow.

Colgate’s smile widened as she trotted up next to Sarah, joining her on the couch and nuzzled her. “Berry here was wondering how everything has been going between us since teaching me how to be a proper Mistress, and she wanted her pet to have another pet she could play with,” Colgate said, her voice taking on a sensual purr.

Sarah moved a hand free of her blanket and stroked Colgate’s mane as she looked at their guests. “So there’s no catch? Just a simple night of sex?” Sarah asked with slight concern.

“Of course. I’m not going to try to push herding on you. This is just meant to be a fun night for all of us, but if you don’t want to, you don’t have to,” Colgate explained in a serious tone.

Looking at Colgate for a few seconds, Sarah rustled Colgate’s mane before moving off the couch. She walked towards Lightning Dust, kneeling down as the latter glanced up at her before quickly looking away. Sarah ran a hand through Lightning’s mane, wordlessly asking her to look up. She searched her features, moving her blanket a little to reveal her feminine figure. She took quick notice of the heavy blush that spread across Lightning’s face. Sarah laughed and smiled, giving a quick kiss to her forehead before standing up and rejoining Colgate on the couch.

Colgate gave Sarah a curious look as she was pulled into the blanket. “I think I’m up for this, but only if they understand what our rules are,” Sarah said, pressing Colgate against her left breast.

“I told them the rules, and they’ll follow them to the letter,” Colgate said confidently.

Sarah gave a quiet moan as she felt Colgate already start, her teeth nibbling at her erect nipples. She fell back against the couch, her mouth hanging open as she felt the broad, dexterous tongue lick all around her mound. The blanket that was covering her was wrapped in Colgate’s magical aura and thrown across the room. Sarah heard the low whistle that Berry gave as a gasp emanated from Lightning. Sarah moved to wrap Colgate closer to her body, but felt her arms and legs weighed down.

Looking at her limbs, she saw the magical restraints that were in place. The couch unfolded, turning to a bed so that they were comfortable. Unable to move, Sarah panted heavily as another surge of magic went through her body, but this time it wasn’t unwelcome. She could feel her insides burning, her pussy leaking juices as it begged for attention. She was going to be tended to, but not by her Mistress. The bed shifted a little before she looked down to see Berry and Lightning had joined them. Sarah watched as Berry moved Lightning closer to her body, more specifically, her inviting pussy.

“Take a look, my little pet. She’s already dripping for attention, and I think you should get first taste for behaving so well,” Berry said, gently pushing Lightning’s face close to Sarah’s delicate folds.

Sarah watched with rapt attention as Lightning stuck out her tongue, Berry’s hoof reaching behind and pulling something out. A small moan emanated from Lightning’s throat as a butt plug was pulled out of her, Berry’s cutie mark engraved on the bottom of it. Sarah’s cheeks burned red as she shifted on the bed, her mind awash at how long Lightning had that inside of her. Her thought was soon cut short as she felt a warm, wet muscle begin lapping at her folds. All Sarah could do was arch her back in pleasure as she tried to press further into Lightning’s muzzle.

Sarah panted heavily, her eyes glazed over with lust as Colgate moved further up her body. She felt something to her right and saw Berry sitting next to her, legs spread wide as her pussy winked in greeting. Berry had her hoof rubbing away at her folds, her essence quickly spilling forth and staining the bed. Sarah wanted to taste her so badly that she would do anything for even a single lick. It seemed that Colgate was reading her thoughts as her pussy soon came into view.

“You may have a taste, but only after I receive attention first, pet,” Colgate said sternly, further stoking the fire inside of Sarah.

“Yes, my Mistress,” Sarah said, licking her lips as Colgate lowered herself.

It wasn’t long before Sarah went to work on her blue slit, her tongue quickly collecting the delicious minty juices that Colgate secreted. Sarah listened to the moans that came out of Colgate’s mouth, encouraging her to work even faster. She sensually ran her tongue up and down the moist labia, giving her engorged clit a quick flick of her tongue before running along the slit again. Colgate ground herself against Sarah’s face, her eyes clenched shut and her mouth wide open as she kept herself firmly planted. Sarah closed her eyes tight, focusing on pleasuring her Mistress, but found it hard with Lightning licking away at her folds.

Sarah poked her tongue against Colgate’s entrance and entered. The velvet walls of her mistress’ pussy gripped at her tongue like it was a cock, naturally trying to milk it for any possible seed. When she poked her tongue inside of Colgate, Lightning did the same and earned a scream of pleasure from Sarah. Lightning’s astounding tongue work was breathtaking as her dexterous muscle hit all the right spots, getting her to hump her muzzle.

The fire inside of Sarah was turning into a raging inferno as she tried to get her Mistress to reach her climax, furiously working with her tongue. As she continued to lick furiously, she discovered that she once again had free movement of her arms. She wasn’t sure when this had happened, but she took quick advantage of the opportunity. She gripped her Mistress’ flanks and dug in her nails where her cutie mark was. Sarah was rewarded with a squeal of pleasure as Colgate pressed harder against her face. It was becoming difficult for her to breathe, her lungs burning for oxygen, but she needed to bring her Mistress to her climax to get her reward.

Moving her hands, Sarah gripped the base of Colgate’s tail, giving it a slight pull, causing her to arch her back. This seemed to be enough as Colgate’s inner walls convulsed around her tongue and gushed a torrent of juices. Sarah happily drank everything that entered her mouth before starting to cough at the amount. She felt Colgate’s body shudder above her before pulling away, causing her to let out a small whimper.

“Pet, clean up Sarah!” Berry ordered, her hoof still working away at her slit.

