My Little Pony: Sisterly Convergence 2

by Hopeful Soul

Rating: mature
Tags: Sad, Drama, Romance
Length: 4059

They thought their secret was safe, that nopony knew, but some things... just don't stay hidden for long.

It's been six months since the secret wedding between the Princess' Celestia and Luna and the couple could not be happier as they engage in sexy roleplay and make love in the strangest of places, all while making sure everypony else doesn't know.

But suddenly, for some reason or another, an unknown pony catches them in the act and following that, things slowly start to crumble around them… Can the two sister's protect their secret and their love or will they face the judgement of the entire pony nation?

Includes sisterly incest, roleplay, spanking and futa, if these things aren't your cup of tea don't read it.

Edited by The Derpy Division

Credit for cover art goes to Jeatz-Axl

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2016-08-06 19:21:16 UTC

Chapter 1

My Little Pony: Sisterly Convergence 2

        A series of hoofs rapidly trotting against the pebbled pathway were heard, as an unknown mare continued to gallop as fast as she could, for what reason only she knew.

        The mare that was running was none other than Princess Luna, Princess of the Night and Guardian of Dreams. Judging by the sweat coming down from her forehead, her rapid breathing, it would seem that she had been running away from something for quite a while and seemed to be getting more and more tired every second.

        As soon as she reached a rocky wall she quickly ducked behind it and panted heavily as she tried to catch her breath.

        She looked around the corner of the wall, but because it was currently night time she couldn’t see much of anything, so she lit up her horn and shined some light but still, she saw nopony there. It seemed that she was being chased by somepony, somepony she desperately wanted to get away from.

        Luna breathed a sigh of relief. “I am safe…” she muttered.

        “Oh Luna…!” Somepony in the darkness suddenly called out in a sing-song voice, making the aforementioned Princess gasp in surprise. “Luna…!”

        “Oh no! I have been spotted! I must flee!” The Princess of the Night declared before she resumed galloping away once again.

        As she ran off, another set of hooves clopping against the ground slowly was heard, ones that were coming from the shadows. Just then, a small light began to shine, a light emitting from the top of what seemed to be a unicorn horn. The owner of said horn wore a large brown cloak that covered most of his or her features, obscuring their identity.

        While Luna galloped as fast as she could, the stranger took his or her time and continued to stalk her like a cat would stalk a mouse before eating it.

        Princess Luna dashed down every corner she could find in an attempt to lose her pursuer, but the unknown pony just kept on finding and following her, and it didn’t help at all that she was growing more and more tired.

        “Leave me alone!” she called out to whoever was chasing her.

        “I can’t do that.” The stranger told her in a low tone. “Please. Stop running.”

        “Never!” Luna cried, defiantly.

        “Fine then,” she heard her pursuer say calm as the Night Princess finally stopped to catch her breath. “Just hold still…”

        “W-what…?” Luna responded, confused before she was suddenly tackled.

        The Princess grunted as her gut slammed into the edge of a stone table close by before being forcefully bent over the edge by her attacker and kept there forcefully by him or her as he or she presses their solid hooves on her back.

        “Ugh! Release me! Now!” she ordered.

        “Oh, I don’t think so…” The unknown pony hissed.

        Luna attempted to use her magic but found herself unable to, much to her shock and horror. Before she could ask how and why, and while she was still continuing to struggle, she felt something hard press against her rump. It took her a while but she quickly figured out that it was something that belonged to a stallion, yet her attacker’s voice seemed oddly female.

        “Wha-what’re you…?” Princess Luna began to ask before more pressure was put on the hard object, which she correctly guessed was a penis, as her new apparent rapist tried to insert it into her. “No… please… don’t…! P-please… P-Please… what-what do you want!? What do you want!!?”

        The one behind her slowly leaned forward and whispered into her ear in a quiet but creepy tone. “Inside… you…” he or she said before smiling evilly.

        Luna continued to look back at her attacker, full of fear before she suddenly jerked and let out a long and sharp gasp as the assailant’s stallionhood finally entered her. Luna screamed and moaned, she felt like he or she was tearing her apart, her ass slapping against the rapist’s with every thrust. burning, tearing and bruising as the assailant’s penis went in and out of her constantly.

        “NO! No…! Stop it!” she begged.

