Best Friends With Benefits

by Night_Dice

Rating: mature
Tags: Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Sex, Slice of Life
Length: 4014

Three best friends spends Hearts And Hooves Day with each other.

Warning: This fanfic contains sexual content, please turn away if you're too underaged for this kind of material. I didn't say I didn't warn you bud.

Hearts and Hooves Day, a celebration which is to be shared with your special somepony. Except for Feather Gale the pegasus. A tomboy pegasus mare who wants to experience the celebration with her two special someponies, Night Dice and Mocha.

Everything will be fine, until the tie breaker. That's when she gets really touchy.

Published 2016-02-24 17:20:02 UTC
Last updated 2016-02-24 17:20:02 UTC

Three Best Buds

Author's Note

This is just for fun and was requested by friends of mine, so I'm gonna post it here for all to see.

(This clopfic will not have any effect on my upcoming story: "Of Dice And Luck".

ENJOY!

Three Best Buds

“So, you got any threes?” Night Dice, a bat pony asked. He has a dark coat with brown mane, tail, and eyes. And he has eye glasses that he only wears for the looks. He has a pair of dice with question marks on them instead of the standard numbered ones.

Mocha, the pony across him shook his head, “Nope, go fish.” His coat is a light gray color and his mane and tail on the side of lighter brown. He also has red eyes and a coffee cup with a heart beside it as a cutie mark.

“OH COME ON!” Night Dice groans and picked up a card from the pile and threw his hoof in the air with frustration. He then crossed his hooves and made a pouty face as he muttered, “I knew we should’ve played P-21.”

The pony across him smirked and fixed his hoof of cards, “Don’t you mean blackjack?” He asked without taking his eyes off his cards. Mocha then sat back on his sit and looked outside at the pairs of ponies trotting by and back to the bat pony, “Hey Dice, you have someone in mind for Hearts and Hooves Day?” The bat pony responded with a shake of his head.

A mare then comes down from the stair case with a white coat dressed up in red entered with a neatly combed yellow and gray mane. “So, which one of you will take me out for Hearts and Hooves day?” She asked. “I’m still a mare ya know and this dress cost me a lot of bits.” Even if she is a mare, she has more of a tomboy attitude. So the two stallions quickly grew to her as a very close friend after agreeing that all three of them share a house together.

Dice grabbed the cards he scattered with his bat wings and dumped them all back on the table. “Feather Gale, uhm…...” He paused and switched his view to Mocha and back at Gale. And an idea finally came to mind. “You know what?” He asked with a smirk on his face.

“What?” Both asked in unison.

Dice pulled off his glasses and wipes them with a cloth and wears them again. “Mocha, take her out for lunch and I’ll take her out for dinner later. What do you think?” He asked with a smile on his face hoping that this plan would work.

Mocha rubbed the back of his neck nervously and turned between Dice and Gale. He sat on his haunches and sighed, “Dice, I uhm uh not sure that’s how dating works.”

He grinned and clapped with his forehooves, “And that’s not how relationships work on that book we read last year.” Dice then wrapped both his forelegs at both their necks. “C’mon, three best friends and Gale dating both of us, it’ll be fun! It’s a win win situation, I think.” The bat pony lets go and lay back on the ground, "Besides, I also have to finish off some last minute weather reports from last night."

Mocha sighed in defeat, "Alright alright. But you'll take her out for dinner later, right?" Dice responded with a nod. "You sure 'bout that, Dice?"
Gale swayed her hips making sure to hit the bat pony at the back making him eep and blush, “C’mon Dice, you should promise us ‘cause we still remember what happened last time.” She said with a grin on her face.

He sighed as he fixed his glasses and crossed his chest with his forehoof and sticked it on his his eye at the end. "Pinkie promise." He muttered as he sat back.

Gale sat on her haunches and wrapped her arms on Mocha and hugged him tightly. She gives him a small lick on the cheek, “This is so going to be so much EPIC!” She shouted from the top of her lungs.