Sarah let out a small whine as she felt Lightning pull out of her, causing her orgasm to recede. She felt Lightning move up her body and begin licking at her face. She could hear the moan of approval as she licked at her, and they both met for a kiss. Lightning elicited a surprised squeak at the action, but it soon devolved into a moan as Sarah wrapped her arms around her. The two continued to kiss each other deeply and passionately, their tongues doing an intricate dance as neither dominated the other. Sadly, Lightning was pulled out of the kiss, a smirking Berry taking her place.

“Who said you can have fun with my pet before I get my turn?” Berry asked, her tone predatory.

“I’m sorry, Berry I- AHH!” Sarah started, but squealed in slight pleasure as something slapped her ass.

“That’s Mistress Berry to you, pet,” Colgate said, her magic massaging the area that she hit.

“Sorry, Mistress. Please forgive me,” Sarah said, her body aching for more pleasure.

“I forgive you. Now pleasure me like you did your Mistress,” Berry demanded, her marehood already pressing against Sarah’s face.

Sarah went to work, licking at the dripping slit before moving up to suck on Berry’s clit. She gripped at her flanks, admiring the different feel it had. Berry’s rear was firm and muscular, displaying her proud natural earth pony physique. Colgate’s was moderately firm, however there was an unmistakable plumpness to give it some cushion and something for Sarah to dig her fingers into. As she continued to lap away at Berry’s pussy, she noted her taste. Berry, despite her namesake, surprisingly didn’t taste like berries at all.

In fact, Berry’s sweet essence tasted like a well-aged wine with a slight hint of alcohol in the aftertaste. With that little discovery, Sarah became certain that if she wasn’t careful, she could probably get drunk off of Berry’s arousal. Or tipsy at the very least. Though at the moment she didn’t care, the taste was intoxicating and her lower half burned with desire. She felt Berry press herself harder into her face, getting Sarah’s tongue to slip inside of her hot tunnel. Sarah licked furiously, gathering all the juices that Berry produced. She could feel every shudder that Berry gave, and if the quickening of her grinds was any indication, she was about to reach her climax.

Smiling internally, Sarah moved her hand to Berry’s tail, giving it a harsh tug. This was enough to get Berry to culminate as she arched her back, moaning passionately towards the ceiling without a care of who could possibly hear her. Juices rained down upon Sarah, who happily drank them up as the area beneath her head became soaked. Her body shattering orgasm lasted several seconds before she rolled herself to the side, panting heavily as Lightning was quick to clean up Sarah. The two resumed their kissing session, Lightning moaning as Sarah shared a bit of the combined juices of their Mistresses.

Sarah could feel Lightning grind against her right leg, liquid covering her skin in a glistening sheen. The two broke away panting heavily with dark blushes on their faces. Lightning’s eyes glimmered as they looked at each other, desire and passion hidden deep within, begging to be released. Sarah’s lust was the same, Colgate’s spell heightened the and steadily increased the longer she went without her climax. They were about to connect lips again when Berry finally spoke up.

“Lightning, be a good girl and help Sarah finish up. Same goes for you, Sarah,” Berry said, a sly grin spreading across her lips as she pulled Colgate close and started rubbing her marehood.

Sarah watched with interest as Lightning turned around, swishing her tail to the side and presenting her puffy, moist turquoise lips. A line of her arousal trailed down her inner thigh and she couldn’t wait any longer. Moving at a pace that would have rivaled Rainbow Dash, Sarah grasped Lightning’s taught flanks and was amazed at their feel. Her flanks were firm, extremely firm. More firm than she thought possible. Then again, Lightning did train intensively to be a Wonderbolt, and if Dash’s athletic physique was anything to go by, it seemed to be the correct build to have for just that.

Sarah listened to the relentless moans that Lightning let loose as she licked at her inner walls, her own moans soon joining Lightning’s when she felt the latter begin to rigorously eat her out. Sarah kept one hand on Lightning’s flank as the other moved to her engorged clit. She pinched it between her index finger and thumb, earning a squeal of delight from the other pet. She basked in the sound that Lightning made, flicking and rubbing against the sensitive nub to keep her singing her song of bliss. Sarah noticed how stiff Lightning’s wings were, shaking along with her body as the latter lapped at Sarah’s pussy with reckless abandon. Grinning a little, Sarah moved her hand to the base of Lightning’s wing. She pressed against the connecting muscles and was rewarded with a sharp gasp from her. Loving the sound, Sarah continued to press against the sensitive area to earn more of those lovely sounds.

A moan from the side made Sarah glance over, making sure to keep up her work on Lightning. Her eyes widened as she saw Berry with a strap on teasing her Mistress. Colgate was hunched over, the faux cock being hot-dogged between her luscious cheeks. More arousal seeped from Sarah’s needy womanhood, causing her to pick up the pace so she could feel that large pleasurable toy inside of her. Focusing her attention on Lightning, Sarah could feel the constricting walls of Lightning’s pussy grip at her tongue, frantically begging for release.

She finish to finish Lightning quickly, and moved her other hand to the puckered star. If the toy that Berry had pulled out of her was any indication, then Lightning was no stranger to anal play. She teased the tight hole, Lightning shaking above her as Sarah let out a deep moan when the former hit an extremely sensitive spot. She continued to play with her anus, and before plunging a finger inside, there was a flash and the feeling of something cool against her finger. Glancing at her hand, she noticed a clear liquid covering her finger and the tight entrance.

