Cupcakes (Choose Ending!)

by xMistyStarx

Rating: teen
Tags: Other, Rainbow Dash, Pinkie Pie, Random, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
Length: 2479

How would Cupcakes end for you?

If you could choose how the end of the worst things to ever to happen to you, how would it end? You must choose not by fate, but actions.

Published 2016-03-31 13:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-12-29 02:13:22 UTC

Insult Her

"Okay Dashie, time to wing it now!" Pinkie says smiling evilly. Rainbow grunts and tries freeing herself.
"You little foal....." Rainbow mutters. A look of anger crosses Pinkie's face.

"Excuse ME?! How dare you...." Pinkie growls, her mane flattening more. She smiles again then flicks on a light on the corner of the room.
"Well, Dashie, since you're acting like helpless filly, why don't I treat you like one?" Pinkie says, breaking the blade in half. Rainbow smiles, thinking she gave up hurting her. She presses a green button and a buzzing noise comes behind Rainbow Dash. It's an automatic chainsaw.

"Rainbow, you never should have been mean... You want to know why you're here?" Pinkie asks, staring Rainbow down as the machine gets closer. Rainbow nods.

"Well, too bad! You're gonna have to LIVE without knowing... not like live will last too long..." Pinkie says smirking.

N-NO!! Pinkie, I'M SORRY! PLEASE, JUST ONE LAST CHANCE! PLEASE! IT'S MY FAULT!" Rainbow begs, the machine inches away from her wing. Pinkie flips a switch, speeding it up, making Dash scream. It's all over.

"Pinkie..... I'm sorry....." Dash says before her head hangs down and her eyes close. Pinkie Pie's mane returns to normal, as she starts crying. She turns to see the machine getting her thighs, and Rainbow's cutie mark.

"Noo! Wait! Dash, it's not you! It's me! NO, DASH!" Pinkie screams, shutting off the machine, then releases Rainbow Dash. She hugs her tight and takes her to Twilight's place.

Rainbow has been lay in a garden for months, not under a grave, but around the Tree of Harmony. She wakes up almost a year later, roaming Ponyville, searching for her friends. After months, she finds them and Pinkie apologizes for what she's done. Though Rainbow now lives as a ghost, she's still there. With her friends.

Author's Note

Good job! Rainbow and Twilight both live for eternity now... O.O Well Rainbow's not alive, she's a ghost, but still visible, so... yeah. Go see how other fates turned out, and I must say insulting friends no matter what they do is a bad, terrible idea... :rainbowderp: :pinkiegasp:

Sentence: Rainbow the friendly Ghost

Empathy/ Sympathy

Rainbow shakes wildly and her fur sways with it. Pinkie laughs and takes up a remote with several buttons on it.
"Hmm... what should I try first... something fun. What do you think Dashie? The auto chainsaw or the Bone Crusher?" Pinkie asks as Rainbow's eyes roll back. Pinkie knocks her in the head and she wakes up again.

"Dashie, aren't you having any fun?" Pinkie asks, frowning. Rainbow Dash just sighs.

"Pinkie, what's gotten you so upset? Why are you being like this?" Rainbow asks calmly. Pinkie, drops the remote, her skin turning cold and her face white then purple, then ed, then pink again. Tears fill her eyes.

"B-Because... y-you don't like m-my *hic* parties any-anymore. M-my special talent is doing s-so and I think that if I don't plan parties a-and make you happy, th-then I should find another way to do it." Pinkie says, lowering her head. She picks up the remote again, trying to decide which to lay on Rainbow.

"I know how you feel..." Rainbow mutters sadly under her breath. Pinkie's ears jolt upright as she has a shocked look on her face.

"What do you mean? You're always happy! Not the earth-pony who's useless and can't even put a smile on her own friend's face and was adopted by two owners of a cake bakery..." Pinkie states. Rainbow gasps, realizing what Pinkie said was true.

"Well, same happened to me with you're parents, Pinkie. They told me to leave cause I was different than other ponies in my family. They thought something was wrong with a foal who naturally has oversized wings and a rainbow mane and tail." Rainbow said, sighing. It was Pinkie Pie's turn to gasp. She didn't know that she had so much in common with the pony she was trying to torcher.

Rainbow sighs.
"Well, do whatever you want with me. Like I said, nopony cares what happens. Do ANYTHING you want..... Pinkamena." Pinkie was shocked by her respect and tears well in her eyes again.

"R-really?"

"Really."

"I-I can do anything with you?"

"Yep." Rainbow says, knowing that it was the end. Pinkie then rips her out of the ropes in a tight ug then shocks Rainbow Dash with the next words:
"Ohhhhhh! I will love you and hug you and name you DASHIE HEEHEE! MY OWN FRIEND!" Pinkie squeals. Rainbow doesn't care. She's just glad to be alive.

