Pretty Dark Mysteries

by DDRarity

Rating: everyone
Tags: Drama, Dark, Romance, Equestria Girls, Mystery, Adventure
Length: 2744

Sunset Shimmer gets Cyber-Threats with the disappearance of Twilight Sparkle.

Twilight Sparkle disappears days after her visit to the Human World. Is she alive? Is she dead? No one knows. What happens when Sunset is the one accused of what happened to Twilight?

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2016-04-08 18:06:15 UTC

Chapter 2 - She Is Back!

Opening her eyes slowly...Sunset finally woke up. She looked at the clock and started to panic. She was late.

"Oh no! Mr.Trenderhoof is really gonna be mad at me!"

She went down, quickly ate her chocolate cereal and rushed out. she ran as fast as she could. She was breathing heavily. After 5 minutes of terrible running she finally arrived. She went inside the School and went to her Class, she quietly opened the door and saw Mr.Trenderhoof writing on the board. This was her chance. She was sneaking to her desk and then...

"I could still see you Mrs.Shimmer" said the teacher.

Sunset flinched and groaned.

"Sorry for-"

"Being late. Yeah I know. And if you come late one more time then your getting Detention dear" said Mr.Trenderhoof

For Celestia's Sake! Detention for being late? Glad I have only tomorrow and it's Holidays.

Class finished and Sunset quietly walked to the Cafeteria. She was walking towards her friend's Table.

"Hi Girls. How is it goi-" she was cut by a voice that almost made her jump

"Hello Sunset!"

She was sitting between Rarity and Applejack...It was her...It was...Twilight...Twilight Sparkle...

"T...Twilight?" stared Sunset

"She is gonna stay in my house for a while!"

"Thanks again Pinkie" smiled Twilight

"But...How!? I thought the portal opened every 30 Moons?" asked Sunset confusingly

"That's true but...I've been doing a research for a while and I've built my own portal to this world. Meaning that i could come and go whenever I want. Spike went to Canterlot with Rarity...Uh...My World's Rarity, and they are not gonna come back for a while. It was a little lonely at the Castle so I decided to come here" explained Twilight

"Say Twilight, is your World's Rarity as fabulous as I am?" asked Rarity

"Well...It's kind of hard to explain"

"Is your World's Rainbow Dash awesome as I am?" gloated Rainbow

"Imagine if we all met our Pony Selves!" said Pinkie

"That would be...Scary" said Fluttershy

"Though, i do have a question. You said we all have Pony identities in your World" said A.J

"That's right" replied Twilight

"You and Sunset are from the Equestria. Do you two have Identities from this World?" continued A.J

"Yes" answered Twilight

"I'm glad i didn't run into this World's Sunset. It's kind of creepy" said Sunset

The Girls talked a while about different topics. Even though Sunset felt a little strange being with Twilight. Honestly, Sunset dislikes her a bit. If she didn't interrupt...She would have ruled the School already. Or the whole World. But now Sunset doesn't want any of this. She is just glad that she has friends.

Chapter 3 - Rumors

Today surprisingly, Sunset looked forward to School. Of course she doesn't mean she is looking forward her 2 hour boring Chemistry class. But it's the last day of School for a while! She woke up really early, took a hot shower and had an amazing breakfast and went to School. Today wasn't so bad. At least today the Students cared much more about ending the School than staring at her like usual. Now she had Chemistry class and she was begging for her life that it would end really soon. Sunset hated Chemistry. Not because it's hard. In fact, Sunset is actually really good in Chemistry. It was because it's just boring. As soon as she heard the bell, she screamed to the ceilings.

"YES FINALLY!" she yelled

Then she realized the whole class was looking at her. Some were even laughing at her. Sunset blushed, packed her things quickly and was running her way to the Cafeteria. That's until someone stopped her.

"Hey Sunset" said Twilight

Sunset just wanted to sigh.

"H-Hey Twilight. What's up?"

"I'm good. Going to the Cafeteria?"

"Yeah"

"Oh me too. Let's walk together" Twilight suggested

There was an awkward silence between them as they were walking. Sunset didn't wanna say anything anyways but Twilight is never just quiet is she? Before she thought more about the situation, Twilight asked something.

"Say Sunset...Do you have my Number?"

"Your Phone Number?"

"Yeah"

"Since when do you have a phone?"

Sunset was confused. Why does she need a phone anyway?

"Pinkie gave me her old Phone a long time ago. She said that I need it so I could text her. But it didn't work while i was in Equestria"

"Oh..."

"So..." continued Twilight

"Um...?" said Sunset confusingly

"N-nevermind! Oh look we're in the Cafeteria. Let's go find the others *nervous chuckle*"

That was weird...Oh well, typical Twilight Sparkle.

"Hi Sunset, Hello Twi" smiled Pinkie

"Hi Girls" waved Twilight and sat

"Hello" said Sunset while sitting near Twilight

"Twilight, Sunset! I'm glad you got here early. I was just about to talk about the new School Rumor! You will never believe this!" laughed Dash

"Rumor?" asked Sunset

"Yes! Mr.Trenderhoof hooked up with one of his Students! That's what Lyra told me. What do you guys think?" said Dash

Sunset noticed Rarity was flinching...Weird? Wow the word weird could define the whole day.

"It's just a Rumor Dash. Plus, i don't think Mr.Trenderhoof likes his Students that way because-" Applejack was talking until she got cut by Rarity.

"I need to go to the Bathroom. If you would all excuse me..." said Rarity in a Dark Tone.

Ok...That was...Again...That Word...That was weird.

"What in the hay is wrong with that Girl? She've been actin' weird since yesterday." said Applejack

Just before they were about to talk about Rarity, the Bell ringed. It was time for Class. Sunset had Math and she was on her way going to her Class but she stopped. She saw the Bathroom and went in. She looked around and it was empty. Sunset thought Rarity was gone but as soon as she was about to leave, she heard sobbing. She closed the Door slowly behind her.

"Rarity? Is that you?"

The crying stopped...

"It's me...Sunset...I'm alone...Look if you don't wanna come out that's fi-"

She saw one of the Bathroom Doors opening. Rarity came out with her ruined Make-Up.

"Rarity, what's wrong?"

"Oh Sunset! *Sniff* you wouldn't understand!" cried Rarity

"I probably won't. But I will try to. Just tell me what's going on."

"Promise you won't tell the others?"

"Promise" Sunset tried to smile

"Sunset...That Rumor...It's true"

"Wait, how do you know...?" asked Sunset

"Because...Because...BECAUSE I was the one he hooked up with Sunset! It was me! ME!" cried Rarity while hiding her Face

"Rarity? Oh my God! What the fu-"

She remembered Rarity hates cursing and that's probably gonna make it worse...(and because there might be children reading this fanfic ;))

"Ok, just...How did it happen? Why did it happen? When did it happen?" asked Sunset

"I...*Sniff*...I'm in love with him Sunset! Yesterday i told him that i liked him but I told him it wasn't possible to be together since he is my teacher but he said he will keep it a Secret and he kissed me! *Sniff* and then we did it! With protection of course! But...Now I just feel so ashamed. If these Rumors keep going or, If anybody found out about us, he will lose his Job and...and it will be like I basically ruined his Life!" explained Rarity

"Rarity...I'm so sorry. But I'll promise you i will never tell anyone. This is serious and if anybody found out, they will get him arrested. Gosh Rarity!Student/Teacher Relationship's are Illegal!...But since you love him, I can't so anything about it. But I will keep it a secret and i will try to clear that Rumor" said Sunset

"Sunset...Thank you so so much!" said Rarity while hugging Sunset

"Glad i could help" Sunset hugged back

Once again, Sunset wanted to describe this day in one Word...Weird

Chapter 4 - The Night

Just as Sunset walked out of School, she saw 6 Girls standing near the Statue. Pinkie noticed her and screamed

"Sunset over here! We've been waiting on you!"

It made Sunset happy that they waited on her. She gave them a smile and walked to Pinkie's House. When they arrived, Pinkie knocked on the Door. And then a grey skinned Girl came out.

