Fight or Flee? (Fluttershy's Final Dilemma)

**Fight or Flee? (Fluttershy’s Final Dilemma)

By: Clue Tzes

This fan-fiction is filled with sex, rape, gore, sadness and very disturbing parts. Be prepared for the worst. It will wrench your heart and mind as you read and follow Fluttershy through her days in hell.

Good luck…

And enjoy.

Chapter 2:

Applejack**

               “Come on Fluttershy, almost there… hurry my tasty mare,” Applejack said, pushing Fluttershy deeper into her crotch.

Fluttershy pulled up, “Your turn AJ.” She spread her legs, slowly pushing Applejack’s head down there.

Fluttershy tasted sweet; Applejack began to lick, her own crotch getting tingly yet again. Fluttershy finished right in Apple’s face; she began sputtering much like Dash had with her. She felt like she could do this forever…

Applejack awoke, lying in her bed, the taste of Rainbow still fresh on her tongue. She glanced down at her wet bed sheets, the wet reminiscent dream of last night still fresh in her mind as well. She had to remember to try some more stuff with Dash soon; maybe she’d show her how to really ride a pony. She started rubbing furiously, remembering all she could of the dream, and the late night/early morning sexcapade with Rainbow. She heard a light knock out her window at the front door. Who could it be this early in the morning? She checked her bedside clock and saw it read 3p.m., how late had she been out?

“A-applejack… it’s me, Fluttershy; I need your help… It’s Rainbow, something’s wrong with her… I came to you because you’re the Element of Honesty, so I figured you’d at least be up front with me about anything you’ve seen,” Fluttershy said from the other side of the door.

Applejack arose, quickly rubbing herself dry and stowing the cum-soaked bed sheets beneath her bed. She then made her way downstairs and opened the door to find a distraught, unnerved, yet still lightly smiling Fluttershy standing there.

“Well, if it’s a problem with one of our friends, I’d love to help,” Applejack said, imitating a hoof to forehead salute.

“Well… it’s… I-I-I… AHHHHH” Fluttershy ran off crying her eyes out.

“Fluttershy, WAIT!” Applejack yelled after her as Fluttershy ran in the direction of her house. “Foolish filly…”

Applejack went back into her room and took the soaked sheets from under her bed. Gosh darn it Big Mac, she thought to herself, I told you to wake me up by noon… Speaking of time, what time had she got home? Had to have been eight a.m. at least… after her little fun with Rainbow Dash… She snapped back to reality and caught herself starting to pleasure herself again.

“No, not now, maybe later though, I better go check on Fluttershy and make sure she’s ok for me to have at least some tearless fun with her…” Applejack mentioned aloud to herself. “Now to wash these sheets.”

She walked outside and over to the nearby wash basket; she set the sheets down on the stool and walked over to the water pump, with basket in mouth. She began to fill it up when she heard hoofsteps behind her. She immediately grabbed a nearby shovel in her teeth and turned to find herself face to face with Big Mac.

Big Mac was stunned by the sight of his sister ready to hit him with the shovel, “N-n-nope!” he managed to say before she could do anything.

“Oh apples Big Mac, you scared the buck out of me, don’t do that!!” she scolded him, turning back around to fill up the tub, hitting him in the face with her tail.

“Sorry sis, I didn’t mean to scare ya…” the big red stallion said.

“It’s ok… I’m just stressed out and all… it’s awful… and why did you NOT wake me up at noon?!?!” she asked, angry again.

“I was workin’ on the setup sis, eeyup! But I’m really sorry Apple…” Mac said, bowing his head in sadness.

Applejack sighed, “It’s ok ya silly stallion… just be glad I love you enough that I forgive you,” she said, eyeing him slightly sexually while starting to drag the basket over to the sheets.

“Do ya need some help with those?” Big Mac asked, looking at the tangle of soaked sheets in front of Applejack.

“If ya don’t care too sug’” Apple said, handing him one of the sheets.

“What happened to these?” he asked, smelling the stain.

“Well, I went out to check on Fluttershy last night and found Rainbow Dash and…” she explained what happened the previous night and of the dream.

As Apple explained, Big Mac pictured all of it; Rainbow on AJ, AJ finishing Rainbow off a few times, then Fluttershy’s willingness in the dream. By the time she was done, Mac’s member was dripping with warm cum as he stood there listening. He quickly crossed his legs, hoping AJ wouldn’t notice. They finished cleaning the sheets as Applejack finished the story still unaware of Big Mac’s leavings.

“Here, hand me that sheet Mac,” she said, motioning for the sheet he had been cleaning. He handed it to her with his teeth, still covering his dripping cum.

