Stixie, Twixie, or... Sunlight?

by Princess Lulamoon

Rating: everyone
Tags: Comedy, Starlight Glimmer, Sunset Shimmer, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Drama, Trixie
Length: 2120

Starlight invites Trixie over, and Twilight notices they're becoming close. Too close. Luckily, its on the day Sunset Shimmer comes to visit, so then she can get conviently wrapped up in the mess.

Without Twilight knowing it, Starlight invites one of her greatest rivals over to visit. Twilight starts to see Trixie and Starlight getting closer than before, and a pit of jealousy worms into her stomach. Luckily Sunset Shimmer is coming the same day to try and 'fix' the mess.

(Obviously, shipping in this one. This would've been loads more relevant about 8 weeks ago. :/)

Published 2016-06-22 05:20:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-07-03 23:51:58 UTC

This could have been written sooner..

Twilight was carefully arranging the table in her throne room, as Spike finished cleaning the chairs down, when she heard a loud knocking on the castle door. She was about to turn and get it when Starlight burst out a hallway, and rushed to the door.

"I've got it, Twilight! Just keep doing what you're doing!", she called hastily as she made for the impatient knocker.

Her head tilted in confusion, she stared at where Starlight had ran off. A snap from Spike's claw caught Twilight's attention, and she turned to see him gesturing to the scattered tableware on the map-turned-dining table. She went back to organizing them, and as two pairs of hoofsteps drew closer, she magically placed the rest of the scattered silverware. Turning, she saw Starlight walking very close to her old rival, Trixie. Twilight glared at Trixie, who gave her a smug look back. Twilight started to blush uncontrollably.

Stop that, Twilight! It's Trixie, for Celestia's sake! You don't, likeher, do you?!

Starlight looked from Twilight to Trixie, who was snickering, locking gazes with Twilight. Trixie then gave Starlight a hug, and Starlight happily returned it. Twilight heaved a sigh of relief, happy the attention wasn't on her anymore. Spike had walked up next to Twilight, and was watching Trixie with an expression of suspicion.

"Good luck with her, Twilight.", Spike muttered, casting a glare at Trixie, "Sorry, but I've got places to be."

"That's fine, Spike.", Twilight whispered.

Spike gave Twilight a quick hug, before a speedily walked past Trixie and Starlight, who were talking and gossiping with each other. As she watched Spike leave, Twilight looked back at the pair of friends, and she had an odd feeling in her stomach. Odd, but familiar. Am I jealous? Why should I be? My own friend's coming today as well.

Trixie and Starlight walked to the table, sitting next to each other. Trixie playfully tapped Starlight's muzzle, and the two erupted in loud giggling. Twilight's stomach churned as that familiar feeling sunk in again. Sitting down at the table, Twilight found her own spot across from them.

Trixie gave Twilight a quizzical look as she sat down. "So, do you have a friend coming? Or is the Princess of Solitude on her own today?", she sneered.

Twilight ignored her face that was starting to flush red, and gave Trixie a smug look of her own. "I do. And it's a pony neither of you have met."

Twilight stood with her front hooves on the table, making herself look superior to both Trixie and Starlight. Trixie cocked an eyebrow, and Starlight started to look uncomfortable. Trying to stand taller, Twilight's hind hooves accidentally kicked her chair too far for her to reach, and she fell to the ground with a soft thump.

"That's the best you've got?", Trixie managed to say before she burst out laughing.

"So that's what Spike meant when he told me about their rival-y battles...", Starlight muttered to herself, crouching lower in her seat, her face red in embarrassment.

An opening of a door made everypony at the table turn. Another pony, Sunset Shimmer, walked in the castle door. She walked up to the table, her eyes closed.

"Hi Twilight! How are things?", she said gleefully, then opening her eyes, she took a step back, noticing the awkward scene before her.

"F-fine...", Twilight groaned, pulling her chair in and sitting back down.

Sunset looked at Trixie, and quickly shifted her gaze to Starlight, who looked as embarrassed as Sunset felt. Taking a breath, Sunset took a seat at the table between Twilight and Starlight. She turned to Starlight, giving her a sympathetic glance. Starlight looked back at her, sighing. Clearing her throat, Trixie caught Twilight's attention. Not that she didn't already have it, anyway.

