Author's Note
Warning: this part of my story has a brief mention of rape. I don't like it, but I really feel as though it should be addressed. I sincerely apologize for any people affected by my mentioning it. To any survivors of sexual assault, I really, truthfully pray for your health and happiness.
...Magic
"Hello, Twilight. I just wanted to say that I'm sorry I had sex with you. No, no, that sounds rude..."
This sentence was muttered on a bright and sunny day in Ponyville. Unfortunately, the young, yellow girl pacing around the door of the Golden Oaks library was anything except sunny. You see, she had a problem. Or, at least, she thought she did. She wasn't exactly sure what she had, but she knew that it was eating her up, and that her friend inside the library could help her out.
Rainybow Dash was busy dressing in style.
Pinky Pie was busy baking. With blood...
...orange food dye.
Applesack was busy being a silly girly.
Charity was probably busy trying to avoid rain, because she was a marshmallow.
So, it stands to reason that Twibright must be busy as well," thought Flustershy. I'd better not disturb her.
She started to walk away, but stopped.
"Ohhh, but I'm disturbed! I have to speak to her!" Flustershy spoke with fervor.
And before she knew it, she had knocked loudly on the door. She only had to wait a few seconds, staring at the door with determination, before it opened widely and exposed a purple girl staring her right in the face.
"AAAH!" screamed Twibright, out of fear that Flustershy's Stare had been meant for her.
"AAAH!" screamed Flustershy, because she had been startled by a face right in her face.
"AAAH!" screamed Pinky Pie, because... well, I guess she screamed because other people were screaming, but she's not important to the story, so we'll just ignore her.
"Hey!" screamed Pinky. "You can't do that, Mr. Narrator! I have to get in there and solve the problem with...guess what!"
I'm trembling with anticipation, Pinky.
"A PAR-"
Aaaaand scene change.
********
"I'm so sorry, Twibright, I was just coming over to talk to you and-"
"Please don't make me relive all my bad memories like the one I had with my brother and-"
"-just seemed like the right thing to do, but Angel insisted, you know how he can be-"
"-can't even imagine how big his penis was at the time, and I accidentally tripped and had it in my-"
"-wait, what?"
Both of the girls stopped talking. While Flustershy looked confused at how the conversation had turned, Twibright simply had eyes as big and a face as red as Bob the Tomato.
"Aheheh," giggled Twibright, a little too loudly to be natural. "Let's, um, let's just ignore the fact that I said that and head inside the library, okay?"
Flustershy agreed, and they both walked inside, chatting it up like good friends do.
After a few bits of small talk, Twibright and Flustershy ended up sitting at the center of the main room, steaming cups of tea in front of both of them. They both sipped from their cups, and that was when Twibright brought up the temporarily avoided question.
"So, um. Flustershy." muttered Twibright. "You said you wanted to talk about something?"
At this question, the smile on Flustershy's face disappeared instantly, replaced with a furtive, nervous glance around the room. "Oh, um, is Spike, is he here?" she asked.
"No, he's actually busy doing Canterlot business," explained Twibright. "Why?"
"Well, I didn't want him to hear what I had to say, because it's really private."
"Oh?", questioned Twibright.
"It's- It's a big- I don't-" she started. She looked at the face that had been so understanding, kind, and helpful, and she frowned, tears gathering in her eyes.
"Flustershy?"
"OH HOW COULD I HAVE BEEN SO CRUEL TO YOUHOHOOOO!" she wailed.
"Wha- Okay, just calm down, Flust-"
"I was just so desparate, and I didn't know how to fix it!"
"What are you talking abo- wait." Twibright blushed. "Is this about...that night?"
Flustershy sniffed before continuing. "I can't believe I forced you into sex. I couldn't help myself."
"Hey, now, it wasn't-"
"But it felt good to pretend to be someone who could overtake you like that!"
"Flus-"
"But I asked you for a bit more, and then I went too far!"
"Wait, I just need to-"
"And then", she broke down and closed her eyes, "I- I just began to ra-"
"FLUSTERSHY!"
Flustershy gave a start. She had never seen Twibright shout so loud...or look so angry.
"You don't get to say that! I was not raped, okay! I didn't say no, and I stayed!"
"But you could have left! Why didn't you say you wanted to?"
"BECAUSE I ENJOYED IT!"
"..."
"..."
Silence. Sometimes it's nice, and sometimes, like right now, it can choke you. Hearing one of your best friends say that she enjoyed having a carrot in both of your vaginas could do that to you. It was almost a minute until Flustershy was able to speak again.
"You...you liked it?"
Twibright, still looking furious, responded, "Yes. It was one of the best experiences of my life. And calling it forced sex is a terrible thing to say, so don't you ever think you did, okay?"
Flustershy was, well, flustered. "B-but, the carrot?"
Twibright smirked. "May have been improvised, but still effective."
"And the touching of your- um- c-cooch?"
"Was so hot," said Twibright, still smirking.
"And the stuff you said?"
The smirk disappeared. "Oh, that." Twibright giggled nervously and rubbed the back of her head. "I got your message to come over while I was, um, kinda, maybe, sorta, masturbating? And I was kinda frustrated about that, and I was also annoyed by-"
"But once I was done, I just shoved you out! Completely nude!" said Flustershy, still in disbelief that her friend was admitting to all this.
At that statement, Twibright then groaned. "Do you have any idea how embarrassing it is to walk through Ponyville with absolutely nothing covering you in the middle of the night? Not only was I cold, but I had to convince Charity that I did it on a dare when she bumped into me!" she shouted.
"Oh." Flustershy looked slightly abashed. "I'm terribly sorry about that. I looked at the clock and saw that Rainsbow was coming over, and I panicked!" She then smiled awkwardly.
"Dash?" questioned Twibright, a little confused. Then confusion turned into bitterness. "Oh. Right. Dash."
"Wh- what's the problem?" asked Flustershy.
"Oh, nothing. I was just wondering how many other ponies you've invited to have sex with," muttered Twibright.
Flustershy's eyes popped wide open. "Oh, nonono!" she said quickly. "We didn't even do it."
Twibright's ears flicked, and some of her bitterness drained. "You didn't?" She then slipped back into her bitter mask. "But you wanted to."
"No, we didn't." Flustershy looked away. "Or...she didn't."
"Explain."
"Well, the first reason she gave me was that she was straight, and the second-"
"Rainsbow is straight?" asked Twibright loudly, forgetting to be bitter for a second. "Huh, pegged that one wrong."
"Huh?"
"Never mind. The second?"
"The second? Oh, right. Um, the second was that she explained to me that I really should ask permission beforehand."
"Oh." Twibright felt a surge of shame wash over her. "Um, sorry for being angry at you for that."
"Oh, that's okay," said Flustershy cheerfully. "I just had my priorities mixed up that day."
"Cool."
"..."
"..."
"Soooooo..."
Flustershy tilted her head. "So?"
"Are they still?"
"Still?"
"Mixed up, I mean."
"Oh!" exclaimed Flustershy. "Um, no, I guess they're not."
"Cool."
Both girls fell into a silence, but suddenly, Flustershy broke out into a huge grin.
"Boy, does that feel good to get off my chest," she exhaled. "I really thought you would be angry at me!"
Twibright frowned again, but this time, there was a sense of humor in it. "Don't think you're off the hook, young lady. You still made me walk through town completely naked."
Flustershy drooped. "Oh, I almost forgot about that."
"Charity didn't."
"...do- do you think we should go over and apologize to her?"
"I think that sounds like a great idea."
Both friends walked out the door and headed towards Charity's boutique.
"Flustershy?"
"Hmm?"
"Could we...um?"
"Yes, Twibright?"
"...do it again? At my place this time?"
"Oh, um, I don't know..."
"Do you want to?"
"..sure. Sounds fun."
"No need to bring carrots though."
"Oh, you have some?"
"You could say that."
"Oh."
"..."
"Oh!"
"..."
"Ohhhhhhhh."
"There it is."
"I- um, I'm looking forward to it."
"So am I."
"...Twibright?"
"Yes?"
"...did...did you say you accidentaly touched your brother's co-"
"HEY CHARITY WE NEED TO TALK TO YOU HAHA NO NEED TO BE SHY"
"Now can I be in the story?"
No Pinky.
"Can I at least have my own later?"
...yeah. Sure.
"Then can we have a par-"
NO
Well, maybe.
