Suddenly I'm Marble Pie?!

I discovered that ponies have neck scruffs, much like kittens, as evidenced by the way Big Mac carried a captive Starlight inside with Fleet Foot in tow. It was a fascinating thought, the same way the ceiling could be fascinating when you were trying your hardest to not think about how many ways Starlight was about to get screwed.

Okay, I gotta admit, some strangely unhinged part of me wasn’t trying all that hard. The memory of that kiss we shared was still fresh on my lips. Something about it left me, well, curious, that’s it. While I was in no rush to pounce her hot violet tush—....I mean, think about her in that way, it wasn’t something I was entirely averse to either. Does that even make sense? Flaming bouncy Starflanks, why does she have to be so confusing?!

“Equestria to Marble?” Cheerilee derailed my train of thought, bringing me back to the cozy little bathroom. “Are you sure you’re alright, sweetie bun?” She asked, pausing midway through wiping my face clean with a hoof-towel.

I gave her a quick nod and a watery smile. The last thing I needed was the herd mom fussing over me anymore than she was already.

“You sure are covered in a lot of soot,” she said disapprovingly as she cleaned behind my ears.

Unfortunate side-effect of terminal train overdose.

“Hmmm, you’re going to need a proper shower I’m afraid. You might as well leave it for now, considering you’re going to need another one later anyway,” she giggled, giving the soiled towel a rinse in the bathroom sink.

‘Yes, preferably one with bleach,’ so I thought. On hindsight, I should have given her words more thought, perhaps even more horror.

“C’mon, Sweetie Bun,” she chuckled, waiting for me by the door. She allowed me to lean into her side, enabling me to hobble alongside her.

I had mixed feelings about walking over that threshold and into our bedroom. On the one hand I had to reassure myself that it was all going to be about Starlight and I might even get away with just watching...something I was admittedly maybe perhaps possibly not entirely against. On the other hand I was at the very least going to see a gigantic male horse rut a small female one senseless. But (and nothing against ponies, some of my best friends are ponies) there was still a part of me that perhaps finds that kinda squeamish.

As Cheerilee guided me into the room, my eyes were immediately drawn to the cerise unicorn lying flat on her belly. Fleet Foot stood over her, one forehoof firmly pushing the unicorn’s head down in between a massive pair of crimson thighs. I felt my breath catch as I watched Starlight’s tongue desperately lick at what looked like a door knob sitting atop a pair of orbs the size of celestial bodies. “Yes, keep at it, rookie,” Fleet Foot growled, huskily, “You’re going to prepare your own punishment, you’re gonna make it bigger and harder than your tight little cunny can take. And you’re gonna take in every inch even if we have to stretch your innermost bits wide open.”

Flaming boomerang dildos, this mare talks so dirty my showers are gonna need showers. Starlight seemed to agree, moaning needily as she traced the thick folds of skin enveloping his mighty orbs with loving lashes of her tongue. Big Mac gave a low groan as his flesh began to twitch and rise. “Ah, ah, you need to lube up every inch as it comes out,” Fleet chided, pressing the unicorn’s muzzle back where it belonged, “And keep it inside where it’s warm and moist so all that lube doesn’t dry out. After all, that’s what your mouth is for, isn’t it?” Fleet caressed Starlight’s cheeks, guiding her lips to the tip peeking out of what I realized was only Big Mac’s sheathe. “That’s right, kiss him deeeep, rookie,” Fleet cooed. Starlight gave a long, slow moan as the flared tip throbbed and penetrated her lips open. Big Mac gave a satisfied groan as his shaft grew and parted her mouth wider.

Cheerilee didn’t seem to mind the performance much, helping herself to a corner of the bed. She patted the empty space next to her invitingly. My legs were quick to give away, depositing me in a numb heap next to her. She giggled as she pulled me the right way up and curled a forehoof around me, as if settling back to watch a movie. I wouldn’t be surprised if she suddenly whipped out a tub of popcorn. Is this how herds do it? I was expecting more action, less peanut gallery.

Speaking of peanuts, I certainly could do with something, anything to bite on. I resorted to biting my own lips as I watched Starlight’s tongue lap at the underside of Big Mac’s sheath, as if desperate to coax more of his length out. His stallionhood had grown to an impressive girth, stretching Starlight’s little muzzle wide where her lips met his sheathe. With a combination of Fleet Foot holding her down and her own determination, she gave no ground even as Big Mac’s forced her maw wider and wider with every twitch. The bulge of her fuzzy cheeks became more and more pronounced as she suckled deeply and lovingly on Big Mac. Her suckles slowly transformed into practiced gulps in between brief hungry moans as the mighty rod seemed to dominate the entirety of her little muzzle. Fleet ran her forehoof lovingly along Starlight’s neck. One gulp was bigger than the rest as a noticeable bulge pushed its way into the tight ring of her throat.

I suddenly caught myself drooling. I quickly swallowed hard, just as Starlight did the same. We both moaned, I at the sight and Starlight at the feel of the mighty rod hardening and spreading the bulge in her throat. I felt the bed become increasingly damp with every happy moan from Starlight. Surely I wasn’t drooling that much?