Dice removed his hooves from his ears after hearing that shout. The two stallions does admire her quite a bit but it’s still not enough for a romantic commitment. He readjusted his glasses and looked at both ponies, “Well, it’s one of those once in a lifetime stuff that you do with friends, right?” He gave out a light chuckle to fill the room. “Besides, all of us will always be together. No matter what.”

~~~~

Mocha fixed his bowtie on the collar of his shirt. He looked at himself at the mirror and nodded. He was ready. Then he collapsed on the floor as he trembled in fear. "I'm not ready for this!" He shouted, but he quickly covered his mouth with his hooves making sure that nopony heard him.

Someone later knocked on the door and entered the room, thankfully it was just Dice. He smirked and leaned on the frame as he shouted, "He's ready, Gale!" Dice lowered his head to the trembling earth pony, "Hey don't worry, and you’ll be fine." He grabbed poor Mocha and tossed him across his back.

Mocha looked at both sides of the hallway as his teeth clattered, "I'm scared man! This is our friend and I have no idea how this afternoon's gonna turn out!"

The bat pony smiled and ruffled up Mocha’s mane with his hoof, "Just relax buddy, think of it like we're hanging out. Minus me of course." He lowered his body so Mocha could jump off his back, "And it's not like you're dating a hot mare." Dice blushed a bit as his face scrunched up while his wings flared open and grew stiff. "Well she is a bit hot and sexy." He muttered.

Mocha threw his hooves up in frustration as his cheeks started to grow red, "You're not helping me you know!"

"Hey guys!" Gale called out from downstairs, and judging by her voice it looks like she's a bit frustrated. "Where's my little coffee pony?"

Mocha gulped, "Uhn, I'm on my way down!" He took one more look at the bat pony before traversing down the stairs. He nervously let out a chuckle and waved his hoof at the mare waiting for him. “Uh, kept you waiting?”

Gale’s face scrunched up as she wrapped her forelegs around the earth pony, “This is one of those rare cases where I literally act like a mare.” She rolled her fetlock into a fist and shook it vigorously, “SO GIVE ME A GOOD DAY OR I SWEAR ON THE NAMES OF THE ROYAL SISTER I WILL PUNCH YOU AT CERTAIN TENDER PLACES WHERE YOU WON’T SIT PROPERLY FOR DAYS! AM I CLEAR!?” Mocha replied with a quick nod and a short whimper. She then lets him go with a bright smile on her face, “Good! Now let’s go!” She opened the door and went out.

The earth pony stood up still traumatized and followed Gale. “Yeah, uhm, let’s go.” Mocha said.

Night Dice upstairs let out a loud laugh making him tumble down the stairs while holding his side with his forehooves. “THAT ALSO COUNTS YOU, NIGHT DICE!” Gale shouted from outside making the bat pony gulp.

“Uh oh.” Was the last thing he said before rushing back upstairs to finish his work quickly so he can prepare himself for his dinner date with Gale later.

~~~~

Mocha took Gale to a local restaurant/café near the town hall. It was just an average afternoon in the small town of Ponyville, so that means that the restaurant’s a bit packed because of the lunch hour. But luckily there’s still a table available for them.

“Here you go, Gale.” Mocha pulled out the chair and waited to push it back as Gale sat down. He trotted towards his chair across her and smiled. “It’s a bit stuffed, but I think this can work, right?” He asked with a nervous chuckle.

Gale replied with a smirk as she browsed the menu. She then waved at the waiter and quickly said, “I’ll take the double decker oat burger with a bottomless iced tea.” She smiled at the end.

The waiter shook his head, “Alright madame,” he then turned to Mocha who was still browsing, “What about for the sir?”

Mocha cleared his throat and faced the waiter, “I’ll have the oat steak, well-done.” He turned the menu to the drinks. Of all the drinks on the menu he settled for one thing, “I’m having what she’s having for the drink.”

“Anything else?” The waiter asked as he jutted down the orders. Both ponies shook their heads in response. “Alright, please wait for your orders to arrive.” He said before leaving the two alone.

Gale leaned back on her chair and tapped her hooves on the table. Both didn’t spoke to each other for a while until she broke the silence, “So, how’s your work and stuff?”

He raised an eyebrow and crossed his forehooves, “But we live together? How do you not notice that?”

Gale blushed and scratched the back of her neck, “Well I tend to not notice the boring everyday stuff we do sometimes.” She touched the tip of her hooves with a nervous smile. “BUT HEY!” The pegasus then slammed her hooves on the table as her wings flared up, “That doesn’t mean I don’t value you guys!” She then jumps forward until her belly’s flat on the table and her hooves wrapping Mocha. “You guys are the best!”

