Ponies Want Anon

Time: Three days after the events of Part 1.

You're back at Twilight's castle, where you continue to share the pitfalls of your world with her. She frantically scribbles down notes, enamored with the subject at hoof. Then, in a similar vein to Part 1, Rainbow Dash interrupts you.

"Hey Anon, Spitfire wants to talk to you!"

"What the hell could Spitfire want with me? We barely even know each other!", you think to yourself.

"I'll need to borrow that hot air balloon again, Twilight."

Twilight sighs. "Can it wait?"

"Do you want to keep learning about my world?"

"Yes, of course."

"Then I'll be borrowing it now. And I need the cloudwalking spell, please."

She reluctantly enchants you with the spell.

You walk out of Twilight's castle to the hot air balloon parked out back.

"Now Rainbow, you'll need to fly slowly, because I have no clue where I am to go."

"The balloon will take you up to Cloudsdale, and I'll show you from there."

You take off, up into the sky, before entering the floating city. The Pegasuseses are afraid, as most other ponies are, so they stay out of your way while exchanging nervous whispers and glances. Dash thankfully is patient with your comparatively-lethargic pace.

You arrive at the destination, which is not Spitfire's house, but instead the Wonderbolts' barracks. You knock on the door, and Spitfire answers. RD heads off to somewhere else on the complex.

"You requested my presence?", you ask nervously, slightly fearing the harsh yellow Pegasus, who is inexplicably in her Wonderbolt uniform.

"Yes. Enter."

You enter the room and close the door behind you.

"So, Crash says you're pretty good?"

"Pretty good...at what?"

"Did you eat a bowl of amnesia for breakfast? Remember what you two did the other day?"

"Wait...she told you?!"

"Yeah."

"..."

"So let's get to it, Mr. Anon."

"Uh...you see...I'm not sure how Rainbow Dash would feel about this..."

"It's either this or Crash gets kicked off the Wonderbolts."

"..."

What a tough decision! But alas, you know how much dear Rainbow loved being a Wonderbolt. You reluctantly agree to give her what she wants.

"Excellent." She opens another door in her office, which leads to what appears to be a bedroom.

"You live here?"

"Yeah. Gotta be ready bright and early for practice."

She sits on the bed, looking at you with bedroom eyes. You join her on the bed, once again thinking of how Dash will handle the news of this later.

Spitfire realizes that she is still wearing the Wonderbolt flying suit. "Can you help me out of this thing?"

"Sure." She lies down on her back. You locate the long metal zipper, normally concealed by a flap of fabric. You bring it down slowly, but not too slow so as not to take too much time. Once that is done, you are able to free her head and legs from the suit quite easily. You wonder if she genuinely needs a second set of hooves to get suited up, or if she just wants you to be seduced by the prospect of stripping her. Probably the latter.

She flips over and lifts her rear into the air, expecting you to do her like a pony.

"That's not how we humans do it."

"Is it the way you did Crash?"

"Nope."

"Then do me like a human."

You flip her back over and spread her hindlegs.

"We humans start with foreplay."

"Doesn't matter, just get to it already."

You give Spitfire a similar but more haphazard fellatio, caressing her belly, and working your way down towards her pelvic region.

"This is...different...", she remarks.

"Remember that we're only getting started. It gets more similar to the way ponies do it soon enough."

Your fingers have reached the destination. You encircle her labia a few times. Her clitoris winks at your touch.

Instead of fingering, like what you did with RD, you decide to try something different. You lie down, and begin to lick around her opening. She grins lustfully. You lick some more, before seeing if you can't slip your tongue in. Surprise, surprise, your tongue is not enough to part her lips. Oh well, it was worth a shot. Then you decide it's time for the good stuff, so you stop licking and start taking off your clothes.

"Now don't laugh.", you command as you take off your clothes. You know that she'll laugh anyway, because she's almost certainly seen stallion dick.

You finish stripping. Surprisingly, she does not laugh at your small (by human standards) package, instead still giving you the bedroom-eyed stare. Maybe I do compare with the stallions, you think.

Hesitating for a brief moment again, you contemplate what you're about to do. You recall what Spitfire threatened, which puts your mind at ease that by doing this you'll be keeping Rainbow on the Wonderbolts.

You lie down next to her, and turn her to face you. You align yourself with her opening again, then force yourself in by pushing her flank towards you. She moans a bit as you insert and begin to pound her. The walls clamp down on your dick, but for some reason not as tightly as Rainbow's did. It's not because RD was a virgin, as you believe these equines are likely similar to those of your own world in that they can essentially adjust their vaginas to accomodate any size dick.

You keep going, building up speed and force as you go. She moans again, this time more intensely. You feel that you're about to let go, so you withdraw and bring your dick to her mouth.

"What the--", she begins, but is cut off by your sudden plunge into her mouth.

You force her mouth over you further, and then finally, you feel that telltale sign that the cum has been released. You pull out and instruct her to swallow it. She obliges.

"So...what did you think?", you idly ask her as you put your clothes back on.

"If you were a Pegasus, I think I'd let you into the Wonderbolts from that performance alone."

You don't believe her statement, because she didn't even orgasm. You show yourself to the door as she settles in for a nap, of all things. Outside her office, Rainbow is waiting for you.

"Rainbow, I need to have a talk with you", you say, as you pick her up and carry her out the building, following the directions she gives you.

"I'm very disappointed in you for letting Spitfire know what we did the other night."

Her ears flip downwards and she holds back tears. "I'm so sorry, Anon."

"I still love you, but just be aware that your actions might have caused some unintended consequences."

"Like what?"

"Spitfire demanded that I have sex with her, or else she would kick you off the Wonderbolts."

Silent tears trickle from her eyes. "So, what did you do?"

"I did her, because I know how much you love being a Wonderbolt. I hope you can find it in your heart to forgive me for cheating on you."

"I forgive you, Anon. You made the right choice to do that."

You arrive back where you parked the hot air balloon. You set Rainbow back down on the cloud-ground, and get ready to descend back to Ponyville. Before you start undoing the ropes that secure the balloon into place, Rainbow takes your head again and kisses you. Your tongues don't connect this time, but it doesn't matter. At the end of the day, what's important is that you saved your dear Dashie from getting kicked off the Wonderbolts, and had sex along the way, even if it wasn't with who you wanted.

Back on solid ground, Twilight teases you. "So I guess you're the first human Wonderbolt or something?"

"No. I will not disclose what I did, because I'm not proud of the decisions I had to make."

She procably knows what you're meaning, but you don't really care.