The secrets dreams can hold

by StraferElite

Rating: mature
Tags: Discord, Princess Celestia, Dark, Main 6, Princess Luna, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Spike, Horror, Romance, Sex, Tragedy
Length: 7483

Luna sees some dreans she wish she shouldent

luna goes into the dreams of the main six, and sees things she wish she could unsee. But pinkie is the worst of all.

(http://angelofhapiness.deviantart.com/) made the art

Published 2016-02-11 12:30:03 UTC
Last updated 2016-02-11 12:30:03 UTC

The secrets dreams can hold

Luna sighed as she walked into her darkened room. “Another night of keeping nightmares at bay.” As she laid on her bed she felt uneasy. She tossed the idea aside as she pulled the blanket close. Closing her eyes, she cast the spell, allowing her to enter the dream realm. For a moment she stood in endless white, but then endless portals wooshed by her revealing windows to ponies dreams.
Above every portal, a cutie mark and the name of the pony who's dreaming had been engraved. The portals that were nearest to her, were the ones that needed attention. Above the very first one bared Rarity's three diamonds. She peared in, terrified of what the fashionista would be dreaming about. All she saw was a calm and peaceful Ponyville. Then there was a grumble and the entire town shook. Then she saw rarity turn the corner running for her life. The unicorn ran passed the princess unaware of her presence. Luna looked to the corner. Then she saw a giant purple claw grab the corner building crushing it. Luna took a step back as she saw a massive purple dragon standing tall. He roared, holding his head high.

“RARITY. SPIKE. WANT.”

Luna was horrified seeing Spike. The baby purple dragon, everypony loved; was now a hulking monstrosity. His purple now darker shade, almost midnight blue, his claws as sharp as swords, his teeth became thin and sharp, his snout was long, and his wings were large but shredded with many holes in the skin. Luna sat in terror as she looked at his eyes. They weren't there small cute round version, now they were sharper and slitted with a cat eye. His pupils thin, the green having taken up his entire eye. As he began to barrel down the road Luna charged her horn, and turned Spike back into his former glory. Setting a much calmer Rarity next to him, they hugged.

“Whoo.” Luna exclaimed wiping her brow with the back of her hoof. She returned to the portal that lead back to the corridor of portals. She lept through, and took a glance to Rarity. She was kissing Spike, the dragon held an evil smirk on his face as he grabbed her ass. Luna blushed, before closing the portal. As the princess walked through the portal, her horn sparked a dark purple.She was confused at first but decided to just brushed it off. She pulled out her dream journal that she puts copies of all the dreams she had appeared in, or overlooked.

Next she saw a certain apple pony’s dream. She stepped through the portal and found herself at Sweet Apple Acres. She heard a thumping from inside the Apple family's' house. She was afraid at first, but after she returned from the moon, she had faced many nightmares. Knowing she just had to push through it. As Luna opened the door, the thumping sound became louder and louder. She was standing outside Applejacks' bedroom. She was about to open the door, when she heard applejack say.

“Nah, Ah can't sugarcube. It's to big.”

Luna blushed. She was about to walk away but she heard somepony else in the room.

“Come on Applejack. You're the one who wanted this.”

Luna blushed even harder. She was about to walk away but her curiosity had pulled her to the door. As she opened it, she gasped as she saw Applejack sitting on top of a older Spike. With a big grin on her face. She blushed furiously. Quickly closing the door, Luna ran out of that dream at full speed. The moment she jumped out of the portal, she pulled out the dream journal. Right before she the next entry, she hesitated. It was law, and she knew that she had to do it. Sighing she wrote it down, in as little detail as she could manage.

Looking at the next portale, a special rainbow mare came to mind. She looked inside and saw a harem of every mare she knew. On top of everything, she saw the mane six, as they all "helped" Rainbow Dash. She was really getting it on with Fluttershy. She blushed harder than ever before, as her heart sped up, seeing herself and her sister Celestia in the corner kissing hard. The doorway held a red velvet rope, adorned with a sign Fluttershy and Rainbow only. She walked out knowing not even the gods can help that one. Luna pulled out her book and wrote down more info. She saw the next portal. It was Twilight's, she looked inside and saw Twilight talking to all of her friends, gathered in the living room, all attention on the purple pony.

“Girls I have gathered you here today to show you a new spell I learned.”

Interested she watched closely. Twilight pulled out a book, and Luna instantly recognized the book of the harem mage. She turned around and threw her front hooves in the air, as she started to hear moaning behind her. She just pulled out the book and wrote. She was getting fed up at this point. The next dream is Fluttershy's. She walked into the cottage. Luna started to leave, but stopped when she saw a trap door under a flipped carpet. She walked forward and instantly heard Discord.