Glad that Colgate wasn’t entirely gone, she pressed her finger against the opening, meeting a little resistance. The resistance gave away quickly as Lightning calmed herself, allowing her finger full access to her tail-hole. Sarah was surprised at the intense heat that was coming from Lightning, the sheer sensation causing her finger to warm up quickly. She didn’t pause to dwell on the thought before mercilessly pumping her finger, causing Lightning to slump forward slightly. Sarah saw that Lightning was having a tough time standing up, and the rapid clenching of both her inner walls showed she was right on the edge of her rope.

Sarah wasn’t far behind herself, Lightning’s teeth nipping at her exposed clit was pushing her near her breaking point. Giving a few more thrusts of her finger, she felt Lightning’s body clench, her walls violently clamping on her finger and tongue the hardest they could. A torrent of liquids splashed against Sarah’s face, and she finally achieved her goal. Sarah’s pussy did its best to grip at the tongue that was writhing inside of her, but ultimately failing. She could hear Lightning moan as she licked along her slit, collecting all of her essence.

Sarah held Lightning’s arousal in her mouth, getting an actual taste of the flavor. Lightning’s flavor was strong, almost like pop-rocks were going off in her mouth. She was expecting a slightly sour or bitter taste, but it was rather pleasant and saccharine, almost like freshly picked oranges. Not focusing on how this was even possible compared to the others, she turned Lightning around and planted her lips against hers. The two swapped their juices, moaning happily as they got to enjoy their combined taste. They were soon pulled away in a light azure aura, both whining at their separation. A line of saliva barely keeping them connected.

“Very good, my pet,” Colgate praised, letting a tendril of magic run along Sarah’s sensitive lips and causing her to squirm, her Mistress taking pleasure in doing so. “Now how about we move on to the next round?” she asked, but didn’t wait to receive an answer.

Lightning was placed on her back, her wings splayed out as Sarah was placed over her. Sarah noticed how adorable Lightning looked with her collar around her neck, especially when her forelegs were pulled close to her body with an innocent and uncertain expression adorning her face. Taking a quick second to get a better look, Sarah could see something engraved on the tag, which read “Dusty”; she could only assume that was Lightning’s pet name given by Berry. Looking up, Sarah saw Colgate move closer to her, her horn barely a fraction of an inch away from her mouth.

“I believe you know what to do,” Colgate said coyly, pressing her horn against Sarah’s lips.

Sarah didn’t hesitate as she parted them, letting the horn slide in. There was a slight tingle in her mouth, something that always happened after her Mistress used a lot of magic. Licking along the grooves, she felt delighted as she heard her Mistress moan passionately. Her tongue work stopped when she felt something press against her nethers. Letting the horn out of her mouth, she looked back to see Berry on her hind legs, her strap-on pressing against her.

“I wouldn’t stop if I were you,” Berry warned, pointing towards Colgate.

Sarah looked in the direction and saw the irritated look that she was receiving. Gulping nervously, she could already feel a magical tendril against her rear. Before she could even apologize, a loud slap echoed around the room.

“AHH!” Sarah screamed loudly at the pain and pleasure mix that shot up her spine.

“I don’t believe I told you to stop,” Colgate said in an audibly threatening tone.

“I’m sorry, Mistress. It won’t happen again,” Sarah whimpered, her pussy dripping from the slightly stinging sensation that lingered.

“Now, Lightning, why don’t you show Sarah here how good your wings are for things other than flying?” Berry said.

“Yes, Mistress,” Lightning answered.

Sarah was confused by what she meant, until she gasped and shuddered at a foreign sensation. Looking down, she saw Lightning was using her wings to pleasure her puffy lips. It was a strange feeling, her soft feathers tickled at her body, but was nonetheless pleasurable as she felt electric shocks throughout her body. Her mind was pulled from these feelings when another slap was administered to her other cheek.

“Pet, I will not repeat myself,” Colgate said sternly, shooting a harsh glare at Sarah. “If you keep this up, I’ll put you in a corner and have you watch without touching yourself,” she warned, her illuminated horn indicated she was dead serious.

Sarah didn’t hesitate again as she took the horn back into her mouth, sucking, licking, and bobbing to keep her Mistress pleased. It seemed to work as the magic died out and Colgate lost herself to the pleasure. While Sarah was busy pleasuring her horn, she felt the flare of the strap-on slip past her folds, spreading her lips wide. Her entire body quivered at the feeling of her vaginal walls being spread close to its limits. As the toy pushed further inside of her, she realized that it was one that Colgate liked to use on her. It also appeared to be her favorite one as well since she felt something starting to seep from it.

In fact, it was a custom made toy for Sarah to use because the regular ones were far beyond her threshold. Being only human, she wasn’t as capable as most of the ponies and couldn’t take a stallion phallus all the way to the hilt without injuring herself. Colgate had gone to a store that was oddly located in Ponyville and ordered a shorter, yet girthier version of the toy after discovering Sarah loved the sensation of being stretched. Sarah was especially surprised by an extra feature Colgate paid for that left her in a mess after its use.

Colgate had also requested for a sensor to be placed in the toy that would cause the dildo to shoot out a faux cum-like substance whenever the user reached their climax. That was one hell of a night for Sarah as she still remembered the feeling at the immense amount of faux seed that covered her body that strangely tasted like Colgate’s arousal. Sarah never really questioned what happened, leaving it up to magic, but she enjoyed it immensely, especially after she learned that it was safe to swallow.

