The Choice of Love

by AppleJackSwagg

Rating: mature
Tags: Pinkie Pie, Sex, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Sad, Romance, Applejack, Original Character, Trixie, Fluttershy
Length: 4122

Yangus is the new colt in Ponyville and he must make a choice of love

Yangus the new colt has just arrived in Ponyville, and there are 4 mares who fall in love with him and so does he but this colt can only have one mare what is he to do, conflicted and worried will he make his choice find out in this story

Published 2012-06-21 07:14:01 UTC
Last updated 2012-06-21 07:14:01 UTC

Chapter 1:Meeting Yangus

Ponyville was lively as ever, everypony was walking around shopping, hanging out, and laughing, the smell of sweets and food filled the air. It takes you back to a simpler time where life was enjoyable and there was peace all around. “Hmm this is the place alright, it looks peaceful, a perfect location to start a new life.” He starts to walk around for a few minutes taking in the sites and smell of the place, only to bump into Twilight, interrupting her magic knocking her books down, “Oh I’m so sorry I need to watch where I’m going,” he helps Twilight up off the ground. When she got up and looked at him, he was a big blue colt with black and brown dreads, sporting a red hat and glasses, he also had some of his fur missing on his mouth. “Oh it’s no problem really.” She looked at what he was holding which was a green sack tied to a stick, “Oh my you must be new here?” He Smiled and said,

“Yeah I am mind showing me around the place?” Twilight giggled, because never before has she seen such a cute colt. “Well shall we begin the tour?” she walked off with the blue colt following behind her, “oh um we have not introduced ourselves yet” she said while walking, “I’m Twilight Sparkle and you are?” “The names Yangus nice to meet ya Twilight.” The tour started at what appeared to be a big tree with windows and a balcony, never before has Yangus seen a house like this.

“This is my place were me and a baby dragon named Spike live here” Just then one of the windows opened up and a short purple dragon with green eyes and green spikes, looked down below “Oh hey Twilight who’s the big blue pony?” “Well Spike his name is Yangus and he is new here, I’m just showing him around the place. The blue colt looked up at the purple dragon and smiled, “Nice to meet ya Spike,” and both Yangus and Twilight walked off to the next stop, which was a big pink house with a brown roof that looked like a big cookie with icing on the side, and to top it all off on the top of the house there were three lit candles on a cupcake. The house looked like you could eat it bite by bite, “Well this place is certainly cheerful” Yangus said while still in awe of the house, “Yup this is Sugar Cube Corner were five ponies live; Mr. and Mrs. Cake, Pinkie Pie, Carrot Cake, and finally Pound Cake, they are very nice people you will love them”

Twilight rang the doorbell, and a Pink pony answered the door, she had pink curly mane and tail, also she smelled of sweets and cupcakes, which brought Yangus back to the time when he stood at the square smelling the same aroma, this must have been what he was smelling. The pink pony had a big smile on her face “Hey Twilight what brings you by here oh you came to have a party with me right?” “Um not exactly Pinkie Pie, you see I’m showing this guy around his name is Yangus, and he is new here.

” Pinkie took a look at him, and she blushed “Oh wow he is big and very cute, I wouldn’t mind partying with him sometime.” Yangus then smiled at her and said well then nice to meet you too Pinkie, I’m gonna have to come by here again and we can get to know each other a little more.” He said in sexy voice, Twilight smiled and said “Well we better go we have a lot more places to visit” she trotted off, Yangus and Pinkie was still looking into each other eyes, then he gave one last smile and followed trying to catch up with Twilight. [End]

Chapter 2: Getting to Know The Place More

Next they came across a bridge, and in the distance Yangus saw a wooden cottage and it reminded him of seeing a old western movie where the hero was held up in a cottage surrounded by thugs and thieves .Animals were all around the cottage, he never seen so many critters in one place, “this is where a pony named Fluttershy lives, and she loves animals very much, she is shy and scared at times about meting new ponies but overall she will get used to you.” Yangus heard some wings flapping, so he looked up in the sky, and he saw a yellow pony with long pink hair that covered part of her eyes, and a innocent look on her face, seeing her face reminded Yangus of his past were there were two little fillies one was Yangus and the other was another was a green filly with long straight hair and the same innocent look as Fluttershy’s. Twilight then said “Hey Yangus you okay?” He snapped out of it “Yeah Im fine just daydream is all” Then she proceeded to say “Fluttershy meet Yangus he is new here im showing him around Ponyville” Fluttershy took a look at the big blue pony and, was a little nervous,

“Um…..hi nice to meet you Yangus” Her voice was like an angle singing a beautiful song in the heavens, “Wow your voice is so cute, everypony must be all over you huh” Fluttershy looked away and blushed “Well um…if you want to stop by later on me and my animals can sing a song for you, if that’s alright with you?” Yangus nodded and smiled, “Come on the tour’s not done yet” Twilight said as was walking away, Yangus followed behind her. Next stop they came to was a house that looked all fancy like it was a castle of some sort, with white and light pink, there was a window at the top and two mannequin ponies on both sides.

