Blind Chance - A Blind Date story

by Blind Writer

Rating: mature
Tags: Shining Armor, Princess Celestia, Sex, Twilight Sparkle, Drama, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Princess Cadance, Alternate Universe, Romance
Length: 59246

Sometimes it's just an impressive clash of luck that causes certain events to take place. Trying something new can have both rewards and consequences at the same time. Two siblings never expected they would meet each other by blind chance like this.

(Reading The Blind Date Company is not required to understand anything. Additional details found below the More button. This begins as mostly clop and turns more to story over time.)
8/28/16 On hiatus due to schedule. Blog
Before things like a student being sent to Ponyville, or a talented officer earning the rank of Captain of the Guard, two ponies independently decided to take a chance. If the very idea had ever even entered their minds of the other doing the same, it would've been dismissed as impossible in the next breath. And sometimes, what seems like an impossible connection can happen under the perfect conditions to let things blossom.

For two unknowing siblings, the impossible gets started, and they must decide what to do with it.

All because of blind chance.

Story contains: Sex. Lots of sex. The acts in each chapter are listed in the A/N at the top with a spoiler bar, but all acts will be reasonably plausible and nothing extreme or nasty. Putting the exact stuff here would spoil some of the fun in the discovery. If the cover image and description doesn't give you an obvious clue to what kind of story this is, you need better exposure to the world to corrupt your innocence (try 4chan). Even then, it is listed like the other kinks. :trollestia:

Decided to change the cover image since I'm a whore for attention and people are highly visual. Image is a cropped version of #1136135 on Derpibooru and NSFW, so I can't give a link to it or the artist page. Artist is Dimwitdog, whose art page is also NSFW.

And on posting Ch 5, I achieved a ratings-driven appearance at the bottom of the vaunted Feature Box. :yay:

Published 2016-05-10 22:40:02 UTC
Last updated 2016-07-31 01:48:40 UTC

Ch 1 - Trying Something New

Author's Note

Contains: blindfolds, glory hole-ish, cunnilingus, fellatio and a little deepthroating, cum swallowing, kissing, unknowing incest

And so it begins. Every chapter has almost constant sex, or a lot of it with some story to make it more meaningful. It's still ultimately a clopfic, so that shouldn't be a surprise. Heck, Ch 4 is basically one constant chain of gratuitous sex scenes directly continuing events of Ch 3. Still, I hope I've managed to make it both enticing and a good read that happens to be heavy on clop as the focus of the story, rather than the story just being some ancillary excuse for clop. More fun when it all comes together, anyway. :rainbowlaugh:

Funny enough, this story is what got my whole Blind Date premise created in the first place. While this particular story will likely never be added to once all chapters are up, the main Blind Date Company premise story will have updates once in a while, when I feel the urge to write a random crack-ship clop.

Also, everyone that reads this is a pervert, and so am I since I wrote this lunacy. Meh, at least it's hot. :trollestia:

Ch 1 - Trying Something New

Twilight Sparkle swallowed back her nerves, her face feeling rather hot from the intensity of her blush and knowing what she came here to try engaging in. In the face of her anxiousness, she stepped through the doorway and into the small room that was hardly large enough for a pony to turn around. Even with all the assurances of anonymity that The Blind Date Company provided, she still felt so very exposed, like she was about to be discovered at any moment.

Despite her worrying, even the staff had little direct contact with clients, with only individual meetings with a single random concierge through a tiny window, only present for requests, questions and payment. The window was too small for either to see the other and a voice modulation spell changed how each sounded, leaving almost no way for any pony involved to be revealed to another. Added with the multiple secretly marked staircase doors into the place in the building’s basement, mixed in with other doors to businesses that were a myriad of ordinary things, it was even quite easy to visit unnoticed. They were kind of a secret, but an open one. It was still a business, after all.

After she shut and locked the door behind her, all she could do at first was stare at the circular hole in the metal wall across from the door. The hole was only about eight inches wide, currently blocked by a metal cover plate she knew was just a thin sheet of metal between her room and the matching one on the other side. The only difference between the two rooms was the slope of the wall just above the hole. It was arranged so a stallion could poke his erection through comfortably, if the two participants decided on such things.

Twilight somehow managed to blush even brighter as she thought about it, and what she had come to do, now that it was practically staring back at her.

She licked her lips self-consciously as she took a look at the only two pieces of furniture in the little white room. A small bed, just large enough for recovering on if exhausted, and a set of shelves. On it were a number of rather varied items, ranging from lube and toys, to drinking water, towels, even a bottle of mouthwash with a small bucket. They also had an option for special requests to be stocked for a scheduled session, if clients so desired.

The whole point of the place was essentially a rather adventurous blind dating service, although Twilight understood some ponies just came here for exciting sex over an eventual special somepony. After looking through anonymous profiles and choosing the same pony that chose you, the two clients then picked a general approach to the meeting with a simple question sheet of options. Once they agreed on that, a meeting was arranged in these special rooms.

It wasn’t even the unusually formed walls that made them so special, but rather the enchantments that were set up. In addition to a custom sound control enchantment on the wall between rooms, and full sound-proofing on the rest, the metal plate that kept the hole in the far wall shut would only open when both ponies on either side were wearing their enchanted mask, located on the shelf in each room. She also understood the lamp in each room would go dark once the masks were on, further improving their anonymity.

Twilight chewed on her bottom lip as she looked to the two indicator crystals on part of the shelf. One red and one white. The red was just for the occupant to know somepony was coming, in the off chance something like a medical emergency or injury happened. She knew her odds of that one lighting up were near non-existent. The white one would light up when her mystery stallion locked himself in on the the other side.

As the anticipation built, her heart raced faster. She wasn’t sure about dating, being so nervous about her inexperience that she could never manage to speak a word at those rare times she had even the slightest inclination towards another pony that way. Her books said all kinds of things about the subject, but her shy discomfort, and occasional wild panic, prevented her from getting anywhere.

Looking into ways to solve the problem, she had come across Blind Date and their promise of anonymous dating where you could control everything, even seeing the other pony, until you wanted to go to a given step. While she had dismissed the place at first, the idea of being in near complete control of how things went and how much exposure she had in such a foreign endeavor was appealing. She could get experience and build up her confidence in intimacy until she was ready to go trying further, or even felt satisfied enough to stop with not doing so at all and pursue an intimate connection more common ways.

Even then, it wasn’t until she realized she could study the whole new path of mysterious knowledge that was sex and sexuality that she made up her mind to become a client.

She gasped when the white light came on, her breathing picking up further and eyes going wide.

Oh gosh! I’m really doing this! I’m about to trade oral coitus with a stallion for the first time ever, and I’m completely safe from anything going wrong! He even knows I’m doing this for the first time and promised to let me experiment with his penis as much as I wanted! Twilight’s mind raced, biting her bottom lip as she stared at the hole as a quiver ran down her spine. Though she was nervous, knowing she was able to control how this all went was making leaving her anticipation shoot through the roof and turning her on something awful. She could tease him and just stop if she so desired, the stallion on the other side entirely at the mercy of her curiosity. It was a feeling of power she had never felt before, and she wanted to know more. And if this went well, she’d see about trying to meet with a mare, too. She did have a secret crush on a certain somepony special.

A soft chime sounded from the indicator crystal stand, prompting Twilight to remember she needed to put her mask on. With her heart thudding in her chest, she levitated the simple black eye cover, almost identical to a sleeping mask, if it weren’t for the interesting enchantments she detected were layered into it. She was tempted to study the way it was constructed, how the spells on it wouldn’t let it budge from her face once on, unless she intentionally spoke a deactivation phrase. She shivered once more at the idea she’d had, of rubbing her face all over the stallion’s length, and not having to worry about the mask being pushed off her eyes, among several other ideas. Her imagination had been running wild for the five days since setting up this first date.

Twilight whimpered and felt her nethers wink as she remembered this was fully intended as an oral sex first date. They’d also agreed on no talking this time because they were both a little nervous and felt doing it in silence would be extra exciting, while removing the need to think of anything to say in what could otherwise leave them in an extremely awkward moment or several. The spellwork on the wall between them would keep them from hearing a sound from each other.

Struggling to keep her shaking legs under her, she moved towards the hole in the wall she knew would be open now. Twilight turned around and, with a little magic to be sure she was on target as she flipped her tail out of the way, pressed her already damp marehood up against the hole. Her mystery stallion had agreed to tend to her first.

Her muscles quivered in anticipation as she thought about her mystery stallion, swallowing against the lump in her throat as she waited for him to start. The simple profile gave little to identify a pony with, but gave a good general hint of what they were like and the life they had. She knew he was in the Royal Guard and stationed in Canterlot, so maybe he worked at the castle and--!

Suddenly, she gasped out loud as a small brush of air graced her sensitive areas, then let out a whine as she felt him softly nuzzle against her. His touch was electric against the fur beside her most intimate area, and he hadn’t even really done anything yet!

Panting, she tried to press herself back for more of his touch. She’d come this far and, by Celestia, she would channel all her nerves into trying to encourage him rather than let her fears make her stop! She had to know what it felt like to have somepony else give her an orgasm. The feel of him starting to kiss gently around her marehood was doing wonders to make her fears fade and her confidence in her choice grow.

Twilight also realized her mind was already made up for setting up a second meeting with her mystery stallion. If he was so readily taking such care with her and, having used her anonymity to let him know she’d never been with another pony, trying to make her first time so good… Well, she certainly wasn’t wanting this to be just once. She could scarcely imagine what he’d be making her feel once he began to taste her.

Just as she felt his lips plant a kiss directly on her treasure, her body winked again. The thought of what he must think of her appearing so eager for his touch made her feel so naughty.

Using her magic before she got any more overwhelmed by the sensations he was giving her, she pulled the large pillow off the bed and set it on the floor. Twilight lowered her front half down, her head resting on the pillow as she began to shudder with a quiet cry. Her mystery stallion had skipped ahead suddenly, parting the outer lips of her marehood and dragging his tongue slowly down her center, then circling around her clit.

Twilight moaned and whined as she felt her mystery stallion continue to treat her to ever increasing sensations. He had claimed he had little experience, that it was pretty much a first for him too, and sometimes he did seem to lose his rhythm with the occasional odd pause, but if this was him inexperienced, she quivered all the more at the idea of him practicing on her until he was a master with that tongue of his.

He nibbled at her lips before finally thrusting his tongue into her and she let out a soft squeal. She was so worked up by this point, she could scarcely think past the feel of his tongue traveling all around and inside her marehood. An occasional extra touch rubbed at her clit and she knew his hoof was helping push her towards her peak.

Pushing herself back against the hole with no small amount of urgent need, Twilight almost wished he’d just jump up and mount her after treating her so tenderly in her first experience with sex of any kind, feeling confident he’d make full on sex equally exciting, yet gentle. Still, knowing she was rapidly approaching her peak was going to be more than enough, the way it was building up in her. Her own self-stimulation never felt like anything even close to being this strong.

Her breathing got shorter as the coil inside her tightened, the feel of him sucking on her clitoris and lashing it with his tongue almost sent her over the edge. Yet, before she had a chance to relax, his mouth fell upon her entrance, her marehood spread open by his hooves, and his tongue thrust as far inside her as he could reach. Then did something she didn’t expect, and sucked at her entrance, licking eagerly at her walls as he did.

“Aaaaaahhh!” Twilight finally burst as her marehood spasmed against his tongue, desperately trying to get more of him inside her even as she wailed out a long note of orgasm. Her mystery stallion’s tongue continued to work her over, encouraging her spasms to repeatedly squeeze at his searching tongue.

As she came back down, she began to feel sharp lightning stabbing into her oversensitive clit as he continued to lick with abandon before Twilight found the strength to bend her hind legs and pull herself away from the hole and his glorious mouth. She really needed a moment to catch her breath.

Before she realized what she was doing, Twilight had gotten to her hooves and spun around, swiftly locating the hole and pushing her face forward. Her hope of catching her mystery stallion’s lips met with success as she kissed him as hard as she could. Their lips separated only because her head was blocked by the hole in the wall, feeling his breath caressing her open mouth for a moment, just out of reach, before he pushed back against her for a second go.

She could taste herself on him as she thrust her tongue into his mouth. For a time, she relished getting to kiss him in appreciation of his tongue efforts, but her craving for the next part of their first date was quickly turning to sucking at his tongue. She wanted to do for him what he had just done for her.

The idea she was about to suck on the stallion’s length until he sprayed his release right into her mouth did nothing to reduce her own arousal. Knowing he might be one of the castle guards made it worse. Every time she walked past one, she’d be wondering if they were her mystery stallion that had felt her lips and tongue, if it was the one that knew the taste of her body and feel of her lips on his turgid length.

There would be no way for her to tell, but she could already imagine things going further between them. Thinking of them agreeing to reveal themselves to each other and starting to date out in the open. Maybe she’d even get to tease him while he was stuck on duty, flashing him a look or brushing him with her tail as she walked by. The idea of making him react against the usual protocol by trying to drive him wild was far too interesting.

As she pulled away from the intense kiss, sucking on his tongue the whole way until they separated with an audible pop both would hear because it was a sound they both made, she had to remind herself not to get too carried away from a first meeting. She did make herself a checklist of various points of interaction she felt was needed before they did something that broke their anonymity. Even if she felt he wasn’t holding up somehow, he might still be willing to meet with her just for exploring sex and help her build up her confidence.

Soooo glad I went through with this. Show me your spear, my talented mystery guard…

***

Shining Armor licked his lips, still savoring the taste of the unknown mare he was meeting with. She had a strange, slightly sweet yet arousing taste to her. She had orgasmed pretty hard, if how much of her essence he just drank from the source was any indication compared to things he’d heard from other members of the Guard.

Not bad for a first time tonguing a mare if I made her gush like that. Guess following Twiley’s example by looking up cunnilingus in a book before coming here paid off better than I hoped. Even if we never meet again, I’ll bet she’s never going to forget her first time having a stallion eat her marehood. He smirked to himself even as he swallowed a little more of her lingering taste and feeling very glad he went through with this. Maybe some more practice and I’ll finally work up the nerve to ask Cadence out on a date. She has been a little annoyed that I’ve been pretending to miss her little hints, but she seems so out of my league. I could at least train a little on how to treat a mare first so I could offer more…

His tongue and jaw were a little sore from trying so hard, but it seemed his efforts had paid off well, if the intensity of her kiss was anything to go by. And the way she had sucked on his tongue had left little question what she wanted next.

His heart was thumping as he rose to his hooves and started slowly lifting himself up on the specially angled wall of his side of their pair of connected rooms. As he understood the place, each side was basically identical, aside from the angled wall. Upon asking the concierge for the information, he was surprised, and little creeped out, that it was not specific to mare and stallion, but rather top and bottom for mounting in general. Gender made no difference, according to the information he looked over. Among other things, some stallions apparently liked getting mounted by a mare with a strap-on, let alone two mares or two stallions meeting together.

He shook those thoughts out of his head in the next moment. His twitching shaft wasn’t going to let him stay distracted by anything but the unknown mare for very long right now.

Moving with care, he pressed forward slowly so he wouldn’t accidentally jab the unknown mare. While he felt like he had no idea what to do around mares, he’d at least gathered that most really appreciated a stallion being considerate of their feelings. Shining figured if he was in her place, he certainly wouldn’t want to get smacked in the face with a cock, that a careful, gentle approach would get rewarded.

Shining gasped as he felt himself bump softly against her, probably her face, before he felt her lips part and start running her tongue across his tip, keeping pace with him as he moved fully through the hole that was their only access to each other. She seemed tentative for several seconds, adding credence to her claim of this being her first time, but she was quickly getting bolder and more confident as her tongue and lips moved more fervently over his engorged shaft.

Her lips nibbled at his sensitive skin, slowly leaving a trail of tingles down the side of his length as her tongue swiped here and there, tasting him as she went. In his mind, Shining was expecting, and assuming she was truly a complete virgin, that she’d want to be free to explore. With that in mind, he let himself relax into her attentions.

With the past couple days having a number of rather ordinary yet frustrating hassles come up to make his work as an officer difficult, there was an additional, special sort of pleasure and relief added to the mix. This mare was eager to please and she was openly worshipping his cock right now. If he was lucky, she’d even let him finish in her mouth at the end, but he wouldn’t be too disappointed if not. She was just getting started, her tongue tracing around his medial ring and making him twitch, and already he could tell anything she did was going to feel fantastic.

He couldn’t help but smile when he felt her rubbing the side of his shaft all over her face, even pausing to take a deep breath with her nose pressed against him near the base. She was definitely acting eager to please.

Her tongue started to lap at the bottom of his length, her nose holding his shaft up and sliding ahead of her dancing tongue, he felt her pause when she got back to his tip. A small rub of her nose hinted she was surprised, maybe not expecting the gathered precum that was likely there. She went still and Shining felt her nose, still touching his tip, get a swipe of her tongue, which made his shaft twitch again as it brushed against him.

Shining’s breath caught in his throat when he felt her lips latch onto his tip and start suckling, her tongue licking everywhere she could, even pressing the tip into the small opening in what seemed to be a request for more of his own fluids.

He felt her jaw open wider and slipped him into her mouth proper, tongue swirling as she almost seemed to nurse at his tip. One of her hooves left his shaft and she took him a little deeper before a faint separate motion began, leaving him an unexpected thought. Is she seriously playing with herself because sucking my dick is turning her on so much?

While he could only guess, the idea was certainly hot, making his tip twitch a bit wider in response. The unknown mare just seemed all the more eager as she started to take more of him in her mouth. Her hoof still touching him began to stroke along the length her mouth hadn’t reached.

Much to his surprise, a new sensation made him blink. It felt like he’d bumped the end of her mouth, if his assumption was correct. What was buried past her lips was constantly getting assaulted by her tongue underneath, even as she pressed him against the roof of her mouth.

Then he felt her go strangely still, seeming to move in some way, before his jaw dropped and he had to struggle not to move. The unknown mare seemed to really trust his good behavior or something because she was pushing him deeper, even as she seemed to tremble just enough for him to feel it.

Her throat slowly slid around the tip of his shaft, causing Shining to tremble himself. Not wanting to surprise her, he forced himself to remain perfectly still, even as his disbelief grew with every bit of himself that sank deeper down her throat. When her lips met his medial ring, then slowly passed over it, he felt her pause briefly. Then he felt her lips clamp down a little, he imagined it was some kind of determined look, because she pushed even more of him down her throat.

If he wasn’t so stunned at how it felt buried in her throat, Shining might not have been able to restrain himself in that moment. She paused again just a bit further, then surprised him again when he felt her start to swallow around his length. It took everything he had to stop himself from using what little space he had left to shove his cock deeper into her throat.

Shining felt his orgasm rapidly climbing before she began pulling back much more quickly, his shaft slipping out of her throat until only the tip was resting against her lips. When he felt her panting against him, he realized she had been pushing herself a lot harder than he expected. It only added to the idea she was trusting him to be gentle enough for her to safely explore him however she wanted.

Part of him wished she’d turn around and impale herself on him, but he knew they could try that another time. He definitely wanted to meet with this unknown mare again.

A groan escaped his mouth when he felt her shove her mouth back down around him. She wasn’t taking him in her throat again, but she was eagerly bobbing her head now. His previous climb towards climax was quickly coming back as she worked him with a hungry suction. All the buildup was adding up on him as she made it clear what she was wanting now.

“Guuaaaaahh!” Shining crossed the finish line and felt himself crash into an incredible climax, his shaft tingling with each burst he released straight into the unknown mare’s mouth. She had stopped bobbing her head as he began to flare, the same faint motions from earlier now accompanied by a vibration some part of him realized was her unheard voice, possibly the sound of her own moans while getting herself off to sucking his dick. All he really knew for certain was how she seemed to tremble and clamp her lips down behind his flare once the first shot sprayed into her mouth, her other hoof stroking up and down his shaft to encourage him to give her more.

The entire time he was pulsing into her mouth, she kept her lips sealed around his tip, her tongue running everywhere it could reach. With each burst, the suction on his tip seemed to reduce a little.

Panting for breath as he slumped his chest and head against the pad on the angled wall, Shining felt a little dizzy. He hadn’t been lying when he’d let the mare know he had little experience with sex. He couldn’t quite bring himself to admit a stallion of the Royal Guard was a virgin at his age. Thankfully for him, she seemed to appreciate the idea he wasn’t exactly some playcolt looking for a mare with skill or something like that.

He could hardly believe her next move as he felt her lips slowly slide over his tip until he was free of her mouth. He felt her slide his still mostly hard shaft against her fur, able to tell enough to know she was sliding him under her chin. She moved forward with seeming purpose, his length rubbing along her throat until her nose pressed into the base, his shaft now laying lengthwise along her neck.

Then he felt the unmistakeable motion of her swallowing a couple times, with his shaft held against the front of her throat.

Shining felt his cock twitch, threatening to firm back up again as she gulped down what he had left in her mouth. He felt speechless that she wanted him to know she consumed everything he gave her like that. Her tongue traced back up his length before slipping his tip back in her mouth and nursing at it again, giving him the impression she wished he would give her more.

Still trying to calm his heart and breathing back to normal, Shining felt he had to draw back. Moving with slow intent, he pulled his dick back through the hole, his unknown mare following until the wall stopped her, seeming reluctant to stop nursing on the head of his shaft. Before he pulled away though, he touched a forehoof to her cheek to keep track of her, feeling her rub against it once he pulled his dick out of reach.

Earlier, he might have had some misgivings about the idea, but as he shoved his lips against hers in his blindness, he didn’t care that he could taste a bit of himself in her mouth as his tongue moved against hers. A part of him really regretted the fact they wouldn’t be able to talk to each other because of how they had set up the meeting. He wanted to thank her, congratulate her, ask how she came up with everything she did, even ask her right then and there to meet with him again.

Instead, he had to settle for kissing her with as much intensity as she had kissed him with earlier and then some. To let her know he was thrilled by her mysterious touch. That he wanted to know more about her and who she was.

The two of them simply kept up their sensual kiss, losing track of time until a chime sounded, letting them know the hour was up and they’d need to clean up before exiting their respective rooms for opposite sides of the building. It took a couple false breaks before they separated for the final time and the sound of the hole between them closing brought Shining back to his senses.

A quick deactivation phrase, then he removed the blindfold, the lights turning on at a dim setting so he wasn’t blinded. Shining had to laugh to himself at how taking a chance at this whole Blind Date thing had turned out so unexpectedly great. Even if his unknown mare didn’t want to meet with him again for some reason, he was very glad he tried this.

If she does want to meet again though, there’s no way I’m turning her down. From what little I could tell, she seemed well-groomed and had really soft fur. It’d be utterly hilarious if Cadence somehow set this up and it was her on the other side. Wouldn’t be the first really crazy surprise prank she pulled on me, although she wouldn’t have had Twiley giving her unexpected ways of doing things only my sister would think of. Also pretty sure Cadence has experience with sex, but whatever.

Yeah, definitely have to meet with that mare again…

Ch 2 - Penetration Preparation

Author's Note

Contains: unknowing incest, kissing, butt plug, brief deep throat, anal, anal creampie

So I decided to indulge a jump ahead with my schedule, just because. I won't change it up again though, so expect to have a day or two for anticipating the looming train wreck they're headed for in the middle of hot sex. Might even tease by having several days between. Yeah, I can be a mean tease like that, and it will be worth it. :trollestia:

Eh, a good period of buildup before getting to the big finish always makes it better anyway. Of course, with Ch 3 only being the halfway mark, there's plenty more of this to go... :trollestia:

Ch 2 - Penetration Preparation

At the sound of the lock turning into place, Twilight couldn’t help the giggle that escaped, nor the brief little dance she did at the chance to meet with her mystery stallion again. She recalled how their second meeting had been even better than the first, deciding not to change anything other than being able to talk and seeing where things went from there. She couldn’t even begin to put words to how much it thrilled her when he’d come out and said why he’d held so still for her the first time. It made her feel so special. Due to the custom sound control enchantment between their rooms, she had found herself frequently wondering what his real voice sounded like without magic changing it to keep them unidentified. With how things were progressing, she was unable to stop thinking about getting to find out in the hopefully near-ish future.

For now, they were meeting for an hour almost every couple of days whenever possible, and they both had the same time slot available. Today marked a full month since their first meeting. Expectations of what they wanted had grown once they started talking, and amazingly, her mystery stallion had happily relished a couple visits where all they did was kiss and talk. They were required to keep things vague about their lives, but she knew he was an officer now. He also came from a good upbringing right here in Canterlot, just like her. What drew her in most was his warm personality. I bet Shiny would approve of him, assuming things keep going so well and we end up giving up our masks. Then I can show him off to my BBBFF and the rest of my family. I think it’s still a little early, but I really think I’m falling for him.

Until today, she had actually been somewhat reluctant to change their planned activity, feeling like it might mess something up for a time when they were getting along so well. He had agreed to let her lead things at her pace, wanting her to be comfortable as a first priority. Due to Twilight’s inclination towards experimenting, he didn’t really have much to complain about anyway. She enjoyed the way he obeyed her every request to hold still or move a certain way as she tried new ways of stimulating him. It was their meeting just yesterday that she finally took his whole length in her throat and got him to cum directly into her stomach as she swallowed around him, her lips clamped around the his base as she felt him twitch with each spurt. And that was after she let him thrust slowly in her throat until he said he was close. With a touch of her hoof, she’d climaxed pretty hard to that feeling.

The memory of his warmth filling her belly made it a little hard to sleep last night, once she’d finished her planned reading amount for the night. Once again, she was really glad she had gotten the dildo two days prior to practice having something inside herself. She hadn’t been able to sleep until getting off to fantasizing about him making love to her. The idea was occupying her mind more with each meeting, but it wasn’t her plan for today.

No, she had an opportunity to make her first time with a stallion perfect, and she wasn’t going to rush that moment for anything. A full checklist of things she wanted to be done or in place first was already half complete, including the dildo to ensure she would feel nothing but pleasure from him thrusting inside her as much as he wanted until he burst. Hopefully, he could get the time off from his duties for what she was planning soon.

Panting in anticipation ever so slightly, Twilight licked her lips at the plan for today. A precursor of sorts that she’d also been preparing herself for. The faint sound of another drop of her own arousal hitting the floor was a quiet indication of how excited she was to meet with him today.

***

Shining Armor closed and locked the door behind himself before finally giving into his anticipation, his cock unsheathing beneath him. Guard training really did provide him some unexpected benefits at times. While there were some environments where it was of no consequence, like simple guard duty in most places. Unfortunately, most of the time that was only for enlisted stallions, and not him.

As an officer, and likely candidate as the next Captain of the Guard in the next year or two, he spent most of his time in places where an unwanted erection was anywhere from a bit rude to extremely insulting and inappropriate. Preventing one when surrounded by dignitaries and officials of all kinds could be a very important skill some days. Of course, it didn’t hurt that it also improved his staying power and recovery time in the process. The Royal Guard had a quietly famous reputation in the bedroom for a reason, after all.

Finally getting to relax the muscles he’d been giving a lot of exercise recently even released some tension in his back, unable to stop the smile at seeing the white light already lit up once he’d closed and locked his door. His mystery mare was usually waiting for him whenever they were able to meet. Another reason he was glad he was an officer was more flexibility outside of normal duty hours, but he couldn’t arrive early like she always seemed to.

He had learned she was a university-level magic student at one of the three schools in Canterlot, and that she had a pretty big reading habit. She had the cutest laughs and pleasure-induced squeals he felt he had ever heard, too. During their conversations, a couple times not even getting into oral at all for the whole visit, he had come to find she had a brilliant mind and was very sweet.

It still amazes me how I feel so much steadier because of her. I’ve been very careful about it so I don’t rush anything, but I’ve even felt confident enough to flirt back a little with Cadence. I can’t forget the look on her face the first time I shot back an easy quip when she gave me an opening, and then just walked away with a confident smirk on my face. She’s been a lot more playful ever since, although she’s been giving me a strange nervous look from time to time as well. If she can sense love in other ponies, could that be it? Could I really be slowly falling for my mystery mare when I don’t even know her face yet? Am I getting ready to tell her who I am? She seems really smart, but would Twiley like her?

Slipping his mask on, Shining shifted around on his hooves in anticipation. His mystery mare had promised a surprise change for today, but hadn’t said what. With both of them having indicated sufficient mutual trust for them to skip planning what they would do when they met, he was curious as heck to know what she wanted to do this time. Maybe she finally wanted to try actual sex for the first time.

For a moment, he frowned to himself that she might be wanting to stick something in his plot, but he dismissed the notion immediately. By this point, he felt they understood each other well enough not to make any particularly off the mark assumptions about what the other would be interested in trying.

His smile returning, he remembered one session where he got to experiment with his mouth and tongue on her, finding various ways to make her react. She had felt guilty for him not getting a turn, but a weary tongue and his thirst quenched by several of her orgasms was enough for him that day. Considering their next meeting after that was her deep throating him completely until he came straight into her stomach from her gulping down his length like she hadn’t had a drink in days more than made up for it.

Hearing the hole between their sides of the meeting room slide open, Shining carefully moved to the opening with a giddiness that had kept growing since the first meeting. The sound of her breathing and familiarity with each other led him right to her lips, their tongues wasting no time as they went all out for several seconds before pulling back to nuzzle a little and talk.

“Mmm… Still a tasty mare like always, sexy,” he said in a low voice. “How do I sound today?”

***

Twilight shivered as she nuzzled her mysterious stallion, licking the side of his mouth before she spoke. “Flatterer. Sounds like you’re a tenor this time, mister mystery. How about me?”

The sound of his warm chuckle gave her another quiver. “You sound like a one of those stereotypically deep-voiced mares from Stalliongrad. I bet you could do some really husky dirty talk with that.”

Humming to herself for a moment, she grinned in the darkness of their blindness, purposely dropping her voice a little. “Are you telling me you want to hear me talk about how I’m going to drag my tongue all over your penis until I get it all wet, then let it slowly slide into my throat until you can’t help but send cum straight into my needy body? To feel me swallowing you whole, knowing your mare thinks you taste delicious and needs another taste?”

She heard him let out a faint hiss before capturing her lips hungrily, simply enjoying the kiss for a bit before pulling back again, speaking in a somewhat pouty sing-song voice. “Too bad for you that I’m not letting you cum in my mouth today~.”

He laughed. “You’ve gotten so much better at dirty talk, sexy. Whatever do you plan to do with me today then?”

Pressing her nose against his, Twilight bit her bottom lip as she gathered up her courage for the step she was about to take, her voice a lot more nervous as she near whispered her intentions. “I-I want you… I want t-to…”

She almost melted when his lips pressed against hers for a tender kiss, her rising nerves snuffed out by his reminder he would never press her for more than she was ready for. A couple times, she’d gotten caught up in her nerves when she made a mistake trying to practice giving him a blowjob. Once, he even admitted a mistake really had hurt, but not once did he get upset with her. When they both had their faces at the hole, he’d taken up a habit of giving her a very gentle kiss when she started getting worked up. Every time, it calmed her.

“Hey now, no need for that. We’re at your pace.” He said in a soothing tone. She imagined him wearing a warm smile as his loving eyes stared into hers.

“I… My plot… I-I want to feel you in my plot today.” She got it out and the rest just rolled free from there. “I’ve been practicing with toys. Trying to get myself prepared so I could try it with you comfortably. I even made sure to clear everything out just before I came to see you. I-I need to feel you in me but I’m not ready to give you my real virginity yet. Please say you’ll be gentle and stay still for me again?”

