A Ride for Two

by Phoenix Warlord

Rating: mature
Tags: Random, Mr. Cake, Sex, Anthro, Cake Twins, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance
Length: 4879

Can Carrot Cake resist his pregnant daughter's advancements towards him or will he give into temptation?

A request by Twilight is the BEST

Ever since becoming pregnant, Pumpkin had been teasing her father to get between her legs again. So far he has resisted her movements towards him, but she figures it'll be soon that he will give in and give her what she wants needs, him between her legs.

NOTE: This is an alternate version of events that happened after Daddy's Little Girl.

Also note, Pumpkin is over 18 years old in this story

Co-Authored with Prince-Nightfire93

Published 2016-08-16 19:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-08-16 19:30:01 UTC

A Ride for Two Passengers

It had been several months since Pumpkin Cake had lured her dad, Carrot, to her bedroom to have sex with her where he deflowered her and came inside, causing her to become pregnant with a foal. When she told her father, he was nervous, yet somewhat excited again to be a dad again, but he’d be the father of his own daughter’s foal. To cover up the affair between them, Pumpkin told her mom she had a one night stand with an ex-coltfriend of hers and they “accidentally” forgot to use protection. Since she told her mother about becoming pregnant, things between had calmed down between her father and her, for the most part. There were a few times where she’d tease him from time to time, but Carrot would surprisingly resist her motions towards him. Pumpkin only knew it’d only be a matter of time to have her father between her legs again, despite her enlarged belly.

And despite each day they spent around each other, Carrot had done his best to resist his daughter's advancements. Loads of those times while they were at work, little tricks like frosting on her body and the suggestive banana or two.

“She's becoming quite the tease... don't know how long I can keep this up.” Carrot says to himself as he walks into Sugar Cube Corner with some groceries to put away since one day a week they would be closed for business in order to either rest or work on a special order that had been placed in advance. As he walks in, he smells something cooking in the oven from the kitchen. “Hmmm, I don’t recall us having any special orders that need to be made. I’ll have to check it out,” he says to himself as he turns and locks the door before taking the groceries with him and places them on the counter, looking up shortly afterwards to see his pregnant daughter, licking a spoon that had cookie dough on it from a bowl. "Pumpkin? What are you doing? Did someone want us to make something for them?" He asks as he steps into the room, enjoying the smell of the cookie dough that she was licking.

“Oh, hi daddy! No, it’s not that. I just felt like making some cookies since I had a craving for some and had to have a little cookie dough left over for myself and our little guest also to enjoy,” she giggles softly with a grin, rubbing her enlarged belly gently.

He smiles a little and then closes the door to the kitchen behind him and walks up to the counter. "So Pumpkin... how long have you been down here?”

“Hmm, a little bit now. I was napping for a while before I was woken up by some pony inside…”

"So our foal’s growing well, huh?" He asks as he walks up to her and places a hand against her belly.

“Mmhmm. They’re coming along quite well, no complications.”

"Do you know if you're carrying more than one?" He asks and then looks into her eyes.

“No daddy. Just one in there,” she giggles and rubs her belly gently, placing her hand on top of her father’s.

"That's good," He replies and then leans down and kisses her belly softly. "You know Pumpkin, I'm sorry that I haven't been paying attention to you much lately.”

“Hmmm, it’s okay, dad. I know you have a lot on your mind considering you’re the father of our soon to be foal. I figured I’d ‘drop back’ a bit, mostly, and let you relax and be as stress free as possible,” Pumpkin replies to him, kissing his cheek softly.

"Thank you Pumpkin. But you know maybe I could help you out with the cookies. You know, as a father daughter bonding experience.”

“Okay. There can never be too many cookies, I suppose, right?”

"Never can be," He replies with a smile and then kisses her forehead softly, just under her horn.

Pumpkin giggles softly and smells the cookies that were already in the oven. “Let me go get the cookies that are in the oven, then we can work on the next batch, okay daddy?”

"Ok sweetie," He replies with a smile, loving the time he was spending with his daughter, making cookies like they used to when she was growing up.