"Hi Maud! We're having a Sleepover so I brought my Friends!"

"Hi Girls. Your all welcome here but don't mess too much. Oh and be careful around Boulder" she showed her Rock

"He is in a bad mood today" said Maud in a dead pan.

The Girls walked in and just as Sunset tried to walk in the Door, Maud stopped her.

"Where do you think your going?"

"...U-Um..."

"Pinkie, why did you invite Sunset Shimmer to our House?"

"Maud...Don't worry she is changed. I promise you nothing will happen" said Pinkie Pie in a strange tone

"...If you try to hurt my sister, I'll break you" warned Maud

Nodded Sunset. Maud cleared the way for Sunset to come inside while giving her a dead pan look. Pinkie gave Sunset a smile and took her upstairs to her Room. Pinkie's room was all coated in pink. On the corner there was a table full of snacks and drinks. The Girls were entertaining themselves. A.J and R.D were playing a fighting video game, Rarity was gossiping with Fluttershy and Twilight was sitting on the Bed alone writing something in a Book.

"Hey Twilight. What are you doing?" asked Sunset

"Just writing something in my Diary." said Twilight

"You have a Diary?"

"Yeah. There are memories and secrets in there. When I grow up, it would be nice to look back at what I've written." smiled Twilight

"That's nice" Sunset smiled back

"Ok Girls! Gather up! Let's play Truth or Dare!" said Pinkie

"I haven't played that in a while" said Fluttershy

The Girls were excited and they were now sitting in a circle. Pinkie put an empty bottle in the Middle and span it. It landed on Applejack.

"Truth or Dare?" asked Pinkie

"It would be boring if i start the game with a Truth so...Dare" said A.J

"Hmm...*Smirk*...I dare you...To let Rarity give you a Make Over!" giggled Pinkie

"Oh, Horseapples..." sighed Applejack

Rarity was excited and pulled out a huge Make-Up Kit out of nowhere and started to put things on Applejack's Face...

"And...Done!" Rarity gave her a Mirror

Scared to react, A.J opened her eyes slowly and she actually liked it

"Woah. Not bad. I actually look prettier than a fresh Apple!" smiled Applejack

"Booooring. I thought you would make her look like Trash not a Princess"

They all took a turn and played over an Hour. They decided to do one more spin to end the Game.

"Ok last spin" Rainbow Dash span the bottle, it landed on Twilight.

"Twi, T or D?"

"Truth" replied Twilight

"Truth...Tell us a Secret!" said R.D

Everyone ooed

"Um...*Takes a deep Breath"...Girls, I wanted to tell you this for a long time. Someone has been threatening me...Actually Cyber-Threatening me" said Twilight in a sad tone

Most of them gasped and were worried. Sunset was shocked. Why would anybody do this? Twilight never did anything bad...

"Oh my gosh Twi. I'm so sorry" Pinkie hugs Twilight

"Who is it!? I swear I'm gonna beat them up!" yelled R.D

"You should tell this to the Police like now!" said Fluttershy

"Uh...I mean it ended now! That was a long time ago it's okay now!" Twilight said nervously

"Oh thank god. You almost gave me a heart attack Darling" said Rarity

"If this ever happened to you again then tell us" encouraged A.J

"Yeah" agreed Pinkie

"T-Thanks everyone..." smiled Twilight

"Ok now it's...SNACK TIME!!!"

Pinkie threw a huge pile of snacks in the middle and gave everyone a drink. All of them started to sip on their drinks except Sunset. She was eating a Chocolate Bar.

"I need to go to the Bathroom. I'll be right back" said Twilight

And with that, Twilight went and the others enjoyed their food.

"Wow these drinks are really good" said Fluttershy

"I agree. Now all I need is a good sleep" yawned Rarity

"Yeah. I'm gonna hit the sack gals. G'night!" Applejack went inside her sleeping bag

"On come ooooooon your all such lazy..." before Pinkie could continue, she fell asleep.

Everyone were now sleeping. Sunset smiled and went to turn off the Lights...