Twilight panted in part from nerves, but also from the anticipation. She felt his breath on her muzzle, noticing his own breathing had sped up and it gave her a tremulous smile, even if he couldn’t see it. When she felt his lips press against hers with a hunger beneath the tenderness, she felt her excitement rise.

After he pulled back, he hummed to himself. “Let’s see… The sexy mare that’s been giving me amazing blowjobs and helping me learn how best to lick her to orgasm wants to try letting me slip inside her plot after taking time to prepare herself. And all I have to do is keep being gentle and let her control the pace? Is there a downside here? I’m not seeing one.”

She nipped at her mystery stallion’s nose before nuzzling against his warm face, unable to stop a bashful giggle from escaping. He had a fun sense of humor and always made it easy to relax around him.

Drawing back, she stopped holding back as her marehood quivered, her voice turning husky. “Produce that cock, stallion. I need to get you ready.”

Getting to her hooves, Twilight dipped her head around the side as he slipped his shaft through the hole for her. Like every previous time, she rubbed her face all over it before anything else, relishing the warmth even as she reached out with her magic in the dark and started getting herself ready for him as she removed the plug she didn’t tell him about. After they were done, she wasn’t letting any of his seed escape until she went to bed. A hefty squirt of lube she sent into her plot would have time to warm before she turned around to finally feel him in a variation of the penetration she was craving more every day.

As she worked on herself, her lips found his tip and wasted no time in letting him enter her mouth. Her tongue traveled all over the head, savoring his taste, before slowly sliding him in further. A deep breath first, she smoothly pushed herself forward so he slid down her throat, stopping once she reached his medial ring and gulping around him. The sound of his groaning voice above her only spurred her on, tempting her to make him feed her as fast as possible.

Instead, she drew back and let him escape her lips with a sucking pop. She then turned herself around on shaky hooves, the wet feeling of her properly prepared plot was one more sensation mixed into her anticipation. She flipped her tail out of the way, then stopped when she felt his tip press against her slippery back door. Proceeding to shift her body around in a teasing manner, Twilight pushed back until it felt like he was just about to slip inside her plot, then pulled away until she was barely touching, then finally pressing herself back until it felt like he was about to spread her open and go inside her.

Swallowing down her nervous energy over what she was about to do, she needed to hear his voice first and called out to him, knowing he could hear her easily through the thin metal wall between them. “Are you ready for me, my mysterious stallion?”

She heard him gasp as she teased him, his voice sounding strained. “You are such a tease. I’m more than ready.”

Licking her lips, Twilight began to slowly press her well lubed plot back against her mystery stallion’s cock, feeling the pressure climb and her ring spread wider until his flared tip overcame the resistance and slipped inside with a silent pop. The foreign warmth of him actually inside her made her let out a shuddery gasp as she squeezed her plot against the intruder for a moment. It was a strange feeling, being able to feel his twitching head inside of her that way, but her preparation with plugs seemed to have paid off. It felt different, but good enough to enjoy the sensation.

Hearing him groan like that because she made him feel good only made it better.

Biting her bottom lip, Twilight pressed herself back a little more, letting the stiff shaft now inside her sink a little further until the lube seemed to grow thin. Pulling herself forward, she let him slip out until she reached his flare again, keeping it firmly lodged in her plot. The lube she had squirted inside herself made her next push back sink a good deal more of him into her before starting to process again. Forward to let the lube spread again, then back to take a bit more.

Twilight gasped as his medial ring slipped into her body, unwilling to pull away as far now, needing more of him and feeling such a unique fullness. She was almost disappointed when she felt her flanks finally pressed against the wall, taking as much of his warm cock inside of her plot as possible through the hole in the wall. Her calculation on lube ratio seemed a bit high, but she had erred on the side of caution.

The extra only made him slip through her ring that much easier at least, and she pulled away to his medial ring, then slid herself back again, biting her bottom lip with a whimper. I need to feel him finish in me. My books said some mares had little feeling, and some had a lot during anal. I can’t believe I feel so much like this. I need to ask him my question about a joint room after this. How good would it feel if he could completely hilt inside me?

***

Shining gasped when he felt his mystery mare stop moving after bumping the wall a couple of times, his cock buried in her plot as far as she could get him. He could hardly believe how hot and tight it felt inside her. Before he could dwell much on it though, he heard her voice call up to him.

“Nnf, please. Please rut my plot my mystery stallion. I need to feel you claim me.”

He felt his cock twitch as he breathed a little harder. Part of him wanted to just start pounding, but staying at her pace was what he knew she wanted. Getting to his peak with slow thrusts would take longer, but it also tended to provide a stronger climax. Besides, there was always the possibility she’d ask him to go faster as she got used to it.

His previously stationary flanks began to pull back from the hole and her plot, drawing back until he felt his flare reach the inside of her back door, then slowly thrust his full length back inside. The lube she had used made it quite easy for him to move.

It wasn’t long before he heard her ask him to speed up and he readily thrust a little faster into her plot. Part of him wished he was directly on her back, holding her close with his forelegs. The wall prevented him from burying himself quite to the hilt inside his mysterious mare. Maybe she’d like to start meeting in joint rooms after this. Even if she just wanted to be held at first.

The inside of her plot was causing Shining to quiver a bit, still tempted to do what his instincts were telling him and pound her until he shot his cum right into her body. Instead, he took his pacing cues from her and the two of them soon fell into a rhythm together. After thrusting into her for a bit, she’d beg him to go a little faster, her whines and moans rising each time.

Soon, she seemed to struggle at forming words as she let him ravish her as fast as he wanted, letting out occasional utterances for more. Breaking the pattern of his thrusts from time to time in order to make his medial ring slip rapidly in and out of her plot would draw out one of her cute squeals.

There was one transition of going from ring thrusts back to deep when Shining felt himself nearing his end and she started moaning she was close. He told himself he’d make sure she started before he did, knowing his flare was starting to expand deep inside her as he held on, each thrust not letting his medial ring slip free so he could stay well inside her clenching plot.

“Nnnf, yes! Fill me! Cum inside my plot!” His mysterious mare cried out to him.

A deep groan escaped him as he tried to thrust faster, feeling her squeezing down on him as her body tensed up, knowing she was going to cum with him buried deep inside. The clenching, raw heat under her tail as he moved was eroding his ability to resist.

Even with his staying power, the dam had to break at some point and he finally rammed himself against the wall separating them and as far inside of her as he could just as his flare swelled to it’s widest. A snarl escaped him, gritting his teeth as the first rope of his cum sprayed deep into her bowels, causing her to squeal a moment later and her plot to clamp down on his cock as it appeared she came from his release shooting deep into her quivering form.

His cock sent several ropes of seed into her body, hearing and feeling her gasp and squeal and clench with every burst that hit the inner walls of her plot. By the time his orgasm had finished, he found himself slumped against the pad on his side of the wall, trying to catch his breath. He could feel her body trembling, the rhythmic clenches of her plot making his extra sensitive shaft twitch as the two of them tried to recover.

When enough strength returned to his legs after a minute or so, Shining slowly lifted himself back up, his still half erect shaft remained buried in his mystery mare’s plot. She let out a lazy moan as he shifted and slowly pulled himself free, slumping down on his haunches beside the hole in the wall between them. He could only lean against the wall for support as he heard her shuffling around.

The moment he knew she was there, he captured her lips with his own. It was a kiss born of deep satisfaction and she made a soft simper as she pressed into it, their tongues dancing together in an almost lethargic way. Heh, our first real post-coital kiss. No leftover mess to taste. No need for words. Just us and our afterglow. It feels… Good…

***

Twilight relished their kiss more than usual until they separated again. She knew she was smiling at him, knowing he wouldn’t be able to see it but needing to show him one anyway. It was one of those smiles that you just couldn’t help. Moving her head forward a little, she nuzzled the side of his muzzle before just going still and sitting with him like that.

Her plot felt a little sore, now that the intensity had faded. She felt it was a special sort of earned pleasant feeling of soreness though, the plug already back in place so she could keep all of his essence inside her until she went to bed. Possibly even all the way until morning. The warm feeling of it shooting into her had caught her right as her hoof on her clit had her on the brink and the feeling had sent her crashing over the line.

There was no question now about her upcoming plan. Her mystery stallion had given her every reason and she knew the perfect time was coming soon. Oh gosh, I hope he says yes…

“C-can I ask you something important, my mystery stallion?” Twilight started, part of her glad he couldn’t see her suddenly nervous look.

Even though his exact voice changed every time they met, she was familiar enough with his Guard-typical style of speech to hear more of him in his voice when he spoke, noting his tone was attentive, if still a bit playful. “My oh so sexy mystery mare, you can ask me anything you want. If you have something to say, I’m listening with open ears.”

Twilight bit her bottom lip again, took a breath, then told him her plan. “I… I want to get a joint room with you. Not just so I can feel your forelegs wrapped around me, but so there’s nothing between us. Y-you know I’ve never had sex before, and I-I’m g-going into estrus in two weeks. W-will you help make my first time absolutely perfect? T-to make love to me, and kiss me, and release your semen inside me while letting me look into the face of the stallion I love without the mask as you become one with me?”

She gasped and put her hooves over her mouth when she realized the word that slipped out. Remembering some of the psychology of love, she worried she might be getting carried away on a bunch of unsubstantiated hormones, pheromones and built up fantasies. It wasn’t that she had an actual reason for concern that she could see anywhere so far, but she struggled to believe he could be so perfect a gentlestallion all the time. Maybe it was like becoming Princess Celestia’s student, and her luck was just that good a second time.

Yet with the word slipping out, Twilight knew she was lost anyway and there was no turning back. She couldn’t bear the idea he could be too good to be true, but neither could she stand not looking into his eyes anymore. She needed him to hold her.

Much to her relief, she heard his relaxed tone convey no hesitation. “You really want to… Yes. I want to see you too. You only get one first time, so I’ll do whatever you need me to do in order to make it the best it can be. I…” He paused as if something came to mind, then he gave a warm chuckle. “I’ll even save a certain three words to say at that final moment too. Just to make it even better. So don’t worry about me not saying it back just yet...because I do too.”

A soft laugh that was more like a whimper escaped her throat as she pressed herself into his lips, happy tears threatening to escape as she kissed him. She felt like she was floating now, basking in the feel of his acceptance of her request and his own admission.

Twilight couldn’t stop smiling after their time ended and they had to depart. He said it shouldn’t be a problem to get a full day off. They would reserve a Reveal Room together for a few hours, just so they could take all the time they wanted for buildup, then make their way back to whomever’s home was closest once they finished their first time together, and then spend the rest of the day and much of the night making love until they couldn’t walk straight. From there they could stop meeting in secret and just enjoy being in love, doing all the simple everyday things that couples do together.

I can’t believe how well this has worked out. Princess Celestia always nudges me to be more social. What will she think when I bring my coltfriend with me? Oh gosh, I hope my mystery stallion doesn’t freak out when I take him to meet her… Hehe, and that she doesn’t tease him endlessly. It really feels like nothing could ever go wrong with him…

Ch 3 - Perfect First Timing

Author's Note

Contains: accidental incest, sex-enhancing magic, kissing, cunnilingus, first time, vaginal, estrus sex, creampie directly in womb, panic on verge of unstoppable climax, extremely powerful mutual orgasm

And like all the signs were saying, this was bound to happen... :trollestia:

Ch 3 - Perfect First Timing

Twilight Sparkle stared at the enchanted mask floating in front of her face as she chewed on her bottom lip.

Standing there in the little entry room before stepping into the room she was about to enter and meet her lover in, make love with him for the first time and they would leave knowing who each other was, she felt herself tremble with nervous anticipation. The white light was on and it was time. Even though they had agreed on the plan, the fact she was about to walk in there and share her first time with her mystery stallion was sending delicious tingles all over her body.

If it wasn’t enough just to have everything else going so perfectly, she was lucky enough that she would get to feel him inside her for the first time when she was in the middle of her estrus cycle. Most of the time, a few spells and some herbal tea were all she made use of, just dealing with the remaining discomfort.

Yet on this day, she was panting, feeling her marehood quiver almost to the point of abdominal cramps, now that she’d removed the reduction spells. She had made sure to have a full set of contraceptive spells cast on her by the Blind Date staff physician before stepping into the entry room. She winced a little at a brief cramp, actually relishing the complete lack of mitigating herbs or spells and facing no statistically viable risk of getting impregnated by her lover, though she certainly let herself enjoy the ‘what if’ idea of it. She knew she was going to have her fires quenched as nature intended at last, and on her very first time with a stallion, on top of it. Most mares dream of getting to have it all perfect, and here she was getting to make that fantasy into a real thing.

Twilight wasn’t sure how she was going to reward him for helping her do this just yet, but she’d think of something. Possibly something involving making him orgasm repeatedly, but something.

And although it took a bit of extra study late at night, Twilight had come prepared with some spells she planned to cast on the two of them. She expected he was going to enjoy what she was going to use as she slipped the mask over her face.

***

Shining Armor would have never admitted it out loud, but he was nervous as he stared at the hovering mask before him. And for more things than he would have expected as he glanced at the white light telling him she was ready with trepidation.

Several weeks of meeting with his mysterious mare had gone so incredibly well. She was smart, funny, had an adorable personality and could be so imaginative… Yet he didn’t know her face.

Ever since realizing he had begun to fall in love with her, that simple fact frustrated him more with every passing day. He needed to look at her, see her eyes light up when she smiled for him, feel her body against his own as he held her tight. He realized if she hadn’t asked if they could reveal themselves when she did, he would have.

Then there was the issue of realizing his mysterious mare meant the same to him as his best friend, Cadence. It had been a staggering realization for him, suddenly understanding his feelings for the Princess of Love because of developing feelings for his unknown mare. Cadence had even begun to wear a look split between happy and sad when she thought he wasn’t looking. Shining supposed it made sense if she could detect his love for her had grown, while he was also feeling a growing love for another. They hadn’t talked about it yet, but he could feel that day was coming soon. If for nothing else, he had to talk to Cadence because he needed to be honest with his best friend. Maybe I could talk to Twiley about it. She’s not much for romance, focused on her studies like she is, but it might help to have a more logical outside perspective for how to talk to both of the mares I’m in love with.

With the rest of his thoughts, he wasn’t all that worried about how well he could perform for his mysterious mare. His previous efforts had usually been well received, and he planned to pretty much worship her body today. Stallions like himself were relatively easy to please, so he could set aside the need throbbing beneath him. He wanted to make her call out his name as he made her peak with his cock deep inside her marehood, filling her with his seed in the middle of her estrus. Making her first time unforgettable was his sole mission right now. They could spend the rest of the day later doing all the exploring they wanted, but she was first for this first time.

He stretched his neck, feeling a special kind of nervous excitement over getting to know his mystery mare on several new levels, and slipped on the mask.

***

Both ponies could hear each other breathing after the entry doors shut behind them. Both breathed a bit faster as the anticipation of finally getting full access to each other was becoming reality at last. Both of their masks giving them general outlines of the room’s shape so they could focus on each other, rather than where an unseen bed might lay. It was only going to stay active for five minutes, then leave them both in total blindness as normal.

Shining called out to his mystery mare, his voice a little tense as he began to catch her estrus-drenched scent in a big way, making his cock throb in anticipation. “Hey there, sexy… Are you doing alright and still feel ready for this? How’s my voice today?”

Twilight let out a husky laugh, her tail waving about and quite intentionally fanning her heated scent into the air of the closed room. She wanted him to know how ready she was to have him inside her. Staring at the vague outline of her mystery stallion, a nice virile stallion she knew was going to completely ravish her oh so very soon. A shiver ran down her spine as she realized that actually wouldn’t be enough, she wanted her marehood absolutely wrecked by the time they were done. She licked her lips and gave him a predatory grin he wouldn’t be able to see. “Mmm… You have a nice throaty baritone this time. And I feel comfortable enough to admit I’m tempted to jump at you and just take you on the floor. I’ve never dealt with my estrus without any reducers before. You going to make sure to put my fire out, mister firepony~?”

Shining gave her a heated chuckle, his grin widening as he stepped towards her mostly hidden form. He stopped just before they touched, feeling her breath brush his muzzle as his head came to a stop almost beside hers. “Firepony, huh? Well, I’m sure I can put my hose right where you’re burning the hottest and pump enough inside you to do the job… Before I forget and get lost in your scent and body though, what was the surprise you wanted to do first?”

She let out a happy sigh at his dedication to things she asked of him, nuzzling against the side of his face before pulling back. It was tempting to forget everything but touching him right now. “Not too much. Will you let me cast some sex spells on you before we get started?”

“I… I guess I can agree to that. What did you have in mind?”

Biting her lip for a moment, Twilight just said it all at once. “First, I want to cast a spell that initially makes your semen production increase by a factor of ten or more, as well as activating after climax to make you recover a lot faster, so you can get back in action almost immediately. Then, a spell for both of us that will align the opening of my cervix with your urethra when you’re about to ejaculate, letting you send everything straight into my uterus. Second for both of us is a spell that will be keyed to the same trigger, keeping my hind legs bound around you and yours in place when you get fully hilted and climax inside me.”

Twilight panted as she pressed her nose roughly against her mystery stallion’s own. “For just me is a spell that will keep all of your seed deep inside me. I want it all, stallion. Spray your seed in my womb so I can feel stuffed so full with so much of you inside me that my belly looks swollen with your foal and not one single drop will escape until I’m ready for a new batch.”

For his end, Shining was a little stunned, but it was unbelievably hot the way she growled about keeping his cum locked inside her. He really only had one answer after that. “Honey, cast your spells. Because by the time we’re through, you’ll be struggling to walk for the next month.”

“I hope that’s a promise, stallion.” Twilight said in a low sultry voice as she pulled back. It was difficult to focus while he was touching her and she didn’t want to get the spells wrong. While they weren’t all that difficult, she wasn’t the most clear-headed with how turned on she was. She was glad she hadn’t opted to cast her own contraceptive spells for the same reason. Those were actually quite intricate and not worth risking a mistake.

Then again, if it wasn’t for blunt reality of it being a genuinely bad idea for both of them, she likely would have dispelled all of their protection by this point. If nothing else stopped her, she’d also never break his trust like that, knowing they already agreed not to take any risks in her actually getting pregnant. Despite knowing it was only her estrus messing with her head, she craved the idea of letting him give her a foal. A swollen womb full of the seed he pumped inside her was the closest she could get today.

With the spells cast, she stalked forward with a purr, rubbing the side of her face against his neck as she pressed into him, his scent making her feel a little dizzy now that she didn’t have to resist the urges anymore. She felt and heard him panting as she nuzzled her way up to his ear and gave him a throaty whisper. “Remove our blindfolds when you’re just about to cum so I can look into your eyes, see you for the first time as you tell me you love me and fill me with your love… Otherwise, you may do with me as you will…”

Shining growled as let a shudder run down the length of his spine before he nipped her neck just behind the corner of her jaw, hearing her gasp in response. He lifted her in his magic and set her down on the middle of the bed’s outline on her back. She wasn’t going to be moving away from that spot again for a while if he had anything to say about it.

He saw the outline of her head turned in his direction, seeing the vague image of her hind legs trembling and spreading as he neared. The time for words was over. Her scent was saturating the room now, making his thoughts hazy with need for her. There was just one thing to do first.

His face neared her marehood right as the outline enchantment faded out and left him entirely blind again. Needing only touch and scent to guide him at this point, he could feel the heat of her body radiating as he followed his nose and that heat until he bumped into her marehood, hearing her let out a shaky gasp as his muzzle made contact. A deep inhale right at her core made him hungry.

It was an opportunity he couldn’t pass up, his tongue slipping out and starting to trace her outer folds. They were swollen with her estrus and arousal. The taste of her seemed sharper than usual, the flavor of her estrus making his mouth water. Her whimpers quickly became moans as he gave her a firm lap right between her folds and flicked his tongue off her clit.

Using what he’d learned from her already, he nibbled her soaking marehood and made her writhe against the bed. When her folds winked, he swiped his tongue over her clit and drew out a squeak from his mystery mare. Soon enough, his hooves had her spread open as he slid his tongue around inside her, feeling her forehooves on his head and holding him against her, trying to grind herself against his tongue.

Twilight couldn’t take it anymore and pulled her mystery stallion up over her body, feeling his mouth slip away from her quivering entrance that needed something else now. He took the hint and let her lead him. When he paused at the right position, she was about to practically demand he rut her, but his lips connected with hers and silenced her voice as she whined.

She felt his cock rubbing against her stomach, again getting ready to speak when he shifted his body and touched his tip against her burning entrance before breaking the kiss. Twilight felt him pause as her anticipation built, then slowly began to push his flare against her folds, feeling herself starting to spread open for him.

A low groan escaped them both as the tip of his cock finally entered her most sacred of places at long last. Pulling him forward in her need, her mouth opened in a silent exclamation as his length slowly sank farther and farther inside her wanting body. A gasp escaped as his medial ring slipped into her sensitive core, her sopping folds were so ready there was no resistance to slow his progress.

When she felt him sink inside to the hilt, at the same time his tip grazed the entrance of her womb, she found herself struggling to breathe. Her plot was one thing, but her marehood was far more sensitive under normal arousal. Her estrus-stricken body kept trying to tug him further inside as her inner muscles winked against him over and over. His lips stole her breath away as he held himself fully inside for the first time, both of them savoring their shared new connection. She lashed his tongue with her own as her legs wrapped around him, almost torn on keeping him so deep inside her versus letting him start to thrust.

The choice was soon settled as she felt him slowly draw back, then begin to thrust back inside her, scraping at her already sensitive nerves. She marveled at the feel of his flare sliding through her core, able to feel the position of it so clearly with each thrust. His medial ring made her gasp every time it slipped back into her body.

Shining panted from the feel of his mystery mare clenching around his cock, feeling her winking passage constantly trying to coax him back inside to the hilt. When he had first slipped fully inside her, it felt like her marehood was almost trying to swallow him like her throat, letting him know exactly how much she wanted him to pour himself inside her.

Each time he drew back for another thrust, it felt like he couldn’t let quite as much of his shaft slip out as the previous time, feeling a growing need to stay buried as deep inside of her as he could. He had started with slow thrusts, but now he was following a steady rhythm. By the time he was only drawing back just far enough for his medial ring to slip free, then thrusting fully back inside, she was whimpering as she tried to meet his every thrust. He began following the lead of her clenching tunnel a bit more, trying to pull back when she squeezed to get him deeper, then thrust back in as she relaxed and her inner resistance was down, which frequently drew a out breathy squeak from getting stuffed the moment she relaxed.

Soon, he was hardly pulling back as he thrust as deep as he could inside her overheated body, feeling her tugging at him with her legs and her marehood, begging for more as he ground against her with firm pressure. Frantic kisses and the rising tension in both their bodies told them both their lovemaking was bringing them close.

Twilight was wondering how he could cause such pleasure when she felt him starting to flare at last, clinging to her stallion in desperate need. It felt like she was climaxing already with how good it all felt because of her estrus, but she knew she was still only building up. And knowing he was getting close himself, she let herself gasp with every tap of his flaring tip against the entrance of her womb, eager to feel him finally release within her and fill her womb with his essence for the first time. The first of many, many more times to come.

“Nrgh… Gonna remove… the blindfolds…” Her mystery stallion spoke in a strained voice, letting her know it was time. She felt herself clamp down on his cock even harder at his words.

“Nnnf, hah… T-touch your horn to mine! Make it perfect as you make me yours!” Twilight exclaimed, feeling his nose and horn press against her own shortly after, his thrusts ramming as firmly inside her as he could, his flare growing. The two of them quickly muttered the deactivation phrase for their blindfolds to prepare for the moment.

At long last, Shining’s magic made the blindfolds fly away from their faces, softly smiling as their eyes locked on each other for the first time as they spoke in unison. “I love… You?!”

The whole world seemed to suddenly slow to a near stop as two minds thought the same counterpart thought, their eyes starting to widen in shock.

Shiny?!

Twily?!

Twilight felt herself jump at a dozen ideas at once as her horn charged, simultaneously trying to push him away, wake herself up, teleport to her bedroom, teleport him to the moon, teleport herself to the moon…

Her scrambled attempt only succeeded in making her magic fizzle out with a small burst of magenta sparks, which in turn caused three things to happen in an instant as a result. Her normally swift mind realized her mistake a moment too late.

The effect of such a charge shorting out caused her horn to tingle and her magic incapable of forming a spell for at least the next hour. The direct path to the brain also frazzles the caster’s nervous system and leaves them extremely sensitive to every physical sensation for a full minute for the average unicorn, which Twilight knew worked tenfold for her. And since her horn was touching Shining’s during the fizzle, she had also caused the exact same effect in him at the same time.

Suddenly, she could actually feel her spells start to activate with specific tingles of magic, everything moving in slow motion.

She felt her cervix being tugged into place against the flaring head of his shaft deep inside her, then forced to spread open by a quarter inch in preparation for his coming seed, her entire path inside left clear for him to fill her with ease. Her attempt to pull her hind legs away was thwarted as her hooves were already magically stuck holding onto him, and succeeded only in pulling him even deeper inside, the opening of his tip pressing tighter to the entrance of her womb.

Twilight felt like she was floating, her every sensation overwhelming with the heightened intensity of everything. Her brother’s scent enveloping her, his warm breath entering her lungs as he exhaled, the bed holding her up for him as his weight pressed against her, the heat of his body over her, and so very deep inside her.

All she could do was squeeze her forelegs around his neck and stare into her big brother’s eyes as he began to climax inside of her, his expanded flare spreading her open at her deepest. Due to her slower perception of time in their shared moment, she could even feel the underside of his cock swell as his first burst of cum travelled down his shaft, on it’s way to pour straight into her ready body as that swelling squeezed past the last feeble defense of her desperately clamping folds and sped down her tunnel towards the now spread entrance of her waiting, wanting womb.

Her primed-for-orgasm nerves were on the edge as she felt the burning heat of his cum escape his flare in a powerful jet that seemed to go on forever, searing it’s way through her cervix and surging directly into her womb. An extra tingle just as that first pulse finished flowing into her said her last spell activated to keep every drop of his seed locked deep inside the very place her estrus-stricken body craved it most. Her world seemed to implode as her whole consciousness centered on him spraying that torrent of his essence so deep inside her core.

A rising wail tore out of her throat as her brother’s seed entering her estrus-primed core sent her careening helplessly over the edge. An orgasm she’d never have imagined ripped it’s way through her body, her widening eyes unable to tear themselves away from those of her big brother. She saw the stunned, helpless look in his narrowing eyes, heard his voice exclaim his own orgasm.

Shining couldn’t even react as he felt his climax hit so hard it was on the borderline of pain, feeling himself launch an oversized burst of his virile seed straight into Twilight’s waiting womb. He knew she’d miscast by his frayed nerves, and unable to stop himself as instinct made him push still deeper inside his sister as her hind legs pulled him in tighter, her body tensing in ecstasy. As he cried out, he felt the second pulse of cum rush down the length of his cock and escape, struggling to fathom how it could feel so voluminous as he filled Twilight with every twitch of his spurting shaft.

The two of them came together, eyes locked on each other as their minds were quickly overtaken with every jet he gave her. By the time Twilight felt the fourth burning pulse of Shining’s cum spray past her cervix, her mind was melting. As Shining felt the fifth surge of his seed escape into Twilight, he entirely forgot where he was. By the time the sixth surge of cum transferred from his cock and into her womb, all they could still comprehend was that the pony they loved was there with them, sharing everything with them.

Somewhere along the way, their lips met and they couldn’t stop grinding against each other. Shining pressed against her just as he fired each jet into his mare in an effort to satisfy her estrus, with Twilight feeling almost like a fresh orgasm had started every time her stallion sent more of his burning seed through her cervix to where she needed it most. The only thing they could process, the only thing they could manage to think, was that they writhed together in the pleasure that the pony they loved had given them.

When the euphoria finally began to wind down, it was all they could do to simply let their muscles go slack, unable to move as they struggled to recover from a climax that seared through their bodies. Every twitch and throb of their deeply connected bodies was like an electric shock and a new orgasm on its own. The extreme sensitivity was slowly fading away as they trembled in a staggeringly powerful afterglow that felt more like hanging in a constant euphoric state akin to a normal climax, yet without the tension. Their minds were simply blank as they drifted through what had happened, helplessly carried along until it would reach its end.

Their shared first time had been so powerful, they struggled just to breathe as they weakly clung to each other. Both felt their nerves tingling across their bodies, with the most intensity coming from where they remained joined. Random weak pulses of Shining’s cum were still occasionally feeding into Twilight’s still greedy womb. Each little burst making them flinch and shudder, causing his magic-touched loins to rush the building of another before a tugging clench of her marehood soon triggered him to fire once more and start them over again.

By complete accident, they had experienced something similar to a very advanced unicorn sex technique, and were entirely unprepared to process the experience.

Ch 4 - Taking Today By Risking Tomorrow

Author's Note

Contains: incest, intimately trapped, unavoidable cumming inside during estrus, impregnation risk, impregnation play, modest cum inflation

Ok, this chapter is downright gratuitous. The story description says in the Story Contains paragraph "Sex. Lots of sex." and here's a good chunk of it. Next chapter still has sex, though the drama tag will really start to kick in, but only after this pile of excess.

Have to wonder what readers are thinking will happen after this... :trollestia:

Ch 4 - Taking Today By Risking Tomorrow

An indeterminable amount of period of time passed before Twilight finally managed a vaguely coherent, rather delirious whisper, her mind still floating as a forehoof rubbed around the side of her stomach, absently wondering if she could detect the results of her tight-feeling womb on the outside. “Oh Shiny, you left me feeling so full… You feel so good inside me… Every time more of your semen was sent into my uterus, it burned so hot I thought I was going to melt! It all still feels so warm…”

Her brother nuzzled her in a daze, his mostly hard cock already had signs of fresh life as he began to firm back up inside her marehood. Making a slow attempt, Shining discovered he couldn’t pull away, despite feeling the limp hold of her hind legs around him that somehow managed not to fall away. Lacking a choice in his current exhaustion, he settled back down against her, what little part of him that he’d slipped from her just sank back inside her as she cooed and squeezed down on him again. He spoke in a soft, weary tone, his nose rubbing just below her ear. “We’ve really messed things up, Twily. Why can’t I pull away so I can, uh, remove myself from you?”

With her mind starting to clear, Twilight tenderly rubbed her forehooves over her brother’s ribs as she tried to stop her body from clenching around his shaft. Sniffling as tears slowly began to slip from her eyes, she tried to keep herself calm and her voice steady. “I know… M-me fizzling our magic that hard probably rattled the spells. Nothing dangerous or bad should have happened, but from what seems most likely with the signs I’m starting to notice already, they appear to stay triggered for now, stuck on active… And I-I can’t do anything to fix or undo them until m-my magic is working again.”

Seeing his sister start to cry, Shining found himself refocusing faster and licked her cheek with gentle compassion, then kissing her temple. He tried not to think about how he was restored to full strength inside her without his even trying, or the tingle he felt each time her tunnel shifted around him, let alone the occasional clenching pull of her body wanting even more of his essence. “Hey now, we’ll get through this, ok? I’m not going to turn you away or something because of this. Neither of us knew. It’s hard now, but we just need time to figure this out.”