She grins and goes to get some oven mitts on and pulls down the oven door, smelling the warm, delicious cookies. She sniffs them and looks at how golden brown they were. “Ah, perfect!” she says, bending over and carefully putting her protected hands into the oven to get the cookies, wiggling her flank teasingly for her dad.

He looks over at her and watches her flank with a small smile and then licks his lips nervously. ’She's trying to tease me…’

’I’m wondering if he’ll catch on that I still want him inside me, despite my… size at the moment…’ she wonders to herself as she slowly pulls the cookies out of the oven and carefully places them on the counter behind her. “Smell good, don’t they daddy?”

"Yes they do sweetie. You're quite the little baker," He replies and then walks over to the oven with his batch of cookies that were on the tray and then slides it into it and closes the door. "I know what you're doing sweetie.”

“What might that be?” she asks, playing dumb.

"You want your old man back inside you," He says softly as he stands in front of her, a smile on his lips then his tongue slides out and moistens them.

“Don’t be silly daddy! Me, your naughty little girl, with a cookie, I mean, bun in the oven?” she giggles softly, laughing at her own pun.

He smile and then giggles with her about her puns. "You know Pumpkin that was a really good pun.”

“I guess I’m so… punny…” she blushes softly before admitting her confession. “But, I have to admit daddy. I… I do want you inside of me again; to give our little passenger and me a thrill ride.” Pumpkin leans into him and rubs her hand against her dad’s crotch. “Have you wanted to be inside your naughty, little girl?”

He moans softly as he looks down at her hand that was teasing his crotch and then slides his finger down her cheek, between her breasts and then over toward her right nipple. "Yes I have... I missed being inside you…"

Pumpkin giggles seductively, giving him bedroom eyes. “Is there any cookie dough left, daddy? Any chocolate chips also?”

"Yes there is. We haven't used it all yet," He says as he looks over at the counter with all of the ingredients on it. "Why do you ask Pumpkin?”

“I’m thinking we can have some… fun with it. You like having fun with your little girl, don’t you?”

"Yes I do. So do you want to take the lead on this?" He asks and then leans down and kisses her lips softly.

Pumpkin softly kisses his lips before slowly pulling away. “Sure. Follow my lead…” The pregnant mare grins and takes the end of boxers she “borrowed” from her brother and bends over as she slowly pulls them down her legs, her pregnant belly showing through the gap between them. She then steps out of the boxers and keeps bent over to tease her dad more. “Hmmm, you like the view from behind, daddy?”

"Yes I do Pumpkin... I really do love it.”

“I bet you stroke your big, mature cock at night, thinking about your daughter’s tight young pussy, don’t you?” she teases, spreading her cheeks, showing her love lips and tail hole to him.

He looks down at her pussy and licks his lips slowly. "Yes I do... and then your mom rides my cock at night I can't help but think of you…"

“Hmmm, naughty daddy… Thinking of your little girl’s pussy instead of your wife’s. The thought of you thinking of me while letting mommy ride you turns me on so much…”

He smiles and then licks his lips before dropping his pants and leaves his boxers on. "Care to get the party started Pumpkin?”

Pumpkin comes up from her bending over and nods, slowly walking towards the counter, swiveling her hips as she does so showing off her curvy flank. She then sits on the counter and spreads her legs, revealing her pussy to her father, showing how pink and wet it was. With the mixing bowl nearby, still having some leftover dough, she takes some of it into the wooden spoon and spreads it on her pussy. Carrot smiles and then walks up to her and then kneels between her spread legs and then leans in and gives her pussy a gently lick with his tongue, tasting both her pussy and the cookie dough. "Wow Pumpkin... that tastes really good.”

“Hmm, thank you daddy… I’m glad you enjoy it…” she moans, licking her lips as her father licks her pussy.

Carrot moans softly and then holds open her legs with his hands as he pushes his tongue into her wet hole, and wraps his lips around hers and pulls away some of the cookie dough. Pumpkin coos softly as her father eats the cookie dough from her pussy, never having experimented with food play before. He pulls his tongue from her pussy and licks up cookie dough around or on her pussy, pushing his tongue back into her slowly. 'This is a great idea sweetie, trying something that I haven't done yet.’