Moaning around the horn in her mouth, she felt Colgate shudder as Berry finally bottomed-out inside of her. Sarah let go of her senses as she allowed herself be used by the others. Lightning’s feather-light touches kept a constant stream of pleasure focused on her clit and labia. Colgate’s horn was giving off little sparks that increased Sarah’s lust, her body heating even more as Berry held still inside of her. Once Berry decided to move, she didn’t even give Sarah a chance to whine at her emptiness before quickly filling her once more.

Sarah’s walls were stretched wide, pleasure fogging up her mind as Berry plowed into her. Every thrust from her made the bed creak, causing Sarah to take Colgate’s horn all the way. Colgate was panting heavily, and she put a hoof on Sarah’s forehead to get her to back off. Sarah looked at her curiously, gritting her teeth to avoid letting out a moan as she was fucked roughly by Berry.

“Don’t worry, pet,” Colgate said in a calm tone. “I just want to give something for Dusty to play with,” she explained, her horn glowing brightly.

There was a brief flash, and Sarah was glad that her eyes were closed at the moment after Berry hit her g-spot with the flared tip of the toy. Opening her eyes, she gawked at what was between her Mistress’ legs. It was in the shape of a stallion’s cock with the same length as the toy and the same girth. It was black in color, but had a few dark blue mottled spots along its shaft. She heard Colgate giggle, gaining her attention quickly, but Sarah varied her eye contact between her Mistress and the lovely cock.

“It seems that you approve, pet,” Colgate said knowingly, waving the cock enticingly in front of Sarah.

“I do… Mistress. Is that… for me?” Sarah asked between gasps, reaching out with a hand before being stopped by a hoof.

“In due time, but for now, it’s for Dusty,” Colgate said with a wry smile.

Sarah gave a small pout, but that soon turned to a smile as Colgate patted her head. Returning back to their earlier activities, Sarah took back the horn as Colgate situated herself in a better sitting position. A low moan came from Colgate’s throat, and Sarah could only guess that Lightning had taken the cock into her muzzle. She wasn’t sure how much was currently taken, but she assumed it wasn’t much with their current position.

Sarah closed her eyes as she sucked on the horn, sparks landing on her tongue again as she licked around the shaft. Her breasts bounced as Berry slammed into her with all her strength, and Lightning was keeping precise touches on her clit. The small fire in Sarah’s core was back to a raging inferno, and if the heavy panting was any indication, Berry and Colgate were about ready to reach their ends as well.

Making sure she was keeping herself upright, Sarah moved her left hand down Lightning’s body, her fingers slipping inside of her warm entrance. It was searing hot inside of her, more so than what she felt from Colgate. As a fire had been lit inside her body, she had an idea about what it was, but there was no way that Berry would have let her walk around if she was in that state. Either way, Sarah was curious of this and would ask about it later. Plunging her fingers deeper, she curled them and started pressing against the soft walls of Lightning’s pussy.
She could feel Lightning writhing on her fingers, her vaginal walls gripping at her fingers desperately to be filled with something. Sarah was so deeply lost in her own bliss that she was pulled back to reality when Colgate moaned loudly.

“AHHN… SWEET TWILIGHT!” Colgate screamed at the top of her lungs.

Sarah felt her mouth fill with a jelly-like substance, the taste reminiscent of blueberries. Sarah moaned as her mouth was filled with the jelly, something she learned was called magic ejaculation. When a unicorn’s horn is stimulated enough, the reaction transforms magical residue into a solid form when the victim reaches orgasm. Or horngasm. All unicorns could achieve this, but it wasn’t well known since most ponies never thought about pleasuring the horn. Considering how odd it sounded. Sarah found out on a whim when she wondered if it would do anything for her Mistress. She received a wonderful reward that had her covered in the condensed magic and she was left unable to walk for a few days.

Berry finally reached her peak as she blubbered incoherent gibberish. A warm, sticky sensation was felt inside of Sarah, her inner walls clamping around the faux cock to milk it for all of its worth. Sarah couldn’t stop the moan that escaped her, the warm seed filling her up nicely, making her stomach extend just a bit.

The feeling of the hot seed filling her set off her own orgasm, her juices splattering all over the toy and coating Berry’s crotch. During her blissful orgasm, Sarah pressed against Lightning’s g-spot and clit at the same time, causing her to culminate quicker than usual. Sarah felt her entire hand become soaked with Lightning’s arousal, the latter twitching madly on the bed as all four of them panted heavily. They were all glistening in sweat, the scent of their passionate lovemaking mixing in and making quite an interesting flavor. The musky stench hung heavily in the air, and it only seemed to drive their lustful desires.

The lust itself seemed never ending as Sarah rolled onto her back, looking at Colgate with pleading eyes. The look didn’t end up lost on her Mistress as she giggled softly, moving away from Lightning Dust. The cock between her legs dangled to and fro, saliva and cum making it glisten in the light of the room.

“Do you want this?” Colgate asked, presenting the cock and stroking it.

“Yes, Mistress,” Sarah said in a pleading voice. Her hand was already working away at her winking womanhood. She felt so incredibly aroused because of the spell, glad that it was only used during these long sessions.

“Show me just how much you want it,” Colgate demanded, sitting on her haunches and spreading her legs open.

Sarah didn’t wait as she rolled back over and grasped at the pulsing shaft. She could feel the immense heat warm her hand. It throbbed in her grasp, a bead of pre leaking out, which she happily lapped up. The pre-cum held Colgate’s signature mint taste, but there was a slightly salty taste that added to the flavor. Her hand slowly started to stroke the shaft, running up and down the entire length as she licked her lips. During her pumping, she heard a small moan and looked over at Berry to see her mounting Lightning Dust.