Mocha blushed and pats the pegasus on the head. “Uhm, you too Gale.” His eye wandered to the other direction and thinks about Night Dice, wishing that he was there with them to enjoy the moment and not be let out.

“Uhm excuse me,” A pony coughed beside them. They both turned to see the waiter with their beverages. “Will you please remove yourself from the table, madame?” He asked kindly while trying to act like a professional.

The pegasus chuckled as she rested her rump on the chair, she touched the tips of her forehooves with a nervous smile. “Can’t I flirt with my date like this once in a while? Sorry ‘bout that.” Mocha’s cheeks went red and stood out from his coat.

The orders later arrived and both ponies enjoyed their meal. A couple of more talks erupted until they left the restaurant and took a little stroll down the park until sunset.

Night Dice on the other hoof………………..

~~~~

“Where is it? Where is it?! WHERE IS IT?!” The bat pony shouted as he threw his laundry across the room. “Where’s my bowtie?!” He then looked at the floral patterned necktie hanged on his chair by the desk. “Well, it’s no bowtie but it’ll do.” He grabbed it without second thoughts and tied it on the collar of his shirt. Dice checked himself one more time before hearing the door open downstairs. “Oh no!”

Gale chuckled as she pecked Mocha’s cheek, “Thanks for giving me a good afternoon.” Her head then perched up and shouted, “NIGHT DICE, YOU’RE UP NEXT!” All they got in a respond was silence. “Dice?” She called out once more.

Mocha sighed and expected what he should be expecting. “I’m gonna get him, just wait here.” The earth pony stallion went up to the bat pony’s room.

He knocked and waited for a reply but silence was the only thing he heard. “Come on Dice, she’s ready!” Mocha opened the door and sees the mess inside the room. He picks up Dice’s missing bowtie and chuckled, “Bowties will always be cool.” A thud emanated from the closet. “Dice?”

The closet door burst open revealing a sweating Night Dice. The bat pony grabbed Mocha’s collar and pulled him, “I CAN’T DO THIS MAN! ONE WRONG MOVE AND IT’S GAME OVER!” He crumbled down on the floor and holds the sides of his head. “I can’t do it….” He said over and over again.

Mocha rolled his eyes and smacked Dice across the face. “SNAP OUT OF IT!” He took a deep breath and lets him go. “What happened to that “it’s gonna be okay, man”? What happened to that?”

The bat pony shrugged, “I-I…. Never went out with a mare before, I-I’m just guessing.” He chuckled nervously.

Mocha bursts out laughing, “Dude, you are so full of it!” He then pulled Dice to his hooves and brushed his mane. “Don’t worry, she’s already in a good mood so you’ll do fine.”

Dice gulped and fixed his glasses with his shaky hoof. He then took a deep breath, “Alright, just two friends, right?” Mocha nodded in response, “She’s just a sexy hot friend, no pressure.”

“Gale! He’s ready to come down!” He shouted from the room.

Dice looked at Mocha one more time and nods, “Just a friend.”

~~~~

“DICE!” Gale shouted into his ear.

Dice jumped back with a high pitch shriek, “JUST A FRIEND!”

The pegasus started to giggle and nudged him, “I don’t bite, don’t worry. I’m gentle.”

He gulped and nodded, “Right, let’s go inside and eat dinner, because that’s what we’re here for.” He opened the door and extended his other hoof to gesture her to go in first. “Ladies first.”

Gale smiled and went in as she waved her tail to touch Dice’s nose making his cheeks red and his wings flare up. “Come on, my little bat pony.”

Dice shook his head to clear his mind but the fact that she made that gesture made him confused and slightly aroused. “Y-Yeah.” Was all he said as he followed her with his stiff wings.

He pulled the chair and offered it to Gale, she smiled and booped his nose, “Thank you Dice.” Gale said. Dice then transferred to his seat across her. The waitress arrived but Gale cut her hoof with a raised hoof, “I’m gonna take the oat burger with large hay fries. Extra crispy too. And some red wine.” She concluded with a smile.