Twilight nuzzled her brother, feeling his cock beginning to twitch with a fully restored arousal already. She began to suspect the stamina spell she’d used was stuck in a constant active state, too. If that was the case, then for possibly over an hour, unable to tell how long the two of them had been trapped in that overwhelmed euphoria they’d shared, she couldn’t use her magic and undo the spells keeping them so intimately pressed together. In that time, he would have only a couple seconds of refractory period, then immediately start to build up again. She also knew that the way it worked, he’d either get increasingly aroused, or far more likely, wind up climaxing inside of her again just from her own rhythmic squeezing because of her estrus.

A quick factoring of variables, she realized Shining would probably cycle through recovery and release at least four to eight more times within the first hour they were going to be stuck together, assuming the stamina spell wasn’t also altered on the strength of the effect. Even at the level she’d cast it, her womb really would be quite swollen with a stallion’s seed, her own brother’s seed, by the time she could fix the spells and they were able to separate. Just the single load of semen he already gave her had left her uterus feeling tight. A perverse part of her mind knew she was more than a little intrigued at what she’d feel with far more inside her.

After she had some time to go over everything in her mind, occasionally pausing as her clenching nethers around his shaft made her quiver, she knew the only thing they could do was wait out the fizzle. At several points, it was a conscious effort on her part not to start rolling her hips as her estrus gradually made her more aroused. A ready stallion was already inside her, her estrus indifferent to who it was, and keeping her mind clear was a challenge. Twilight swallowed back an urge to whimper, though from stress or raw arousal, she couldn’t even tell. Realizing the inevitability they were faced with, and the very short list of choices left to her, there was only one viable course of action left in her mind.

Twilight knew it made no practical difference to their situation now, and at least they could have this one experience. She stopped trying restrain her marehood as her tunnel tugged eagerly at his rigid, twitching shaft. Her hormone-laden body certainly had no hesitations over seeking more of his seed, indifferent to the source. A faint pleasured moan slipped out as she focused on the heat of him laying so deep within her body, how good it felt to be almost surrounded even as he left her feeling full with his buried length.

She turned her eyes to him, but he’d have to lift his head for her to look into his face, rubbing her cheek against his head and neck. “Shining, just make love to me for now. We’ll have to worry about what to do later.”

His head lifted up so he could stare at her in disbelief. “Twily, haven’t we done enough?”

She sniffled again and gave him a tremulous smile. “It’s the stamina spell I gave you. If my calculations are right, I don’t think it shut down after restoring your erection. I’m pretty sure it’s stuck on active, too. That means it won’t matter how good you are at holding yourself back while you’re inside me. I can’t stop my estrus from trying to stimulate you, and the spell will keep making your arousal stronger until you can’t resist anymore and the smallest brush will make you release. It could be an hour or longer before the fizzle ends. By the time just that first hour is up, you will be putting even more of your semen inside me.” Twilight paused and took a shaky breath, feeling more turned on by the second. “At least four more times, maybe even eight times, assuming it takes around a full hour and my math is right. You will be ejactulating inside me with enhanced semen volume several more times before we’re done. If it’s running stronger than I set it, who knows how much of your love I’ll have sealed away inside me when we’re done…”

Shining winced, then began to look much more worried. “Wait, if those spells were messed up… Twilight, what about the contraceptive spells?”

A soft, resigned laugh escaped her mouth. Twilight let out a gasp as she gave in the rest of the way, openly squeezing her marehood around his shaft with full intent and desire. She let herself enjoy how her estrus was being agitated by having such a ready stallion buried inside of her, her body knowing more seed would fill her soon, and it was making her own arousal continue to rise. “Shiny, the damage is already done either way. While the separate magical resonance of another pony’s spells is less likely to be affected by a fizzle like that, it doesn’t change the fact we can’t separate or use any magic right now. And my uterus is already filled with your semen as it is, or with you being unable to avoid adding more. You won’t be making anything any worse by making love to me until the fizzle ends and I don’t want to spend all that time panicking when it won’t matter either way. I’ll check the spells when my magic works again. For now at least… C-can you…”

Twilight swallowed the lump in her throat, a vulnerable look in her eyes as she met his gaze. “I love you, BBBFF. And I know you love me. Not just as siblings, but as my lover. My stallion. We both know it’s true. Whether we admit it out loud or not. We can figure out how to deal with this later. Spike is even staying at the castle until tomorrow so we’re completely free. Right now, just love me, Shiny. This will probably be the one and only time we can ever just let go and enjoy being with each other like this without anything left to hold us back or worrying about what might go wrong. Nothing will change the fact that it’s all done for us already now. Let’s just continue with our original plan before we gave up the masks and spend the rest of our time here making love to each other. My apartment is closer and set apart. We can head there after we can separate and leave, then just talk this out there. M-maybe even let ourselves finish the plan we started, keep making love for most of the night and then talk in the morning, I-I don’t know. J-just…”

She began to tremble as she laid herself bare, her voice only a pained whisper. “I’m in full estrus, big brother. It might be too late by the time I can check and I’ll already be pregnant because of you. For now, just make love to me. Let go and share this perfect fantasy with me, like you’re trying to put your foal inside your mare because you’re the stallion I love with all my heart. Right now, I’m young and fertile and receptive and I need you. Shining, for both of us… Just this once…”

Staring up at him with pleading eyes, Twilight voiced her desperate desire.

“Breed me…”

Shining Armor felt his cock lurch inside his sister, his mouth opening and closing as he tried to argue, but try as he might to tell her otherwise, he found there was nothing for him to say. He wanted to deny it, to say she was wrong, yet between being trapped by malfunctioning spells and unable to avoid knowing he’d fallen in love with his sister that way too, the words of denial never formed. If it was just raw physical lust, he might have had the strength to resist, but he knew it was so much more than that. He swallowed the lump in his throat as his eyes misted, what few arguments he managed to think of were all crumbling away as his sister’s body, a mare he truly loved, tried to encourage him to release in her again.

It wasn’t long before his eyes softened completely, looking at the mare he had unknowingly fallen in love with, yet had also known and loved since the day she was born. He was trapped on several levels, admitting to himself that his growing level of arousal said he was indeed going to burst inside her again either way, then realizing he wasn’t even really resisting it anymore.

He realized his Twily needed him. She had needed her big brother to take care of her and help her with plenty of things in the past, and now she needed him to help her through her estrus. Her womb was needing more of his seed to calm, and she was begging him to give her more. If what he already gave her wasn’t enough, he would make sure so much of his essence was inside her that her estrus would be sated twice over!

Tossing the last of his resistance aside, he gave himself over to the only chance for this fantasy that they would probably ever have. Grinding against the still held open entrance of her deepest core with the head of his cock, he focused on the idea that his lover needed him to put his foal inside her belly, to satisfy her estrus by being impregnated by her stallion.

His lips pressed against hers as he pulled her in, slowly rocking against her as she gasped into his mouth. He felt her tremble and roll her body back against him in counterpoint to his thrusts, making it clear her body needed more of him filling her to calm her rampant need.

Twilight panted as she felt her brother give in and begin to thrust himself inside her core once more, her legs keeping a gentle grip on him. He could only withdraw himself from her marehood by an inch or so before the spell keeping their legs in position prevented him going further, then he slid himself back inside her to press against the open entrance of her deepest door.

She let herself stop caring that it was her brother inside her, even let it excite her further now, nerves tingling as she held him against her. The feel of his muscles moving in a steady pace, the sound of his breathing as her eyes fell closed as she let her head lay back. He was slowly rocking her back and forth with unhurried passion, and she reveled in the feel of it.

It wasn’t long before Shining began to flare inside her for the second time, causing Twilight to tremble in anticipation. When he thrust himself as far into her marehood as he could reach, she felt him start pulsing deep inside her, and more heat flowed past her cervix. She let out a squeal as it pushed her over the edge, the tightness in her womb growing a little as he added more to what was already contained within. Even in her oversensitive state after her climax, she whined in need as he began to move again and craving the intensity, the strength in his cock seemed to return even faster this time.

Shining pressed his nose to her throat as he worked his buried length in Twilight. It was a strange sort of state as he filled his sister again, yet needing to give her his love so much he couldn’t even stay still for very long after he came a second time. Drawing those soft gasps out of her mouth became his focus, her orgasimic squeals his constant goal. His forehooves held her in place so she wouldn’t slide forward, letting him push with firm strength each time he hilted inside her on every slow thrust.

The two of them strained together for one climb towards orgasm after another, with only Twilight’s own arousal free to escape and soak into the white silk bedsheets beneath them. As she had promised, every drop of Shining’s seed was kept locked deep inside her body.

Somewhere along the way, their lips met again and their tongues danced together in similar movements to their bodies, sweat earned in passion clinging to their coats. Their manes were soon damp and clumped together strands occasionally getting pushed aside from time to time. Even when they fell out of synch, they usually stared into each other’s eyes when one of them peaked, needing to see their lover’s pleasure as it happened.

When the chime sounded in the air, they finally found a reason to pause. Their four hour reservation had passed almost unnoticed, Shining making the last few thrusts to another plateau and giving Twilight another round of his seed for her still hungry womb. He relished the tired squeal that escaped her, feeling her insides twitch with each burst he gave her. Going still, he let her have some time to recover. It was just a ten minute warning for clients to know their session was almost over.

Twilight laid her head back as her orgasm faded, letting herself work on catching her breath again. She had lost count how many times her brother made her cum, or how many times he had cum inside her. The very notion of interrupting their shared passion to check if her magic was functioning again had been forgotten entirely until the chime sounded. Part of her wondered how he could still be pressed against her the same way, given how full her womb felt. A forehoof lazily moved down to the side of her stomach, partly just to feel her brother’s fur in another spot, and found her belly was tight, but did not seem to be externally swollen. A bit of pressure told her it was right on the edge of visible in the same way she might have been at three months pregnant. Having lost herself to the fantasy, it made her shudder and squeeze his cock again, feeling him twitch and signal his shaft was almost ready to start yet another round.

As much as she didn’t want to stop, she did realize it was necessary. She gave her brother a firm kiss, without tongue, before a helpless look came to her features. “Ok, let me fix the spells I cast that are keeping us stuck together first. I want to focus more before I try to do anything else. It’s really hard to focus on anything but you when I can almost feel your heartbeat inside me.”

Shining gave her a small nod, keeping still, and Twilight carefully drew on her magic.

A few seconds later, she fixed the two spells keeping their legs bound to each other’s body, then the one keeping her cervix held open against his tip. With a nod to him, Twilight couldn’t help the powerful shudder and gasp as his cock stimulated her nerves in ways he hadn’t been able to for hours. She was half-tempted to order him to slip back inside, already missing his presence more than expected, but knew they had to get going soon.

Before she could speak after the sudden rush of new sensations had passed, Shining’s hoof touched her lips and she looked at him in confusion, seeing him give her a tender smile.

“Twily, before you say a word, I want you to understand something… We can’t get today back, no matter what we do. Check the spells and fix anything that needs it, but don’t tell me what the truth is. If everything is actually fine, or if you’re already pregnant and there’s nothing to stop it now, we can deal with everything tomorrow morning.”

He smiled in a way that made Twilight’s heart flutter as his eyes misted. “Right now, I am going to take the mare I love back to her place. We are going to get some food together, then make slow love while we feed each other so we can keep our energy up. Then I’m going to spend the rest of the afternoon and most of the night trying to give my mare a foal. I am going to send so much of my seed into your womb that you will look eight or nine months pregnant by the time we’re done. I will see my mare looking beautiful with my foal inside her, or as close to it as I can get. To be honest, part of me is even torn on asking you to forget about the contraceptive spells entirely and keep yourself uncertain, too. To let yourself not know if it’s too late, or if the next time I breed you is the climax that makes our foal a reality. Do what you need to for yourself, but let me keep the uncertainty we can’t get back.”

Twilight stared at her brother, lungs heaving by the time he was done speaking as tears threatened to fall from her eyes. She smacked his hoof to the side and crashed against his lips with her own as she rose, giving her stallion a deep kiss. For a long moment, all she could do was hold still, lips pressed to his, struggling with her desire to simply pull him back on top of her.

Finally pulling back, Twilight sniffled and gave her big brother a shaky smile. “Alright then. Let me have a moment to check the things I need to and we’ll head for my place. We’ll have to go separately and I need to be waiting when you arrive. You could pick up some food and anything else you think we might want on the way. That would take care of everything we’d need to delay for.”

Seeing him nod, Twilight closed her eyes and focused on the spells on both of them. She removed the stamina spell on him, then the one that lined up their parts for him to have a straight path through her cervix. They could be recast later. She did take the time to cast something that would relieve the uncomfortable tension of her being stretched by what she kept sealed in her body, and the same spell would later allow her belly comfortably stretch as far as a full term pregnancy, if necessary. The more she thought of the idea, the more she needed to make it happen.

If they could only do all of this once, she wasn’t going to hold back on any of it.

Opening her eyes as she rolled off the bed and stood, Twilight looked at her belly and saw there was only the faintest visible sign of the mass of cum hidden inside her womb, as if she’d merely had a hefty meal. Her bags would make it impossible to spot on the way to her apartment. Her nostrils flared, eagerly looking forward to the two of them making it impossible to miss over the coming hours ahead. And that nopony but Shining would get to see her so completely swollen with her brother’s essence. Her nethers tingled at the thought.

And from knowing she decided not to check the contraceptive spells…

“Let’s get out of here, Shiny.”

***

Close to an hour later, Twilight Sparkle and Shining Armor had finished eating, the pair now in her bedroom and making use of her bed for the first time.

The time to calm and think a bit more left them deciding to just eat relatively quick at the table in a flimsy reach for the fantasy that they were living together, and it was just a normal meal with their special somepony. Neither really believed it of course, but both confessed it hurt knowing the morning meant it all had to end. Regardless of the possible results of how their accidental encounter brought them to this point, morning meant facing reality, and being forced to walk away. To try to forget they’d fallen in love and return to the normal kind of relations between brother and sister.

They admitted they weren’t sure how they could even begin to do such a thing and really hoping time helped.

Twilight stood over her brother as he lay on his back, staring up at her with a sly smile in the middle of her own bed. She had recast the stamina spell on Shining, but they both decided it would be more fun to leave it stuck on active again, rather than having it only function to reduce his recovery. The spell to align her cervix with his urethra shortly before his climax was renewed, then the one that would keep him hilted inside her when either peaked, though both spells would function as originally intended this time.

Aside from checking the integrity, she didn’t need to do anything with the one that kept his essence locked inside her still needy womb, much to her relief. She relished the knowledge that every last drop of of his virile seed was put inside her so effectively that her cervix was the first part of her body it had touched as Shining bred her multiple times earlier, the rest of her tunnel was still untouched by his cum.

A small shiver passed through her when she thought that maybe after she felt he bred her womb directly enough, she’d have him make a mess of her tunnel a few times as well. She only had this one time to let him ravage her in every way, after all.

She was even tempted to have him spray his seed over every single part of her body until she was nearly swimming in his essence, to let him mark her and claim her whole self as his mare alone. He already claimed her mouth, her plot, and her womb. Her heated stare bored directly into his eyes as she felt his tip touch the entrance of her sodden tunnel, only slight pressure was needed before the head slipped easily back inside her where his shaft belonged.

Twilight found she wanted her brother to know she owned his cock, and all the seed it could pour inside her. That no matter what else happened after they were forced apart, not one single mare after her would ever have more command of his arousal. And after an earlier confession he made to her as they shared their meal, Shining would know his former virginity on all levels was sprayed into her body. He would know his first time having sex was sealed by shooting his entire load directly inside his own sister’s receptive womb. She felt herself clamp down on his shaft, trying to coax him to give her more of his wonderfully warm, delicious cum as soon as possible. First, he’d fill her womb until she was thoroughly sated, and all but certainly impregnated with his foal. Then, she would swallow his length whole, make him completely fill her stomach with her new favorite meal as he begged her for more. And then she would slide him into her plot to cum deep in her bowels until…

“Uh, Twilight? You have a rather intense look on your face. You ok?” Shining spoke with a mixture of concern and lust, feeling Twilight’s marehood convulsing around him in a way that made it quite easy to perceive her estrus-driven needs. “You want to just skip dessert and get started or…?”

Shining watched his sister’s face explode with a blush so intense, he wondered if she was managing to change her fur color, her hooves coming up to cover her face as she peeked down at him, even as she continued to grind on his dick as it spread her open within. A faint squeak escaped as the closest sound to a response, though she couldn’t stop staring him in the eye and only seemed to squeeze her inner muscles even tighter.

Finally, after Twilight’s gyrations had grown enough she was likely moments away from starting to bounce on the length buried inside her, she managed to speak in a strained, lust-soaked voice. “We’re… Ah~! Going to get to, nnf… Dessert after you breed me again, Shining. M-my estrus needs more of you warming me up inside first… Mmm…”

With that, she let herself begin sliding up and down his cock, whining faintly and pressing her cervix against his tip with each drop of her body. Shining didn’t even try to reply as he placed his forehooves against her cutie marks to help her move with less effort. It wasn’t long before Twilight could feel his flare expanding, soon unable to do more than grind his tip against her deepest entrance, her spells activating to ensure everything he had would go right where it belonged.

She squealed and arched her back as the distinctive heat of his seed burned through her gate and into her core again, her tunnel squeezing and tugging like it was trying to draw his entire body in, coaxing more cum out of Shining. The sound of his gasp as he came inside her for the first time in her own room, on her own bed, their eyes locked on each other again, all of it came together to make her body shudder, her legs shaking as she collapsed on his chest, his last couple of spurts escaping his cock and entering her swelling womb.

A few errant twitches in her muscles aside, Twilight felt much more relaxed now and let out a content sigh. “Mmm… I needed that, Shiny. I… I’m letting myself simply give in to everything my estrus wants now, and wow, is it ever making me more turned on than I’ve ever been. I wouldn’t even object to you just spending the next several hours doing nothing but spraying cum inside me. Just letting you settle in on my back and not stopping…”

Shining Armor smirked, feeling his cock already reviving because of the stamina spell, even as Twilight was still getting over her orgasmic twitches. “If you want to do that, we can, but I know you wanted to spend time trying out anything we can think of before morning. Still want to enjoy some slow lovemaking as we feed each other the chunks of fruit in our dessert?”

Twilight quivered and nuzzled her brother, a content smile on her face. “I’d like that. Lay on your side with me so we can enjoy you sliding back and forth inside me without straining? I want to feel you cum inside me in every way I can.”

He let out a short laugh before catching her lips in a kiss, holding her close as he rolled to one side, keeping himself well inside her.

The two of them fed each other occasional pieces of fruit as they made love together, acting like lovers that had known each other intimately for years. With every climax they shared or gave to their partner, Shining hilting so his entire orgasm could be sent into her womb, Twilight’s belly swelled just a tiny bit larger.

The fruit was eaten along the way, everything else forgotten as they strained over and over, just seeking to give each other the next climax. It was a rare moment Shining’s cock was more than halfway out of her marehood, with most every shared peak only a few minutes apart.

As the sky was going dark outside, Twilight waddled slightly as she stepped into her shower, her brother right behind her. Her womb had enough of his seed inside that she looked around six months pregnant now. She cooed as Shining began to wash her, his attentions unhurried and intimate. They had no intention of staying clean though, fully intending to try lovemaking in the shower after they cleaned each other and some appropriate buildup. Soon, they eyed each other in the falling water, eager for the fun part.

“Do you like seeing your mare’s belly growing because of what you did, Shiny? To see me carrying your foal inside me?” Twilight’s voice was seductive, her wet mane stuck against her form as water ran down her body, posing for her brother’s gaze with a teasing smile. She relished every bit of their shared fantasy that she could get.

Shining snorted, giving her an amorous stare and grin as he broke eye contact to nibble along her neck and down her spine, earning a small whimper. “You look beautiful with part of me there inside you. So beautiful that I need to have you again. Right now. I need to make sure we’re ready to go again right after our foal is born. To put another one in your womb as soon as you’re receptive to my seed again. You love being my broodmare, don’t you Twily? Feeling my hot seed entering your womb during your estrus, knowing you’re all mine to breed…”

Feeling him nip her dock, Twilight let out a sharp gasp. “Yes~! Breed me again, big brother! Make sure I can’t forget who is the only stallion allowed to put foals inside me!”

Despite playing along with the shared fantasy they planned out, Shining was mentally laughing at the things they were saying, even as he used his magic to make sure her tail was laying along her back and trapped beneath him as he moved up to mount her. He could feel her shudder as the head of his cock found her entrance and sank inside, her marehood winking against him before he could reposition and thrust fully into her body again, the action drawing a moan from his needy mare.

For a moment, he just relished the feeling of being inside of Twilight again. The internal ripples of movement she made up and down his cock without even moving could probably get him to orgasm if he gave himself enough time. Standing there in the watery cascade of warm water falling over their bodies, he did his best to commit the moment to memory like he had done several times already. The feel of her head angled so he could nuzzle her cheek from behind, the way his forelegs were positioned around the swollen shape of her belly…

He kissed her cheek before his teeth found her ear and latched onto it, earlier experiments revealing it helped quite a bit to excite her even further. Then he began to make slow thrusts into her body.

Twilight made soft gasps as she felt her brother mount her with purpose, inner muscles clenching on his invading shaft when he growled in her ear and made a particularly firm thrust. Her eyes stayed shut as she felt her forelegs getting weak, feeling him get a little deeper inside her as she lowered her front half to the tiled shower floor. Even if she didn’t have spells for it, her position would have ensured everything he was going to give her would be kept deep inside. The position also sparked new feelings of submission. The feel of him thrusting down into her body and tapping her cervix was stirring her up more and more, knowing the feeling of him sending fresh pulses of semen into her womb would set her off hard again.

Feeling himself starting to flare, Shining increased his thrusts, making Twilight’s form shake each time he crashed against her to hilt his cock deep inside her body again. He rubbed his hoof over her enlarged belly, savoring the idea of her being full of foal. The uncertainty of not knowing if the next time he bred her could mean she might actually end up pregnant because of him kept sounding less terrible in his mind.

He knew a part of him loved her entirely as a mare, and wanted to fill her until his seed found her egg cell and ensured it was fertilized by him. As he panted and neared his climax, he told himself he wouldn’t stop until morning, to put enough inside her that her estrus would end overnight.

Shining used his own magic to play with her clit, pushing his cock as far down into her body as he could reach as his climax rose, even feeling her cervix kiss the opening of his tip, almost like her womb was begging to be bred.

Both of them came at the same time as his cum shot straight into her swollen core, their orgasmic cries mingling with the sound of the shower. Twilight’s squeezing passage encouraged him to fire numerous large ropes of seed inside her, adding more to the volume he had already filled her with. Every new position or method brought a new variation of climax, as well as leaving her just a little more sensitive than before.

Twilight found herself hoping her brother worked her into such a state that all she could do was cum on his cock and watch her belly swell with so much of his gift being locked deep inside. She thrilled in not knowing if the next time he burst inside her would be the one that ensured she carried his foal. To have the one she loved leave that kind of gift inside her. She demanded another dose of his seed before they had even finished drying off, squealing as he made her go off again, thrilling at the feel of more of his essence flowing into her.

On and on they went, straining together in various ways. Shining rarely slipped out of her marehood other than for position changes, and spent most of his time inside her hilted, teasing her cervix as he attempted to bring her another orgasm, while he built up the next one of his own.

By the time it was late into the night and they agreed on one last round of slower, more romantic lovemaking, Twilight had reached a point she looked ready to give birth any day now. So much of her brother’s seed was inside her bloated womb, she looked every bit as pregnant as their shared fantasy role play could have wanted.

Laying on their sides, spooned together as Shining made slow thrusts, Twilight experienced a modest orgasm every couple of times he hilted. Her marehood appeared unable to get enough, the constant winking against his shaft tried to press him against her inner gate and not let go.

Her hoof was holding one of Shining’s own against her swollen belly, her voice husky as she tried to drive herself onto his cock with each thrust he made. “Do you love knowing you put this in here, Shiny? That you put your foal in me even as you get ready to cum inside me again? You love impregnating me, don’t you Shiny? You love knowing your own sister only lets her big brother’s cock inside her body, knowing you came inside my womb and bred me, that I was begging for your seed to quell the craving of my estrus…”

Shining heard her let out a small whine as another orgasm rippled through her, feeling her marehood tugging at his shaft, her body still trying to pull even more of his seed into her. After staying hilted through her pleasured shudders, he went back to making slow thrusts as he drew back to his medial ring, then thrust back inside to the hilt and touching her cervix again, nibbling just behind her ear as he continued to work her over as he rubbed her swollen middle.

“I do love knowing you’re fat with foal, Twily. I love knowing how much of me is inside you, how much more is going to be inside you. And you love feeling me pouring my thick, potent, virile, seed,” Shining punctuated each word with a firm hump against her cervix, “directly into your fertile, receptive womb. You crave the feeling of me breeding you like a proper mare, don’t you? My own sister, so desperate for her brother’s cum to splash into her unprotected body, knowing I’m the only stallion you want when you’re in estrus. So desperate, you can’t stop orgasming on my cock and knowing you’re going to lose your mind when I burst inside your already pregnant body again…”

Twilight whimpered as she felt his thrusts drive her to another peak, but not stopping to let her ride through it now. He just kept filling her with his endless, slow, steady thrusts and making her orgasm last longer, her spasming folds trying to suck him in deeper. A nip at the base of her ear where she was particularly sensitive made her gasp, another orgasm already starting before the last one had finished.

Hearing a change in his breathing and his cock starting to swell, Twilight panted as she arched her back, trying to get more of his cock inside, hardly aware she was speaking as she rode a now continuous orgasm. “Yes, Shiny! Do it! Oh Celestia, g-get me pregnant!”

Shining growled, resisting the temptation to speed up his slow thrusts and feeling her constant spasms working at his cock in an effort to get his seed. His flare was starting to expand inside her and he knew it wouldn’t be long.

“Ah~! I don’t care anymore! I want your foal, Shiny! Rut your sister and cum inside me!”

Feeling the urge rising, Shining let himself give into the need and thrust with sudden speed, a smacking sound heard with each plunge inside. The rising volume of her voice and his rapidly approaching climax were making it hard to do more than deep thrusts, the head of his cock bumping firmly against her cervix each time. He just needed…

“I never checked the spells! Oh Celestia! Shiny, you’re going to impregnate meeee~!!”

He slammed his cock inside her to the hilt as he bit down on the back of her neck and mane, hooves pulling her down as his tip jammed against her cervix. His flare swelled just as Twilight’s spell made her womb open for the first jet of his cum to shoot into her, just as she said he was going to impregnate her.

Twilight’s voice devolved into a loud squeal as her last orgasm of the night hit her with force. The combination of her brother’s teeth pulling her mane and his spurting shaft inside her sent her careening over a whole new peak.

The feel of each other orgasming so strongly after many hours of sex left nerves raw and the experience feeling more intense. The two of them quivered and twitched as they began to come back down. Had they not already been laying on their sides, they would’ve fallen over.

When they finally recovered some of their senses, panting from the exertion, Shining hugged Twilight close, still keeping himself fully inside. A hoof ran lazy circles over her swollen belly, feeling her wiggle deeper into his embrace and letting out a tired coo.

His voice somewhere between sated and uncertain, Shining spoke in a quiet tone. “I guess you wanted the uncertainty too, eh, Twily?”

Her hoof pressed against the his on her belly, some of their reality starting to settle back in as she let herself enjoy the feel of him against her back and still inside her. “Yeah… For right now though, we’re going to enjoy today in every way we can. We’re going to enjoy falling asleep as lovers, BBBFF. Reality and consequences can wait until tomorrow, j-just this once…”

Shining nuzzled the back of her head with a small squeeze, hearing the ‘I hope’ she didn’t say out loud. Even he knew enough to realize it could mean the difference between her getting pregnant or not, if the contraceptive spells had malfunctioned or failed, but they both wanted it this way, knowing the risk of their fantasy turning very real with the light of the morning sun. “I really enjoyed getting to share all this with you, Twily. I’m also still your big brother. You are more important than anything this might potentially cost us. Even my career in the Guard, if it comes down to it. No matter what morning brings, I will still be here for you, ok?”

“I…” Twilight paused, taking time to think things over as she undid the stamina spell on him, then the two that made sure he’d put everything into her womb. A deep, calming breath put her worries aside for morning and she smiled, enjoying the incredible feeling of being so thoroughly sexually satisfied, a soft sigh of contentment escaping her lips. “Thanks, Shiny. Even if everything else falls apart, I won’t turn my back on you either. I wish we didn’t have those worries and could just be together, but it’s just not meant to be, I guess. At least we can always remember everything we did today as we lived out this fantasy, and most of all, sharing our first time together. Other than that initial moment of panic, I could spend the rest of my life trying, and still not have a moment that perfect again. Y-you made me feel complete in that moment, when everything was so overwhelming that all I could feel was you pulsing inside me, and all I could think was how much I loved you.”

Shining nuzzled against the back of her head again and gave her another small squeeze, then just held his Twilight against his chest as he used his magic to pull the bedcovers over them, previously shoved out of the way for their lovemaking late into the night.

“I love you too, Twily. Now I want to get some well-earned sleep while I keep my cock buried inside my well-bred, pregnant mare. The morning, and possible consequences, aren’t here yet…”

Ch 5 - Facing Reality

Author's Note

Contains: incest, kissing, vaginal, cream-pie, cum entering womb, impregnation?, lingering results of moderate cum inflation

There we are. Clop with story gets a chance to exercise the Drama tag. And I apparently need to add an extra chapter, due to how things have played out. I didn't want to make this chapter ridiculously long, so I'll do the next part, what was originally the second half of this, as it's own chapter. Depending on how I feel when I get there, I might even add an 8th chapter. Overall, that's the limit though. The story plan just doesn't have any substance past that.

Will they eventually find a way? You'll just have to wait to find out. :trollestia:

Ch 5 - Facing Reality

The sound of chirping birds somewhere outside combined pleasantly with the warm glow of the morning sun filtering in through the windows. It offered an almost uncomfortably pristine perfection that seemed so at odds with the demands of reality that were soon to be faced by two unexpected lovers.

Slowly, it brought those two unfortunate ponies reluctantly back to the waking world, the day begun anew, and their one chance to indulge now passed. They felt no rush to break the spell of contentment by opening their eyes right away, knowing it was going to bring necessary heartache as they were forced to accept the situation they were in. And the walking away from things that had to happen.

Shining Armor held his sister close with a faint smile on his face, relishing the comforting warmth of her body so close to his, both on the outside from being curled around her, and the snug embrace of her marehood where his shaft still lay buried within her. He could feel occasional faint twitches from her inner muscles and the tempo of her pulse wrapped around him there. It was a soothing counterpoint beside the familiar scent of her mane in his nose, and coupled with the steady rise and fall of her breath as it came and went. If not for the knowledge of why they could never have a moment like this again, it truly would have been a perfect morning, spent with the mare he loved after they had made love for hours uncounted the day before. He still felt sated and relaxed, entirely content to hold her in his half-awake daze, deciding he could wait a bit longer for her to wake.

Twilight Sparkle relished how wonderful it felt to have her brother spooning her as she slowly woke up, a faint smile on her face as she let the feeling of him wrapped around her back fill her with warmth from the outside, while the pleasant feeling of him still inside her as he had been all night made her feel warm from within. There was something so uniquely intimate with the way he held a hoof over her distended belly, which still looked like she was ready to give birth. All of it was coupled with the occasional shift of his length inside, alongside the feel of his heartbeat both inside her and against her back. She let every tiny detail of his presence, around her and within her, sink firmly into her mind, hoping she could hold onto this moment forever. The morning was so pure in her perception, surrounded and filled with the love he gave her over the course of hours upon hours of lovemaking. She still felt entirely sated, taking delight in the realization that her estrus had indeed ended early because of everything he put inside her, putting the various possibilities out of her mind for now. She could wait till he woke up before she moved, savoring the vague, delightful feeling of floating, with only his forelegs keeping her safely snuggled against him.

