The Fantasy That Came True

by CaringSlash

Rating: everyone
Tags: Comedy, Romance
Length: 1952

Caring's fantasy comes true and he doesn't expect it.

Caring dreams of having a special somepony but one fantasy made it come true in a random way.

Contains: [spoiler]Rule 63ing…..that's all.[/spoiler]

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2016-04-19 20:26:25 UTC

The First Dream That Came True

"Ugh" A upset Caring enters his house. "I wish I could get a special somepony but everytime I try I screw up or the mare doesn't even like me. I just...can't find one. Mare's are lucky, they get all the stallions while I sit and stare as they get stallion after stallion. Maybe if I was a mare I would have stallions all over me.....I need some rest *yawns maybe tomorrow will be good luck for me or maybe I'll meet the love of my life in my dreams tonight." Caring jumps into bed and falls asleep in a snap. Caring opens his eyes and notices he is now in a white room. "Wait. Am I awake or am I dreaming?"

"Your dreaming." A voice from behind Caring speaks.

"Uh hello there." Caring notices a mare walking towards him. "Who are you?"

"I'm you but the difference is I'm a mare and your the stallion you. It's confusing."

"Yeah. But I must say I look cute as a mare."

"Then why don't you be a mare."

"I had a thought about that but I.....don't know about it."

"It'll be fun. Just Imagine how many stallions will be drooling when they see you."

Caring imagines it for a second. "It would be sweet. But how I'm I going to do that. Do you want me to get my gender swapped by a spell or something else?"

"I know a spell where I can turn you into a mare."

"Ain't it impossible to do."

"Yes. But your dreaming right."

"I was trying to have a fantasy."

"Or having a fantasy ok. When your dreaming or having a fantasy.....anything can happen. If you dream or fantasize about it and it will happen."

"Okay i'll try it out."

Wait! Before you do can I do something?"

"Sure. What are going to d-" Caring gets interrupted by his mareself kissing him on the lips and after a few seconds they broke the kiss and silence was in the air. "That was strange. I just kissed myself."

"Yeah. It does."

Caring makes the spell happen and.....nothing happens. "What the heck. Nothing happened!"

"It will happen the next time you dream or have a fantasy."

"Oh ok."

In the early hours of the morning..........

"I'm about to wake up."

"Yes you are." Then all of sudden Caring's mareself started snickering then it turned into laughing.

"What's so funny?"

"You fool. I trick you. You won't be a mare the next time you dream or have a fantasy. When you wake up you'll be a mare." The mare starts laughing evily.

"Why did you do this?"

"You needed help getting a special somepony so there you go, welcome to your new life as a mare."

"Are you even a part of my mind!?"

"Yes I am. I just changed your life completely without even trying, so now the next time you dream or have a fantasy you'll be a mare and I'll be a stallion." Caring's mareself continues to laugh evily

"I'll fix it before it's too late."

"Too late look." Caring was about to wake up. Bye bye."

"Nooooo!" Caring wakes up abruptly and his eyes open and quickly he rushes to the bathroom to see if he's a mare annnnnd he is. "It really happened." Caring stop talking in a flash and covers her mouth. "I sound like this." Her voice was high and feminine. Caring moved around to see what the rest of his body looks like. she sees a skinny and slim body and his hair and tail look the same. "I look exactly like my mareself in my fantasy. But I can't wrap my head around how this worked." While Caring tried to figure out how this happened she hears knocking at the door. "Who could be here this early in the morning?" Caring heads downstairs and sees whose at the door and it's some random stallion. Caring opens the door to see what he wants. "Hello."

"Hi there miss, I was wondering if you could sign this petition to help us rebuild town hall."

"Did somepony damage it again or something."

"Yes but it was by accident. So we decided to pass these petitions around to see if somepony will sign them so we can remodel it."

"I'll sign." Caring signs the petition and gives it back to the stallion. "Here you go."

"Thank you miss. Say you look pretty."

"Well thank you." Caring starts to blush.

"Do you think we can maybe.....go out." The stallion says sheepishly.

Caring thinks it over. "Sure. Talk to me tomorrow."

"Yes!"

"But there's something you need to know about me."

"What is it?"

"Your not going to believe this but..........I use to be a stallion."

"That's okay with me."

"Wait! Your okay with me originally being a stallion!"

"Yeah I'm fine with it. I know it's weird. I forgot to tell you what your name is?"

"My name is Caring Slash. What's your name?"

"Loving Cut."

"Cool name."

"You too."

"Okay. I'll see you tomorrow."

"You too."

Caring closes the door and suddenly thought something. "I have a date with a stallion that I don't know and he's okay with me originally being a stallion. I only know one good thing about him is that we both have similar names. Maybe he'll be a nice stallion. So far being a mare ain't that bad. But I'm going to have to get use to this new body."

Later that night..........

Caring falls asleep and starts dreaming. "I'm back here again. Oh wait." Caring gets interrupted by a familiar voice and she can't wait to tell whoever is behind her some awesome news.

"Hello there Caring. Enjoying your new life?" Her stallionself says.