“Hmmm, yeah daddy! Eat my pussy out good!” she groans, running her fingers through his hair, loving how flowing his mane felt with her gentle touch.

As he eats her pussy out, having cleaned it of the delicious cookie dough, he reaches down to his boxers and slips a hand between the band and his body and slides his hand against his hard shaft and begins to slowly stroke it.

Pumpkin takes a hand and rubs her covered breasts, moaning for her dad as she feels a soft kick from inside her belly. ’Looks like some pony is enjoying this as much as we are…’ she giggles softly as she continues to moan.

As he continues eating out his daughter's pussy and playing with his own cock, he opens his eyes and looks up at her, seeing her eyes closed in content and a hand groping her breast. "Sexy little minx," He moans as he pulls away a little and then quickly pulls off his boxers and tosses them aside and then dives back to eating her out.

“Oh… Oh fuck daddy! Oh sweet Celestia yes! Make me moan like your little whore!” Pumpkin moans as she thrusts her hips forward softly into his mouth.

"Language dear... don't want our little one hearing such words do you?" He asks teasingly before pushing his tongue back into her pussy and slides it against her clit as his hand rubs his head, sending shivers down his spine.

“S-Sorry daddy! I-It’s just… your tongue feels so… incredible! I… I can’t help it…”

"Maybe you'd want something a little thicker..." He moans as he pulls away from her pussy and stands back up, his cock standing erect and dripping pre from his head. "And better for you.”

Pumpkin pants softly, looking at his long and erect cock, making her pussy even wetter and her nipples harder. “Hmm, yes daddy. I could… Can I suck it to taste you?”

"Close your eyes first Pumpkin, I want to surprise you.”

“Okay daddy,” she replies, closing her eyes for him.

He smiles and then reaches over for a small scoop of cookie dough and slowly smears the treat all along the shaft and head of his cock. "Hope you like what I did," He says before adding some chocolate chips to the dough. "Open your eyes.”

She opens her eyes and grins slyly. “You know how to treat your princess daddy…”

"Did you think I wouldn’t?"

“Why wouldn’t you?” Pumpkin giggles and changes position to lay on her side as she takes her father’s cock head into her mouth, sucking on it to taste his flavor mixed with the cookie dough and chocolate chips.

Carrot moans softly and then slides his fingers through his daughter's mane while his free hand slides down from her back to her belly and rubs it softly. The mare coos softly as she enjoys her father’s flavor in her mouth, swirling her tongue along his member, loving how he was rubbing her enlarged belly gently to his future foal. He gently thrusts forward into her mouth, shivering with the skill his daughter had at pleasuring an old stallion like himself. "Good girl... just like that.”

Pumpkin softly bobs her head on his member, taking a free hand to fondle his hanging sack with her gentle touch, while her tongue licks along his head, finishing off the cookie dough and chocolate chips off of his cock, swallowing it to nourish the developing foal inside her.

Her father groans happily and then slides his hand through her mane to the back of her head and pushes against it so that she could take more of his cock into her mouth. "Ju-Just like that... more sweetie.”

The mare moans as she swirls her tongue along his length, while giving his orbs a gentle squeeze, knowing what makes an older stallion like him, tick.

He moans and groans deeply as she gives his balls a gentle squeeze. "Y-You know ex-exactly what to do, don’t you?" He asks softly with a smile, his question more rhetorical than anything.

“Mmhmm,” she replies, popping his cock from her mouth, kissing his cockhead as she speaks in a low, sensual voice. “You know how I love to tease and turn you on, daddy. Us younger mares know how you older stallions tick and know tricks to extract loads of your cum from you…”

"I-Is that so? Well care to tell your old stallion how you know this?" He asks softly and then licks his lips, still tasting her sweet juices and the cookie dough on them.

“Hmmm, we never reveal secrets like that, daddy. You know that, don’t you?” she grins, gently squeezing his sack with a free hand, giving him a small amount of pleasurable pain.

