A New Star

by CaringSlash

Rating: everyone
Tags: Other, Starlight Glimmer, Romance, Human, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Second Person
Length: 984

You have a crush on Starlight Glimmer but you are afraid to tell her. What will you do?

You heard about Starlight Glimmer being a one of Twilight's most evil villain she encountered, she took ponies cutie marks away along with Twilight and her friends and she tried to change the past. But she's turn over a new leaf and she's a student of Twilight's. But you don't know that.

But for some reason you suddenly have a crush on her but you don't know that she's change. Will she tell you that she's change or will you get the courage to tell her and get ready for what she's going to do to you.

You X Starlight

Published 2017-02-10 22:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2017-02-10 22:40:01 UTC

Why Is She Here!

When you appeared into Equestria 5 weeks ago you've become friends with everypony and learn something new along the way. Twilight Sparkle, one of your friends, tells you about her worst enemy, Starlight Glimmer, she took ponies cutie marks away. That was the first thing she told but several months later she told you that she traveled back in time to change the past, at that point you just hate her completely, you ranted about her, you keep on saying you hate her, and saying she should never come back to Ponyville. That is until now you realize that Starlight is living in Ponyville and she looks different. Twilight tells you that she's change but you don't believe it so you your going to try your best to ignore her. But there's something wrong and the problem is that you have a crush on Starlight. When you hear her voice it sounds so nice and down to earth and her hair is beautiful, you try your best to not show it because you still hate her, so you push it off. If she's close to you. You get scared and nervous, which at one point made you run away cowardly.

You decide to go talk to Twilight but that doesn't go well because when somepony opened the door for you, that pony is Starlight.

"Oh hi." Starlight says in her beautiful voice.

You freeze in place. "Uh.........."

"Hello, anypony home." She trys to get your attention but you don't move an inch. Eventually you did move but you fell flat on your back and got up to run away. "What did I do?" She says as your running away.

"That's great. Starlight's at Twilight's place. Darn it!" You say in a angry tone.

1 hour later..........

Twilight calls you to meet up at the castle for a private meeting. "What is going on with you?" She asks.

"It's Starlight. I can't get over the fact that she changed."

"Well it's official. In fact she a student of mine."

"She is." You ask what a surprised look on your face.

"Yes she is. I'm teaching her all about friendship."

"Well that's nice. But I just can't believe that she changed."

"Well she has."

"It's going to take me a long time to believe it."

"Well don't worry you'll get over it eventually. Thanks for coming."

"No problem. See you later Twilight." You walk out of Twilight's place and head on home.

The Trap You Couldn't Escape

You head on home and lay down on your couch and think. "I can't get over my fears. It's going to take me a long time before I realize that Starlight is a changed mare. As long as she doesn't know that I'm afraid of here and that I have a crush on here I think I'll be fine." Suddenly something is knocking on your door. You look through the peephole and it's Starlight. "Hello. I know your home." She continues to knock on your door and you take drastic measures and run upstairs and once you got upstairs you let her come in.

"Come in." Starlight enters your house and you think of a plan. You are going to run out the front door without her noticing.

"Hello! Where are you!?" Once you realize the coast is clear you make a break for the door and opened it but it was closed instantly my magic. "There you are."

"Aah!" You make a mad dash upstairs but you stoped my a magic aura around you.

"Relax. You don't need to fear me. I'm just here to talk to you." She puts you down onto the couch and she starts to explain. "I know it's hard to believe but I've changed. I know it's hard to understand a mare like me to change instantly." She keeps on explaining and you don't even realize your face is red and your sweating. "Oh my. Your face is red and your burning up. Hang on I'll get you an ice pack please lay down." You lay down and she runs into the kitchen to get you an ice pack.

"Crap. I'm getting nervous." You say before Starlight returns and puts the ice pack on your head.

"Is that better?" She asks you. You nod your head. You both sit in silence before you say something out of nowhere.

"IloveyouStarlight!" You instantly cover your mouth.

"What did you say?"

"Nothing nothing."

You try to ignore the fact that you just said that you love Starlight but Starlight gives you the "Tell me the truth" look and you accept defeat.

You take a deep breath and let the words flow. "I said that I love you. I love you Starlight. It just that I'm afraid you'll hurt me cause I still think your evil.....I look like an idiot don't I?" You wait for Starlight to reply to you but she doesn't. "Starlight." You get up and try to get her attention but she doesn't answer you until out of nowhere she kisses you on lips  tackling you onto the couch. A little over a minute later she breaks the kiss.

"I have to admit it but I also had a thing for you but I knew how afraid you were when your around me so I was planning on waiting until Twilight told me to go talk to you so.....here I am now. Kissing you and confessing my feelings to you."

You are shocked to hear this. Starlight has a thing for you. "I didn't know you were in love with me."

"I've been hiding it. I love you." Starlight wraps her hooves around you and you wrap your arms around her.

"I love you too Starlight." Starlight nuzzles into you and gets comfortable. You throw the ice pack down and the both of you fall into a peaceful slumber.