The latter had her flank raised high in the air, her tail swished forward and was covering her eyes as Berry dominated her. Remembering what she wanted to ask, she kept up her actions as she called out to the other Mistress.

“Mistress Berry,” Sarah said, her voice laced with desire as she continued to work the cock in her hand.

“Yes, my pet?” Berry called, slamming her hips against Lightning’s flanks.

“Is Dusty in heat?” Sarah asked, moving her other hand to the low hanging orbs and massing them.

“Very… observant, pet,” Berry said between pants. “I don’t normally let her walk around town… while she’s in heat as she can be pretty aggressive… if I’m not there. Though when Colgate came with her… offer, Dusty really wanted to meet you. I decided ‘what the hay’ and… came to see how you were. You’ve really… exceeded my expectations,” she said appraisingly, giving a smile to Sarah as she humped Lightning.

“Thank you for the praise, Mistress,” Sarah said happily, returning her attention back to the cock in her hand.

“Hey, Berry, want to switch out the strap-on for something more real?” Colgate asked.

“Oh, I finally get to try out that little spell you’ve been keeping secret from me? Lay it on me!” Berry said excitedly.

Sarah looked between the two of them as Berry slowly pulled out of Lightning, the latter whimpering as she shook her flank desperately. Berry removed the strap-on and Colgate’s magical aura covered her crotch. Aware of what was about to happen, Sarah closed her eyes when a flash lit up the room. Upon opening them, she stared at the well sized cock that appeared between Berry’s legs. It was the length of a regular stallion, but with added girth to it. Sarah could feel her cheeks burn at the intimidating size of it, but glancing at Lightning, her heat-addled mind merely caused her to drool at the sight. Looking closely at the throbbing length, Sarah could make out the beads of pre forming at the top and sliding down the shaft to her oversized testicles.

“Wait, is this thing even sterile?” Sarah asked, her mind remembering what it means for a mare to be in heat.

“Colgate’s probably is, but mine… should work just properly,” Berry answered, quickly mounting Lightning and sinking her cock deep inside. Sarah could make out a small bulge that formed in her stomach and Sarah felt a little afraid.

“Aren’t you taking a huge risk, though? What if she doesn’t want to become pregnant?” Sarah asked once again, her hand slowing down in its ministrations. She had half a mind to use the safe word to put a stop to this, Colgate reassured her.

“Lightning consented… to this, Sarah. It’s not known to… most of the ponies here, but Berry and Lightning… are actually engaged,” Colgate said, running a hoof along Sarah’s back as she panted heavily.

Sarah looked between Colgate and Berry, a pang of worry sitting in her heart as she tried to process everything she was told. Both had content smiles on their faces, and if anything Dash had said was true, Lightning wouldn’t have allowed this without truly consenting. Smiling a little, she relaxed as she mentally hoped for the best for the newlyweds. Her attention was returned when Colgate’s voice cut through in a commanding tone.

“Enough talking, pet, and get to work before I make it so you can’t orgasm for an entire week,” Colgate said, pressing a hoof on the back of Sarah’s head to bring her closer.

Sarah all too eagerly allowed Colgate to push her head closer to the throbbing length, her mouth open and hitting it with her hot breath. She listened to the hitched breath that Colgate made as she breathed on it heavily, the strong musk coming off of it. Moving towards the flat head, Sarah let her tongue drag across the slit, collecting all the pre that was forming. The taste was like liquor to her as she lapped away, trying to coax more out of her Mistress. Gripping the dick, she held it as she wrapped her lips around the head, suckling at the tip.

She listened to Colgate’s moans as she slowly went down, hitting the medial ring before traveling up. Her tongue ran across every inch of skin, passing over the present veins, and letting the pre fill her mouth before swallowing it. She started out slow, Colgate’s hooves helping to guide her along as she bobbed her head. Every downward thrust had her taking a little more, until she was finally at the base. Sarah had taken the entirety of the cock into her mouth, the tip just barely pressing against the back of her throat. It was painful having to accommodate for the massive girth, but it was also a pleasant feeling as she increased her pace.

Colgate had taken control at this point, holding Sarah’s head with her hooves and fucking her face with much vigor. Sarah drooled all over the length, making a mess of her chin as her spittle went flying everywhere. She was literally her Mistress’ fuck toy at the moment, and she couldn’t feel more content. Her eyes rolled back with pleasure as she let Colgate have her way with her. She felt every throb of the cock, and more pre began to fill her mouth as Colgate gave small, primal growls. Sarah could feel the flare starting to expand, and she sucked with much more strength to get the seed hidden below.

“You better swallow all of it, pet!” Colgate growled out, slamming Sarah’s face against her crotch.

Sarah closed her eyes, listening to the high pitched moan of Lightning Dust, along with the growl of Berry as they reached their climaxes. She felt the flare in her mouth expand to its maximum size and felt the first strand of cum hit the back of her throat. Colgate’s cum was thick, heavy, and oh so delicious. Sarah happily and greedily swallowed every drop that landed in her mouth, trying to keep up with the heavy load that was being deposited in her mouth. It proved to be quite difficult as Colgate fired off more volleys of cum faster than Sarah could swallow.

Before Sarah could choke, Colgate pulled out of her mouth and began to coat her face. Sarah left her mouth open to any stray strands that came her way. She had to close her eyes as they soon became covered with the heavy seed, her nostrils flaring as she smelled her Mistress’ scent on her. After several seconds, she felt Colgate flop onto the bed, breathing heavily as her cock twitched in time with her heartbeats. Sarah collected the cum into her mouth, filling it with all the remnants of her Mistress’ marking and showed it to Colgate.