“Please no! This isn't the Fluttershy I know and love. Please come back.” Discord begged.

“That Fluttershy left when you decided to be buddies with Tirek, you fucker.”

Luna flipped open the door and ran down the steps and saw King Sombra and Discord chained up to a wall, with a pony wearing all black leather and zippers all over her body; including black leather that covered her face, a zipper over her mouth making it was hard to tell who it was except the long, wavy pink mane and tail. Luna knew that she couldn't deny it was Fluttershy. Luna put up a hoof to her mouth, as she watch Fluttershy kiss Discord, before smacking him repeatedly with a riding crop. His hands clench and unclenching with each strike. He had little red welts all over his body, and Luna noticed Sombra in a similar state. A noise drew the alicorns attention as Fluttershy was unzipping one of the zippers on her nether regions. Slowly placing herself on the unwanting Discord. The pegasus walked out but not before she saw a pleading Discord. It was almost enough to make Luna intervene, but she knew she couldn't interfere unless it was a nightmare. she walked out sorrowful.

Next was a certain party pony.

She walked through the portal, expecting it to be weird, but when she turned the corner she nearly vomited. She saw the elements. Her friends. Twilight was dead, s a pool of blood pooled out of where her horn used to be, brain all over the floor. Next was Rainbow, who is missing her wings and her belly was ripped open, Her guts spilling out, but with a few missing organs. While Applejack, Rarity, Spike, and Fluttershy were beaten and starved. They had chains around their necks, and Spike had been missing an eye. It looked dried out and crusted like it had been gone a long time. What petrified the moon princess the most was a pink pony who had adorned blue wing, a purple horn sticking out of her forehead, and her one eye had become a dragon's eye. Her normally pink mane was straight and flat. while she had the biggest grin on her face like she had just dominated the world. Luna stepped back in horror but knocked into something. Pinkamena looked at her and started to flap rainbows wings, as she floated down to the floor.

The pink pony started to speak as she made her way to Luna.

“Hey Luna, It's so nice to finally meet you. I'm Pinkamena. As you are most likely confused, allow me to explain. The real Pinkie, the one you know as Pinkie Pie is the one that broke from years and years of psychotherapy and electroshock. Did u know that if you perfectly take the horn and wings from a unicorn and pegasus you can become an alicorn. That was the dream before they fried my brain, but i live on in my dreams, and no matter what you do I will never leave, and eventually i will get out.” She finished, eyeing Lunas regalia.

Then she started to laugh maniacally as Luna backed away. For once in her immortal life, she truly scared of something. She jumped out of the portal, looking back, she saw a pink pony banging on the portal, like she knew it was there. Luna lit up her horn, and out from nowhere chains and locks surrounded the door. She was breathing hard as she looked down. She saw a warm yellow liquid fall down her fur between her legs, as they were shaking violently. Quickly pulling out the book, she started writing as she shook. She closed the book and collected her composure. She woke up to a soaking wet bed form all of those dreams. She jumped up using her wings and burned the bed in a flash of magic. She was never sleeping on it again, and decided she was gonna get a new one. Maybe from cloudsdale. She walked out and passed by a guard, and his nose scrunched up as she passed. Noticing this, Luna turned to him with anger in her eyes.

“Not. A. Word.”

All the guard could do was nod. She turned to the royal bath and cleaned herself from all these dirty dreams. She had business to do, and her sister had yet to tell her. So she went to her room and grabbed her saddle bag, but a dark aura enveloped her horn. On the nightstand laid the dream journal. Luna picked it up and put into the saddle bag, before she turned to nothing. Thinking it was nothing she turned to leave for the her day. She went to Celestia to ask what her duties were. Celista turned to face her sister while remaining on her throne.

“Luna you need to check up on the elements bearers in Ponyville.

Luna's face grew pale like she had seen a ghost.

“Luna what's wrong.”

“N-Nothing my dear sister. I-I will leave at once.”

With that Luna turned and left. Leaving her sister confused and unsure. As she was walking, the nightmares plagued her thoughts. Were these the ponies that have the ability to wield the strongest weapon in equestria? She walked through canterlot re-viewing all of the dreams. She was lost in her thoughts, and didn't see the front gate. She was about to walk into it but her horn lit up, illuminating the gates, and opening them. She walked outside, she was thinking about the worst dream she encountered last night. Was Pinkie truly like that at her core. She was flying the entire time, only thinking about that dream. She looked down and saw that sign.