"Surprisingly Yes. Yes I am and thank you for the new life." Caring says with a smile.

"What! Your...your welcome. But how I thought you would be miserable?" Her stallionself says in shock.

"Apparently within a few minutes of waking up a stallion came to my door and thought I was cute so he asked me out and I said yes and our date is tomorrow." Her stallionself looked shocked then his jaw dropped.

"Well.....I made that mistake." Her stallionself says in defeat. "Sorry."

"No it's fine. I'm starting a new life thanks to you."

"Your welcome."

The New Adventure

Caring adds a few finishing touches and heads downstairs when suddenly something knocks on her door. "It must be Loving. Coming!" Caring gets to door and it is Loving.

"Hey there beautiful."

"Hi Loving."

"I say you look real beautiful in that dress."

"Thanks." Caring starts to blush. "You look good too."

" Thanks. So are you ready?"

"Yes. Where are we going?"

"Not that far."

"Okay. Let's go." Loving holds his hoove out for Caring to plant her hoove on it.

5 minutes later..........

"Here we are! Sugarcube Corner. Is this okay?"

"Yes. I expected something else but this is fine."

"Shall we enter?"

"Let's." Caring and Loving enter Sugarcube Corner.

"Where should we sit?"

"Hmm how about over there."

"That's fine with me." Caring and Loving sit at there table and start up a little conversation. "So tell me about yourself?"

"Well as you can tell by name I am very loving. I made lots of friends when I was a colt. Also my cutie mark is a heart."

"My cutie mark is two ponies hugging each other. As you tell by my name also I am very Caring to ponies. Like when one of my friends were sick I took care of them and when I was young I use to comfort ponies to let them know I cared about them."

"Nice."

30 minutes of conversation later..........

Caring and Loving are just talking it up and Caring is still going. "One time Rainbow pranked me and then after that karma got her hard." Loving is just laughing at the funny stories. "You know what. Within 30 minutes of a conversation that turned to you telling me funny stories to me telling funny stories. I'm beginning to like you Loving."

"You are! Does that mean?"

Caring nods. "Yes. Were a couple now."

"Yes."

"Do you have another funny story to tell me?"

"Yes I do."

"Do tell."

Another 30 minutes later..........

Caring and Loving are leaving Sugarcube Corner. "Thanks. I had fun." Caring says.

"I'm glad you did and can we- never mind."

"What. What's wrong?"

"I don't know if you want to do this because of what happened to you but I was wandering if we could..........kiss."

"I guess we can ki-" Caring is interrupted by Loving's lips connecting with hers. Caring has a shock look on her face. She used to be a stallion and now he's kissing a stallion as a mare. Caring doesn't know if this weird or not. But she put the thought away and enjoyed this moment. "Take it easy. Don't smother me with your lips alright. Don't go crazy."

"Sorry."

"Can you take me home?" Caring asks.

"Sure thing my lovely." Loving takes Caring home holding hooves.

"Thank you."

"See you tomorrow."

"See you tomorrow. Wait! You forgot something." Caring runs up to Loving and gives him a quick kiss on the lips. "See you tommorow."

"You too." Caring enters her house and Loving goes home.

Caring takes her dress off and jumps in bed. "I'm surprised he didn't ask to stay over here for the night. " Caring thinks for a moment. "Being a mare doesn't seem so bad. Sure there's new things I'll have to learn and all that but *yawns* I might stay like this. Time to get some z's."

Getting Prepared For A New Adventure

Today is Caring's date with Loving and she's excited. "Today's the day." It's in the evening and Caring is getting ready for her date. "Ok. What to wear what to wear? I got it! I'll go to Rarity's place and find something there." Caring runs off to Rarity's to find her something to wear. "Hey Rarity!"

"Hello th-! You look familiar. Have we met?"

"I'm Caring Slash Rarity."

"What happened to you? Why do you look a like a mare?"

"I was mad about not having a special somepony and I talk about mares getting all the stallions but when I talk to a mare they don't like me or I don't like them and why do I look like a mare, it's because I was having a fantasy and apparently a mare version of myself told I'll be come a mare in my dreams if I use magic but it did to me on the outside and this happened."

"Uh.....wow...I can't believe that happened to you darling. Aren't you worried about the new one?"

"I'm giving it a shot. So if I don't like being a mare I'll find away to change myself back to a stallion."

"Alright. So what are you doing here?"

"I have a date so I need a dress."

"You have a date! Congratulations darling!" Rarity runs to Caring and shakes her hoove.

"Thank you Rarity."

"Let's go and find a dress for you."

30 minutes later.........

"How about that you?" Rarity says.

"Let me try it out." Caring goes into the dressing room and puts the dress on."How does it look?"

"Fabulous."

"Rarity you say that about all your wow." Caring looks in the mirror. "It's perfect!"

"Great!"

"Do I need to pay you?"

"What time is your date?"

"45 minutes from now. Why?"

"Nothing. You don't have to pay me. Were close friends and you have a date. Get going!"

Thank you Rarity." Caring runs out to give herself some finishing touches.