Author's Note

Wow.... empathy/ sympathy goes a Loooooooooooooooooooooooooooong way! Rainbow ends up being Pinkie's pet for the next two weeks, and the Mane Six have a special picnic to celebrate it! Great ending, though.. I don't think Rainbow was too happy about eating doggy treats for lunch, two weeks strait... Ending Emoji: :rainbowhuh: :pinkiehappy:

Sentence: Rainbow Dog

Honesty

Honesty

Rainbow Dash shakes her head to herself and stares at the bags on the other side of the room. One cutie mark cut off, one wing bruised and damaged and her hindlegs in great pain, and blood barely pumping there. Rainbow Dash is covered in sweat and her hooves numb from being tied for Who-knows-how-long, and the buzzing of machines burned her ears.

The cuts in her thighs burned as Pinkie spills in some rubbing alcohol, but added poison joke and some things that should never go into anypony's body system. Pinkie taps her chin with her pink hoof. She then smiles and sprints to a table on the far corner of the room, next to Rainbow's saddle bags.

"Pinkie, I have to tell you the truth. Why.... I was so mean to you lately..." Rainbow says quietly. Luckily, pony ears pick up sound easily, which made Pinkie turn, and walk over, saddle bags in her hoof. Pinkie glares and chuckles a bit. She tosses the bags aside, then shrugs.

"Eh, what have I got to loose? Alright, spill." Pinkie commands, leaning against a wheeled table with a cloth covering up her 'tools'. Rainbow stares at it and curses it in her mind. She then nods to Pinkie, knowing she's only got one shot at this.

"Well, last Tuesday, Twilight, Fluttershy, Rarity, AJ and I were takin' a walk to the park to play soccer, while Fluttershy and Rarity had a picnic. Apple missed the ball and Twi tried catching it, but slipped her hooves, then bounced off my head, smashing Fluttershy's honey sandwich. It splashed on Rarity who screamed, then you came. You instantly cleaned honey off Rarity, replaced the food and even brought cake for them, you helped Apple and Twi back on their hooves, then came to me with your bright smile and healed my sprained hoof. You even brought me an ice pack then skipped merrily back home. Twilight and I decided to treat you to something special since you've always been so nice to everypony, so I went on planning one." Rainbow said, looking down. Pinkie tapped her chin again, then waited.

"For several days I had ignored you, hung up on you on the phone, embarrassed you, teased you, and even yelled at you. It hurt me the day I ran away from you, seeing you run off crying like that. I didn't sleep that night, but worked and worked on the party, and didn't sleep at all. Twilight came to my place at midnight with Rarity, and we made invitations all night. At five, we slept then woke early at eight to deliver the invitations to everypony. I went flying around Ponyville and Sweet Apple Acres for hours and I ran into you. You kept trying to find out what I was doing but..... you didn't listen..." Rainbow finished. She motioned for Pinkie to open the saddle bag, and to her surprise, a stack of neatly organised cards were there, in a neat fashion, pink decorated all over them. It read:

AWESOME PARTY FOR AWESOME PONY!!!

EVERYPONY COME IF YOU LOVE PINKIE, BEST PARTY

PONY AROUND!!! TOMORROW! ALL WELCOME!

Pinkie released Rainbow, crying hard, but every tear was tears of joy, and the next day, Pinkie never could have been happier!

Author's Note

Congraaaaaaadulations for getting the best ending! :D There would have been more, but meh. Go and check out the other ones!

Ending Emoji: :pinkiehappy: :rainbowwild:

Sentence: Friends 4 Ever *Squee*

Go with the Flow

Pinkie stared Rainbow down like a sharp arrow, holding the longest knife in two hooves. Rainbow smiled idiotically. Pinkie wears a confused face.
"You... you like it?" Pinkie asks, hopes high. Rainbow nods.

"If it makes my friend happy, I''l be happy!" Rainbow says, shrugging. Well, trying to shrug because she's in ropes so..... yeah. Pinkie smiles, her mane poofing up instantly.
"Oooh goody! So, what do you want to do?" Pinkie asks, smiling. Rainbow thinks carefully.

"Give me a list," Rainbow says. Pinkie introduces her to a line of buttons on the wall near her.
"This one crushes your bones, this one yanks off your wings, this one.... well, this one... is a screwdriver, but larger! I think it's really really FUN!" Pinkie says, smiling wider and laughing. Rainbow thinks again, then points to the blue button.
"Bones? Alrighty then!" Pinkie presses the button, taking a last look at Rainbow Dash. She frowns a bit as the pistons power up. A light flashed to indicate it was ready, then a loud crushing sound was heard.
Rainbow, still awake, looks at Pinkie, whose jaw is dropped.

"You're still...... Oh! that was the wrong button! The TRASH crusher! My bad! Hmm... I got a better idea, Dash, and let's just say I'm willing to spare you... as my personal SLAVE!" Pinkie states, taking all the things in the trash.
"BAH! Who's idea was killing ponies, anyway? I could have slaves working for me making yummy CUPCAKES! Meat free and full of sugar! OOOH! Dash, you want to know your torcher?" Pinkie asks, smiling.