The rest of the day was going to be hard to get through, they both knew. It would be much harder if the contraceptive spells had failed and he had actually gotten her pregnant, but such things wouldn’t be changed by knowing immediately or not. At least in that moment, it was uncertain enough it could be set aside, and the best parts of their intimate connection could be relished just a little longer.

And when they were honest with themselves, each held the tiny, secret wish that all the love they had shared the day before would leave a permanent memento, regardless of all the problems it would put them through. It was knowing what it would bring with it that kept either from making any move to make it a certainty. Reason and sense won out over that desire, the temptation simply acknowledged and put away, but not denying that it was there.

Eventually, Shining had to stretch and arched his back with a yawn. His spine popped as his shaft pulled halfway out of her, then merely slid right back in as he returned to hold her close as he had been. The feeling of her inner walls rippling from the new stimulation told him she was still incredibly sensitive. After a moment of thought, he found himself hoping they could make love together one last time before they separated for good. Considering what was in her belly, it certainly wasn’t going to make any real difference in that regard. A way to share a fond farewell to what they’d had a chance to share, if nothing else.

Twilight felt her marehood quivering for several seconds after her brother stretched and gave her insides a stroke of his shaft before relaxing against her again. A lazy yawn found it’s way out of her as she decided to have a stretch of her own, though she knew what she was doing as she arched her back until it popped like his had, grinding herself down on his stiff length and making sure he stayed just a little deeper inside her when she went still again. Feeling him shift so he could press in just a little further still as he gave her a tender squeeze made her smile broaden.

Once she had taken one last moment to savor waking up with him in such a way, a resigned sigh finally escaped, a tension growing in her chest as she spoke softly. “Alright, Shiny. H-hold me tight. I’m going to check the contraceptive spells now. Time to find out if you really did put a foal inside me or not…”

She felt his forelegs pull her in more firmly as she folded her own over his and across her swollen belly that suggested what their future might hold, then began to channel her magic. There were multiple spells to check, and she needed to go one by one. Somehow, she managed to keep a detached, clinical approach until she finished, with a specialized detection spell to finish off her efforts. As her emotions took hold at how the spells had performed, she was at a loss of quite how to feel about what she found.

There was a rather pregnant pause, then Twilight felt her eyes begin tear up, her checks complete and emotions running through several contrasts at once. She felt herself run through surprise, relief, joy, disbelief, and more, with each hitting her with such weight she could hardly breathe. Small shudders ran across her form as she managed to say it out loud for her brother. “I-I… It’s both, Shiny…”

Shining wasn’t quite sure what he was expecting, or truly hoping for, but it certainly wasn’t the answer she gave him. “What? How can it be both, Twily? Isn’t you being pregnant or not kinda an either-or thing?”

A hoof rubbed over his foreleg laying across her belly, feeling a strange giddiness as a rather odd, choked giggle escaped. “It’s because three of the contraceptive spells are perfectly fine. Only two in the set failed…”

“Uh, doesn’t that mean you’re not pregnant then?” Shining furrowed his brow as he started to worry about his sister a little, hearing her let out another strange giggle as she started grinding herself down on his cock.

“Mmm…” Twilight was wearing a wide, almost manic smile as she started to move her marehood over his shaft, in and out with slow strokes, breathing a bit faster as she relished the idea of what she discovered and needing to feel him pulsing inside her again. “The spells for, ah~… For protecting my womb are fine. The three of them, oh~, keep egg cells away with a micro-repulsion field, a highly specialized shield, and a method to, nnf, restrict a fertilized egg cell still managing to achieve direct contact from implanting in my uterus. Each of which has around an approximately 0.1 percent chance of failure…”

Unable to resist her motions in his confusion, Shining began thrusting into her with the same deliberate slowness she started, drawing out a pleasured gasp from her as he pressed in deep as he could reach, each time also had his tip pressing against her cervix like it had so many times the night before, when he sent each and every bit of his cum straight into her womb. “S-so why did you say both…?”

“B-because, ah, because the two that failed were to prevent ovulation, and a field by my ovaries to put a micro-shield around any egg cell that did get released. Mmm~! T-then I did a detection spell...” Twilight panted as she used her magic to pull her brother up and over her body, making sure his cock never slipped out on the way, while she remained on her side. She wanted to look him in the eye, giving him an intense look of lust and love as he thrust himself inside her.

Bracing himself above her, Shining made constant deep thrusts, anxiousness growing in his chest even as he worked on getting another orgasm out of her. It was all without conscious thought by this point, his attention hanging on her next words as he hunched over her.

“You did it~!” Twilight exclaimed with a gasp, feeling her tunnel spasming eagerly around his invading shaft, electric tingles shooting up her spine each time he hilted himself and knocked on her inner gates. “My poor, defenseless egg cell was floating around in all the sperm you put inside me. The detection spell revealed it was fertilized successfully! You ended my estrus, Shiny! Oh Celestia~! My own brother proved his virility as a stallion by getting me pregnant! Ah~! My BBBFF really did put his foal inside me! Nyaha~!”

For his part, Shining barely managed to keep thrusting on autopilot at first, trying to process what she had just said. Twilight had just told him major life changing words. His mind went mostly blank as the words ‘I got Twily pregnant…’ kept repeating in his head. It mixed together with everything else as deeper instincts grew.

The mare beneath him, his own sister, had his foal inside her. His thrusts grew stronger as his arousal swiftly spiked, feeling the growing urge to leave his mark in her again so other stallions knew she belonged to him. His mare. To protect. To breed. His flare swelled as he gave her a wild, intense look of raw instinctive lust. His.

“Breed me again, Shiny!” Twilight cried out when she felt him getting close. With a mix of magic and hooves, she pulled his head close and crushed her lips against his, her tongue doing everything it could to taste all of him.

The way she yanked him forward also forced Shining’s cock firmly up against her cervix again, the suddenness setting them both off. He held himself as deep inside her as possible as his climax took hold, his forceful blasts of cum crashing against her inner gates. The width of Shining’s flare, combined with her tightly clenching depths, prevented anything from escaping around him, with the pressure building with each pulse of his shaft.

Between the volume of his release in the small space and her spasms, her brother’s semen began slipping through her cervix even without a spell to open her most intimate path for him. Twilight’s climax seemed to double in intensity, strong shudders making her shake as she felt the heat of it sliding even deeper, making it’s way into her womb with every uterine contraction her orgasming body made. Her body locked up around him as her mind melted under the dual beat of his strong warm pulses, and her own body allowing the heat of his gift further inside.

Twilight’s horn glowed almost without a thought, a small application of telekinesis at her cervix held it open just a little, her eyes rolling back in her head with a loud moan as the bulk of Shining’s release began flowing through the small gap she’d made. Oh stars, how can that feel so good… I think I’ve developed a fetish for feeling ejaculate passing through my cervix, or is it only when it comes from my big brother?

As their shared peak wound down, Shining panted as he broke the kiss and looked at the closed eyes and rather satisfied smile on his sister, her tongue lolling from the side of her mouth as she caught her breath. A painful ball of emotions began to grow in his chest.

Visions passed before his eyes as he saw himself shielding Twilight from misplaced anger walking down a random street, them being labeled as degenerates by ponies that wouldn’t care that it was because of a complete accident, of losing his officer’s commission and being forced out of the Guard. Numerous dark possibilities flashed through his mind. He struggled with himself, desperately trying to find a reason or way to take the blame so his sister and their foal could possibly get out of most of the problems they’d have. He didn’t care if she got mad at him for it, he’d bear it and still give her a smile. Yet try as he might, he just couldn’t see how either of them could be blamed because of how it happened. Not that it would matter if they were found out.

Even if they’d somehow known that the other was going to The Blind Date Company, never in a million years would he have thought they’d end up meeting each other. As far as he could remember of how they ran their service, Blind Date wouldn’t even be capable of telling they were related.

“Twily,” Shining started as he looked her in the eye, voice strained but certain as he continued, “I’ll do whatever I need to for you. I’ll take as much blame as I can and help raise our foal. Depending on how it plays out, I might have to leave the Guard to make it work, but you and our foal come first. I…”

Twilight held her hoof to her brother’s lips to silence him, giving him a confused and somewhat amused look. “Um, Shiny? Why are you talking like I’m fully pregnant?”

Shining blinked, staring at her and struggling to understand what she just said. “But you… You said you’re pregnant? My sperm got to your egg and you detected it was fertilized. How can you say I didn't get you pregnant all of a sudden?”

She gave him a sated grin and bopped him on the side of the head with a hoof. “Simple biology, you dummy. I said you fertilized my egg, and I am technically pregnant right now, but it hasn’t implanted in my uterine wall yet. With the contraceptive spells for preventing exactly that still working as intended, it isn’t going to happen. So yes, you successfully inseminated me like a healthy stallion and did your part of making a foal in me, but I won’t be carrying to term or anything. It’d be a different story if I hadn’t gotten the spells, or if they had all failed, since those only work preemptively. Nature would’ve been left to take it’s course otherwise.”

He just blinked at her, still confused. “So… All that yelling about me getting you pregnant was…?”

Licking her lips, she brazenly squeezed her marehood around his slowly softening length. “It turned me on so hard when I discovered you succeeded. My BBBFF squirting his proven fertile sperm inside me? I suddenly needed more of you inside me at that moment. My estrus might have ended because of the apparently successful fertilization, but knowing just how certain it was, that I was all but guaranteed to get pregnant without protection…” Twilight gave her brother a half-lidded smile. “There’s no way for me to be sure or prove it, but I suspect you managed to impregnate me with the very first, deliciously heavy, oh so large load of clearly very virile semen that you sent into my womb. You aren’t going to have any problems making foals with a mare in the future, when we’re ready for one.”

There was a pause between them as they both felt Shining’s half-hard length give a twitch within her from hearing her talk about him climaxing inside her so eagerly, before what she said clicked for both of them. Emotions flashed across their eyes before Twilight turned her head to the side and broke eye contact.

Twilight’s voice sounded a little distant. “A-actual implantation in the uterine wall takes longer than we’ve been engaging in penetrative vaginal sex. Both of us reached full orgasm multiple times, with all ejaculate successfully passed through my cervix and kept contained in the most optimal location for maximizing the probability of fertilization. The contraceptive spells protecting my uterus mean there is only a statistically miniscule chance of implantation. I… I’m only pregnant until the presently viable zygote flushes out as I evacuate all the accumulated semen currently held in my uterus. My estrus is also likely to return as the pregnancy hormones exit my system. I’ll probably return to a highly aroused and fully receptive state. Even if I start using reducers again. R-rather than pursuing m-my stallion, for a s-second… insemination…”

Shining clenched his jaw as his mouth formed a tight line, immediately figuring out why his sister was attempting to use more technical terms, and her not quite managing it. She’d always done it when she didn’t want to admit that something tough and unpleasant was not going to change. He remembered how she’d done something similar when she killed her pet goldfish many years ago as a filly, a miscast spell to let her clean the fishbowl easier that did something to the water. The memory was a simple accident she’d taken really hard at the time, and with his heart aching, Shining also knew what she would do next.

Seeing her eyes close as they welled up with tears was all it took before he laid gently over her side, both of them still in the same position after their bout of lovemaking. As much as he could, he wrapped her up in his forelegs and just held her.

Some of her resistance finally gave way, and Twilight started shaking from small sobs as she was held by her brother. A moment later, her face was buried against his neck and her available foreleg was squeezing his. He didn’t say a word, just letting her deal with it as she needed while her tears soaked into his fur and quiet cries met his ears.

Minutes passed before she just had the occasional sniffle, nuzzling against his neck a little before she turned his head and met him for a brief but loving kiss, her tone resigned. “A week, Shiny. A-after we part ways for a week, let’s meet here and see where we’re at. I don’t think either of us is going to be capable of completely rational thought right now, and some distance will hopefully give us a chance to sort through things so we can talk.”

Brushing her cheek with a fetlock as he wiped away some of her remaining tears, Shining could only stare into her eyes for a long moment before finding his voice. “If… If that’s what you need, we’ll do it, Twily.”

Twilight caught his lips for another kiss, holding it a little longer than before, then met his eyes again. “I really don’t know what I need right now. There’s a part of me that wants to tell you to move in with me. And I mean today. I know you don’t have the option of having anypony move into the officer’s barracks with you. A-another part…” She paused, swallowing as she trembled at what she was about to admit. “Another part wants to…” A slow, calming breath was needed before she could say it. “Shiny, part of me wants your permission to drop the contraceptive spells and keep what you gave me right where it is. To let the product of our love grow, even as I plan out making sure you keep me with foal. To try to put a new one inside me the very moment estrus or a spell makes me receptive again, and to make you keep sending more of your semen into my womb until we have some kind of test saying I’ve gotten pregnant with the next one. I…” She coughed lightly, a troubled expression on her face. “Like I said, I don’t believe I can think very rationally right now. I love you, and in my current state of mind, I just keep thinking about ways to show it.”

Shining blinked as he stared at her. For several seconds, the idea of putting foal after foal inside his sister was all that ran through his mind. He had to shake his head to clear it and cleared his throat, though he was long past feeling embarrassed about his shaft slowly starting to swell back up inside her again. “Ok, I can see what you mean.” He paused, realizing something. “Uh… I’m still inside in you and only just realized how much I’ve been avoiding pulling away.” Glancing at the clock beside her bed, he grimaced. “And I’ve got about an hour and a half to get back to the castle and return to duty.”

When a particular thought came to mind, Twilight pulled his head in close after a brief pause to look into his eyes, then met his lips in a deeply loving kiss. This time she held it, humming for a moment at the feel of her big brother’s presence in every way he was there with her, inside and out. The kiss was unrushed, no tongue involved as their lips moved together, and every ounce of passion in it was somehow entirely without lust. She poured every little bit of how much she loved him, all the different ways that now included, into just one kiss as her closed eyes filled with bittersweet tears. She kissed her stallion with all she had before they had to let go.

As he felt his sister’s lips meet his, there was a moment he thought she was going to try and encourage him for one last quick round. Then he felt the subtle yet stark difference. Shining pressed forward and moved his lips with hers in equal measure, able to feel how much she was pouring into this, and he simply let it wash him away in the torrent of emotion. All he could do was match it with his own, pouring everything he felt for Twilight into that one intimate touch. A tightness in his chest and a tingle in his own closed eyes were noted as he was swept away by the love he had gained for this mare. Since it could be their last chance for a true kiss, he gave it all he had.

When the moment felt ready, they pulled away and locked eyes again.

“I love you.”

The words came out almost of their own accord as they spoke in unison, knowing that was the ending moment for their time together.

Shining slowly pulled away, his shaft slipping out of her as both shivered. He was on his hooves by the bed soon after when Twilight spoke up.

“You should just use my shower to save time. I’d join you, but…” Twilight gave a resigned sigh. “If I did, I’m pretty sure we’d end up starting something again. I’ll just relax here until you head out.”

Despite the growing ache that he knew wasn’t going away any time soon, Shining gave her a small smile and keeping his words short, denying everything on the tip of his tongue. “Thanks. I won’t take long.”

Twilight watched her brother exit the room, then laid her head back on her pillow as she felt tears pricking at her eyes, but this time refusing to let them fall. It was the way it had to be, and she wasn’t going to even try convincing herself otherwise.

As she lay there in thought, absently listening to the sound of the running shower in a small daze of temptation, Twilight wondered about Blind Date and the circumstances that led her to the situation she and her brother were in. Different points of note began to list themselves in her mind as she turned an eye to where she’d put the information packet she’d assembled when deciding on using Blind Date or not. It levitated over to her swiftly, the various papers already assembling themselves mid-air into a suitable formation for perusal. She was just re-checking it for peace of mind, really.

Taking note of various things, she reminded herself that The Blind Date Company used a fully double-blind anonymity system. They didn’t know who their own clients were, not even a name or anything else. Just a magically-traced identification number so clients could have their needs kept consistent. The identifier didn’t even carry between their other locations in one city to the next, so there was no one place for anypony to track any one client, if it was even possible at all. Medical screenings were only taking note of relevant health, so there was little to identify anypony from that either.

It all came back to the clear and simple fact that her choosing her brother’s profile for his compatability with her, the same with him choosing hers in turn, and the two of them starting to meet for sexual exploration and conversations that led up to today, was just a matter of pure blind chance.

When she was as satisfied as she was going to get in her review, Twilight returned the information packet to its place again, rolling onto her back as her hooves absently stroked her swollen belly. He hadn’t even left yet, and Twilight already missed Shining terribly. All the fantasies she’d had about the mysterious stallion she’d fallen in love with before the blindfolds had come off had since changed to Shining.

Rubbing the belly that looked so much like she was ready to bear a foal was like a direct heartbreak right in her face. She’d most loved the idea of marrying her stallion and having a couple foals with him in a few years. He’d tell her how beautiful she looked while heavily pregnant, especially when she had some random silly moment of feeling fat and ugly like many pregnant mares seemed to have. A few loving words would be said, and he’d make gentle love to her until she felt perfectly content again. She knew without a doubt that her BBBFF would do that for her in a heartbeat, given the chance. And how much she’d love him for it. What society thinks of my being with my brother intimately aside, is it really that unfortunate that fell in love with a stallion I already thought the world of and know so well? Aside from us being related, he really is what I always dreamed of.

Another resigned sigh escaped her lips as she moved back to her side. With the water having stopped a couple minutes ago, she knew her brother would be leaving soon, and she’d have to get in the shower herself for the day’s lesson with Princess Celestia coming up as well.

Shining finished his quick and basic grooming regimen, a standard spell getting his mane and tail dry in under a minute as he brushed them out. Part of him really missed Twilight’s scent on him already. Or the soft warm of her body as he held her close.

His emotions were mostly under lock and key now, set aside for him to deal with when he had the chance to sit and think on his own. His time in the Guard gave him the resilience necessary to endure challenging circumstances, though he never imagined it would come into play like this. Shining didn’t tell his sister just how badly he wanted to damn the consequences to Tartarus and not stop making love to her until a whole second day had passed. It was rather difficult to keep himself from giving into the desire.

He hoped taking a week would help him clear his head. He needed it as much as Twilight did. There were enough difficult questions before we even discovered what happened. It was confusing enough before, but how the heck do I talk to Cadence now? How long can I even avoid doing so when she always manages to get me to talk every single time, once she decides to? And how can loving Twily so much, to have made love to her so much, still feel so right?

For a moment as he left the bathroom and walked towards her bedroom door again, Shining could think of nothing else other than going straight to the bed and apologizing for leaving, to give her another climax in apology and forget everything else.

As he stepped through the doorway to her bedroom again, it was suppressed once more.

Shining stopped a couple paces into the room, seeing his sister reclining on her side as he’d left her. His heart beat a little faster at seeing her disheveled mane and tail, the rumpled sheets pushed to the end of the bed, the spots of her coat that lay in unusual directions. From his position being more in line with the end than the side of the bed, he also saw her exposed haunch, her plot, and her very well-used, still swollen marehood that had a small bit of his semen by the entrance of the very depths he now knew so directly. Coupled with her swollen belly and the curious little smile on her face, it was very hard to hold back his erection from returning.

With well-practiced control, he spoke calmly, even as he worried he would break if she wanted him give her a goodbye hug. “I guess I’ll see you in a week, Twily. I assume you want to talk over dinner or something, so in the evening? On Saturday?”

Twilight let herself relish the delight at looking at him after just a small separation, a content little smile on her lips. The sound of his voice rolled through her, making her shiver just a little. She realized if he crossed the room and so much as touched her, she’d pull him back into the bed and have him filling her with his semen again soon after.

“I’ve got plenty of time that evening, so yes, drop by for dinner on Saturday next week.” The smile faded as she spoke, becoming a sad expression. “We… We already had a very wonderful goodbye kiss, so you should probably just head out. And…”

Twilight paused, a question on the tip of her tongue. For a moment, she thought better of it, but slipped out when the desire grew too much, her voice turning both nervous and sultry at the same time. “Shining, do you still think I’m beautiful, even when I’m all swollen like this?”

Shining had a moment where his breath caught, her comment changing how he was looking at her. A half-vision lay before him just then. His very pregnant mare was seeking reassurance he still desired her, even with her body so laden by their foal within. A hoof lifted from the floor to walk forward before he caught himself again, unable to hide the want in his eyes as he stared at the beauty of his pregnant sister. He’d heard the invitation in her voice as much as he’d caught onto her worry. It took all his willpower not to go right to the bed and make love to her for hours as he showed her how desirable he thought she was.

Keeping himself still took more than he could spare to also keep his eyes and voice in check, giving her an openly hungry look as he spoke in a heated growl. “Twily, if this were any other situation, you would have just committed yourself to at least a few hours of me physically showing you just how beautiful you look like this. As it is, I can barely keep myself in check from doing exactly that right now.”

A warm blush spread to her cheeks as Twilight smiled, suddenly feeling inexplicably bashful. Her eyes closed as she turned her head, needing a moment to gather her self-control again. She nearly let the words ‘then come and show me, stallion’ escape her lips in direct invitation. The way he looked at her, and that tone in his voice, told her he would’ve more than fulfilled that dream. It made her love him just that much more.

Finally, she took a deep breath as her eyes began to mist, her gaze turning back to him as a pained smile took over. “A-alright, Shiny. You better go before one of us breaks. I-I’ll see you on Saturday.”

Shining took a slow breath and nodded, jaw clenching as his mouth pressed into a tight line before he could speak, his tone now a mirror of sad resignation. “I’ll see you on Saturday, Twily. We’ll get through this, once we have some time to accept and deal with it.”

He wanted to say so much more, but worried he wouldn’t be able to stop trying to postpone his departure for just one more thing.

With one last pause to stare into her eyes from across the room that he dare not remain in a moment longer, Shining turned and let his military training march him out the door, collect the bag he’d brought, and head out to the street and away from her with a set jaw and steel in his eyes.

On the surface, he was every bit the picture of a marching guardspony heading towards the castle. Inside, he had to resist a powerful urge to scream in anguish.

Back in the room, Twilight shakily got to her hooves after she heard the front door open and close. She just went through the motions as she got in the shower to get herself ready for the rest of her day.

There was a moment as she got ready to release the spell keeping all of her brother’s gifted essence inside her where she contemplated the crazy idea of letting it pool in the tub. There was easily enough where she could literally bathe in her brother’s semen, to coat herself so completely that every last bit of her mane, tail, and coat would be drenched in it, marking every last part of her body, inside and out, as his alone. She’d wear his scent for several days if she did. And for a moment, she let herself imagine it before she released the spell, knowing she didn’t have the time to indulge that desire and be properly presentable for the Princess, her brother’s scent on her or not.

As the water streamed down over her body, and her brother’s gift began to escape, belly slowly shrinking, Twilight found she couldn’t stop herself as the tears started. She didn’t fight it at all, the water steadily washing away everything but the memories of his presence, slowly getting herself clean while she cried. She’d make herself stop when she was done, but that was in a few minutes.

They were both completely aware that all the love they’d shared was a beautiful experience that could never be replaced.

And now it had to be left as no more than a memory.

Ch 6 - Troubled Talk On A Touchy Topic

Author's Note

Contains: talk of incest and acts of previous chapters, sexual confession to an authority figure, soaking a cushion with mare juice, and a secretly perverted Celestia

While I planned for 6 chapters, it seems the story behind all the clop demanded more room, so I think it's going to be 8-9 chapters. All things considered, this is the most tame chapter in regards to sex being present in every chapter. Yay for feels. :twilightsmile:

Next chapter will be Shining's side of the drama. That has a pretty impactful opening move... :trollestia:

Ch 6 - Troubled Talk On A Touchy Topic

Twilight Sparkle swallowed a lump in her throat. What she had been dreading had happened and there was no getting around it now. Something she never even imagined before the recent events of a few days ago with her brother now needed to be faced directly, though for better or worse was still undecided. She trembled on her cushion, trying to decide what she could say. The growing silence was awkward and oppressive as she stared at the floor.

“I-I… I’m…” Twilight began weakly before her subdued voice failed again, ears pressed back and thinking she probably looked as miserable as she felt.

Her eyes rose to meet those of the pony beside her again as her eyes grew teary, unable to stop the burning shame that left her face feeling like it was on fire. She saw the endless compassion in those eyes, the supportive kindness that said they’d always be there for her, no matter what. And it somehow felt both reassuring and damning at the same time.

“Twilight, I ask because you have been quite distracted for a few days now, and it is clearly something unexpected and substantial to occupy you this much. I know it is not your estrus, as you have always done so well in keeping it under control. Talk to me about what is weighing on you so. You know I will always listen, and I will offer honest advice, if I can.” Celestia said with a delicate sigh, tired of letting Twilight try to ignore whatever troubled her in silence.

“Princess, I…” Twilight tried again before her eyes closed and she sniffled, knowing she couldn’t run away or tell her mentor any lies. I know I’ll have to admit what Shiny and I did before this lesson ends. Please, please, please, Princess Celestia, don’t say I can’t be your student anymore because I fell in love with my brother on accident and ended up spending my entire day off in bed with him. We’re already prepared to walk away, no matter how badly we don’t want to.

Celestia’s voice took on the slightest bit more of an edge. “Twilight, we have reached a point where this is now, in part, a test of your trust in me. You need to talk to me. Whatever problem you are facing is impacting your studies quite substantially, and I won’t allow it to continue without some understanding. Even if you would prefer to keep it to yourself, you need to share at least a little of it so I know if this will continue to affect you to such a degree, and for how long it may do so.”

Twilight’s face still burned as hot tears began to fall, no longer able to keep them in. Every bit of her resolve was straining to keep herself from breaking down as she grit her teeth, forcing herself to at least give her beloved mentor a shaky nod in acquiescence as she gathered herself.

It was another long pause before she managed to speak. “I-I… A-a-a f-few months ago, I-I wanted to t-try getting some c-confidence and experience d-dealing with other ponies and i-intimacy. P-putting together a report for myself, I f-found the best option was…” Twilight paused again to take a calming breath, sniffling with the resignation slowly setting in once she started and an honest sadness in her tone. “Th-the… The best option seemed to be using the services of The Blind Date Company here in Canterlot. F-fully anonymous. No expectations or standing requirements. Near complete control of how meetings with another pony would proceed. Scheduled times and a surprisingly good system of selecting the kinds of ponies one meets with.”

While Twilight didn’t see it, Celestia allowed herself a tiny smile as she listened and her own thoughts ran. So my faithful student expresses that hidden daring streak I see deep down, and at Blind Date of all places? Someday, you will look back on this moment and laugh with me, my dear… Although, I really hope she never finds out I first met her father there, many years ago when he was a Private in my royal guard, and how I took him as my last long-time lover. That stallion was far too good with his dick. And it’s still funny how much Velvet blushed and squeaked when she thanked me for teaching future husband so many tricks. Hmm, now I have to wonder if Twilight squeals out her orgasms or tastes like her mother did during those threesomes we had before Night and Velvet felt it was time to marry and raise foals. Those are two questions I’ll likely never know answer to, now that I think of it. My little ponies have become so curiously prudish in the past century.

Unaware of her mentor’s mental memory monologue, Twilight continued in the same subdued tone, blushing to the tips of her ears. “I-I don’t know if you’re familiar with The Blind Date Company, Princess. D-do I need to explain more of what th-they do before I continue?”

Celestia gave a quiet, thoughtful hum, tempted to make Twilight actually explain the sexual liaison and fetish functions at Blind Date, but she didn’t want to overwhelm her. Celestia merely gave her a kind smile. “I am fully aware of them and the unique services they provide to my little ponies, Twilight. Please, continue.”

With another small, jerky nod, Twilight pressed on. “I-I found a n-nice sounding stallion’s profile, and we set up a first meeting and date. He turned out to be a unicorn.” Despite sensing she didn’t need to say it, the words spilled out almost of their own volition as her need to confess grew. “W-we had an… oral sex first date. H-he licked me and d-drank f-from me. Then I-I used m-my mouth in return, and s-s-swallowed h-his s-s-sexual fluids.”

One eyebrow arching in silent amusement, Celestia noticed Twilight’s scent in the air, already strong from her estrus, was quickly growing thick and heavy as the young mare was likely getting rather turned on from her memories. While she didn’t mind it, Celestia did have to giggle inside. Oh my, Twilight. This estrus cycle hit you extremely hard, didn’t it? You probably don’t even realize it is so obvious right now.

“The first meeting, we planned for no talking. The second time a few days later and it was the same plan, aside from getting to talk then. I came to find out he was fun to talk to. A couple times, we never even got to the oral sex, and just spent the whole session in conversation. I found out he…” Twilight paused, seeming to wilt a little. “He’s an officer in your royal guard, here at the castle. At first, I was infatuated with the idea of finding out who he was and teasing him whenever I could walk by. I knew I had a crush on him by that point.”

Celestia had already gleaned something had recently gone quite wrong for Twilight. Now it seemed apparent that it had something to do with this stallion she’d met. Depending on the rest of the tale, she might consider discussing things with young Cadence on how to improve matters, but that would take the rest of the tale first.

“A couple weeks ago when we met, I surprised him by letting him go inside my plot. I, I told him that I wasn’t ready for full intercourse just then, but knew I was going to enter my estrus cycle soon. H-he agreed to a Reveal Room with me and we planned our first time to be everything it possibly could be. We planned to take off the blindfolds just as we had our first orgasm during intercourse, and we’d just see how things went from there. I wasn’t really sure what I was feeling towards him at the time, just that the longer I went without knowing his face, his eyes, his smile, the more anxious to know him I became. He’d been so wonderful to me that I-I couldn’t stand not knowing, and maybe I rushed myself, I don’t know.”

Her face remained impassive as Celestia listened, but inside she tensed. While nothing specific had been said, her protective instincts flared. I may never be able to actually tell Twilight for decades, but she has become like a daughter to me. She hasn’t said anything to actually suggest as much, but if this stallion did her harm, I am probably the one pony alive that could track him down. My little ponies have long forgotten the reason why I was once known the world over as The Vengeful Sun and Ashmaker… With effort, Celestia prevented her magic from flaring alongside her urge to protect her foal, knowing Twilight would easily detect it, and she really didn’t need anything else to worry about.

Unaware of the internal reactions of her mentor, Twilight sniffled as she pressed on, her tail twitching a bit and she shifted on her cushion, painfully aware how much she was leaking her own arousal. “We… We met to do just that a few days ago. He was a perfect gentlestallion, as always. I-I had a standard suite of contraceptive spells cast by the Blind Date physician, so we didn’t have to worry about that. I even put a couple of sex spells on us to make it as amazing as possible. Everything was so perfect at first. His tenderness, how he felt inside me, the way he responded to my every need. Most mares dream of how perfect he made our first time together. The kisses he gave me, how he was the perfect length to get all the way inside and touch my cervix with the perfect level of pressure. It stayed perfect up until he started to flare inside me and we got ready for our first mutual orgasm as full lovers…”

Celestia felt a little confused as the story continued. If the stallion had treated her so well and she still had not shown the slightest hint of displeasure, then what was troubling her so?

