The Sun or Moon?

by The Pony of Darkness

Rating: teen
Tags: Comedy, Alternate Universe, Romance, Drama
Length: 1755

Twilight realizes that two ponies have a crush on her. But not just normal ponies. The raisers of the Sun and Moon. Twilight is torn between Celestia and Luna. But neither of sisters know that they are both interested in the same mare.

Twilight realizes that two ponies have a crush on her. But not just normal ponies. The raisers of the Sun and Moon. Twilight is torn between Celestia and Luna. But neither of sisters know that they are both interested in the same mare.

Twilight has another problem. She can't tell who she loves more. But Twilight knows in the end, one will be heartbroken and one will have true love.

Will Twilight pick Celestia? Or Luna?
Will Twilight even tell them the truth?!
How will the Princesses react?

Contains: [spoiler]Luna x Twilight and Celestia x Twilight. And some lovely stuff.[/spoiler]
The story is taken in the middle of Season 5.

Rated T because I know everyone would not be comfortable with this. :rainbowlaugh:

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2016-05-19 00:50:01 UTC

Chapter 1- Shining brighter then the stars!

The shiny silver doorknob creaked as it was begin turned by purple magic. The wooden door slowly opened and it revealed that it was the outside. The full moon and stars shined brightly.

Twilight gasped as to what she saw.

There was a small table in the center of the outside. The table looked like it was made out of metal. The ends of the table were facing to the right and left of Twilight. Two empty plates were sitting on the end of the very nice small table, and three lonely lit candles on the middle. Two fancy wooden chairs were almost touching the ends of the metal table. And small purple pillows were on the wooden chairs.

"I'm very glad that you like what I did for you."

Twilight turned her head to the left, where the familiar voice was heard.

A kind and gentle smile and eyes filled love looked at Twilight. No other pony could make such a face, only Princess Celestia.

Twilight smiled and blushed as she looked deeply back at Celestia's eyes. They were memorizing.

Celestia suddenly blinked, she looked away from Twilight and at the fancy table and chairs. Then back at Twilight.

"Shall we sit down Twilight?" Celestia asked.

Twilight still smiling said "Yes."

Twilight and Celestia began to walk. But Twilight couldn't help but take a look at Celestia while they were walking. Celestia was smiling and had her princesses gear on, and so did Twilight. Celestia's mane shined each time it moved in its wave formation. Twilight then looked away and sat on a chair on the left side of the table.

Once Twilight got comfortable, she looked to see what Celestia was doing. Celestia was looking at Twilight.

Twilight quickly looked at something else to save herself from embarrassment. She decided the look at the three candles that were at the right side of the table. All three of them burned brightly and slowly while also making the wax drip.

Celestia smiled and began to speak.

"Is there anything you want to talk about? Or are you going to stare at the candles all night?"

Twilight looked back at Celestia.

"Princess Celestia, why did you invite me here?"

Celestia's expression stayed the same. Which surprised Twilight.

"I want to spend more time with you Twilight. It's the least I can do since you have done so much for Equestria."

Just then, the same wooden door opened. A white unicorn waiter that was wearing a tuxedo stepped outside and was using his magic to hold a pen and a small notebook. Both Celestia and Twilight looked at him the whole time as he walked up to the table. Then he suddenly used his magic to move the candles to the other side of the table. And put the pen and notebook in front of him.

"What kind of drink can I get for you majesty's?" The waiter asked without look up from his small notebook.

"Water please," Twilight said.

The waiter nodded at Twilight then he looked at Celestia.

Celestia smiled at the waiter and said.

"I would also like some water."

The waiter smiled back at Celestia and then walked back to the wooden door. The waiter opened it with his magic and then closed it when he was inside. Celestia and Twilight were just about to go back to their conversation when another waiter came out.

He was also a unicorn and had the same looking tuxedo, but instead of white fur, it was grayer. The waiter looked like he was carrying two menus with his magic. The menus looked mostly brown and very fancy. Something Rarity would never stop looking at.

Once the waiter was in front of the table, he put the two menus next to the plates on the right side. Then he quickly bowed.

"We are sorry your majesty's. We forgot to give the menus to you. Enjoy." The waiter said and turned back to the wooden door.

Twilight turned her head toward the menu and picked it up with her magic. When she opened it... There were many pictures of foods and deserts. And words about the food underneath. Many caught Twilight's eyes. And she wondered why all the food looked so good. Twilight realized she had a hard time deciding, but she finally picked one.

Twilight put the menu back on the table and looked to see if Celestia was done choosing. She was. Celestia smiled when she realized her favorite mare was done choosing.

"What are you getting Princess Celestia?" Twilight asked.

"White chocolate cheesecake," Celestia said.

"Huh? There are different kinds of flavored cheesecakes?" Twilight questioned.

Celestia nodded.

"There are so many cheesecakes that I lost count. But I have tasted all of them. White chocolate cheesecake is the best one I tasted so far." Celestia said.

"Oh, I see," Twilight said.

Twilight has heard rumors that Princess Celestia loves cheesecake. But she didn't think it was true. Until now... No wonder Princess Celestia's rump looked bigger than the last time Twilight saw it.

"Wait... Princess Celestia. Are you going to have dinner first?" Twilight asked.

"I was going to. But I would like to skip to the desert. I had a hayburger before I left to meet you, and my stomach should suffice." Celestia said.

"Have you ever looked at your rump, Princess Celestia?" Twilight thought, then smiled. Twilight wanted to say that.

Suddenly the same white unicorn came out. He was using his magic again. He had the two glasses of water. The glasses were shaped just like wine glasses and they sparkled and shined, which gave Twilight the hint that they were polished several times. He was also carrying the same small notebook and pen.

"Here is your glasses of water your majesty's. Are you ready to order?" The waiter asked as he looked at the two princesses.

"I would like two hayburgers, with ketchup only. And a side of hay fries." Twilight said.

The waiter looked up at Twilight and nodded, then he looked at Celestia.

"The usual white chocolate cheesecake, your majesty?" The waiter asked.

Celestia smiled and nodded.

The waiter smiled back and walked away with his notebook and pen.

"I see that we have the same tastes when it comes to hayburgers," Celestia said.

"Yes..." Twilight said and looked away while blushing.

Celestia noticed and decided to play a game.

"Oh? Do I see my princess blushing?" Celestia teased.

Twilight's face turned as red as a tomato. Twilight lifted her right hoof and covered her face from Celestia.

"Stop!" Twilight said while embarrassed.

Celestia chuckled.

"Gotcha."

                                                                                            ~~~

"Hello, Sister."

Celestia and Twilight turned around and found out Luna standing there in the same hallway of the Canterlot Castle.

"Luna... I wasn't expecting to see you here. How is the night going?" Celestia asked.

"It is going good, my sister. Why are you not in your bed chambers? It is quite late." Luna said, concerned.

"Me and Twilight needed to do some studying. We were just about to go to my bedchambers. We are in the hallway of my bedchambers after all." Celestia said.

"Sister... May I have Twilight Sparkle for the night? I would like to talk to her." Luna asked.

"Why Luna?"  Celestia asked

"Sorry sister. I cannot tell you." Luna said.

Celestia's eyebrow raised a bit. But decided to not go further. Celestia then looked at Twilight.

Celestia suddenly winked at her and that made Twilight smile. But Twilight had no option but to go with Luna. Twilight walked up to Luna and gave her a nod. Luna turned around and started walking. Twilight then looked at Celestia, who was still standing there. Celestia's look was still the same happy smiling face.

Twilight turned around and caught up with Luna.

"It is nice to see you again, Princess Sparkle. I missed you." Luna said and turned her head to Twilight.

Twilight blushed slightly.

"Thank you, Princess Luna," Twilight said while looking back at Luna.

"Where are we going?" Twilight asked.

Luna smiled and looked away from Twilight

"To my bedchambers instead."

                                                                                             ~~~

"Luna! No! Hahahahha! Stop!"

Luna chuckled and got off of Twilight.

When Twilight realized she stopped. She jumped out of Luna's bed.

"What wrong Twilight? Cannot be tickled?" Luna asked playfully.

Twilight smiled. But only for a moment. Twilight then looked over at the Princess gear. Both Twilight's and Luna's. Then she looked back at Luna. To Twilight, Luna looked better without her princess gear.

"Thank you, Luna. I had a fun time playing pillow fights and tickling. But I need to go back to my castle and rest." Twilight said and then turned to Luna's door.

But before Twilight could leave. Luna used her magic and levitated Twilight right in front of her.

"You are not getting away that easily from the princess of the night! I have waited long enough and I am very lonely. You shall stay here with me Twilight Sparkle."

Twilight gulped in fear.

"Come now! Do not be afraid Twilight Sparkle. Tonight you shall sleep with me." Luna smiled and blushed while she said that.

Twilight blushed madly. And then Luna let go of Twilight from her magic, Twilight plopped on the ground, landing on all her hooves.

"I'm not sure I am ready..." Twilight said. Her ears went down in embarrassment while still blushing. She was trying her hardest to get away from this situation.

"Nonsense Twilight. I shall make as comfortable as I can."

As Luna said those words. Twilight then knew there was no way out of this. She climbed back on the bed and laid her head on the soft pillow. Luna smiled and then did the same.

Luna suddenly rapped her two front hooves around Twilight and scooted closer to her.

Luna's two hooves were on Twilights stomach. Which made Twilight madly blush. Then soon Twilight could feel Luna's stomach touching her back while also feeling the warmth.

Twilight knew this was wrong. But another part of her was telling her that this was right.

Twilight wondered why she felt this way. But before Twilight could finish her thoughts. The blanket suddenly floated and covered Twilight all the way to her neck. Twilight knew Luna moved the blanket with her magic.

Suddenly Twilight's body started to go limp and her eyes felt heavy. Luna's warm body, the soft pillow, the blanket. It was too much for Twilight...

Before long... Twilight feel into a deep slumber.