"Of course..." He moans and bites down gently on his bottom lip, and breathes deeply, the pleasurable pain making more pre escape his head. "Oh sweet Celestia…"

She leans in, making sure not to waste the valuable pre-cum, licking her lips shortly afterwards. “Now, what position do you want to take your little girl, daddy?”

"Bend over the counter... and I'll make sure you moan for me.”

“Anything for you…” she grins and turns to get off of the counter to turn around and show off her ass to her dad, raising her tail to the side.

"Good girl." He replies softly and then slides his hand over her round ass.

“You like feeling my cute ass, daddy?” she asks, raising her shirt to let her puffy breasts rest on the cool countertop.

"You bet that sweet ass I do," He replies lustfully as he spreads her cheeks and then lines up his cock with her pussy lips.

“Naughty daddy…”

"Am I?”

Pumpkin nods with a sly grin. “Now come and give our passenger and me a good ride on your cock…”

"Trust me I will," He moans and then thrusts forward into her tight pussy, groaning from how wet she was. The young, pregnant mare moans softly and licks her lips, loving at how big her father was again, inside her wet and warm pussy.

"You're just as tight as I re-remember…"

“Hmm, and you’re just as big as I remember, daddy… Oh Celestia…”

He moans happily and hilts inside her gently, not wanting to hurt their foal growing inside her. Pumpkin lets out a soft groan, bouncing softly as she feels his cock push against her walls, making the foal gently bounce within her womb.

"Feel that sweetie?”

“Y-Yeah daddy! I… feel every inch of you… inside me!”

He moans happily and then slowly pulls free of her pussy and then slides back in gently. "Good... Because we've go-got all day.”

“D-Don’t wanna burn the… cookies in the oven daddy…” she reminds him.

"No we don't..." He moans and then grabs her hips and slowly moves them in a small circle up and down. Pumpkin lets out a soft groan as she moves her hips with her father’s movements, loving how his cock feels inside of her pussy. She feels a gentle kick inside of her belly, getting a feeling that the foal was enjoying the ride. He smiles happily and then pulls out so that only his head was inside her and then slowly sinks back into her tight pussy with a low groan.

“D-Do I feel good around your… older, mature cock daddy?” Pumpkin asks, turning her head slightly.

"Better th-than ever before sweetie…"

“You like claiming m-my young, tight pussy as your own?”

"Yes I d-do... More than y-you will know…"

Pumpkin shutters softly as her belly bounces from him gently pushing his cock into her. “Y-You’re so naughty daddy…”

"Comes with age... Trust me," He moans happily as he thrusts forward into her and feels his medial ring push against her lips.

She bites her lower lip, feeling his wider ring press against her lips. “Hold… onto my… my tits daddy! Push your… ring into me!”

He smiles and then reaches around and grabs her breasts and pushes hard, his medial ring pushing deeply into her tight pussy. "Damn Pumpkin... you're so tight!”

The mare bites her lower lip, a long moan escaping her lips as her belly bounces with the sharp thrust into her, feeling her father’s medial ring enter her pussy. “Oh… f-fuck! Oh fuck yes!

"Cum for me... you dirty li-little slut…"

Pumpkin moans for her father, biting her lower lip as her pussy wraps around his cock, enhancing her pleasure before she squirts her juices around his member, feeling some drip down her legs, sending shivers throughout her body.

He moans deeply and then pinches her nipples hard with his fingers before he groans loudly and then shoots his cum deeply into her pussy.

“Hmmm, fuck daddy! Oh fuck! Shoot that load into me!”

Carrot leans over her back and breathes deeply into her ear before thrusting a little harder into her. "Lo-Love that?”

“I… I loved that daddy… I think our passenger loved it too…” Pumpkin giggles, turning her head to kiss his lips softly, feeling his thrusts move her belly slightly on the counter.

"Did he?" He asks softly and moans happily into the kiss before rubbing her belly slowly.

“‘They’ daddy. We’ve yet to see if it’s a colt or a filly, remember?”

"Ri-Right sweetie..." He moans softly and then slowly pulls out of her pussy, groaning from being so sensitive after cumming inside her pussy.

