Rewarded Nightmare

by heatedflower

Rating: mature
Tags: Romance, Equestria Girls, Sex, Sunset Shimmer, Human, Twilight Sparkle
Length: 2228

Twilight was invited to Sunset Shimmers house for a slumber party with the rest of their friends after the friendship games. Twilight has a nightmare and Sunset is there to... 'Comfort' her.

After the friendship games, Sunset invited all of her friends over to her house for a Slumber Party, including her new friend Twilight. A fun night they had had, yes, until Twilight went to sleep and awoke with a nightmare...

Sunset to the... Rescue?

Published 2016-09-10 04:50:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-09-10 04:50:01 UTC

The Reward

She liked the power, the invincibility, the... Strength. How could Twilight not have seen this before? The inevitability of being able to tear this pitiful world apart and understand all withstanding magic before her. It felt incredible. Inspiring, almost. Brewing portals and rips to Equestria sent a rush of adrenaline through her body. Twilight- no... Midnight Sparkle was now in charge.

Seeing all the helpless little people trying to find a place to hide, to escape this madness. Idiots. There is no place to run to. Not while Midnight Sparkle is trying to deform this non-magical universe, despite the past magical encounters. Poor, poor tiny foul ants. Nothing they can do will stop Midnight Sparkle and her invincible power. The power... The large amount of piercing strength and power...

Twilight gasped as her eyes shot open, tears already rolling down her cheeks. An unsatisfying nightmare. Twilight sat up, trying her hardest to stop her hyperventilating, which she let out a wracking sob as a result. Then more and more sobs. Twilight pulled her knees up to her chest and cried into them, not willing to make any noise. Twilight was invited over to Sunset Shimmers house for a slumber party with the rest of the girls, to show Twilight what it's like to have real friends. And real friends certainly do not wake each other up by crying at twelve in the morning.

Twilight looked around the room, at Pinkie, Rarity and Fluttershy sleeping on the left side of the bed she was in, Applejack and Rainbow on the right side, and finally Sunset sleeping peacefully next to her in the bed. But just looking at Sunset made another loud sob escape Twilights mouth, resulting her to break out to tears again.

Sunset helped her, did all she could for Twilight, and now Twilight liked the power. No- she loved it, and she couldn't help it! In all honesty it felt the best, and Twilight wanted it all... But she didn't want to disappoint her dear friends... Especially Sunset. Twilight just cuddled up into a ball and cried for about twenty minutes, before she heard a soft whisper beside her.

"T-Twilight?"

It was Sunset Shimmer, who was sitting up and facing Twilights helpless self. Then Sunset Shimmer seemed to realise why Twilight was crying because she did all she could to comfort her.

"Twilight... It was a nightmare wasn't it..." Sunset looked just as sad as Twilight by this point. All Twilight could do was nod, and sob a bit more.

"It's okay, it's okay... Calm down... I'm here now it's alright..." Sunset scooted closer to Twilight and tugged the blanket back over her shivering body. Twilight shivered at the sudden warmness. Twilight looked up at Sunset and felt a pang of guilt cross her body. Sunset is helping her now... Just like she did at the Friendship Games...

More sobs. Twilight tried to hold them in but she just couldn't. Sunset sighed. "Twilight... Nothing can hurt you anymore. You can't hurt anything else anymore."

"But I can! I could have destroyed this whole w-w-world!"

"But you didn't! And that's the best thing about you. You chose to do the right thing and stop..." Sunset cupped Twilights cheek in her hand, wiping a tear away with her thumb. Twilight looked into Sunsets eyes. They were sparkling with truth, and hope, and something else...

Sunset pulled Twilight into a hug and the two sat there for a while. Twilight tried not to, but she ended up crying into Sunsets shoulder. All Sunset could do was smile and hold Twilight closer.

"You did the right thing Twilight..." Sunset whispered under her breath. Twilight looked back up at Sunset, rubbing her eyes before speaking. "R-really?" Sunset nodded, and when she looked down to Twilight, Sunset just couldn't help but to think about how cute Twilight looked. How adorable she was wearing those pyjamas, cuddled up with Sunset Shimmer... Sunset almost felt like kissing her...