Twilight took a shuddery breath and whimpered, feeling and hearing her marehood wink with a soft squelch, much to her shame. Her estrus had already begun to return in force, with no sign of slowing down, and was apparently making arousing memories far more effective at getting her riled up. The fact it was so powerful a moment was in no way helpful to keeping herself calm. The faint cool sensation around her haunches said she had best set the cushion she was using aside for cleaning when she got up. She burned with shame over it, despite knowing Celestia had more than once told her not to worry when it inevitably happened during her estrus.

After a moment to compose herself, she continued, fresh tears starting to fall. “W-we took off the blindfolds just before we went over the edge, our horns were touching so we could stare into each other’s eyes for our first release together. I-I couldn’t even finish telling him I loved him as I stared into his eyes for the first time, and I realized who he was.” Another sniffle. “I-I panicked. I tried to cast a half dozen spells at the same time and fizzled out pretty bad. Everything seemed to move in slow motion at that point. I felt my earlier spells activate to keep us locked together so he stayed locked fully inside when one or both of us would climax. I even distinctly felt his penis swell inside me and how his first pulse of semen raced down into my body. With the fizzle making me hypersensitive, it was like his semen was boiling hot as it squirted directly into my uterus, all while staring straight into his eyes. Because of one of my spells, my cervix was even held open and in the perfect place for him to send everything straight in. With another spell meant to keep all of his semen inside me, every little bit he released was kept where he sent it.”

Panting more as she struggled to control herself from grinding her own hoof against her marehood, she remembered exactly how it had felt as her brother had nearly broken her mind with the orgasm his turgid shaft had forcefully blasted into her deepest core. Twilight kept going. “I’ve never felt anything so powerful before. Before either of us was even halfway done with our orgasm, we were kissing and grinding against each other for more, completely unable to stop. Eventually, we just collapsed as the main part of it ended, but our shared orgasm kept going for several minutes, I think. I can’t really remember how much time it took, or how many times he squirted more of his semen inside whenever my body had another spasm and stimulated him again. All I really know is I couldn’t think about much of anything for a while as I was carried along for the ride.”

Twilight swallowed, her eyes having become a little wild and unfocused, though her tears started to pick back up again. “W-we basically woke back up from the extreme orgasm and found out my fizzle had d-damaged the spells. Most of them had remained triggered, rather than shutting off once their conditions were met. Our bodies were stuck together, so he couldn’t pull himself out. W-with the stamina and productivity spell I’d cast on him, he also quickly became fully aroused inside me again. We h-had a short conversation, and I knew there was nothing we could do until my magic started to function properly again. One way or another, he was going to ejaculate inside me multiple times before I even had a chance to fix the spells. I didn’t even know if the contraceptive spells were still functioning. With no other choices, I… I-I told him to make love to me. I completely gave in and realized just how much I loved him in that moment and I begged him to keep going. I told him how fertile and receptive I was, even outright begged him to breed me, even though we both worried whether or not I’d be pregnant by the time we were done. We that the choice to either keep still and we would both feel his arousal grow until my estrus stimulated him enough to release in me again, or we could make the most of it, and make love together for the same amount of time. The results would be the same, regardless of what we did.”

Celestia held her passive expression even as she wondered what the problem was. So far, apart from her recognizing the unidentified stallion and he was somehow a problem in some way, everything Twilight had been describing was all a fantasy come true for just about any pony alive. Getting to experience a first time mutual orgasm with a pony you loved, and while hit with hypersensitivity just before climax? It was difficult even for experienced lovers with practice at it, so Twilight would likely never fully repeat the event at the same level. Having done it a couple times herself, including with Night Light, Celestia discreetly added a little spell over her own marehood to prevent any hint of her own growing arousal from being revealed. Definitely using a dildo tonight. Poor Twilight. She’d completely lose it if she ever realizes just how casual I am about sex in private.

Twilight obviously knew who the stallion was, but Celestia would hold her tongue until the story was over. She could ask for his name later, if it went unsaid by the end, as Twilight clearly needed to let this out.

A shaky smile managed to form on Twilight’s face, even as her eyes were hazy and tearful. “W-we made love for over three hours. I don’t have any idea how long the fizzle really lasted because we were completely lost in each other until the room’s chime sounded and let us know the scheduled session was almost over. Fixing the spells was easy enough, and we separately went back to my apartment after we left. He got us some dinner and we spent the rest of the day and much of the night making love over and over. The whole time, every climax he gave me was kept inside me and I-I swelled up with it. By the time we were done, he had filled me with so much of his semen that I looked ready to have his foal.

“W-when we woke up together the next morning with him still inside me, I don’t think I’ll ever feel that level of total contentment again. It was just so perfect, aside from knowing it had to end. I-I checked the contraceptive spells and found the three protecting my uterus were still fine. The ones that failed led me to getting so turned on and having him climax inside me one last time. H-he actually managed to impregnate me at some point during the night, even though it wasn’t going to implant. I know it has since passed out of me, considering I’m experiencing my estrus again already.” She had to pause to whimper and sniffle, taking a slow breath to keep herself calm enough to continue. “W-we shared the most wonderful k-kiss before he cleaned up so he could leave. After a short talk to set up when we could talk things out when we weren’t overwhelmed with sex, he left. I-I… How could I meet him through Blind Date like that, and have it end up with him ending my estrus early by getting me pregnant? Why did I have to fall in love with my own brother? Why did my completely perfect stallion have to be Shining Armor?!”

As Twilight finished with a small wail and finally broke down completely, Celestia moved a wing over her and pressed Twilight against her side, holding Twilight’s head against the side of her neck as she curled around her sorrowful student. In one name, Celestia suddenly understood completely. And knowing the quality of character in said stallion, secretly already planned as next in line for her next Captain of the Guard, Celestia also knew how true Twilight’s predicament and feelings really were.

As she held Twilight against her, sobbing against her neck as her coat was soaked with tears, Celestia let her mind drift. My dearest Twilight, I wish I could give you an easy answer this time. While incest in Equestria isn’t illegal, nor do we equines have to worry about almost any of the problems of some other races regarding inbreeding, the public opinion is very rigid and negative about it. How I wish I’d paid attention as views on it began to change two centuries ago. It will take me decades to undo, and I’ve been quietly working to correct the misunderstandings for several already when I finally noticed. If you perform as I have been preparing you for with the many great trials to come, and you save my beloved sister like I know you can, I know how much she will need my company. At least Luna will likely want to hide for a time, and nopony will know some of how I care for her. While we never desired each other for romantic love, Luna and I had a bond of deep intimacy I’d neglected to treasure and had ignored too long, like so many of my other great mistakes back then. Sisters-with-benefits, I think is the most apt term in this modern day. Hmm, maybe Equestria will see the Day or Night of the Trembling Heavens from one of us climaxing too hard and shaking our charge around in the sky again. It has been a long time, and we only ever seemed able to do it with each other… I sadly won’t even be able to tell Twilight I support her because of bucking politics, but at least I can easily continue to accept her without reservation. Still, if they’re found out and it becomes necessary, I will publically give her and her brother my support, and make any of the Nobles or general public back off, one way or another. Until then, I cannot otherwise get directly involved, if Twilight is to stay on her path to help save us all.

Minutes passed as Twilight slowly let her emotions out and was able to calm down. She had no idea how Celestia had taken her retelling of what happened, and gradually steeled herself for the worst. If she had to, she’d accept any rejection, or even loss of her apprenticeship, without complaint. She had messed up, plain and simple, and deserved whatever the Princess deemed appropriate punishment. All she’d do is beg that her brother be spared any hardship. His military career would never recover from a major strike against him. She’d take punishment for him, if it came down to it. Hopefully without him knowing.

Celestia let the faintest of smiles show as she looked down at Twilight, still being held snugly against her by a large white wing. “There now, my faithful student. Are you feeling a little better after telling me what has so troubled you?”

Twilight tried to scrub her face and clean off a bit of her tears so as to be more presentable, though she only succeeded in making herself look even more rumpled, unaware Celestia was secretly giggling at how adorable she now looked. Twilight let out a resigned sigh as she looked at the floor and prepared to face the music, as it were. “I do feel much better for being able to tell somepony. I’m sorry I messed up, Princess. I, I understand if you need to punish me for having sex with my brother. All I ask is if you feel the need to punish him in some way, that I be allowed to bear it in his place.”

After taking a moment to blink, Celestia actually did let out a small chuckle. “Oh come now, Twilight. I know you’re sharper than that. What law exactly would I apply in doing so?”

“It would… be…” Twilight had to blink as she paused, running various laws and statues through her head for anything relevant before she wilted a little. “There… aren’t any laws specifically saying incest is illegal? I’m not going to be punished or anything?”

“That is correct. While there are many misconceptions regarding it today, and public opinion of it is rather unpleasant, it was once an almost common practice amongst our smaller communities, and particularly around Equestria’s founding, when it was important to repopulate after losing so many to the ice. I am sure you can figure out the truth from fiction in this matter for the rest. So no, I have no reason to punish you, unless you really want me to. I’m sure I could come up with something.” Celestia said almost jovially.

Taking a very deep breath and letting it out, Twilight let herself relax a bit more than she was. “Thank you for saying so, Princess. Everypony seems so committed to it being deeply wrong, and I know if it got out that my brother and I had sex, that we’d probably receive a lot of anger over it.” She sniffed and leaned against Celestia’s warm side a little more, still being held by her mentor’s wing. “I… I love him so completely, Princess, but what do I do now…? I’m in such a publically-visible position as your student, and so is he with his position as a high ranking officer in the Guard.”

Even as she kept her expression neutral, Celestia made no move to release her wing embracing Twilight. As much as she wanted to tell her to follow her heart’s wish, she could say nothing to that effect. Twilight had to come to her own decisions for the larger plan to play out in their favor. It was of utmost importance that those choices, whether success or mistake, were Twilight’s own choices alone.

“I’m afraid I can’t tell you that, Twilight. It is your life to live, and I must remain neutral on this important moment in your life. All I can say is that I will never turn you away for anything, so long as you continue to live a good life. Just know that I trust your judgement when you have thought something through. Now, considering the situation, we can talk more on this or, if you’d like, we can simply chat and snuggle for the rest of our lesson time.”

Twilight nuzzled against her mentor a little more, not entirely satisfied, but at least feeling much better. And thanks to all her crying, a lot less aroused, if still feeling the slowly drying remains of her marehood getting completely soaked. A content smile appeared on her face, the moment once again reminded her of how she looked to Celestia like a second mother to her, but had never said a word about it because of their respective positions.

“You know, Princess, it’s been some time since we last could do it, and you just let me vent a lot of stress. Have any of the Nobles done anything particularly egregious lately you’d like to poke fun at? Maybe Blue Lord one-upped his own most inane proposal again?”

Celestia tittered, now free to give Twilight a gentle squeeze and happy to spend simple personal time with one she treasured so dearly. “Oh my, yes. The newest one was wanting to tax hoof-made potato corks he heard about from…”

Ch 7 - Different Strokes For Different Folks

Author's Note

Contains: romantic first time, sappy moments, severe lust, perverted princess, wild sex, demanded impregnation, cum in womb, creampie, scary horny princess

Ok, wow. This chapter wound up running away with itself because Shining and Cadence kept working so well and flowing. This chapter has ended up with a surprising emotional rollercoaster of highs and lows, sap and sex.

I really wasn't expecting it to go like this, but it did. Should easily stay the longest chapter, at least. The rest lack the same level of dynamics and history involved here. :twilightsheepish:

Ch 7 - Different Strokes For Different Folks

Shining Armor was stunned, blinking slowly at the pink mare standing above him.

It wasn’t because he was speechless though.

No, he was physically stunned after Cadence, dressed in her full padded black sparring gear from head to hoof, her mane and tail in braids, had nearly outright tackled him with a full haymaker to the head. She had suddenly come out of nowhere while he was working a striking bag with his forehooves. His entire focus was on making hit after hit, simply ignoring the way his left shoulder felt.

In fact, she hit him so hard that he needed a moment to figure out which direction the floor was in, despite laying on it, as he somewhat dizzily stared up at her. And as he got his wits back, he realized he’d been so focused on the bag, he hadn’t done anything to react when she’d come charging towards him from where he should have easily seen her coming. He couldn’t claim it was a cheap shot when he was one that failed to react accordingly. She even yelled out a battlecry at me, but for the life of me, I can’t recall what she said.

“Buck, Cady! What’d I do now?! I haven’t even seen you all day and you suddenly get the drop on me from outta nowhere?!” Shining eyed her incredulously, wondering what his sometimes, maybe often, ok when wasn’t she, crazy best friend was doing this time.

Princess Cadence scowled, ears perked sharply forward and giving her wings a small, sharp flex. Her eyes looked fierce in a way that he’d seen make even combat veterans flinch when her gaze landed on them. “Shining Francis Armor, pick yourself up off that floor! We’re going a couple rounds right bucking now!”

Shining was suddenly very glad he’d been wearing full sparring gear himself, as the moment he got to his hooves Cadence started to attack, giving him no other option but to start blocking before anything else. With him forced to favor his hurt left shoulder, he already knew what the end result would be. He just wondered how long he’d last before she had him laid out on the mat again.

They had done the same thing numerous times, so Shining wasn’t completely off guard, but lacking the time to think, he couldn’t figure out what brought it on. Their rules were basic, only with full gear, and no magic. They trusted each other not to go too hard, well-experienced with how far they could take things together to vent in a very active fashion. And it was always the worst during Cadence’s estrus cycle. Which he realized she should be in the middle of now, in fact. The unintended sudden thought of helping her vent estrus stress in another, far more intimate, way caused him to make a bad block that let a jarring hit land on his good shoulder. At least she wasn’t teasing him on purpose. That always ended in pain and frustration.

For her end, Cadence was rather pissed off at her best friend and secret love. He’d dislocated his shoulder in sparring with another stallion the day before, it being a planned physical training week. Then, late this morning, Shining’s CO actually sent her a message that Shining was refusing to slow down, despite temporarily being on hold from sparring because of said shoulder.

According to what she’d been told, he simply turned to running and working out. While technically not in the wrong, his CO was asking her to pay him a visit, and hopefully figure out what was on his mind to drive him so hard. The almost ready to retire older stallion was pretty fond of Shining, and it wasn’t an official channel, which told Cadence plenty about how bad it was. She would have arrived sooner if her diplomatic meetings with the Maretanian dignitaries hadn’t taken so long. While they were generally pleasant and easy to deal with, if kind of stuffy, her constant worry about Shining possibly hurting himself had been stressing her out all day. That meant she was irritated in the extreme by the time she went to hunt him down.

She was pleased, if also still a little irked by it, to find him by himself in the officer’s private gym, already wearing his gear, so she got into her own sparring gear before rushing him. She was not in the mood for wasting any time starting to smack some sense into him by whatever means necessary.

Knowing how he got when faced with something serious, she’d been scared she would end up finding him in a hospital bed again. Three years already, and she’d still not entirely forgiven him for the mission that had nearly killed him. He had done the impossible by single-hoofedly holding back the demon that a cult had summoned and saved his wounded troops, and several dozen captive civilians, then collapsing in a pool of his own blood as reinforcements finally made it to them to finish the fight.

It was the only time she had ever used her rank as a princess to postpone a meeting of any kind, and she put aside several. From the very moment she was told he was in critical condition and for the three days it took after getting to the hospital, she had remained at his side until she knew he was no longer in the slightest danger of slipping away. He had crashed twice in the first few hours even after arriving at the military hospital, as close to death as he was that day.

Though heroic as he had been, she hated that medal Celestia gave him for his act of valour, the highest military honor she could bestow, always remembering what it nearly cost. He could have easily received it posthumously like most recipients. Self-sacrifice was as much a quality as a curse for him, as he simply pushed harder under all forms of stress. It didn’t matter if it was a battle or personal problems. He pushed until he dropped, if she didn’t do something to redirect him.

Hopefully someday soon, she could just screw the stupid out of him, but for now, pounding on his big dumb handsome flank would have to do.

Shining was forced to keep blocking over attempting many strikes because of his shoulder slowing him down. Shining was usually skilled enough to be one of the few unicorns that could beat the average pegasus in a melee, themselves generally more dominant in hoof to hoof because they could strike with their wings. On most days, he was also a step ahead of Cadence, herself quietly famous for rivaling almost any other member of the Guard at pure physical sparring. At least, those who dared to square off with her anyway.

Whether because of her rank, or her sparring reputation, only the better skilled veterans in the Guard, and the hilariously outclassed rookies, ever did so. He knew Cadence’s earth pony traits as an alicorn gave her the raw physical strength to easily rival the average Guard stallion. And Cadence had enough skill that she had even earned the informal nickname Love Ninja, after her uncanny flexibility, balance and speed, which left even some pegasi in a daze.

Of course, nopony admitted to how much it also applied to her love magic and matchmaking habits on any given day as well, but the veterans knew how much she loved discretely setting ponies up, whether they wanted her help or not. If she wasn’t right every single time, there’d probably be some actual complaints about it.

But Shining figured with how much she was a blur today, she was possibly, kind of, maybe, probably really mad at him for something.

Cadence whipped around, nearly folding herself in half sideways, spinning around on one foreleg and forcing him to dodge a wing strike that left him open to the now approaching padded hind hoof. Shining Armor was once again forced to ask himself why in Tartarus she liked him in such a way that she would sometimes merrily smack him around, like now, as her hoof connected soundly with his already hurting left shoulder and sent him back to the mat. It was all he could do to simply roll onto his back and hold up his right hoof in surrender, letting out a grunt when he landed and grimacing with his eyes closed at the flare of pain she’d just provided.

All things considered though, with as stupid as he’d been acting, it was what he’d been doing to himself the whole day already. The whole week, really. Simply because it hurt so much more to stop and think about having dinner with Twilight in two days and how he could possibly even begin to deal with everything surrounding his sister and their current situation.

“Oof!” Shining wheezed as Cadence sat on his stomach with only minimal care. The throbbing pain in his shoulder was kind of difficult to ignore for several seconds before he stared up at her. Why exactly do I like spending so much time with the lunatic of love again? Oh yes, because I’m an idiot masochist, and Cady’s completely crazy. And for some stupid reason I find that very attractive. Some days, I swear it’d be easier to jump off a cliff and walk away from the sudden stop at the bottom. Seriously, ow…

“Alright, Shiny. No more dodging or games. I want you to tell me what’s been bothering you so much this week. You’re not getting out of it this time, no matter what you do, so don’t even try to weasel out of it. If you don’t start talking, I’ll use my Blue Marble spell on you again until you cave.” Cadence had placed a foreleg on either side of his head as she hovered over him, unable to stop her secret thrill from knowing what it was so similar to, and she someday hoped to share it with him in bed. She just needed him to start pursuing her, to make the bucking connection that she wanted him as her coltfriend, not just her best friend. She suspected he had known for over two years now, but for some reason he never seemed ready to make that change and she could never figure out why.

Shining blinked before his eyes widened a little. “Don’t you dare! That spell is pure evil and made of crystallized torture for a stallion! Seriously, inducing a rampant and growing case of blue balls while preventing any possible erection to relieve it?! I still can’t believe you used it on me that one time! I don’t care that you asked first!”

Cadence remembered the day she tried convincing him to let her test it out on him a while ago. She’d planned to act like something went wrong and the only way to undo the spell would have been if he got an erection that went straight into her body in some way, or possibly just if she licked him, both of which were really just how the spell was constructed to deactivate in the first place. In the end, she’d chickened out when he couldn’t stand it anymore, and she’d lost that particular chance to break the weird friendzone-but-not-quite state their relationship was stuck in. Now, she was terrified that the new love for another pony he’d gained in the past couple months was going to take him away before he ever turned to her at all. She would never force him, but she also couldn’t understand how he seemed to love her as much as he did, yet never did anything about it!

Outwardly, Cadence was a well-trained graduate of Celestia’s school of poker face, only giving him a hard stare as she roughly pressed her nose against his. Even if she never got to have him, he was still her best friend in all the world, and she needed to know why he was hurting so much. “Then start talking, you dummy. What. is. wrong?!”

They stared at each other for several seconds before something in Shining broke free, forcing him to close his suddenly burning eyes and he turned his head to avoid her gaze. As he did, his right foreleg slipped around her and pulled her in tight against his chest, letting her know he was hurting inside without a word, and he was going to tell her when he figured out how to say it. Feeling her wings soon holding the back of his head as her body relaxed just seemed to make it harder to keep it together. Cadence was the only one that ever made him somehow be able to cry like a foal in private, if something big enough happened. Like when his grandmother passed away several years ago. He never did tell her just how much he loved her for it that day.

For a long stretch, all he could do was cling to her and let her presence calm him, eventually rubbing her back a little before meeting her eyes again. “You, uh, mind if we sit down somewhere more private than a gym first?”

“Mmm, I suppose we can. It’s a little after dinner already, so let’s just head back to my suite. Whatever’s going on, you can yell and scream there if you need to. Maybe even do that adorable blubbering for me again like that one time.” Cadence gave him a teasing, sympathetic smile and nuzzled him a little more intimately than just a friend, then stood up.

Shining sighed as he gave her a bemused look that slowly grew into a faint smirk. “You are such a weirdo for thinking I looked any sort of adorable or cute like that. I was a complete wreck. Is it a mare thing? Or just uniquely crazy you?”

Cadence only gave him a dazzling smile, her eyes glittering.

He snorted at the look in her eye and shook his head in mock dismay after he stood up, carefully rolling his shoulder as he grimaced. With much of the adrenaline and focus gone, it was far more troublesome, but he’d dealt with worse. Walking to her suite would be rough, but it’d help him stay focused for now.

…

A short while later, Shining was making use of a privilege only a very, very short list of ponies had. Laying next to the Princess of Love on her personal bed. The only other two allowed were just Twily and Princess Celestia herself, as far as he knew. Both of them were reclining on their backs, not touching but side by side. He always found himself secretly wondering what it would be like to wake up next to Cadence everyday someday, whenever he found himself where he was now. With everything they’d been through together, he knew he was going to finally bucking confess he loved her more than life itself. Falling in love with Twilight made him get it through his head that he truly couldn’t live without Cadence, and perhaps he’d get to wake up beside her from time to time soon.

Staring blankly at the ornate, frilly canopy of the bed, Shining sighed in a final resignation. I’ll start with confessing, I guess. I can’t go another day without doing so, but even as sure as I am about her feelings for me, it’s so hard to say it. Ugh, a bucking combat zone is easier to deal with. Maybe if…

“I…” He started, losing his voice for a moment and taking another deep breath. “Cady, I’ve seen those looks you give me when you think I’m not looking. The ones where you seem happy and sad at the same time. I… I’m not trying to deflect telling you what happened. This happens to be related for me and…” Shining had to pause at his own words in a moment of private bemusement. “And, well, it feels easier to start with that side of things before I go on. I have ideas, but will you tell me the real reason why this time?”

Cadence bit her bottom lip as she tensed, also staring at the canopy over the bed, her mane and tail brushed back out after they got back to her suite after she indulged in his offer to do it for her while he got his head together. The moment he asked that question, she suddenly felt very trapped. She could tell he was being honest in his request, so she had no real way to get around answering him. It was one of those rare moments she was reminded that Shining knew her far better than she let herself believe at times, and he had noticed her trying to be sneaky with those looks of frustrated desire. She had felt his love for her grow a surprising degree in the past couple months, but it grew at the same time his love for another had as well, which left her with her current worry of possibly losing him.

Even as Princess of Love, she had some things she was limited on. Such as him simply choosing another over her. Though she’d dragged him into a lot of mischief and fun over the years, she could never condone exercising her rank or magic to actually force his love. It was far too precious to her to spoil it like that, and she long ago decided she’d rather hurt from rejection than feel the guilt of that kind of coercion.

It wasn’t long before she found there were no fancy ways for her to say it, so she just kept it simple and honest as she looked at him, though her voice began at a near whisper. “B-because I’m terrified you’re going to love that other mare instead of me and I’ll never get to have you after trying so hard for so long to just get you to stop dodging and see me the way I see you but now you’ve fallen in love with that other mare and I have no idea if I still have a chance of keeping you for myself because you mean so much to me and I can’t believe it’s been so hard to just make you see how I feel about you but never wanted to push you and if you weren’t there anymore I really don’t know what my life would look like because I can’t even imagine my life without you around!”

Shining blinked as he listened, turning his head to stare at her halfway through as her voice rose nearly to a shout, a scared, tearful look in her eyes. Giving a slight cough and feeling like his heart was in his throat, he responded in a low tone, filled with more emotion than he quite knew what to do with as the words came out almost on their own. “Cady, I know. Well, I’ve suspected for years at least, but I have never felt I was good enough for you to even begin thinking I could ever deserve your love. I had been resigned to just staying your best friend for a long time now because of that. You can be the wildest, craziest mare I’ve ever met, that can kick more flank than a lot of the stallions under my command, yet at the drop of a hat, you turn into the most delicate, sweetest, most tender caregiver of foals I’ve ever seen, and pass through a doorway, suddenly the young but talented, highly skilled diplomat appears, helping build international treaties and mediating trade disputes. And then after all that, you slip into an evening gown and become an elite socialite, able to read the flow of the power games among the Nobles better than most, and dancing so elegantly when called for that there’s very few heads that don’t turn your way to watch in awe of you. All of it even manages to come across in such a way that you’re loved by just about every pony you meet and you somehow keep everything together in this impossible package of amazing that you somehow think I’m deserving enough to even be in the very presence of at all. Yeah, I might have had a good career in the Guard so far, and have some promising future prospects, but I’m still just a soldier. I still don’t know what I could ever offer you that you don’t already have mountains of.”

Cadence was staring at him, open-mouthed as her eyes watered, before she found her voice again. “Shining, I, it’s always just been you I wanted. To you, I’m never a princess when you’re not on duty and stuck obeying protocols. I’m just a mare you like to cheer up when I’m down, or crack a well-timed joke at because you’re trying to get me to laugh with a snort again. You make me feel special because you don’t treat me that way. And you’re the only stallion in Equestria that never lets me forget that time when we were teenagers that I was sick and sneezed all over your face with that stupidly large amount of snot I still can’t explain. It even left a connecting strand of it from my nose to yours for those awkward ten seconds of mutual shock, and yet you stayed at my bedside until I got better anyway. Besides, it’s not like I do all that stuff you said all in one day or something.”

He was long since used to the memory of what would forever be known between them as The Sneeze. Even the part where he’d had his mouth open to ask her something when it happened. That was the day he knew he had to love her in some deep way, because somehow he only spit into the bucket beside her bed and wiped off his face with a towel before immediately pretending it never happened. He was content to forget it entirely until she apologized profusely after she got better. He had teased her about it every once in awhile ever since. A well-placed call of Booger Princess was so completely foalish, but it never failed to make her blush in the cutest way.

In response to her attempted denial though, Shining just gave her a flat look. “Cady, all that stuff I just said was on the day of the Grand Galloping Gala a couple weeks ago.”

Cadence’s cheeks reddened, giving him a sheepish smile at that.

He’d given her compliments before, but what he just said was a whole different level. All it was missing was three direct words stating his feelings to be any more obvious.

A moment later, Cadence realized it had just happened. They would never be only friends after this. They were either on the cusp of finally pursuing their romance together, or it all just ended before her eyes. She needed to know the truth and she needed it without another moment of delay.

Moving like a crashing wave, Cadence rolled closer and pulled his face towards her as their lips met, crushing her mouth against his. They’d had a rare peck on the lips, but now there were no questions of intent or friendly touches. She tried to fill it with a feeling that all but screamed her love at him out loud.

The feeling of him responding in full a moment later was easily one of the greatest feelings she’d ever known. She didn’t even remember when their tongues started to dance together, just that she wanted more, and more, and more.

Cadence was soon laying on top of him, careful of his now wrapped left shoulder, the kiss ongoing as she began rocking against the bulge of his sheath. It was a foregone conclusion to her that she was finally going to have him inside her in a matter of another minute or two. With the privately created spell Celestia taught her, Cadence could enjoy every bit of her suppressed estrus in whatever degree she wanted and not have to worry about having a foal just yet. As soon as that idea even came to mind however, she immediately delighted in the knowledge she’d definitely give him one down the road. After all, a Captain of the Guard is fully capable of marrying a princess, if such a pair were so inclined…

Then, to her utter disbelief, just as she started to feel herself growing slick, and his sheath was swelling for her, he pushed her back and broke the kiss. At a loss with what was happening, she was just staring at him blankly as she panted in arousal, confused. “Sh-Shiny?”

Also panting, Shining brushed her cheek as he stared into her eyes, desire and regret in his own. “I, I’m so, so sorry I have to interrupt this right now, Cady, but I need to finish this talk before I could honestly be with you like that. Maybe after, but I-I, I can’t just…”

Seeing a tear slip from Shining’s eye sobered her up instantly. Whatever was going on, he was very right. They had to finish talking about whatever it was that had happened. The stallion she loved so much was clearly torn up inside from something and she needed to know why. Screwing each other’s brains out to celebrate finally admitting they loved each other could wait until this other problem was settled.

Snuggling against his side with absolutely no hesitation, Cadence held him as he pulled himself together. “You’re right. We need to talk first. No matter what though, you’re stuck with me now, Shiny. Unless you did something really dishonorable, which I’m positive isn’t the case because I know you too well, there is nothing that will make me let you go. Especially not now, understand? Maybe we’ll finish talking and get to make love tonight, or maybe it won’t feel right afterward and it can wait for tomorrow, but either way, I’m keeping you right here in my bed until morning, and until I know you’ve worked through whatever happened as much as possible. So start talking. I am here for you.”

Shining turned his head to her and softly kissed her nose as his eyes misted, annoyed that it was so hard to hold things back around her, and yet, he was desperately thankful she never failed to make him feel like he always could. “C-Cady, I… You know how I said I never felt good enough for you? Well, that’s kind of what got me into this mess. I, well, kinda went to that Blind Date Company dating service here in Canterlot a while ago. I know you’re a huge fan of what they do and figured I could make use of them. After a lot of thought, I wanted to try getting some sexual experience, hoping to gain some bedroom skills and extra confidence so I could finally work up the nerve to tell you how I felt about you. Maybe get a little more to offer you or something.” He sighed. “You’re right, too. I did meet a mare that I fell in love with. To be quite honest, I still might have lost my nerve in approaching you in the end, if my love for her hadn’t made me truly realize just how much you really mean to me, and I discovered I really can’t imagine my life without you either.”

Cadence felt her breath catch in her throat, not really sure how to respond. Various ideas passed through her mind. He wouldn’t actually ask for a threesome or something, would he? He’s never even hinted he’d be that kind of kinky. I’d certainly be willing to give this mare a chance if he does, at least. Still, to this day, there’s only one mare I’ve ever genuinely considered that way.

“I… I don’t know how it all happened, really,” Shining continued after a pause. “We had a first meeting and traded oral, immediately knowing we needed to meet again, despite her having asked that our first meeting have a sound barrier. She...she was so easy to talk to on our second meeting, and we traded oral again. A couple times when we met later, we never even got past talking and a few kisses because we lost ourselves in talking. Every few days or so when her schedule matched mine, that’s where I was going. I’m sorry I was too embarrassed to tell you sooner, but while at first I felt kind of lame for going, the more I cared about her, the more nervous telling you started to make me feel. It was only oral up until one of our more recent meetings, when she asked to have me in her plot. That was also when she asked if we could have a Reveal Room. Her estrus was coming up, and she was a virgin, so I tried to let her have every fantasy I could.”