“Here ya go sis, all clean,” he said, “so what are the plans for today?”

“First, we’re gonna clean up your little mess; don’t think I didn’t notice,” Apple said, with a wink. “Second, I’m gonna go visit Fluttershy and check on her. Lastly, I’m bringin’ her back here and having my way with her…”

“Can I have a turn with her sis?” Big Mac asked, eyes widening.

“After we’ve had her, she’s open to anypony at all, even you,” she said, laughing.

“Ok AJ, if you say so,” he said, cracking a slight smile.

“Alright then, now take these sheets and put them in my room. I’ll start doing todays things,” she then sent him away to her room.

Dipping one hoof in the left over cum, she giggled, it’s warm, wet and sticky feeling tickled her slightly. She then slowly licked it off her hoof, tasting it, and swallowing it. It tasted great, she thought, for such a common stallion, he’s got some great cum. She then continued dipping, licking, swallowing until it was all gone. Big Mac would be surprised to see the cum was already taken care of, hopefully he had stopped dripping prior to taking the sheets to her room. She didn’t want to have to clean the sheets again… Oh well, if she did, she would.

Fluttershy started running away from Applejack, tears streaming down her face.

“Fluttershy, WAIT!!!” she heard Applejack yell after her.

She couldn’t, after thinking about yesterday, she lost it, and maybe once she recovered she would try again. But as of right now, there was no way in all of Equestria she could bear even remotely remembering any little aspect of it. She had to take her mind off it somehow, maybe she’d go find some of her woodland creature friends and tend to them…

“Oh Celestia,” she thought aloud, “my woodland friends…” She remembered the horror stricken looks on their faces when it all began; those poor, poor animals. She needed to find them and assure them she was ok or else they’d start to worry, and she couldn’t bear the thought of her friends being upset. Where was she though, she’d been walking for about an hour or so; what was this part of the forest? Surely she hadn’t crossed into the Everfree Forest… Suddenly, she heard a twig snap behind her and immediately flew into the nearest tree.

“Fluttershy, you in here pal?” she heard Applejack ask out loud to the forest, “I ain’t here ta hurt ya or nothing.”

Fluttershy gently flew out of the tree’s leafy embrace down to the orange earth pony.

“O-oh, hi Applejack. What a, um, coincidence seeing you here.  What brings you all the way out… here?” Fluttershy said, trying to act as nonchalant as possible about her own being lost.

“I was lookin’ for you, and I should ask you the same question; this ain’t nowhere near your home. Are you sure that you’re not lost or anything?” Applejack said, blatantly seeing through the smiling pony’s act.

“Y-yes… I’m lost. A-after I left your farm; I j-just couldn’t bring myself to stop running. Next t-thing I knew, I was here; well, wherever here is,” Fluttershy said while on the verge of tears and collapsing to her knees, now starting to shiver.

Applejack slowly approached the hurt pony and put a hoof around her, giving her a slight squeeze to reassure her she was there for her. As the hug was given, Fluttershy burst into tears, crying on Applejack’s shoulder immensely. Apple stroked down the pink mane, her plan going perfectly; she was ready for the next step.

“Hey Fluttershy pal, how about ya come back to my place and we talk the whole thing over?” Apple said, laying her head on the sobbing pony’s shoulder.

“Th-that sounds nice…” she replied, drying her eyes in Apple’s coat. “I’d love to… thank y-you Apple.”

Apple released Fluttershy from the hug and walked next to her as they returned back to her farmhouse. Apple could only smile, thinking about how much fun she’d force Fluttershy to have. She would have her in her room all to herself, and not a single soul would bother them; no matter how many screams were heard.

As Big Mac walked into the house, he began thinking about Fluttershy; her soft coat, those beautiful eyes, that ear-pleasing voice. He began getting hard again just thinking about it, but he had to stop. He walked into Apple’s room and saw the bare bed; he decided to go ahead and make the bed.

As the sheets were put on and fixed, he couldn’t get Fluttershy out of his mind. He knew Apple would get her back quick, and if he couldn’t join, he might as well watch. After fixing the covers, he looked around for a place to hide; the closet stuck out to him like a sore hoof. He walked over and opened the door; it’d be a tight fit, but if he stood on his hind hooves, he’d manage. He squeezed in and barely got the door cracked enough to where it wasn’t too noticeable but he could see out it.

Fluttershy and Applejack walked back to Applejack’s house, arriving shortly after Big Mac hid in the closet. Apple offered Fluttershy some cider and sat in the living room with her. As they drank and talked, Fluttershy began to be more at ease with Applejack; now forgetting mostly about Rainbow Dash’s attack on her. As they laughed and cried, Applejack kept getting closer and closer to Fluttershy as another hour went by.

