Starlight Mistress

by Emiko Gale

Rating: mature
Tags: Nightmare Moon, Thriller, Trixie, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Starlight Glimmer, Romance, Sex, Dark
Length: 1915

Starlight's dreams of living happily with Trixie were destroyed as she got swept away by the ruler of nightmares.

Starlight dreamed of living happily with Trixie but her dreams were replaced by nightmares after getting kidnapped by Nightmare Moon...Who keeps Starlight Glimmer as her mistress. Will Starlight and her love for Trixie ever be the same?

Published 2016-06-25 22:50:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-07-22 20:42:39 UTC

Chapter 1

Author's Note

Hello everyone, it's me Emiko Gale and I am here...To post my first ever pony fanfic. *fanfare*

But I am here to give you some warnings...This fanfic has an M rating for a reason. This fanfic involves implied rape, abuse, and some other stuff that readers might find disturbing, not in the first chapter but in the near future. I realize not everyone is interested in ponies after dark. Heck! I disturbed myself with the concept but I decided to go with it...Besides, this fanfic will also have Starlight and Trixie romance as well, my otp.
I hope you guys enjoy.

Chapter 1

The two unicorns Trixie and Starlight Glimmer danced around together. Starlight wore a maroon tuxedo and Trixie wore a purple dress with pale yellow stars, similar to her magical cape. They were the best of friends who acted like marefriends, in their hearts they wanted to be that way.

With Trixie's pale magic she tried to lift Starlight in the air, it made the lilac unicorn shocked and overjoyed at the same time. She was never held with such affection by a mare, her stomach sang with glee.

"I want to become more powerful so I can lift you up above every pony," Trixie declared.

Starlight gasped, but then she charged up her maroon colored magic and lifted up Trixie higher. "Not if I do it first," Starlight said with a grin.
The colors of their magic mixed and created a bliss that felt so right to them. They swam around in the air giggling until they pulled themselves into a hug, and then descended on to the ground to sit side by side. Starlight savored the moment giving a happy sigh for her friend.

Then like the flash of light, an ominous noise caused Starlight's eyes to open. The world around her was now dark and cold, and Trixie was gone.

"Trixie," Starlight cried.

Starlight rose up, unwilling to accept what was happening, but as she breathed in the cold air she believed, and her legs buckled.

"Where—" Starlight was cut off by seeing her own breath.

Starlight sprinted away trying to rid herself of the cold and to look for her friend. She looked up and the stars that were racing along with her briefly only to crash into something else, possibly another pony. The blow caused Starlight to curl up trying to rid herself a pain, and then she looked up.

A large pony with hair like the stars. No, it was an alicorn, Starlight thought there were only 3 alicorns. Starlight stood up and prepared to charge her magic, but the alicorn's hair seemed to grow longer, curling around Starlight.

"Where's Trixie," Starlight cried.

The alicorn moved her face closer to Starlight, which caused the unicorn to charge up her magic and clench her teeth, the alicorn laughed. Her laughter because so powerful that she nearly fell backward, but alicorns were not easily fallen.

Starlight unleashed a zap, hoping to hit the vulnerable alicorn but her indigo hair caught the spark and caused a flash that nearly made the unicorn go blind, then silence.

Despite being battered, Starlight wasn't about to back down, but she felt a large hoof hold her own, it wasn't the same as Trixie. The alicorn looked down on Starlight and smirked.

"I have more power over you."

The alicorn's hair slithered towards Starlight again, and the dark alicorn spread her wings enveloping them on Starlight and causing her to let out a scream, and wake up back to reality. The unicorn hoarsely breathed in and out, and then closed her eyes and allowed some tears to escape. She wiped a droplet off with her hoof and then grabbed on to the ground to drag herself out of her bed falling on her hind legs.

She looked into her crystal vanity and summoned a tissue with her magic, and cleaned her face. She looked in the mirror and swallowed seeing her own fear stricken face and bloodshot eyes. Her picture perfect mane now out of place and her mint streaks ruined.

Who was she?

Starlight stroked her forehead with her hoof thinking the first thing she should do was alert Princess Twilight, but then her horn blinked a bit. She looked up at her horn and with the corner of her eye saw it was blinking pale blue. Starlight gasped and quickly grabbed a hairbrush and brushed her mane which thankfully wasn't tangled, and then summoned a magical video cam with her horn, Revealing a familiar unicorn with her usual confident smirk. Starlight tried to her best to make a natural smile, but Trixie made her smile easily.

"Hello my friend," said Trixie.

"Trixie!" Starlight cried almost a bit too loudly. "Thank goodness!"

Trixie placed her purple hat on her head. "Nice to see you are—" Trixie paused. "Are you alright Starlight?"

Starlight sniffed, "Yeah…"

"I was going to say that I was heading straight for Ponyville but would show up late in the evening, however," Trixie stopped to levitate a sandwich and take a huge bite. She made sure to chew and swallow before talking again. "I feel I should show up now."

Starlight placed a hoof on her chest, thinking Trixie couldn't see her distress.