For the first time in quite a while, Cadence found herself feeling a little bemused about something to do with sex. Still listening with her full attention, it wasn’t easy to keep her expression neutral and her lust out of her eyes. Everything that had happened this evening was giving her the weirdest mix of desire for him. Wonder if he even realizes it’s a bit rude to discuss having sex with one mare while in bed with another. Still, I love it when he’s so innocently being even a little kinky. I am going to pervert you repeatedly and oh so hard in the future, Shiny. You just wait. Finally getting to see a clear glimpse of what you might be into later, so I really hope you’re up for having our first time once this is over. It’ll be hard to sleep without having your dick fill me up tonight.

Unaware of her hidden thought processes or what she was planning for later, Shining looked at Cadence with a vulnerable expression that drew a compassionate look from her. “We met in that Reveal Room almost a week ago. Everything went smoothly until we were just about to climax and the blindfolds finally came off.” Shining visibly trembled as his eyes closed and pressed his nose into her neck as she held him a little tighter. “She panicked when she saw me and our horns were touching when she fizzled out both of us. The spells she’d cast on us kept us stuck together and left her cervix open as I filled her with everything I had. I… It was like nothing I’ve ever felt in an orgasm before, and I was so turned on that I couldn’t have stopped, even if we weren’t stuck together in that moment.

“When we recovered from what happened, we found out the spells were still active and neither of us could undo them. Because she gave me a stamina spell, there was no way I could stop myself from filling her several more times by the time the fizzle was over, and we realized even the contraceptive spells might have been damaged in the process. Maybe I could have resisted more, but when she said we should just give in and make love until the spells could be fixed, I did just that. She, she begged me to breed her because we’d probably never get another chance when there was nothing left to get in the way, since I’d already filled her once and we were stuck like that. We didn’t even notice the following three hours pass until the warning chime went off. We met back at her apartment a little after we left Blind Date and made love well into the night.”

Cadence was now honestly feeling confused. Who the heck was this mare that she’d panic at seeing him? Or make him react like this? The more she heard, apart from the unknown cause of the mare’s panic, the more it sounded like a really good night that Cadence would love to have him try to repeat in her own bed, aware that she was now rather jealous of this mystery mare. Don’t make me ask, Shiny. I think it’s best if you say it yourself. What is her name? Have I met her? It’d be really bucking kinky if you’re about to tell me you somehow ended up banging your own mother or something. You have no idea of the kinds of things I’ve talked about with Velvet, and I know she’s got quite the hidden wild side. Just ask Aunt Tia…

Shining sniffled as he pressed his nose against her neck again, gritting his teeth as he tried and failed to stop his eyes from starting to tear up. “We woke up the next morning and she checked. The contraceptive spells didn’t all make it, though the ones that did were only to keep her womb from accepting anything. I…” He gasped and held her a little tighter, “I somehow accidently fell in love with Twilight and got her pregnant, Cady! My sister! Even if she wasn’t going to stay pregnant, I still did it to her! You know how ponies would react, the kind of heat she’d get for it! I should have stopped it once we were able to get free but I realized I love her just as deeply as I love you and I just couldn’t! I can’t protect her from very much if we’re found out and I’m scared somepony would try to hurt her even though it was all on accident!”

Cadence felt her heart practically stop, almost absently holding him tighter as he began to shake quietly against her as his words ran out. A thousand things suddenly ran through her mind all at once, and her heart suddenly ached so very deeply for them both. Of all the mares in the world, it’s the only one I’ve ever and still…! Oh, Aunty, you weren’t kidding after bringing me into your work to prepare for the dangers coming our way, and me for the Empire’s return. I never expected just how painfully true it would be when you said the first time I couldn’t intervene for ponies I care deeply for was going to be the hardest thing I’ve ever not done. Twilight has to develop freely of her own will or everything falls apart. Still going to steal your bucking cake and eat it in front of you for this, after we have a very long talk and I tell you how pissed I am… At least I can take some solace that my role changes enough in a few years, so maybe I can help without you, if I can at all by that point. You’re always trapped in your own role, Aunty. Maybe forever, if I can’t figure something out when your sister Luna comes back. After the chain of events calms down enough though, I am so setting your flank up with somepony you can’t resist. Maybe I’ll even put Blind Date to use. I know how you are about a fit pegasus stallion. Heh, maybe even your own sister, or at least get her in on it, after what you admitted to. And then we’ll both steal your cake and eat it in front of you then, too.

It took a minute of letting Cadence carry him through the deep ache before Shining sniffled as he calmed back down, the outpouring always leaving him feeling so emasculated in a way, yet he was in the embrace of the one pony that made him never seem to care about being tough and keeping everything in. For a while, all he did was let her somehow make him feel shielded from the world in a way that left him free to let all of his walls down. After it happened the first time, he treasured his best friend’s, probably now marefriend’s, ability to help him clear his head in minutes over things that took him weeks or more in the past. He’d never admit it to anypony else, but he enjoyed the unique freedom Cadence provided that let him crumble without ever actually falling.

As he opened his mouth to speak once he’d pulled away, he blinked. Cadence had placed her hoof over his mouth with an enigmatic little smile like she sometimes wore.

“Shiny, first off, I’m actually perfectly fine with the fact you had sex with your sister.” Cadence smirked a little deviously before she managed to hide it again. Maybe someday she could tell him she had something of a fetish specifically towards the two of them getting busy, and how finding out they actually had was more than a little arousing. It was so much worse on hearing he even got her pregnant, however temporary. It all had her far too ready to jump his bone, and not just because of her estrus. I might even make you tell me every tiny, naughty little detail about it at some point later. Not sure I’ll even be capable of sleep at all tonight if you aren’t ready to fill me up after this, Shiny. Extremely tempted to see if you could even repeat it by doing the same to me in one night too, if I set the spells right. Buck, I hate it when I have to hold back like this with you during my estrus, even if it is suppressed. At least I know this is one of the last times I’ll ever have to hold back with you, and that dick is mine on demand hereafter because I know you’re such a pushover for me. Soon, my stallion. Soon you’ll get to learn all about the part of me I could never show you before, and the hidden lust in me, in so very, very many ways. Rawr, Shiny. Rawr… “There’s not really a biology problem or anything like that, either. Some races have one, but we equines don’t, for the most part. Second, you’re right. You’d both probably get some serious headaches if you were found out, but it is something that could be dealt with, if necessary. The way our society looks at incest is pretty bad, but knowing you, it’s probably all blown way out of proportion in your head right now.”

Cadence sighed, gently appearing resigned outside, while quite frustrated over need for non-interference within, a wing sliding over him to rub his belly comfortingly, with only the slightest bit of tease behind it. It had definitely proved to be an unusual day. “Third thing is… I can immediately see you need to work this out together with her. I’ll tell you right now that I’m not offering any other advice. This is me acting as the Princess of Love, Shining. Just know I’m not going anywhere, no matter what you two decide, ok? I love your sister too. And Twilight can be a very special exception to the fidelity you know I’ll expect of you, if it comes down to it. Don’t be afraid of any possible choice if it feels like the one you two need.” And I love her more than you both even know, but could never act on it because I knew she wasn’t ready. She’s gradually gotten close enough for me to start hinting soon, at least. Shiny, it has always, always been either you or her.

Shining, still unaware of Cadence’s hidden thoughts, touched a hoof to her cheek as he sniffed, a wave of relief slowly washing over him as he let her words run through his head. “Cady… You really… Uh, you really don’t mind about Twily?”

“I really don’t.” She gave him a warm smile, moving to place a wet kiss on his nose. “The two of you have always had the cutest relationship. Now, although it has become something far more involved, it is still all built on love. Talk it out with her and find out how the two of you need to deal with it for yourselves. I will support your decision, so long as it’s honest, ok?”

Feeling an overwhelming gratitude, all he could do was press his lips against hers. He immediately felt Cadence pushing back in the kiss with a passion, her tongue thrusting between his lips and into his mouth. Almost without a conscious effort on his part, he moved closer and they lay belly to belly on her bed, mouths locked together as things swiftly grew more heated.

It wasn’t long before Shining realized it was happening. It felt right and they would finally cross that one intimate line they’d apparently both wanted to cross for a long time. Feeling his sheath swelling, he had another moment of feeling unworthy of everything Cadence was, but then he relaxed and let the moment continue. As his shaft began to grow and harden between them, he felt her openly grind her heated marehood against his base. If it wasn’t for the constant dull throb of his left shoulder reminding him to be careful, it was unlikely he could have otherwise resisted the urge to push her onto her back and do everything he could to rile her up before impaling her on his cock. After years of her being the sole focus of his sexual fantasies, knowing they were so close now was getting him fired up on the idea alone.

Cadence was practically cheering inside as she slipped a pink forehoof between them to grab hold of the now stiff length rubbing against her. A shudder ran down her body as she felt more of the firm warmth he provided, grinding her marehood more firmly against him and panting at the knowledge she was starting to smear her own juices on him. It seemed like her biggest question in the moment was how much of her own essence she’d rub up and down his dick before taking him inside.

Then a thought struck her and she felt her marehood tingle. Pulling away from the kiss while she continued sliding her now quite slippery marehood against his dick, Cadence panted as she waited for his eyes to open before she said anything, relishing the lust she saw in his gaze. She had every every intention of taking full advantage of it. “Hah… Shiny, mind if I cast a couple of sex spells on us before we get carried away?”

Taking the pause to draw in some deep breaths, Shining gave her a smile as a question came to mind. “Wow… Uh, sure, if you want. And you never did say how you feel about me and Twilight though. This whole evening is weird at this point already, so mind if I ask what you really think of us together?”

As her eyes grew half-lidded and a sultry smile made it’s way to her lips, Cadence casually cast the various spells she was very well-practiced with as a private hobby. She had been preparing for their finally getting together for a long time, and intensity was something she was going to take every advantage of. She also included something a little advanced, but suspected he should be able to handle, after what he did with Twilight.

Though in response to his question, she had the perfect response. “Unf, Shiny. That’s what I think of you and Twilight.”

Shining blinked, feeling a little confused. “You think ‘unf’ about it?”

Cadence’s eyes twinkled with mirth at his obliviousness. “Unf. That’s everything I need to say and then some.”

A moment passed and it clicked, his eyes widening with surprise. “Wait… You mean unf unf? Like, that kind of unf?”

“Shining Armor, you are a blooded soldier, a well-trained killer. You have some pretty impressive battle victories on your record…” Cadence giggled at his expression as she licked her lips in just the right way to add to her hungry look. “And yet, you still manage to have to most adorable innocence at times. You can’t possibly get any cuter without actually being a certain mare you’ve recently bucked, and I am going to screw you senseless for it. By the way, that is a statement, not a question or a suggestion.”

Again, he blinked. She could sometimes be so incredibly casual about discussing sex that he still found himself caught off guard by it. You know, now that I’m actually at this point with Cady, I have to wonder about this side of her. It’s the one part of her life I’ve never really learned much about and I’m starting to get a window into it. Just what I have gotten myself into here?

Cadence had a few guesses to his thoughts as she watched his eyes, the same eyes she wanted to see the storm of climax in as often as she could. “Are you ready for me, Shiny? We’re already past that point of no return together, and I’d really, really like it if you and I could make love after I’ve wanted you for so long…”

He smiled, capturing her lips with a bit of hesitant shyness from how new it still was to be sharing so much with her, then pulled back again. “Cady, I know I’m not exactly well-practiced at sex, but give me time and I will gladly learn what makes you feel the best, if you show me. It’ll be tough for me tonight because of my shoulder, but however you want me to share this bed with you, say it. I’ll make this as good as I can. And before I somehow forget to say it another second: I love you, Cadence. I have loved you for a long time.”

Even with her inner fires stoked, Cadence felt her eyes mist at his sappy words as she smiled brightly. He was such a dork, and she loved him for it. It is getting really, really hard to keep myself contained, Shiny. Please do keep it up. I’ll certainly be keeping you up for a while. “I love you too, Shining. I can’t even say how good it feels to finally tell you and hear it back. I took care of the spells I wanted. And don’t worry about your shoulder, either. Tonight, I want do most of the work anyway. You’ll find out why soon enough… Are you ready for me?”

Shining opened his mouth to reply but words failed him as he laid there, pressed belly to belly with her, his fully erect cock slowly being stroked by her hoof. The warmth of her body, her scent and touch, the way he found it near impossible to break his eyes from hers, it all made the rest of the world vanish from his awareness for a moment. It was all he could do just to crush his lips to hers for his answer, feeling her shudder as she pressed back against him.

There was no more waiting for Cadence, pushing him onto his back and keeping her belly against his as she rose up over him. With his shoulder to consider, she decided she wasn’t going to let him move again for a while, if she had anything to say about it. It was hard for her to hold back, and only the knowledge she’d be free to let go after their first time was letting her keep herself in check.

Breaking the kiss, she rose up a bit higher, sliding her marehood up and down his shaft. She relished every ridge and bump as her petals slipped smoothly along his own turgid flesh. From the base to his tip, then back down and starting again, she made sure she didn’t miss a spot. Watching his eyes when she toyed with the head of his cock using her soaked flower added to the flames she was doing nothing to restrain anymore.

The things Cadence was doing to him were somehow almost more than Shining could process. He couldn’t tell if it was just pure anticipation, or if she was using some kind of trick. Each time he felt the lips of her marehood pause against his tip, his breath caught and his eyes widened, only to have her slip away from letting him inside one more time. Knowing it was going to happen, yet her continuously denying him, was clearly getting both of them more excited. And each time she teased him with entry, she added the tiniest bit more pressure. Let her marehood threaten to engulf him just a little bit more than the last time as he felt the head of his cock pushing her open to the point he thought it was finally the moment, only to have her pull away again.

Cadence smiled when she saw the time was right. His dick was wet with her own arousal and he had the tension she wanted to see in his eyes. Keeping her pace, she pressed his tip against her gate like before, then a faint pause like she was going to pull away again.

Instead, with the same constant pace she’d been sliding against him with, she didn’t shift her position as she moved this time, feeling tremors ripple through her body as the lips of her marehood closed behind his flare and sealed him in. With the steady slowness of before, she sank him all the way inside her body for the first time, pressing herself back until she had him hilted and let her weight rest on him. A foreleg came to rest on either side of his head as she stared down at him, her voluminous mane draped around their faces like a curtain, as if the world had become just the two of them. Despite the moment, Cadence couldn’t stop a few tears from slipping free as she finally crossed this line with the stallion she loved so completely, giving him a look and a smile of joy finally fulfilled. “You’re finally mine, Shining Armor. You don’t know how badly I’ve wanted this for so long.”

Shining wasn’t far off from her on his own side, struggling to draw deep breaths. After years of convincing himself he could only ever love her from afar, to be her best friend but never her stallion, he was struggling to take in the turn of events. Even if deep and true, his recently gained feelings for Twilight were still a new love. Unlike that connection, his love for Cadence had gone through years of silent repression and apparently unnecessary forced denial, despite long knowing he’d never be able to stop loving her.

Now it was not just acknowledged and returned, but fulfilled by joining his body to hers. While he didn’t know what all the fluttering inside her body was telling him exactly, he had a feeling he would come to know a lot about her intimate responses in due time. He barely noticed his eyes were burning as he touched a hoof to her cheek and drew her closer. “After all the years I spent thinking I could never have you, I finally do. Cadence…”

Their lips met as they both shuddered and clung to each other. Shining was so far gone he hardly noticed his shoulder complain as he held her tight to his chest with both forelegs, feeling her doing the same. The kiss became a touch of noses as they drank in each other’s presence for a long time, unable to do more than stare at each other, despite how turned on they both were. It was a moment that demanded to be relished before anything else could happen, and they had no arguments.

In those fleeting moments, they also knew without any doubt that this was it for them.

This love was for life.

When the moment felt right, Cadence slowly lifted herself back up so she was sitting on his dick, squeezing her inner muscles as the fires inside began to take priority. She felt euphoric in her heart from the burst of love they’d just shared, and now she wanted her whole body to feel the physical equivalent as she smiled, sniffling as she wiped at her eyes with her wings. “Y-you dork. Making me get all teary eyed when you’re supposed to be filling me with every drop of cum you’ve got. You ready to go the rest of the way, honey?”

Shining brushed a fetlock over his own eyes and smiled, feeling things starting to shift more towards what he was expecting before this all actually happened. Celestia help him if the stallions under his command ever found out the sappy details of today, but he wouldn’t trade it for the world. “Honey, huh? I like that. And I’m more than ready at this point, Cady.”

Taking her cue, Cadence slowly began rocking herself against him. She saw his eyes dance with a growing desire as she ever so lightly slid over his cock. It was very tempting to just close her eyes and let herself get lost in the way he felt inside her, yet seeing his eyes shift with each little change she made was something she couldn’t let herself miss. Every little change in how she squeezed him with her inner muscles reflected back at her as she watched.

She could lose herself in just the sensations after she took him over the edge the first time and took his release where she wanted it so badly. And with her rising urges beginning to require conscious control again already, she had every intention of ravishing the stallion beneath and inside her.

As Cadence began to slide herself up and down his shaft, Shining could only pant as he stared back at her. He wanted to look down, to watch himself sliding into her with each stroke, but her eyes held him, a helpless prisoner that could do no more than rock his hips against her when she came down and observe the glimmer of her eyes, the way they seemed to delight each time she took his entire length back inside to stimulate her depths.

He soon saw her eyes slip closed as her chin turned up, mouth hanging open, her quiet gasps escaping as she slid up and down his cock just far enough his medial ring slipped free before she began to move back down. He marveled at how her beauty shone all the more amazing in sexual bliss, the way her perfectly toned form quivered with each drop as she gradually increased her speed. If not for his practiced self-control, he was convinced he’d have already been pushed to climax. Were this only a one-time event, he could spend the rest of his life getting off to this single vision.

Cadence couldn’t stop a whine from escaping as her self-control frayed from approaching her first orgasm with Shining inside her. She’d lost the fight and her eyes had closed, the need to relish the sensation of him slipping through her soaking folds getting too strong to ignore as her head tilted towards the ceiling with her eyes shut. If she pressed down on him just the right way, she could even feel his tip barely graze her cervix, the sensation driving her nuts and causing her marehood to spasm. Though he was barely starting to, she couldn’t wait until his flare swelled just before he gave her what she wanted so badly. It wasn’t hard to realize she wasn’t going to keep her control much longer, hoping to keep their first time sweet and tender as long as possible.

Shining felt himself inexorably approaching his finish line as the pressure built. The way she was riding him had grown increasingly fast and firm, the wet sounds of her taking him all the way inside on each downward push, added to his rising need to release. When he felt her suddenly clamp down on him and let out a moan, he had a moment to think she had just climaxed herself until she started to say things he’d never thought he’d hear come out of her mouth.

“Nnnf, in me! You need to bucking cum inside me!” Cadence said in a heated tone as she rode her stallion’s dick. Her control was slipping away as her estrus-fueled lust grew too strong to restrain, and words she’d been holding back began to escape. “In me, Shiny! Buck, I want it all inside!”

She fell forward onto her forehooves, hips in constant motion as she worked him over with furious intent. Her mouth wouldn’t stop anymore. “You know I’m in estrus and you won’t stop! You’re going to squirt it all inside my womb if you do! I made sure of it with a spell! Bucking fill me!”

Her blazing eyes locked onto Shining’s own as he stared at her, helpless to her motions and his own need to keep pushing back against her. He had seen a lot of expressions on her, but the raw, unquestionable storm of lust burning in her eyes made his heart skip a beat. It was unsettlingly arousing to see that much raw hunger, to see she was ready to simply devour him in her lust.

“Aaah! Buck! I made sure my egg is waiting for your cum, Shiny! If you fill me now I’ll get pregnant! I want it!” Cadence growled as she slowly got closer to his face, her hips crashing against him. She could feel his flare growing as he got closer, and it drove her crazy. “I want your bucking foal inside me!”

Shining panted as he felt himself being dragged towards his climax, eyes widening at what she’d just said. Though part of him registered they’d have some talking to do later, most of his mind fixated on her telling him to impregnate her. After recent events, it struck a chord in him, causing him to thrust against her harder than before. The urge to put his mark in a fertile mare for a second time quickly driving his need higher as he strained. The moment when he would shoot his liquid claim inside her was getting close, and he couldn’t get there fast enough.

Cadence ground herself on his dick with each thrust, her passage rippling in anticipation as she shoved her nose against him and laid her horn next to his own. She wasn’t going to miss her chance to blow his bucking mind as she snarled, tingles racing all over her body. Her wings had his head trapped as she made the tip of his dick touch her cervix as often as possible, knowing where she wanted to feel him burst. “Nnrgh! Give me that cum you already proved to be so fertile! Cum inside your princess!”

She locked her eyes on his as her magic readied, feeling his flare spreading her open deep within as the moment hit and the spell activated into both their horns, shouting the last words she could as their mutual orgasm finally struck. “Get me bucking pregnant! Bucking breed me like you bred your sister!”

There was a moment where Shining felt like the world stopped as he yanked her as far down onto his cock as he could, his eyes widening as her words hit. Then the impact of his orgasm crashed down upon him like an avalanche and all he could do was cry out from the intensity. The barest familiarity registered as every pulse of his cock seemed to knock the wind out of his lungs and his eyes rolled back from the staggering level of sensations all over his body.

Cadence felt the first burst of Shining’s cum blast through her open cervix and deep into her womb as she jammed him as deep inside herself as she could. A scream tore itself free as he finally gave her what she wanted so badly. Her whole focus was his pulsing dick pouring everything he had inside her. Her wings spread wide, quivering with every heated dose of his load she received. With rampant desire, she kept her marehood milking his spurting shaft the entire time, craving and savoring every drop of his seed he provided.

…

It was several minutes before Shining managed to drag himself back from an oddly familiar fuge of orgasm, though needing a bit longer to get his thoughts together. He was not expecting to find Cadence looking at him with a playful twinkle in her eye and the absolute biggest cat-that-ate-the-canary grin he had ever seen. In all the time he’d known her, he wasn’t sure he’d ever seen her look more outright pleased with herself, and smug about it.

“Welcome back to Equestria, honey. Enjoy your trip?” Cadence asked with a purr, her smile grew just a little more smug.

Shining blinked a little slowly. He remembered something about cum and pregnancy. “Wha…?”

“You have no idea how pleased I was to find out about your first time with Twilight. It told me you could remain conscious if I tried that. It’s not as fun if you pass out in the middle of an orgasm that powerful and miss most of it. I wanted you to never, ever forget how I made you cum the first time we made love. Did you enjoy your first time with me?” Her smile was only seeming to get bigger, her husky voice still a sultry purr that dripped with blatant sensuality.

All he could do was manage a weak nod, blinking slowly as he stared at her, just trying to get his brain to function again. Shining’s entire body was still tingling, it was like countless mini-orgasms kept firing off, gradually tapering away over time. He had thought what happened with Twilight had been powerful, but whatever Cadance had just done was indescribable.

“And before you even say it, I meant what I said about getting me pregnant. I didn’t protect the egg waiting inside for you with any contraceptive spells, but I did protect my womb, just like you experienced with your sister. I’m going to enjoy having my estrus end early for once, even if I won’t stay pregnant, so don’t worry. But mark my words, honey…” Cadence touched her nose to his again, eyes half-lidded and speaking with an even more sultry low growl. “I will give you foals in the future. Just not yet, because we need to talk about it first and plan ahead when we feel ready for it. Together.”

Shining closed his eyes and rubbed the side of his head with his right forehoof before looking at her again. “Buck, Cady, that was really bucking intense! And I… I’m glad you planned on us not having a foal just yet. I was worried for a bit there, with how crazy you were acting. And yes, I would love to have a foal with you later on. When we’re ready.” He coughed for a moment, feeling his still buried cock twitch as it began to recover already. “So, uh, what the buck did you do exactly?”

Cadence hummed as she gave him a peck on the lips, her stare slowly getting more intense as she felt his dick firming back up inside her. “Honey, I have something of a secret hobby. I love sex, and I love sex spells. I might have given up on having sex with anypony the moment I realized I was in love with you, but I didn’t stop studying sex spells and practicing them. The one I just used on you was barely even a medium-level spell for enhancing orgasms. Wait till I show you one of my masturbation sessions and I’ll show you how I get during one of the more powerful solo ones. After you’ve had some time to get used to cumming like that when you’re with me…” She stretched her neck out so her lips were by his ear, her breath caressing the fine hairs there, her voice dropping into a soft, throaty purr. “They’ll get… even better…”

A deep quiver ran through his form as Shining heard that at the same time she started rocking against him again, letting his shaft slide around inside her with casual slowness. He wasn’t sure he could take anything stronger than what she’d just done to him. He still felt incredibly sensitive, which was a novel experience. “A-and the… That last comment you made before we came together?”

She kept up her slow rocking motions as her eyes locked on his again, an amorous smirk came to her lips as she leaned in close. “You haven’t learned about this side of me yet, but I am far more lusty than I ever let show. Especially when I’m going through my estrus. In fact, Aunty Tia taught me a much more powerful estrus suppression spell that still isn’t quite enough to block all of the effects I go through. My deep attunement to love and sex makes everything about it far more powerful for me, including desire and fertility. I’m going to enjoy teaching you just how strong my self-control is tonight, because I’m going to take the spell off completely and stop restraining my lust for you. I have years of lusting after you to work through before I can keep my calm during sex and I expect you to make sure to make sure my fire gets put out from now on, firepony…”

His heart began beating a bit faster, starting to wonder again just what he’d gotten himself into. He tried not to even think about that last part and what happened last week. “Uh, ok… You still didn’t answer my question though.”

The tip of her tongue grazed his lips as she kept moving and kept staring at him with the same lusty smirk and half-lidded eyes. “Because… Finding out what happened with Twilight turns me on… And I’d love to hear the story of when you first had sex, too. Those stories are another turn on for me, strange as it might sound.”

Shining couldn’t help the small blush that warmed his cheeks as he gave her a sheepish smile. “I, uh… It’s pretty embarrassing but, well, despite my sometimes making it sound like I wasn’t a virgin for a while, I kinda gave my virginity to Twilight last week.”

Cadence froze as her eyes widened in sudden shock, only able to blink at him for a second before she could talk. “You… You actually innocently fell in love with your sister, gave your virginity to each other, shared a first time mutual orgasm way stronger than normal as you came straight into her womb during her estrus, made love for several hours as a first night together, and got her pregnant. All at once?!”

His blush grew a little as he let out a strained laugh as he saw her eyes smouldering, her nostrils flaring as her breathing starting to deepen. “Heh, um, yes…?”

A terrible, devious, hungry smile split Cadence’s face as she rose back up a little. It was just a quick flick of magic and her full estrus suppression was gone. Just sex and contraceptive spells remained. The suppression had just become meaningless before the level of her arousal anyway.

Cadence spoke in a deadly calm voice with that same smile. “I am going to buck you now, honey. I am going to buck you and buck you hard. Sometimes I’ll keep every drop inside, maybe let my belly swell up with your warm, delicious cum, and sometimes I’ll let it go everywhere it wants as you keep spraying more and more inside me because of the stamina spell I put on you. You are going to cum a lot, and it will all go inside me first. If I want it anywhere else on or in me if I’m not swallowing your dick whole to guzzle down your seed, you will watch as I squeeze your cum out of my marehood to swallow or rub into my coat, and I can already tell you I am thirsty for the taste of you. You are going to cum hard all night and I will make certain you can’t walk straight by morning, if you can walk at all when I’m done with you. And if you can’t walk or don’t otherwise leave, I will buck you for most of the day, too. You are my buck toy now and I am going to love every second of this and every splash of cum you give me. And you will love it as you cum so hard you are left dizzy for the light ones!”

Then her voice became suddenly intense, heavy breaths adding to the way she snarled at him, her teeth gritting in lustful fury. “I am going to buck you so hard, our bucking grandfoals will feel the afterglow!”

Shining looked at her in shock. He now really wondered what he’d gotten himself into. “Oh. Buck. Me.”

She was aware he had no real clue yet, but he definitely would by morning. Cadence’s voice was more of a heated, animalistic growl with still growing lust, just before she crushed her lips to his and got started on ravaging her stallion’s dick.

“I intend to, honey. I intend to.”

Ch 8 - Certain In Uncertainty

Author's Note

Contains: incest, reluctance, teasing, estrus sex, creampie, cum in womb, sappy romantic lovemaking

By this point, there's enough pieces in place to see some things coming. Sappy is good. :pinkiecrazy:

Next chapter, there shall be much :facehoof: :trollestia:

Ch 8 - Certain In Uncertainty

Twilight Sparkle paced back and forth in her living room, feeling anxious about meeting with her brother for dinner that evening. There just hadn’t been enough time to sort herself out before the day arrived, and it was incredibly nerve-wracking to feel so out of control of her life.

Her worrying that she couldn’t think clearly on the morning they parted ways, after all the lovemaking they had done, had in fact caused her to make an obvious mistake. She should have told him a full month, or something. Anything. Not just one week.

Once Twilight’s hormones had settled back to normal, her estrus cycle had merrily come back to trouble her as well. Except now, her body had fallen victim to a natural hiccup of her own biology. Namely, teasing her estrus with very real satisfaction from Shining temporarily getting her pregnant, and then her letting it go out of necessity, had made her estrus come back with a vengeance like it was foal mad over stolen cookies. Tea had no effect on her now, and estrus suppression spells burned out a lot faster than normal. To make matters worse, because of how they worked, the estrus suppressor spells had to run their course before being recast. Unlike the thankfully fully refreshed three contraceptive spells she made sure remained intact just for her peace of mind, themselves designed to last a minimum of two weeks even without being re-energized.

She sighed, again pausing in her endless nervous pacing to stare at the floor at her forehooves. Studying had been increasingly difficult over the course of the week as the urge for sex had grown. Princess Celestia had at least been kind enough to give her a reduced lesson plan so Twilight had more time to tend to her personal needs. Even if my suppressor spell burns out even faster than the last one while Shining Armor is still here, and I get to have him one last time, feeling him shaking in the ecstasy I gave him, pulsing inside me as my womb fills with every warm drop of his… Gah! No! I can’t think like that right now! I need to keep my head clear so we can make logical, smart decisions about us accidentally falling in love and how we should deal with it!

It didn’t help, that in addition to her estrus running rampant, the suppressor spells had been behaving erratically on how long they’d last. With times running anywhere from eight hours, down to less than one hour, it was a frustrating predicament. As it was, she’d just endured over two hours of her full overactive estrus just so she could use the spell shortly before Shining’s expected arrival for dinner. Her cheeks warmed as she recalled how furiously she’d been masturbating for most of that time, unable to stop picturing her brother working her over instead of a rubber fake. Twilight knew that if he’d shown up right then, he would have been her dinner. She couldn’t help the flash of guilt the knowledge gave her, even though she knew it wasn’t even logical to be guilty for it.

Back and forth she went in her head, sometimes pacing and sometimes just staring at her hooves, until the dreaded time finally arrived with a modest knock on her front door.

Steeling herself before pulling it open, Twilight blinked in confusion and suddenly found herself at a loss for words to the sight before her eyes.

For lack of a nicer way of putting it, she thought her brother looked half dead, haggard and worn out. He had his left foreleg in a sling, and there were serious bags under his oddly vacant eyes. Even his usually well-kept mane seemed very frazzled. “Um, Shiny? Are you ok?”

Shining Armor gave her a weak, sheepish smile. “I’m fine. Just kind of tired is all.”