“Hey Shy,” Apple said softly, “Why don’t we have ourselves a good ole fashioned sleepover?”

“O-of course Apple! That sounds delightful, and with Big Mac here we should be safe in case she finds me…” Fluttershy explained, smiling.

“Well, why don’t you come on up to mah room,” Apple asked the yellow pegasus.

Fluttershy followed Applejack up the stairs and into her room. She took quick notice of the crisp sheets laid out on AJ’s bed; must have been laundry day. The closet was cracked open slightly, but Fluttershy didn’t think twice of it. She laid on the bed giggling softly as her defense was weakened; for she felt safe in AJ’s home. Apple shut the door behind her and locked it as Fluttershy pounced upon the clean sheets. Applejack turned to the yellow pony and spoke.

“So Flutters, shall we have ourselves some fun?” Apple asked, picking up a pillow.

“O-oh, a pillow fight; of course we can AJ!!” Fluttershy giggled happily, true ignorance and happiness irradiating from her.

Fluttershy playfully stood and hit AJ with the pillow, both standing in front of the bed on their hind-hooves. Apple hit back a few times softly, waiting for her chance to have some fun… her way. They kept giggling and hitting, having fun like mares at a sleepover; which in Fluttershy’s eyes they were. To Applejack, it was predator and prey. Suddenly, Fluttershy lunged at Applejack, frightening the earth pony into thinking Fluttershy knew all along, but it turned out to just be a surprise hug; Fluttershy cooed softly as she held AJ in the warm embrace.

“Th-thank you Apple,” Fluttershy whispered while nuzzling Applejack’s neck.

“It’s my pleasure sug’” Apple replied, smiling deviously.

Fluttershy went to release Applejack from the warm embrace and tried to pull away, but Apple still held her tightly. Fluttershy tried to pull away a little harder this time, and Applejack’s grip increased, beginning to hurt the frail pony.

“A-apple, you’re crushing me… Let up some silly,” Fluttershy pleaded playfully.

A devious smile arose on Applejack’s face as a carnal desire began to flow through her orange body; Fluttershy now in her room, trapped. Apple released Fluttershy only for a moment to throw her onto the bed and leap atop her.  Applejack looked down at Fluttershy’s speechless face and leaned down to plant a kiss on her lips. Fluttershy turned her head and Apple grew impatient, giving the pegasus a backhoof and holding her head right, now forcing the kiss upon her struggling lips.

Flutters saw no way out of this battle, Apple was a labor based pony and would be strong and she had no way to distract her… Trickery wouldn’t work this time either… She had to give up and just give in; so she laid back and took what was going to happen.

Big Mac peeked out through the small slit in the closet door to see AJ on Shy and felt himself stirring inside. He looked down, his member growing rapidly as he heard Apple’s sounds. He reached down gripping it and began to rub his shaft, not wasting anytime to keep up a quick pace as he grew more in his hoof. That was when his hoof hit the closet door with a loud bang.

As Fluttershy relentlessly gave in, she looked up into Apple’s eyes with a final pleading look. As she gazed into her pupils she saw a swirling darkness throughout the iris and realized Rainbow had had the same thing, she’d just not realized it until now; the constant repression of the prior rape forcing her to be unable to. Then they heard the bang.

Apple rose up quick, “What the buck?!” she yelled, looking over.

The closet door slowly opened to reveal an erect and shameful looking Big Mac. As Applejack looked, Fluttershy saw her chance and got ready. She pulled her hind legs up slowly and kicked Applejack off of her towards the closet. Applejack, surprised as could be, couldn’t resist against Fluttershy’s kick; she smashed hard into Big Mac and the closet, one of her legs breaking as she fell. Fluttershy jumped up, off the bed and quickly unlocked and ran out of AJ’s room.

AJ lay in pain on top of Big Mac who was now unconscious, she groaned and began trying to stand, her broken hoof now fully healed. She stood; two minutes after Fluttershy left, and began making her way downstairs.

Fluttershy leapt down the stairs, turning the corner, running into Applebloom. Fluttershy wasted no time hesitating and knocked Applebloom aside with her right hoof. She kept running towards the door when something caught her eye. A brown saddle-satchel rest on Applejack’s couch; it had Fluttershy’s cutie mark on it. She quickly grabbed it and threw it on, worried as to how it had gotten here. She ran as quick as she could to the front door and threw it open. On the other side was Rainbow Dash, ready, a pipe in her hooves. She struck Fluttershy in the head with the pipe hard, knocking her out cold.

Applejack hurried down and found Rainbow standing over the pegasus, “Thank Celestia you made it in time…” she said, panting.