“Welcome to Ponyville”

The thoughts sent shivers down her back. She landed and started walking, staring at the ground. She couldn't stop thinking about these dreams. She was about to look up but her eyes caught a pair of distinct pink hooves. She slowly looked up to see a smiling Pinkie Pie. Her face went white, and she felt a warm liquid run down her legs. She realized exactly what it was and she instantly teleported to the lake to clean herself. Pinkie was surprised but just kept walking until she stepped in something wet. She brought it to her nose and sniffed it, she instantly knew what it was. She couldn't help but wonder why did the princess go to the bathroom, and why she couldn't wait. So she pushed it to the side and started to hop to Golden oaks Library. Luna walked out of the lake and shook herself off, heading to the library as well. Inside everypony was there as they waited for Luna.

They had learned of her arrival in Celestia's letter and from Pinkie, but in her letter she warned them that Luna was hiding something. When Luna opened the door she stopped, all she could see was Pinkie's dream flash before her. All her friends flashed their darker counterparts. She started to tremble as flashbacks of the party pony's dream filled the room. All the horrible things that happened to everyone, how Pinkie did the worst out of her entire group of friends. Her face was meshed with that crazy smile and Spikes eye, Twilight's horn and Rainbows' wings as she looked at the rest of the girls. She looked over the rest of the girls, memories of their appearances flashing back in her mind. Twilight with blood running down her face, and her eyes glassy, Rainbow Dash with her guts spilling out of her stomach, Spike and his missing eye, the space like a black hole into nothingness, and all her friends had glassy eyes. When twilight tried to open her mouth to speak. Luna took a step back, pure fear was plastered all over face. All the girls and Spike look worried. They all walked to her, and she lit up her horn and threw up a barrier around herself. Looking at each other, Pinkie walked over to the alicorn, and Luna started trembling more violently, while paralyzed with fear.

“Hey Luna, What's wrong”

“Get back you demon”

“What's wrong Luna?” Pinkie tried again, taking a neither step closer to the princess

“I said GET BACK. YOU VILE SHE DEMON.” Luna yelled in the Royal Canterlot Voice

Everypony jumped. Luna backed up into the doorway, her dream journal fell out as she ran into the door frame. She saw them all walk closer, looks of concern written on their faces until the memories flashed again. Those glassy eyes, and poor Spike. She turned and ran out, taking to the sky. Pinkie Pie's' hair went straight. As the girls ran outside, Luna looked behind her and saw her. She instantly teleported back to the castle. After a few minutes after the initial shock, they walked back inside. Rainbow picked up the dream journal and looked at it confused.

“Hey egghead, is this a new book of yours.”

Twilight walked forward. and took the book in her magic, bringing it to her.

“I have no idea where this came from. Luna must have dropped it”

“Well sugarcube, only one way to find out.”

“Oh please dear, we don't even know what it's based on.”

Everypony heard a poof “It could be about parties!”

“Well I'll read it so we all can find out. Ok?"

"Read it out loud."

"I was planning on it Rainbow." She rolled her eyes at her polychromatic friend.

All the girls nodded as she opens it to the first page of Luna's latest entries.

“As i walked into Rarity's dream, all I saw all of ponyville and it was all fine.”

Everypony looked confused, everypony except Rarity who was madly blushing, realizing what happened in her dream.

“I saw Rarity run by and thought it was nothing but then the ground shook. It was then I saw a gigantic Spike who had looked like a monster.”

Everyone looked at rarity.

“Rarity is this your dream.”

she nodded, but before she could protest. Rainbow was the first to take it and keep reading.

“and Spike spoke out loud. “Spike. want. Rarity.” and came charging I turned Spike back to normal and brought Rarity to him, but before I left through the portal I looked at Spike. He held a evil smile on his face as he was reaching for Rarity' ”

Rainbows mouth went agape and her eyes wide seeing the last word. Rarity tried to grab the book but Rainbow said the last word.

“ass.”

Everyone looked at Rarity who was blushing madly.

“j-just read the next one already.”

“Ok ahem. As I walked into the next portal I smelled a distinct apple scent.”

Everypony looked at applejack.

“What.”

They all said nothing as they turned their heads to rainbow.

“I was in front of the Apple house when i heard a bumping inside.”

Everyone looked at her with big smiles on their faces.

“Damn it yall, I dont think like that, so quit yer bellyaching.”

They all turned back to back to Rainbow to allow her to finish.

“As I walked in, the thumping got louder. I turned to the steps, and as I walked up them. By the time I reached the top I heard voices.

”Nah I can't sugarcube. It"s to big.”