"But Trixie…"

"No ‘buts' Starlight," Trixie said firmly. The unicorn summoned more magic and if Starlight was hearing correctly, Trixie was packing up her traveling gear really quickly. "If I leave now I'll show up earlier, maybe you could meet me towards the front of Ponyville."

Starlight nodded. "I will."

Starlight didn't think about it much, but she wanted to see Trixie above all else.

"Great!" Trixie cried triumphantly. "I'll head there now and will be there when the sun sets."

Starlight placed her hoof on the bottom of the video cam, and for a moment she let out a small smile. "Ok." She mouthed something she couldn't bring herself to say at the moment, but Trixie was too busy to see anyway.

"See you soon Starlight," Trixie said. Starlight saw her purple eyes sparkle a bit before the video cam disappeared.

Another set of tears formed on Starlight's eyes, she grunted and galloped out of her room nearly hitting her head on the door. Starlight ran for the Princess Twilight's chambers but gasped at the sight of Twilight not being around, she searched the hallways and library for Spike but couldn't find the young dragon either. She then walked around aimlessly with her head down heading back to her room, only to find a note on the door. The unicorn stared wide eyed for a moment and then nervously held the note towards her face with her magic.

Dear Starlight,
You'll have the castle to yourself for the time being for the entire day, maybe 2 or 3. I am sorry to leave you alone like this. But the girls and I were called up to solve a friendship problem together. Could you believe it?! I love days like these…
Anyways, I hope you'll be fine by yourself for the time being. If you're not too busy maybe you can sort through books and sweep. You don't have to but that would be really helpful…Oh, who am I kidding? Try to discover some more discoveries in friendship my dear student, you won't regret it!
~Twilight

Starlight sighed and nearly crumbled the paper with her magic, the unicorn was always alone but for once in her life she wanted to cry out that she was alone and she was afraid, even if it was pitiful. She sat against the crystal wall and curled up, looking down at her reflection in the floor and saw her long face, but then the light bulb went off in her head. She glared at her reflection and stood up.

"I need to be stronger than this!" She cried.

She went into her room to grab her bag and placed it over her, and then she headed out for Ponyville.

~~~~~
Starlight had to admit, she adored Ponyville. It wasn't as stuck up as her hometown, sure there were some ponies more special than others but it felt that every pony was special for some reason here, and boasting wasn't a thing. Even Princess Twilight felt relatable and down to earth despite being a princess.

The unicorn considered going to the spa again but felt it wouldn't feel right without Trixie. Then again, she felt she should look nice for her and decided to just take a beauty appointment, but the spa ponies noticed Starlight's knots and insisted on a short massage. It did ease the unicorn up a bit.

Then fine dining Ponyville style, Starlight started off with freshly made juice. She chose the dark purple drink that looked pleasing to her eyes and then caused her tongue to dance inside her mouth because of the tart tastes of strawberry, blackberry, and blueberry.

For the first course, Starlight reluctantly ordered a dish that involved toast with chopped tomatoes and olive oil. When the food came to the table the delicate scent took her in and she ate 3 pieces with her cheeks going wide as she chewed. She ended up getting a second order and enjoying it as much as she did the first but then decided she was satisfied enough to not want a second course.

After the meal, she walked, walked slowly to digest her food properly but she found enjoyment in just walking. But she also stared at the windows of stores. One store stopped her in her tracks and she practically placed her hoof on the window. Staring at the sparkling jewels that Rarity and Spike would like, but she questioned if Trixie would like them as well.

A gray stallion with a silver mane saw Starlight staring through the window and smiled widely, Starlight gave a weak smile back and trembled a bit. The door opened with a loud dinging noise. "Good afternoon Miss! Would a lovely mare such as yourself want to buy something nice?"

Starlight's eyes went wide. "Oh!...No no no!" She shook her head furiously and took a few hoof steps back. "I don't have enough bits."

Starlight sighed and sat down on the grass, flicking a few blades of grass with her hoof. "Still, it would be nice to get my friend something…She deserves something as nice like the stuff in your store."

The shopkeeper pony peered above Starlight. "A marefriend?" He said in a nosy matter.

Starlight's lilac face turned a shade of rose red from blushing. "Oh no." She cleared her throat. "It's not like that."

The shopkeeper pony smiled at Starlight and then turned. "On the other side of Ponyville, you may find a few vendors. One is somepony I know, a nice young mare. She sells cheaper pieces of jewelry. Maybe not made of real silver or diamond but perfect for friendships…And other close bonds."

Starlight smiled slowly and nodded. "Thank you."

Starlight continued walking, remembering that she didn't have much money to burn on special stuff, but she found herself captivated by the small vendor area. A green-maned mare was working in her area decorated in what looked like soft velvet blankets. And a pony manikin head that wore something around its neck that caused Starlight's periwinkle eyes to light up like a filly awestruck by something glowing. The accessory didn't glow, but Starlight felt it was perfect for her and Trixie.

Chapter 2

Something has gone wrong. We don't seem to have an archived copy of that chapter.