Sunset raised her hand to Twilights chin, titling her head upwards a tiny bit, and pressed her lips to Twilights. Twilight gave a small whimper as she felt Sunsets lips against her own. Yes, she was shocked at first, but she seemed to melt into the kiss, closing her eyes. Twilight wrapped her arms around Sunsets neck and pulled herself closer, deepening the kiss. Sunset had waited so long for this moment... Which she actually didn't know she wanted at first, but now she had it, she never wanted it to go.

The two girls parted, still holding onto each other, a line of saliva hanging between their mouths. They blushed, and Sunset smiled. Twilight was lost in thought... Sunset kissed her! How incredible was that! Definitely way more better than being able to hold the power of magic...

A sudden burst of confidence overcame Twilight and she blurted out her thoughts then and there; "I should have nightmares more often..." Twilight mentally slapped herself for saying that... Idiot!

Sunset giggled. "You don't have to have another nightmare if you want me to kiss you..." She spoke, therefore leading to another kiss, better than the last. This kiss had more passion and recognition added to it, making it obviously one of the best.

Twilights lips slowly parted as the kiss went on, and Sunset took advantage of that, slipping her tongue inside Twilights mouth and exploring all it could touch. Twilight moaned into this new motion, making Sunset hungry for more. Sunsets hands subconsciously made their way to Twilights breasts, feeling around them as the kiss deepened slowly, earning another soft moan from Twilight. Sunset had just had enough of patience and slipped her hand up Twilights pyjama shirt and grabbing hold of one of Twilights breasts, discovering no frustrating bra in the way.

Twilight began to pull Sunsets shirt off, having to part the kiss just slightly to lift it over Sunsets head. Sunset stopped touching Twilight and removed her pants as well, now only exposed to her underwear (without the bra, of course). But before Twilight could go to take Sunsets underwear off, Sunset returned to squeezing Twilights breast once again, harder than before. Sunset returned to kissing Twilight, and pressed her knee up against Twilights womanhood through the fabric of her pants.

Twilight tried her best not to but parted from the kiss and let out a moan, making Sunset put her spare hand to Twilights mouth to not wake the others. After ten seconds or so, Sunset took her hand away from Twilights mouth and slowly unbuttoned her pyjama shirt, whilst her other hand was still squeezing Twilights breast. Now with Twilights shirt gone, Sunset bent down and began sucking on Twilights free breast, causing her to moan again.

Sunset smiled as she continued to suck and play with Twilights breasts. Sunset then stopped sucking on Twilights breast and made small nibbles into Twilights collarbone, slowly beginning to trail up to Twilights jaw line. Twilight was panting like a dog at this stage, just before Sunset pulled her into another heated kiss. As the two kissed, Sunset removed her hand from Twilights breast and moved it town to the rim of her pants, slipping them down slowly. Twilight shuddered at the coolness of the touch, but got used to it pretty quickly. Sunset then began to rub Twilights womanhood through the wet cloth that was separating Sunset and it. Twilight moaned loudly into Sunsets mouth, making her purr in excitement.

Sunset had enough waiting and tugged Twilights underwear off and smirked into the kiss. Sunset then began to rub Twilights lower lips, making her part the kiss with a loud moan again, once more resulting in Sunset covering her mouth. Sunset slowly trailed her head down to Twilights woman hood and thought a little teasing would come to reason. Sunset slowly kissed Twilights thighs and ever so slowly made her way to the very middle. Sunset slowly licked at Twilights heated flower, making Twilight squirm with excitement. Sunset moved her head away from Twilights womanhood and slowly parted the lips with her hands, viewing the wetness.

Without hesitation, Sunset slipped her middle finger into Twilights entrance and quickly raised her spare hand to Twilights mouth to lower the loudness of Twilights muffled moan. Sunset slowly pulled her finger out and just as fast pushed it back in, earning another moan. Sunset repeated her finger action once more, and suddenly felt Twilights wet walls tighten against her finger. Sunset began pumping her finger in and out at just a slow pace, to make sure it didn't hurt Twilight. Twilights mouth was still covered by Sunsets hand but she let out a moan loud enough for everyone in the room to hear, but luckily none awoke. Sunset continued on extremely slowly, draining the patience right out of Twilight.

