Night Mares 4.5

“Dear Princess Celestia,
Tonight, I learned a valuable lesson about the benefits of friendship. All ponies have secrets, and it's often OK to keep them to yourself.”

The sound of quill scratching on parchment ceased suddenly, interrupted by a loud, stuttering moan of pleasure. Twilight Sparkle looked up to see Sunset Shimmer restrained from behind by Applejack. The orange earth pony's arms were hooked under the unicorn's armpits and her fingers were clasped together behind her neck. Although the fiery mare struggled valiantly, she could not break the farmpony's hold.

Down below, Rainbow Dash held the trapped unicorn by her ankles, lifting her legs up and keeping them spread wide, while her tongue attacked the exposed flesh between them. Seed and saliva dripped sloppily from Sunset's sex, and she let out another moan as the blue pegasus's tongue darted against her slit.

Twilight smirked as she remembered watching each of the Element-bearers have their turn with Sunset after she was done. They finally untied the unicorn at the end of the sexual marathon, leaving her a dripping, shuddering mess. As Twilight started penning a letter to the Solar Princess, she thought perhaps they were finished with the unicorn, but grinned as she realized she was mistaken: Her friends had plenty more in store.

Relenting to Rainbow's assault, Sunset squeezed her eyes shut and threw her head back, groaning as she resigned herself to yet another climax. The athletic pegasus stopped short, however, leaving the confused unicorn panting, quivering, and more than a little frustrated.

“As much as your moans are music to my ears, it's really ruining my concentration,” Twilight said, grinning evilly. “Could you girls maybe quiet down a bit?”

Without a word, Applejack effortlessly hefted Sunset off her hooves, moving the hapless unicorn to the side of the couch while Rainbow Dash hurriedly scrambled out of the way. The blonde-maned cowpony then bent Sunset forward over the armrest, lining up her massive, magically conjured cock with the unicorn's soaked sex.

As the thick organ sank between her spread folds, Sunset would cry out again, but Rainbow Dash was quick—The unicorn blinked in surprise as she suddenly found her muzzle stuffed with the blue pegasus's throbbing pole, muffling her heavy, breathless moans.

“Much better,” the purple princess remarked casually as she returned to her scribbling.

“But sometimes, those secrets are just so wet and juicy that you can't help but share them with your friends! We spent the whole night opening up and letting each other in, and I found that it was a great way for all of us to really come together!”

Twilight's ears flicked, a devilish sneer stretching across her lips as she heard simultaneous groans from the three mares at the couch—one of which was muffled.

After the rough tonguing by Rainbow, Sunset's sex was more than ready to accept Applejack's thick, equine member. Satisfied that she was filled again after the earlier interruption, the unicorn quickly gave in to the pleasure of being spitroasted by two of her best friends.

The trio came in unison, the earth pony's trembling, twitching cock splattering the unicorn's squeezing, rippling walls with hot Apple seed while the pegasus pumped her rich cream down Sunset's eager, ravenous throat. Filled from both ends as the three shuddered in climax, Sunset's cries rose to a crescendo while excess cum seeped from her muzzle and her sex.

As their orgasms waned, AJ and Rainbow eventually withdrew from the exhausted Sunset. No longer supported by the two stiff organs impaling her, the unicorn collapsed like a rag doll, spilling onto the side of the couch, still bent over with her exposed nethers gaping slightly from the ordeal.

Sunset's eyes fluttered, and her chest heaved with each breath. Unconsciousness beckoned to her invitingly, and a pleasant, hazy afterglow covered her mind like a blanket, lulling her sore body toward sleep. She would've drifted off then, but her friends had other plans.

The unicorn suddenly stiffened, her ears flicking toward the sound of a gleeful giggle behind her. Sunset didn't have to guess at its source as soft fingertips caressed the outer lips of her sensitive sex. Her limbs unresponsive, she murmured a weak protest as Pinkie Pie gently but firmly rolled her onto her back.

Lying face-up with her legs draped over the armrest, Sunset suddenly found herself surrounded. Fluttershy was perched on the couch behind her, her upside-down face smiling serenely down at the sun-colored unicorn. Rarity was to her side, kneeling in front of the couch, her horn flaring a gentle blue as she prepared her magic. And Sunset didn't have to look to see where Pinkie Pie was, as the party pony's hot breath brushed against her slit.

Sunset whimpered as the trio set to work. The yellow-furred pegasus fondled her ears and bent forward to rain soft, gentle kisses along her muzzle and neck. The magical blue glow from the alabaster unicorn's horn spread across her breasts, cupping and squeezing them while precisely pinching and poking each hardened tit. Finally, the pink earth pony's fingers and tongue slowly circled and stroked her netherlips, never slipping between them, but instead flicking along the sensitive flesh teasingly.

The unicorn squirmed weakly at the continued affection on her tired body. It had been a long, weird night for her, and Sunset's addled mind could barely tell if she was dreaming. Or if this was a nightmare.