Her whole body pushed upward along the stone table from the stranger’s thrusts, her head tipped backwards and eyes rolling up as she gasps. Tears trailed down her face as she jerked again from the next thrust, and the next. Luna continued to sob as her attacker rocked forward and back, flexing and thrusting their hips. More screams, ones that sound like an animal in pain are heard from Luna’s mouth.

Each thrust caused a different response. She gasped, then cried out, then gives a shudder as the first mixture of pain and pleasure hit her as her attacker continued to drive their sex into her like a sword.

“Get off of me…!” Luna pleaded, even though she knew it was pointless.

The rapist soon began to settle into a rhythm and slowly but surely increase and speed and force of her thrusts while Luna began to become teary eyed as she felt the long erection slide forward and back down her walls. She could also feel it poke at the entrance to her womb over and over again making her moans loudly it was almost as if she was speaking in her Royal Canterlot voice, she was close and so was her rapist, she could feel it.

As this continued on, Luna moved forward and back across the stone table she was pinned onto, trying to keep her head down, her eyes shut and her mouth closed, though a moan still emitted from her as the attacker continued to increase their pace.

Then it happened. Both of them let out a cry of moans as their orgasms hit, they lifted their heads upwards toward the sky while their eyes rolled back. Her assailant ceased their thrusting as he or she ejaculated inside of Luna. Exhausted, Luna’s head fell down against the stone table as she panted while the rapist collapsed on top of her, panting also.

After a few moments of silence, an odd sound began to emit from the two which soon revealed itself to be laughter. Both Luna and the her attacker, who’s hood fell back to reveal that it was Celestia all along, were laughing their hearts out at what had just happened.

“So? How was that?” The elder sister inquired.

“Well done dearest, you played the role of the rapist perfectly.” Luna praised.

“Only the best for my little sister.” Celestia beamed as she got off of Luna and pulled her still erect and magically created member out of her, causing a soft gasp to emit from her lips.

“Your wife, Tia.” Princess Luna reminded her as she got off the stone table.

“My wife, of course, how silly of me to forget…” Princess Celestia said, shaking her head with a warm smile. “It’s still hard to imagine that just six months ago the two of us got married.”

“I know what you mean…” Luna said with a sigh. “And I am grateful that nopony has suspected a thing.”

“As am I.” Celestia nodded. “But let’s not worry about what might happen and enjoy what we have right now.”

“Agreed.” Princess Luna smiled as she cupped her wife’s cheek with her hoof and pressed her lips against her own.

“Well… we’d best get back inside the castle before anypony notices or sees anything.” Celestia suggested.

“Right, lead the way, dear.” Luna offered.

“It would be my great pleasure.” Celestia bowed before turning and walking ahead. With her true love right behind her. Once Luna caught up with Celestia they wrapped their wings around each other while also wrapping their tails together as well.

A little while later, the Princesses arrived back inside the castle and made sure that their wings and tails weren’t touching each other specifically for when some guards came up to them, looking concerned.

“Your highness’!” The first one said as they both bowed.

“Yes? Is there a problem?” Celestia asked, calmly.

“W-we were just worried about you, your majesty.” The second one added as they stood up. He then turned to Princess Luna. “Both of you.”

“Your concern is greatly appreciated but you do not need to worry, for we are both fine.” Luna told them. “Thank you.”

“Now, if you’ll excuse me, I must rest.” Princess Celestia stated.

“And I must continue to guard the night.” Princess Luna added. “Have a nice rest, sister.”

“And you be careful while watching over the dreams of everypony in Equestria.” Celestia responded.

“I will, good night.” Luna nodded.

“Good night.” Celestia nodded back before they both went down separate hallways, leaving the guards by themselves and looking somewhat confused.

“Uh… you know what just happened?” One asked.

“Nope.” The other one replied.

“I swear the Princesses sure have been acting odd lately.”

“Sssh! Quiet! They might hear you! Plus we’re not supposed to talk about them like that.”

“I know, but I can’t help it!”

“I know the feeling.”

“Let’s just keep an eye on them, ok?”

“Yes, sir.” The other guard nodded.

The two guards then turned and went their separate ways, like the Princesses did.

Soon enough, it was nighttime, and all throughout the castle everything was quiet, aside from the sound of some of the guards walking up and down the hallways with their horns illuminated. What none of them noticed however was a certain Princess sneaking down each of the hallways to her wife’s room, Princess Luna to be exact.