Pumpkin moans softly and feels some of his cum leak from her pussy and onto the floor underneath her. She slowly stands up and wraps her arms around her father’s neck. “Hmmm, I love you daddy…”

"I love you too Pumpkin," He replies softly and then hugs her back and kisses her lips softly.

Pumpkin coos into the kiss, still feeling her pussy itching for his cock, wanting to be satisfied.

He smiles and then moans into the kiss before breaking it and looks down into her eyes. "Want to move on to another room?”

“How about your bedroom, daddy. I want to ride you now…”

"Sounds good..." He says and then takes her hand and leads her out of the kitchen, up the stairs and into his bedroom. "Ready for another go sweetie?”

“I’m always ready for you daddy…” she grins softly, kissing his cheek. “Want to stroke your older cock for me to tease me and get me wet?”

"I have a good idea," He says as he lies on his bed and waves her close to the bed and strokes his cock slowly. "Come and help daddy stroke his cock.”

“Of course…” she coos and crawls onto the bed near him as she takes one of her hands and gently strokes it along with him.

"Feel good? My hard and ho-hot cock in your hand?" He asks softly and then smiles at her.

“It does daddy. It feels like we’re doing a porn film together,” she giggles softly,

"I know sweetie. Feels nice doesn't it?" He asks with a smile before using his free hand to fondle his own balls.

“It does daddy,” Pumpkin nods, kissing his cock head softly.

He moans softly and then humps gently up into her mouth, feeling her warm lips against his head.

‘Hmmm, you know you love my lips over your cock head daddy…’ she coos softly to herself and swirls her tongue around his cock, tasting some pre-cum before running it along her cheek, making an audible ‘pop’ as it leaves her mouth.

"D-Damn Pumpkin... you're su-such a fucking tease..." He moans deeply and bites his bottom lip as he lets his hand leave his cock so she can take over.

“I know I can be daddy… It’s a trait us younger mares have with older stallions like you…” she says seductively as she kneels in front of him, lining his cock with her cum filled and wet pussy, rubbing his head against her lips.

"Do it... impale you-yourself on my cock…"

“What are the magic words daddy?” she asks, teasing him more.

"Please sweetie... impale yourself on my cock like a good girl.”

“Since you asked so nicely…” Pumpkin grins and slowly inserts herself onto his cock at an agonizingly slow pace, wanting to make it last as long as she could before she could get to his medial ring. He moans happily and gives a little thrust up into her pussy, shivering as her pussy grips his cock and almost milks him for just his pre cum alone. “Fuck..."

She grins and slowly grinds her hips against him, moving his cock inside of her. “You like that, don’t you daddy?”

"Yes sweetie... I lo-love it so much," He replies softly and then gives another gentle thrust up into her pussy, pushing the middle of his medial ring finally into her pussy.

She coos softly as she feels his medial ring enter her pussy, making her belly bounce with the thrust. “A horny, pregnant, younger mare that’s your daughter, riding your older stallion cock? Does that turn you on so much?”

"Y-Yes it does sweetie... I wi-wish I could make you pregnant again…"

“Mmm, make me your pregnant toy, daddy? How naughty of you…” Pumpkin giggles softly as she moves her hips every way to make Carrot groan with pleasure. He moans deeply as she moves, moving his cock around inside her pussy, his cock leaking his pre deep inside her tight pussy. "Oh fuck... you're so fucking tight!”

“I’m… always tight for you daddy. You and… you alone! Oh Celestia, yes!”He groans happily and pulls her down and kisses her lips happily, slipping his tongue into her mouth and wraps his around hers. Pumpkin groans into the kiss and swirls her tongue with his, letting him dominate tongue, letting it explore her mouth, making her pussy leak more of her juices.

’She's so cute like this... pregnant with my foal and riding my cock like a good slut,’ He thinks as he thrusts up into her pussy and then slips his tongue past his teeth, then against her lips.

’He’s so dominant of me, even though I’m on top of him. I love letting him fuck me. I wouldn’t mind being a fuck toy for him after I give birth...’ she thinks to herself as she shivers with pleasure and lets him dominate her mouth with his tongue.

He moans happily and then pulls his tongue from her mouth and then tilts her head more so that he could take her horn into his mouth and slide his tongue along the ridges of it.