Privately, Shining gave a small shudder inside. Twenty. Seven. Hours. All without stopping. Even when I needed to eat, Cady was gulping down a load or two with her lips around the base… Yeesh, if it wasn’t for bathroom breaks, I probably wouldn’t have even a single moment’s rest. Unbelievably amazing as it was while she was in action, this hangover from excessive sex is gonna kill me if it happens again anytime soon, but at least she confirmed she burned off nearly all of her pent-up lust. Been a fun day, stuck waking up at the crack of dawn to get the missed day of duty. She might have given me a royal order to remain with her for the day, but it doesn’t mean the work stopped coming in. And having General Hardass laugh himself to tears when I privately admitted why Cady suddenly ordered my temporary leave was just embarrassing. It’ll be really nice to just spend some quiet time with Twily for a while as we sort our situation out. She’s far less crazy than Cadence.

“Work out too hard for PT week?” Twilight questioned, glancing at his left foreleg in the sling as he limped past her so she could close the door.

He coughed lightly, grumbling out, “Something like that, yeah. The dislocated shoulder is from a sparring accident a few days ago.” He paused, deciding to just be honest as he glanced down before looking at his sister again. “Actually… I, uh, kinda let myself get lost in working out for the week because I kept worrying about things between us. Things have changed forever, no matter what we do about it from here, Twily. I worry it’ll mess something up between us, and we will never find a way to fix things again.”

Giving him a soft smile as she stepped close and nuzzled his cheek, there was comfort in the warm familiarity of his scent. Twilight spoke in a quiet voice. “I know. We’ll talk after we eat. It’ll give us a little time to think of what we want to say, now that we’re here together.”

The two of them soon settled at the dinner table to eat without fanfare. Ordinary small talk and banter, much like they’d shared their whole life as siblings, passed back and forth as they ate their meal of ordinary penne pasta and sauce. It was one of the few things Twilight felt comfortable making, and between the food and banter, it all felt surprisingly normal. When dinner was over, both of them left the table feeling that, just maybe, not quite everything had to change as they went down new paths.

Sitting quietly together on the couch, Twilight snuggled up against Shining’s right side, his foreleg around her shoulders. Nothing was said for the first few minutes as they stared off into space, having no need to rush as they thoroughly relished being close. The simple comfort of being together in the moment further helped ease their worries, as the idea that they could find a comfortable solution gradually seemed more attainable. And having made arrangements for Spike to spend the night at the castle again like the previous weekend, they were free to talk without risk of him hearing or interrupting, once the moment was right.

“So…” They both started at the same time, glancing at each other with small chuckles.

Shining gave his sister’s soft cheek a gentle nuzzle. “You go first, Twily.”

Twilight returned the nuzzle and wiggled just a little closer to her brother, enjoying the warmth of his body next to hers, and how despite his muscle, he was so completely comfortable to rest against. A lavender hoof rubbed idly against the fur of his chest as she spoke. “I… I still haven’t really decided on what I want to do, Shiny. I tried listing the pros and cons of everything, even came up with a scoring system to help me identify the risk and reward factors of this thing between us. I, I keep feeling like I have the wrong answer because I can’t separate myself from the emotions involved. It’s hard to objectively figure out the best course of what to do.

“I love you. I somehow love you so much it hurts inside. But at the same time, I have to think of other factors, like how it would affect Spike. He’s still so young and innocent, and I can only imagine the kind of stuff he’d be exposed to from other ponies if you and I decided to pursue our love out in the open. I might have Princess Celestia’s favor in a lot of ways too, but she could probably only get involved if things got really bad first.”

Giving her a gentle squeeze, Shining sighed with a deep frown. Tucking her head under his chin, the scent of her mane was wonderfully familiar as he held her tight. “I wish I could just make this all better, Twily. I really wish I could, but I can’t this time. BBBFF powers or not. Maybe the question just comes down to how much we’re willing to suffer to be together? I know Cadence would fully support us, no matter what. Or maybe we’re thinking about it wrong and we could be together without anypony unpleasant ever knowing? I tried to think it through this week and kept getting more and more frustrated, which is part of why I look so worn out. And you’re right about needing to consider how this would affect Spike, too. I can’t believe just how much I love you, and yet still feel so trapped that I can’t just act on my love for you without serious thought. Sometimes I toy with the idea of just forgetting it happened. That maybe giving you a chance at finding a stallion that can openly love you like you deserve is best, but it kills me to think of anypony else getting to have you.”

Twilight felt herself tremble from an ache in her heart before she rolled herself around to hug him fully, chest to chest as she held him tight. She often did it when they were younger, always feeling secure against her big and strong older brother. Burying her face in his neck, she forced away the feeling of her estrus teasingly reminding her that she was now straddling his lap. Instead, she just focused on the soft warmth he radiated. The comforting feeling of his right forehoof gently rubbing her back chased away much of the heartache at least. For several quiet minutes, they didn’t move or speak, simply appreciated the mutual comfort the other was giving.

Eventually, Twilight lifted her head after placing a soft kiss on his neck before meeting his eyes. “Shiny, I think we need more time to think. There are a lot of factors that are going to take a lot of time to process. Especially since I’m still in estrus, and not really able to keep my head consistently clear right now.”

Shining stared at his sister, momentarily frozen when her nose stopped an inch from his and he swore he saw desire flit briefly across her face. A mirrored desire of his own flashed through him, knowing he couldn’t hide at first either. “Not much I can say there. Whatever you need though, just ask and I’ll do it. How much time do you want?”

The longer she stared into his eyes, the closer Twilight felt herself getting, the feel of his breath playing across her lips wasn’t doing anything to dissuade her, even as she kept reminding herself it shouldn’t happen, that they needed to have clear heads before anything happened between them again. “I, I don’t know yet. Maybe I just need some distance until I have a handle on it and I could tell you. I… W-we…”

Twilight’s resistance broke just then, and she knew what she was going to do, even as she continued to question and doubt herself. I really can’t tell if I’m doing this because my estrus suppressor spell might be wearing out early or not, but do I even care when I love him this much?

Shining’s eyes widened as hers fell shut, Twilight’s lips pressed against his as she held him tighter. Despite knowing they weren’t in the clearest of minds, he couldn’t deny her a kiss, pressing back as their lips moved together with slow burning passion.

It wasn’t until Shining felt her starting to rock her hips against him that he snapped out of the daze, realizing she’d put herself in a risky position. Her faint rocking motions were pressing her marehood right against his sheath, causing him to push her back as he kept himself in check, both of them breathing a little faster than before. “Twily, what are you doing?”

Twilight bit her bottom lip for a moment, still making faint rocking motions as she kept her eye on him. She felt herself tingle from anticipation when she felt his sheath shift and swell slightly beneath her. “Shiny, I… I need to know what it’s like when we’re not lost in the moment and just going with it. I love you so much, and I need to know what it’s like to be with you just because we wanted to make love. No shock, no panic. No haze of lust keeping us almost trapped. Just feeling each other intimately again after we’ve been together before.”

Swallowing despite his dry mouth, Shining held onto his composure, even as her rocking motions gradually got more insistent and he had to restrain himself more. He could feel the heat of her pressing against his sheath, and the dampness she was rubbing against him. “Twilight, I want to as well, but neither of us is thinking straight right now. Maybe we should hold off until we have this figured out.”

She could feel herself getting wetter as she pressed herself against him more firmly, a small shiver running down her spine from knowing his gradually swelling sheath was starting to be smeared with her own arousal. She held his gaze as she rocked against him, biting her bottom lip again as she didn’t even bother trying to hide her need from reaching her eyes anymore.

Shining knew he wasn’t really resisting very much, feeling a particular liquid warmth spreading around the opening of his sheath and making restraining his cock more difficult. Her aroused scent was a heady, enticing thing as it filled the air. The look in her eyes and the way she bit her lip as she sat on his lap was doing nothing to help him resist. “We, we really shouldn’t…”

Twilight’s horn lit up as her brother watched her, not knowing she quickly cast the spells to open her cervix for his seed at orgasm, and to keep it all locked deep inside, unsure if her estrus suppression spell had faded or if she just needed him that badly. She knew what she wanted now, what she needed, and how much he’d put inside her. She saw his eyes widen at the part of her magic he would be able to notice, when she used her magic to spread open her marehood right against his sheath, the tip of his cock now peeking at the edge as her entrance was spread open against it. She only gave him a heated stare as she continued to grind against him.

He tried to say something, to deny how much he wanted her, maybe even claim how utterly exhausted he was from his time with Cadence, yet nothing came to his lips. Twilight’s softly panting breaths were like desperate pleas that called out to him. He knew he was going to lose this fight if he couldn’t express why they should hold off, but was losing all desire to do so as he kept getting more aroused, gradually overcoming his reluctance with each beat of his pulse making him swell up just a fraction more. The way her spread marehood slipped against the leading edge of his tip told him she was soaking wet. For me, or from her estrus? Does that even matter when I’m was the only one she wants to begin with?

Leaning just a little closer, the fur of their lips brushing against each other with feather-light touches, Twilight felt her brother’s arousal finally reach high enough that the head of his cock stuck out sufficiently for her to make her move. As she pressed herself down again, still holding herself wide open, a circle of her hips spread more of her own copious arousal around the head of his shaft. The lips of her open core glided against him with a tingling smoothness, before she centered herself and let herself rest directly over his sheath again. The edge of his flare rubbed between her spread vaginal lips slightly before she released them, feeling herself close behind his warm flare and trapping his tip fully inside. A shudder ran up her body as she let her marehood tug encouragingly at his slowly growing length, knowing she’d get to feel him harden inside her body until he touched her cervix again.

Her voice was a sultry, desperate whisper. “You’re inside me again, Shiny. Stop holding back and let me feel your love again. Make love with me. I need you big brother. Please…”

Shining gasped when he felt her close around the head of his cock and her inner passage began to tug gently at him to go deeper as they both went still. Giving in to his own need, his unrestrained arousal was a like a sudden surge as he smoothly spread her open. As his shaft speared slowly upwards through her core, he heard her let out a long shuddery gasp, then a soft whimper when he finally touched her cervix again. When her lips found his, he had no resistance left. His tongue met hers readily as her body quivered around him.

Twilight felt a happy tear escape and roll down her cheek as she kissed him, starting to rock herself gently on his buried length again. In some ways, this time felt even better than before. She still had her worries, but for the moment she could put them away. Her world felt complete and right with her BBBFF physically joined with her in the oldest dance. While tempted to move more urgently, to let his whole shaft slide in and out of her body until she came to the feeling of him spraying his own climax inside her, the moment of gentle, tender passion felt too good for her to interrupt.

The pair worked their bodies against each other in small motions, feeling a certain desperation that demanded he remain deep inside her and not pull away very far. It was similar to the first couple of hours where they’d been stuck together after they learned each other’s real identity. Yet, even without being stuck, the feeling of being so joined kept resonating through them. They were making love together with each passionate gasp or slippery grind that let his tip press straight against her cervix. It was unhurried, loving passion.

At some point along the way, Twilight finally felt his flare starting to spread her open deep within. Time meant nothing to her, and knowing she was going to bring her brother to release made her feel somehow even warmer. Breaking their deep kiss to nibble at one of his ears again, she panted her faint, whispered words right into his ear. “Inside, big brother. Every drop will go right in my womb again. Aaah~... Please, give me your love where I need it most.”

Shining never stopped his steady rocking motions, only an inch of his length slipping out before pushing fully back inside her, his right foreleg pulling her down with each push. He could feel the tingles of a powerful climax building, ignoring the urge to go faster and just letting it rise at it’s own pace. He whispered back to her, a desperate need in his voice. “Y-you’re still in estrus. Twily, if I do that…”

Twilight struggled to keep her breathing under control as she panted, feeling her own orgasm nearing and meeting every push inside her, pressing him as deep as she could. It was moments later that she felt her cervix getting pulled and spread open as his flare grew close to it’s widest. “A-and if I-I said I want you to get me p-pregnant again? That maybe m-my uterus is unprotected because I want you to gift me with a foal b-because I love you s-so much?”

Pulling away just enough so he could press his nose to hers, Shining met her eyes. For a moment, nothing scared him, and he only gave her a loving smile. Pulling her more firmly onto his shaft as their impending peak grew, he gave her a hoarse whisper. “I’d say to look into my eyes as I put all the love I have inside you…”

She tried to make a sound as she saw the lack of hesitation in his eyes, but her voice was snatched away as their mutual orgasm finally took hold. As she struggled to even breathe, pulses of intimate warmth began to flow deep within her trembling body, passing through her inner gate to rest in her most sacred of spaces. Their eyes remaining locked on each other as they watched and shared each other’s pleasure breaking over them like a long-lasting wave of electric ecstasy.

Neither was entirely sure when their shared climax ended, as they didn’t move a muscle, just remaining still as they stared into each other’s eyes. Whether seconds or minutes had passed by then, neither could tell.

All they knew right then came bubbling out of them at the same time, tears welling in their eyes from their total conviction and absolute certainty.

“This love is for life.”

They needed no more discussion than that. They were going to love each other as lovers for the rest of their lives. And they would never have to worry that it would somehow change, no matter what happened down the road.

Eventually, Twilight curled in against him and held him tight, feeling him hold her close in return. She could easily have fallen asleep right where she was, his shaft staying fully inside her, and the feel of liquid warmth now securely held inside her womb. She felt completely comfortable right where she was, but didn’t want him to feel uncomfortable by staying in his upright position too long. She knew he’d let her sleep all night right here if she ask, but letting him be uncomfortable was not going to happen.

Once she felt it was time, Twilight sat back up and gave him a warm, loving smile. “Shiny, do you think you can stay the night?”

He returned her smile with relaxed ease, though there was a faint note of resigned acceptance. “Thankfully, tomorrow is a partial day off for me after PT week, so yes, I can. I do have to get back around noon, but that leaves me all yours for the whole morning. So, we’re, uh, probably going to have a foal, huh?”

For a moment, Twilight was confused. And then her mind registered what she’d done.

Twilight’s face exploded with a brilliant blush and she initially only managed a horribly embarrassed squeak, forehooves covering her face. It took her a minute to find her voice, feeling more than a little ashamed as she slowly lowered her hooves, ears folded back against her head as she looked down. “Shiny, I… I don’t know what came over me in that moment. Please don’t be mad, but I still have the same contraceptive spells in place on my womb from before. W-we, well, I could drop the spells if you really want me to. I could even apply a fertility spell if we want to be even more sure… Um, I--mmf…!”

Shining’s hoof touching her lips made her go silent, though relieved at seeing he was still smiling. “Ok, no. No need to go down that road, sis. Honestly, while I was completely ready to, if that wasn’t obvious enough from my filling you up without a single regret in doing so, I’m kinda relieved it was really just a question and it’s not actually going to happen. And before you even respond, I will say this…”

He took his hoof away from her lips before capturing them with his own for several seconds, then pulled away to meet her eyes again. “That only means ‘not yet’ for us. We’re not really ready to have a foal right now, but I think I’d really like to someday. When we’re ready.”

Twilight stared at him in surprise for several seconds, then the emotional dam simply burst. She crashed against his chest and half laughed, half cried into his coat as she held him tight. Her happy tears soaked into his fur as she let the feel of just how much he accepted them being together wash over her with a deluge of joy.

A wide smile beamed back at him when she finally lifted her head, wiping her eyes with a fetlock. “I’m so happy to hear that, Shiny. I know it will probably be a long time from now, but no matter what happens between us and whatever we decide to do with our relationship, I would love give you a foal when the time is right. I want that someday. I want that so much.” But I still don’t have any idea what to do long term. Maybe I can ask Cadence for advice. I know you have a thing for her, and I hope you get her so somepony worthy can love you openly, but I also hope she wouldn’t mind you and I being together, at least in some way. Not like my crush on her is ever going to lead anywhere. She’s just never been interested in mares.

Shining simply smiled back, briefly glancing at a clock. “Well, while we still might not know what we should do about us yet, do you feel ready to go to bed now? In one way or another? It’s already after ten.” And I’ll have to tell you about things with Cadence soon. She did give me explicit permission to be with you, but maybe I’ll hold onto that until we figure things out between us. Heh, never thought my special forces endurance training would be useful for sex, but I can keep going a while longer if you want me to, Twily. So long as you’re happy.

Twilight gave him a nod as she slowly lifted herself off of his half-hard length, a delighted shiver of satisfaction passing through her as he slipped free. “I think that sounds like a good idea. I’m honestly not sure if I want to make love again or not just yet. You managed to satisfy my estrus surprisingly well with that one orgasm. If nothing else, I’ll get to snuggle against you under the covers and sleep very, very well.”

She saw him smile mischievously for a second, then could only give a playful yelp in surprise before she started giggling when he lifted her in his magic and set her on his back. Twilight wrapped her forelegs around his neck as he carried her off to her bed with a casual air that made her eyes mist, even if he was limping on three legs and could be mistaken for being nearly dead on his hooves at first glance.

The two of them felt confident that no matter what might come up as they figured it all out, no matter how hard it might get if they became open about it, at least they knew for certain they would hold tight to their love. Whatever else, they would always be able to share that now.

Ch 9 - Hearth's Warming Headaches

Author's Note

Contains: incest, seduction, kissing, sixty-nine, vaginal sex, cum in womb, mild cum inflation, caught in the act, forced surprise orgasm, amazing parenting skills

If any weird formatting got missed, let me know. Uploading the chapter from Gdocs caused a trainwreck of weird errors I had to fix. No idea why.

This chapter kind of ran away with itself. Hope people enjoy this one. Still heavy on sex, but it's becoming more story-centric than earlier. That moment when you realize your clopfic has become a story with sex...

I love how this one ends. :trollestia:

Ch 9 - Hearth's Warming Headaches

It was a late hour. The usual Hearth’s Warming celebrations were long over.

Shining Armor made a slow and quiet walk down the familiar wood-paneled hallway of the home he grew up in. His parents had long since gone to bed. He slipped out of the room he had lived in for his entire colthood, another familiar place as his destination. He looked back over the early years of his life spent in this house. Countless memories he would always cherish were made in just a single hall.

A warm smile came to his features as he recalled playing games with Twilight. He remembered things that one could describe as a lifetime ago for them. A time when she was not long out of diapers, and himself yet to get his own cutie mark. He never admitted it out loud to anyone just how much he loved the games he’d played with his little sister. How she’d squeal with delight when he pounced at her without warning, when she tried to be stealthy and sneak up on him. Or the times he pretended he didn’t hear her coming up behind him, the hardwood floor calling out her steps. Letting her pounce on him instead for the sounds she made. Making her squeal with laughter was once the sound he treasured above all others.

His smile grew a little more at his next thought, his cheeks warming in the private space of the darkened hallway. Shining’s new favorite sound lay split between two that were almost the same, if he was honest with himself. The sound he loved most was the sounds of an orgasm taking hold over Twilight or Cadence. Hearing each of them gasp, mewl, or scream because he’d given them pleasure. He doubted he would ever get enough of either.

The faintest sigh escaped as he neared his sister’s foalhood bedroom door. She was staying in her old bed for the holiday. His only real regret about all that had happened was just how hard it was to meet up with Twilight. How hard it was to meet for more than a lunch every month or so ever since pure blind chance brought them a deep love to share. It seemed chance had also let their free time match up just long enough to meet at Blind Date so they fell in love. To realize they would never let go of each other as lovers despite the challenges ahead. And ever since, they seemed unable to manage even a single private moment.

Now, they finally had a chance to reconnect after several months of little time to see each other.

It wasn’t Cadence’s fault, despite her role in events. Shining was given increasing high-level official duties and diplomatic appearances. His CO was the Captain of the Guard, after all. Upon learning that Shining had begun dating Cadence in private, General Hardass had begun to demand far more of him than before. Shining did recognize his CO was doing it to help prepare him. For what life would be like if, really more of a when, he married a Princess. Shining had also been summoned to a private meeting by Princess Celestia. He still heard what she had told him that day, those fateful words simple and heavy with importance. It was hardly more than a week ago now. After that meeting, it made all the more sense why he’d been working harder than was expected of his current position in the Guard.

Less free time, and a much more dynamic schedule. It made it hard to get any time away without going on scheduled leave. He felt a built up sense of guilt over having so many opportunities to spend time with his Cady, but not his Twily.

He was still a little surprised with how supportive Cadence was about him being in love with Twilight. She was often quite open in her trying to help him spend time with his sister. Even if it was just toying with schedules so he could squeeze in an occasional lunch date. And it was often at the expense of him spending the same time with Cadence herself. All she ever says about it is ‘because I love you both’ and gives me that same strange smile I can’t help but feel is hiding something. Sometimes she gets a look in her eye, and I swear she wants to come with me for some reason.

Shining stopped in front of Twilight’s door, knowing it was unlocked and she would be waiting for him. She’d held his attention with a sultry look in her eye earlier. She told him not to bother knocking on her door and to just come inside when he was ready.

He loved how much of a tease she could be when she wanted to.

Finally, they could have some private time together without worrying over interruptions. After having had no time to for a private chance to talk, at last they could. They hadn't even been able to share so much as a kiss for fear somepony would see.

A small wave of self-consciousness made Shining check himself over to ensure he looked reasonably his best. He took the time to smooth out his coat and mane a bit more. Even though he knew they would snuggle up in bed together, among other things. A quick breath check said the mint was doing it’s job as well.

He was stuck giving Twilight so little of himself most of the time. Because of that, he tried hard to give her his best whenever he could. The century old, early-edition, obscure enchanting reference he’d given her earlier contained a few hard to find rare spells left out of later versions. It was one he knew she’d been looking for. It had cost him more effort and bits than he let on, but it was well worth it. He would’ve gladly spent twice that if he could see her eyes glimmer so much every day.

Once he was as satisfied as he would get, he took a calming breath and reminded himself not to rush anything. Difficult though it was right now, they had every intention of being together for life. Later, they hoped to plan out and arrange their lives so they had more time for each other. They had a lot of time to make it work so they could be ready to have a foal together like they wanted.

Shining relished the anticipation of joining his sister in her bed. He let his magic quietly open the door to Twilight’s dimly lit room. The moonlight coming in through the window as the only source of light, casting all in a silver glow.

When he turned to the bed after the door shut, his breath caught at the vision that lay before him.

Twilight Sparkle lay on her bed with the covers pushed away, letting the chill of the winter’s night prickle across her body. She’d placed a silent charm in the hallway so she could be ready when he came in. Hiding under the covers for warmth until he approached. She would never so much as breathe a word of doing so, but she had looked at some Playcolt magazines and other relevant materials once plans had been set. All for researching the best way to tempt the stallion she loved on this night. It had been her naughtiest checklist ever.

Laying on her bed in a pool of silver moonlight streaming through the window, Twilight was resting on her left side. As she eyed him, her left forehoof was holding up her head. Her right lay just so over her side so her hoof seemed ready to caress her exposed lower belly beside the strategic placement of her tail. Almost as though she were about to rub herself intimately before his eyes.

A sultry smile graced her features as she tried her best to give him a subtle yet hungry look. One laden with confidence she didn’t feel, and half hidden in the shadows drawn by the moon. She had checked earlier with a mirror she’d placed by the door to make sure her face was angled just right. Now letting him only see half of her face in the moon’s silvery glow. The visible eye staring at him with the full intensity of her desire for him.

Her mane lay draped behind her, with a careful few locks allowed to hang in front. A delightful shiver of anticipation traveled through her. The wet lips of her sacred treasure felt the crispness in the air. Her tail was a paltry blanket against the chill as it teased him and hid her already aroused body from his view. Her right hind leg was turned up and set perpendicular to her left as she reclined, hind legs open to his eyes. Her position allowed him to see the full length of her prone form in an open invitation.

She had also ensured her scent was thick in air of the room and watched his nostrils flare. He took an obvious deep breath as the spell keeping it back from the door was finally allowed to roll over him. To let the scent of her arousal finish filling the area. The same spell would keep the scent of sex from leaving the room. Something she had every intention of putting to good use tonight. I want to feel you inside me again, big brother…

Judging by the floored expression on his handsome face, her effort to be seductive and sexy for him had paid off. She could see his shaft filling out beneath him. Further clear evidence of the effect she’d had. Twilight’s arousal climbed higher with a tingle in her core. She knew she would soon have his entire thick turgid length within herself. And she would feel him release all that wonderful hot semen inside her. All because she brought him to the peak of pleasure with her own body.

Her facade of confidence slipped for a moment. She was struggling to keep her own focus, finally getting to be alone with her brother again. Her last planned move to entice him left her lips as a wispy erotic promise. Her desire to make it perfect for him held, despite the nerve-wracking brief stutter that almost made her crack. She had practiced so many times with the mirror. She emphasized just the right words to tease him with exactly what she wanted him to do to her. “P-please, my love. I need you on this cold winter’s night, for I am quite desperately chilled. Will you please fill me with the heat of your love so I might feel it deep inside and be warm again?”

Shining found himself moving forward without quite recalling how to walk. The movement becoming a mystery like all other thoughts beyond the mare before him. He hardly registered his cock twitching beneath him. Already prepared for what was going to happen. The very idea of them talking first was now a long forgotten notion. Twilight had him completely enthralled with desire for her. He struggled to resist the urge to just leap upon her and make her scream for him. Cady, you just got a challenger for sexy. How is it I somehow have two mares of such unparalleled value? I am unworthy…

Reaching the bed, his eyes remained locked on hers as he got closer. Shining panted as he slowed down the closer he was. He savored the moment as his hooves touched the sheets and he drew near to her. Twilight turned her head to him as their lips finally connected. A faint, happy moan sounding in her throat as their tongues joined in their efforts. It was a kiss that was long overdue.

Just as Shining went to push her towards her back so he could really get started, he felt a gentle hoof push him back. Curious, he let her nudge him back and met her eyes. He already missed the warmth of her lips and tongue against his own. His voice was low, speaking through now heavier breaths. “What’s on your mind?”

Twilight’s eyes were half-lidded, a desirous smile on her face. “I want you in me, Shiny. I want to feel you fill me. But first, we should make sure each other is ready. Will you put that lovely tongue of yours to use and make sure I’m ready to receive every last inch of you?”

Shining felt a faint shiver run through him. He could only wonder where Twilight was getting all this from even as he smirked. “Twily, if you want me to taste your body again, you only had to ask.”

As he began making light kisses down her neck and chest, she made little coos when he nibbled on her. A matter of moments passed before he noticed a nudging touch against his body. Glancing up told him Twilight’s horn was active. Once she met his eye, she smiled with mischief as his hindquarters made a gradual move towards her head. A second later, he realized she had said they should make sure each other was ready. Finally registering what she was doing, he soon found himself laying on his left side beside her. Both their faces now close to each other’s sensitive areas.

Twilight found herself staring at the rigid length before her. She leaned in so she could rub her face against it. The time apart left her missing the special masculine scent that liked to linger in her fur until she washed. At last, she could relish the warmth in his shaft again and did so. Her lips soon brushed across his flare, feeling his precum smearing over them. Licking her lips clean, she let more rub into the fur around her mouth and started to nibble at his flare. It was a little hard to focus when feeling her brother’s hot breath and lips tickling around near her marehood. He was taking his time like she was.

Rather than diving right in, Shining enjoyed the act of worshiping her body. He kissed, nibbled and licked around her inner thighs and belly in a vague spiral. Drawing ever closer to where the end of her tail still concealed her soaking core. He could feel the quiver of her muscles and the little gasps escaping her. Even while he tried not to let the feeling of her exploring his cock steal too much of his focus. A gasp of his own accompanied a small thrust against her lips when he felt her tongue drag across the head.

Not to be outdone, Shining let his tongue run over the sticky hairs of her tail hiding her marehood from view. His magic working slow as he pulled her tail out of the way and sucking some of her arousal away from the strands. A small shudder went through her as he began to nibble on the petals of her flower. Growing hungry for more of her excited taste on his tongue.

As she tongued the base of his shaft, Twilight relished the feel of his hot tongue making direct contact. The temperature difference from the chilly air was tremendous. The slippery touch of his mouth was almost burning by contrast.

Pushing things along, she began licking up the length of his shaft as her free hoof made slow strokes. Her lips giving extra attention to his sensitive medial ring before moving on. With a careful motion, she let her nose drag up the underside, a hoof in place to control any twitches of his body. She let the head of his cock drag over her nose and lips. Letting his built up fluids smear across them and pulling herself away. Twilight let his anticipation build as she licked her lips and nose clean of his taste. Then she opened wide to slip his entire flare into her mouth in one motion and began to nurse on his tip. Her tongue traveled all over the sensitive surface to taste as much of him as she could.

Shining couldn’t resist letting out a groan as he felt her lips close around his tip. Hips thrusting forward in response and finding she didn’t resist or stop the motion. His sister letting him slide deeper into her mouth until he felt the back of her throat. As she finally gave him a signal to hold still, she began to bob her head. He returned his attention to her slippery marehood. He followed her cue by letting his tongue slide right between her lips. He grazed his tongue across her entrance to tease her. The moan he felt through her mouth around him had him repeating it. Probing at the door of her inner passage with his tongue as he spread her lips apart. After a moment to lash his tongue against her clitoris, his tongue stabbed inside her. The sudden motion caused her to arch her back as Twilight gasped in pleasured surprise. His tip fell from her open lips as he drew out her reaction.

Twilight needed a second to collect herself. She felt her brother’s tongue starting to stir her up far more than she already was. Soon slipping his length back into her mouth and bobbing her head with greater urgency. This time, she didn’t stop as she let him in. Only slowing for a deep breath before she let his flare slip into her throat. When she began trying to swallow by reflex, she just let him slide in even deeper, sucking him in with each gulp. Her tongue lashed against his medial ring as it passed. Twilight shuddered at the feeling of him sliding across her tongue as he stretched her throat wide.

Struggling to keep moving, Shining moved his tongue around everywhere inside her. He kept some of his attention to when she was getting close. He tried to restrain himself. Yet, feeling Twilight’s throat constricting as her lips bumped against his base was more than he could stand. He had let himself go without for days in preparation for tonight. Then just when he thought his tingling flare was going to grant her his seed, his climb stopped. Twilight took it slow as she pulled herself off of his length. Her tongue swirling around his tip before she released it. All he could do was pant, bewildered at how he hadn’t gone off even when he had been on the edge.

Once she’d let his tip free, Twilight took a full breath as her horn dimmed. Getting so close left her quivering a little from her own interrupted peak and she gave a soft hum. “Mmm… Can’t have you releasing too soon, big brother. I’ve been waiting too long to feel you pulsing inside me as I orgasm around you. Turn around for me?”

Swallowing more of her unique flavor, Shining lifted himself up and laid back down beside her on his right. It let them face each other and he shuffled closer until he lay pressed belly to belly with her. He felt his length laying against the soft, warm fur of her stomach. He enjoyed how the base of his shaft pressed right against her sopping marehood. The way those lips molded part way around his girth hinted at the way they would welcome him inside soon. “Hah… I’m guessing you did something to stop me from going off?”

Twilight let out a soft giggle, staring into his eyes with loving desire. “Yeah. I can get a taste of your semen later. This first time after so long, I want it all inside me where it belongs. And… Um…”

He looked at his sister as she seemed to grow a bit bashful, her cheeks blooming before she spoke.

“This time, no spells or anything between us. Make love to me as we snuggle up under the covers and keep each other warm.” She nosed in under his chin as she pulled the blankets up over them. The cold that had been seeping into them despite their intimate efforts soon began to recede. Her every breath caressed his throat in soft airy touches. “I might not be in estrus this time, but there’s also nothing protecting my womb right now. I want to be absolutely full of your potent sperm, big brother.”

She pulled back to look him in the eyes, her own misting as she gave him a smile that expressed how much she loved him. “Please remind me that this isn’t just a dream. We can play with sex spells after this and some time to talk. Finish this last little part of making me your mare, Shining.”