"So... who's this?", she asked.

"Sunset Shimmer.", she retorted. Looking to Sunset, and speaking in a calmer voice, she introduced Trixie and Starlight to Sunset.

Sunset said a quick greeting to the two unicorns, and lowered in her seat at the awkward tension in the room. She looked to Trixie. "S-so... what're you doing here?", she asked curiously.

Trixie tapped her chin with a hoof. "Well, I do like to come in every now and then to make Princess Loner mad... but today, its mainly to see my best friend.", she smiled, first giving Twilight a triumphant look, then looking at Starlight more sincerely. Starlight smiled back.

The pit in Twilight's stomach fumed, and crossing her hooves, she put her muzzle on them, heaving a heavy sigh. Sunset and Starlight looked at the alicorn sympathetically, and Trixie looked her over quizzically.

Sunset looked back to Trixie. "Best friend?"

Trixie and Starlight nodded in unison, glancing at each other and blushing. Sunset smiled. "You seem very close.."

The blue unicorn gave another nod. "Speaking of which..", Trixie pulled her hat off her head with her hoof, then using her magic, pulled a bouquet of flowers out of the star-etched hat. Looking at Starlight, Trixie was about to give her the flowers when Twilight realized what was going on. Jealousy still churning in her stomach, she slammed her hooves on the table, making the other three mares jump, all startled. Trixie looked at Twilight, a challenge gleaming in her eyes.

"Something wrong, Twilight? Is there some feelings about somepony you'd like to let out?", she sneered.

"No! I d-don't! It's just-!", Twilight looked at Trixie, face flushed as red as a tomato.

Sunset and Starlight looked even more awkward than before. Trixie leaned a little closer to Twilight. "Well?"

"Oh, fine! I like-", her last word was cut off by a loud crash coming from Twilight's kitchen. By the sound of it, probably a pan that fell. Off the fridge, most likely. The mares all looked confused, except Twilight, who stifled a loud groan.

"It's that time of the week again...", she said to herself, sighing.

"Oh yes it is!~", Discord sang, walking out of the kitchen, and into the throne room, his arms full of cabbages.

"Discord?", the other mares all gasped in unison.

Twilight rolled her eyes. "Yes. Discord. He comes by every week and raids my fridge. For some reason..."

Discord nodded, and with a snap of his claw, the cabbages were all in a hiking pack that was already on Discord's back. "There doesn't need to be a reason when you're Discord, Twiley!", he replied, smiling at Twilight.

"Whatever..", the alicorn sighed again.

"Welp, I'll be off! Oh, and if you're having a 'love problem', I would suggest going to these ponies.", he added, snapping his claw to make a short list of names appear in front of Twilight.

Watching Discord teleport away, Twilight's gaze soon went to his list of names. Reading it quickly, she shook her head. "No, no, and no... Wait, who the heck are these 'rock trolls'?"

Trixie looked curiously at the list. "Wait, who are the other names? And why no?"

Twilight groaned. "Names, doesn't concern you. And why no? Well, let's see, first, I'd rather not get involved with changelings again. Second, the Crystal Empire is too far away, and third, Pinkie Pie knows nothing about love."

"But she's psychic.. Isn't she?", Starlight pointed out.

"That's just her Pinkie Sense, which has nothing to do with relationships.", Twilight countered, dismissing the idea.

Trixie cleared her throat yet again. "Twilight? Who is it that you like again?", she asked, going back on topic.

Twilight stuttered. "U-um..."

"Well?", Trixie gave Twilight a curious look, leaning in closer, causing Twilight to blush again. With no answer from Twilight, Trixie came even closer, until their muzzles were touching.

"Y-you...", Twilight whispered, the word barely audible to Trixie's ears.

The Second Part, 'cause you asked for it.

Starlight and Sunset gave each other a confused look, not hearing Twilight. On the other hoof, Trixie looked at Twilight, a tinge of blush reddening her otherwise blue fur.

"Me..?", she whispered back.

Twilight nodded. The two mares looked at each other, both of the faces now red. All of a sudden, a white flash made the two mares jump, and Discord thrust his snout in between Trixie and Twilight.