If she could, she could just teleport herself to her sister’s room but that would most likely catch the guards attention, what with the flash of the light being so bright and the sound of the teleportation being a bit noisy.

Using the shadows to keep herself fully concealed, Luna managed to evade the attention of every guard that was in her way. When she was not too far away from her wife’s room, she lit up her horn and used a spell to magically freeze the guards that were stationed outside the doors and then proceeded towards it.

“Good evening gentlecolts, keep up the good work,” she said to them, even though she knew that they couldn’t hear or see her. She then magically opened the doors and closed them once she got inside.

Upon entering the bedroom, she casted the sound-proof barrier she and her sister put around both of their rooms, so that the other guards wouldn’t hear their ‘activities’. She looked ahead and smiled at what she saw;

Celestia, her sister turned wife, sitting on top of her bed with little candles burning around it giving the room a dim but romantic lightning. The Princess of the Sun turned to Luna and smiled warmly as well.

“Why, hello there,” she said in a very seductive tone.

“Hello. Kept the bed warm for me?” Luna inquired, raising a brow with a smile.

“Of course.” Celestia nodded with a come hither look. “Now come here.”

“Gladly.” Princess Luna said as she trotted over and slid under the covers along with her beloved wife. “Ah… how I’ve missed this…”

“As have I.” Celestia agreed.

“So… it has been a while since our last… sexual escapade, you know.” Luna pointed out.

“Yes?”

“Are you thinking what I am thinking.”

“I think I am.”

“Oh really?”

“Yes.” Luna said with a sultry smile.

“Well then…” Celestia began, sharing her grin. “Let us start another one, shall we?”

“After you.” Luna offered.

Celestia then pulled the covers over herself and Luna, covering them both completely. The only evidence that they were even there were the two large lumps in the bed that soon became one, followed by a giggle of laughter, squealing, panting, kissy noises and other sounds as well as labored breathing.

As they both continued to presumably make love to one another, they were completely unaware that somepony was watching them, through the keyhole in the door. The unknown pony did not make a sound and continued to watch them until the covers came off from two and revealed them kissing in plain sight. After which, the unknown pony moved their eye away from the keyhole and left, leaving the Princesses unaware that their secret wasn't a secret no more.

Chapter 2

Chapter 2

The next morning, after Luna had teleported herself back to her own room before the guards could suspect anything, an act that she and her sister had long since mastered. The two Princess’ went about their everyday routines and acting like they always did around their subjects. Apart, they tended to whatever their subjects requested of them or whatever royal duties they’d have to do but alone they engaged in some loving make out sessions and cuddling.

All in all, the two sisters turned wives were happier than they’ve ever been…

At the moment, Princess Celestia was just exiting the magic school where she first met Twilight, as she usually did every now and then. She greatly enjoyed seeing all the young fillies and colts practicing their magic, it made her reminisce about the times Twilight was young, innocent and wide eyed.

That’s when she noticed a familiar face nearby.

“Auntie Celestia!”

The aforementioned Princess smiled when she saw her adopted niece waving to her at the end of the steps. She walked on over and gave her a quick hug.

“Cadance, so good to see you.” Celestia said, warmly.

“Likewise Aunt Celestia, how are things with Aunt Luna?” Cadance inquired.

“Splendid.” Princess Celestia smiled.

“Good. No suspicions?” Cadance asked, curious.

“Not at all, nopony suspects a thing.” Celestia replied.

“You know you might not be able to keep it a secret forever, don’t you?” Cadance inquired. “I mean… I managed to find out, so it’s not unlikely that somepony else just might as well.”

“Perhaps…” The Princess of the Sun mused. “But so far so good, and we cannot let paranoia keep us from leading peaceful and happy lives now can we?”

“Your right, of course.” Princess Cadance nodded.

“But enough about us, time me about you, anything going on?” Princess Celestia inquired, interested. “Is little Flurry Heart, ok?”

“Oh, she’s doing great!” Cadance beamed. “Shining Armor is a bit stressed out though… can’t wait to see how he’ll deal with the teenage years…”

Princess Celestia chuckled, amused. “Indeed. But I have faith in him.”

“As do I.” Cadance nodded before gaining a coy smile. “Speaking of babies… have you and Auntie Luna ever thought about… you know… maybe…?”

Celestia’s eyes widened while her cheeks became hot and red when she realized what her niece meant, reducing her to a stuttering mess. “Oh… well… I-I… uh… I-I mean w-we… that is… I-I…” she tried to say while Cadance giggled.