Looking at this house reminded him of a picture he saw in a magazine, it had the same design and everything, maybe this was the place that was being advertised in the magazine. Twilight rung the door bell, and a little white filly with green eyes answered the door, she had a little purple pinkish curly mane and tail, “Oh hello Sweetie Belle is your sister home?” Twilight said, “Yeah she is right over there putting some finishing touches on a dress” Her voice was adorable but squeaky like a mouse. Yangus and Twilight both walked in the store, to see another white pony with a very curly purple mane and tail with blue eyes, “Ugg hold still this will be over in a minute."

The pony she was talking to was a blue pony with a rainbow colored mane and tail and red crimsion eyes. She seemed like she was the cocky and athletic type thought Yangus, Twilight then said “Hello girls this is Yangus he is new here and im showing him around Ponyville, they both looked over at them. “Hello darling my name is Rarity welcome to Ponyville.” Her voice reminded him of his high school teacher who always dressed nice and had a certain class to her, “Hey Rarity nice to meet you too, um who is the blue pony over there?” The blue pony then looked at him “The name is Rainbow Dash I’m Ponyvilles best athlete and weather watcher” She reminded Yangus of his workout rival, who always brags and competes with him. He then pointed at the blue pony and said

“One day me and you are going to compete to see who is more fit.” He then smiled and walked out the door, “Well then we best be going, we have one more place to visit” Twilight then left as well. Both ponies walked until they came to a farm, it was the biggest farm Yangus has ever seen. There was a big barn that also served as a house, it was a reddish color with an apple on top, and the smell of livestock filled his nostrils. It reminded him of a bedtime story his mom used to read to him, it was the saddest story he ever heard. [End]

Chapter 3: Staying

There were four ponies that walked out of the house, one was a pale green old pony with a white mane and tail, her eyes were an orange like color, also she used a walker to get around. Looking at her reminded Yangus of his own grandma and how she used to give him advice on life, it almost brought a tear to his eye because they were so close, the next pony that walked beside her was a big red pony, he was exactly the same size and bluffness of Yangus, he had a blonde mane and tail, which was short, his eyes were green, and also he had a wooden thing around his neck Yangus did not know what it was but he thought it looked cool.

The next pony was another filly like the one he saw and Carousal Boutique but she was a light orange pony with orange like eyes, her mane and tail were pink and short, she reminded him of his neighbors, filly who was always sweet and kind. And the last pony caught his eye, she was a brownish color with blonde mane and tail like to big red pony, also had green eyes, a brown western hat on and finally three freckles on her face which made her even more cuter. Twilight Sparkle then walked up to them and said “Ah perfect timing Yangus this is the apple family, apple family this is Yangus he is new here and im showing him around.”

The granny pony looked at him and said in a wrinkly voice “Big Macintosh what are you doing over there and why are you blue?” Everybody looked at her with a confused look then the small filly pony said in a adorable voice much like the little white filly, “Hey Yangus welcome to Ponyville I hope you enjoy your stay, oh and im Applebloom im the youngest sibling of the Apple Family” Next the big red pony talked in a manly deep voice “As you already heard im Big Macintosh, but everybody calls me Big Mac for short, welcome to Ponyville” His size compared to that of Yangus size but Yangus was a little bit buffer.

And lastly the light orange pony spoke in a southern accent which made Yangus fall for her harder “Im Applejack im the second youngest of the apple family, big mac is the oldest, oh and over there is Granny Smith, ya’ll are welcome to stay for as long as you like partner.” Yangus smiled and said “I’m glad to be here in Ponyville I met a lot of nice ponies and I think I will like it here, now we just got to see where I’m going to stay.” Hearing his voice Applejack was not the only one falling for him, she blushed a little. “Well I will gather up the girls at my house and we can discuss who he can stay with, come on Yangus and Applejack lets go gather the rest of the girls.” All three of them walked to Sugarcube corner, and Carousal Boutique , and gathered the rest of the mane 6.

At Twilight’s Library house the meeting got started “Alright everypony settle down now the reason why you all are here is because we need to find a place for our new resident Yangus to stay, any suggestion girls” Twilight said, Pinkie Pie walked forward and said happily bouncing up and down, “He can stay with me Mr. and Mrs. Cake would love to have him stay, we can both party and do all other stuff and and…..” “Hold on now Pinkie darling I don’t think Yangus wants to stay with you because you will drive him insane with all your parties.”

Rarity said gracefully, ‘Okay the miss fancy pants how about you then?!” Rarity looked surprised and said “Oh no no darling I have too much to orders to fill and plus I have to keep Sweetie Bell out of trouble, although it would be nice ot have a nice fit muscular young colt to help with the packages of materials that comes in.” “How about you Rainbow Dash im sure you could use some company?”

Rainbow Dash looked at Yangus “Sorry Twilight I cant because for one he can’t fly up to Cloudsdale , and I’m not picking his heavy self-up, and second of all the Wonderbolts are coming to my house to hang out so sorry Yangus I would like a pony who is athletic but im gonna be busy.” Fluttershy stepped up and said quietly “Well… um he can stay with me I would not mind the company.”

“What was that Fluttershy we could not hear you?” She then got a little bit louder “Um…he can stay with me because its just me and angel and I would love the company but you know if that’s okay with you.” She hid her face with her hair, Twilight smiled “Yeah that could work but lets see what applejack has to say” “Aw sucks Twi it would be no problem letting him stay with me and the family we would love the company of another big strong colt” She looked at him with sexy eyes, “Well I won’t say anything because we do not know who he wants to stay with, so Yangus who do you wanna stay with?” He looked around the room at all the mane 6 faces , some were eager, and some were not sure it would be a good idea, and finally he said “Well my choice is” [End]

Chapter 4: Have a Taste of Sweet Pie

Yangus made his decision, “I will stay with Pinkie, but for a few weeks then Fluttershy, and finally Applejack.” Everypony looked at him with surprised faces, “Well then that settles it Pinkie you have Yangus for a few weeks” Pinkie eyes lit up with joy and she jumped up and down, “Oh yay we are goning to have so much fun and then some” She said standing next to him really close. The other ponies all agreed on his decision, all of a sudden Rarity pulled Pinkie to the side and whispered, “you naughty pony, you plan on having a good time with him, hehe have fun not walking for a few days.” Pinkie blushed and smiled,

“Alright well I have to fly the Wonderbolts will be here any minute now, nice meeting ya Yangus and I accept your challenge to see who is more fit” Rainbow Dash then took off like a rocket going at top speed. “Well darlings I have to go see if Sweetie Belle made a mess of things while I was gone, good to see you Yangus I hope to see you around sometime.” She then trotted off, “Well those apple trees are not gonna buck themselves I have to get to work, but um Yangus im really excited for when ya’ll stay cause im going to see if that body is just for show” She also walked out “Oh my I forgot to cook angle something I better get back,” When she walked past him she let out a cute while blushing, and flew out the door.

“Okay Pinkie Yangus time for you to go as well because I have a lot of research and reading to do, and send a letter to the princess about my report for today,” Pinkie and Yangus walked out of Twilight’s library, just the Spike passed by them “Oh hey Pinkie, Yangus how’s it going just got back from Zercoars getting a herb so Twilight can research it, so what are you two doing?” Pinkie eyes were still lit up “Yangus is going to be staying with me for a few weeks right Yangus?” “Hehe yeah im excited cause I have not had a place to sleep in a long time so this is good for me.” Spike smiled “Well Yangus I hope you enjoy your stay and welcome to Ponyville” he went inside and closed the door. Back at Sugarcube corner Pinkie introduced Yangus to Mr and Mrs. Cake, Seeing those two reminded him of another Magazine he was reading and they was doing an article on places to get sweets from and he saw two ponies in the article that looked exactly like Mr. and Mrs. Cake, he pondered to himself is this the place they were talking about.

“Well it will be no problem for Yangus to stay with us, but one thing how is he going to pay rent” Pinkie then said “Oh don’t worry Mr. Cake I will pay for his expenses” Mrs. Cake, said “Oh no no no he don’t have ot pay rent since he is staying for only a few weeks, just help around here with the babies and chores, and we shall call it even” Yangus smiled and nodded “Come on Yangus I will show you were you will be staying” They went up the stairs and turned right and there was a door with a visitor name sign on it, so Pinkie opened the door and the room Yangus walked in was medium size but just enough for him to stay in. The walls looked like candy and the bed sheets had different kinds of sweets on them, the four support beams on the bed were like candy canes, the floor was soft just like some bubble gum, and finally the room smelled like cake icing, Yangus was in awe of all this and said “I like this room I think im gonna like staying here “ Just then down below the cakes shouted up the stairs

“We are going on a delivery Pinkie, Yangus so watch the babies okay.” Then the door shut and they were gone. Yangus proceeded to put his stuff on the bed when out of nowhere pinkie pounced on him knocking him on to the bed on his back with her on top of him, she whispered in his ear

"Now we are going to have a party just the two of us” “But pinkie what about the babies shouldn’t we check on them first?” He said sweating badly, she then pressed her lips against his softly, the thought of babies left Yangus mind all he could think about was how Pinkies mouth tasted like cake. She broke the kiss and said “Hmmm don’t worry about them they are asleep, but you’re a good kisser Yangus.” He blushed and turned her over so that he was on top of her, his massive size overpowering her it was like a bull holding down a delicate little pony, he then proceeded to kiss her on the neck.