“What the hay went wrong?” Rainbow asked

Applejack pointed upstairs, “Big Mac decided to hide in my closet… and she got the best of me… She broke my bucking leg… but now it’s good as new,” Apple smiled deviously.

“So,” Rainbow Dash asked, “What do we do with her?”

“Ol’ Mac, even though I’m quite furious with him, managed to get something special set up… just in case she escaped…” Apple giggled, walking to Fluttershy.

“Oh? I’m quite curious AJ,” Rainbow said walking up to Flutters as well.

“Well, don’t be; ain’t nothing sexual. That want ended the second she broke my hoof. Now we’re out for blood sug’” Apple said with a blood-lust on her dark infested eyes.

Rainbow’s eyes lit up, her rose and shadow-mixed eyes looking into AJ’s, “Finally… I must say though… she was fun while she lasted.”

“Help me get her to the barn?”

“Course’ AJ, of course,” Rainbow Dash lifted the front of Fluttershy as Apple took the back; together they carried her into the barn.

“Now, we wait til she wakes up,” AJ said, strapping Flutters into the set-up that rested within the barn.

Fluttershy awoke some time later, her head now with a soft ache as she groggily raised her head. Her eyes were clouded with darkness from the forced sleep that left her energy still diminished. As she began to blink it away, gravity and realization kicked in in her mind as she noticed she was suspended in mid-air, her hooves tied with ropes stretching her in four different diagonal directions. She looked around frantically at her bindings made of rope, attaching her to a metal frame inside what she thought was Applejack’s barn; she couldn’t be too sure though as it was quite dark. A creak sounded from across the room and a sliver of light slightly illuminated a bit of the room; enough for Flutters to see the saddle-satchel tossed on the ground nearby. She heard hoofsteps approaching and quickly acted unconscious.

“When will we start?” Rainbow Dash asked.

“Soon, whenever she wakes up. We’ll check back here in about half an hour, k sug’?” Applejack responded.

“Of course, shall we go check in on the others?”

“We shall.”

More hoofsteps, this time away from her, echoed through the barn, followed by the barn door closing again. Flutters rose her head back up and looked around quickly for a way to escape.

“Psst!” a whisper came from behind her

She held still, shivering slightly as fear and terror pierced through her body. She wouldn’t dare acknowledge the unknown pony behind her without knowing it was safe. Suddenly she felt the caress of a hoof running down her left leg and begin thrashing at the person touching her. She felt a snout as she reared her hoof back and connected.

“Ah!” the voice was now nasally and distorted, “I’m trying to help you, you fool! Now stop squirmin’!”

Suddenly the rope holding Fluttershy’s back left hoof let go of her, followed by the back right. As she hung from her front hooves she heard another grunt that wasn’t that of the original voice and grew fearful again as the hoof now traced up her left hoof. The tension tightened in her body as she broke out in a cold-sweat, fearful of this pony, unsure whether they were friend or foe.

“Loosen up Flutters, it’s ok… they’re with me. I couldn’t very well come alone. You need to go find Zecora quickly.” The left hoof came free, “She can help you end this… I can’t promise any of the taken ones will live… but she can help you escape or free them… hurry though and be cautious… the forest is now her domain.” The right hoof was free and Fluttershy crashed to the ground.

“Wait! Who’s h-her?” The scurry of hoofsteps running away answered silently. “W-well… thank you… your kindness shall b-be r-remembered…”

The barn door opened fully, the light quickly flooding the room. Fluttershy grabbed her saddle-satchel in her teeth and dove into some nearby hay. She looked at her prior holdings and saw it was a medieval-like stretching machine. She was going to be killed by these ponies if she didn’t get to Zecora. She heard ponies arguing from the other side of the hay.

“WHERE THE BUCK IS SHE!” Applejack screamed.

“A-ah don’t know sis! N-nopony was watchin’ her!” Big Mac replied shamefully.

“Then get out there and find her. We can’t have her loose. She’s not like the rest of us you idiot!” The sound of a hoof hitting someone hit Fluttershy’s ears and made her recoil softly.

“O-ok Apple… I-I’m so sorry! Eeyup. Won’t h-happen again, I swear!” Big Mac shivered as he spoke, Fluttershy heard it in his sad tone.

She sighed in relief as they left and began to look for a way out. Where had those other ponies come in at? If she found that, she could escape easily and have a straight shot for home- wait, no. They’d be looking for her there… she’d have to go to the forest from another way… She traced along the back wall of the barn until she found a loose board where the night air was seeping in. She moved it away and stepped into the night, ready to escape the Apple’s property and get this all over with… She began to walk around the barn towards the road back towards her house…

End Chapter 2