She made a show of it by swishing it around in her mouth, before finally giving a loud gulp, making sure her Mistress saw the lump in her throat as she swallowed the heavy load. Sarah let out a contented sigh as Colgate’s cum joined Berry’s in her stomach, giving her a pleasant warmth inside. Looking over, her eyes widened at the sight of Lightning, whose stomach was highly noticeable with a pool of white gathering beneath her marehood. Rolling away from Lightning, her eyes landed on Berry who was strutting towards her.

“Now it’s my turn with that mouth of yours, pet,” Berry said with a hungry grin.

“Yes, Mistress. I’ll please you however you need me to,” Sarah offered, making Berry’s grin wider.

Sarah saw that Colgate had moved from her spot and was now looming over Lighting Dust. She wondered how they were all still going, when she remembered about an endurance potion that was simple and easy to make. Watching as Lightning took Colgate’s cock in her muzzle, her sight was soon obstructed by Berry. She looked down at the intimidating length below, wondering if Berry was expecting her to take the whole thing.

“Don’t worry about how far you need to go,” Berry said, smiling gently at her. “Go as far as you’re able because I would like to play with you again,” she said, her smile still present.

Sarah returned the smile as she positioned herself better. “Thank you, Mistress. I enjoy playing with you and Dusty,” Sarah replied happily, returning the warm smile.

Berry sat down, her legs spread wide open and pre already traveling down her length. Sarah could still see spots of cum and saliva that still coated the length. Grasping the shaft in both hands, she planted her lips on the flat head and took the first couple of inches. She didn’t bother playing with it in the beginning, knowing that Berry wanted to get to the main course quickly. As if reading her mind, Sarah felt Berry place a hoof on the back of her head to help guide her down further. Sarah couldn’t help but grin internally at the surprise that she was going to show to her other Mistress. It was true that she wouldn’t take an actual sized cock into her pussy, but that didn’t mean she did it for her other two holes.

Sarah reached the medial ring and the tip was already pressing the back of her throat. She felt Berry remove her hoof, expecting her to pull back up, however, she had other plans. She took a deep breath through her nose and shoved herself further down. The surprised moan of Berry was music to her ears as her lips met the base of the cock, the length throbbing violently in her tight throat. Sarah held herself in this position for a few seconds before giving a harsh cough and pulling off the dick.

Looking up at Berry with saliva coated lips that left her connected to the length, she giggled before speaking happily. “Do you approve, Mistress?” Sarah asked, her hand massaging the heavy orbs below.

“Colgate… said nothing… about that,” Berry said between heavy pants. “I’m going to fuck your throat silly,” she said in a low, playful growl, grabbing Sarah’s head with her hooves.

Sarah grinned deviously as she opened her mouth, the tip entering and was quickly shoved down her throat. Her eyes teared up a little as Berry pounded at her throat, but she loved the feeling of the long cock expanding her throat. She could barely make out Colgate doing the same to Lightning before becoming lost in her own bliss. She had never felt so used before, Colgate sometimes still being cautious around her even though she knew she would be able to take it, but Berry had confidence in her. Sarah happily kept taking the length into her throat, allowing her muscles to constrict around it so she could get a delicious meal.

Sarah felt the flare widen in her throat, getting her to give a sharp cough, but this didn’t stop Berry.

“OH… MERCIFUL LUNA!” Berry hollered loudly, slamming Sarah’s face into her crotch and holding her there.

Sarah felt the volleys of cum shoot straight down to her throat, joining the other loads and increasing the warmth inside of her. She put a hand to her stomach, and she swore it grew just a tiny bit more, but it didn’t feel like it would be noticeable. She felt Berry pull out of her throat, her cock still shooting out heavy, sticky loads into her mouth. Once the cock popped free, Berry stroked it vigorously, getting more cum to shoot out. Sarah held her mouth open invitingly, having not swallowed what was in her mouth before being coated in another layer of cum. Once she felt Berry was done, she collected the cum into her mouth once again, showing it to her Mistress before lifting her head up. She swallowed loudly, a bulge most likely noticeable to show she swallowed everything.

Panting heavily, Sarah looked over to see that Lightning’s stomach had gotten slightly bigger after her passionate session with Colgate. Colgate moved away from Lightning as she joined Sarah by her side, all of them panting heavily.

“You think… you’re up… for two more… rounds?” Colgate asked between heavy pants.

“What more… is there, Mistress?” Sarah asked, trying to catch her breath.

“The last one is saved… specifically for you, but this… next one is a special thing for… you and myself, and… Berry and Lightning Dust,” Colgate said, wiping her brow of her sweat.

“Please, Mistress, can we continue?” Sarah asked, her hand on Colgate’s hoof.

“Very well, pet. Close your eyes because I want this to be a surprise,” Colgate whispered seductively, causing Sarah to get goose bumps.

Sarah did as she was told, closing her eyes and shaking with excitement. There was a flash of light before she felt Colgate tap her arm. Opening her eyes, she almost jumped her Mistress at the sight. Underneath Colgate’s horse cock was something she had mentioned a few times in passing. She was staring at a dragon phallus, something she was interested in trying out because she wanted to know what it would be like to be knotted by such a powerful creature. Granted, going for an actual one not the best idea, but this was the next best thing.

Grinning happily, Sarah took great interest in the dragon cocks her Mistresses sported. Colgate’s dragon penis was blue in color and was the same length as her horse cock. It was tapered at the tip with a bulbous, arrow-shaped head. Below that the shaft narrowed, then thickened gradually to the base, which consisted of a small knot. Glancing over at Berry, she saw she was sporting the same two lengths, but her dragon length was the same color as her coat. Looking back at her Mistress, Sarah couldn’t stop the tear that escaped her eye.