Dice’s jaw was wide open dumbfounded, he then turned to the waitress, “I’ll just have some salad and an iced tea, thank you.” The waitress nodded and trotted off to the kitchen. The bat pony looked at the pegasus across him, “So how was your date with Mocha earlier?” He asked.

Gale shrugged and smiled, “It went well so that means you have to do just as well as him.” She sat back and closed her eyes. “You have to give me a good time, Dice.”

The bat pony took a deep breath, no pressure.

Soon their food and beverages arrived, Gale quickly dug into her food while Dice ate his salad as he watched his date. “Ain’t that a bit classy, Dice?” She asked and pointed the salad he was eating.

Dice swallowed and nods, “Well,” he scratched the back of his neck and fixed his glasses, “I’m on a diet.”

Gale nodded slowly, “You are growing thin.” She slowly moved forward, “And you look foxy.” The bat pony blushed red as his wings sprang up and choked on a piece of lettuce in his throat, making the pegasus laugh. “You are so full of it Dice!” She took a sip of her wine as she sat back for the entertainment in front of him.

Later the two ponies finished their dinner and went home. In Gale’s mind, she was satisfied in her two dates. But it’s a tie, and a tie breaker was already running in her mind.

Dice yawned as he collapsed on the couch while Mocha was doing some drawing on his sketchpad. Gale on the other hoof flew straight up. “So how was the date?” Mocha asked without removing his eyes from the sketch.

“I think it went well.” He responded under the pillow.

Mocha hopped off his chair with a yawn and patted the bat pony on the back making him groan, “C’mon buddy, and time to go to your room and take the night off.” He trotted up the stairs to go to his room.

Dice threw away the pillow that was covering his face on the floor. “Alright, I’m gonna go up now.” He stood up on all fours and stretched his legs.

“WHAT IN THE NAME OF THE TWO ROYAL SISTERS AND EVERYTHING ROYAL ARE YOU DOING WITH THE DOOR OPEN?!” Mocha shouted from upstairs.

With that, Dice flew up the stairs and landed beside the shocked Mocha, who was also blushing? “What happened? What’s going on?” Dice asked hastily, but the only response he got was a hoof pointing inside the mare’s room. He turned his head towards the room, but the view made his face burn and his wings flaring out knocking the pony beside him.

Inside the room was Feather Gale, with hindlegs spread out while she was touching her sensitive opening with the tip of her forehoof. She then smiled seductively as she continued to moan as juices started to squirt out of her opening, “C-Come, h-here you t-two.” She said in between moans, “Come inside.”

Mocha stood up as he sweats and blushes, “B-But………..” He stuttered.

The bat pony gulped and tries to look away, “W-Why are you-“ He cleared his throat, “W-We have a rule about self-pleasuring, r-remember?”

Gale stood up from her bed and wrapped her forelegs around the two confused stallions by her door. She slowly pulled them closer and closer to her bed. “You two gave me a very awesome and entertaining day.” She then sat down on the bed with her lower regions staining it. “So, it’s only fair that you two have a tie breaker round.” She licked her hoof tip and started to play around her opening again.

“Uhm uh…..” Both stallions stuttered as both of their thick and throbbing members are stiff and unsheathed.

“I want the two of you to jerk off,” Gale said, she paused and licked the juices off her hoof tips. “And whoever cums first, loses.” She concluded with a wink.

Night Dice stepped up as sweat started to run down from his forehead, “I-I’m not sure about this-“

He was cut off by a kiss on the lips by Gale. She then pulled away and pushed the bat pony to his haunches, “Get to work, bat boy.” She turned to Mocha and kissed him on the lips as well as she slowly touched his throbbing member gently. The pegasus finishes and goes to his ear and whispered, “You two, coffee.”

The two started to stroke their throbbing members, and each moan grew louder and louder as both of them started to leak pre maturely. Both of them turned to each other’s eyes and then to the pegasus in front of them.

“Mmmmmmmm uuuhhhgggg hhaaaaaa” Night Dice shouted in ecstasy as his seeds shot out from the opening of his penis. He then fell down on the floor, panting and a bit tired. He rolled his eyes and groans, “Why me?”