“Somepony’s enjoying herself, hmmm?” Cheerilee giggled. I let out a little squeak as I felt her tail run along my back before curling over my….

HOLY FLAMING FLYING CHILI TACOS OF DOOM!

Wh-what is that hot, wet thing she just zapped with her tail?! And what is her tail made of?! Lightning bolts?!

I gave a loud cry as I protectively pressed my thighs together. I felt whatever it was leak more over my fur and into the soaking bedspread. I bit my lip as I felt my thigh roll accidentally draw Cheerilee’s tail in between them. She sniggered mischievously as she slowly, torturously drew her tail out. I felt every strand prickle and tingle as her tail ran over….

Hold. The. Pony. Phone.

I suddenly realized what I was missing down there, or, perhaps, more accurately, what I had gained.

Just in case I wasn’t shellshocked enough, Cheerilee pulled the tip of her tail up to her mouth and slowly, sensuously suckled on the tip. “Starry, Snuggle Bear, Fleety, Marble is really enjoying your show. I can taste it,” she cooed as she ran her tongue through the dripping strands of her tail.

And I was obviously leaking. In fact, I was leaking even more with Cheerilee’s stunt. Obviously my new parts didn’t need me, it was already busy doing its own thing.

“You shouldn’t keep your audience waiting then,” Fleet chuckled, “Think your punishment is ready, Glims?”

Starlight gave a low moan and a stiff nod as she allowed Fleet Foot to pull her head back. I think I lost my jaw on the floor somewhere when my eyes widened so much it pushed everything else off my face. What emerged from Starlight’s mouth was nothing short of an artillery gun, almost twice the width of my hoof at its root. There was a loud, wet pop as his medial ring, thick as a donut, squeezed itself past Starlight’s lips. Her glistening saliva hung in thick ropes across the long, wicked curve as more and more of its impossible length emerged. She gave a soft whimper as the largest bulge in her throat finally cleared, turning into a swelling in her already stretched cheeks. She panted as her mouth struggled to deliver the monster that was his flare. Fleet had to give her some help, caressing her lips apart as she coaxed the shaft out. Starlight gave a loud gasp as the flare finally cleared her maw. It was a truly the staff of kings, with thick cruel phalanges and a wide hard crown still gleaming with Starlight’s labour of love.

With practiced efficiency, Fleet Foot rolled Starlight onto her back, allowing her to stare up at her soon-to-be pussy wrecker. Starlight could only moan in awe. Thick strands of drool trailed from the tip to the unicorn’s panting tongue as the rod traced a glistening path of saliva down her chest, over her round pony tummy and down between her trembling thighs.

“Oh, eager, are we?” Fleet Foot taunted, pulling Starlight’s rear legs wide apart, revealing her trembling little maidenhead. “Do you want your punishment, you naughty little filly?”

Starlight gave a little nod in reply.

“I can’t hear you, rookie!” Fleet taunted, slapping a forehoof down on the unicorn’s plush rump. Starlight’s tight marehood quivered, leaking a fat dribble of mare juice.

“P-please, buck my pussy!” Starlight moaned, leaking even more.

“Louder! I can’t hear you over the sound of you leaking all over the place!” Fleet barked, smacking the unicorn’s inner thighs, releasing a generous dollop of love juice from Starlight’s pent up cunny.

“P-Please, Big Mac, I n-need you to punish me hard!” Starlight pleaded.

Big Mac didn’t need any more encouragement. With a loud grunt he pushed his cruel flare up against Starlight’s impossibly small opening. The unicorn whimpered, biting her lips tight as her pegasus herd-sister raised her rump up with a pillow, angling her hips for him. With a feral growl his enormous tree-toppling muscles rippled, plunging his ribbed flare deep inside her. Fleet Foot allowed her to cry out passionately for but a moment before she buried Starlight’s face in soft, Grade A pegasus ass. “Yes, I want to hear you scream in me, rookie!” Fleet cried as she sank down on Starlight’s muzzle.

Both Fleet Foot and Big Mac dug their hooves into the bed as they each straddled their own bit of Starlight. Big Mac had begun to slide his length in slow, firm strokes, easing his flare deeper and deeper into Starlight’s depths. Minute after long minute, every slow inch spread the unicorn’s already tight pussy wider and wider until his thick medial ring finally slapped against her quivering outer lips. The shaft itself seemed to struck firm resistance where it bulged visibly against Starlight’s belly.

“Hmmm, are you ready to take it all and complete your punishment?” Fleet Foot panted, excitedly, as she squeezed the quivering bulge with a forehoof.

The trembling unicorn beneath her gave a loud, needy moan into her depths.