“Thank you, Mistress,” Sarah said happily, quickly wiping away the stray tear.

“Anything for you, Sarah,” Colgate said happily, giving her a warm hug.

Filled with a surprising amount of giddiness, Sarah rolled to an open spot on the bed and laid down on her back. She spread her legs open, her hands parting her folds open to show her pink insides. She saw the dual cocks throb in approval as Colgate sauntered over. Sarah felt a wave of lust magic take over, and if she was correct, there was a sensitivity spell as well. Looking over at Lightning Dust, she saw that she had her head planted into a pillow her flank raised into the air one final time. She watched as Berry mounted her, the dual cocks pressing against both entrances.

Feeling Colgate’s cocks pressing against her own, Sarah’s body shuddered from the increased sensitivity. Gazing into Colgate’s eyes, she saw they were glazed over with pleasure, and a grin plastered on her face as she teased Sarah’s entrances. Colgate’s horn glowed briefly and was followed by a flash. The flash wasn’t as intense as the others, but what Sarah’s Mistress did was made very clear from the cool sensation against her anus and pussy. Both cocks were thoroughly lubed, and she assumed the same was for Berry.

“OH… CELESTIA, YES!” Lightning screamed out, confirming Sarah’s thoughts.

It wasn’t long before she felt Colgate penetrate her, both cocks sliding into her easily. She felt so full as her Mistress hilted her on both of them, but she could feel pressure against her rear. Sarah’s legs wrapped around Colgate as she started off in a slow rhythm. Sarah whimpered every time Colgate would leave her, her holes begging to be stretched and stuffed to their fullest. Thankfully, she wasn’t left empty for long as her Mistress would slam back into her, causing her to moan loudly.

It took only a few thrusts before Colgate increased her pace until she was slamming into Sarah, making the bed rock. Sarah gripped at the couch, her knuckles turning white as her mind went into a deep lustful haze. All she could feel were the two cocks working in tandem to hit every single sensitive spot inside of her. She could feel the knot press against her star, and her stomach grew butterflies at the coming end of the round. Panting heavily, she looked over to see Lightning having a tough time standing up on four hooves. Her face was buried in the pillow and Sarah could barely hear the moans she was eliciting.

Sarah could see Lightning’s belly jiggle from each thrust that Berry gave. She was certain if she had her ear pressed against the bulging stomach, she would be able to hear all the virile seed swish inside. Closing her eyes, her hands dug into the bed, breaking through the fabric. A blazing inferno was spreading through her entire body, a fraction of it coming from the lust spell, but the majority of it coming from her desire of feeling the knot press inside of her. The sensitivity spell did its job excellently as well, since Sarah could feel every inch of the dual cocks slide in and out of her, every throb that they gave as they slid along her velvet walls, and the heat they radiated.

Opening her eyes, she glanced down at her Mistress, panting heavily as she desired to feel the massive load fill both her holes.

“Please, Mistress, I want to feel it… inside of me!” Sarah begged, gyrating her hips to help bring more pleasure to Colgate.

“I bet… you would, wouldn’t… you, pet?” Colgate said, a wicked grin on her muzzle.

“Yes, Mistress! I’ll do… anything that you want… me to if it just meant… feeling you cum inside of me!” Sarah screamed openly, trying anything to get her Mistress to heed her request.

“Tell me… who is your Mistress?” Colgate asked, her grin growing wider.

“Colgate is… my Mistress! I am the… pet to my Mistress! I am nothing, but a… slut to my Mistress!” Sarah screamed at the top of her lungs not caring who heard her as she knew where this was going.

Sarah waited for the dam to break, however, Colgate grinned evilly at her. “Tell me, pet…” she said, slowing her thrusts to a tantalizing pace. “Do you… love your Mistress?”

Sarah balked at the sudden question. Her sense came back when Colgate completely stopped her movements. “Yes! Yes, I love my Mistress!”

Colgate resumed her thrusting again. “How much do you love your Mistress, pet?”

“I love my Mistress with all my heart!” Sarah shouted in one breath, gyrating her hips, begging for her Mistress to finish her off. Sarah could feel her body quivering with desire and lust, her body temperature comparable to an active furnace.

“Hmm, such a good pet…” Colgate cooed, rubbing her leg with her hoof “I think you deserve… that reward,” Colgate said, a smile overtaking her features as she wrapped her hooves around Sarah’s leg.

Sarah moaned as she felt Colgate pull back, only the tips of the two cocks still inside of her. A scream filled the room, and Sarah looked over to see Lightning arch her back, her mouth open wide as her juices and a heavy stream of cum leaked out of her holes. Sarah could see the knot buried deep inside Lightning’s pussy, pulsing as it continued to shoot its potent seed deep within her. Sarah could only imagine what it would feel like in her own pussy, and that thought was soon answered.

Colgate took this chance in Sarah’s distracted state to slam her hips forward, hilting herself all the way and popping the knot into her ass. Sarah howled like a banshee as she felt the knot spread her tight star and being confined to her insides. The cocks throbbed harshly as streams of cum flooded her insides, ensuring that any of her pink walls were now coated in a healthy white. Sarah expected the cocks to stop after a few seconds, but they continued to fire, filling her all the way and beginning to seep out of both her holes.