"Umm no-" Rainbow says before being cut off. (No pun intended)

"YE SHALL BE FORCE FED SUGAR FOR DINER EVERY.MONDAY.NIGHT!!! Mwahahahahaha!!!! Join forces with me, slave!" Pinkie calls, releasing Dash. Then, the whole basement filled with evil laughter.

Author's Note

Cool, you joined forces to make ponies unhealthy servants...... Umm, okay... :rainbowhuh:

Ending Emoji: :pinkiecrazy: :rainbowlaugh:

Sentence: Gimme Sugar

Make A Joke

Note: please reread, this was very heavily edited!

Pinkie watched as Rainbow Dash screamed in pure terror. One wing was mercilessly sliced off, the other bruised and scarred. Her fur was wet and bloodstained, and the maniac was soon headed for her cutie mark. Dash looks at Pinkie, watching her weapon near her limbs. She has a chainsaw in her hooves, smiling evilly, then she lifts it up, bringing it down, but stops as she hears Rainbow scream.
"WAIT!!!" she yells. Pinkie frowns and throws the chainsaw down.

"Aww, Dashie, it was just getting fun! So.... you finally some kind of rebuttal now, huh?" Pinkie smiles and folds her hooves.
"Well? Go on..." She says, tapping her hoof on the chainsaw. Rainbow looks up to Pinkie then sighs.

"Please don't do this, Pinkie please! Im begging you, have you even heard the stallion who was torchered, but got his whole left side of his body cut off?" Rainbow said. Pinkie tilted her head, wondering if she was being literal.
"Uh, no? Must be painful! Is he Okay?" Pinkie asked, with almost too much concern.

"Oh, he's all RIGHT now!" Rainbow joked, seeing a smile crack on the edge of Pinkie's lips, but quickly faded.
Rainbow held back hysterical laughter, causing her face to turn purple.

"Oh! Remember the Lunar Eclipse yesterday? Looks like two sisters didn't get along very well!" Rainbow laughed. The two giggled for several moments until Pinkie turned to get a blade and knife. Her mane was still in it's flat state the whole time, though. Rainbow didn't even care what Pinkie would do to her. She was just glad she had the last laugh.... with her friend.

Pinkie Pie turned, knife and blade in hoof, then came towards the pegasus, eyes shut tight, ready for the worst. She lifted up the knife and blade, Rainbow hugging her tight with one free hoof, still smiling. Pinkie sent down the knife and blade, slicing...
"H-huh?" Rainbow stuttered.

Rainbow opened her eyes, seeing her hindegs free, as Pinkie sliced open the last ropes, gravity sending her down to the floor. Rainbow looked up.
"Huh?" She repeated, dumbfounded. Pinkie gasped Rainbow howled in pain, blood still leaving the scars and gashes in her body. She was a monster....
She bent down to hug Rainbow Dash and carefully lifted her onto her back.
"I... Couldn't loose a friend who constantly brings me joy, now, could I?" She whispered, as Rainbow slightly smiled.

Author's Note

Well done! Your fate wasn't it, no! It was the choice you made! No go read other chapters to see how other fates could have played! :rainbowlaugh: :pinkiesad2:

Sentence: A Good Laugh

Being Romantic

Pinkie Pie grinned evilly, hooves bloodstained from the earlier victims. Rainbow looks at her with pleasure, breathing slowly and silently. "Alright, Dashie! Get ready to-" "You're... Pretty..." Rainbow mutters as the earthpony flinches. "You really, really are." "Ehm, what?" She says, staring with a frown. "You're beautiful." Rainbow says as Pinkie begins to break out into laughter.

"AHAHAH! Dashie, is that how you think you'll get out of this? You- wait. Did you say.... I-I'm... Beautiful?" Pinkie asks, eyes filled with bloody tears. Rainbow Dash looks at Pinkie Pie with both fear and admiration. "I know why you are doing this, and it is not the way... I know you just want to be understood... Because I love you and I understand you.

She runs over to the tied up pegasus on the iron board, hugging her, crying loudly. "Yes, you ARE beautiful. Every pony knows it." Rainbow says as years drip onto the gash Pinkie cut in her left flank. Rainbow screams in great pain as Pinkie begins to stop crying. Rainbow coughs heavily as her flank starts to burn wildly. Tears well up in her eyes, the horrible pain beginning to overwhelm her.

"I-I'm so so sorry....Don't die Dashie, I'm so sorry!" Pinkie whispers, grasping onto the pegasus. She taks Rainbow Dash's cutie mark that she had cut off, and sews her mark back on. "Let's take you to the hospital, Dashie," Pinkie says, the pegasus resting on her back as the two ran out the basement.

Author's Note

Congratulations if you chose this first! Not the best ending for you, but atleast you made it out alive, just some major injuries!

Ending emoji: :pinkiesad2: :rainbowderp:

Sentence: Love and War