The pegasus then crawled towards the bat pony and started to lick his member gently. “Oh don’t worry Dice, you get the consolation prize. I always wanted to taste your thick bat pony meat.” Gale turned to Mocha was just sitting on his haunches and catching a breather. She waved her hoof to signal him to get to her, “And time for your prize, Mocha.” She uses her free hoof to spread her pussy wide open as her clitoris winked at the lust hungry stallion.

Mocha started to lick her gaping opening with his tongue making her moan as she continued to suck and savour the taste of his cum. “W-Why a-am I still h-having this?” Dice asked as chills ran down his body down to his lower regions.

Gale pulled away for a moment with a grin on her face as she turned to the earth pony, “Stop licking and start bucking or else I’ll kick you in your certain tender place.” Mocha pulled while puffing his hot breath on her pussy.

He nodded and readjusted himself so his stiff and throbbing cock aligned himself to her opening. “I’m sorry, Gale.” Mocha gently made his way into her and rocked his hips back and forth penetrating her with every movement.

She moaned loudly and returned on sucking Dice’s flaccid and wet member. The moans of all three ponies filled the room and their sweat and musk covering the air. With each passing moan they grew closer and closer to their limits. Gale pulled her head up, “I-I’m about t-to cum, s-so w-who’s about t-to c-c-cum too???” She asked in between pants as Mocha rammed his penis back and forth into Gale’s opening. Both ponies shakily raised their forehooves.

Dice leaned back his head as his hard erect penis throbbed as precum slowly run down the shaft. “I-I have no idea how long I can hold it.”

Mocha slowed his pace. “I-I think I’m almost t-to my limit too.”

“I want both of you to do it.” Gale said. She quickly turned to Mocha and shouted, “CUM INSIDE ME!” She then faced Dice who was puzzled and tired. “YOU TOO! I WANT TO TASTE YOUR BAT PONY CUM IN MY MOUTH!” Gale opened her mouth and dove in to suck on Dice’s penis once more, but she’s licking and sucking twice as fast than earlier.

Dice moaned louder and louder, “G-Gale! Don’t, I-I’m about to…… hhhhrrr mmmmmm.” He tried to hold it but lets it go making his seeds shoot down the mare’s throat. Simultaneously, Gale released her orgasm and almost chocked from the stream that she gagged back making the rest of his cum splatter on her face.

“I CAN’T HOLD IT ANYMORE!” Mocha shouted as he doubled his pacing making him shoot out his cum inside her walls. He pulled back and collapsed on the floor while still spurting bits of his seeds from his tip.

Gale’s hindlegs shook as the white liquid poured and squirt out of her winking opening. She turned to Mocha and started to lick his still flaccid penis. “Dice, now’s your chance. I want you to buck me too” She winked at the bat pony as she started to lick the earth pony’s wet pole.

The bat pony stood up and wobbly trotted to the mare’s rear. Her hind legs are spread out while the opening of her vagina, “I-I’ll try.” He wrapped his forhooves on her waist and made his way into her wet and oozing pussy. He started to rock back and forth making him hard again.

Mocha peered down to his penis which is being sucked by one of his best friends. “D-Dice,” He called out, “What h-have we g-gotten ourselves into?” The bat pony shrugged as he quickened his pace. The earth pony laid his head back down letting Gale do her work.

Dice moaned as he was about to reach his third climax, “GALE!” He shouted as he released his seeds deep inside her vagina making her moan loudly.

Mocha’s face scrunched up as he expelled his cum onto her face, mixing it with Dice’s cum. Dice and Gale fell on the ground beside Mocha. “Best Hearts and Hooves day EVER!” Gale shouted and kissed Dice on the lips making him taste the cum on her lips. Mocha was about to say something but was cut by her lips meeting his. She pulled away and wrapped her hooves around the two stallions’ necks, “You guys are the best.” Her grin grew larger at a sudden thought. “You know what?”

“What?” Both asked at the same time.

“I can’t stand up yet I feel good and filled, so that mean……….” She paused as she pulled both of them closer, “LET’S DO THIS EVERY HEARTS AND HOOVES DAY!”

Both stallions’ eyes shot wide and shouted the same thing, “EVERY HEARTS AND HOOVES DAY?!”

Gale just closed her eyes with a smirk on her face, “I love you two nutjobs.”