Colgate's Practice 4: Blood, Torture and Power

Night had fallen on Ponyville and Colgate was down in the sub-basement deciding on what she was going to take to punish Cheerilee with. She heard a voice say, "Colgate, the last lights in town have gone off."

Colgate replied, "Good. Let me get what I need and we'll get going." She said to herself, "Ok, this isn't going to be a long drawn out torture given we won't have much time but I'll need a body bag for transport, I'll need my whip, I'll need some chains, I'll obviously need sedatives and I'll need my knives," She raised her voice and continued, "And I'll need my general to help me transport some of this stuff."

Pearly headed downstairs and asked, "So what is it you want me to carry?"

She levitated some saddlebags on to him and replied, "Ok, you'll carry the needles, the knives and the body bag." She levitated those items into his bags and continued, "And I'll handle the rest."

Pearly sighed, "Alright, let's get this done."

The two headed out into the darkness on their mission. While she had been putting forth a tough as nails attitude over doing this, she was a tiny bit nervous over who might be watching them. That however was easily overpowered by her desire to punish Cheerilee for her crimes. As they approached the teacher's house Colgate said, "There it is! Let's do this."

Pearly nodded and much to Colgate's surprise, Cheerilee didn't even lock her door at night. Colgate whispered, "Well this makes life easier, that is that much less light my horn will radiate."

As they headed in, they remained as quiet as possible. Given that Cheerilee lived in a single-story home, finding her was not difficult. As they headed into her bedroom Colgate couldn't help but smile realizing that very soon her old ways would officially return. She walked over to Cheerilee, pulled out a syringe of sedatives and moved it towards her neck. She whispered, "Sweet dreams little rat!"

She rammed the syringe into Cheerilee's neck and injected it. This caused Cheerilee to wake up screaming in terror, "What? Who's in here?" She then saw Colgate and her general standing over her. She yelled, "Colgate, what are you doing in my house?"

Colgate pushed her hoof on her neck and snapped, "Punishing you for the crimes you have committed! A pony should never get away with failing to teach the foals what they MUST know to get through life!"

Very quickly the sedatives took effect as Cheerilee fell back to sleep. Colgate said, "Alright general, open the body bag so I can get her put in."

Colgate levitated her into the bag and zipped it. Colgate threw her hooves up in the air and continued, "General, you are going to have to levitate her to the forest. My horn gives off way too much light when I am levitating things."

Pearly replied, "Alright, I'll levitate her."

The two left the house and quietly shut the door. While Pearly's horn did not give off much light, they still had to avoid getting too close to anypony's house because with some ponies, even the smallest amount of unexpected light will wake them up. Once they got inside the forest Pearly sat the bag down and said, "Wow, I didn't expect her to be so heavy."

Colgate levitated the bag and replied, "Well, unicorns can't levitate heavy objects as far as Alicorns can." She looked further into the forest and continued, "Let's get going. I want to get this done and hopefully get back to the castle before anypony will know we are gone."

As they proceeded through the forest they could hear the growls of timberwolves. While this unnerved Pearly, it did not bother Colgate one bit. She knew that if they came after them that she could easily destroy them with her magic. After an hour of walking they finally arrived at the castle. Colgate said, "Alright Pearly, here is the castle where that torture chamber is."

He nodded and followed Colgate across the bridge and into the old structure. They headed to the center until they found the entrance of a passage way. Colgate ordered, "Pearly, be careful. This passageway has multiple traps and if you were to even brush against the wall, you could either get cut in half or have arrows fired at you."

He nodded again and they continued their way down to the bottom. Forty minutes later they arrived in a room illuminated with a dim yellow aura. Colgate looked around and saw the decayed remains of Donut Joe. She walked over to his remains and kicked them, "Hey donut boy, miss me?"

Pearly asked, "I take it that is the one that you and Amethyst killed last time?"

Colgate replied, "Yes, it is." She looked around and saw two sets of hoof cuffs attached to the wall. She continued, "Bring her over here and help me secure her."

Pearly did as ordered and they got to work on Cheerilee. Once they were finished she had her legs stretched out to where it looked like she made an X. Once she began to come to she slurred, "Ugh, where am I."

Colgate and Pearly walked out in front of her. Colgate laughed, "You are in what shall be your final resting place."

Cheerilee began yelling, "Help, help! Somepony help me!"

Colgate smacked her and yelled, "Look bitch, nopony can hear you here and it's not like anypony is going to care you're gone to start with."

She noticed that it was Colgate who had captured her and secured her to the wall. She yelled, "Why Colgate? I know you're mad but it's no reason to do this!"

Colgate pulled out her whip and laughed, "Oh but it is! You promised me two years ago that you would teach those little rats in your school about how important it is to take care of their teeth and to top it off, you come into my office with seven cavities, two rotten teeth and a breath that would make a maggot puke!"

Cheerilee began to struggle, "You'll never get away with this! You'll get caught and Luna will punish you!"

Colgate began to whip Cheerilee violently, causing her to cry out in pain. Colgate screamed, "The only pony who punishes anypony else is ME!"