“Then take it, you naughty little filly,” Fleet growled, pulling Starlight’s tender lips apart, letting more pressurized juice to escape. On cue, Big Mac delivered a ponderously slow but powerful thrust that simply grinded past any barrier. He drove his medial ring and his shaft past Starlight’s final resistance. The unicorn released a long, loud passionate cry, her entire body arching. Her already tight pussy contracted rhythmically against his stallionhood, releasing great spurts of thick hot marecum from her overflowing honeypot. Her hooftips curled sensuously as she curled her rearlegs around her stallion, pulling him in deeper.

Starlight suddenly curled her forehooves around her pegasus herd-sister’s thighs. Fleet’s eyes widened at the sudden reversal of control. “Wai-...” She barely managed before the strong hooves curled around her thighs tugged her downwards. “G-GLIIIIIIIMS!” Fleet shrieked as her pussy was speared open by Starlight’s muzzle. The unicorn didn’t relent even as a deluge of marecum flooded her face. She burrowed her muzzle even deeper. I just about saw her open her muzzle wide inside before she disappeared beneath Fleet’s collapsing body.

Big Mac continued to pound the little unicorn beneath him. He had no other choice with how powerful Starlight’s vicegrip was on his rump. He found himself forced to thrust deeper and deeper as the unicorn’s hold tightened further and further. He finally hilted with a loud growl, his strokes deep, feral and frantic. Just when he thought he had found a rhythm, a thick luscious tail curled around his balls. He gasped as he realized the bitter truth - Starlight had been in control all along. He let out a loud cry as the tail gripped and milked his orbs for their contents. He hilted true, burying himself as deep as possible in his mare. He grunted again and again as he pumped into her again and again, each thrust filling her more and more. Her already impressive belly bulge swelled with the sudden deluge of what could only be thick, hot Apple seed. Starlight cried out as her own thick hot honey mixed in with Big Mac’s, churning inside her trembling insides before finally spurting around the edges of the cock plugging her foal hole.

The mighty stallion groaned loudly as he finally pulled all the way out of his mare, likely for want of space. Starlight gave a loud cry as the madly pulsing rod tugged out of her still contracting honeypot. Big Mac continued to pump burst after potent burst of seed all over Starlight’s thighs and belly. Starlight’s pleading look and invitingly open mouth coaxed the stallion to aim the final deluge all over her face. He finished by allowing her to cradle the tip in her forehooves, filling her little muzzle to the brim with thick, hot stallion juice.

His gaze was suddenly pulled away from the sight of his herd mare suckling his cum straight from the tap. I followed his gaze down to Starlight’s battered pussy, still overflowing with hot stallion seed. Fleet Foot had crawled over to pull her herd-sister’s pussy open, her tongue softly lapping up the flowing love mix. The sight of the pegasus drinking his cum out of his unicorn’s used pussy seemed to give him a second wind. He groaned loudly as he delivered a fresh volley of seed into Starlight’s overflowing muzzle.

Big Mac gave a loud, contented sigh as he finally finished. He just about managed to stay on his hooves long enough to kiss his two beloved marefriends on their foreheads. Starlight and Fleet gave appreciative hums at his show of affection.

To my surprise, Fleet still managed to crawl on her trembling hooves, pulling herself over to Cheerilee. I couldn’t help but gulp as I watched Cheerilee lean in, gladly locking lips with Fleet’s bulging mouth. Pearly white cum dribbled down their chins as they swirled their stallion’s seed back and forth with their tongues, moaning loudly into one another. I was so mesmerized by the sight that I didn’t notice a certain pony sneak up on me on her belly. I suddenly found myself on the receiving end of a flying tackle that sent me sprawling on my back. My assailant was quick to straddle me, her hot sweaty pony body pressed up against mine. Her brilliant magenta eyes gazed deeply into my own as she gently pressed her lips against mine.

I knew what waited behind her lips. A small part of me rebelled at the thought of it. The rest of me had resigned myself to it.

To my surprise she didn’t press in any further. She waited, expectantly. She gave me the option. Suddenly I had the choice of sharing something very intimate, very special, with this beautiful pony who has caused me no end of confusion. Maybe I could finally end that confusion. Or maybe I could quit overthinking things and enjoy an excitingly kinky moment with this cute mare, sharing our stallion’s seed with a loving kiss.

Eh. You only live once and a half.

I curled my forehooves around her neck and pulled her into me. Our lips met and parted, melting into one sensuous hot pot as steaming thick bittersweetness flowed between our tongues. I felt my heart race in rhythm with hers as our tongues dove and curled around each other in a sea of our stallion’s warmth. I milked her tongue and suckled on her lips for every drop of the gift she had so painstakingly gathered for me.

I moaned in protest as she finally broke the kiss, leaving me with nothing but a thin strand of seed trailing from my lips to hers. She let the strand of seed trail further and further as she crawled down towards my….wait, where are you….?! Cheerilee, Fleet Foot, why are you two spreading my legs open?! Why’s Big Mac watching?! Where’s Starlight going?! Wait, Starlight, where are you kissing?! No, stop drooling horse cum into my taco! No, don’t push your muzzle into it either...no! NO! Don’t open your muzzle eitheeeeeeeeeeeiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii……...