Grilled

by MLPMacyStudios

Rating: mature
Tags: Sad, Horror, Dark
Length: 1305

Cheese sandwich has a secret

Cheese sandwich loves throwing parties for all the ponies in equestria. He has just left ponyville and needs to make food for his next party. He has a secret way of doing it though

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2016-04-02 21:01:32 UTC

Chapter 2

Everything was fuzzy. Black. Cold.

Pinkie began to panic. Where was she? What was she doing? Why was she here?

"Hi there pinkie pie!"

That familiar yet joyful voice said again.

"Ugh!"

Cheese Sandwich slapped pinkie pie round her cold face.

It suddenly became clear. It was Cheese.

"Cheese?!" She said.

“Finally!" He said "You really at least try to wake up sooner. You don't know how ANNOYING it is waiting for ages to finally get started!"

"S-started? Started on what?" Pinkie said, shaking.

"Well Miss Pie, I use some very particular ingredients for my sandwiches you see. Very particular. So, the right ingredients are in ponies!

"H-HUH?" Pinkie said.

"Now, let me show you something..."

Pinkies eyes widened.

It was Rainbow Dash. Dead. Grilled. Gone. Dry blood was covering the dead Pegasus as her lungs were half ripped open. Bones were sticking out of her skin whilst her feathers were ripped of her wings and stuffed down her throat.  Calved in a bare patch of her skin was "Rainbow Sandwiches"

Pinkie threw up. What had become of her best friend?

"She didn't take too long to deal with, it was her present. Last one she had gotten!"

Cheese began to laught whilst Pinkie began to cry.

Her friend was Dead and gone. Why? How? When?

Cheese stopped laughing and turned to the Pink mare.

Before he could say anything, Pinkie tried to wrestle Cheese to the ground but ending up getting caught in a bear trap that Cheese had prepared.

She felt the spikes gauge into her skin as blood began to poor out of it.

"Ahhh!" Pinkie screamed

Cheese made a slight giggle as he walked over to her.

"Now, it's time to begin making some sandwiches" he said.

Chapter 3

Cheese walked over to a light switch and pulled it down.

"Sugar cube corner?" Said Pinkie, still in shock and squinting her eyes.

"Yup!" Cheese said!

"H-ha Mr and Mrs Cake and the babies will hear you

"Well that is where your wrong! I knocked them out so they'll be out for at least 5 hours. Giving us enough time to make some sandwiches!

Pinkie Gulped

"But...why?" She said

"Sandwiches! He said, happily. You know, we should really begin,Pinkie"

With that,the yellow Colt walked up the few steps from the basement to the shop. He looked through each cupboard, trying not to make too much sound, and took out a knife.

Back in the basement, pinkie was strapped to a table, still crying and watching her dead best friend.

"I hope this is all a dream. If only I didn't let you go"

She cried even more. Warm tears were dripping down her face.

Loud hoof steps came closer. Cheese was coming.

"Now Pinkie, I only had limited tools to do this." said Cheese.

Pinkie looked down

Cheese Sandwich walked closer to Pinkie Pie, smiled, and then shoved the knife strait through her stomach.

"Gahhh" Pinkie screamed

Blood oozed out of the pink pony and her bones were acheing. Pinkie started heavy breathing, panicking, this was happening

"Hmm..." Cheese whispered

He got knife circled it around Pinkie Pies bloody stomach, creating a whole.

"Ahhhh!" Screamed Pinkie

"Time to see if this does taste like candy floss!" Cheese said.

He ripped out a portion of Pinkies neon pink mane, swirled it around the open wound (covering it with blood) and popped it in his mouth.

Pinkie threw up at the sight of this.

"Mmm tasty! You know, Rainbow Dash's mane tasted a lot less nicer than yours. Guess that's one thing you can be proud of!" Said Cheese Sandwich

Pinkies mane deflated and her colours faded

"Please let me go" Pinkie whispered

"Sorry to say this Pinkie but I need to make some sandwiches for my next party. We don't have much time!" Cheese said

He got his hoof and began pulling out pinkies insides. He ripped out one of her kidneys and punched her lungs, causing her to throw up blood.

"I won't give in!" Pinkie said. I won't let Rainbow die in vain!" Pinkie spat at Cheese sandwich

Cheese rolled his eyes and giggled

He walked over to a blender he had boughtfrom the kitchen.

Cheese grabbed it and carefully pressed it on Pinkie pie's left hoof.

The switch lifted

"Ahhhhhhhhh!!!!" Pinkie screamed as the blenders flicked of bits of her skin and blood poured all over the room.

After about 10 minutes of blending, the blender had managed to demolish her left hoof.

Cheese ran to the pieces of skin and put them in a bowl

By now, Pinkie Pies body was missing it's stomach skin and had a ripped apart hoof

What was to come next?

Chapter 4

"Well Pinkie, it's nearly time to meet your fate",said Cheese Sandwich.

Pinkie was shattered. She didn't care anymore. There was nothing's left to loose. Why? She thought. Was he always this way? Pinkie pie was past caring now.

Cheese walked over to the few tools he had left and picked out a peeler.

"Hey Pinkie",he said

Pinkie looked up.

Before she could say anything, the peeler dug into her skin and ripped of skin of her legs. Then her right arm.

"Ahhhhhhh! Pinkie screamed. Nooooo!"

She began to cry again

Cheese sandwich began pulling out all of her organs, one by one. Her kidney. Liver. Lungs.

Then her eyes widened as Cheese crouched down at her. Reaching. Reaching for her heart.

And then. It stopped. She was gone.

Cheese grabbed a large knife and chopped her in half. "Ah, I wish I could have had more fun with you Pinkie, but it's sad we had a time limit." Cheese said, evilly.

He lifted both parts of her up lay her on a worktop. Then he cut her up her insides into hundreds of little pieces, blood squirting on his face as he did so. Then, he put all the pieces into a large bowl and mixed normal bread ingredients into the bowl as well and mixed them up. After that he walked up the few steps and baked it.

After hours of baking, finally he had his grilled, baked bread for his sandwiches. One with a slight touch of rainbow and the other with a shade of pink.

Chapter 1

It was a cold, dark evening. Cheese had just finished his first party in ponyville. “Looks like I'll be needing some more ingredients,boneless. " He said with a evil like smirk. The boneless to dropped of his back and onto the muddy floor. “Who do you think will make the most delicious sandwich mixture,boneless?" He said. The rubber chicken made a squeak. Cheese laughed with a grin on his face. “Your right boneless" said cheese. And with that,he turned around and ran back on his way to ponyville. Leaving his black cloak and sombrero behind.

Ponyville, sugar cube corner.

“Ah, that cheese sandwich sure was something, wasn't he?" said rainbow dash, embracing the last few hours of her birthaversary.

“He sure was!" Twilight exclaimed.

"Ah'm just glad he managed to make up with Pinkie I'm time for Rainbows party." said applejack

“Yeah! Me too!" Said pinkie.

About an hour later, Pinkie sent all her friends home and told them to meet her back at here at 11 tomorrow morning. They agreed, and left the sweet shop as happy as could be. Unaware of what was about to come to pinkie.

"Whelp boneless, welcome to the pie family!" Pinkie said. I'm glad Cheese gave you to-"

A knock at the door.

"Who could that be?" Pinkie said.

Pinkie walked over to the sugary door,trembling slightly. She reached out with her candy floss coloured hoof, turned the knob on the door and pushed it out.

She screamed.

A familiar voice whispered: boo!

Everything turned as black as night.