All he could do was wrap his forelegs around her and pull her in closer, nuzzling her with a tender smile. When the moment felt right, he pulled back to meet her eyes.

With a slow movement, his hips drew back. One hoof nudged his shaft down. His tip dragged across the fur of her quivering belly until it found the slippery gate to her depths. Their eyes remained locked as gentle pressure spread her open for him. Her warm folds soon closed behind his flare with a faint squeezing tug. It was like her body was glad to hold him inside again. Quiet sounds escaped as they joined their bodies once more. Their smiles small yet glowing at finally being together again.

Gentle thrusts saw Shining’s length sink further into her body. Soft pants let their breaths trace across each other’s mouths. They did not need a kiss to feel more intimate. Twilight first gave a faint gasp when his medial ring slipped inside. Then a helpless groan of relief as she curled against her brother. He went still as he finished sliding into her depths, his tip resting against her cervix.

It had been months.

Months had gone by and they were finally joined again. If not for the delicious tension of promised pleasure, the calm relief both felt could have let them fall asleep. There was no need to move again at first. Just laying on their sides together and sharing warmth almost as one body. An almost empty feeling now driven away with a sudden realization of fullness. A difference unnoticed until it changed in that moment and their now renewed physical union. They didn’t even notice their heartbeats falling into step with that of their partner.

Shining stroked her back with a hoof, both of them now covered by up to their necks by the blankets of her bed. The steady motions of her inner muscles were a loving massage. A request for what he would provide her with soon enough. He tried to say something, but the words died in his throat before they could form. Shining's eyes misting as her heard her faint sniffle. Deep emotion shone in her eyes when she finally looked at him again, filling him with a different kind of warmth. With a small bit of his magic, Shining brushed at a wayward lock of the mane he had known for so much of his life, tucking it behind her ear.

An unspoken cue saw both of them begin to grind against each other. Twilight soon found herself trembling whenever his tip pressed against her cervix. She relished the knowledge that everything was natural tonight. Nothing between them. She let herself indulge in the wish that it was in the middle of spring, instead of Hearth’s Warming and winter.

Thoughts floated across her mind of getting to share each other’s bodies down the road. To feel him pulsing inside during her estrus in a few years as he gave her his foal. Just the idea made it more intense. Her brother would have to get used to sleeping next to her once he finally could get her pregnant. There was no way she’d leave his side by choice after that. Once they got their lives in position to raise a foal together, they planned to. It would just take time. The rewards were worth the wait. At least, that was her most desired fantasy. Twilight hoped fantasy wasn't all she'd ever have.

Tonight at least, his seed would rest in her womb. She needed to feel it again so much. To have the warmth of his thick semen sliding inside her body, filling her womb until some point in the morning. Twilight made a soft gasp from the feel of her brother moving inside her as he built them up towards orgasm. The only stallion she desired filling her mind at the same time he worked to fill her body. Please, Shining…

The feel of her slick tunnel, combined with their earlier close call, had Shining feeling his peak drawing near. From how she was holding him and quivering, he knew Twilight wasn’t far off either. He made slow, steady thrusts into the wet warmth she surrounded him with. Only the faintest sounds of their union heard alongside their quiet pants. There was no need to rush as he felt his widening flare touch her deepest gate with each return. He realized his sister was going to climax when he poured his claim inside her. Both enjoyed knowing there was nothing stopping anything tonight. Her body was his.

He had every intention to make love to her during her estrus down the road. And to continue doing so until his foal was inside her. Until they were ready though, turning her into a drooling mess of pleasure would suffice.

Twilight could feel herself rising higher as his flare grew. She had to resist the urge to make him go faster. To make her cry out his name behind the bubble of silence that kept all their sounds of pleasure within the room. She would get there soon enough. Their still locked eyes never shifting even as they panted harder as the moment drew near. Another unspoken cue and their heads angled. Their horns touched. Both found themselves unable to look away from the rising storm of pleasure the other was feeling. His pace picked up, drawing more of his length back before returning. The ball of tension inside her was growing tight.

Shining thrust one last time as he twitched within her passage. Both of them narrowed their eyes as they gasped. Their magic mixed between their horns with a faint tingle. Whispers of what the other felt crossing their connection. His buried length at last sent his seed crashing against her cervix.

Twilight clamped down her inner muscles. His warm flood pushing her over the edge of climax. Orgasmic spasms left her trembling against him, breathless. Much to her own pleasure, the feel of foreign warmth slipping deeper within made itself known. Her body was his.

A low whine sounded in Twilight’s throat. The knowledge he had claimed her in every physical way possible drew her lips to his as her eyes fell shut, tongue invading his mouth. Her inner muscles kept rolling along his shaft, trying to milk every drop out of him. Doing what she could to squeeze more of it past her deepest gate as it began to slip past his flare to fill the rest of her quivering tunnel.

She needed it filling her, estrus or not. She wanted him to know his essence made it all the way through as she tried to squeeze him harder. The hind leg hooked around him trying to push him deeper as his potent gift was working it's way into the womb that belonged to him. Twilight's resistance finally broke as her magic rolled along his shaft down her tunnel. She took the mass of seed and pushed it past her cervix in a steady flow, welcoming every drop into her core.

She hoped he felt her putting all his seed where it belonged. Twilight shuddered at the liquid warmth that proved she was his again. She had no doubt that no other stallion’s seed would ever touch her.

Someday, she hoped to be free to let him breed her. Twilight wanted to feel him worshiping her pregnant belly as he made love to her. Wanted him to know anything he wanted of her was his at a word. She kissed him more fiercely. How she wished he’d start pulsing inside her again a second time. Oh Celestia, is something wrong with me that all I want is to swell up with your seed again? Make me burst on your cock more, big brother!

Shining couldn’t help the shudder that traveled through him, unaware of his sister’s thoughts as he met her passionate kiss. He felt the tickle of magic that passed along his length inside her. Then a shift around his tip touching her cervix. It made him suspect she had shoved his cum into her womb again. It was beyond arousing to know she wanted it that deep inside her so much. If I wasn’t already coming down from one…

Their shared grinding motions to prolong the moment were slow to taper off. Soon, they were panting softly as they stared into each other’s eyes, content to remain connected. There were a thousand things to say, yet not a word needed to be said.

For Twilight, it was relief and release in finally having him all to herself again. Just savoring the feeling of being his mare after having to hide how much she loved him whenever she saw him.

For Shining, it was relief and reassurance that, despite the struggle over more than half a year, their love was still powerful. Just like when they shared so much at the start back in the spring.

Twilight stared into her brother’s eyes, sated for the moment. Her face held a faint, lazy smile of sexual bliss from having his semen in her womb once again. If she wasn’t sure of it being her fetish before, she had no doubts of the truth now, speaking in a low, husky tone. “I want to be swollen with your seed by morning, Shiny. Think you’re up for making me feel like a thoroughly satisfied, well-bucked mare again?”

He gave a sly smirk in return. “Give me that stamina spell and I’ll keep you up all night if I have to. I won’t stop until you say so.” Then he pulled her in close, tucking her head under his chin. “I’ve missed getting to show you how much I love you, Twily.”

“Mmm…” Cuddling a little deeper into his strong chest, Twilight felt content. The warmth of what he put inside her and snuggling in his embrace him gave her great relief. She felt the tension and stress of waiting just melting away like she was breaking through the surface of a pool for a breath of much needed air.

After a short time to focus on that, she gave her brother’s neck a nuzzle before she spoke. “You know, Princess Celestia told me about her private meeting with you. You’re to be officially declared as the successor to the current Captain of the Guard next month. And that Captain Hardass will retire just before spring. I’m proud of you, Shiny.”

Shining gave a soft hum, one hoof making slow strokes along her back. “It’s definitely going to be a change. Mostly just means I’ll have even less free time, more than anything else though. Hardass has been giving me most of the relevant workload since you and I figured things out. I’m sorry I haven’t been able to give you the time you deserve, Twily. I’d even started planning on setting up a vacation trip with you for this coming summer. You know, before my responsibilities changed. I’d hoped to steal you away for a week somewhere that nopony would care. A place far enough where we wouldn’t have to hide for little while.”

“While that idea sounds lovely, I do understand. Princess Celestia has been giving me extra assignments for months, too. I think there’s something important coming up that she hasn’t mentioned to me. I’m not certain, but it might have something to do with the next Summer Sun Celebration being the 1000th year. I’m wondering if she wants me to attempt some kind of special magic for the festivities as a test. It’s just more general studies so far." Twilight sighed and held her brother a little tighter, her voice growing a touch forlorn. “So… You and Cadence, huh?”

Giving her a soft squeeze as he winced, Shining told her the truth. “Yeah. We’re dating. I’m sorry I couldn’t tell you sooner. We're keeping it out of the public view for now. I couldn’t risk somepony overhearing when out to lunch with you. I wanted to tell you, but earlier today was the first time we’ve been in any kind of private space together in all this time.”

Twilight nuzzled him a little harder, unsure how she felt. On one side, she was thrilled that her brother was dating somepony she herself thought the world of. She was glad he could have somepony so wonderful that could love him out in the open. On the other side, she was jealous. She wished it was her that got to have him without worrying over how others might react. She also worried he would have to let go of what they had at some point.

“I, I know you tried to tell me earlier that it doesn’t change anything between us, and I do feel a lot more sure of that, now that I have proof sitting inside me…” Twilight gave his half-hard cock a squeeze with her inner muscles, earning twitch. “Just... I’m still worried you’re going to tell me we have to give each other up. I won’t ask you to lie to her for us to stay together. I want to know everything we have is honest and real and never anything to regret. I-If…,” Twilight took a steadying breath as she gathered herself. “If you… Shiny, I can let you go if I have to. I won’t be able to live with myself if I forced you to start being dishonest about us. I feel guilty enough as it is already. I won’t let our love be tainted like that.”

Shining just smiled, still rubbing her back as he held his sister close. “Well, it’s a good thing Cady actually gave me explicit permission to keep loving you, isn’t it?”

Pulling back until she could meet his eyes, Twilight stared at him with a look between confusion and alarm. “Wait, you told her about us?! When? What did she say? She’s not going to tell anypony, is she? And why didn’t she tell me she knew?! I had a chance to spend time with her two weeks ago!”

“Twily, shush! Those panic attacks might be kind of adorable, but you stop that right now.” Shining touched his nose to hers with a grin and rubbed against her until he saw she was ready to hold her tongue, then leaned back with calm confidence. “First, I actually told her two days before you and I had that dinner to talk things out and we made love on the couch. Cadence and I actually started dating the same day I told her, in fact. I was losing my head and I had to spill my guts to her because I’d been such a mess that she wouldn’t let me off the hook. And no, she won’t tell anypony, so don’t worry about that.”

Shining then gave his sister a brief kiss. “I just told you she gave me permission to keep loving you. And what she thinks? Well, who do you think is responsible for me having an open spot in my schedule at the same time you did so I could meet you for the occasional lunch over the past several months? She has tried to help make sure I see you as often as possible. Usually, it's by having those same lunches alone as a result, knowing she gets to have me more often than you do. Twily, she genuinely wants you and me to stay together. While she can’t do much, she’s even trying to help us. Cadence didn’t say anything because we both felt it was best if I told you myself. If we’d had a private moment sooner, I would have told you then. I’m sorry it’s taken until Hearth’s Warming to do it.”

Staring at her brother for several seconds, Twilight let it filter through her mind. As she did, she tucked her head under her brother’s chin again. She just wanted to be held for a little while.

After all the freaking out in private about what might happen if they were found out, Twilight was at a loss on how to respond to a positive result. Still, despite the relief, it made some of her feelings of guilt grow. She loved Cadence. A lot. Even harbored secret wishes of getting to be in love with the mare, as unlikely as that was. Just the idea she could be doing her wrong by accident made her heart ache. Twilight was grateful that wasn't a problem after all.

Of all ponies in her life, knowing Cadence approved of Shining and herself was growing into a relief so deep it brought tears to her eyes. The ponies we love rejecting us when finding out was my absolute biggest worry.

Heaving a sigh with her nose buried against his neck, Twilight found her voice again. “I guess Cadence and I have a lot to talk about the next time I can meet with her. But are you ok dealing with two mares? One of whom could even ruin your career overnight if we’re discovered?”

Shining gave her a firm squeeze, earning a tiny squeak from his sister. “Twily, I don’t care about that. What we have matters more to me than a Guard career. As for handling two hot mares at once? Well, that part’s easy. I’m mean, it’s me we’re talking ab--ouch!”

Twilight’s horn dimmed after giving his ear a sharp flick to express her thoughts, face still buried in his neck as she hid her smile. The easy tone of his response said more than his words.

A hoof massaged the sting in his ear for a few moments before returning to her back. “Ok, ok. Guess I’m not allowed to be proud about having two amazing mares that somehow think I’m worth enough for both be with me at the same time. I get it. And here I thought stallions were emancipated. At least the title of ‘love slave’ is one I can live with. How else can I serve my mistress?”

Pulling her head back, Twilight bit her lips to keep her giggles under control as she nuzzled him. Whenever he made her laugh, the whole world seemed brighter. One hoof drew small circles in his chest fluff as she gave him a sultry look. Her horn lit up to start adding her spells. “Alright enough, you goof. I need more. We can have another talk after. Your mistress now demands you lay her back and get to work on making her scream for half the night. I demand more of you inside me, BBBFF.”

Shining gave a low hum and a sly smile, pushing her on her back as he rose up over her. His cock, now recovered, hilted fully inside as he rocked his hips against her to get started.

“Good thing my mistress gets what she wants.”

***

Twilight inhaled a deep breath of cool morning air as she stirred. As she did, her nose filled with her brother’s scent as she lay tucked in under his chin. With a faint nuzzle, she tried to bury herself a little further into his embrace. How she had missed the feeling of waking up next to him, whether during the night or the following morning. It was just the third time she’d had this chance.

His forelegs held her with a gentle firmness even as he slept. It made her feel secure to know he had the instinctive need to keep her close. Giving a small squeeze of her inner muscles, she also thrilled in knowing his morning wood lay inside her. The hind leg she had over him pulled him the tiniest bit closer, enjoying him slipping deeper into her body.

He had only left her marehood twice last night. When the urge to taste him had taken her. She had delighted in teasing him until he filled her mouth, savoring how his warm semen slid down her throat when she swallowed it down. The second time, she had hung her head off the edge of the bed as she lay on her back. He had hilted in her throat, filling her stomach in a far more direct manner. She still didn’t feel hungry. If it’s not too late that our parents might be up, maybe Shiny can give me breakfast. At least, if I can let him slip out without one last round instead. We won’t have another chance to do this for possibly a whole year.

Shining drifted back to the waking world on a slowly descending cloud. Even in his half-awake state, he immediately registered it was Twilight, not Cadence, that lay wrapped in his forelegs. The warmth of his sister pressed into his chest made for a wonderful sensation to wake up to. Feeling her slow steady heartbeat through her marehood as it hugged his cock was also pretty good.

Taking a deep breath with his nose against her mane, he cracked his eyes open just to see the top of her mane. Just seeing the rose, violet, and deep blue of it drew a faint smile to his lips. They were forced to be apart so often. For the moment at least, he felt like a sort of vindication after all the time he spent missing her. He probably shouldn’t love her the way he did, but he’d personally travel to Tartarus and back if he could see another heartfelt smile on her face. Making her cry out in pleasure so many times last night certainly had its charms, too.

On that thought, Shining let a hoof trace across her coat, sliding along her side until he felt the side of her swollen belly. All the cum he’d put inside her marehood was still sitting in her womb. He felt a fair bit of pride over it. Knowing how much of his seed she had been so eager for him to fill her with caused his shaft to twitch inside her. The faint gasp she made under his chin also told him she was awake. The day will come, Twily. We’ll get things sorted. Then you can be swollen with the new life we’ll make together. Don’t know how things will work with Cadence until the three of us can sit down together, but we’ll figure it out.

Twilight smiled when her brother twitched inside her. She knew right then she needed him to fill her one last time before they parted again for Celestia knew how long. To that end, she pulled his lower body closer as she pressed towards him. Feeling him bottom out inside her body made her release a happy groan.

She pulled her head back to look at his face and met his eyes with a half-lidded sultry stare. “I think we have time. One last quickie before slipping back to your room, Shiny?”

Shining responded by pulling her into a kiss, both their eyes slipping closed as tongues their entwined. He was gentle as he pushed his sister onto her back. With deep, powerful thrusts to maximize sensations, Shining set to work. Starting the day off by making love to Twilight was telling him it would be a fantastic day.

As the two of them strained against each other at a steady, unhurried pace, they kept up their kiss. Twilight broke it as her head tilted back when she felt both of them getting close. A soft gasp escaped her lips, panting at the feel of her brother sliding deep into her body. His flare was starting to expand as he got ready to burst inside her again. She loved how his heated pulses could often trigger her orgasms, leaving her own wanting body milking him for everything he had. Their past experience told her the steady pace was going to give them a strong peak together.

Then he was just a thrust or two away from release. Twilight readied herself to burst all over him in return.

It was in that critical moment, the siblings froze, eyes snapping open to the sound of a throat clearing nearby.

Sharing a mutual look of utter horror, they slowly turned their heads to the side.

Twilight Velvet, their mother, was standing in the room with a blank expression on her face as she stared right back at them.

The silence stretched for several seconds as the two sides stared at each other.

Mortified looks in their eyes and their faces bright red, Shining and Twilight finally blurted out in unison, “Uhh… It’s not what it looks like?”

Velvet was slow to react, her left brow arching up in a gradual manner before she spoke. “Is that so? You mean to tell me that, if I were to look under those blankets, I won’t see a brother’s bare penis fully inside his sister’s aroused vagina, and was about to ejaculate inside said vagina, where I am reasonably certain said brother has put his semen several times already?”

As their ears went flat against their heads, both siblings managed to blush even harder as they felt the world starting to cave in on them. They didn’t even know where to begin, let alone what was going to happen now. Their mother could be unpredictable in the extreme at times.

Velvet frowned. “Exactly how long has this been going on? Be honest with me, or it will just make everything more difficult. Were you two sleeping together even while you lived here?”

Shining swallowed a lump in his throat. The nervous shifting both he and Twilight were doing kept him pretty close to the edge of climax in a maddening additional torment. Too far to simply finish, but too close to calm down.

He also did not do something as coltish as squeak before getting his voice under control to respond to his mother’s inquiry. Nopony could prove a thing. “It… Ahem, it, uh, started this past spring.”

Twilight spoke up in a meek voice, not quite in control of herself. “It was all an accident, Mom! We somehow met at The Blind Date Company and we fell in love before we found out! Neither of us could give things up even though we know how everypony would react! Don’t make me give up Shiny, please!”

Velvet blinked at seeing the tears in her daughter’s eyes, then snorted and waved her hoof in a casual dismissal as a light smirk appeared on her lips. “Oh stop that, Twilight. Before anything else is even said, you’re both grown adults. It’s not my place to do more than offer advice to either of you anymore. Do what you want with your lives. Besides, your father owes me 100 bits for thinking you two were banging for years. I know my foals better than he does. I knew this had to be fairly a recent development sometime in the last year. I’ll gloat at him later.”

There was another period of utter silence as both siblings stared at their mother in confused disbelief, a single word escaping them.

“...what?”

An amused chuckle escaped Velvet’s mouth as she looked at them. “I can only guess at how much of a mess is under those blankets. Judging by the smell, you two were definitely enjoying a long night. I remember how it was to be young and full of energy, among other things…” She let out a wistful sigh. “So how serious are you about each other? Does Cadence know?”

Velvet didn’t mention that Cadence had actually given her some advanced warning a few months ago. The pink Princess had been on a proverbial warpath when she’d approached herself and Night Light about their foals being in love. Fortunately for all involved, Cadence’s gambit to shield the pair even from their own parents was unneeded. They were shocked of course, but they loved their foals unconditionally and had no real problem with it. Cadence was quite thrilled, and very relieved, that there wouldn’t be any conflicts on their end. She’d almost been ready to outright attack herself and Night, which made Velvet very amused. If Cadence loved their foals that much, she was quite confident about another bet she made with her husband about something likely to happen later. Night didn’t believe it would ever happen.

Unlike him, Velvet knew how to read other ponies very, very well.

And that included Cadence, kinky Princess that she was. They had great chats.

Focusing back on the situation, she watched her foals trading a look before Shining spoke up.

“Uh… Cadence knows. And, well, Twilight and I are very serious. Enough that we’re going to try and build a life together long term. We don’t have everything figured out yet.”

Velvet gave an understanding nod. “It’s a lot to sort out. How about you, Twilight? Are you serious about this?”

Twilight swallowed, still on a sexual edge that seemed to hang just at the edge of a climax. Her marehood still fluttering along Shining’s length and swelled flare that felt on the verge of finishing the job. It was a maddening experience to find herself in. Unable to calm and not quite able to cross the finish line. It was an edging from Tartarus and she did not want to orgasm on her brother’s cock in front of her mother. The mix of sensations and emotions kept her squirming against Shining, unable to decide whether to try and slip him out or make him give her one good thrust to make it stop.

“A-as serious as I am about learning magic. I know I want Shining to give me a foal someday. Once we’re ready to start a family. I know there’s a lot to prepare for. We’re being very careful about all of this.”

That made Velvet’s smile grow wide as her eyes danced. “Oh you better believe you’re giving me grandfoals! And since you’ve got two mares involved in all this, I expect double. You hear me, Shining? I want two grandfoals each from Cadence and your sister. I want some babies to spoil!”

Shining blinked hard at that.

There was acceptance, and then there was their mother.

Deciding to suffer the indignity of his mother watch him pull out of his sister so he could stop the distraction of a near climax, Shining began to extract himself in a slow movement. “Mom, did you really have to tell us that right now?”

Just as the siblings felt Shining’s length pull back to the tip, their hearts skipped a beat when he suddenly thrust back inside to the hilt. Unprepared for it and on edge as they were, Shining sailed right over the edge as he began to spray his seed into Twilight as he cried out. As she felt her brother burst inside her, Twilight threw her head back and gasped as she clamped down on him. Feeling him firing his load through her cervix to join everything else he’d left inside her had her shuddering through the pent-up climax she shared with her brother.

Both of them were panting when it ended, staring at each other in weary shock as they tried to get their heads around what had just happened. The renewed massive blushes on both their faces told the other enough about personal feelings of experiencing a huge orgasm in front of their mother.

Turning their heads, they were further mortified to find Velvet’s horn glowing just long enough for them to notice.

Velvet wore a supremely smug, knowing expression on her face. “Really, trying to pull out when your mare is ready to peak. Shining Francis Armor, I raised you to take care of the mare you’re with. That includes during sex. A mare can’t get that close to orgasm and stop like that or she’ll just be irritable all day. And I do not want to put up with your sister’s potential attitude just because you didn’t make her finish. I’d think Cadence would’ve ingrained that into you by now. Guess I’ll have to talk to her about your sexual skills next time she drops by for tea.”

Neither Shining nor Twilight could do more than gawk at her, eyes wide and mouths hanging open. They didn’t even know how to begin to process what had just happened.

Turning towards the door and starting to make a casual exit, Velvet stopped before she left and looked back at the two ponies on the bed. “By the way, your father knows, too. Don’t worry about him. The only reason he wasn’t with me is because we thought it might be too much for you to deal with all at once. Join us for breakfast once you’re ready. I’m going to get some pancakes going in an hour. While you’ll sometimes have to face some serious challenges due to being related, I’m happy for you two. Love as deep as yours is a very special thing.”

Shining and Twilight just kept staring at the door after their mother closed it behind herself. For over a minute, they could do nothing but stare at the door or each other.

It was Twilight that found her voice first as she caught her brother’s face with her hooves. “You know what? Buck this. Buck that. Buck everything. Obviously, Mom has once again confirmed she’s completely insane. Shiny, they already know what we’re doing. I have no idea how to respond to this, so I am just going to settle on some really weird sex. Hopefully after you give me another orgasm or two, the world will make more sense. Sound good?”

“I…” Shining tried to make the gears in his head stop grinding together but failed as he stared back at his sister beneath him. “You know what? Sounds good. Not like this morning can possibly get any worse.”

***

Velvet took a sip of her coffee after the pancakes were ready. As she’d cooked, she told her husband what happened after he’d headed downstairs to start the coffee, leaving her to deal with their foals’ indiscretions. Night had laughed a great deal by the time she was done.

Night Light chuckled. “Still can’t believe I lost that bet. Makes me want to rethink the other ones we’ve made. All these years and you’re still such a pervert, honey. I suppose you’ll be wanting some action later, once the kids head off. Blind bondage this time?”

Flashing him a winning smile, an ear twitching at a familiar sound elsewhere in the house, Velvet cooed, “You know me so well, Nighty. Enough on the special topics though. They’re on the way now. Her room might have been silenced, but she forgot to hit that old door hinge and its quiet squeak. Since just about an hour after we went to bed and Shining joined her, that door’s been shut until we found them. Obvious all nighter from the scent.”

“Still amazes me how attentive you are with anything to do with sex,” Night commented, taking a drink of his own coffee as he turned to his morning paper. He was long since used to his wife’s rampant love of sex and sexuality being a constant thing when in private with him. He found her acting skills to hide it almost everywhere else to be hilarious because he knew the truth about her. Only one other pony really knew, but she’d never tell a soul. The in-joke innuendo they often shared around other ponies never got old to them.

The sound of two sets of hooves nearing the dining area were followed by their foals entering the room.

Velvet froze when her eyes landed on her daughter. She didn’t actually forget to…

If one had compared the devious grin on her face from the earlier discussion, it paled before the one she now wore. Glancing at her husband and catching his eye, she knew he’d caught on as well. A subtle look was all she needed to communicate her thoughts. Are we taking advantage of this?

Night Light’s answering look was subtle and sly as he smirked back. Definitely.

With a moment to decide how to start, she made a beeline towards her daughter as she let out a squeal of delight. “Oh my goodness, Twilight! Why didn’t you tell me last night! This is so exciting!”

Twilight was confused for all of a second.

Then, with her mother’s hoof rubbing the side of her swollen belly, she realized the most horrifying part of the morning had just started as her limbs locked up. She heard a faint rushing in her ears as she blushed harder than she ever had in her life. It was somehow even worse than having her mother making her brother and herself orgasm by proxy. Or something. She still didn’t know how to deal with that yet.

To her great horror, Twilight realized that she had forgotten and headed to breakfast with their parents while still visibly bloated with her brother’s semen. And she looked a few months pregnant because of it. Oh Celestia, please just kill me now…

“Oh my goodness! You must be at least three months along already! You must have been hiding your belly with an illusion last night! I hope you’ve gone to the doctor already to make sure everything is flowing smooth in there! Oh, I’m gonna be a grandmother in a matter of months! I’m just full to bursting with excitement!” Velvet continued to gush as she rubbed her daughter’s semen-bloated belly while putting on the act. She knew what she was doing because of how weak Shining’s scent was in the bedroom compared to his sister’s. It had to go somewhere, after all.

Night Light strolled up next to Shing and tossed a foreleg over his shoulders with a broad smile. “Congratulations, son! Your sister really wears that look well. Was it a lot of work to put that in there? You’re gonna be a dad soon!”

Shining Armor’s brain ground to a halt. His face was white under normal circumstances. By this point, he had gone full tomato as he stuttered. He could only process the knowledge of what exactly it was they were gushing over. And his part in causing it. “I-I-I… Um, th-that is…”

Twilight didn’t know what to do as she scoured her brain for answers and found only empty thought cabinets. The first thing that came to mind won by pure lack of options.

“I-I have to pee!” she declared. Then she wheeled around and dashed out of the room like her tail was on fire, blushing down to her shoulders.

As Shining saw his mother turn her focus on him with a still terrible grin, his father offered a small suggestion.

“It’s always a good idea to make sure your mare is alright when she’s pregnant or stressed. But if you wanted to stay here with…” Night Light watched his son scramble after his sister with a vague ‘goTwilycheckbye!’ for parting words.

Velvet’s eyes glinted with mischief as she turned to her husband, putting up a simple sound bubble around the dining room as they spoke in unison. “Worth it.”

A second later, both of them were laughing themselves to tears as they leaned against each other.

Once they’d managed to calm back down, the sound bubble was removed.

Velvet wiped the tears from her eyes with a light gray fetlock as she caught her breath. “Oh my. We haven’t gotten in that good a round of trolling in years, have we, Nighty?”

Night chuckled and shook his head as they sat back down at the table. “That we haven’t, honey. Think the family curse is fulfilled?”

Taking a sip of her coffee again, Velvet hummed with a relieved smile. “Most likely. I think I can finally tell Twilight about how mares in our family always end up doing something incredibly perverted around her age. All things considered, she’s landed a wonderful approach where it probably won’t be a curse for her. Ending up in porn for over five years, let alone a mare of the night like most before me, had it’s dark side. I managed to escape most of the worst parts, but not all of them.” Velvet let herself feel a small shudder before putting the memories away again. “And her brother will keep her safe if she didn’t do enough yet, so we can take comfort in that at least.”

“That he most certainly will,” Night replied in his own relief. “Always had some worry she’d try to approach me when it finally happened. I wasn’t looking forward to having to find a way out of that scenario. Still, are we going keep teasing them much longer? If you think you should tell her, then maybe today is a good time. Shining is even here with her to offer support. They still have a couple hours before they even need to think about leaving.”

Closing her eyes for several seconds as she thought about it, Velvet soon shook her head. “I need to think it through first. Also want to give it some time, just in case things do go sideways on her. Heck, I might even need to involve Cadence if my guess is right.”

“Up to you, honey,” Night acknowledged before changing topics. “Still can’t believe Tia was willing to make your porn record vanish for such a low price after Twilight took the entrance exam and gained her apprenticeship.”

Velvet snickered as the memory played across her mind. She had long enjoyed the public reputation of a devoted mother and published author with multiple popular fiction books to her name. And not as any kind of porn star. “I still remember how she said it, too. ‘As a connoisseur of pranking, I have an interest in learning any new variations or techniques I see from others.’ Who knew Princess Celestia herself was such a huge fan of trolling. Certainly explains some of the famous lines in some her speeches over her long reign. Twilight better hope she doesn’t let herself become a target by pranking her first.”

“You know, honey, this does make me want to consider talking to Tia again. The foals are out of the house nowadays and we know she’s often lonely,” Night said before sipping his coffee again.

“Ah, yes,” Velvet replied, a fond look crossing her gently aged features. “Well, it’s still a standing option to me, Nighty. You know I’d happily go back to her in a heartbeat. We couldn’t keep up like we used to, but if she’s not found somepony since us, it’d be nice to keep her company from time to time again. It amazes me to this day that the three of us actually did things as wild as shrinking and unbirthing when I was in estrus. Followed by you and I having sex in Tia’s womb as she masturbated to us wiggling around inside her. I don’t know which of us came hardest from that. I also still swear that was how Shining was conceived. If ponies only knew what she’s like in bed…”

From elsewhere in the house, alongside the faint sound of a shower, came a soft dull thumping sound that caused both Velvet and Night to perk up their ears. Both began to smile with coming mischief again. A certain pair of ponies forgot a silencing spell.

“We going to tease them over this one, too?”

“Of course we are. Maybe we can start with something like ‘kinda hard to drain the tub when you keep plugging the pipe!’”

The two older ponies struggled to contain their laughter as they planned how to mess with their foals even more than they already had.