“F-Fuck daddy! I-I’m sensitive there! Oh Celestia!” she groans as her pussy wraps tightly around his cock, leaking more of her juices. He giggles around her horn and then flicks his tongue against the tip of her horn and then slides his hand through her mane as he fucks her pussy slowly. Pumpkin groans at her father’s touch and suddenly cums around his cock, spraying her juices around his cock, shivering softly as to not let her horn poke at his mouth.

He moans happily as he feels her pussy quiver around his cock and then clench down tightly before he thrusts up and hilts inside her, watching her belly move with the thrust and then bites his lip. He pulls away from her horn and exclaims, "I'm go-gonna... gonna cum!”

“C-Cum on my belly daddy! On my belly!”

"Mo-Move sweetie... You have to move!" He moans deeply and pulls back as far as he can, only up to his medial ring, needing her to move the rest of the way.

Pumpkin nods and pulls herself off as quickly as she can, landing on her back before rubbing her pussy with her hand, reaching a soft, spraying orgasm as she sprays her juices onto the bed.

Quickly, Carrot Cake gets onto his knees and aims his cock at her pregnant belly as he strokes it as fast as he can, his hand moving almost like a blur as he closes his eyes and feels himself reach his peak, shooting his cum all over her belly, his cum sinking into her fur.

“Oh fuck yes daddy! Cover my belly with your foal batter!” Pumpkin cries out, as she feels her father’s cum coat her belly.

As he strokes himself off, he sees some of his cum settle in her belly button and more of his cum go flying randomly, some landing on the bed, some landing on her breasts. She groans softly as she feels some of her breasts covered with his cum, making her coo softly with a grin on her face. After a little while of stroking himself off long past his limit, he collapses on the bed beside his daughter, his cock pressed against the smooth sheets of the bed.

“Oh daddy… you covered our little one with so much cum…” Pumpkin giggles softly, rubbing some of his cum in her hand, licking her fingers to clean them.

"Do-Don't lie and say you do-don't like it," He replies and turns his head to look at her with a smile.

“I loved every moment daddy!” she replies as she feels him rest next to her, hugging her side.

"I'm glad... and pretty tired..." He says with a smile and then a little yawn.

“I… I am too… but what… about those cookies? They’ll burn…”

"I took out the last batch. Remember?”

“N-No, that was my batch, silly daddy.”

"I guess I sh-should take them out... Wait here for me?”

“Of course daddy,” she replies, grinning at him and gently kisses his lips.

He smiles and then rolls out of the bed and quickly runs down stairs to take his batch out of the over and sets them down on the counter. "When we wake up from a nap they should be nice and cool.”

Pumpkin coos softly and patiently waits for her dad to return in bed while his cum slowly dries into her fur.

"Hey sweetie," He says after walking back in the door of his bedroom. "Miss me?”

"Of course I did daddy. Why wouldn't I?" She replied, eyeing his sexy body

"Just thought I'd ask," He says as he crawls back into bed and lies besides her, her belly between them as he looks into her eyes.

Pumpkin looks back at him and her eyes meet his, feeling their hearts sync simultaneously.

"I can't wait till we can hold our foal.”

"I can't either daddy. Would I be lying that I'm nervous but excited to be a mother already?”

"I don't think so. Your mother was the same with you two," Carrot says and then kisses her cheek softly.

"She was daddy?”

"Yeah, she was becoming a mother for the first time in her life. I'll let you in on a secret, I was nervous as well. I didn't know how I would be as a father.”

"Well, you did great daddy, and you'll be a father again with your own daughter..." She coos and kisses his lips softly.

He moans back and kisses her lips gently in return. "Thank you Pumpkin.”

"You're welcome daddy. I love you with all my heart.”

"Just like I love you with all of mine," He says and hugs her close with one arm and his other hand rubs her belly gently.

Pumpkin coos softly as she feels her dad's soft touch lull her into a soft sleep, feeling the foal kick as she closes her eyes.

He smiles and then slowly closes his eyes, happy to have spent another day with his daughter and their soon to be foal.