“It’s ok, it’s ok, you don’t have to answer.” Princess Cadance assured her. “I should have known better then to ask you something like that.”

“No, it’s fine, it’s only natural you should ask something like that.” Celestia admitted. “And I must confess I have been thinking about it recently…”

“And Luna?”

“I’m not sure…”

“Have you asked?”

“I’ve hinted at it here and there, but every time I do she is always so vague…”

“Maybe she hasn’t decided on it yet.” Princess Cadance suggested.

“Maybe…” Celestia muttered, glancing away.

Cadance put a hoof on her. “Aw, cheer up, it’ll be ok,” she assured her. “I’m sure she wants to, it just scares her a little like it does you, correct?”

Celestia nodded, sighing. “Yes.”

“Thought so. Just give her time, alright?” Princess Cadance requested.

Princess Celestia knew she was right, even though waiting was driving her somewhat crazy, she sighed deeply. “Very well, you are the Princess of Love after all, so I suppose I should listen to you.”

“Thank you.” Cadance said, gratefully.

“Well, we’d better get going then.” Celestia declared.

“Right. Lead the way.” Cadance offered as they started to walk away. But before they could get very far somepony called out to the Princess of the Sun.

“Princess Celestia!”

They turned, looking alert, while a messenger unicorn pony galloped toward them and finally stopped when he reached the royal figures. He panted out of breath. “Princess… there’s… there’s a message for you…” he breathed as he levitated a scroll before her.

“A message? From who? Twilight?” Celestia inquired as she magically took the scroll.

“I-I don’t know, it just appeared out of nowhere…” The messenger revealed.

“How very strange…” Princess Celestia remarked, baffled. “Thank you good sir, that will be all.”

The messenger saluted. “Ma’am!”

After the messenger pony had left Celestia opened the scroll and levitated it front of her face as her eyes scanned what was written on it quickly.

Cadance leaned in. “What does it say?”

After a pause Celestia gasped in horror. “Oh no… it can’t be…!”

“What’s wrong, Auntie?” Cadance asked, worried.

“Somepony knows…” Celestia breathed, the fear in her voice becoming more and more clear.

“Knows what?” Her niece inquired, beginning to look worried.

“About me… and Luna…” The Princess of the Sun revealed, her voice filled with dread.

“What!?” Cadance reacted in shock.  “But… but how…?”

“I-I don’t know… we’ve always been so careful… what could we have missed…?” Celestia wondered, beginning to panic.

“W-Well… does the pony who sent that given any demands yet…?” The Princess of Love asked, nervously.

“No. It just says ‘I know about you and your sister. I know you have both committed a great crime’” Princess Celestia said as she read the letter.

“T-That could mean anything!” Cadance pointed out as she started to panic as well.

“Yes… but there’s only one great crime that I can think of right now…” Celestia despaired.

“It’s not a crime if you two truly love each other!” Cadance protested, firmly.

“I know, but that is not how this pony sees it…” Princess Celestia said as she glanced at the scroll she was levitated sadly.

“What are you going to do?” Princess Cadance inquired, concerned.

“Firstly, I have to tell Luna, unless she’s already been messaged as well…” Princess Celestia declared as she began to leave in a hurry. “Please, excuse me.”

“Good luck!” Cadance waved as she watched Celestia gallop off into the distance and silently prayed for the safety and love of her two aunts.

Meanwhile, around that same time, Luna was currently sitting inside her personal study. It was dark and somewhat small, just the way she liked it and had many decorations that most would find ‘creepy’ yet she found them to be beautiful and unique. She was currently in the middle of reading what appeared to be a very interesting book when her sister turned wife suddenly burst it, with the scroll still floating by her

“Sister!” she cried.

“Beloved, what’s wrong? Is something the matter?” Luna asked, concerned.

“Yes, something is the matter…” Celestia revealed, still looking panicky. She levitated the scroll over to her younger sister. “Take a look.”

The Princess of the Night took the scroll and gave it a quick read over before gasping in shock, just like Celestia did not too long ago.

“Indeed… it is very troubling…” The Princess of the Sun said, solemnly and worriedly.

“But… how!?” Luna asked, baffled.

“I just don’t know… but somepony knows about us, and what’s worse; this pony could be watching us right now…”

“He or she would dare commit an act of treason against the Princess’ of Equestria!?”

“If this secret get’s out we won’t be Princess' of Equestria anymore…”

“No… this can’t…”

“Can be, and is… and we must find out who and why before it is too late.” Princess Celestia stated.

“Could it be Discord?” Luna wondered, her face quickly becoming a scowl. “Because I swear if that little weasel…”

“No, this isn’t his style, and even if it were Discord, he wouldn’t let us know via scroll.” Celestia pointed out.

“I guess you are right…” Luna admitted.

“And even if he does know, it wouldn’t quite as much fun for him if it suddenly ended.” Princess Celestia added.

“Then who? What could we have missed?” Princess Luna wondered.

“I don’t know… whoever it is must have been spying on us without either of us knowing it for quite some time.” The Princess of the Sun assumed. “Somepony quite powerful…”

“Somepony very sneaky…” Luna mused.

“And knowledgeable enough to work their way past the guards…” Celestia added, thoughtfully.

“That narrows the list of possible suspects a great deal… but there’s still too many.” Princess Luna pointed out.

“Perhaps we must wait, until we receive another letter.” Princess Celestia suggested.

“But… but he or she said…” The Princess of the Night began to say, worried.

“This unknown pony has not yet made any demands yet, he or she could be just trying to scare us.” Princess Celestia pointed out. “But if another letter is sent, we’ll have a better idea of what they want and they we’re dealing with.”

Luna sighed a long sigh. “Fine… but what about… ‘having fun’ if you know what I mean?” she inquired, a bit hesitantly.

Celestia saw her point and thought for a bit. “I suppose we’ll just have to put them on hold, until this spy has been revealed, we don’t want he or she getting photographic evidence of us… ‘doing it’,” she declared, solemnly which made her wife moan with disappointment. She lifted her chin with her hoof. “But don’t worry, we will find out who is trying to do this to us, darling.”

Princess Luna smiled, comforted by Celestia’s words. “Thank you, dear.”

The two sisters-turned-wives quickly shared a kiss before sharing a loving look.

“Now, shall we go about our everyday lives?” Princess Celestia offered.

“I supposed so.” Princess Luna nodded, melancholic.

“That’s my girl.” Celestia said, proudly as she began to lead Luna out of the room, while the Princess of the Night got an idea in her head.

“I… don’t suppose holding tails like we usually do is out of the question too, is it?” she asked her wife, nervously.

Princess Celestia thought for a bit before finally answering. “I suppose not, after all, it wouldn’t be too suspicious of the two Princess’ of Equestria were seen holding tails every now and then, after all, that’s what sisters do, am I right?” she pointed out.

Luna smiled. “Indeed, they do.”

With quiet happiness, as she and Celestia stepped outside and began walking back to the castle ground, their ethereal tails wrapped around each other and practically mixed together as they continued to trot away.

They began to pass by a few ponies along the way, most of whom bowed at the sight of them and didn’t see that they were holding tails at the time. The ones that did see however, didn’t seem to think much of it, treating it as a sisterly thing just like Celestia said so.

Although some did look at them both a little strangely, which made Luna somewhat uncomfortable, especially when she began to hear what some of them we’re saying behind their backs.

“Boy, they seem awfully close.”

“Yeah, a little too close if you ask me.”

“Come on, they’re sisters, what’s the big deal?”

“But look at them! They look more like a couple too me!”

“Can you imagine? The Princess’ dating each other?”

“Scandalous!”

“Disgusting!”

“Sssh! Quiet! We’re not suppose to talk about the Princess’ like that!”

“They won’t be Princess’ anymore if we’re actually right about them!”

Princess Celestia quickly noticed sweat dripping down her sister’s worried face and when she noticed some of the ponies talking about them, one simple eyebrow raise immediately shut them all up, knowing it was unwise to talk about their rulers like that when they were around.

Celestia then put a wing around Luna. “Don’t worry, it’s fine, just ignore them,” she whispered to her comfortingly.

“Ok… but… but what if…” Princess Luna began, her eyes widening in fear. “What if the one who is blackmailing us sees this and uses it as photographic evidence!?”

Princess Celestia simply nuzzled her sister turned wife. “Let ‘em watch,” she smiled as Luna nuzzled back, completely cheered up and also completely unaware that she was right about their mysterious stalker watching their actions closely before making his or her escape without anypony noticing.