“Oh my Yangus im getting turned on kiss me some more” And he did just that, until Pinkie could not take any more and kissed him passionately Yangus hoof was moving down south to see how wet it was, he felt all her juices on his hoof. “Oh Pinkie your so wet and I’ll make you even wetter.” He then moved down to her special area and started to lick the juices and use his tongue to lick the clit. Pinkie was overcome with pleasure, letting out moans, squeals, and drooling out of her mouth, Yangus knew what he was doing.

As he was not the only one turned on his member was stiff, he then stopped and wiped his mouth, “Now its your turn Pinkie” His member was right in her face it was so big and well-endowed, she smiled and gladly licked the tip of his head to get the precum off, Yangus could not wait anymore and forced her mouth right on his member, and she did not resist. Her mouth was so wet and warm, he was in heaven “Oh Pinkie ahhhh I don’t think I can hold out any longer” Moaned Yangus, she then took her mouth off of his member “Oh not yet you have to bang me first” [End]

Chapter 5:Choices

Pinkie bent over exposing her plot and private place “Go ahead and fuck me like there’s no tomorrow, I want you to ram me hard!” Pinkie said with a sexy voice, Yangus smiled and got behind her and rammed his member inside her, it was wet and warm like a bagel that just came out of the microwave. Wasting no time he starts to fuck Pinkie brains out, all you could hear was Pinkies moaning and the sex sounds that was coming from Yangus and Pinkie. “Are you enjoy this my sweet?” Yangus said, Oh yes I am im so happy to be doing it with a big strong colt, and I need to tell you something after we finish” He smiled and bent his head down to bite her ear, doing that made her really wet, now his member was sliding in and out so easily. She stopped him from fucking her to; push him on the bed on his back, “It’s my turn now” Having said that she got on top of him and plopped down on his wet member, then started to bounce up and down,

“Fuck yes its hitting my womb so hard I want you to shoot inside me” Yangus eyes opened wide “Wait a minute now Pinkie I don’t want to do that, can I just cum on your face or something?” She then brought her face to his and what he saw was not the fluffy mane he once knew now it was long and straight, she looked really cute this way which made him even harder. She kissed him softly and whispered in his ear “I love you Yangus, and don’t worry I will just tell Twilight to use her magic to not make me pregnant” Hearing that made Yangus heart pound in his chest hard, “Pinkie you…I,” Yangus had a smile on his face, and then he got up and she was now on her back, thrusting harder and harder until he let all his semen out inside of her, so much was released that it flowed on the bed sheets and on the floor, finally he took his member out of her and fell right beside her

“Pinkie I….I love you too” Saying that made her so happy they held each other. After the sex they cleaned up and walked out of the room “Oh um I will be right back I need to go out for a second.” Pinkie nodded and Yangus walked out the door, only to meet Applejack who was walking by, “Howdy partner how you doing so far?’ Applejack said happily “Oh im doing alright just going out for a walk after settling in my new room” “Well shoot partner im going to the market, gotta get some more baskets want to join me?” “Okay” So both ponies walked together to the market. While in the market Yangus looked at Applejack, with her perfect form he wanted to say something that did not sound to awkward, but she looked at him as well with his big muscular body and cute face, also she did not what to say anything awkward.

Finally Yangus got the courage to talk “Hey AppleJack do you have feelings for me?” That question startled her for a moment, and she looked away and blushed “Well yeah that is why I was hoping ya’ll would stay with me first, because I really wanted to know more about you.” They made it to the basket place; she got five baskets, which she paid for. Yangus helped her carry some, and they left Applejack could not hold it in her heart any longer, so she stopped him and looked In his eyes,

“Yangus I love you” In his head he remembered that Pinkie said the same thing, he was in a bind because now he has two ponies that loved him, sooner or later he would have to make a choice. “I…Love you too Applejack” They kissed softly, her mouth tasted like apples, After they kissed she said

“Wow you kiss like a pro, well I better get going thanks for walking with me to get some baskets I’ll see ya’ll around” Then she walked off in the distance, what was Yangus gonna do was conflicted and sad that he would have the break a heart. But little did he know his problems were just getting started for another pony had the same feelings about him [End]