Sarah was wracked with her own orgasm, her ears ringing as her body convulsed. She could feel the warm cum pool beneath her, another small expansion happening to her stomach as she was filled from both holes. A minute went by before Colgate finally pulled out, the two of them panting heavily as they came down from their respective highs. Sarah’s entire body twitched as her tongue lolled out of her mouth, a content smile spreading across her face. She was pulled from her relaxed state by a quick flash.

Looking down, she saw Berry sitting next to Colgate, their horse dicks gone and only leaving their dragon cocks present between their legs, and throbbing with open pleasure.

“So, are you ready for the final round?” Berry asked, stroking her dragon penis happily.

Sarah gave a look to Colgate and received a nod from her. It was a silent question, but one that was asked often enough that a simple look conveyed everything. She wanted to make sure that her Mistress had used the cleaning spell to get rid of anything that could give her an infection before agreeing to such a thing. Happy that Colgate had cleaned off both their cocks, she looked between them with a smile.

“Who gets to put what where, Mistresses?” Sarah asked, giving a quick glance to see Lightning sleeping peacefully.

“Oh, I’m getting your ass this time,” Berry said, moving to stand behind Sarah.

“Get on your hands and knees, and we’ll take care of the rest,” Colgate ordered, sliding underneath Sarah.

Sarah did as she was asked, her muscles straining, but she would steel herself to last this final round. She could feel both cocks press against her entrances, both thoroughly lubed for penetration. Giving a few teasing prods, Berry was the first to push inside, forcing Sarah to moan into the air. Colgate followed behind Berry, burying her own cock deep inside Sarah’s pussy. The feeling of both dragon lengths was a strange sensation to Sarah as the bulbous base pressed against her openings, but never pushed past them.

Clutching at the sheets, she began to accommodate Colgate’s length, moaning as Berry worked in the opposite direction. Every time Sarah would pull off of Colgate, Berry would push forward, and when she would slide down Colgate’s length, Berry would pull back. Both of her Mistresses worked together, hitting every sensitive spot they could and getting Sarah to lean her head down. She was breathing heavily and could feel Colgate’s warm breath hit her sweaty skin. The smell of the room was intoxicating with their combined smells that they were sure any pony that would enter would be driven sex-crazed. That wasn’t even including Lightning’s heat musk that Sarah could now properly take note of.

The musk was strong, much like Lightning’s attitude, but had a sweet scent to it that made it intoxicating. There was also a chance Sarah could have been mixing it up with another scent, but she was confident that it belonged to Lightning. Her Mistresses continued to plow into her, using the last of their strength to bring them all to a climax. Sarah focused on her core, tightening her insides around the intruding lengths and getting Colgate and Berry to moan in approval. Clenching her eyes shut, Sarah moved a hand down and started playing with her clit. She pressed and rolled the sensitive nub, making her walls tighten around the dragon phalluses.

All three were reaching their limit, and their bodies were delicate from so many orgasms. Sarah could feel her last one for the night rising, and the rapid thrusts of her Mistresses showed how close they were. Arching her back a little, Sarah started putting a little more pressure against the knots, wanting them to pop inside of her. Her actions weren’t lost as Berry placed her hooves on Sarah’s shoulders, giving a slight downward pressure.

“Are you ready… to feel two knots… pop inside your tight holes? Are you ready… for your… final filling of the day?” Berry asked sensually, her voice sweet like honey.

“Yes, Mistresses! Breed me, fill me to the… brim so that I’m leaking… your essences for days!” Sarah screamed.

“Then here you… go, pet,” Colgate said, giving a rough thrust.

“OH… CADENCE, YES!” Sarah screamed as the first of two knots entered her.

Berry gave her final thrust, popping her knot inside of Sarah. Both cocks exploded inside of her, showering her insides in a warm, sticky sea of cum. She could feel her holes filling with all the delectable seed, her stomach giving its final expansion and making itself prominent now. Sarah rested a hand on her belly, moaning at the warmth that she felt inside of her. Cum traveled down her legs and collected into a small pool at the bottom. Her Mistresses continued to fill her until they were finally spent, the cocks slipping out of her holes with an audible pop.

Berry collapsed to her side, her eyes quickly shutting as exhaustion finally took over. Sarah rolled towards her Mistress, landing on her side as Colgate rolled over to meet her eyes. Sarah noticed the cock between her Mistress’ legs fade into a sparkle of magic. She smiled happily as she reached out to Colgate, running a hand across her cheek and getting a small hum of happiness. As she continued to pet Colgate, she had one last question for the night before being taken by sleep.

“Did you do something to the lust spell?” Sarah asked, pulling Colgate closer to her. She took a quick glance behind her and was surprised to see both Berry and Lighting cuddling together.

“I may have had Cadence help me alter it a bit so that I could get it to expand a little,” Colgate answered, her cheeks turning a slight shade of red. “Was it too much?” she asked with a little worry.

“It was actually a very interesting experience,” Sarah said, her eyes starting to close as her body began to relax. “I wouldn’t mind doing it again during one of your days off,” she said, letting her eyes slip closed.

“Then I’ll make sure to plan another special evening the next chance I get. Do you mind if they join us again, if they’re willing?” Colgate asked, pulling a sheet over everyone and then giving Sarah a kiss on the cheek.

“As long as they follow the rules and are fine with this, then I wouldn’t be against it,” Sarah answered, letting her body relax on Colgate’s warmth, sleep finally taking her over.

The last thing she received was a kiss on the lips and a “good night” from Colgate before everything became quiet and dark. Her dreams would be a pleasant one today when she reached the dreamscape.

Author's Note

Once again, thanks to all my editors for all their help.