"You know", Discord whispered, slinging an arm around Twilight, "Love triangles like these normally end with murder. And I'm putting the weapon in Twilight's hooves."

With a snap of his claw, a bloody knife appeared in front of Twilight. She jumped, startled, almost falling off of her chair. Using her own magic to make the knife disappear, she shot an angry glare at Discord. "Discord! Why can't you just leave?!", she snapped at the draconequus.

"Fine. But there isn't this kind of drama at my place.", Discord grumbled, snapping his claw and teleporting away.

Starlight and Sunset then looked at Twilight, still completely confused. Clearing her throat, Starlight finally spoke. "Um, Twilight, what was that about?", she asked, looking to her mentor.

Twilight gulped. "Oh.... N-nothing..."

Trixie looked from Starlight to Twilight, unable to keep her mouth shut. "Twilight said I'm the pony she likes!", she burst out quickly, slapping a hoof to her mouth immediately afterwards.

"Trixie!", Twilight glared at the unicorn.

Trixie gave Twilight an apologetic smile. Starlight let out a gasp.

"Is that why you didn't want me being friends with her?", she asked after a moment of recollection.

"Partly...", Twilight replied, sounding more and more awkward.

Starlight looked at Trixie. "So who is it that you like?"

Trixie's eyes widened. "I l-like... um...", she stuttered, startled by the sudden question.

Sunset heaved a sigh, cutting Trixie off before she could find her tongue. She got up from her seat, walking up to Twilight.

"Twilight, this has been... interesting, and all, but I think I'm going to head out. Princess Celestia said she wanted to see me, and you seem to be busy enough without me getting in the way."

Twilight stopped Sunset with a hoof. "Don't go! I.. we-"

Sunset cut her off, pushing Twilight's hoof away. "If I wanted to get involved in drama like this, I would've stayed at CHS."

Saying a quick goodbye, Sunset made her way out the door, closing it softly behind her. Starlight was still glaring at Trixie, while Trixie gave Twilight a sympathetic look. Twilight heaved a sigh.

"So..?", Starlight prompted Trixie again.

Trixie blushed, and looked from Twilight to Starlight. "Can't I just say both of you?"

"No!", Twilight and Starlight shouted in unison.

"That figures...", Trixie muttered heaving a sigh.

After a few moments of awkward silence, Starlight asked Trixie yet again.

Trixie looked at both Twilight and Starlight before getting up and storming out of the room. Watching Trixie go, Starlight let out a heavy sigh, putting her face flat on the table. Twilight put a comforting hoof on her shoulder.

"I'm sorry, Starlight. I didn't mean to drive her off...", Twilight apologized.

Starlight let out another sigh. "It's not your fault. It's mine," she mumbled, her voice muffled by the table.

Twilight was about to reply when Starlight continued, "I'm the one who invited her over here. I'm the doofus who kept pestering her."

"That may be true, but we can still go and apologize...", Twilight reminded her.

Starlight lifted her head. "You think she's still in town?"

Twilight shrugged. "I'm not sure, but we can always try."

Starlight gave a determined nod. "Let's do it.

Trixie was in her wagon, pacing around and mumbling angrily to herself. She let out an angry snort when she heard an knock at her door. Now who could that be?, she asked herself as she walked over to answer. Trixie opened the door to see Twilight and Starlight standing there, apologetic looks on their faces.

"What do you two want?", Trixie asked in an irritated tone.

Starlight looked at Twilight, who gave her a reassuring look in return. She stepped closer to Trixie. "I... I'm sorry, for pestering you about who you liked. I shouldn't have been so impatient with you..."

Twilight stepped up next to Starlight. "And I'm sorry as well, for making your visit more awkward then it should have been.."

Trixie looked from Starlight to Twilight, an odd expression on her face. She then nodded. "And I forgive you." She gave a warm smile, and wrapped her hooves around Twilight and Starlight in a warm hug.

Starlight looked up at Trixie with hopeful eyes. "So, who is it you like more anyway?"

The three mares broke up from their hug, and Trixie cleared her throat to answer the question. First, she slapped Starlight's face with a hoof, and then she gave an even bigger smile than before.

"I like both of you the same, featherbrain."