She continued to whip Cheerilee for another fifteen minutes until all she heard was a soft whimper. Colgate walked up to her and smacked her. She laughed, "That's it! I abuse you like this and all I get is a pathetic little whimper? Damn you're weak!"

Cheerilee cried, "Colgate, I'm sorry! I'm sorry for not educating the foals! If I promise to teach them what I promised, will you let me go?"

Colgate grabbed her chains and began to beat Cheerilee with them. The teacher screamed in agony as her ribs were beginning to break which brought out a manic laughter from Colgate, "No I will not let you go! You know about me doing this and now you must die."

Knowing that she was on a tight schedule Colgate quit beating her and decided the time for her and Pearly to have a snack had come. She grabbed her sharpest knife and headed towards Cheerilee. She looked back at her general and asked, "Hey Pearly, you want a pony leg?"

Pearly licked his chops and replied, "Sure!"

Cheerilee began to struggle but given how well she had been secured to the wall, it did no good. Colgate began cutting her hind legs off, laughing as the screaming got louder and louder. After she got the first one cut off, she tossed it back to Pearly. To make sure she didn't bleed to death she cast a spell on Cheerilee to stop the bleeding. Once she got the other leg cut off she did the same so she could enjoy her snack without worrying about her victim bleeding to death.

As Colgate began to chow down on the leg, she had forgotten how good pony meat was. She licked her chops and laughed, "You know General, I completely forgot how good pony meat is!"

Pearly added, "I know! It is so tasty."

Cheerilee yelled, "You two are gross! How can you stand to eat pony meat?"

Colgate took what was left of Cheerilee's leg and began to beat her with it. She yelled, "Look, everypony has their own vices and with us it happens to be cannibalism."

Cheerilee screamed, "Well I still think it is gross. Hopefully you are done with this."

Colgate smacked her and yelled, "Oh your legs were just the appetizer. Now it is on to the main course."

Colgate released her from her bonds allowing her to fall to the floor. Cheerilee tried crawling away with her front hooves but would not make it far. Colgate bashed her face into the floor and snapped, "Oh, so you're going to be one of those types of rats huh?"

When she turned Cheerilee onto her back she noticed that her face was heavily bruised and that she likely had a concussion. She sighed, "Oh horsefeathers, I was hoping that she would be completely coherent when I do what I do next."

Pearly said, "Well I guess you can't win them all."

Colgate pulled a knife out and continued, "True but I'm still hungry" she began to laugh, "and now it is on to the main course!"

She began to dissect Cheerilee the way one would a frog. Despite Cheerilee having a rather nasty concussion, her screams were still very loud and the pain was agonizing. Colgate began to pull the skin back and eat the meat off of the rib cage, exposing the organs underneath. Colgate began to cry, "General, I also forgot what a truly lovely sight the inner workings of a pony are."

Pearly walked over to see what Colgate was talking about. He too had forgot what the inner workings of a pony looked like. He began to lick his chops, "So Colgate, what part do you get and what part do I get?"

Colgate bent down and ripped the rib cage open, causing Cheerilee to cry out in pain even louder. Colgate smashed the back of her head against the floor and yelled, "WOULD YOU SHUT UP ALREADY?"

Cheerilee was now drifting in and out of consciousness. Colgate yelled, "Damn it! How could I be so foolish? Now I am going to have to wait until she is a bit alert before I take my final prize."

Colgate kept one eye on Cheerilee's face and the other on what she truly desired, her heart. When she heard Cheerilee say, "You monster." she knew the time had come. She bent down and ripped the teacher's heart right out of her chest. Blood was gushing out of her mouth as she chewed up the heart and ate it.

Once she had finished the heart she pointed a wing down at the remains and said, "General, pick something before the body goes cold, but I would avoid the stomach. The acid in it would likely kill you."

Pearly nodded and began to eat her lungs. He was chomping down his part in delight. After finishing their meal Colgate had a feeling it was getting late. She said, "Well General, we had better get home. I have a feeling that dawn isn't too far away."

Pearly looked at the two and asked, "Don't you think we better find a lake to wash off in? I'm covered in a bit of blood but you are soaked and we can't have any blood stains in the castle in the event Luna were to drop by unexpectedly."

Colgate replied, "Yeah, we probably should. There is one not too far away from here. Let's get going."

As they left the chamber Colgate was happier than she had been in ages. She felt that this was her true calling and that she must do anything possible to make sure she can continue to do this. Once they reached the lake they washed themselves off and headed home.

It was nearly dawn when they arrived and the first thing Colgate did was return her equipment to it's proper place and cover the trap door with what was there before. She sighed, "I don't know about you Pearly but I'm tired. I think I'm going to get some rest."

Pearly replied, "Likewise. Cheerilee's lungs were filling enough that I should be good until lunch time."

As Colgate laid there in bed it did not even bother her that Amethyst was not there to cuddle with. She had accomplished what she wanted but soon her mind began to wander elsewhere. She began to wonder what it would take for her to be able to punish ponies without worrying about getting caught and getting executed. She realized that she would have to aim higher than simply ponies with bad teeth and bakers, she would have to start taking out higher ups.