Everyone wiped their heads to applejack, who was currently hiding under her hat. She looked at Spike who saw it and blushed, but the others didn't notice. So Rainbow continued

“Then i heard the somepony say.”aw come on Applejack. You're the one who wanted this.”

I opened the door, and saw Applejack sitting on top of a much older Spike.”

Everyone gasped and turned to Applejack who was now laying on the floor, pulling her hat down to cover her face, except her muzzle was sticking out. Spike walked over and tapped her on her nose. Looking up, she lifted her hat to see a very happy Spike.

“Well, what you have ta say Spike?”

“Well, umm, maybe my dream is in there and we will all find out.”

Applejack stood up.

“Yeah your right.”

“Next story Rainbow.” Spike said enthusiastically

“Alright ahem. Next was Rainbow Dash. I walked into her dream and I found myself inside Twilight's library. It was filled to the brim with....”

Rainbow instantly blushed.

“With what rainbow.”

“N-Nothing Twilight. N-nothing at all.”

“Ah no you don't Rainbow. You read ours, so let's hear yours.”

“Fine.”

She looked at fluttershy before she read it.

“It was filled to the brim with h-horny mares. All of them grinding on each other while her friends were on top with Rainbow, but she was really focused on Fluttershy. I saw a rope hanging on a doorway leading to myself and my sister with a sign saying “For me and Flutters only.” then I left.”

“Oh my Rainbow, I didn't know you were a filly fooler.” Rarity teased, holding a slight blush.

“Well whatever next story. I walked into Twilight's dream, she had gathered all the girls and said. Girls i have gathered you to show you a new spell. She then pulled out a book”

Twilight instantly knew what was about to happen, but didn't try to stop it, knowing and attempt would be pointless.

“I instantly knew the book. It was from the harem mage. I walked out the room but before I left I heard some very happy moans.”

Most of the girls looked confused except Rarity.

“Twilight I of all ponies, wouldn't expect that from you.”

“Wait Rarity, you know what harem means?” Rainbow asked, confusion still written over her face

“Yeah Rainbow got the right idea sugarcube. We have no idea what that word means.”

Rarity pulled them close and whispered something in there ear. Their mouths dropped but Rainbow got a big grin and rushed over to Twilight who was blushing madly, and now pale in the face.

“So Twi. How about me and you go on a da...”

Twilight grabbed the dream journal with her magic and shoved it into Rainbow.

“ju-just read the next dream”

“Fine. The next dream is Flu-fluttershy’s.”

They all glanced at her.

“I walked into her house and saw a trap door under the carpet.”

Suddenly the book was taken in a yellow flash. They all looked at Fluttershy, who had lit a match and threw it into the book.

“What the hay Flutershy! I was gonna read that.”

“What in tarnation are you doing Flutters.”

“Deary, Fluttershy, what's wrong.”

“No pony. Can ever know that side of me.”

But there was a small wave of magic and they all looked. The book was fine. Rainbow was about to get the book but Spike got to it first.

“Spike what are you doing? I was gonna read it.”

“No it's time I get to read a little.”

“Fine.”

“I was about to walk out when i heard someone say. “Please no. This isn't the Fluttershy I know and love, please come back.” This caught my attention. I walked forward and i heard someone else. “That Fluttershy left when you decided to be buddies with Tirek you fucker.”

"SPKIE!" Twilight screeched at the language

"It's in the book Twilight! I swear"

Everyone stopped everything and they all looked at Fluttershy, who was hiding behind her mane and very pale with a deep blush.

Then Spike kept reading.

“I opened the door and ran down the stairs and saw Fluttershy kissing Discord. While he and Sombra were chained to a wall, and she was wearing all black leather with zippers covering everything.”

They all looked at her. There jaws agape. Fluttershy was whimpering under her mane, attempting to escape. Twilight noticed this and used her magic to hold her.

“She then started to whip Discord with a riding crop. Sombra and Discord had little red welts all over their bodies, and they looked like they had been there for ages. I was about to intervene when i remembered it was a dream. I slowly back away but before I leave, Discord looked at me with pleading eyes. I almost cried. Just then Fluttershy unzips one of the zippers on her nether regions and forces herself on an unwilling Discord.”

The groupe of friends all looked at Flutters. They were about to say something.

“Just read the next story so I can leave.” Fluttershy said flatly.

“Ok. Spike Next story plea-”

“AHHHHHHHHHHH”

Everypony shot there heads to Spike who had screamed as the book fell to the ground. He started to scurry away from the book he dropped on the floor, when he hit the wall he placed his hands on his face covering his eye. He looked at his friends but his eyes locked onto Pinkie Pie, nothing but fear plastered over his face. Everypony was worried, and moved closer to Spike.

“Sta-Stay back.”

“What's wrong Spikey Wikey?”

Spike was horrified. He looked left and right trying to find a way out, and all he saw was the window. He knew Twilight was gonna wring him out, but he didn't care, as getting away from them was more important. He turned and ran, and jumped threw the window. They all ran to the window and saw Spike running as fast as his little legs could carry him.

“Guys we need to get him.”

“Twilight's right. Let's go girls.”

They all turned to get to the door, but Pinkie was standing there. Her hair was straight, and her frown was slowly creeping into a sadistic smile. Twilight walked forward.

“Pinkie what's wrong.”

Pinkie looked up, her smile sending chills down all of their spines. She dropped the book and kicked it over to them. Twilight picked it up in her magic and read aloud.

“I walked into Pinkie’s dream and walked down a dark corridor. When I turned the corner, I saw Twilight dead on the floor. With blood pooling from where her horn used to be. I saw Rainbow Dash strapped to a chair, her wings were gone and she had her organs ripped out. I turned and saw Rarity, Applejack, Fluttershy, and Spike. They all had glassy eyes and looked starved and beaten, but poor Spike had an eye ripped out of his socket. It looked like it had been a long time since it happened. It was dried out and crusted, but I will never forget the dark abyss that lies were his eye used to be. They all had been chained by their necks to a chair. On top of the throne was a pink pony, who was adorned with a purple horn and cyan wings, and one dragonian eye. She had a smile like she had won the lottery. I had to leave, but when I backed up I bumped into something. All there faces focused on me. It rocked me to my soul. All their glassy eyes and that one endless dark vacuum of an eye. It made me freeze in my tracks. Pinkie flapped her new wings and landed on the floor. She walked to me slowly, and instead of talking in her normal fun happy fun voice, she now spoke like a psychopath's voice. All crackly and giggled, as she killed her friends and maimed them.

“Hey Luna nice to finally meet you. I'm Pinkamena. As you are most likely confused, allow me to explain. The real Pinkie Pie, the one you know is the one that broke from years and years of psychotherapy and electroshock. Did u know that if you perfectly take the horn and wings from a unicorn and pegasus you can become an alicorn. That was the dream before they fried my brain, but i live on in my dreams and no matter what you do i will never leave, and eventually I will get out.”

“Then she just started laughing. I turned and ran out of the portal, but what I saw still haunts me. I turned and saw Pinkie banging on the portal out into the dream realm, and behind her stood all of her friends. They all stood there staring me down, but Spikes eye kept looking into me. No matter how I looked into his eye, I saw nothing. Not hope or fear, it was just, empty. Just death, so i locked her dream scape so no one may ever enter it again.”

They all looked at were Pinkie used to be. They saw the door wide open.

Then they all said unison.

“Buck.”

They all ran outside and saw her hoofprints. They followed them, and ended up at Sugarcube Corner. They walked inside and were met with a Pinkie Pie standing on her back hooves. Holding Mrs. Cake by the mane, along with a knife to her throat. The saw Mr. Cake dead across the room with another knife in between his eyes. Pinkie looked at them, and slowly pulled the knife across her throat. Blood gushed and sprayed everywhere, washing Pinkie in a bath of crimson. She dropped her body as it twitched on the floor. Pinkie walked over to the cabinet and grabbed a bunch of knives. Twilight had ran out of options. She lit up her horn, and teleported them into the throne room. With the princesses and dozens of the royal guard, everyone in the room looked at the group. Celestia stood up. as Pinkie dropped all of her knives

“Twilight Sparkle, what is the meaning of this.”

“Pinkies gone insane.”

Just then a knife flew past Celestia's head and hit the wall. nopony said a word, it was deathly quite, until

“Damn, looks like i'm a little rusty.”

Everyone in the room locked eyes on Pinkie. She had just tried to assassinate the princess, within seconds of being in her presence. The guards instantly jumped into action. Trying to detain the pink pony, but every guard that got close to her, ended up with dead with broken legs, as she snapped their legs and necks without hesitation. She bit a guard on the neck and ripped out a chunk of his flesh as blood sprayed her and the floor. Everypony stopped and stared at her, Celestia was furious her. The white alicorns mane went from it's nice flowing pastel colors, to a bright orange and yellow as if it caught on fire.

“Pinkie what in tartarus are you doing.”

“Oh sweet princess don't you EVER COMPARE ME TO THAT PLACE.”