The trio's gentle but constant attention eventually worked: Sunset lashed her tongue along Fluttershy's as they shared a deep kiss, arched her back and pushed more of her chest into Rarity's enveloping aura, and bucked her hips against Pinkie Pie's fleeting touches. Lust won out over exhaustion, and the unicorn soon quivered with need. Her friends were only too happy to oblige.

“As the Princess of Friendship, I plan to someday share this experience with all of my friends—and that includes you, of course! I hope you consider joining us one of these nights. And Princess Luna can come, too! The more, the merrier.”

Twilight looked up toward the couch once more, and the edges of her lips pulled into a twisted smile at the sight before her. Pinkie Pie had Sunset Shimmer's legs propped on her shoulders as she rhythmically pistoned her cock in and out of the unicorn's slit, each thrust punctuated by a soft, wet squish. Fluttershy sat with the unicorn's head trapped between her knees, her magical member buried deep in Sunset's muzzle and muffling her cries.

Meanwhile, the yellow pegasus was making out with Rarity, who sat atop Sunset's stomach with her shaft nestled between the orange mare's breasts. The fashionista's hands were busily kneading those mounds against her hard, throbbing pole, and drips of precum were already dribbling from its tip and soaking into the fur of Sunset's neck. “The girl sure does love to accessorize,” Twilight mused as she watched the foursome.

Sunset's mind was overtaken with desire, her body operating on carnal instinct as she struggled to pleasure each of her friends. She wantonly squeezed and bucked her hips as Pinkie plowed her with her pulsing penis. She eagerly stroked her tongue along Fluttershy's shaft while teasing its tip, her enthusiasm soon rewarded as drips of pre leaked down her throat. And although Rarity was doing a fine enough job squeezing Sunset's breasts against her own cock, the sun-colored unicorn did her part by arching her back and pushing her mounds against the hard, throbbing flesh.

Applejack and Rainbow Dash soon joined the fray, completing the circle of sin. The blonde-maned earth pony stood in front of the couch, flashing a predatory grin at her sky-blue companion, who sat perched on the back of the couch while leering down at the preoccupied Sunset. Invigorated by the sounds of her restored vigor, the two mares were at full-mast once again, their throbbing tools still glistening slightly from their last session.

Sunset's wrists were seized, each hand guided to a different cock. Even though her vision was blocked by Fluttershy's pink, swaying tail and full, hanging balls, the unicorn quickly figured out whose shafts she now found herself squeezing. Pushing her multitasking skills to their limit, she nevertheless stroked and pumped each member dutifully, flicking her thumbs across each flared head and coaxing drops of precum out.

All at once, the pace of thrusting, squeezing, squirming bodies picked up, the six ponies' pleasure building toward a boiling point. Trapped at the center of it all, working five separate cocks with everything she had, Sunset was soon overwhelmed by the sensations. As the sounds of squishes and slaps grew to a crescendo, so too did Sunset's unbidden arousal.

The unicorn gave in, bucking her hips and squeezing her thighs as she lost all semblance of control, lust and instinct driving her movements. Swept up in the waves of orgasm, her beleaguered body quivered and twisted spasmodically, signaling her sweet surrender to ecstasy.

“Now that Sunset Shimmer is back, it might feel like a tight fit, but I don't mind accommodating so many guests. In fact, it would be my pleasure.

Ever your faithful student,
-Princess Twilight Sparkle”

The purple princess looked up just as Sunset's muffled cries turned into soft gurgles, her friends joining her in climax. She set her quill and parchment down to soak in the pure, unbridled lust emanating from the six mares. The devilish grin never left her face as she watched the sun-colored unicorn getting coated inside and out in warm, sticky cum.

Twilight waited patiently as the group slowly dispersed, then walked over to survey her latest toy. Ropes of semen lashed across Sunset's chest, forearms, and muzzle, while thick wads of it drooled lewdly from her lips and nethers. She was a complete mess, and the thought made the purple alicorn's grin wider as she leaned closer to the orange unicorn.

“Enjoy yourself, Sunny? Was it everything you ever wanted?”

Sunset Shimmer did not respond, pushed to the end of her endurance from the long night's ordeal. Lying limply on the defiled couch, she had finally slipped into blissful unconsciousness.

“Heh... You lasted much longer than any of the others.” A cruel smirk flashed across Twilight's lips. “With stamina like that, I can see why you were once Celestia's chosen.”

Suddenly reminded, the Princess strolled back over to the letter she had written, calmly rolling up the parchment and mentally noting to send it out after dawn broke. It wasn't like her recipient would read it right now, anyway.

Elsewhere...

Princess Luna furrowed her brow, trying to make sense of Sunset Shimmer's barely coherent message. Her sister's student flickered between Her domain and the waking world, barely able to maintain contact with the Guardian of Dreams.

As snippets of Sunset's thoughts erupted into Luna's mind, though, one thing was clear: This was a cry for help. Soundlessly, the Princess slipped off into Her night.