You Can't Ever Catch Her

by Phantom001

Rating: everyone
Tags: Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Adventure
Length: 1148

This is the second part of "A Magic Pegasus." When Sinister Symphonic leaves the comfort of her house, she builds her own black crystal palace. She is living on her own. Sinister's father, Book Mark, asked for captain Hurricane's help to find her.

Sinister is gone from her parents' comfort. Book Mark, asks Captain Hurricane for his help into finding his lost daughter. BUT NOT BRINGING HER BACK! Captain Hurricane brings his grandson along, Phantom Armor. He is the second Magic Pegasus after Sinister, although they were born same day, same year, same time. While listening to Book Mark's story, Phantom finds it interesting that there is a FEMALE magic Pegasus in existence. He agrees to help Sinister's father on finding her, but what will happen after Phantom brings her back?

Published 2016-05-15 21:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-05-15 21:30:01 UTC

The Three Sinisters

The Three Sinisters

The next day, was a cool humid morning. Phantom and Book Mark wasted no time in going looking for Sinister. Phantom was pretty much expressionless but on the inside he was excited about meeting Sinister.

They flew all morning long, until almost midday they arrived to this mountain that had a black crystal palace sitting on it.

"Here she is." Phantom said, talking more to himself rather than to Book Mark.

They entered the humongous palace. They were pacing slowly, every hoof step they gave echoed across the castle. It was dark, but you could still see the shimmering of the crystals.

"Wow. This is a creepy place." Book Mark said, his words echoing in the endless walls.

They kept walking until they heard the flapping of wings growing closer.
Then, Sinister appeared in front of her father.

"Hello Dad! Mind if I give you a little test?" Sinister asked.

Phantom couldn't help but to keep staring at her. She looked almost exactly like him, only difference was that she had blue violet eyes instead of ocean blue.

'She is beautiful. Just what I expected to see. Now I only need to win her over.'
Phantom thought.

Then, all of a sudden, three Sinisters appeared in the middle of the entrance. Then all three talked at once:

"There are three of us in here. But two of us are copies. Which one of us is the real one?"

"Uuuuhhhh…" Book Mark said speechless. He couldn't tell them apart, they looked exactly the same. But fortunately Phantom could tell them apart. His eyes turned into snake eyes.

"She's the one on the right." he said.

In a second, the other two Sinisters disappeared, and the real one approached him so closely he could've sworn she intended to kiss him.

"Must've been a lucky guess." Sinister whispered so low that only Phantom could hear her.

"Are sure about that?" Phantom replied, a smile curling in his face.

She made a move of her wing and made her own magic ball appear.

"Think you can guess this one?" She said with her eyes half closed, smiling.

Phantom raised an eyebrow and did the same move and his own magic appeared.

"I think I can." he said matter-of-factly.

'That's impossible! I'm the last magic Pegasus!' Sinister thought.
Sinister made a slightly more complicated spell. The disappearing spell. But just as soon as she started, Phantom followed. They both disappeared in midair at the same time. The next thing they knew, they were flying and battling each other in midair. But as much as she tried, Sinister couldn't even place a scratch on Phantom. She was starting to get frustrated. Sinister didn't seem to notice, but Phantom was not actually trying to hurt her…he was flirting with her.

"I'M DONE!" Sinister yelled frustrated.

"Oh, I know isn't it tiring to fight and fly at the same time. I believe we haven't met before, I am Phantom Armor. What is your name beautiful?" Phantom asked smirking in a flirty face.

Sinister was not sure wether she'd answer or not.

The Second Magic Pegasus

The Second Magic Pegasus

One night, in Book Mark's home there were two stallions talking with him. It was a cold and rainy night. There was very loud thunders and heavy pouring rain.

"Sorry if I bothered you Hurricane, but I really need your help." Book Mark said.

"Oh, no you didn't bother me. But what is it that you need help with? Oh, and by the way
do you mind if Phantom stays, he's my grandson." Captain Hurricane said.

"Oh no it's fine, I don't mind him. Anyways, you know how I have two daughters, Jewel and … Sinister. I only have Jewel for now. I don't know where Sinister is, but I would really appreciate if you could just tell me where she is. I DON'T want you to bring her back!"

"Why don't you want me to bring her back? She's just a pegasus."

"Oh, she's more than just an ordinary pegasus. She's a MAGIC pegasus."

Up until this point, Phantom's face had been uninterested. But as soon as heard that the so-called-Sinister was a female Magic Pegasus, he became very interested in the conversation.

"She's fast. She's dangerous. She can appear and disappear. But she never chooses a pattern. That's why you can't ever catch her." Book Mark said with concern on his face.

"Actually…I think I know where she is. And I CAN catch her. Magic Pegasi developed a way to find each other since they 're about to disappear and I am a Magic Pegasus." Phantom spoke for the first time. He was very tall and had an unkempt black mane. He also had an enormous pair of wings folded on his back and a pair of deep ocean blue eyes. His cutie mark is a black spider.

"Really? Prove it!" Book Mark demanded.

Phantom did a spinning move with his right wing and a blue magic ball appeared. It looked like a fire ball. The flames were ocean blue like his eyes and a violet blue nucleus. It looked almost the same as Sinister's magic, only hers had violet blue flames and an ocean blue nucleus.

"Is this enough proof?" Phantom said with those blue snake eyes.

"So can you help me then?" Book Mark asked getting closer to him.
"Yes, but we'll have to go tomorrow. It's too dark and wet right now.

Phantom's Girlfriend

Phantom's Girlfriend

"I'm Sinister Symphonic." She said a little of rage on her voice.

"Hmm…nice to meet you, Sinister." Phantom said making a little bow with his head.

"Well then, assuming you really are a magic pegasus. I suppose you know that each one has a special spell that another cannot copy." Sinister said with her eyes half closed.

"Yes, I do know that but I doubt you actually have one." Phantom replied.

Sinister turned around and fluttered her tail against Phantom's chest, now she was flirting.

"Want to put that to a test?" she smirked.

"Heh, you don't have to ask me twice." Phantom said.

Sinister raised her wings and made a spell that went into her mouth. It was poison. But Phantom didn't know, or did he? She approached him carefully and gave him a full kiss on the lips. He returned the kiss. When they broke apart, Phantom whispered:

"Was that your spell?"

"Yes." She replied.

"Hm…thought so. That's why I counter attacked."

"Oh really? How?"

They both descended from the heights. Sinister's violet eyes were not violet anymore, they were the same color as Phantom's. He was smirking, proud of himself. They approached Sinister's father.

"What happened?" he asked.

"Oh, nothing. Just that Sinister decided to come back home. And I am asking you for permission to date Sinister?" Phantom inquired.

"Yes, you may date her. After all, she came back thanks to you."