Then she threw another knife. She had brought an ample amount of knives when Twilight teleported her. Celestia quickly wrapped Pinkamena in a bubble, but some of the knives were in there with her. She grabbed two knives, she started to scratch the tip of one knife onto the blade of the other. Everypony was wondering what she was doing, until she tossed the one knife to the side, and she stabs the bubble with the sharpened knife, managing to pop it. Everypony stood astonished, at the fact that a earth pony broke the princesses barrier with nothing but a knife. As she landed on her hooves she looks to the princess and said

“Oh princess, did you really think that I wouldn't have a plan to get out of a situation that involved barriers. Its called anti-magic ruins. I had memorized the entire runic alphabet before they tried to fry my brain. Now I can enchant anything; even myself.” Her manic grin reappeared as She grabbed a knife and drew the same symbol on her chest, legs, and on her forehead with the knife point. It looked like two arrow heads overlapping each other, with a line drawn down the middle. Everypony cringed at it as she laughed the pain off. She was winding up her arm to throw a knife, but before she could finish, Discord had teleported in front of her.

“Is that chaos i sme-.”

Everypony stopped again. He looked down and saw the tip of the knife sticking out, and fell to his knees. He started gesturing his hands round the knife, and a moment later a loud slice filled the room everything was still and quiet. Then discords limp body feel forward, and his head rolled of his shoulders. Pinkie lifted the knife so the tip is pointed to Celestia, and her grin grew wider. Everything was silent, and celestia was gone she couldn't do anything. as discord a god was just killed like nothing. but before anypony said anything a wave of hate and anger filled the room. It was so strong that people could feel it in their core. Celestia turned her head, not able to look at the scene as the mane 6 stood in shock. There was fluttershy her nice bright yellow had more of a red tint in it. He mane was draped over her face as tears dropped from it. Pinkie saw this and opened her mouth.

“Oh hey Flutters, here's Discord." She tossed the corpse at her "I know how you like to force yourself on him, so now it should be a lot easier for ya.”

At that moment the air in the room grew twice as thick. Pinkie saw this and her smile grew wider.

“Oh ok lets dance rapist.”

Then the both dashed to the side, running on two legs. Then they turned to one another and started throwing and deflecting each other's hits. Pinkie ran back to her knives, picking up two, and throwing them at Fluttershy's hooves pinning them to the ground. She simply picked up her feet and kept walking, even though the knives ripped the muscle and spilt her hooves. This caught Pinkies attention. So she leaned down and picked up Discords disembodied head and brought it near her head. Fluttershy stopped dead in her tracks.

Even with blood pooling around her feet, she stood there waiting to see what Pinkie was going to do. Just then the main doors opened and Luna walked in and everyone saw it. Pinkie kissing Discord's head. Fluttershy moved her mane out of her face everypony saw her face it was contorted. Showing a huge amount of anger, she had she roared and ran at Pinkie. Raising her hoof on brought, she brought it down and left a crater in the floor as the whole room shook. Before Fluttershy could react, Pinkie appeared behind her. Pink hooves wrapped around her head, as everypony was frozen. As Pinkie snapped Fluttershy's neck, a loud CRACK filled the room.

Luna’s horn lit up in a dark aura and shot a bolt at Pinkie. Them moment it hit her, Pinkies body started convulsing. It looked like she about to get split in half, then there was a blinding light and there were two Pinkies. One with straight hair and one with poofed hair, both unconscious. Everypony didn't know what to say. A god and a friend died from a psychopath. Then the psychopath was split into the evil and the nice. Everypony turned to luna, and all she could do was shrug. Celestia teleported to Luna and mumbled something. Luna's face changed, then there was a a really familiar laugh. Everypony turned to the head of Discord who was laughing like crazy. Then his body pulled out the knife and picked up his head.

“You really all thought i was dead. HAHAHAHA priceless! The best part, the seemingly nice pony and element of laughter was the most fucked up in the head.”

And with that discord popped his head back on his shoulders. He snapped his fingers and turned.

“So Celestia how goes th-"

SLAP

Discord blinked his eyes and rubbed the back of his head, before he turned around and saw Celestia.

“What was that for.”

She stomped her hoof on the ground, tears running down her face before turning and as she pointed to Fluttershy.

“yeah she's unconscious.”

Celestia shook her head, as Discord turned to Fluttershy and snapped his fingers again. She didn't move. He did it again and again with the same results. He began to snap harder and more frantically as his face shifted to a worried look. He began to force magic into his hand making every snap emit a wave of chaotic energy. As a last attempt, he put his hands on her shoulders he shook her vigorously

“Wake up Fluttershy, it's time to wake up.”

Only silence filled the room.

“Come on Fluttershy, if this is a joke it's not funny.”

Nothing.