"S-Sunset... mmmm... Fa-fas...ter!" Twilight spoke, which only was heard as a muffled amount of speech to Sunset, but Sunset understood well enough. Sunset pumped a bit faster, speeding up as she got more and more aroused herself. Twilight began bucking her hips in time with Sunset and tried not to moan too loudly. Sunset added another finger, pumping harder and faster. Twilight had never felt like this before in her life... She'd never even had sex with a female before. Sunset added yet another finger, thrusting her hand harder and harder, even making herself moan a bit. Twilight was so close... Just a bit more and...

Suddenly Sunset stopped. She pulled her fingers back out and smirked when she saw Twilights disappointed look. Twilight whimpered, as if asking why. "Don't be so sad Twilight... That was just the warm up." Sunset seduced. Sunset didn't even know where all this confidence had come from, but it was sure to have blossomed from somewhere.

Twilight was oddly confused, but that confusion disappeared as soon as she felt something wet sucking at her heated flower. Sunset licked at Twilights entrance before pushing her tongue all the way in, once again hearing a muffled moan from Twilight. Sunset flicked her tongue around, tasting the damp wetness inside of Twilight. Sunset began to move her tongue in and out like she did with her fingers, once again making Twilight moan and Buck her hips again.

Sunset began to touch herself with her now free hand and slipped a finger in herself as she listened to Twilights shuddering moans. Sunset moaned softly, trying not to stop licking at Twilight. But Sunset had a great idea pop into her mind. Sunset then once again stopped, and Twilight was questioning again as well. This was Sunsets favourite idea yet. "Now I'm going to try something that... Not many people experience in their day to day lives..." Sunset tried not to blurt out what she was planning... Yet.

Sunset pulled her underwear down past her legs and smirked as she crawled above Twilight. Before Twilight could ask anything at all, Sunset pressed her pussy hard against Twilights, making Twilight almost scream with pleasure, if it weren't for Sunsets hand stopping her from doing so. Sunset herself had to hold in a moan too, as she felt just as aroused as Twilight at this point. Sunset began to move back and forth, rubbing her and Twilights heated flowers against each other's. Twilight was so close again, and she was certain Sunset would stop again and try something else.

But Sunset never stopped, in fact she went faster and faster, letting out moans of her own. "Sun-Sunset... Don't... Oooaah... S-stop this... Time!" Twilight managed to say through forced moans as Sunset took her hand away from her mouth. Sunset softly chuckled, as she slowed down just a tad. "Oooh, I'm not going to... Aah... Stop..." And so Sunset went faster, and faster, and to add more amazement, she began to play with Twilights breasts. "Oh, oh... Ah-mmmmm! Ooh Sunset, I- Aaah! So... Clo-ose- Oh!" Twilight was biting her lip and clenching her teeth shut just trying not to moan, Sunset doing the same. But Sunset was getting tired, and she began to just thrust their pussies together instead of rubbing, and this drove Twilight insane. Twilight let out a long moan, her arms wrapping around Sunset and making scratch marks on her back. Twilight subconsciously wrapped her legs around Sunsets waist giving a better angle for Sunsets thrusting.
Sunset began moaning I bit louder too, but not too loud to wake the others. Sunsets moans and groans started to come in time with her thrusting, making her edge closer and closer to her climax. Then Sunset had this feeling she just couldn't ignore. Release, was all her mind told her. "Oooohh, Twilight! I-I'm gonna... Mmmm... Cu-um- oooohhh!" Sunset began squeezing Twilights breasts even harder. "I-I- Aaaah... Gonna- Aaaaaaaahhhh!" Twilight let out a loud moan as she came, and just a few seconds after Sunset came too, with one last thrust she moaned just as loud as Twilight.

And lucky for them, all of their friends are very heavy sleepers...

Author's Note

Thank you so much for reading this! It's my first EG fanfic so I hope you enjoyed! Don't judge, it sucks I know, and I should get an editor, I know, but right now I'm just beginning so I don't really care. I already know what I need to improve on. :moustache: