WARNING: This chapter does not contain sex, but instead deep conversation between Starlight and Pinkie. Topics include BDSM, roleplay, polyamory, watersports/omorashi, autoandrophilia and infantilism. I promise that there will be more fetish-ness next chapter, I just wanted to add a story.

Starlight woke up at three in the morning to a nagging full bladder. She groaned in annoyance before treading to the bathroom to relieve herself. However, somepony else appeared to be up at this hour. There was Pinkie, rubbing her red marks from earlier with one hoof, and jerking off with the other. It wasn't long before she orgasmed and collapsed onto the sink.

"Um...Pinkie, can I pee quickly?" Starlight asked nervously.

"Go ahead," Pinkie grumbled.

After Starlight was done, Pinkie was waiting for her at the door. "You doing OK?" she asked. For once in her life she sounded serious.

"Uh...yeah, I'm fine," Starlight reassured. "Really, this whole thing doesn't bother me anymore."

Pinkie raised an eyebrow.

"Well, OK, there is one question I had..."

"Wanna come to my room and talk about it?"

Pinkie's room was an absolute mess. It looked like a tornado had come through the room. But Starlight did her best to ignore it as she sat on the bed with Pinkie.

Starlight began, "Well, I'm just confused as to why I like this so much. I mean, I've never indulged in a fetish in my life. I always thought they were weird...and went against my equal philosophy. And I also had no idea I liked mares. I still love Sunburst with all my heart, but now I have you three, and I'm just...confused."

Pinkie laughed. "We're not dating, silly! Twilight and Dashie are madly in love, but I'm still just their friend. It's just casual friend sex."

"That's a thing?"

"Well, it's not a normal thing, but I have to have sex with somepony. I don't know if you know this, but...I'm in a long distance relationship with Cheese Sandwich."

"Cheese Sandwich? The super-duper traveling party pony?"

"Yup! That's him! Of course I can't bang him if he's traveling, so he told me that since I had such good friends, I should have them satisfy my needs. He's perfectly fine with it. An open-minded stallion, Cheese is."

"That may work out for you, but I don't know what Sunburst would think. He does appear to have his own standards."

Pinkie nodded. "Well, I'm sure you can figure out what to do in your own time. And about your new-found fetishes, well, how do I put this...you probably want somepony in your life to look after you."

"How did you know - "

"I'm Pinkie Pie, silly! And I totally get it. My parents weren't the most supportive ponies either. They were so different from me. After I got my cutie mark, they had me move to the Cakes, thinking they would be more of a help."

"I had no idea," Starlight felt a twinge of sympathy toward the pink pony. "Of course, my parents just wanted me to be the best at magic, and didn't give two craps if I was upset about my lack of friendships. I guess that's why I love you mares so much."

"E-XACTLY! You know why Dashie is such a dom?"

Starlight shook her head.

"It's cause she has a protective side. Ponies like me, and Twilight, and you, she worries day and night about our safety. She feels if she's the one in control, she is more capable of ensuring our happiness. She's the Element of Loyalty, after all. I'm sure you've noticed that."

"A bit," Starlight admitted.

"In fact, she kind of treats my like her daughter. But she likes being a dad, it turns her on. And she likes treating me like I'm a rebellious baby filly." Pinkie giggled.

Starlight tried to process all this. It was pretty strange to think that Dash acting so much like a stallion was just because it turned her on so much. Her tomcoltish ways just seemed too...natural.

Starlight and Pinkie exchanged an "it-will-be-all-right" hug before Starlight returned to her room.

Author's Note

There's that. As always, let me know what I can do better in future chapters! Things will start falling into place soon, so be on the lookout for that. See ya!