“Flutterbuddy.”

he said weekly. His words drenched in shock and worry, but she remained still, growing cold in his hands. He looked at her face, and noticed it was peaceful and serene. She looked happy. He looked to Celestia, and she said nothing in a attempt to keep her face stearn. Luna walked forward catching the remaining elements attention. She walked to the Pinkies and put them in a bubble. The one with straight hair feel through, Luna then put down the one with poofy hair, keeping her encased in the barrier. Celestia walked over to Luna, knowing what they needed to do.

The Pinkies woke up, surrounded by darkness.

“‘Is anypony here.”

“fuck you”

“Oh hi Pinkamena”

“fuck you Pinkie.”

“why are you so mean to me sis”

“i'm NOT you sis, I'm you”

“well you can't be me, if I'm me.”

“I'm a diffrent you.”

“There, you just said it. If you're different then how can you be me.”

“You're so lucky I can't see you, or I would kill you.”

“Why do you like killing so much?”

“Why do you like parties?”

“Cause they're fun silly.”

“Well then there's your answer.”

“But I don’t see how killing can be fun.”

“Think about it this way, it's a good way to get rid of a pony you don't like.”

“I get that bu-”

“Shhhhh, Pinkie let me show you my kinda fun.”

Even threw all that darkness Pinkie knew there was an evil smile.

“ok.”

Everypony was stunned by the display. The raw emotion flowing from Discord it hit everyone, even Rainbow felt it. As Discord clutched fluttershy's body he weeped. Celestia and Luna were in the corner talking, then some stirring on the floor. Nopony noticed when the Pinkies got up, they walked over to Discord and they both looked over and saw Fluttershy. Pinkamena just smiled while on the left, Pinkie did nothing on the right, the elements looked up and saw them. their faces changed to rage.

“Discord if ya wanna do something look to yer left.” Pinkamena whispered

He did so, and his face changed to rage as fire grew in his eyes. Standing up and turned to her, but she just kept smiling as she kicked her runed knife under Discord. The draconequus was to angry to notice, as were the others. Pinkie picked it up, it felt right in a way. The way was alien to her but her blank face grew into a smile. She tossed the knife in the air it did a flip, she caught it and her smile grew. Rainbow saw this and flew at her. Pinkie slid to the side, Pinkamena grabbed her leg and slammed her on the ground.

“Ouchy! Girls help me!”

It was then Pinkamena hopped on top of her, as she slid the knife across her face. The princesses finally caught what was happening. Luna fired a bolt of magic at Pinkie, but she held up the blade and sliced the magic bolt in half. It flew by her and blew up behind her with a flash. It shadowed Pinkie’s face, but her evil eyes sadistic smile stayed bright and vigilant. Discord and Pinkie were just staring at each other in a deadlock, but when the explosion went off Discord lunged and Pinkamena jumped back. She quickly kicked up a knife, and threw it at Discord. he turned and stopped the blade within his index and middle finger. Pinkamena slowly dragged the knife across Rainbows back. Rainbow didn't struggle, knowing all she had to do was slid in the knife. Then her greatest fear happened. It hit her wing and she stopped, the knife right at the pinion joint. Pressing a little harder, she started cutting into the skin. Celestia ran up but was stopped when Discord was thrown into her by Pinkamena. It was then Pinkamena grabbed her left wing and yanked it upward, dislocating it, and breaking multiple bones with a loud cracking noise. The other elements tried to reach her in time, before she lost her wing completely, but was stopped when Pinkamena ran in front them. Applejack tried to fight her by bucking her chest, but Pinkamena moved out of the way, reaching out, she grabbed Applejacks back right leg and broke it in two.

“ENOUGH!”

Celestia shouted and she teleported everypony except for the Pinkies outside. Locking the door, she broke the room off from the castle and lifted it up high. The door flew open and outside the
Pinkies jumped. they were falling but they were fighting at the same time. Then one stopped moving. They hit the ground, and there was a huge splat, and one of them stood up. It was Pinkie.
She stood on two hooves, and was slumped forward. Her hair covering her face while her arms were swaying with the runed knife in hand. She stopped while everypony was only 5 feet away, before she let the tears flow. She lifted her head up to look at everypony,
and it was then that they saw her face. Half was obviously forced into a smile, while the other half was a combination of sadness and fear. Tears ran down both her cheeks while her eyes looked like
they said kill me and die at the same time. She took a step forward, and almost fell onto the floor. Then she opened her mouth.

“It looks like it's time for a Pinkie Party.”

Everypony cringed, her voiced sounded forced and cut up but high pitched and sadistic still.

It bothered everypony as they all backed away. It was then a royal guard came and tried to stop her. Her eye twitched and she turned to the charging guard. When he was close enough to almost touch her,she gave him a uppercut, knocking him out.
She sliced him in half at the waist with the knife, before he fell to the floor. The pink pony turned to the rest of them, letting her hair fall over her face again as Luna walked forward.

“What are ya doing Luna! She'll knock your head right off your shoulders.” Twilight yelled, having a idea of what the moon princess was planning.

she said nothing.

“Yes darling, we can't stop her.”

“I can” she whispered like the wind

Rainbow studied her for a minute. “How then smart guy.”

“Because I am just like her.”

Celestia walked forward to her little sister. “and how might this be Luna.”

“Pinkamena is her Nightmare Moon.”

Everything was silent. Pinkie just stood there with her arms sawing side to side as if she was in a trance. Luna lit up her horn and expelled smoke, wrapping around her and Pinkie. Pinkie attempted to cut it, but to no avail. They both fell asleep. Luna woke up in the corridor of dreams and saw the locked portal. She unlocked it and carefully walked in only to hear the sound of crying. When he turned the corner, all she saw were all of her friends, decrepit and cut up. They should be dead she told herself, but instead they were all yelling at a crying Pinkie.

“You killed us.”

“Why would you do this.”

it was then Spike walked forward. He looked at her and asked “Why.”

When Pinkie looked down, she had a knife in Spike. He fell to his knees, unable to say a neither word. Even Luna felt bad for her, she cast a spell so she could record this dream for the future.
Pinkie took a step forward, while the rest of the dead bodies of her friends, were yelling at Pinkie. Pinkamena walked forward and sat on Pinkie's back. She yanked her counterparts head around and forcing her to look her friends.

“LOOK WHAT YOU DID PINKIE. THESE ARE YOUR FRIENDS AND YOU KILLED THEM. YOU'RE MORE OF A MURDER THEN ME. YOU EVEN KILLED POOR SPIKE, AND HE DID NOTHING. LOOK AT ALL THE DEATH YOU CAUSED.”

Luna was done with this, and banished all the living bodies, but Pinkamena and Pinkie.

“What are you doing here Pinkamena.”

“You forget that I'm a part of her, and no matter what you do I can't leave. You can try to fix this, but I will always come back.”

Pinkamena pulled up pinkie by her hair more, as she started sliding her knife across the mare's neck.

“She can never get rid of me.”

Luna used her magic and grabbed Pinkamena.

“WHAT ARE YOU DOING.”

“I'M LEAVING AND YOU'RE COMING WITH ME!”

“YOU IDIOT, YOU WILL KILL HER.”

“NO ONE DESERVES YOU IN THERE HEAD. IF ANYTHING THIS WILL BE A BLESSING.”

everypony stood and stared into the dark fog.

“Whats going on in there princess.”

“A battle for Pinkies state of mind, my dear student.”

Just then there was a bright light and the gas dissipated. Pinkie Pie laid unconscious, while Pinkamena and Luna were staring each other down. Pinkamena was angry, witch was not one of her favorite feelings. Luna picked up Pinkie and pulled her close for protection. Pinkamena ran forward trying to stab Luna, when a wall of fire appeared in front of her. Confused at first, she pieced everything together. Discord walked through the wall of fire, his face drenched in rage and hate. He brought up his claw, casting his magic, the walls of fire started to surround them. Chains came up and grabbed her legs, holding her in the hair. Legs stretched out, and unable to move. With a snap of Discords talons, Pinkamena felt everything, and more. Her nerves and senses were heightened. He then took a needle and pushed it into a sensitive part of her skin and she started screaming bloody murder. It felt worse than any other pain she could have felt before; and that says something. Discord then snapped his fingers, and crossed his arms. The chains started to pull her apart, limb by limb. Her legs started to rip out of their joints, as her bones started cracking from the pressure. As the sunset behind them, so did the life of the demonic being known as Pinkamena Diane Pie. Thankfully, and Pinkie Pie was still alive. After Luna showed them her dream everypony was appalled by what was in her brain. They knew that they could have done, could have come close, to what Pinkamena did in her head.

Pinkie Pie is still haunted by her dreams of killing Fluttershy and the Cakes, but she was chosen to raise their foals Pumpkin and Pound, and she took great honor in that. She was able to live her life happy again. There is one issue that they faced. One of the elements was gone. They knew there needed to be a new element, but who will takes its place. For who is kinder than Fluttershy.

Author's Note

im soo sorry for the ending i wanted to bring flutters back but there was no way with out it hurting the story

and thanks for Hinata Linn for the editing