2 Hours Later...

Fluttershy opened her eyes slowly and stretched herself. She checked her phone and it was 12 o'clock midnight. She looked around and saw all of them, enjoying their sleep...But Sunset and Twilight were missing. She was confused. Where could they have went? She tried to wake Rainbow slowly.

"Uhh...What is it Flutters?" asked Rainbow

"Rainbow Dash! Sunset and Twilight are missing!"

"W-What?" she woke and looked in Twilight and Sunset's Sleeping Bags and gasped "GIRLS WAKE UP!" she screamed.

Everyone jumped from their Beds.

"What is it Rainbow dash!? Can't you see that I'm having my Beauty Sleep!?" yelled Rarity

"What's going on?" asked A.J

"Sunset and Twilight...They're not here!" screamed Fluttershy

Suddenly, they head the door open. It was too dark to see who was it.

"Twi? Is that you?" Pinkie asked the Dark figure

The figure opened the Lights and it turned out to be Sunset.

"Sunset? Why were you out? Where is Twilight?" asked Applejack

"I...I don't know...I think I heard her scream!" trembled Sunset...

Prologue

Hurt. Destroyed. Ashamed...These 3 Words that were describing Sunset Shimmer at the moment...Eyes looking at her...People ashamed of her...

**"I...I'm sorry...I'm so sorry. I didn't know there was another way"* cried Sunset while looking at the dissapointed faces above her.*

**"The Magic of Friendship doesn't just exist in Equestria, it's everywhere! You can seek it out...Or you can forever be alone. The choice is yours"* explained Twilight.*

**"But...But all I've ever done here since being here is drive everyone apart...I don't know the first thing about Friendship"* cried Sunset.*

She suddenly feels a hand reaching out to her and grabbing her up to standing. Twilight pointed at her friends.

**"I bet they can teach you"* smiled Twilight...*

Chapter 1 - Learning Around Friendship

3 Months Later...

It's a Thursday morning...Walking in the Hallways everyday with weird looks people giving you is something Sunset Shimmer got used to in her daily life. After all, she tried to destroy the whole school and was a bully. Some people forgave her...Well 6 Girls did...She kept looking down while walking, hoping she would reach the Cafeteria faster...And she did...She went to pick up some food and then looked around, figuring out where to sit...

"Sunset Shimmer! Over here!"

That voice...A certain Pink Girl was calling her from a table...She fake smiled and went to sit. These girls was all she had right now and she was really grateful...

"So Sunset! How is it going Dear?" asked Rarity

"I'm fine" answered Sunset

"Sugarcube, you don't look fine at all. Mind telling us what's wrong?" Asked A.J

"Well...It's just...The Usual. People staring at me all the time with looks on their faces...I mean, it's something I'm used to but that doesn't mean I'm fine with it"

"Don't worry silly! They will be all over it soon"

"But...It's been already 3 months, Pinkie"

"Give it more time. Plus, you've got us. You don't need to worry about the others" said R.D

"Yeah. And i really appreciate it...Thank you all so much...But can I ask you a question? Will you all answer me honestly?"

Sunset saw the nodding faces so she immediately asked...

"Are you guys really are trying to be my friends or...Or is it just because Twilight said so?..."

The Table was silent. The Girls were looking at each other and Sunset was waiting for an answer. Dash gave Applejack a nudge.

"Well...Honestly Sugarcube...At first it was just because Twilight said so...

Sunset felt a little hurt inside at that moment...

"But now we really are having fun with you" explained Applejack

"You really mean it?" she asked

Everyone smiled and nodded in agreement

"Oh almost forgot! We're having a sleepover on Friday since it's gonna be the last day for a while" said Pinkie

"Last day?" asked Sunset

"We have 6 week Holidays silly!"

"Oh! I forgot! Thanks for reminding me though"

"So are you coming to the Sleepover?" asked Fluttershy

"Uh...Sure!" smiled Sunset

The Bell ringed and everyone had to attend classes. Sunset and Fluttershy had now Algebra with Mr.Discord. They all said goodbye to each other and went to class